6 ms·
I'm sorry, but I've been to the State Fair and comparing it as a Disney alternative is kind of a joke. State Fairs are glorified carnivals, and probably hire so
by dylan604 4y ago
I'm sorry, but I've been to the State Fair and comparing it as a Disney alternative is kind of a joke. State Fairs are glorified carnivals, and probably hire some actual carnys for the month they are open. To compare that to the rides at Disney is really a stretch. You could have at least suggested Six Flags like amusement park instead.
Your other points I'll agree with. State Fairs->Disney was just too much of a stretch for me to accept.
- raverbashing 4y agoHah yeah I agree State Fairs can be "fun" (for some definition) but it's very different from Disney
- alex_sf 4y ago> And people expect more exciting and high quality things now, because they have seen a lot (comparably).
- aaronax 4y agoObviously it is not as good. Disney is literally the best, in the wealthiest nation in the entire world. But a state park will still entertain a family for a day or two, which may or may not be the true goal. Maybe you feel it is necessary to show your children the absolute best entertainment...pay up. (I never went to Disney until I was 25, when I visited for free for 1/2 day thanks to a friend who was working there seasonally.)
- daveslash 4y agoYour "State Fair vs Disney" really struck a nerve with some people! But I agree with your point. I took your comment to generally mean: Things like Baseball games and Disney used to be economical and within reach to the common-everyday family with a tight budget, whereas now they're out of reach for many people. Part of that is because the attractions themselves are on an elevated level compared to days of yore. These same attractions used to be shittier than they are today! Shittier made them cheaper, and more accessible to the masses. If the common-everyday family on a tight budget is willing to settle for a little less-than-the-best experience, there are still plenty of options available in the form of State Fairs, State Parks, etc... Edit: Spelling.
- kjgddhnbc 4y agoLol Disney is a cult! If you say anything bad about it people come out of the woodwork to defend the mouse. I was raised outside of the cult but I have dear friends that are a part of it. Totally rational people until you level any criticism towards Disney, which is especially crazy because most of these folks are normally anti corporate types, but Disney gets a pass for some reason. Now, I don't enjoy amusement parks and never did, and don't feel strongly about Disney media, so it's just amusing to me, especially seeing it play out on HN I'd rather go to a state park than Disney lmao
- b112 4y agoEvery time I went to Disney in Florida, loads of rides were 30+ minutes, sometimes 1 1/2 hours. My single thought was "?!", followed by wanting to leave.
- unbalancedevh 4y agoOne of the points in the article was that there are a lot more rides at Disney now. But my thought was, "yeah, but you can still only ride 5 of them in a day!"
- dylan604 4y agoWhich theme park have you been to that has not had long lines to the rides?
- neutronicus 4y agoIt's been a hot minute (like 20 years), but the Maryland Six Flags used to stay open until 8 or 9 PM in the summer and I could ride the coasters with basically no wait (waterpark was closed, though).
- Retric 4y agoI remember doing multiple rides on the same roller coaster without giving up my seat as a teen at Busch Gardens in Williamsburg. At peak times they had 20+ minute lines, but I never considered that as worthwhile. Disney lines are horrific by comparison. It’s nice they add some theming while you wait, but you will have a far better time just skipping the rides unless you want to run to something at park open or schedule your day around fast pass.
- vel0city 4y agoTo me it really depends on your metrics to determine which is "best". If you're really into Disney stories and the Disney experience then of course there is no substitute. However, I find I get a good bit more enjoyment from other parks which focus more on the rides themselves instead of the stories, so parks like Kings Island, Cedar Point, Six Flags, etc. are far more enjoyable. They're also usually a lot cheaper and you can end up riding more rides.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoGet off my porch. Man let people have fun. I've been to Disney World a couple of times. It's not that fun with all the crowds and lines and such. We all have our own idea of fun. Mine is with friends and families having a low stress day at a water park, nature hike, minor league sports event and not worrying about bragging rights after the "adventure".
- jimbob45 4y agoThere's a rabbit hole to go down here but the short of it is that Disney's willingness to sell out in recent years have allowed other parks to steal its claim as the best park in the world, particularly German parks. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZL_ZVJMF2rA&t=795s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZL_ZVJMF2rA&t=795s
- themodelplumber 4y agoI've noticed that my friends who like Disneyland are "accept no substitute" types. They will even talk down Legoland. So I wonder if it's even meaningful to them to talk about alternatives at all. Many of them are mainly visiting that one special place for sure every year, so it's not too terrible to save the money either.
- brewdad 4y agoIt's these types that the park caters to and a significant part of why Disney can charge so much more than a "comparable" theme park. Personally, I've done the theme park thing as a kid and later with my kid and have no interest in going to one ever again. My county fair is this weekend. It's free and less than 2 miles from my home. I doubt I'll attend this year but do go about every other year. That's plenty of that atmosphere for me. Now get off my lawn.
- bobthepanda 4y agoI will say that because they are permanent as opposed to occasional, theme parks have more selection in terms of rides like roller coasters or any sort of water rides. And there is a whole world of difference in affordability and hecticness between Disney and something local like Hersheypark.
- hardtke 4y agoMy family is going to Dollywood this summer during a visit to Tennessee. A one day ticket is $84, but a 3 day ticket is only $114. So, yes, Disneyland is "accept no substitutes" pricing. I would argue that Disneyland should be even more expensive. As Yogi Berra once said (paraphrasing) "Nobody goes there anymore, it's too crowded." People that simultaneously complain about Disneylands price and the crowds are delusional.
- dylan604 4y agoI went to Dollywood as a kid. One of the "attractions" was fishing out of a literall barrel for perch IIRC. that's the memory that stuck with me. not the singing and the dancing and other things. fish in a barrel. can't make that up
- scifibestfi 4y agoBut in the spirit of what the OP is saying, most people have never been to something like the State Fair, let alone Disney. Disney is for the rich. The State Fair is amazing from the perspective of those who have been to neither.
- oceanplexian 4y agoDisney was a thing that my pretty average middle-class immigrant family was able to do. We would drive down from Northern California, stay at a cheap motel, and then go buy a general admission ticket. It was never a “for the rich” vacation. In the last 10 years, Disneyland has become an activity for wealthy childless millennials, which is almost certainly driving up the costs and turning Disney from a middle class activity into a wealthy one. Disney, just like any other corporation is gladly taking their money.
- alistairSH 4y agoI think that's mostly true. A middle-class family can still afford Disney, it just becomes a once-in-a-childhood thing instead of an every-year thing. Every year trips have become something for the wealthy. Pretty similar for pro sports. Lots of my friends take their kids to minor league baseball - for the kid, it can be better, as they often have specific kid activities. I've always been shocked at the price for Redskins tickets/parking/etc. Nationals is a bit less expensive, but still not cheap.
- neutronicus 4y agoOrioles are dirt cheap if you want to take the MARC up for some baseball, though. And the MARC itself is 7 bucks
- alistairSH 4y agoNats tickets aren't bad, it's parking/transit and then food/drink that are the killers. I guess you can skip the concessions, but that's part of the fun, IMO.
- nostrademons 4y agoNote that there's quality creep in any established institution. Disneyland's attractions on opening day weren't all that different from a local carnival: https://touringplans.com/disneyland/attractions/opening-dates https://touringplans.com/disneyland/attractions/opening-date... Favorites like Pirates of the Caribbean and the Haunted Mansion didn't open until the late 1960s, a decade after the park did, and Space Mountain & Thunder Mountain didn't open until the late 1970s.
- kevinventullo 4y agoYeah I agree. I’m not sure it even makes sense to compare state fairs and especially county fairs to theme parks; they’re aiming at a different experience altogether. They have more kitsch like fried butter and tractor pulls, the ground tends to be just dirt or whatever pavement was already there, and it’s all temporary so they feel more like a community event. In contrast there are plenty of regional parks even lesser known than Six Flags like Adventureland, Kings Island, Dorney Park. These are much more similar to Disneyland (albeit scaled down) than they are to a state fair.
- tomc1985 4y agoAh yes, corporate-sponsored, mandated happiness with childrens characters smoothed over for maximum appeal/profit. The perfect salve for these troubled times Give me the carnies any day of the week!
- woodruffw 4y agoI agree that it's an apples-to-oranges comparison, but maybe not in a way that casts Disney World in a positive light: it seems like the primary experience of Disney World is queueing for hours on rides that are references to things you already know, and paying a general "Disney tax" for being surrounded by familiar intellectual property. That's some people's thing, but it's not mine. State and Country Fairs, on the other hand, are relatively diverse in their attractions: you can do the carnival stuff if you'd like, or you can: * Peruse your state's agricultural and crafts competitions * Go to the livestock auctions * See live music by local artists * Go the the trade halls and look at/purchase goods by local businesspeople * Attend the live performances and competitions (my favorite county fair[1] has tractor pulls and pig races) [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutchess_County_Fair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutchess_County_Fair
- gsk22 4y agoThat's fine for you, the adult, but the kids are gonna wanna go to Disney. I remember going to the state fair growing up, and it was excruciatingly boring waiting for the adults to finish looking at cows and trinkets. Whereas our family's trip to Disney was tailor-made for kids from start to finish, and honestly features pretty prominently among my favorite all-time memories.
- scelerat 4y agosheet, I remember being eight, and a tractor pull would have been just about the best thing ever. And I grew up twenty minutes from Disneyland. Loved it as a kid, but also loved the Pomona Fairgrounds -- LA County Fair -- and the drag strip
- neutronicus 4y agoYeah, IDK what County/State Fairs people here are talking about. I often went to the Boulder County Fair in grad school and that had a Demolition Derby, which my kid would love.
- woodruffw 4y ago
- 9TRHEsEdDwZAySX 4y ago
- chazzyluc 4y agoSure, if I define Mickey as entertainment, the Yankees as baseball and the Grand Canyon as nature than anything else will be a pale knock-off. I have great memories of doing all that stuff too but I also remember standing in line in 90 degree heat for over an hour, seeing grown men getting into fist fights over a game and the majority of nature on display being forests of selfie sticks. Point is that you can do that stuff once in a while and then step back, figure out what you like and don't like about the experiences and then find cheaper local alternatives that are pretty amazing too. If your goal is to spend a nice summer night walking around with the family, seeing interesting stuff while eating churros and taking the occasional tea cup ride then you don't exclusively have to pay Disney $1,000+ to do it.
- lazerpants 4y agoTo be fair, I went to a Yankees game for $30 last week and had okay seats. Food and drinks are expensive Yankee Stadium, but you can bring snacks in, so it's actually pretty affordable as an occasional activity for a family.
- dylan604 4y ago>Grand Canyon as nature than anything else will be a pale knock-off. I've been to the Grand Canyon as well as other canyons like Palo Duro and similar. However, they all do pale in comparison as a cheap knock-off and none are as grand as The Grand Canyon. If you're into outdoorsy type things, you cannot not be moved by it. It is one thing that is very much appropriately named. This is not to say that any of the other parks are not worth going, state or federal, but if you're a canyon and The Grand Canyon exists, just know you will only ever at best be second chair.
- selimthegrim 4y agoEven Copper Canyon in Mexico?
- dylan604 4y agoIs it copper colored or have copper in it? If not, then it's not named as well ;P But no, I have not been to that canyon.
- JohnBooty 4y agoI mean, they're vastly different but I'd much rather go to a state fair or state park. Disney is not objectively better.
- ROTMetro 4y agoI disagree. Disney are EXPERTS on making magic happen. I fought vacationing at Disney tooth and nail, it was so expensive. It was one of those life long memory vacations that will sustain you when the kids are gone. My fair memories are far less intense years later.
- JohnBooty 4y agoOkay. I mean, that's something you like better. That does not mean it's objectively better.
- ecshafer 4y agoEh I would rather go to a state fair than Disney. Its less commercial and more down to earth. I went to Disney, and I don't really get it. There's cartoon characters and some rides with huge lines that are maybe better than the local amusement park.If Disney tickets were maybe $30 and there was 1/5 the number of people. But its just a tourist trap.