6 ms·
This is an excellent long-form article on the history of AeroVironment and their history of developing light-weight long-endurance aircraft. Beginning with the
by dredmorbius 4y ago
This is an excellent long-form article on the history of AeroVironment and their history of developing light-weight long-endurance aircraft. Beginning with the Gossamer Albatros and Solar Challenger, which may surprise some.
That largely confirms a view I'd previously formed that the principle beneficiaries of lightweighting materials and solar (or small-engine) aircraft + nav & comms capabilities will be in warfare and surveillance applications.
A solar + battery styrofoam + balsa aircraft with cameras and transmission capabilities could loiter for weeks or months over a region transmitting close-range realtime imagery. Given comparable mission costs for manned aircraft (listed in the article) at $20k -- $40k/hour, it would be possible to "darken the skies" (or at least saturate regions of interest) at very low cost.
A smaller number of response UAVs could address specific points of interest with a response of a few minutes to hours.
All without putting pilots in harm's way.
The nature of ground (or surface naval) warfare will be profoundly changed. This is to bullets and shells what bullets and shells were to pikes.
- philipkglass 4y agoIn related news, the Airbus Zephyr just set a new record for endurance flight and is still aloft: https://www.space.com/airbus-zephyr-drone-long-endurance-flight-record https://www.space.com/airbus-zephyr-drone-long-endurance-fli... An experimental aircraft tested in conjunction with the United States Army has been in the air above the Sonoran Desert for 42 days, breaking its own record for longest uncrewed flight. The solar-powered, high-altitude Airbus Zephyr S took off from the U.S. Army's Yuma Proving Ground on June 15, 2022 and has since been flying patterns over the Yuma Test Range and Kofa National Wildlife Refuge. The flight has now broken Zephyr's previous record of 25 days, 23 hours that it set in August 2018. The latest flight has seen Zephyr reach a number of additional milestones including its first flight over water, first flight into international airspace, the longest continuous flight while being controlled through satellite communications, and the farthest flight from its launch point, according to a U.S. Army statement (opens in new tab).
- dredmorbius 4y agoThanks, yes. That's the "weeks or months" I was talking about. I'd be interested in knowing what its flight profile looks like. The Solar Impulse manned solar-powered aircraft that flew around the world (though with stops) performed energy potential banking by climbing over the course of the day, then descending through the night. Altitude was thus a large part of the "battery" storage system, banking energy received during the day. Article below describes the aircraft, if not the energy management element. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/inside-first-solar-powered-flight-around-world-180968000/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/inside-first-solar...
- sitkack 4y agoAmerica's proxy war in the Ukraine, while full of video-op content from state media about kids with high tech weapons killing other kids in tin cans makes it seem like the good guys are winning. Everyone loses. Alpha Go plus some drone kit from aliexpress and banggood is the start of WW3. If America does anything well, it is blowback. Russia's utter dysfunction would and should have been a long term strategic asset, but we burned it in Ukraine. Good technologists are globally distributed, everyone know where this is going and it will only cost a buck oh five. Often times, the winning move is not to play. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tiD86FtF2x0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tiD86FtF2x0
- dredmorbius 4y agoLeading your response with a gross mischaracterisation of a Russian war of aggression ... somewhat overwhelms any point you might have been trying to make here. Who is "we"? Good technologists ... tend to migrate toward attractive remuneration and/or sociopolitical environments, circumstances permitting.
- Nomentatus 4y agoThere can be proxy wars in which one side is acting on the defence, I don't know if that's what your interlocutor had in mind or how pure his intentions are, but there can be. This is an odd case where the proxy isn't attacking and Russia is unlikely to be a proxy for China, granted. I glanced at the youtube he linked to but didn't start it up. Too vague and blustery and idiosyncratic to warrant my time.
- gumby 4y ago> AeroVironment and their history of developing light-weight long-endurance aircraft. Beginning with the Gossamer Albatros Before the Albatross there was the Gossamer Condor, which is the one that won the £50K prize mentioned in the article. For some reason the name of the aircraft wasn't given. I remember when this prize was won. I was taking Unified (MIT aero-astro department requirement) and this achievement astonished me.
- dredmorbius 4y agoGC was also MacCready: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacCready_Gossamer_Condor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacCready_Gossamer_Condor> I also remember when these flights were made. Part of the reason why TFA is having such a strong impression on me. Also MacCready was the Quetzalcoatlus pterosaur: https://yewtu.be/watch?v=8WFmpEmmzOU https://yewtu.be/watch?v=8WFmpEmmzOU
- tiahura 4y agohttps://youtu.be/cH_vFJctl9I https://youtu.be/cH_vFJctl9I Solar loitering for a few hundred bucks.
- dredmorbius 4y agoIs there a particular segment of that hour-long video which specifically addresses capabilities / features / other elements of interest?
- UncleOxidant 4y ago> Beginning with the Gossamer Albatros and Solar Challenger, which may surprise some. Yeah, wow, I would not have even had the remotest idea that the Gossamer Albatross and the Switchblade were somehow connected prior to reading this article.
- marktangotango 4y ago> with cameras and transmission capabilities I think the "transmission" part here is the real story for military applications. To get real time video further out than a few kilometers, not many nations have satellite datalink capabilities. Those that don't will be at the whim of commercial providers (Starlink for now). Otherwise, the long duration drone flight discussed here could be most valuable for aerial, orbiting, microwave transponders.
- semi-extrinsic 4y ago> To get real time video further out than a few kilometers, not many nations have satellite datalink capabilities. Suppose you capture video at 4k resolution and 2 frames per second, and you compress it with h.265 at reasonable quality. Most of your image will be the same from frame to frame, so encoding will be really efficient. Then you're looking at ballpark 70 kilobytes per frame, or 1120 kbit/s. If you transmit that over 1.3 GHz and the receiving station has a good antenna, there is no reason why you shouldn't be able to reach 100-200 km range?
- nine_k 4y agoFly a larger re-translator drone 50-100 km away from the area of interest, which can relay the signal over a higher-power microwave link to a ground station another 100-200 km away. It could relay signals from many front-line drones.
- nradov 4y agoIn future high end conflicts, satellite communications will be unreliable due to heavy use of anti-satellite weapons and electronic attacks. In order to maintain communications, military forces will need relays in the air and on the ground, plus agile orbital launch capabilities to quickly replace satellite attrition losses.
- ElectricalUnion 4y ago> satellite communications will be unreliable due to heavy use of anti-satellite weapons > agile orbital launch capabilities to quickly replace satellite attrition losses. Once you reach Kessler syndrome / collisional cascading, the problem is no longer anti-satellite weapons, it's just lots of damaging space pollution in orbit - at this point, launching more satellites won't help anymore. EDIT: on another note, this also reflects the Mutual Assured Destruction/ICBM situation - you don't destroy my things, I don't destroy your things - it only works if both parties have things to loose. Anti-satellite weapons are the most dangerous in the hands of countries with low amounts of spacecraft.
- themodelplumber 4y agoIt'd be interesting to look at cheap counter-loiter tech and e.g. light exostructures and materials that are more difficult to penetrate at layers and readily repairable after drone attacks. I would guess that there is some interesting low-hanging fruit in that area. It also seems like a possible co-creative opportunity with the concept of covering ground properties with solar panels. Defend against airborne threats but also make the protective layer pay for itself if possible. Given additional sensor and environmental control development (vs breathing in munitions byproducts, etc), I wonder if over time the rationale for going outside, especially in a war zone, will simply fade away.
- pelorat 4y agoIn the future all these things will be countered by portable LASER systems.
- coredog64 4y agoIsrael has explicitly identified drones as a target for Iron Beam. Once that’s operational I think you’ll see attitudes shift on drone value.
- qqqwerty 4y agoDrones aren't going anywhere. They are so cheap, plentiful, and useful that it doesn't really matter how good the counter measures get. And if the counter measures get too good, then those systems will become primary targets themselves. EDIT: Looking at the wikipedia for Iron Beam. The range is only 7km. A quick google search indicates drones can fly at elevations of 10km, safely out of range. Also, it sounds like Iron Beam was designed to handle the occasional rocket launch from Hamas, and not a full scale barrage of artillery. So a possible way to defeat this system would be to send a drone up to 10km, locate the Iron Beam system, and send a barrage of artillery shells in its direction and maybe sneak in a high precision shell or two in the volley to increase your odds of a hit. That seems like it would be sufficient to take it out.
- 4y ago
- hutzlibu 4y ago"This is to bullets and shells what bullets and shells were to pikes." Mainly these drones are for scouting and directing the shells of the artillery and the bullets of the soldiers, so I am not sure the comparison is adequate as they are not making the shells obsolete. Once they are so cheap, that a drone with explosive is cheaper than an artillery round, they might make artillery obsolete, but so far they are strenghtening the value of artillery.
- dredmorbius 4y agoDrones obviously provide several capabilities. One of those is precise pinpoint attacks. Russia's extraordinarily high losses of senior general staff officers would highlight these capabilities. The ability to identify, inderdict, and disable high-capital equipment (e.g., tanks, the Moskova missile cruiser, another. There's an interesting observation in an unusual source that I've had come to mind: Regularity, order, and prompt obedience to command are qualities which, in modern armies, are of more importance towards determining the fate of battles than the dexterity and skill of the soldiers in the use of their arms. But the noise of firearms, the smoke, and the invisible death to which every man feels himself every moment exposed as soon as he comes within cannon-shot, and frequently a long time before the battle can be well said to be engaged, must render it very difficult to maintain any considerable degree of this regularity, order, and prompt obedience, even in the beginning of a modern battle. In an ancient battle there was no noise but what arose from the human voice; there was no smoke, there was no invisible cause of wounds or death. -- Adam Smith, Wealth of Nations https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_V/Chapter_1 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_V/... Smith discusses the earlier realm of shorter-ranged and melee weapons as well. Bullets have typically required soldiers somewhere in the immediate region, at distances of a few tens, hundreds, or at the extreme, a thousand or so metres. Artillery has longer range but has typically required larger launch systems, even where those are portable. Human-portable drones extend range to tens or hundreds of km with loitering and seeking capabilities. Again, the range of peril is extended greatly.
- nine_k 4y agoAn artillery round flies much, much faster, supersonic for a good part of the trajectory. It hits a target 10-15 km away in well under a minute. A drone would take 10-20 minutes to cover such a distance, and it would likely be easier to spot and destroy while en route, even if it tries to fly low and maneuver.
- jeffreyrogers 4y ago> The nature of ground (or surface naval) warfare will be profoundly changed. This is to bullets and shells what bullets and shells were to pikes. They said this about torpedo boats, submarines, tanks, and guided munitions among others. It will require countermeasures and changes in tactics but I doubt much will change. Since these systems are cheap and slow everyone else will have them too and they will be easy to shoot down.
- ethbr0 4y agoTorpedo boats led to substantially-reinforced secondary batteries on capital ships and eventually mixed composition fleets. Submarines led to ASW (as a doctrine and embodied in single-purpose aerial and surface platforms). Tanks led to ATGMs and decades of penetrator and armor evolution. Guided munitions (and specifically, nuclear ones) led to radically dispersed combat and logistics deployments and the C3 necessary to support them. All of those are very big changes. The most likely effect of loitering munitions will be a revolution in SHORAD and an understanding that even dug-in infantry can't operate outside of an air defense bubble. Or countries with the manpower and ethical flexibility going all-in on poorly-equipped cheap numbers over exquisite platforms.
- dredmorbius 4y agoCapital ships are hardly the only, or even primary, target of submarines. Cargo shipping was, and will likely be. Further, submarine warfare by the US against Japan during WWII was absolutely devastating to Japan's ability to supply raw materials for its own war effort. Japan was (and is) an extraordinarily capable and productive country, but, thanks to its volcanic geology, also extraordinarily limited in crucial raw materials, particularly iron and fuels (coal, oil), both of which are formed or concentrated largely through long-term biological activity. The U.S. had become aware of these costs itself due to the earlier actions of German U-boat operations against both intracoastal and transatlantic shipping early in WWII. In March 1943 alone German U-boats sank over 100 Allied vessels, mostly cargo. One consequence of the attacks against US oil shipments was the construction of inland oil pipelines, the "Big Inch" and "Little Inch", as government projects, during the war. These remain in use AFIAU. Later, one of the first projects following establishing a beachhead in Normandy was to run an oil pipeline across the English Channel. (Daniel Yergin's The Prize coves all of this, and I'm relying on it for specifics.) We're familiar with the notion of coal and oil forming over hundred-million-year intervals. Most iron-ore deposits are multi-billion year old accumulations, many predating the Great Oxygenation Event. Present long-distance transport modes (sea and air) are reliant on cheap fuels, large vehicles (both aircraft and ships become more efficient with size, within limits), and secure passage along routes. I was struck a few years ago how the development of large-scale long-distance cargo shipping largely paralleled the evolution of large-scale long-distance whale species. Both rely on the fundamental greater efficiency of long bodies moving through water ("hull speed"), the existence of widely-spaced reward (cargo/payment, food source) locations, and the ability to traverse such routes with little risk. Human-based whale hunting absolutely annihilated whale populations, which crashed to a few percent of their pre-hunt levels. In instances in which combat regions have emperilled commercial aviation flights, airlines have acted quickly to route around such regions, even at the cost of much longer travel (and higher fuel costs). A reintroduction of anti-shipping naval-warefare activities, and unlimited targeting of commercial aviation, would have profound effects.
- carabiner 4y ago> the principle beneficiaries of lightweighting materials and solar (or small-engine) aircraft + nav & comms capabilities will be in warfare and surveillance applications Isn't that the explicit reason these technologies were developed? Just as 7000 series aluminum and carbon fiber were made for fighter aircraft before they trickled down to iPhones and golf clubs.
- InCityDreams 4y ago> before they trickled down to iPhones and golf clubs. Oh, and $€10k bicycle frames.
- dredmorbius 4y agoI don't believe military capabilities were high on the reported benefits of the Gossamer Albatross or Solar Challenger at the time. Contemporaneous account: <https://www.nytimes.com/1979/06/17/archives/over-the-waves-in-a-flying-bike.html https://www.nytimes.com/1979/06/17/archives/over-the-waves-i...> There was a long article in National Geographic at the time (where I likely saw it). I don't know if that's online though it appeared in the November 1979 issue: <https://nationalgeographicbackissues.com/product/national-geographic-november-1979/ https://nationalgeographicbackissues.com/product/national-ge...> Internet Archive doesn't appear to have the issue.