10 ms·
SF’s Black Market Thrives Off Retail Theft
- beachtaxidriver 4y agoThe subject of the article killed two men, and is now living on social security and subsidized housing. If I was family of the two killed men I would be furious.
- rayiner 4y ago
- renewiltord 4y agoWoah, I've seen that dude by Leavenworth and GG Ave, I think. Damn, I walk around there casually not knowing there's dudes who have gone and killed multiple people just chilling out. Yeah, that's messed up.
- igorkraw 4y agoWell, he's also a Vietnam vet. So he has probably killed a lot more than two people, but the majority of it was state sanctioned if that makes you feel more at ease?
- Mouthfeel 4y ago
- Teever 4y agoThat sometimes when we pick people at random to go fight and kill in some shitty war they come back fucked up and end up killing people stateside? Is this really so hard to understand? Like is the trope of the Vietnam vet with PTSD alien to you?
- renewiltord 4y ago
- simoncion 4y ago> The fact that there's a bunch of killers there... Converting "One man who went to jail for killing (or maybe merely being involved with the killing of... the article doesn't make it clear) two people during a robbery forty-two years ago and was released early after fifteen years behind bars due to demonstrated good behavior, and has -as far as _we_ know- never killed (or been involved in the killing of) anyone since." into "there's a bunch of killers [in the TL]" is _definitely_ you getting your undergarments in a twist.
- renewiltord 4y agoHaha, have a nice night :)
- vaidhy 4y agoWhy is that messed up? Do you feel the same about army vets? How about ones who have been dishonorably discharged? I would also be curious what you feel about Rambo, the movie? Do you identify with the sheriff or the vet?
- renewiltord 4y agoI haven't watched Rambo. Well, I feel differently about army vets as a total population than civilian killers. But perhaps there is a difference to the way we perceive the world. I'll ask you a question in turn and tell you how I feel. Imagine there are two hypothetical groups of people. One is a group of people who will punch you for "looking at them funny". The other is every world heavyweight champion. The latter has punched more people in the head than the former. Is the second group (far more punching performed overall) or the first group more preferred by you to walk by at 1 AM at night? In the spirit of fairness, I will answer my question first. For me, I would actively avoid the first group and not be concerned by the second group.
- simoncion 4y ago> ...I feel differently about army vets as a total population than civilian killers. How about military combat vets who were involved in killing in unspecified circumstances in the civilian world? > I haven't watched Rambo. You should. It's a good movie. The later ones (and most especially the most recent one) are dumb action movies, but the original is pretty good. > One is a group of people who will punch you for "looking at them funny". The other is every world heavyweight champion. I would trust the first group to act less erratically than the second. It's well-documented fact that getting hit in the head as much as boxers (and pro football players) do fucks you up, and makes you violent and erratic.
- renewiltord 4y agoI guess we've got nothing left but to see whose life turns out better. You do your thing and I'll do mine and may the chips land where they do.
- troutwine 4y agoAfter serving 15 years in San Quentin. I get the feeling you’re sharing but what would you prefer? The article does not paint a particularly rosy view of this man’s life, nor does social security amount to much money, per the article.
- deepdriver 4y agoSide note on the money aspect: San Francisco spends approximately as much on homelessness per vagrant as it costs to house an inmate for the same length of time in San Quentin, where per-prisoner costs are also notoriously high. Inmates are ineligible to receive Social Security.
- rendall 4y agoHe paid his debt to society and has a felony record. Now he's staying out of trouble. What more do you want? Guy's in a wheelchair. You want him to starve in the street?
- Mouthfeel 4y ago
- simoncion 4y ago> Gets more in aid than some get paid in a month WORKING? From the article: > [Chavez is] barely getting by with his $1,100 monthly social security payments and subsidized housing in the Tenderloin. Unless the article is misrepresenting the source of the funds, his income is solely Social Security payouts. That's money that every living American is entitled to after they reach a certain age, or meet a few other eligibility requirements. Chavez already paid in to Social Security earlier in his life. Now he is receiving that money back, as promised by the Federal government. Unless your suggestion is to claw back that entitlement for folks who are convicted of felony manslaughter or murder charges, then his income is immaterial. _Is_ that your suggestion?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rendall 4y agoKeep in mind, the description was only "he committed a brutal robbery that left two men dead". That can include anything from "Chavez shot two men in order to steal from them" to "Two robbers were shot to death in the course of an attempted robbery while Chavez survived". But, let's take as granted the worst possible interpretation. Ok: you don't accept that his debt has been paid. What would you suggest? Honestly curious.
- igorkraw 4y agoWhich is why justice and the judicial system is not really intended to facilitate revenge. Also, for the fullccontext >(...)serving in Vietnam when opposing soldiers ambushed and killed his commanding officer. Returning home to San Francisco at age 22 in the early 1970s, he can still recall how the trauma led to a burgeoning heroin addiction that he supported by shoplifting. He killed the 2 people in 79 and is now 70 years old and in a wheelchair. What would you propose to do with him instead? And are we denying that he could have benefited from assistance and intervention to deal with that trauma and reintegrate into society? Back to "fuck the vets"?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- refurb 4y agoYou know what I’m going to tell God when I see him? I’m going to tell him I was framed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fmajid 4y agoYes, he’s clearly a far worse case than Napoleon Brown, London Breed’s brother who killed his own accomplice, not two innocents.
- jakelazaroff 4y ago> Annual cases of theft in San Francisco are down 33% from where they were in 2017, according to San Francisco police data, but a national retail security survey found that shoplifting was at an all-time high in 2020, costing the industry an estimated $61.7 billion. Such crimes are part of what’s led 80% of San Franciscans to feel increasingly unsafe, according to a survey from the San Francisco Chamber of Commerce. The other part is articles like this, that find a way to make it seem like people are especially at risk even though crime is at a historic low.
- lazide 4y agoreported crime. Most folks gave up years ago, anecdotally.
- jakelazaroff 4y agoThis article isn’t talking about individuals, though. What would be the disincentive to retail stores reporting theft? There are presumably insurance benefits even if they don’t think the police will recover it or apprehend someone.
- toast0 4y agoReporting comes at a cost to the store. They've got to have their personnel working on it, possibly managerial staff, and they've got a lot of other things to do, and staffing shortages, etc. If reporting doesn't result in police actions that reduce future theft, it seems like it's a waste. If retail theft is as endemic as reporting would seem to indicate, I don't know how they could get insurance for 'petty' theft anyway, so a police report isn't likely to be useful. Likely their business insurance has higher deductibles anyway, so it's more useful for major theft or damage, not for smaller claims.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoFor general retail, there is no point to insurance for predictable recurring costs. If you get robbed for 1000 a week, you just add it to your budget. This is differ if you have rare theft of high price items.
- ceeplusplus 4y ago
- maybelsyrup 4y agoSo you support the state housing them at taxpayer expense? I do too, I just think they should have their own keys.
- ceeplusplus 4y ago> So you support the state housing them at taxpayer expense Describing prison as "housing at taxpayer expense" is... one way of putting it. I think they should be given a choice: go to jail or get a job and 2 months of state funded housing. If you go back on the streets because you didn't want to work, then police will pursue every public nuisance, public urination, shoplifting, etc. charge and send you to jail. If you're mentally ill you're forcibly committed. If you're a drug addict, you're forced to go to rehab or go to jail. Otherwise these people will never learn to be decent members of society (you know, people that don't steal and shit on the streets - the bar is on the floor). A lot of these people don't want to go into shelters because those shelters have no drug use/no alcohol policies. But I say the state should not be supporting their drug habits with taxpayer dollars.
- chmod775 4y ago"What are you in for?" "Couldn't find work." There seems to be a proclivity in the states to solve social issues by diving headfirst into a dystopian nightmare, instead of learning from somewhere else. That aside, jails are more expensive than simple housing. Just house them regardless. It's way cheaper.
- rejor121 4y agoAhh but that’s how the liberals socialist commies take over, ya know?
- 4y ago
- olivermarks 4y agoThis is an article from February 2022 by the pro SF DA Boudin SF Standard. Boudin has now been recalled and the excellent new DA Brooke Jenkins has started cleaning house. It will take some time - there are still lots of people openly selling stolen retail merchandize on the streets and the cartel drug dealers are still openly selling Fentanyl in open air drug markets - but the tide is slowly turning.
- inferiorhuman 4y agoRemember how everyone piled on Boudin for working to get his parents released? Turns out Jenkins is doing the same thing for Mayor Breed's brother. Meanwhile Jenkins withdrew over a dozen drug cases because she felt that Boudin overcharged those people. If you really believe cronyism will turn the tide, I've some oceanfront property in Kansas to sell you. https://sfist.com/2022/07/28/state-ag-refuses-da-jenkins-request-to-take-breeds-brothers-case-plus-case-involving-jenkins-family/ https://sfist.com/2022/07/28/state-ag-refuses-da-jenkins-req... https://www.davisvanguard.org/2022/07/regardless-of-what-da-jenkins-did-with-standalone-drug-charges-enforcement-is-not-the-answer-to-sfs-drug-problems-public-defenders-say/ https://www.davisvanguard.org/2022/07/regardless-of-what-da-...
- refurb 4y ago
- inferiorhuman 4y ago> What game are you playing? Did you read the article? Yeah she's stepped back from the case and asked the state AG to do Mayor Breed a solid. More or less the same exact thing that people tried to flog Boudin for doing (his parents were part of the Weather Underground). Meanwhile Ms. Tough-on-Crime Jenkins is claiming Soft-on-Crime Boudin overcharged a number of drug cases… which seems to run counter to the narrative being pushed of her being tough on drug crime. What game are YOU playing?
- 4y ago
- lettergram 4y agoI remember being in SF in 2016 and there were whole city blocks that were barricaded and the gangs ran checkpoints. There were clearly stolen goods behind the checkpoint and drugs as well. I recall me and a few co-workers going to eat right next to one of these checkpoints. Open needles, could buy drugs right there at the entrance. The restaurant was nice, a niche pizza place. You could order 20-30 kinds of different meats on a neapolitan style pizza. We walked out of the restaurant to a fully nude woman, giving head to a man. Another nude woman near by and a pimp looking at us. We just turned and walked around them. This is San Francisco I remember. Having wandered all over SF Oakland, and the Bay Area generally… It is the most dystopian place I can imagine. It’s a cultural rotten to its core in many ways. Yes, the art, the passion, it’s beautiful. But the people and city have lost the humanity, ironically enough.
- whyenot 4y agoI'm not disputing your personal recollection, just adding another data point, but I have lived in SF since 2013 and have never experienced anything like that.
- inferiorhuman 4y agoSF native, worked and socialized in the Tenderloin, live in East Oakland currently, and I agree. This sounds a lot like the guy who complained on r/oakland that government is a wild racket and that they're enforcing street sweeping restrictions without actually sweeping the streets. Lots of people pointed out their blocks are getting swept. Turns mechanized street sweepers aren't effective against the type of debris that the guy was complaining about. People love to vent their hot air and thump their chest at their excited discovery that San Francisco is a grimy city. Guess what. Noted junkie and author Jack Kerouac was complaining about the winos on third street back in the 50s. Claims about the death of San Francisco are generally overrated. Anecdotally I watched the street sweeper go by my kitchen this morning.
- lettergram 4y ago> SF native, worked and socialized in the Tenderloin, live in East Oakland currently, and I agree. It could also be the case that your accustomed to it? Or perhaps it’s gotten worse? This restaurant was in the Tenderloin in 2016. Can’t speak to your experiences, but this was a pretty near daily occurrence.
- daenz 4y agoSome people have a blasé attitude towards shoplifting/shoplifters: "Why are you defending rich companies?" This assumes that the company just eats the loss. How much of those shoplifting losses are passed onto your average consumer I wonder? If shoplifting is subsidized by everyone else, does this relationship make it an unofficial social program?
- int_19h 4y agoThe obvious solution is for everyone to shoplift. ~
- pm90 4y agoIf that were true then Im fine with this kind of unofficial sales tax to support people who are in desperate enough circumstances to be compelled to shoplift.
- DevKoala 4y agoWhat about poor people with a moral code? Raising prices to account for shoplifting punishes the poor too.
- pm90 4y agoIt does. Im not suggesting it be the model by which we help all the poor. Better solution: invest in welfare benefits and social programs. However if the choice is between paying extra v/s throwing people in prison Im not ok with the latter.
- DevKoala 4y agoIt doesn’t add up to me. Raising prices to account for shoplifters punishes poor people the hardest and reduces social mobility; poor people cannot save. Less social mobility makes it so that only people coming from privileged backgrounds control the destiny of poor people, thus never really fixing any issue.
- BoorishBears 4y ago
- daenz 4y ago>“They knew it was a crime before they did it, and they did it anyway. So what we have to help them do is examine why.” This kind of naivete is plaguing so many leaders. If only criminals could examine themselves and introspect their actions, then they would understand! It's like people forget that we are still essentially animals, and when the reward of opportunity outweighs the risk of punishment, there is slim chance that the moral mind will prevail. Even slimmer if the person in question does not have a foundation of morality guiding them. Restore morality and revamp the idea of punishment to actually be a deterrent in the 21st century and these things will go away. Unfortunately we are inundated with weakness to a degree that we consider morality as undefinable and punishment a faux pas. "Punish a criminal? How unacceptable. Who are you to say what is right and wrong?" It seems we'd rather society fray apart into nothing than re-establish any kind of order.
- _8j50 4y agoIt is a fundamental question of the nature of man. People are fundamentally evil and need to be thought to do good. Religions including Christianity have a way to address that but what is a secular society's way to address this? If you disagree with this please let me know why. Most people are raised to believe they are fundamentally good which causes a lot of harm and suffering. Challenging that preconception and learning to do good is the best way to defeat evil and let justice and equality prevail for all in my opinion.
- daenz 4y agoSecular society has been so busy deconstructing the concept of God and religion, on the premise that it's useless if it's not provably true, to come up with an adequate replacement for the positive things God and religion provided. They seem either completely disinterested or completely incapable of the task.
- polotics 4y agoWhat evidence do you have for "People are fundamentally evil". Personally I have found it useful to get new acquaintances to tell me their opinions on this one. A lot of the rest of their behaviour can then be inferred.
- Proven 4y ago
- hansword 4y agoThis whole bunch of comments shows that y'all have far too much money for your own good.
- RickJWagner 4y ago"While many fencers justify their actions by saying they only steal from large corporations" And who ends up paying for it, in the end? Not faceless corporations, I can promise you that.