10 ms·
I stopped cosmonauts from carrying guns (2014)
- hourago 4y ago> In my publicity campaign, I suggested the presence of the gun, especially in light of recent space team psychological problems, might be an invitation to a future disaster. The problem with guns is that they are designed for one clear purpose, someone that gets into some mental problem may see one and get ideas.
- efitz 4y agoIf an astronaut develops a mental health problem in space, what’s going to stop them from opening the hatch or probably a thousand other things that would result in the deaths of everyone aboard? Guns are just a distraction in this case, or more precisely, removal of guns from this situation doesn’t seem to meaningfully reduce risk. That said, I have no idea why astronauts need guns; they’re unlikely to encounter hostile humans or animals and shooting isn’t a practical hobby in space. Maybe in case they land in a bad neighborhood or wilderness? In that case, why not just store the guns on the outside of the landing module, making the guns difficult (and obvious) to access while in space.
- grogenaut 4y agoHave guns been tested for those temperature swings, or the primers and other explosive components? Do they off gas in zero atmosphere?
- thatguy0900 4y agoYou could always store the ammo separately
- jmillikin 4y ago> That said, I have no idea why astronauts need guns; they’re > unlikely to encounter hostile humans or animals The fine article, and Wikipedia's page on the same firearm[0], describe it as intended for wilderness survival in the event the crew capsule had to land in the Soviet tundra. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TP-82_Cosmonaut_survival_pistol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TP-82_Cosmonaut_survival_pisto...
- almog 4y ago>probably a thousand other things that would result in the deaths of everyone aboard? Guns are just a distraction in this case, or more precisely, removal of guns from this situation doesn’t seem to meaningfully reduce risk I imagine that many of these things would involve either: 1. More steps/time to execute than pulling the trigger on a gun, thus leave more time for the rest of the crew to react. 2. Or require more planning than pulling the trigger on a gun and thus more chance to rethink one's plan + a chance to recover from that mental health problem as well as higher chance that the rest of the crew will be able to assess the mental health problem and treat it. At either case, I don't see how _having access_ to a device that can functions as a death switch would not be considered at least a meaningful risk to the space vessel or its crew.
- LanceH 4y agoStarting a fire would be easy, not obvious and devastating. It wouldn't be difficult to have the gun be completely unavailable until landing.
- almog 4y ago> Starting a fire would be easy, not obvious and devastating. I'm not sure how starting a fire would be non-obvious but, in general, fire prevention, detection and suppression a risk that space crews are well trained to deal with, regardless of sabotage. > It wouldn't be difficult to have the gun be completely unavailable until landing. Agree, but: 1. That is not the case that's described here. 2. My argument was to counter the claim that having access to a gun onboard a spaceship does not significantly increase the overall risk to crew members.
- hourago 4y agoYou are trying to be reasonable and informed taking with the pro-gun crowd, you deserved to be upvoted.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoActually, they're attempting to force an agenda into a reasonable conversation about a reasonable case of gun use. But at least, unlike you, they're not being a complete jerk and adding nothing.
- jaywalk 4y agoWhile I'm sure there are plenty of ways a determined astronaut could wreak havoc on the ISS, opening the hatch isn't one of them. Much like on an airplane, the pressure differential makes it impossible to open when the inside is pressurized and the outside is not.
- stevenjgarner 4y agoDo we know for sure there are no weapons on the ISS?
- efitz 4y agoUh, on an airplane, you absolutely CAN open the door at altitude because the pressure inside is greater than outside. I think you’re thinking of submarines, where the higher pressure outside holds the hatches shut.
- sundowners 4y agoThat's why Submarine hatches are conical and open out, and airplane hatches open in. The pressure differential keeps them closed. Yes, the plane door eventually pivots out of the hole and hands on the outside but it first had to move inside the cabin a little bit
- marssaxman 4y ago> Maybe in case they land in a bad neighborhood or wilderness? Exactly this, and this is why it was a Soviet/Russian practice - their spacecraft make ground landings, instead of splashing down at sea. In fact, when the Voskhod 2 navigation system failed, it landed in a wilderness area so remote the men on board had to spend two nights in the snow before rescue. One of these cosmonauts was Alexei Leonov, who went on to a leadership position in the cosmonaut program: the survival gun was his initiative.
- maest 4y ago> If an astronaut develops a mental health problem in space, what’s going to stop them from opening the hatch or probably a thousand other things that would result in the deaths of everyone aboard? Guns are just a distraction in this case, or more precisely, removal of guns from this situation doesn’t seem to meaningfully reduce risk And yet, in countries with higher levels of gun ownership, lethal assault occurrences are higher.
- hourago 4y agoYes. Guns increase the amount of killings. Too have a gun in a controlled place like a space station was craziness and a catastrophe waiting to happen. I understand that some people like guns, but their lack of acceptance of the consequences is childish. I guess that so many shootings were kids die have created a cognitive dissonance on many gun owners. They want to see guns as "only for good" meanwhile kids die.
- wrp 4y ago>...in light of recent space team psychological problems... I saw this reasoning and thought, "OK, what about the survival knife, or potentially lethal pieces of rope, or in fact any small pointy thing like a screwdriver?" Also consider that they are in a fragile environment where a deranged individual could do considerable damage with just bare hands.
- amelius 4y agoA gun might be useful on a space walk when you lose grip and are about to fly off into empty space. Just shoot in the opposite direction of where you want to go :) Perhaps a nice plot device for Gravity II ...
- lumost 4y agoFunnily enough orbital mechanics don’t work that way. To accelerate towards an object ahead of you in your orbital plane you need to lose velocity, drop into a slightly lower orbit, then gain velocity to slow down and intercept. Velocity is tightly coupled to altitude when orbiting.
- amelius 4y agoIs that relevant at relative speeds of say 1 m/s and distances of a few tens of meters?
- namibj 4y agoNo, only when you get close to being on the other side of the planet by the time you reach the other spacecraft. Or take even longer, of course.
- NobodyNada 4y agoNo. Thrusting the "intuitive" way will indeed bring you closer to your target in the short term. Over time (specifically, enough time to be an appreciable fraction of the orbital period) the difference in speed will cause you to drift into a higher or lower orbit, but at low speeds and low distances this effect is tiny, and you can easily compensate for it by thrusting radially. See this Space.SE post: https://space.stackexchange.com/q/44622 https://space.stackexchange.com/q/44622 Or just play KSP :)
- lumost 4y agoThis effect is pretty pronounced in KSP at distances of a hundred meters or more. Trying to dock the intuitive way is pretty much impossible.
- foobarian 4y agoThat seems like an awful lot of dead weight to bring on a launch.
- causi 4y agoConsidering he's claiming credit for getting guns out of space, I'm disappointed but not surprised he failed to mention that the gun was required to fend off bears after the Voskhod 2 mission. So thus far the gun's record is +2 human lives.
- hristov 4y agoYeah. It should be noted that in places where Soyuz capsules have historically landed there is a real danger of man eating bears and/or wolves. That is what the gun is for.
- WillAdams 4y agoYep: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/bears-eat-wealthy-couple-and-pilot-after-helicopter-crash-in-wilderness/ar-AAZJDWR https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/bears-eat-wealthy-coupl...
- amelius 4y agoFrom Wikipedia: > Leonov and Belyayev could have likely been recovered by a helicopter with the use of a rope and ladder or rescue basket but Soviet Leader Leonid Brezhnev strictly prohibited cosmonauts to be rescued with those methods.[why?] This resulted in Leonov and Belyayev spending a total of 3 days, two nights, in the forest before finally being recovered So, yeah, but this paints a different picture. Perhaps dropping a gun from the helicopter would have sufficed too.
- sudosysgen 4y agoLikely isn't good enough. What if the helicopter wasn't there fast enough? What if they weren't immediately found? It's a pretty big place. You want to stack your chances as much as possible.
- amelius 4y agoNote: GP originally mentioned specifically the Voskhod 2 mission. And I should have added a link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voskhod_2#Crew_recovery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voskhod_2#Crew_recovery
- midislack 4y agoI’m pretty sure cosmonauts still carry guns.
- kidme5 4y agoWeapons in Space are inevitable with Space Force. Even Elon Musk is involved: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink#Military_satellites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink#Military_satellites
- MrZongle2 4y agoGo read up on the Almaz. The Soviets mounted a 23mm cannon on one of their early stations. Long before the Space Force.
- al2o3cr 4y agoMoon's haunted.
- maest 4y agoParent's referencing this meme: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/moons-haunted https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/moons-haunted
- dionian 4y agoThere is a word for an irrational fear of this particular type of tool: hoplophobia
- BaculumMeumEst 4y agoPer wikipedia: "It was intended as a survival aid to be used after landings and before recovery in the Siberian wilderness." Why is banning them worth celebrating?
- a4a4a4a4 4y ago
- maest 4y agoNobody is claiming they were banned because guns are absolutely, intrinsically bad. It's just that the safety tradeoff didn't seem good enough. From TFA: "Of course, plans were to use it only in special circumstances on return to Earth. But in space, on occasion, well-laid plans have a way of turning out very differently. In my publicity campaign, I suggested the presence of the gun, especially in light of recent space team psychological problems, might be an invitation to a future disaster. Fiendishly, I proposed that to guarantee the gun only be usable in an off-course landing (its official purpose), it be stashed in compartment accessible only from outside the Soyuz, after landing. There never was any response to my helpful suggestions."
- a4a4a4a4 4y ago> Nobody is claiming they were banned because guns are absolutely, intrinsically bad. It's just that the safety tradeoff didn't seem good enough. I was making a (what I thought was) very thinly-veiled commentary on the current political discourse regarding guns in the media. > I suggested the presence of the gun, especially in light of recent space team psychological problems, might be an invitation to a future disaster. And this is just poor reasoning and political grandstanding from the author. The author wants to feel like he accomplished something really meaningful, and is patting himself on the back for it. These people can be trusted to travel to space and depend on each other for survival out there, but the presence of a very scary gun is the breaking point of where they can't be trusted anymore? At some point, you either trust someone or you don't. If I couldn't trust a colleague with a gun, there's no way I would be traveling to space with them, because either way my life would be in their hands. Edit: from another comment, https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/bears-eat-wealthy-couple-and-pilot-after-helicopter-crash-in-wilderness/ar-AAZJDWR https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/bears-eat-wealthy-coupl...
- jrochkind1 4y agoI am nostalgic for days when resisting militarization of space seemed possible, before the "US Space Force".
- MrZongle2 4y agoGo read up on the Soviet Almaz station from the 1970s, and reconcile that with the Space Force from the 2020s.
- Someone 4y agoFor the curious: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almaz#Defense_measures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almaz#Defense_measures
- blamazon 4y agoAh, you mean those halcyon days when China blew up a satellite in 2007 to demonstrate its anti-satellite military capabilities and caused a huge debris field? https://swfound.org/media/9550/chinese_asat_fact_sheet_updated_2012.pdf https://swfound.org/media/9550/chinese_asat_fact_sheet_updat...
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoSpace Force is just an org chart change. There is nothing new that wasn't already being done before.
- BitwiseFool 4y agoThere was never a point in time where spaceflight wasn't militarized to some degree. Even France has a space force. The US Space Force isn't some lurch towards militarism, it's a glorified bureaucratic reshuffling of what the DoD was already doing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_space_forces,_units,_and_formations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_space_forces,_units,_a...
- jrochkind1 4y agoThey used to have at least pretend they weren't doing it, because there was popular demand to avoid it. I miss those days. When we believed this was possible, and there was demand for it, hope for it, and it was a real topic for international treaties, and governments had to figure out how to do it anyway. I'm not talking about 2007, but earlier. The evidence of that period is in the OP, that's the era he's talking about. Now nobody hopes for anything but forever war everywhere.
- dsmmcken 4y agoA bit of a spoiler -- this is also a plot point in Astronaut Chris Hadfield's novel "The Apollo Murders".