8 ms·
Why Academic Freedom Matters (2021)
- hikingsimulator 4y agoThe issue is that a freedom is only a freedom for those who can afford it, afford escaping from the consequences of it in the case of freedom of speech. A person of color from the deepest recesses of the Bible belt can go to Harvard, can... Academic freedom does matter, yes, but Academia isn't an ivory tower of neutrality. It shouldn't be. First because it should not be shielded from the consequences of its output, second because it should help advance mankind -- a political aim in more than a few regards. Economics for instance has shown in multiple occasions that it is biased, toxic, and lacking diversity, pushing on towards ideology [1]. Academic Freedom does matter, but freedom appears vacuous when it only grants -- quite literally in terms of research -- the same ideas, the same people, the same social groups the whole spotlight. [1] https://youtu.be/mwojD0iHS4U https://youtu.be/mwojD0iHS4U
- swatcoder 4y ago> “deepest recesses”, “advance mankind”, “toxic” This language is so explicitly ideological itself that it’s hard for me to draw out what position you’re actually taking here. Can you elaborate?
- hikingsimulator 4y agoIt is not ideological to say that academia should be held responsible for its output, especially in fields that can drive policy (for instance, in economics it is well known that one of the key studies that tipped the scale in favor of austerity was erroneous, but it was not checked because it was in the academic zeitgeist [1]). I do not think it is ideological either to say that the purpose of research is to help develop people and nations. Whether it comes from hard science or soft science (a contentious categorization). All in all, I think my point is fairly clear. Neutrality in academia, especially political science, economics, etc. is non-existent and that the developments and recommendations coming out of those departments should never escape a wide scrutiny and criticism. The way the article frames it is that criticism, when it leads to retractation in Cotton's case or that of polsci/humanities, is bad. I profoundly disagree. Calling for freedom of speech in academia, like the article does, does not mean that every one is heard, only that the already entrenched and tenured remains unchallenged. [1] https://theconversation.com/economists-an-excel-error-and-the-misguided-push-for-austerity-13584 https://theconversation.com/economists-an-excel-error-and-th...
- nradov 4y agoYou are being irrational and ideological. It is unreasonable to hold academics accountable for policy decisions. We should instead demand that our elected leaders not set policy based on generally low-quality academic fields such as economics, at least not until research results have been independently replicated multiple times.
- hikingsimulator 4y agoWhen one of the stated goals of a discipline like Economics is to help drive economic decisions, i.e. policy, it is not an unwarranted expectation that the milieu that led to them be held accountable. Science is not performed in a vacuum.
- Sin2x 4y agoScience should be performed in a vacuum, that's the whole point. Its applications, on the other hand, are not to be performed in a vacuum.
- hikingsimulator 4y agoIt's not achievable, and likely never will. Even research in physics or mathematics is embedded in internal department politics and financing issues that influenced what is researched, who does the research, and ultimately who gets the rewards.
- causi 4y agoFor the first day of class, I asked my students to read both essays along with the original Cotton op-ed, and write on the following question: Do you think the New York Times should have published Cotton’s essay? Why or why not? We are woefully lacking in the ability to respond to anything with something other than cheering or frothing hatred. I don't know if the problem is actually getting worse or if it's just more visible these days, but I feel like I used to be able to see someone be called a fool without also calling for his crucifixion. Instead of criticizing and mocking we attack and attempt to destroy. If we fail we make an enemy into a worse enemy and when we succeed we make an enemy into a martyr. Fear is the wrong tool to use in the shifting of public opinion.
- jmugan 4y agoMy concern is it seems we are no longer able to see big decisions in terms of tradeoffs. We say X is good but don't acknowledge the downsides. The other side says Y is good without doing the same.
- Sin2x 4y agoTo put it differently, we feel rather than think.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoBecause the dialectic is a remarkably powerful tool of social division and coercion.
- Sin2x 4y agoDialectics teaches about unity of opposites so I don't see how it fits here.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoSynthesis does not equal unity.
- freedomtogripe 4y agoAcademic freedom for Amherst faculty is important to the college's mission. Their students will inherit the leadership of large institutions or storied family businesses and will need to know how to navigate these topics with poise and care. Understanding how to message to an increasingly diverse stock of labor supply is crucial to the good stewardship and continued accumulation of generational wealth. For those blissfully unaware: Amherst has a $3.8B endowment and 1745 students, or $2,177,650 per student (endowment income: $87K/student/year at a 4% withdraw). In addition to that $2M/student from the endowment, they also charge $61K/year in tuition. Amherst is a undergraduate-only teaching college, so unlike R1 these funds aren't e.g. funding a giant amount of R1 research labs or anything like that. They really do just have $90K/student per year in safe endowment withdrawal and then also charge $61K/yr in tuition. Academia has a lot of exhaustingly bullshit inter-personal stuff in general, but I have no idea how I would sit through the faculty meetings described in this post without exercising an excessive amount of academic freedom... UMass next door does infinitely more for all of these stated goals by just... not being a finishing school for the wealthy elite. (I don't have anything against Amherst per se. It's just a bit insufferable how few faculty at places like this understand that they are running finishing schools for the economic elite.)
- limpbizkitfan 4y agoNo, you’re absolutely right. Amherst exists for a completely different utility than any public university. It’s ironic how much of the “academic freedom” discussion on campus, much like the “mental health” discussion we’ve seen in the past 5 years, has led to so many of these sorts of haughty backgrounds now making their mental illness their identity or making their purported “freedom” yet another reason to love the Amherst brand.
- bannedbybros 4y ago
- igorkraw 4y agoI wonder why these type of op-eds see to always defend the speech of racists or those in favour of the beliefs of old billionaires, or the importance of publishing racist (etc) speech in private newspapers with editorial control, while the speech of hardcore Nazis, Hardcore leftists, Taliban sympathisants, radical equality movements, speech that is about sex and link and things that give offense to the prudes amongst us etc. does not get the same defense. Or speaking less blithely: Freedom of speech does not mean a right to be heard, it means the state can't stop you or punish you for speaking. Likewise, academic freedom does not necessarily mean everyone gets to say what they want. I don't think administrators deciding what should or should not be allowed to be said by faculty is good. But at the same time I don't see the problem of a society deciding that they don't want those endowed with a voice to amplify messages that are obsolete and/or regressive. As long as the hurdles for creating alternative newspapers and universities and...are low enough, I see no problem in faculty and staff lobbying for political stances out in the open - otherwise we'd have hidden political stances anyway.
- pjc50 4y agoAnother non-partisan example: should academics have free speech to publish opinions they have clearly been paid to promote as if they were research? https://www.theguardian.com/news/2022/jul/12/uber-paid-academics-six-figure-sums-for-research-to-feed-to-the-media https://www.theguardian.com/news/2022/jul/12/uber-paid-acade...
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago> I wonder why these type of op-eds [seem] to always defend the speech of racists or those in favour of the beliefs of old billionaires, or the importance of publishing racist (etc) speech ... It might help to consider that these beliefs are widely held and therefore more commonly encountered. I don't see why the argument can't be extended to the other classes of speech you mentioned. > Freedom of speech does not mean a right to be heard ... I feel like if that's the argument you're making, then you misunderstood the argument that was made. I don't think a person I disagree with has a right to be heard but I'd love to hear what our disagreement is. An important point to understand is that it's more likely for me to have a better understanding of my own opinion (rather than having it changed) specifically because I listened to and considered the dissenting opinion. It seems that it can only help me understand where the disagreement is. Perhaps more to the point: that it's speech being suppressed not by a government but rather a private entity doesn't mean that I would (or should) agree with said suppression. You can disagree but, indeed, that can only happen after you've heard me out.
- Sin2x 4y agoObligatory link to FIRE: https://rankings.thefire.org/ https://rankings.thefire.org/
- celeritascelery 4y agoI was a supporter of the ACLU back in the day. But when they changed from defending free speech, to working against it, I was not sure what to do. FIRE is now what the ACLU used to be, and I am so happy to have a organization fighting for this.
- frognumber 4y agoI feel like academic freedom matters a lot less than it used to. Academia used to be a place where intellectuals lived in relative austerity in return for the freedom to pursue intellectual pursuits. That made sense to me. Academic freedom in that context mattered. Academia is now a political race, rife with fraud to gain advantage, odd conflicts-of-interest, and extreme biases. You get tenure by sucking up so you have strong letters. From there, the elites are extremely over-capitalized, which leads to financial fraud too (my alma mater has an endowment of around $30M per faculty member). NDAs and non-disparage agreements are used to shut people up (at least below tenured-faculty level) who step out-of-line and to cover up fraud. In most modern elite academia, I don't really see a case for academic freedom. If there was something I'd want, it's more oversight and checks-and-balances. I do see it as important in K-12 education, community colleges, and some state schools (someone mentioned UMass; that's a good example). Indeed, providing real academic freedom is just about the best thing we could do for free to improve K-12 education.
- mfer 4y ago> I do see it as important in K-12 education Academic freedom of teachers teaching a 2nd or 3rd grader how to read? Or of teachers of 6th graders learning geography. This is where we get into politics and agendas. What happens when teachers want to introduce political ideas / ideologies to impressionable minds without them realizing it (they are kids)? What happens when parents disagree with those ideologies? If everyone involved is free thinking and capable of evaluating things it's one thing. That's something that's possible at the college level. Dealing with young children is entirely different.
- freedomtogripe 4y ago>> I do see it as important in K-12 education > Academic freedom of teachers teaching a 2nd or 3rd grader how to read? Or of teachers of 6th graders learning geography. I share your concerns, but I'll take the difficult position here. Before CRT bogeyman there was the Common Core bogeyman. Tucker Carlson has Strong Opinions on how to teach math. I shit you not. Every time I flew through MCI I had someone in the terminal or on the lane strike up conversation (midwest is like that) and learn that I'm in a math-heavy field. They would then say some inane shit about math education. I would ask the last math course they took. The highest answer I ever got was Calc or Linear Algebra, and 90% of the answers were "I don't remember" or "algebra in high school". So, yeah. Third grade teachers need cover. Because even http://www.corestandards.org/Math http://www.corestandards.org/Math was politicized by cable news talking heads. Go read it, not knowing what it is, and explain to me why someone who hasn't thought about math in 20 years would reasonably have any sort of opinion that's not motivated by a cable news talking head telling you that the reason you don't understand fifth grade probability theory is not that you were woefully failed by the American education system and your kid is already outstripping you, but because Obama Socialist Math makes no sense.
- jrm4 4y agoAnecdotally, I was in college for 95-99, and I think we are in a much better place, free-speech-wise, than back then. I think perhaps a LOT of people underestimate the extent to which a lot of the biases that e.g. people of color discuss today were so pervasive that one could not even bring them up without reprisal back then. And by reprisal I mean the following: if I were to merely discuss --as in, not advocate for, but merely discuss as a concept -- reparations, I'd immediately be dismissed and generally forever known as the angry black guy. Of course, not to purely blame white people I suppose, that was just the "way things were." In retrospect, the line someone like me had to walk was far narrower back then. We do have problems today, but I do not see a huge gap between those then and now.
- Sin2x 4y agoYour example has nothing to do with academic freedom whatsoever.
- bee_rider 4y agoThe ability to engage with unfashionable topics in an academic context has nothing to do with academic freedom?
- Sin2x 4y agoThere is no academic context here in the parent comment, only social context. This example would fit the topic if it were about writing a thesis on reparations that was rejected or if the author was actively dissuaded from writing it.
- bee_rider 4y agoIf we exclude the social context in which academic discussions occur from "academic context" then I guess there won't be very many cases where academic freedom is infringed upon.
- 4y ago
- kmeisthax 4y agoI generally agree with what the author is trying to say, as I like my reasoned takes on free speech, but I found this particular paragraph sticking itself up my craw: >When we act to silence white nationalists because we believe their views are false, we undercut our ability to justify our belief that their views are false, by preventing our reasons for believing so from being weighed against their reasons for holding those views, and thus we undermine our justification for the very act of silencing them. And this problem is not unique to the act of silencing white nationalist views. No matter the content of an opinion or the character of its proponent, the act of silencing it is self-undermining. Please, for the love of all that is holy, consider what white nationalists explicitly want to do. They want to prosecute a culture war, up to and including the marginalization, expulsion, or genocide of left-wingers, non-whites, Jews, Muslims, gays, the mentally ill, and generally anyone not perceived as part of their in-group[0]. I don't even need to go as far as to say free speech is an instrumental goal of something else like anti-racism. Even if you think free speech is itself the final goal, white nationalists are still harmful to you, because censorship is specifically a foundational plank in the platform. This is the sort of thing where the ardent free speech supporter needs to think a few steps ahead and consider what maximizes total freedom at the end of the game rather than the first move. I'll give you that frequent accusations of being a Nazi are mind-numbing. In fact, Nazis use that to their benefit. But at the same time, free speech supporters should not jump to their defense if those accusations are true. [0] Notably, what is actually considered the in-group - the "whiteness" to be protected - has no real logic to it; so this list will change all the time based on who swears fealty to whom. American nativists wanted to kill and eat the Irish, Hitler had underlings that wanted to replace Christianity with the old gods, etc.
- nonethewiser 4y ago> Please, for the love of all that is holy, consider what white nationalists explicitly want to do. You've missed the point. Removing the speech of white nationalists begets more white nationalism.
- pjscott 4y agoThat sounds like all the more reason to keep the arguments against them sharp. There's a recurring pattern that happens when you have a clash of two ideas, one of them so dominant that its supporters have forgotten how to argue. When Milton Friedman used to debate people about more-vs-less-free markets, his own position ("much more free, please") was so unpopular in academia that it gave him a huge rhetorical advantage. He knew his opponents' positions and had looked for good counterarguments, but his opponents had mostly not given much serious thought to the matter -- it seemed so obvious! -- and so they would be caught off-guard trying to refute unfamiliar points they'd never considered. He got to do most of his debates on easy mode. Bringing it back to race stuff, there's a common story you hear from people on certain parts of the internet: they saw one side that had what looked like a lot of calm, compelling scientific arguments, and they saw another side that never responded with anything more substantial than "you're a bunch of horrible racists whose opinions should be suppressed," and so they decided, welp, looks like these "human biodiversity" people have Important Hidden Truth. And from there some of them can be recruited to white nationalism, which has a similar rhetorical advantage. For anyone who's not a white nationalist, this should be at least a bit worrisome.
- boplicity 4y agoThis discussion of free speech makes one of the most common mistakes people make on this topic: It conflates not supporting speech with stifling speech. This actually turns the idea of free speech on its head: If your actions (which should be considered speech) are forced to support others' speech, then that's not free speech. That's forced speech. Most individuals, and non-government funded institutions, should be free to choose which speech they actively support, and which speech they simply ignore. Too often, proponents of free speech are actually promoting forced speech. They claim that not actively distributing, repeating, or hosting certain speech "suppresses" that speech, when, in fact, the lack of support is simply just that -- a lack of support. To force the support/disemmination of speech is antithetical to free speech.
- 78124781 4y agoNot allowing college professors to choose what readings they want to assign in class is, in fact, stifling free speech. The essay is advocating against "forced" speech in terms of only allowing consideration of one point of view and refusing to even provide/offer other points of view.
- scarmig 4y agoRestricting "freedom of speech" to simply the ability to function in an environment with no intrapersonal or governmental violence gives us at best a faded facsimile of it. Most "totalitarian" countries don't function by literally throwing people in prison or beating them for saying Bad Things: that's far too expensive to be total and widespread. It functions by removing people from positions of media exposure; by denying them access to physical or network media; by ascribing implicit or explicit social credit scores that governs access to resources. None of those things are violent and rarely even explicitly ordered by the State. In fact, "no one has the right to a platform to hurt society/the nation" is how those totalitarian regimes typically justify their repression. And they're still every bit as much a restriction on freedom of speech.
- freedomtogripe 4y ago> Most "totalitarian" countries don't function by literally throwing people in prison or beating them for saying Bad Things Yes, they absolutely do, and the threat of either state or political violence keeps most people in line. > that's far too expensive to be total and widespread. That's true for all criminal acts, everywhere. The US doesn't even clear the majority of its violent crime. Law enforcement of all types and in all cases works via deterrence rather than perfect enforcement.
- kepler1 4y agoTwo major problems with academic freedom right now (which you find yourself wondering, were the liberal-claiming professorate only respecting academic freedom when they were opinions they agreed with?): 1. There is an increasing belief in "the right to not be offended" which is something that if you want to live in a society with free speech rights, you must nip in the bud. Anyone can be offended about anything, including things that are true. This cannot be the standard for censorship. 2. "Racism" and censorship based on "racism" is sinking its teeth into everything and extending its scope to include discussion of facts and policies that plainly have to do with race. Pointing out blatant facts that have correlations with race is becoming taboo. I put racism in quotes, because what racism means is being expanded, including to cause anyone offense with facts having to do with race. The more the above 2 factors are allowed to take hold in an organization, school, society, and people get shouted down for daring to raise such points -- then the more legitimate opinions and discussion relating to these 2 areas will simply be pushed underground and only privately held in people's minds, and unable to be talked about publicly. And then, people who claimed they were all for free speech, non-censorship, will be surprised when people, in the privacy of the voting booth, actually express their opinions and show that they did not agree the entire time and are not on board with the ideas that the one side thought everyone was on board with. I'm glad the OP article touched on these points.
- nonethewiser 4y ago> "the right to not be offended" Sadly, I think this understates it. In the case of the article, it is disallowing "speech that causes identity-based harm." Instead of treating these people as offended, they are treated as if they were assaulted.
- ltbarcly3 4y agoI think the current state of affairs is that everyone in academia has 100% perfect and total academic freedom. However, they don't have basic rights of due process, so it becomes quite easy to remove someone who's opinions are not 'allowed' via a spurious, sometimes decades old, accusation and evaluating those accusations via a process which does not value truth.
- bannedbybros 4y ago[dead]
- alsaaro 4y agoA quote from the Lt. Gov of Texas, who is also leader of the Texas state Senate. "“During the upcoming 88th Legislative Session, one of my priorities will be eliminating tenure at all public universities in Texas. To address already-tenured professors, we will change tenure reviews from every 6 years to annually,” Patrick said. “Additionally, we will define teaching Critical Race Theory in statute as a cause for a tenured professor to be dismissed,” he added." There is too much hand-wringing amongst the liberals, accusing each other of being anti free speech; when in reality, as always, the people who are actually anti-speech are the supposed conservatives. Witness conservatives use the power of government to un-Constitutionally suppress speech by banning books from libraries, to requiring professors to register their political affiliation (in Florida), to banning what students can or can't learn or even hear about in class. I'm trying to be fair and think of an instance where American liberals used their legislative power to outright ban ideas, and I can't think of a singular instance. I suppose this is what it means to be an outgroup, unprotected by the 1st Amendment, yet still bound by anti-speech codes at the State/local level (currently).
- nonethewiser 4y ago> by banning books from libraries Does anyone genuinely believe this is a threat to free speech though? I only see this projected onto people who argue for free speech, like you are doing. But people who argue for free speech don't also argue that we should push all information on children. Sex, how to murder someone, curse words, etc. It's not that they are hypocrites, its that you're oversimplifying someone else's perspective until it appears to be a contradiction.
- deadpannini 4y agoWe badly need strong cultural norms against ostracizing people for what they say, short of speech that breaks the law. People should meet bad arguments with counter-arguments, or if they wish, disassociate from those that make bad arguments, but organizing someone's personal or professional destruction for speech they disagree with has been, throughout history, nothing other than a naked exercise of power and a wellspring of bloody social conflict.