5 ms·
> those systems are not a path to AGI If that's the actual meat of your claim, it's weird to just put it unsupported at the end. If you think it's an aside you
by tialaramex 4y ago
> those systems are not a path to AGI
If that's the actual meat of your claim, it's weird to just put it unsupported at the end. If you think it's an aside you've got a big problem, because without it the rest is pretty weak.
We saw this with chess. Anybody who was clinging on to the idea that well, the machines can't really play chess, because technically there do seem to be a few humans who are better, was screwed the moment the machines begin routinely beating grand masters. Either this categorically isn't something that the machines can do, or, it is and so it's important that they can do it at all. We shouldn't expect any half measures on this.
Do you consider Rob Liefeld an artist? What do you reckon the chances are that the machine can get human anatomy right more often than Rob Liefeld? Rob is a human, so it seems like that should give him an advantage. However unlike Rob DALL-E has learned by seeing lots of existing pictures of humans that they don't look the way Rob draws them...
- ajafari1 4y agoRight on. When do you expect a productized AI that can replace your average skilled programmer?
- ben_w 4y agoI'm not sure what average looks like. Possibly last August? Possibly some time around 2035? It'll be a moving target though, as anyone worse than the AI isn't likely to stay in the role for long.
- carapace 4y agoHere's me almost exactly six years ago, predicting "most coding and design tasks will be automated within three to five years." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11718300 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11718300 If we count GitHub Copilot as the tip of the spear then I was too optimistic. > GitHub Copilot ... was first announced by GitHub on 29 June 2021 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GitHub_Copilot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GitHub_Copilot
- ajafari1 4y agoNice! You were very close. With any exponential curve, it takes forever to get to point A, but once there, it's an immediate job to point Z.
- carapace 4y agoCheers! I'm going to try to work up a decent reply to your article, but it might take me a day or two. Have you read Wendell Berry's "What are People For?" (that essay not the whole eponymous book)? - - - - The (open) secret at the heart of AI is that no AI can answer: "What is good?" ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31720621 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31720621 ) AKA "Lucky for whom?" Teela Brown, fictional character in Larry Niven novels Spoiler alert! This link gives details of the character that are spoilers: https://larryniven.fandom.com/wiki/Teela_Brown https://larryniven.fandom.com/wiki/Teela_Brown Unfortunately those details are the point I'm trying to make, and I'm a huge Niven fan so I'm not going to spoil Ringworld, but it ties in with the (ultimately metaphysical) question, "What is good?"
- YeGoblynQueenne 4y agoYou were too pessimistic! Automatic programming, a.k.a. program synthesis, has been a thing since the early days of AI and computer science, for example the idea of deductive program synthesis, where a program is generated wholesale from a complete specification in a formal language that is not a computer language goes at least as back as Alonzo Church himself, in 1957: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Program_synthesis#Origin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Program_synthesis#Origin Much work has been done since then and inductive program synthesis from incomplete specifications consisting of input/output examples (a form of machine learning) has been possible for quite some time. This is the second time this week I point to the report by Gulwani et al for a modern overview (of both kinds): Program Synthesis https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Program-Synthesis-Gulwani-Polozov/f0a79cb16c3e53e9c536b65ec7b2157db1d352f1 https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Program-Synthesis-Gulw... Rather than Copilot being the "tip of the spear", it is really a step back, a system that can only generate code but not check its correctness, unlike pretty much every program synthesis system since forever. Although this may actually be an advantage for its commercial application (since it makes it easier to match expectations of the system's performance) it is not really any indication of progress, in any way, shape or form. In truth, Copilot is famous today because it is supported by a large company like Microsoft and because earlier work is not well-known by most people who get their AI knews from blogs and podcasts, who are also not very well aware of the history of the field. But, "tip of the spear"? Oh, no. Unless it's a very blunt, toy spear, more like a tech demo of a spear. And this is by no means restricted to program synthesis, and Copilot. For example, the first self-driving car to drive on a stretch of real road, with real traffic, without human intervention, was Ernst Dickmann's 1995 robot car: https://people.idsia.ch/~juergen/robotcars.html https://people.idsia.ch/~juergen/robotcars.html Again: 1995. And yet, fully autonomous self-driving cars are still not here. The revolution hasn't happened and progress has only crawled marginally forward.
- mr_toad 4y agoAI vs average programmer, maybe 10 years. Commercially viable AI vs skilled engineers, that’s going to take longer. I wouldn’t be surprised if we could replace the average BA with an AI right now.
- krageon 4y agoThe average is so bad it barely even has to produce code that works, so that's not really a bar I'm interested in seeing cleared.
- YeGoblynQueenne 4y ago>> Anybody who was clinging on to the idea that well, the machines can't really play chess, because technically there do seem to be a few humans who are better, was screwed the moment the machines begin routinely beating grand masters. Who was "clinging on to the idea that well, the machines can't really play chess" and when was that?
- janalsncm 4y agoMade an account so I could mention David Levy’s infamous bet: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Levy_(chess_player)#Computer_chess_bet https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Levy_(chess_player)#Co... That’s the way it is with AI: first people say X is impossible for computers, then they say X is hard, then they say X doesn’t work for certain edge cases, then they say we’ve known all along that computers could do X.
- YeGoblynQueenne 4y agoWhy "infamous"? In any case, Levy did win his bet when there had been no computer chess engine that could beat him in ten years after betting against McCarthy and Michie [1]. Despite that he acknowledge that chess engines had improved further than he had thought: >> Levy wrote, "I had proved that my 1968 assessment had been correct, but on the other hand my opponent in this match was very, very much stronger than I had thought possible when I started the bet."[37] He observed that, "Now nothing would surprise me (very much)."[38] (Edit: the quote is from your WP link.) So that at least really does not match the pattern you mention. Levy's evaluation of chess engines was pretty much in the water, all the way up to Kasparov's loss to Deep Blue. As far as I can tell he never said anything like "the machines can't really play chess" as the OP suggested. He just made a prediction about how much they could advance in ten years. And he was right. I would therefore like more justification for your assertion that "that's the way it is in AI". I would also like a clarification: who are the "people" who say all those things? How representative are they of experts and researchers? Who makes all those naive predictions about the impossibility of AI that are later proven wrong? For the time being, it seems that naive predictions can be traced more directly to luminaries of the field, like Alan Turing or Marvin Minsky [2], who predict that AI is "just around the corner", rather than skeptics and naysayers who say it wont' happen, as is usually suggested. And then of course, there's Rodney Brooks' dated predictions, so far standing the test of time (although that's a short time!) [3]. _______________ [1] Totally coincidentally, Donald Michie was my thesis advisor's thesis advisor, so I'm, like, his academic grandchild. [2] See: https://web.eecs.umich.edu/~kuipers/opinions/AI-progress.html https://web.eecs.umich.edu/~kuipers/opinions/AI-progress.htm... "In 1958, Herbert Simon and Allen Newell wrote, “within ten years a digital computer will be the world’s chess champion”; note that this is 10 years before Levy and McCarthy's bet. [3] https://rodneybrooks.com/predictions-scorecard-2022-january-01/ https://rodneybrooks.com/predictions-scorecard-2022-january-...
- slowmovintarget 4y agoOn "not the path to AGI": Gary Marcus on the Mindscape podcast is worth a listen. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANRnuT9nLEE&list=PLrxfgDEc2NxY_fRExpDXr87tzRbPCaA5x&index=23 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANRnuT9nLEE&list=PLrxfgDEc2N... Transcript: https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2022/02/14/184-gary-marcus-on-artificial-intelligence-and-common-sense/ https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2022/02/14/184-... "...And then there’s natural language understanding and reasoning, and I would say we have not really made progress at all. GPT-3, which we may wanna talk about, gives the illusion of having natural language of understanding, but I don’t really think that it does. And we are nowhere near, for example, an all-purpose general assistant. ..."
- lostmsu 4y ago> I don’t really think that it does Either the quote is poorly chosen or reading this article is not worth the time.
- slowmovintarget 4y agoThat's a false dichotomy. Select the name Gary Marcus, right-click, and search (on my browser it defaults to Duck Duck Go, but that returns the right result). The Mindscape Podcast is hosted by Sean Carroll. You have a very sharp quantum physicist interviewing an expert in the field of AI research. The podcast is worth the time, and the quote is representative of an expert's take on the matter. He elaborates, but I don't need to write an essay just to argue on the internet.
- krageon 4y agoThis argumentation is based on the "feeling" that something doesn't understand things the way they do and that this is sufficient to say that it is inferior. It's a very old argument against AGI, and it's as boring as it ever was: It relies on human exceptionalism and on the concept of the soul (i.e. something humans have and other things can never have, which cannot be quantified or understood). It is compelling only to those who are religious or who still hold religious tendencies.
- challenger-derp 4y ago