4 ms·
I'm not so sure Hilton's strategy is shamelessness. It seems more like "owning" it. For example, the leak of the sex tape is the first I'd ever heard of her. I
by WalterBright 4y ago
I'm not so sure Hilton's strategy is shamelessness. It seems more like "owning" it. For example, the leak of the sex tape is the first I'd ever heard of her. I expected her to be mortified and sue and hide. But nope. She owned it, turning it into an opportunity for fame and fortune.
For an example of the opposite, remember the Star Wars Kid? The video of him twirling the light sabre was leaked online, and he was humiliated and sued. Another path he could have taken would be to "own" it, say "yep, that's me". I bet he could have made a lot of money off of that, and perhaps even gotten a cameo on a SW movie out of it.
I have a friend who underwent some major abdominal surgery for cancer. She didn't want to wear a swimsuit because she was embarrassed and ashamed of the large scars. I suggested that her scars were battle scars of her triumph over cancer, and she should be proud of them and show them off. She owned it, and told me later that it transformed her to turn those scars into a positive.
Similar things happen to bald men. The ones who try to hide it with wigs and comb-overs come across rather poorly. The ones who own it and flaunt it fare far better.
- mikkergp 4y agoHow would you define the difference between shamelessness and owning it? I guess one could be seen as passive and one as active, but they seem like they're basically the same thing to me, or maybe two sides of the same coin. I guess you could be void of the emotion of shame without taking a resulting action.
- lazide 4y agoThe difference I think is future behavior. You can own it by saying, ‘yup that’s me’ but not doing it again/ensuring that was the last one that got out. Shamelessness is keeping doing it, even afterwards, intentionally. So for example, sex tape wise - owning it would be acknowledging it and not hiding from it. Good, bad, etc. Shamelessness would be turning it into a porn brand and making a series of them for sale.
- mathewsanders 4y agoParis shared in a 2020 interview that her “Barbie airhead” was a defense mechanism and act to hide childhood trauma. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-real-paris-hilton/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-real-paris-hilton/ I think she’s savvy to be able to use it to her advantage, but I get the impression that if she could change her history she wouldn’t choose the path that she experienced. When it aired I was a big fan of The Simple Life (and later Paris Hilton's My New BFF) so I guess you could say I was a fan. In TSL so much focus was on the comedy of Paris and Nicole being put in ‘everyday’ situations, but what strikes me was how she treated every person she met with respect and (IMO) humility and without any sense of irony. Despite the persona, I think we saw a lot of who Paris is, which I think makes TSL unique in the genre of reality TV.
- WalterBright 4y agoAnother example is the original Star Trek cast. We love them, but let's be honest - they are C list actors. They complained that ST had ruined their careers because they were typecast. Nimoy even wrote a book "I Am Not Spock". It took years, but eventually they realized that ST had not cursed their careers, but had made them. They'd unintentionally struck into a lifetime vein of gold. Nimoy then wrote another book "I Am Spock". All they had to do was own it to cash in.
- moistly 4y agoHard disagree about their acting chops. I’ve been watching Star Trek original series and Shatner & Nimoy were damn fine actors. The memes and mockery are unjustified. (Some of the scripts, otoh, not good.)
- lordnacho 4y agoThis is a really interesting take on it, because I was thinking it was the opposite of owning it. Or at least different to "owning it" in an important sense: the thing that she's owning is some attribute that isn't intrinsic to her, and it's by it not defining her that she owns it. Traditional shame seems like some kind of permanent personal curse: child out of wedlock, feckless, poor, and so on. Having any of these qualities used to basically be an indelible part of your character, best hidden away from view. This modern shame is like an article of clothing: wear it well and it looks good, apologize for it and it looks bad (eg jeans with holes in them). You could say the same about any of the things I mentioned, turning it around: tireless fighter for her kids, work-smart-not-hard, rag-to-riches.
- WalterBright 4y agoAnother example: Bob Hope owned his ski nose. He made it his trademark. Ahnold Schwarzenegger was told he had to lose the accent. Instead he owned it.
- dspillett 4y ago> Ahnold Schwarzenegger was told he had to lose the accent. Instead he owned it. It did stop him getting certain work when trying to get into acting though, because to urban Germans he “sounds a bit like a farmer”. For those familiar with UK accents: think west country (oive godda bran-new combine'arvester…). He could afford to pass on that work, rather than having to change himself, because he was already financially comfortable from his successful body-building career and having carefully managed & invested his income from that. For someone starting from nothing, standing by yourself and refusing to change, owning and controlling your identity on principal, can be a more difficult choice. Of course Schwarzenegger's move to the American film industry got around the accent problem quite nicely: to a non-German ear the association of parts of his accent with particular places/work doesn't exist. No slight on Schwarzenegger intended here, he worked himself into a position where he could take the risk of making those choices rather than being in a comfortable position from, for example, the luck of being born into wealthy circumstances.
- lliamander 4y agoI think owning it can be a strategy, and maybe that is what Hilton did, but I think some people just aren't strongly motivated by social disapproval - in some cases to the point that they don't even realize it's happening. For them, it's like the low murmur of other people's conversations at a restaurant. They instinctively ignore it and are generally so wrapped up in what they are doing that someone has to actively bring it to their attention.
- karencarits 4y agoThis is true and also, in a sense, very unfair; how our personality and who we happen to have as friends or parents can have such deep impact in how we perceive ourselves, the eyes of others, the world, and our options in it. Perhaps I am defeatist, but "choosing to own it" looks a bit like "have you tried to not be so sad" when facing depression My impression is that the empirical psychology hasn't dealt properly with shame yet and that we must resort to psychodynamics or -analysis to properly understand its depth and impact. Perhaps someone here are familiar with good literature on the subject? Another observation is how unevenly shame is distributed; some people seem like they simply don't get it whereas others are drowning in it
- toyg 4y ago> "choosing to own it" looks a bit like "have you tried to not be so sad" when facing depression It's fundamentally a conscious choice - unlike depression, which has deep links with chemical equilibria. > how unevenly shame is distributed; some people seem like they simply don't get it whereas others are drowning in it Shame is essentially a social concept. A child raised by wolves would have no concept of what shame is (at least not human shame). It's clearly the case that early socialization with parents and peers is what shapes one's perceptions of the subject.
- karencarits 4y agoThank you for pointing out that the analogy is not perfect, there are fundamental differences (such as depression being a defined pathological condition and shame being an emotion ranging from healthy and useful to pathological). But I will not be surprised if you can see structural or biochemical differences in the brains of people suffering from pathological shame. My main point in both the statements you quote is that "choosing to own it" is too hard or difficult for some people and, in practice, not an option although it is in theory. And perhaps it can become a realistic option with enough psychosocial support or psychotherapeuric treatment. It is not about wanting enough or being stupid, see e.g. borderline personality organization (not the disorder); > Healthy people might have trouble visualizing what it is like to live with this "borderline" level of personality organization. Healthy people understand that who they are is not determined by a particular action, in a particular moment in time. They know that if they behave poorly one minute, this one bad behavior, in this one moment of time, does not define who they are. They are still able to recall all the wonderful things they have done in the past, and plan to do in the future. People with a fragmented sense of self are not so fortunate. If they just did something "bad," they literally become a bad person (i.e., they start representing themselves as an entirely bad person with no redeeming qualities). When this occurs, they can no longer access any of their good qualities. This is a terribly painful state to endure. (https://www.mentalhelp.net/personality-disorders/three-levels-of-personality-organization/ https://www.mentalhelp.net/personality-disorders/three-level...) In general, we should be careful to tell others to just choose differently (I am not accusing you of this) as it may often be rephrased as just be someone else - which is possible in some regards, difficult in others, and impossible in many cases
- watwut 4y ago> expected her to be mortified and sue and hide. She did sued and got money.
- WalterBright 4y agoI stand corrected.
- shkkmo 4y agoShe settled with an agreement that made sure she literally owned it and that it would get published so she would get royalties. So while the "sue" part matches, it is hard to describe that behavior as "mortified and hide".
- alxlaz 4y ago> I expected her to be mortified and sue and hide. She did, and she also got counter-sued: https://people.com/celebrity/hilton-salomon-end-sex-tape-legal-battle/ https://people.com/celebrity/hilton-salomon-end-sex-tape-leg... . "Owning it" worked fabulously for her for a whole lot of reasons, not the least of which are that she is rich and has an army of well-paid lawyers behind her. If you're rich and get laughed at and humiliated by the staff of a high-class restaurant, you have a ton of options. If you're Star Wars kid and you get laughed at and humiliated at a hiring interview, your options basically amount to "move on". Having that kind of legal and financial backing shields you from most negative consequences of unwanted fame, and leaves you only with the good parts -- the attention, at least. Without that backing, you get to deal with all of it, and some kinds of fame have very little to show in the way of good parts. Star Wars kid could have just stopped being poor (lol) of course but that's easier said than done :-).
- K0balt 4y agoYou can own it without money or cred backing you up, but it requires courage and a willingness to go all in and double down in the face of the inevitable pushback. Money just makes it so you can own it even with weak character. Owning it has always been an option for the courageous, the wealthy can pay instead of having to risk everything.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoAgree and wealth is even then only a substitute up to a certain threshold.
- dspillett 4y ago> I expected her to be mortified and sue and hide. But nope. She owned it Ish. She went for the sue and own it combo.