12 ms·
What is to prevent school WiFi from one day requiring a Pluton assertion that your Windows PC hasn’t been tampered with before you can join the network? Remote
by userbinator 4y ago
What is to prevent school WiFi from one day requiring a Pluton assertion that your Windows PC hasn’t been tampered with before you can join the network?
Remote attestation is the true enemy of your freedom. The power of the authoritarian corporatocracy to force you to use only the (entire) systems they control. It's worth reading https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html again just to see how prescient Stallman was.
- turns0ut 4y agoEngineers could leverage their economic might via collective action; don’t open your wfh laptop today. Updating the Upton Sinclair quote without the gender bias; it’s difficult getting a person to understand something when their investment portfolio valuation depends on them not understanding it. Who are they if they’re not what they are now? When you all stop posting on corporate forums and working their jobs, shopping their stores, I’ll take you all sincerely and seriously.
- r3trohack3r 4y agoThis was the case at my university. In order to use the dorm network, you had to download a software package that validated your setup. It would then add your computer (I assume MAC) to an allow-list. In order to deal with it, I had to create a subnet with a router, use an old laptop to do the verification, and then the whole subnet was added to the allow-list.
- gfo 4y agoThis is almost the entire thesis of Zero Trust Networking principles. Somehow, the user AND the device need to attest to validity during the authorization process. "Validity" for a device can mean many things (latest patches, is running anti-virus software, among other things). A general user probably doesn't need to attest to these things. I would argue that anyone trying to access a corporate or some other organization's network SHOULD be required to attest to these things given the cyber threat landscape. The caveat: those same entities should provide or heavily subsidize the platforms they require (work computers). It's their IP at risk. I'm not so naive to think they would actually do this with BYOD initiatives, unfortunately. For personal users on personal devices, I agree this might go too far (but some principles like MFA are best practices).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoDamn, now I'm nostalgic for the older days of hacker news where RMS was quoted every other post. The community is forgetting it's roots.
- q-big 4y ago> Damn, now I'm nostalgic for the older days of hacker news where RMS was quoted every other post. The community is forgetting it's roots. Keep in mind that now many of the people who post on HN earn a lot of money by working a company for which it is part of the business model to track users and collect data about them (officially for advertisement purposes).
- kmeisthax 4y agoTop-voted comments are linking directly to Right to Read and The Coming War on General-Purpose Computing, so I don't think the community has forgotten its roots. You really wanna be scared? Go look at the multiple comments on the EU DMA announcement complaining that having a sideloading option is just a ploy for malware vendors to get into their iPhones. Or that someone else being able to sideload or jailbreak somehow hurts their security. These are coming from actual HN users!
- userbinator 4y agoWell, my comment that linked to RtR was highly voted... But now it's near the bottom and what's at the top is, for lack of better phrasing, a corporate mouthpiece. Was it voted so high it triggered some bot detection? That would only explain the former, not the latter. Either way, there's something funny going on.
- sillysaurusx 4y agoAs someone who was here from day two, this is not how old HN was. It was many things to many people, and it’s very difficult to break out of the illusion that rose-tintedness tends to give us. (Guilty of it myself.) HN has been consistently contrarian. That’s about all that you can say without quickly becoming mistaken.
- aplanas 4y agoWindows security models and policies are the enemy, not remote attestation (RA). RA is a technology that has its fair use, and can be desired for other systems, like in Linux. With a pure RA system your services can decide to trust or not those devices on your network that can be compromised, and report to other devices that there is something suspicious. As anything, this can be used properly to increase the security of your edge architecture, or wrongly to limit the users actions. Let me put another example. With RA I should be able to authorize validated systems in my R&D VPN. If you are using your own laptop with the company certificate, and the verifier tag the systems as "unknown" or "unhealthy", it will not allow the access to the internal network, but sure you can still use your laptop for anything else. This, IMHO, is a fair use of this technology.
- POPOSYS 4y agoIs it possible to realize this with Linux systems / networks today? Do you have any good project / description / URL? Thanks!
- ajvs 4y agoGrapheneOS remote attestation arguably fits this criteria by being built on Android.
- aplanas 4y agoIt is still under development, but try Keylime[1]. They have also a nice agent written in Rust[2] with low footprint. I write some notes[3] about how to use it in openSUSE MicroOS / Tumbleweed, but can be extrapolated to many other distributions too. [1] https://github.com/keylime/keylime https://github.com/keylime/keylime [2] https://github.com/keylime/rust-keylime https://github.com/keylime/rust-keylime [3] https://en.opensuse.org/Portal:MicroOS/RemoteAttestation https://en.opensuse.org/Portal:MicroOS/RemoteAttestation
- fulafel 4y agoYes, lots of Linux devices apply it like that today: You can't use your banking app or consume DRM crippled media on your Android phone if you have root or run a open source Android distribution.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoSame with TPM and why it had so many critics. Some people still seem adamant to say that boot viruses are the greatest threat in the 21st century, but the economic interest are far more dangerous for general computing in my opinion. And it isn't even close.
- vanderZwan 4y agoSo basically, Cory Doctorow's "The Upcoming War Against General Computation"? https://boingboing.net/2011/12/27/the-coming-war-on-general-purp.html https://boingboing.net/2011/12/27/the-coming-war-on-general-... https://github.com/jwise/28c3-doctorow/blob/master/transcript.md https://github.com/jwise/28c3-doctorow/blob/master/transcrip... Don't know enough about the subject to tell if his "attempts to control general computation will converge on rootkits" prediction has held up.
- q-big 4y agoTo this talk, there exists a less well-known sequel: DEF CON 23 - Cory Doctorow - Fighting Back in the War on General Purpose Computers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pT6itfUUsoQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pT6itfUUsoQ
- vanderZwan 4y agoThank you for bringing this to my attention, will check it out after work
- nibbleshifter 4y ago> "attempts to control general computation will converge on rootkits" prediction has held up. If you play video games, you probably have a couple of neat kernel rootkits installed as "anti cheat". A lot of remote proctoring stuff for exams are looking a lot like rootkits too. EDR/XDR is also just rootkits. For security. The only thing that can stop a bad guy with a rootkit is a good guy with a rootkit, after all.
- 4y ago
- jart 4y agoStallman was right again.
- freemint 4y ago> Remote attestation is the true enemy of your freedom. Technology is a tool. What is true however is that under the current way how the economy is structured remote attestation weakens freedoms of individuals mostly. If Facebook was under remote attestation that private information was only used in limited and specific ways and even the NSA can not get to them without breaking the remote attestation, that would be a good thing. If firmware was under remote attestation we would have to worry a lot less about backdoors and the Diesel scandal would have never happened.
- leksak 4y agoBut it'd make a lot of whistleblowing impossible too
- kasabali 4y ago> If firmware was under remote attestation ... the Diesel scandal would have never happened. Remote attestation would prevent a firmware written by first party and passed certification processes WHAT?
- userbinator 4y agoIt is a tool, just like nuclear weapons are a weapon. I'm definitely not on the "ban all crypto" side, but I see why the governments are in support of that, and for the longest time, strong crypto was (and still is?) classified as a munition; it's very powerful.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoWell, I think governments are mostly concerned with people having secrets. Who would need secrets who isn't a terrorist? That it was classified as munition is probably more due to old war hawks and how they saw encryption employed.
- acdha 4y ago> It's worth reading https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html again just to see how prescient Stallman was. I think it’s also worth asking why he didn’t have more impact despite pretty clearly seeing this problem. Part of the answer has to be resource disparities but I don’t think it’s just that - Linux didn’t really capitalize at all on Microsoft’s lost decade, and much of the innovation in security has happened on other platforms. I think there’s also some kind of blind spot in the open source community where a lot of people see this as something other people need, not them personally.
- userbinator 4y agoConsider that the one whose comment is currently at the top is pro-cancel-Stallman, and he also works on "free" software related to secure boot --- not as in breaking, but instead aiding its adoption. The FSF was strongly against secure boot, then inexplicably started seeming to be in favour of it. Connect the dots yourself.
- acdha 4y agoWhy don’t you spell out the conspiracy theory directly? It’s not relevant to this thread even if true but leaving the details vague makes it seem like you don’t think it would stand up.
- userbinator 4y agoYou only think it's a "conspiracy theory" because that's what they have told you to believe. The organisations of OSS have been infected with those whose ultimate goal is to EEE, and they will do it by whatever means they have available to them.
- acdha 4y agoNo, I think it’s a conspiracy theory because it’s poorly argued and full of insinuation, following the classic pattern of expecting the reader to fill in the gaps. This is how it magically becomes a negative when someone works to make free software compatible with modern hardware in a way most users want.
- VoodooJuJu 4y agoIt's so true, but I'm trying to imagine a normie's reaction to reading this, and all I'm coming up with is, "This guy is a paranoid schizo, back to TikTok for me...", and so unfortunately, I don't see us steering away from this fate anytime soon. These people won't respect you until you start taking their money. Become one of their techno-corporate overloads. Demonstrate how you're controlling/profiting off them, why it's bad. Maybe then they'll start listening. Or not. At least you'll have made a nice profit.
- jjoonathan 4y agoAn economic niche supports one or two overlords, not a bunch of them. You and I aren't overlords. We need a different strategy. People have become aware and angry that tech monopolies are exploitative. The winning strategy will involve focusing this fuzzy, ambient anger at a concrete target. Once Pluton outs itself as an exercise in naked monopolistic power covered by a fig leaf of security -- and it will, as all hustles must eventually involve monetization -- the bad optics will be our opportunity to act. Any strategy on our side that involves putting down TikTok is doomed to failure, but if we put the bad optics in front of people, make the connection, and get them to briefly agree "yeeah, f** the monopolies! F** Pluton!" then a political solution becomes possible. Not easy, but possible. It's a pity that this dialog has to be so reactive and simplistic, but communication at scale cannot function any other way.
- turns0ut 4y agoI don’t have a problem with central organization of effort; mathematician by education; there a real efficiencies in material use and lack of redundancy. The real problem is continued deference to old ownership memes; that a minority must be empowered due to past contract none of us were even alive to see signed. How do we know in real terms the truth given a past we can never experience? Historical trends are one thing; that Bezos specifically is that special is another. This is the first period in history where the elders could hold power this long. It’s tacit ageism and everyone is too scared to say that to old people who would collapse in shock at the slightest whiff of real pushback, they’re so used to being coddled; they’re hardly a real threat. Start telling your elders their past success does not give them ownership of the future.
- slowmovintarget 4y ago...and before Stallman, Hayek. Hayek couldn't have seen the technological means, but he did see the "self-regulated monopolies" shaping up from anti-competition moves on the part of government (most of which are driven by lobbying).