16 ms·
> Automotive giant Ford is shoring up its battery supply chain — partly by importing lower-cost, iron-based batteries popular in China — as it sprints to increa
by bell-cot 4y ago
> Automotive giant Ford is shoring up its battery supply chain — partly by importing lower-cost, iron-based batteries popular in China — as it sprints to increase electric vehicle production.
Old geezer's perspective: Back in its heyday, Ford Motor was one of the most vertically integrated (large manufacturing) companies in the world. They owned and operated their own fleet of ore carriers (cargo ships), to haul iron ore from the mines to the steel mill that was part of their all-Ford integrated manufacturing complex. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_River_Rouge_Complex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_River_Rouge_Complex - though Wikipedia barely scratches the surface on this. ) Back in the early 90's, I knew a couple guys who had spent their careers working on those iron ore carriers.
Current-day Ford Motor having to go begging to China - for a major, iron-based component needed to produce more cars - that is laughable, and beyond pathetic. In a dark, miserable sort of way, if you care about America or its future.
- cumshitpiss 4y agoWhat's wrong with trading with China?
- phtrivier 4y agoChina spent the last two years demonstrating that they're "fair weather partners" when it comes to trade. And winter is coming. So obviously it's not bad _per se_ to rely on China ; but if it's not possible to diversify sourcing, this is begging for a disaster next time whatever geopolitic hits the fan.
- CyanBird 4y ago> Fairweather What do you even mean, it wasn't them whom started the whole tradewar... It was the US gov
- phtrivier 4y agoI meant that in any situation where china has to choose between interior market / upholding CCP plans / régional partnership vs trading with the global west, they will chose the former in times of crisis. Which is not a bad thing, again, it's just that everyone is relying on them as if they are an infinite factory of everything with unlimited supply, and it seems that, well, it's not true any more. But if they decide to stop trade with Russia tomorrow, I'll reconsider.
- criley2 4y agoHow did they spend two years demonstrating they are fair weather partners? Was it the part where they locked workers inside of factories producing goods for America to make sure that the Americans got their shipments in spite of the Covid-0 policy? Or was it how China is actually upholding most sanctions against Russia, despite giving less than 0 f's about Ukraine? IMO the real disaster would be a total de-link between Chinese and American economies. Neither country can currently engage in any kind of meaningful hostilities while 10%+ of their economies are linked in trade. Trade prevents war because war would mean decimation of their economies and lead to likely depressions, although I suppose the results of Russia's invasion and how their economy handles de-linking will inform this logic going forward
- Cupertino95014 4y ago> Trade prevents war because war would mean decimation of their economies and lead to likely depressions 1913 is calling and wants its optimism back. If the fertilizer hits the fan re Taiwan, the CCP will not hesitate to cut off all trade with everyone who supports Taiwan.
- sudosysgen 4y agoThey won't stop trading with Taiwan supporting countries. They don't have any plans of that as far as anyone knows and never threatened it. The threat is that the US executes it's public plans of sinking ships trading with China in such a contingency.
- phtrivier 4y agoThat will sound tongue in cheek, and to some extend it is, but if the last few years have shown us anything, it's the perils of starting a sentence by "xxx won't yyy" (for several values of x and y.)
- sudosysgen 4y agoThat's an extrapolation. There hasn't ever been in a country that decided to sanction themselves within wartime from most of the world economy, and leaked documents show that one of the reason China wants Taiwan to begin with is to make their trade more secure.
- clouddrover 4y agoChina arbitrarily bans trade when it wants to "punish" nations: https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/china-turns-to-lobsters-wine-and-coal-to-punish-australia-1.1516850 https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/china-turns-to-lobsters-wine-and... China has made it clear that it is an unreliable business partner. It is a mistake to do business with nations that don't share your values, as Russia is also currently demonstrating.
- pacija 4y agoThis is the price, those are the terms. If you don't like them go buy somewhere else or produce yourself.
- stale2002 4y agoSo then yes, you agree completely with the statement that was made, which was "It is a mistake to do business with nations that don't share your values". Yeah that's the point.
- pokepim 4y ago[flagged]
- clouddrover 4y ago> And what values are exactly that? Democratic nations which abide by international trade agreements. Nations you can do business with which are governed by the rule of law instead of the whims of a political party or dictator. > We just had president who was white supremacist who called other countries shitholes. America can turn itself into whatever it wants to be. If America can no longer be trusted in business then it's correct not to do business with it. > When business with China was good nobody cared they still had communist party ruling the country. Yes, that's a mistake.
- wowokay 4y agoWhat the heck? Do you somehow only watch the super opinionated stuff on both Fox and CNN, giving you polar opposite trash talk from both sides of the aisle? Lol If anything The first one wasn’t a white supremacist because “he had alot of Mexican friends” and the other isn’t cozying up to a dictator because our gas supply offset wasn’t shifty to Saudi backed oil supplies, not to mention all his work his son has done with sketchy characters that he tries to distance himself from.
- bell-cot 4y agoBeyond the political issues already noted... - "We must travel to the most-distant place in the world, and the only source of $Thing, which we cannot survive without!" That sounds great, if you're writing epic fantasy quest stories. If you're talking supply chain management...maybe there is something profoundly wrong with your company? - Even if the CCP would never dream of squeezing Ford's battery life-line...the battery factory there could be shut down for yet another COVID outbreak, or the US could squeeze it (due to domestic politics or "Taiwan Troubles"), or etc. - The giant mess (huge delays, staggering price spikes, etc.) that global shipping has been in the past few years. Shipping car batteries from China to the US via air freight does not sound like a money-making plan. My old World Atlas suggests that shipping by rail is probably not an option.
- dylan604 4y ago>My old World Atlas suggests that shipping by rail is probably not an option. Is that the same atlas that says there's not an option for rail from UK to France as well?
- bell-cot 4y agoGreat quip, but it's more complex. The Chunnel is delicate infrastructure, with neither a backup nor a short repair time if something bad happened. I have not examined their Dangerous/Forbidden Freight List for "bulk rechargeable batteries" - but such lists can change. OTOH, there are dense freight rail networks on both sides of the Channel, and similar for ports, shipping, etc. Vs. you'd need to build a few thousand miles of freight RR in Siberia, Alaska, and other places "unfriendly to economical RR construction and operation" in order to ship from China to the US via rail.
- timwaagh 4y agoThemz commies something something pooh bear.
- tedk-42 4y ago> Current-day Ford Motor having to go begging to China - for a major, iron-based component needed to produce more cars - that is laughable, and beyond pathetic. In a dark, miserable sort of way, if you care about America or its future. Sounds similar to Boeing where accounting for personal gain (promotions / raises) of upper managers and executives took effect over the long term advantage of the company.
- dotancohen 4y agoBut there was no McDonald Douglas absorbed into Ford to explain this shift. Yet it seemed to happen during a similar timeframe (late '90s, early 2000s).
- b112 4y agoJIT MBA driven push came then, plus the whole "stay within your area of expertise" movement.
- Spooky23 4y agoWall St punished diversification, so anything that could slow growth had to go. We’re shifting to a new era where cash is king. That’s why Amazon built their own UPS and Apple will be a bank in a few years.
- MrMan 4y agowhy "a few years" why not now?
- chiph 4y agoFunny you should mention Boeing. Alan Mulally went to Ford in 2006 after working for Boeing for 35+ years. In my opinion he was a net positive for the company, securing a credit line just before the 2007 recession so that Ford did not have to get bailed out by the government. He also sold off Jaguar/Land Rover just in time before gas prices spiked and their sales slumped. I think he is one of the "good" Boeing execs, unlike the ones that came in with the McDonnell Douglas merger and mismanaged production of aircraft like the 787 and 737-MAX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Mulally https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Mulally
- solarkraft 4y ago> Current-day Ford Motor having to go begging to China - for a major, iron-based component needed to produce more cars - that is laughable, and beyond pathetic. They're lucky China is answering. They're incredibly late to the EV game; considering that they're doing remarkably well.
- dylan604 4y ago>They're incredibly late to the EV game; considering that they're doing remarkably well. When you're not the trailblazer, it's easy to make catch-up progress to those that went before you in much much less time. Why this is constantly a source of amazement is funny to me. By the time Ford got involved, the path was no longer a beaten down path, it was fully paved 8-lane highway. Instead trying to figure out how to make an electrified car, they just took all of the learning before them and then turned it into something fancy. While Tesla is "working" on self-driving and not doing well with it, Ford said, nah, we'll just turn our batteries into a generator for the home. They built an actual truck that looks like the same truck everyone is used to and say here it is as an electric. That's easy to do when you are riding coat tails
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoAll of this is true except for the part where no other manufacturer (other than Tesla) has a reliable source of batteries -- so they're subject to intense supply chain constraints that limit inventory drastically. And so they were unable to meet the consumer demand for EVs. Hence you simply can't even get a Ford F150 Lightning even though it looks like a great vehicle. This all pre-dated the COVID related supply chain issues, BTW. Lack of battery supply is behind the lackluster inventory (and therefore sales) of all non-Tesla vehicles for over half a decade. I say all this not as a Tesla fan, but as a GM electric vehicle owner. GM was unable to produce more then a few tens of thousands of Bolts a year -- not because consumers didn't want them, but because there was simply no way for them to get them from LG Chem. VW/Audi group has had the same issue. They're both not late to the game on EV tech or production, but very late to the game on battery production. Being late to the game in this case has a huge cost. And various governments wasted time and money providing consumer subsidies for EV purchases thinking this would lead the market to magically "solve" the EV supply issue by increasing consumer demand when the issue that really needed solving was volume and cost of battery production. If we were going to involve public dollars in getting EVs to market we should have invested massively in encouraging battery production. Some governments are waking up to this now at least.
- NickRandom 4y agoAnd of course as a further example of their supply chain integration no conversation on it would be complete without mention of Fordlandia [1][2] [1] Lost cities #10: Fordlandia – the failure of Henry Ford's utopian city in the Amazon https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/aug/19/lost-cities-10-fordlandia-failure-henry-ford-amazon https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/aug/19/lost-cities-1... [2] Wikipedia Entry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fordlandia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fordlandia
- RustyConsul 4y ago>the failure of Henry Ford's utopian city in the Amazon That title is extremely loaded. Ford rubber mining operations in the amazon fail when synthetic rubber is invented is the true story.
- NickRandom 4y agoHence the [1] and [2] provison of sources. It is an interesting historical factoid. Nothing more. Nothing Less.
- rasz 4y agoOne hour podcast: Fordlandia: America In Brazil (RCR Car Stories) - YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gN5JjScdB3g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gN5JjScdB3g
- fredsmith219 4y agoFrom the U.P. To Rouge it was Ford all the way. Did they own the mines as well?
- bluedino 4y agoDoesn't sound like it http://www.miningartifacts.org/Michigan-Iron-Mines.html http://www.miningartifacts.org/Michigan-Iron-Mines.html
- justapassenger 4y agoOffshore outsourcing of everything is as bad of an idea as vertical integration of every single aspect of your business.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AngryData 4y agoVertical integration builds up a resiliency against supply chain issues. You have a guarenteed supply of materials and components for a reasonable price no matter how crazy world markets get.
- namlem 4y agoIt's often too expensive to be worth it though. Just look at Intel.
- justapassenger 4y agoIt’s often not even about cost. Vertical integration works great if you can always make right R&D decisions. If you bet on wrong horses (even if you have money) you’re hopelessly stuck as you cannot “easily” shift to different suppliers that made better R&D choices. Just look at Intel.
- rawoke083600 4y agoThey also grow their own trees for the rubber required to make tires ! Next level !
- criley2 4y agoWhat a shocking final sentence!! "Current-day Ford Motor having to go begging to China - for a major, iron-based component needed to produce more cars - that is laughable, and beyond pathetic. In a dark, miserable sort of way, if you care about America or its future." I could not have summarized it more differently. Vertical integration and monopolies are absolutely terrible in many ways. Globalization and inter-reliance are very good in many ways! The ideal system for everyone (workers, buyers, the business itself, the society it resides in, and the world itself) is probably a healthy middle point. I'll go so far as to say this: if the US did not inter-rely on China over the past 30 years since they opened up their markets, with multi-national US corporations beginning to rely on various Chinese resources or products, then the US would be at a hot or cold war with China right now, just like they were with the USSR a generation ago.
- dghughes 4y agoAnd if I recall correctly Ford was the only US vehicle manufacturer that did not request a bailout in 2008. That was impressive at the time and it made Ford look like solid well-run company that planned ahead.
- bobthepanda 4y agoIt was a really well run marketing campaign, complete with clever nicknames (e.g. Government Motors) The truth is a bit murkier. The car division was not bailed out, but the financial arm did accept government assistance like all the other car loan companies.
- dragonwriter 4y agoIIRC, Ford explicitly said that if it hadn't been for the effect of the bailouts of an other manufacturers on shared supply chains, it would have needed a bailout.
- sitkack 4y agoCould you explain this with a couple sentences, I don't understand.
- throwaway_4ever 4y agoSay GM and Chrysler weren't bailed out. Then they wouldn't be able to support the trade between other third party car parts manufacturers that rely on them. Those companies would lose economies of scale and/or go out of business too. Then wouldn't Ford be able to make their cars without those third parties and would need bailing out to not go bankrupt also.
- pixl97 4y agoWhen dominoes start tipping they can all fall over.
- HWR_14 4y agoTotally made up example (with easy to follow numbers): Let's say GM, Chevrolet and Ford all buy 12V car batteries from BatteryCo at the rate of 1,000,000 a year (each). BatteryCo has fixed annual costs of $3,000,000 and per battery costs of $1. Right now, Ford pays $2/battery. If GM and Chevrolet both go out of business, Ford's 1,000,000 batteries need to absorb the whole fixed operating cost of $3,000,000. Therefore, Ford's per battery cost doubles to $4/battery. You can imagine other numbers and other parts of the supply chain all working similarly.
- throwaway9870 4y agoFord bought New Holland back in the 80s. New Holland was very vertically integrated and Ford, after taking the reins, declared that they were going to teach New Holland how to become recession proof by outsourcing as much as possible and pushing the risk onto the suppliers. Yes, there is some logic in that plan, but on the other hand, it comes with a whole other set of risks.
- Animats 4y agoFord is building other battery plants. Huge plant going up in Tennessee, "Blue Oval City", for lithium-ion batteries.[1] The battery technology comes from S. Korea. The lithium will come from Ioneer in Nevada.[2] Another plant is going up in Kentucky. Plus there's existing electric production at the Rouge plant in Detroit. Ford is serious about electric trucks. Tesla's Cybertruck initial delivery was just delayed another year.[3] [1] https://www.commercialappeal.com/story/money/business/2022/04/01/ford-blue-oval-city-tennessee-sk-on-group-innovation/7121656001/ https://www.commercialappeal.com/story/money/business/2022/0... [2] https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/ford-buy-lithium-ioneer-american-ev-battery-plant-2022-07-21/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/ford-b... [3] https://observer.com/2022/07/tesla-cybertruck-production-delay-reservation/ https://observer.com/2022/07/tesla-cybertruck-production-del...
- knubie 4y ago> But Ford also wants to produce LFP batteries in North America, and plans to open a 40-GWh LFP cell factory by 2026. (That's in addition to three previously announced battery plants in Tennessee and Kentucky.)
- freemint 4y agoThe west completely ignored graphite + iron phosphate as electrode combination for cars while China researched it for decades. Packing innovation from China made that combination feasible to use in electric cars. Those packaging innovations are way more impressive then what Tesla is doing. </Context>