7 ms·
The experiment is over. It failed. Social media didn't bring us what we hoped it would bring us, and its cons outweigh its pros. Perhaps we should organize a n
by amelius 4y ago
The experiment is over. It failed. Social media didn't bring us what we hoped it would bring us, and its cons outweigh its pros.
Perhaps we should organize a national poll against social media. It is time we admit that the Amish were right to a certain extent, and if it helps: believing that technology only brings value is in itself much like a religion.
- vocram 4y ago> We We who? Most of the people enjoy them and spend on them a large part of their time. They don’t want to give up.
- digitalengineer 4y agoWe once said the same thing about smoking…
- mensetmanusman 4y agoPeople will make choices you disagree with…
- hackerlight 4y agoAll well and good until they ask for my money to treat their self-caused metabolic syndrome and lung cancer, or when their self-induced depression causes them to vote for a populist authoritarian that takes my rights away. People's self-destructive personal choices ultimately impacts on others.
- bumby 4y agoAnd still say the same about junk food…
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAlcohol/sugar/Sat fats/sitting/using fossil fuels/plastics/etc
- closedloop129 4y agoLike the Romans ignored the early steam engines? Have you seen the social network behind the css gear submission [1]? >nobody has gotten it quite right yet >we think existing platforms have some good ideas, but no one’s managed to create one without profound flaws. we’re borrowing liberally from other sites, but we want to build cohost into something that works well and serves its users rather than just another clone. There is a huge probability that we haven't figured it out yet. Instead of quitting, we should double down and try new things. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32123804 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32123804
- amelius 4y ago> Instead of quitting, we should double down and try new things. If you can find a way to effectively fight fake news, then there is something to be said for it. Otherwise, sorry, but we've seen enough already.
- mawise 4y agoI hadn't heard of cohost, but there's something to be said about curation--which seems to be their proposed approach to discovery. This is a big part of the service newspapers and libraries (used to?) provide. There's an argument to be made that curation equates to censorship, but I think it's wrong. Anyone can write anything on the internet, but that doesn't come with the right to have your message amplified just because it pisses off a lot of people.
- closedloop129 4y agoIt may be naive but I think all you need are accounts linked to human identities and a central repository of facts and sources. When something is reported, OP can check his facts and alter his content or insist on his view. The reporter then can double down and a moderator looks at it. Request a down payment for both content and reports, and moderation pays for itself when the losing party has to pay the process. Don't allow people to post new content as long as a report is open. The expensive part is the repository of facts. That has to be maintained with membership fees of the social network.
- mrweasel 4y agoI don’t know what we had hoped to get from social media, but for a brief period of time, 15 years ago, it was fun. The stopped when ads once again was called upon to save a business that failed to make a sales pitch directly to its end-users. It not the fault of the ads as such. It is a reasonable solution, if you can accept that it will never make you insanely wealthy. Sadly that not what happens. Companies keep pushing and pushing to make as much money as possible, forcing their platforms into attention hoarding machines. Platforms, such as Facebook, Instagram or TikTok, no longer serve any purpose other than sell attention and killing other platforms that would stand in the way of them making a few extra dollars. For a brief time in history social media provide us with a bit more fun. It allowed us to be a bit more social. Then corporate greed took it away, almost as fast.
- neilalexander 4y agoI'm not really convinced that _anyone_ ever really had an up-front vision for what social media could bring to the table, either good or bad. To me, it always seemed more like a solution in search of a problem, which in turn just ended up creating more problems.
- mrweasel 4y agoTake Facebook, for a brief few years it did bring your closer to old friends and family, if you let it. In the quest for profit, that feature seemed to be the first to die off. Maybe it wasn't a vision, but it could have been.
- slfnflctd 4y agoIt's pretty simple to me. It started out as a way to remove the barrier to creating a personal website. Why would someone want a personal website? So you don't have to explain everything about yourself to every new person you meet. They can see what your interests are, what kind of ideas or projects you promote, and learn more about your quirks. This helps filter out those who would clash with you, as well as giving potential friends or colleagues a much smoother on-ramp to future interactions. That was in the MySpace days. At some point, Facebook took over because it was a more standardized interface with more bells & whistles, and eliminated the issue of really ugly page designs made by amateurs with auto-playing audio of music you might hate. For a little while, FB was a superior product. Then, they started messing with The Feed so it was more likely to do things that benefited the company. There was some uproar, but it was ignored and those voices turned out to be an inconsequential minority. Other platforms followed suit. This was the turning point which soured the whole experiment. I still think it can be quite useful when you're hyper-focused on using it to enhance offline interactions and/or certain collaborative efforts. But if you're just idly bouncing around, The Feed will hijack your brain and start pushing you toward things the company thinks will make it more money. The problem is that social media became an end unto itself, rather than a tool to facilitate other things. Apparently there were hundreds of millions of people with a bunch of idle time who didn't want to do anything challenging with that time other than occasionally be enticed to spend money in an attempt to make themselves feel better about their lives. Their eyeballs were ripe for the harvest. And now we have to reckon with all the unforseen ways this has changed our culture, including the whole 'influencer' plague. It takes a lot of discipline to avoid the siren's call of FOMO, and most people are not sufficiently equipped to do it. It's inextricably intertwined with our failures to adequately address the mental health needs of the wider population as well. All those of us who are better off can do is lead by example.
- myspy 4y agoSocial media as it is done by Facebook is the major problem. We need no algorithmic timelines, no manipulation what can be seen by a company. Just what you follow is a scrollable timeline. Group features that cannot be moderated need to be banned. Forums were good because the mods kept it together. Same goes for commentaries to posts.
- hackerlight 4y agoNot just Facebook, all of the big platforms. Twitter and Reddit also stoke division, outrage, echo chambers for profit. Example of bad faith from Twitter: allowing users to disable replies in order to prevent harassment by mobs, but still sneakily allowing mobs to use quote tweets to dunk. It's transparent. They just want to appear to be addressing the problem (maybe to placate a small contingent of outspoken employees by greenwashing) without actually addressing it. Another example of bad faith: resorting to content moderation because the real fix (altering dynamics) will cost them engagement. What's needed is regulation. I don't think the US will be able to do it, both because of ideology and political dysfunction, it'll have to be the EU.
- myspy 4y agoI agree, good post.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoYeah for me this timeline stuff totally killed Facebook for me. It's so horrible now. They should have made it possible to keep the old feed.
- Joeri 4y agoThose features are all but inevitable to an ad-funded social media platform. If you want to increase ad revenue you need people to spend more time in your app, and that means you need a constant stream of new stuff in their feed. If facebook and instagram just showed us the stuff from the people we knew, we would scroll through it, be done, and move on. Instead they push us to follow lots of people we don’t know, so there is always more new stuff and a reason to be in the app and watch ads, but now the stuff from the people we do know gets buried, so they give us an algorithmic timeline that tries to make sure that no matter how often you go in or how long you keep scrolling, there is always a reason to keep scrolling and you’re always seeing the stuff you came to see. Commentaries on posts are the same thing, every reply is a notification ping and another reason to be in the app. Ideally the discussion / group functionality has enough drama to keep people energized and posting, not so much as to turn them off completely. This is the market at work. If the current crop of social media platforms with these patterns hadn’t chosen this path, other platforms that did would have outcompeted them. The fact that people spend so much time in these platforms is proof they are really good at showing them what they want to see. Wanting to build a “healthier” social media platform is sort of like trying to make a “healthier” alcoholic beverage. We make it healthier by consuming it less, not by changing its nature, because its nature is the point of why we consume it in the first place.
- neilalexander 4y agoI think you're possibly right in that the cons of social media outweigh the pros at this point, but questioning the value of technology is altogether asking the wrong question and claiming "the Amish were right" is utter nonsense. It's like a workman trying to blame his tools for a job badly done. Social media is a use-case. There are plenty of other use-cases. Some of them bring value and some of them don't, but that is not the fault of the smartphone.
- hackerlight 4y ago"The Amish were right" != "The Amish were right to a certain extent"
- dqpb 4y ago> Perhaps we should organize a national poll against social media. Including HN?
- janandonly 4y agoWhat if all the users, combined, could take Twitter off the market? Imagine Twitter, but it only asks some money from subscriptions, let's say $1/year/user[1]. Now we take away all adverts. And voilà, a wonderful platform. [1] If memory serves me, this was once upon a time the yearly price for using WhatsApp.
- quest88 4y agoIt works when you curate it. I removed lots of "friends" and family. Joined hobby groups, and now it's a good source of relevant events for me.