7 ms·
This Intel-approved not-a-review isn't a good look for LTT.
by wmf 4y ago
This Intel-approved not-a-review isn't a good look for LTT.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 4y agoWhat specifically would you change? They talked about the important failings of the GPU drivers, and it's not worth giving many specific numbers when they're likely to change before release. They also can't evaluate the whole package properly until a price is announced. There's not really anything intel could be hiding here that's worse than the big performance issues they acknowledge. And I'd much rather have this kind of preview than nothing.
- wmf 4y agoI think I'd prefer nothing, but that's just me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Teever 4y agoSo just to be clear, you don't like the content and wish it didn't exist, but can't really articulate much beyond that? This is some 'old man yells at clouds' level posting man. Why do it?
- LoveMortuus 4y agotl;dr: Received LTT hoodie as a gift (the gift giver paid almost 2x the price due to shipping and import), the quality of materials is so bad that since trying it on, I haven't worn it since. I used to like their videos because they seemed honest and somewhat transparent. But about a year ago I received a LTT branded hoodie (WAN hoodie) as a Christmas gift and I was seriously shocked but the quality. It's July now which means that is been more then half a year and I haven't worn it once since trying it. The inside of the hoodie is extremely rough so much so that it could be unpleasant to the touch. The zipper is flipped, which means that you have to use the other hand to zip it, which here where the position of the zipper is basically standard is perceived as just basically wrong, at first I thought that maybe it was a manufacturing defect, but there seem to be many people that report a flipped zipper and when I was trying mine on quite a lot of lose threads were just falling out. This was a real shock to me, especially because LTT always talks about how quality is important and how they won't release a product if it isn't good. Sadly I can't return it, because it was a gift and I've been told that the import costs and shipping for the hoodie were almost the cost of the hoodie.
- IntelMiner 4y agoHave you considered just...contacting their support team? It's Linus Media Group, not Versace. They pride themselves on good customer service
- LoveMortuus 4y agoI have considered it. But there are three problems that I encountered: 1. It was a gift, so it just feels wrong, which is of course completely subjective and on me. 2. It being a gift I don't have the receipt for the hoodie, which could cause issues. 3. Shipping again. For those wondering, I'm from Slovenia, Europe, so it is quite away from Canada.
- rawoke083600 4y agoTo be fair, I think they are changing that or the focus on quality. Looking at their recent videos it looks like they constantly on the hunt for better manufacturers and even do their own testing like color-bleads washing.
- LoveMortuus 4y agoYou're right. Their adventures regarding the development of their screwdriver does give you hope that it might be good, like the tools used to be, where you bought them and they stayed with you for the rest of your life.
- proto-n 4y agoA quick note about zipper sides: customs are quite varied on this in different countries. From shipping cost I assume you live far away from canada, maybe it's just that your country has it the other way around? You can't really fault ltt for that.
- LoveMortuus 4y agoYou're correct, I'm from Slovenia, Europe, which is basically on the other side of the planet. Regarding the zipper, you're correct, it's not a thing that people think would be different around the world and thus don't pay much attention to it when buying stuff on the internet.
- AlphaSite 4y agoThey also did another good unscripted section on their podcast, which I enjoyed, Ryan sprout and friend are both fun to listen too and seem to happily share details.
- denkmoon 4y agoHow so?
- wmf 4y agoIn general when a company is controlling what you can say, they're doing it to make their product look better. Publications that aspire to actual journalism shouldn't participate in that.
- sirtoffski 4y agoOverall I do agree with you, it does make reporting seem very “sponsored“ and disingenuous. However, an argument could me made that “We have the first look at the new technology. We’re obviously very limited at what we can legally say or show, but nevertheless here’s a very limited sneak peak” is still genuine journalism. They’ve reported as much as they could and did not hide obvious Intel participation, etc. The video was very underwhelming and cringey imho. But to informed audience it probably wasn’t misleading or false - that’s how I felt after watching it.
- jamesgeck0 4y agoLTT is generally pretty transparent about any restrictions companies want to put on previews/reviews. Intel’s conditions are spelled out multiple times in the video, and LTT aired a longer discussion with these folks on their podcast that contained a fair amount of Intel criticism. This is 100% Intel trying to set the correct level of expectations for what will be a extremely competitively priced GPU with major compatibility issues at launch.
- jeroenhd 4y agoThey're transparent enough to be trustworthy for reviews, but not they're not really transparent about the influence a company might have. They will do videos for a manufacturer reviewing a product with a given set of rules, but don't always disclose their rules. They argue that their viewers know that if "showcase" is in the title they're being paid for the product (though they often omit "showcase" from their clickbait titles before adding them back later) but their custom definitions for content types are hardly an industry standard, let alone well known to the viewers. They do disclose what companies send them what, at least. They're better than most YouTube reviews in that sense. Their current content is always entertainment first, sales second, reliable reviews third. They're a media company, it's the way they do business. I have no idea what they were trying to do in this video other than show off some cherry picked samples. I'd much rather have seen a quick table of stats next to the unscripted interview during their podcast to be honest, but that doesn't bring in any cash.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoLTT is trying to build a lab and grow - but to be honest, if I was a qualified engineer, why would I go to work at the LTT Lab? All I would get to do is review other products and then have my findings boiled down into 15-minute summaries where nuance isn’t a strength and you might get lucky and be on a clickbait video thumbnail. Boring compared to actually building products. If I’m an engineer from, say, Intel, I’m not moving from Oregon or Arizona to Vancouver for it.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoWell they don't need to hire thousands of such people, they need like a dozen. I'm certain they can find that many competent engineers in greater Vancouver, even if some of their peers have left to the US.
- kadoban 4y agoThe output of lab isn't going to be just videos, and they don't appear to be having any issues hiring.
- favorited 4y agoYou'd also be going from working with fellow engineers to working with influencers. Look at how often they do a "we lost our archived data" video – their whole schtick is making videos featuring how many hard drives Seagate sends them rather than how to make informed decisions.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> Look at how often they do a "we lost our archived data" video Twice in a decade? The first time they lost no data, the second time they lost a small amount because they weren't monitoring failed drives. Considering it's data they don't care about enough to back up, that doesn't seem so bad.
- sandworm101 4y agoUnless they break into the lucrative consulting/reverse-engineering game. Rather than videos, they might start writing reports paid for by actual manufacturers, reports that would influence realworld products
- arein3 4y ago
- jeroenhd 4y agoThis is a topic many youtubers discuss. The stupid thumbnail faces drive views and bring in sales. Everybody knows how dumb they are, but it works. Same with the clickbait titles: unless they're outright lies, they help immensely in getting a video recommended by the YouTube algorithm. There are a whole range of algorithm tricks that are necessary to build a business on YouTube. For example, the first 30 seconds or less are crucial to grab people's attention, so overloading them with entertainment or promises about what's coming is essential for maintaining viewership even if the quality of the video overal suffers. I haven't yet caught them doing the more egregious algorithm tuning (intentionally putting mistakes and spelling errors in graphs to drive comments, for example, or spamming polls to YouTube to get their engagement stats up). The YouTuber face is kind of a turn off, but when I watch a video I don't watch it for the thumbnail anyway.
- smcl 4y agoYeah the thumbnail gurning is silly, but by now it's a lost battle - they're an integral part of many popular channels. At least it can be a source of amusement, I frequently think of this tweet by Rob Whisman: https://twitter.com/robwhisman/status/735281634656669696 https://twitter.com/robwhisman/status/735281634656669696
- arein3 4y agoI don't watch videos from such guys. The over enthusiaatic reactions feel cringe and fake. The thumbnails are dumb at best. It's a person that is in this for money or has no self respect that would do such things, and I don't value their opinion. There is better content, it's not needed to put up with this disrespect for the viewer.
- silisili 4y agoBasically all tech reviewers, LTT included, are garbage because of this arrangement. To have a day one review, you have to get a prerelease device. To get said device, you have to stick to mfg talking points. It's an awful circle of scummy companies and scummy people. Really wish there was a reviewer who just buys shit with their own money AFTER release, and tells it like it is. Some may exist, but none of the household names have the integrity to do so.
- mkaic 4y agoYou're describing Gamer's Nexus pretty well I think -- easily the highest quality and most transparent/trustable PC hardware reporting I've personally come across. They frequently burn bridges with manufacturers because they refuse to stay quiet about major flaws in products.
- mardifoufs 4y agoI kind of disagree. I like the gamer nexus reviews, but the constant stream of perpetually angry/ranting videos also gets tiring at some point. Like yeah, controversies and angry call outs are fun but what's the point? I prefer the ltt approach here. They went pretty hard on Intel on their original Arc video a few weeks ago, but the fact that they are known for not burning bridges made it worthwhile for Intel to respond and showcase the improvements they have made since. As I said in another comment, they wouldn't have bothered if linus could've been just paid to update his review to make intel look better. But I also don't think Linus would have had that type of influence (enough for a corporation like Intel to engage with his complaints directly ) if he just kept burning bridges instead of keeping channels open. (Gamer nexus is far far from the worst in that regard, and they too had a visit from intel engineers. But I still think the LTT approach is just different, but I dont think that means they are just corporate shills.)
- Y-bar 4y ago> the constant stream of perpetually angry/ranting videos also gets tiring at some point Hear me out here. Maybe it is warranted and we ought, instead of directing the criticism towards the messenger or those who expose problems, direct this towards the manufacturers which produce subpar products?
- cptcobalt 4y agoStrong disagree. The videos Intel did with LTT and GamersNexus reveal inner workings of some of the GPU architecture. Certainly a marketing-focused presentation targeted at tech-savvy folks, but some of that narrative is required to really set the stage for a new entrant into the field, since there's no preexisting story, and existing mental models of Nvidia & AMD GPUs don't mesh so cleanly into the Intel GPUs. Knowledge will advance much faster with some marketing then with pure lab tests. And it's obvious LTT and GamersNexus plan to test these to the ends of the earth, like they do AMD & Nvidia cards.