6 ms·
You're not the only one whos confused about the economy. Experts are baffled too
- theknocker 4y ago[dead]
- mikkergp 4y agoWhat is the ELI5 20 people trading things in a small town definition of a recession? I get the whole 2 quarters of economic decline definition, but I guess I ask because part of a recession is psychological right? It gets worse because people stop spending, creating a downward spiral. I guess the question is, if we just spend through it, will it last a shorter amount of time? I get the impression that that creates economic risk - i.e. if you're spending through it and lose your job or have a financial crisis, you might additionally lose your house or some other bad thing could happen.
- pjmorris 4y agoAt the risk of butchering an old joke, my attempt at the ELI5 small town version of a recession is the following story, but the rich tourist never shows up.... From [0]: It’s a slow day in some little town…….. The sun is hot….the streets are deserted. Times are tough, everybody is in debt, and everybody lives on credit. On this particular day a rich tourist from back west is driving thru town. He stops at the motel and lays a $100 bill on the desk saying he wants to inspect the rooms upstairs in order to pick one to spend the night. As soon as the man walks upstairs, the owner grabs the bill and runs next door to pay his debt to the butcher. The butcher takes the $100 and runs down the street to retire his debt to the pig farmer. The pig farmer takes the $100 and heads off to pay his bill at the feed store. The guy at the Farmer’s Co-op takes the $100 and runs to pay his debt to the local prostitute, who has also been facing hard times and has had to offer her services on credit. She, in a flash rushes to the motel and pays off her room bill with the motel owner. The motel proprietor now places the $100 back on the counter so the rich traveler will not suspect anything. At that moment the traveler comes down the stairs, picks up the $100 bill, states that the rooms are not satisfactory, pockets the money & leaves. NOW,… no one produced anything…and no one earned anything…however the whole town is out of debt and is looking to the future with much optimism. [0] https://www.econlib.org/archives/2012/01/an_answer_to_a.html https://www.econlib.org/archives/2012/01/an_answer_to_a.html
- h2odragon 4y agobut the $100 wasn't the motel's to spend yet; it was a conditional deposit and reclaimed quickly. had it gone elsewhere in the chain the actual owner of that money would have a case for theft.
- mikkergp 4y agoThis makes the joke so much more funnier.
- psi75 4y agoDavid Graeber's Debt: the First 5,000 Years is really worth reading to understand the anthropology of debt. It's common in societies to accumulate unpayable debts (that, over time, evolve into debts designed never to be paid) for ceremonial purposes. A society might foster interdependence by having everyone in debt to everyone (as described in the fable above) in small amounts. Over time, these amounts grow. Nothing really stops them. House prices and education costs are no longer limited by what people can pay, because borrowing in increasingly large amounts becomes licit (and necessary, due to inflated prices). This generates a spiral. People can't afford to pay off their coming-of-age debt? Yeah, it's designed that way. In other societies it has been marriage or funeral expenses or receiving one's first hunting tools--in ours, it is the last 4-8 years of schooling. These ceremonial debts seem harmless, insofar as the penalties for nonpayment are rarely enforced--few people actually have their wages garnished over medical bills or student loans--but, of course, they're anything but. In practice, they reify the ruling class's self-asserted superiority by giving them a legal justification for bringing harm to those who "freely" took on these debts. For reasons unclear, although Graeber examines a few possibilities, there seems to be a psychological weight given to the notion of debt, so strong that debts even outlive governments and states.
- ChadNauseam 4y agoThat does have a resemblance to what happens during a recession, but I'll point out that clearing houses mitigate that specific problem with debt cycles. For a more realistic analogy than the one you mentioned, I'd check out Krugman's article about a recession in a babysitting co-op: https://slate.com/business/1998/08/baby-sitting-the-economy.html https://slate.com/business/1998/08/baby-sitting-the-economy.... . It seems to be exactly what the GP was looking for
- grumple 4y agoIf our savings over the pandemic are able to keep us afloat through a recession, isn't that exactly what we hoped those savings would do?
- im3w1l 4y agoAn attempt: Adam sees a gold nugget on his property. He decides that rather than preserving plums like he normally does this time of year he will start a business mining gold. He takes out a loan from Bob at a high interest rate. He hires Charlie who previously worked as a tailor, and Dick who was unemployed. Anticipating future riches Adam, Bob, Charlie and Dick all start spending more money. Evan the innkeeper has to cook more and fancier food for them. He works longer hours and builds up some savings, thinking that he will spend it on fine gold jewelry from Adam later. The mining effort finds absolutely nothing. Adam has neither gold nor plums and defaults on his debt to Bob. He lays off Charlie and Dick. For Evan business goes back to normal, he has money but the jewelry he wanted to buy doesn't exist. Eventually Adam starts preserving plums again and Charlie goes back to tailoring.
- mikkergp 4y agoUntil someone else comes up with a wild idea? I guess this is sort of what I had in mind, to make it at like state or industry sized scale, new idea comes along 20 companies try it. Spend a bunch of money hire people etc, feeding the economy. 16 companies fail. 1 company grows to 4x, 3 companies stay at 1x = 7x. 13 companies worth of value sort of has to dissolve into the economy before the next innovation/growth train comes along.
- corey_moncure 4y agoIt's very easy to understand if you just think about the basics. Put the books and academic theories back on the shelf. In the USA we want "good" jobs that come with personal fulfillment, agency, mental stimulation... great. We also want free healthcare, free education, free everything. Fine. But at the end of the day our money has to buy things of actual value, even as we provide the aforementioned niceties, such as food, housing, medical equipment, computers, i.e. manufactured products, which can only be made by soul-crushing labor and toil. There's a difference between productive labor (creating value) and service (moving value around). Our currency loses value because too much of the economy is constituted by unproductive jobs where people just attend to each other instead of creating any value. 1.2 trillion dollars on health care every year. 800 billion dollars on welfare. The wolves are at the doorstep.
- jvalencia 4y agoOne slight adjustment to your thinking, tech titans create massive value: "In 2021, the Big Five tech giants—Apple, Amazon, Google (Alphabet), Meta, and Microsoft—generated a combined $1.4 trillion in revenue." https://www.visualcapitalist.com/how-big-tech-makes-their-billions-2022/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/how-big-tech-makes-their-bi...
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoOnly if one assumes that revenue is the same thing as "value" in this context, which it clearly isn't.
- chrisco255 4y agoSo what is "value" then? Seems like you're hinting that it's some subjective, personal impression more than anything else.
- pythonaut_16 4y agoThe parent's point is that revenue is not equal to value. Determining actual value generated by tech companies is tricky
- slaw 4y agoFed printed crazy amount of dollars. I am not confused at all why we have inflation. I am confused why Fed is not rising interest rates which should never go below 2%.
- iso1631 4y agoFed printed crazy amounts of dollars since 2008 and didn't drive inflation High oil prices, restricted supply chians from covid do drive inflation
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hcurtiss 4y agoAbsent supply constraints (putting aside the fact that's another way of saying demand exceeds supply), do you believe there is any point at which printing money drives inflation? If yes, at what point would you say it would? See the M1 graphic linked above.
- keyme 4y agoEverybody is trying to explain this away with Russia, Covid... I'm not even following the excuses anymore. It'll be climate change soon. But that's ridiculous. Literally the only way to have inflation is if the Fed chooses to cause inflation, or not to resist inflation, of which it has done both in the last few years.
- daenz 4y agoIs this an accurate representation of the situation? https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL
- brianbterry 4y agoIts not because there is a series break when M1 was redefined in May 2020. See No.5: https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h6/h6_technical_qa.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h6/h6_technical_qa.h...
- burnte 4y agoThat's because economists think there's a rational market, and there isn't, only a human one. Everything in the human world, including the economy, is affected by human psychology as a primary driver, everything else is secondary to emotionally driven discussions based on prognostication.
- buscoquadnary 4y agoTo my economics is one of the peak science "cargo cults" it would seem that if there was some sort of science behind it many of the experts would all agree on the same thing, yet the argument between Austrian and Kenseyian economics is alive and well. I studied economics for a long time got deep into it, and what I've concluded is that it has much more in common with Philosophy than science. They dress it up with words and charts and formulas but it always seem that what they say doesn't pan out. I'll agree with the idea of supply and demand that seems to work pretty well in most cases to describe things, but beyond that the economy is such a complex system it is too chaotic to model with any degree of accuracy.
- readthenotes1 4y agoYou are much kinder than I am. I believe it has much more in common with astrology than philosophy. In fact, it is hard for me to differentiate between the two.
- marcosdumay 4y agoIt would help if the people that actually know it and want to honestly speak about it had a voice, instead of politically oriented talking heads and entertainers.
- EarlKing 4y agoAt some point you have to ask yourself if maybe they're not simply confused but rather they say whatever anyone pays them to say. In short: Stop attributing to confusion what can be adequately explained by payola.
- freedude 4y agoI think the headline is missing air quotes. It should be "Experts" not Experts.
- Negitivefrags 4y agoCompanies are frantically hiring and yet output is dropping. Output per worker is lower than ever before! What possible massive shift in the way people work could possibly explain this?! It’s so obvious but people just don’t want to hear it.
- freemint 4y agoWhat is your answer? Mine would be energy costs. Methods which employ more manual labor and less energy are preferred.
- game-of-throws 4y ago> Output per worker is lower than ever before! Citation needed. In 2021 corporate profits increased more than any year in recorded history: https://fortune.com/2022/03/31/us-companies-record-profits-2021-price-hikes-inflation/ https://fortune.com/2022/03/31/us-companies-record-profits-2... > When taxes are factored in, last year’s corporate profit increases were even more of an outlier. They soared 37% year over year, more than any other time since the Fed began tracking profits in 1948. Companies that embrace this mysterious "massive shift in the way people work" will have a nice competitive advantage.
- freemint 4y agoI am looking forward to the deflation once the energy prices recover.
- taylodl 4y agoThe experts have never experienced an economy suffering from supply constraints in their lifetime. Just prior to the pandemic there was talk of how to do economics in a "post scarcity" world. That's how foreign of a concept supply constraints are. Thanks to their advanced healthcare and pharmaceuticals, the West has largely put the pandemic behind them. Life has more-or-less returned to normal, meaning demand has more-or-less returned to normal. In fact demand has increased - there's pent-up demand from being on lockdown for two years. Bottom line - demand is up. What about supply? Almost everything manufactured has at least one component manufactured in an East Asian country. Even if you're an American manufacturer you probably rely on at least one component coming from one of these countries. Significant portions of East Asian manufacturing is still locked-down due to the pandemic. There have been articles here on HN just in the past two weeks talking about, for example, American synthesizer companies going out of business because they can't get needed parts - parts that in some cases they ordered two years ago! Bottom line - supply is down. What happens to prices when supply is down and demand is up? ECON 101 says they increase. Which they did. That increase has freaked out central banks who see the inflation as a need for fiscal policy intervention and raise rates. The U.S. dollar is trading at historic levels against the panoply of world currencies yet the Fed took action to make it even more valuable - incredible! Maybe instead we should stop pretending the pandemic is over all over the world and start focusing on the impacts the still-continuing pandemic is having on supply chains. Just a thought. Another thing - this is why Putin invaded the Ukraine now. With the global supply chain out of sorts this is the time that's allowed Putin to maximize the chaos and economic pain on the West should they attempt to retaliate. Putin wasn't stupid, he thought this one through. Putin knew he could throw the oil market out of sorts, the nitrogen fertilizer market out of sorts, the noble gas market out of sorts, and the world grain market out of sorts. Russia is waging economic warfare against everybody but the Middle East, China, and India. Stew on that one for a while.
- orky56 4y agoGreat points and a few others to add. 1. Russia has definitely chosen the optimal time to act. Grain harvest is down everywhere due to drought except...Russia (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-62149522 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-62149522) and they naturally benefit. Based on the heating/cooling cycles, the Ukraine land will produce better harvests in the next 10-20 years. So we see Russia impacting Western countries and alliances with grain/oil. China & India are happily importing said oil. Russia still is enjoying its victories in the information war on the West. Obviously militarily, Russia is behind where they would like to be. 2. It's also important to note that artificially low interest rates have allowed businesses to charge more for the same goods/services (sometimes less with "shrinkflation") since consumers/businesses have access to higher lines of credit. High demand inventory is turning over, unemployment is still low, and wages remain stagnant.
- jongjong 4y agoI think the problem is that a handful of very large companies have found ways to extract a lot of money from the economy whilst providing essentially no economic value in return. The economy has become so manipulated and schematized, in certain sectors, it's essentially all fake at this stage. All money through the economy just flows to people based on where they fit within the grand financial scheme. This scheme is not connected to fundamentals like supply and demand of consumers. It almost seems as though some companies have literally found a way to print themselves unlimited money and other economic participants won't figure it out for another decade... They're still playing by the rules.
- tmnvix 4y agoFinancialisation. I have a strong suspicion that the benefits of increased productivity are claimed by the finance industry. Credit/debt increases along with productivity keeping us mere mortals from enjoying the benefits we otherwise could (e.g. greater security and leisure time).
- mixedCase 4y agoHave they asked any non-Keynesian economist why printing and distributing large amounts of money do not lead to a large, sustained economic recovery?
- dragonwriter 4y agoThat's not a mystery, even to Keynesians (which is why it's the Keynesian response to a particular condition, and not the Keynesian approach to, well, everything), and isn't the issue of confusion the article is addressing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- willcipriano 4y agoI doubt Thomas Sowell is confused, Milton Friedman wouldn't be either. Having read both I am not confused. Events have transpired as they have predicted. The only thing that is confusing is how someone could think it would've went any other way.
- danaris 4y agoI wouldn't expect that it's the sole cause of the current instability and troubles (there are a number of other obvious sources of perturbation), but it can't be entirely irrelevant that we've been going for ~50 years with minimal increases in real wages, and vast increases in income and wealth at the top, and then thrown in on top of it a global pandemic, a war in Europe creating supply shocks (particularly in energy), and now very, very clear signals that if you're not part of The Elect (rich non-queer white men), you're going to have your rights stripped away from you, including your (effective) right to vote (if you're a minority or queer in a red state) and your right to bodily autonomy (if you have a functioning uterus). These things can have a real effect on how, and whether, people choose to spend.
- badinsie 4y agooh, very easy. illegal naked short selling. hedge funds and too big to fail banks got caught with their hand in the cookie jar. very very simple to explain. too bad no one cares to listen, though.