7 ms·
At least for the US why not keep one or more nuclear missile subs in the Great Lakes? Lake Superior alone covers 31,700 square miles to an average depth of 483
by Retric 4y ago
At least for the US why not keep one or more nuclear missile subs in the Great Lakes?
Lake Superior alone covers 31,700 square miles to an average depth of 483 feet. It’s far to large an area to target with a first strike and well protected from non US/Canadian forces.
Edit: A US/Canadian treaty demilitarized the Great Lakes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rush–Bagot_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rush–Bagot_Treaty
- ok_dad 4y agoThe idea is subs deliver missiles halfway around the world, the rockets do the rest. It’s a matter of an hour for a rocket to transit from the Great Lakes to the other side of the planet, but half that for rockets fired from most of the way there already.
- jwithington 4y agoHmm…maybe I don’t quite understand what you’re saying. But I think you’re implying is that subs drive pretty far away with their nuclear missiles and shoot closer to the target?
- ceejayoz 4y agoShortening the time to target is one of the benefits (well, is that really the right term here?) of submarines, yes, but another is survivability for a retaliatory strike as a deterrent. Trident missiles have at least a 7,500 mile range. A couple in the Great Lakes would provide that with complete safety against Russian hunter-killer subs.
- sitkack 4y agoRussian subs are already in the Great Lakes.
- shrewduser 4y agosurely this is in jest
- l33t2328 4y agoIf you’re not joking, where do you suspect they were deployed from?
- mbg721 4y agoWisconsin, duh.
- koterpillar 4y agohttps://xkcd.com/405/ https://xkcd.com/405/
- sgt101 4y agoPassing through Montreal and Quebec City at 27' of depth in the dead of night (challenging for a Yasen at 32' draft but possibly some freak condition might make it possible) a few drunks watching in awe as it slides silently under bridges. River patrol craft carefully edging out of the way (a tearful salute offered to brave comrades, perhaps a lifted glass of Vodka or a gentle pat on the wallet to acknowledge regular payment). Other patrol craft can be seen lying idle by the side of the water due to their crew celebrating "arranged" events, or being "taken out" by the KGB (or whatever they've taken to calling themselves now). Now it runs through Lake Ontario and spends a day lolling in the deep cold waters there before night falls once more and enters the Nigara river (oh shit, you see where this is going) and starts the run through Nigara City. At full speed the most daring Naval maneuver of all time is about to be attempted. Now, finally, the true value of the Yansen class will be revealed as two vast titanium wings snap out from under the hull and the super-cavitating bubble generator is deployed. The hidden rocket engines on the rear of the boat ignite. The submarine fills with the stench of human excrement as the whole crew void their bowels in unison and the Russian sub leaps from the water in front of Nigara falls and.. oh I give up. Just when HN seemed to have settled into semi-intelligent tech talk we get this. Sheeech
- ninjanomnom 4y agoWhile the parent post here is (I hope) a joke, the reply here is beautifully written and now I want a full length story of how this could happen.
- ok_dad 4y agoI want a TV show about this submarine, but a comedy like Hogan’s heroes lol.
- sangnoir 4y ago> Just when HN seemed to have settled into semi-intelligent tech talk we get this Oh, HN has always been like this on topics not directly related to tech.
- kennend3 4y agoAs others have posted, you must be joking? Are you aware that in order to reach the Great lakes via the ocean requires navigating several locks? Do you propose the Russian subs stopped at the locks, paid the lock fees and continued on their way? when the reach the locks, what type of ship do they state they are https://greatlakes-seaway.com/en/commercial-shipping/tolls-schedule/ https://greatlakes-seaway.com/en/commercial-shipping/tolls-s... They don't list "submarine"?
- kiernanmcgowan 4y agoYou're skipping over the concept of "survivability" of submarines which enable a second-strike capability. It's not about getting the missiles closer to the enemy, but ensuring that there are nukes that can be launched in the case of the US falling to a surprise attack. In theory this would deter a first-strike against the US because the subs could still retaliate with massive damage. Thus, cutting second-strike capability could make first-strike more likely in the eyes of US strategic (eg nuclear) planning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_triad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_triad
- dylan604 4y agoYes, the fact that nobody really knew where the subs were was a key factor in that first strike survivability. Even ComSubPacFlt only knew of very large sectors of ocean that a boat was to patrol, the rest was up to the captain and circumstances.
- noduerme 4y agoIt does seem silly, but not out or the realm of possibility. The Great Lakes stretch further north and closer to the Russian heartland than almost any land in America. Any international waters further north and closer by great circle distance to Moscow, besides the north Atlantic, are covered in ice part of the year. Someone said it's cheaper to dig holes in the ground. The problem is those holes are on a first strike list. There's a case for second strike capabilities based in the Great Lakes.
- RajT88 4y agoGreat lakes commercial fisherman and also crew on container ships have said for years that they see weird stuff dozens of miles offshore in the Great lakes. Fish stories and all that. But there is precedent for submarines and even aircraft carriers in the Great lakes. Lake Michigan is filled with crashed trainer aircraft from WWII.
- xattt 4y agoCan you be more specific about the weird stuff? Are you suggesting the Great Lakes are occupied by foreign states? A comment above mentions a demilitarization treaty of the Great Lakes.
- RajT88 4y ago> Are you suggesting the Great Lakes are occupied by foreign states? I am definitely not suggesting it's a foreign state. That's less probable than unknown domestic military activities. Reports of odd lights in sky or water. Or general nonspecific stories of "weird shit". There's more too, but those are fish stories (sharks, people claim). I like to do outdoorsy stuff, so this is what I've heard from fisherman, ferrymen, etc.
- kennend3 4y agoCan you provide a map which indicates how the "Great lakes" (Lakes Superior, Michigan, Huron, Erie, and Ontario) are somehow "close to Moscow"? These lakes are in general on or near the Canada–United States border. There are rivers to the north which feed the lakes, but the lakes are no where near Moscow. Perhaps you mean Moscow, Ontario which is around 35KM north of Lake Ontario? If not, Moscow, Russia is a 16 hour flight from the great lakes area.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y ago[1] https://designobserver.com/feature/blast-door-art-cave-paintings-of-nuclear-era/6697/ https://designobserver.com/feature/blast-door-art-cave-paint... <- says 30 minutes or less.
- napier 4y agoThat’s part of the idea. Another is, as parent suggests, survivability and stealth.
- runjake 4y agoKeep in mind if we launch a missile from the Great Lakes, it’s heading north over the arctic to get to its destination.
- jakzurr 4y agoWe could use that as a defense against Canada. ;)
- cwillu 4y agoWe send an army south every year right under your noses. You know them as “murder geese”. ‹honk›
- lb1lf 4y agoYou may be joking, but do keep in mind that the Canadians (well, the British, but if memory serves, a significant fraction of the force were from Canada) sacked Washington D.C. in 1814.
- lostlogin 4y agoIf anyone is going to sack D.C. in the near future, it would seem most likely to be Americans.
- K0balt 4y agoTbf the Canadians would probably be more pleasant about the whole ordeal.
- kennend3 4y agoThis gets posted and re-posted often.. Not that it matters, but I am Canadian and we were taught in school Canada was created in 1867 via the BNA (British North American Act). Therefor, those who "sacked" Washington must be British, the same way that George Washington must British as well be given he was born prior to the formation of the USA. He became "American" later, much as "Canada" was created later..
- dontlaugh 4y agoThe US uses submarines to threaten attacks on far away countries, not for defence.
- walrus01 4y agoMAD is a form of defence at the level of nation states with ballistic missiles that can reach anywhere else on earth.
- XorNot 4y agoNo it doesn't. Ballistic missile submarines are exclusively useful as second strike weapons: they don't carry enough warheads, nor are they accurate enough to first strike weapons (which have to reliably hit military targets and threaten an opponent's retaliation ability).
- trasz 4y agoNot true; subs are part of every carrier fleet.
- trashtester 4y agoThose would be Virginia class attacks subs, not ballistic missile subs, I think. An Ohio class could be added temporarily, though, to add even more cruise missile capability to the task force. (Since they, or at least some of them, are now dual purpose platforms.)
- dylan604 4y agoAnd how many of those Ohio class subs actually carry missles and have not been filled with cement ballast?
- trashtester 4y agoI expect such things to be confidential....
- jwithington 4y agoI think we could but why build a whole base complete with nuclear weapons handling and reactor maintenance facilities on the Great Lakes? Just use the ones in Georgia/Washington. It’s a fun thought exercise though!
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe idea is that ones based in the Great Lakes would be immune to interception by enemy submarines discovering and shadowing them; you're not gonna get an Akula up the St. Lawrence Seaway.
- sgc 4y agoHowever, it would leave them is a small, well-known area and would allow for easier signature profiling via sensors mounted on any number of craft, that could then be used on other subs of the same class elsewhere in the world. That was the reason why when some idiot in the White House revealed where our subs were near China and HK, it was a big deal.
- Retric 4y agoShips much larger than ohio subs can get into and out of the Great Lakes via locks. Looks like the real reason is a US Canadian treaty. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rush–Bagot_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rush–Bagot_Treaty
- bombcar 4y agoIt is/was simpler and cheaper to just stick nukes in big holes in the ground all over the midwest. Some are probably still "hot".
- onion2k 4y agoThose will be among the targets in the first strike. Unless they can fire before the nukes hit they're not useful. Subs are pretty much the only option. I suspect foreign agents try to bribe people in submarine crews to sabotage their sub in the event of a strike. If someone onboard could stop the American second strike missiles being fired they'd give Russia a huge advantage. I imagine the Navy have considerer this.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Unless they can fire before the nukes hit they're not useful Surely hitting every ICBM silo, B-2 airfield and nuclear submarine virtually simultaneously is nontrivial.
- xoa 4y ago>Unless they can fire before the nukes hit they're not useful. Au contraire! An important aspect of them as land based is the "nuclear sponge" concept: every single nuke spent on a silo is a nuke not aimed at a population center or vital infrastructure. They're out in the middle of nowhere for a reason (well, multiple reasons, but that's one of them). Even if they're all lost they've constrained the opponent's tactical choices merely by their existence, pushing towards the logic of a counter force strike instead of counter value. Any nuclear exchange would be very bad, but unlike Europe the US does indeed have a lot of near completely uninhabited non-arable land for strategic depth. Makes sense to use it.
- volkl48 4y agoIn the event of a full nuclear war, whoever is on board the sub has probably just had their family, friends, and home vaporized. Further, they are trapped in a small metal tube with 100 other people in similar condition, and who will probably be....not pleased if any sabotage is discovered. I suspect it would be very hard to successfully bribe said crew members. (And have them actually follow through with their end of the deal, rather than just taking the money and...not doing it if the war ever happened)
- prpl 4y agoSurely it’s easier to emit low frequency noise from various decoys
- jlawson 4y agoThey might be an easier target than you think. What could a dozen 1MT warheads, sunk to a depth of 100ft, do to submarines anywhere in the Great Lakes? Shockwaves travel through water much better than through air. Water explodes into steam in a way that air doesn't. My intuition is that you actually could pretty reliably paste a sub inside the Great Lakes using some nukes launches from Russia. The lakes may just not be deep or big enough to hide in. This is leaving aside the treaty, the lack of freshwater sub technology, the long time to retaliation due to long range, the lack of a sub facility on the lakes, and the unnecessary nature of the whole enterprise (if the US lost 1 boomer sub to an enemy they could bring the others into a defensive posture making them practically impossible to hunt down, to preserve 2nd strike capability).
- Retric 4y agoNuclear depth bombs are well known technology that was abandoned because they don’t actually work that well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_depth_bomb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_depth_bomb They aren’t that much better than depth charges in part because energy is spread in 3D space. 1,000,000 times the energy means ~100x the range, but depth charges are very short range weapons. In WWII with a sub on radar and using 12 depth charges in a grid they only had a 5-10% kill chance. Which is one reason why nuclear depth charges where replaced by target seeking torpedoes. Carpet bombing the Great Lakes with thousands of nukes could work but that’s a great nuclear sponge. Directing a huge quantity of munitions away from other targets. PS: 100ft is likely shallow with much of the blast being sent into the air but that’s not very important to your suggestion.
- fivefifty 4y agoNot exactly the same but there has been consideration given to store ICBMs in lakes amongst other things: https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/air-force-considered-firing-icbms-from-lakes-tunnels-before-picking-new-missile https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/air-force-considered-f...
- andkenneth 4y agoBecause submarine launched missiles do not have the range of ICBMs.
- sigmoid10 4y agoThe Trident II Submarine Ballistic Missile has a range of more than 7500 miles (12000km). The exact capability is still classified, but you could easily hit places like Moscow or Beijing from a submarine in the great lakes.
- kennend3 4y agoMost nuclear equipped responses use the same principle. Get the payload to Low Earth orbit and re-enter. So let's look at the Trident system for a second (used on subs). This is a MIRV weapon (Multiple independently targetable reentry vehicle) Reentry refers to "space". This gives them a tremendous range. Triden's posted range is 12,000 KM. Using "Toronto" to estimate distances as it is on Lake Ontario: Toronto to Moscow - 7,400 KM Toronto to Beijing - 10,583 KM Therefor a sub in the great lakes with a trident system can reach pretty much any key "target".
- Qem 4y agoWouldn't the pressure wave from a underwater burst make the submarine hull collapse, given the lake has limited depth to disperse the energy of the blast, when compared to open oceans.
- Retric 4y agoNot something I know that much about, though nuclear depth charges where apparently replaced with torpedoes because they aren’t that great a weapon. Best case 500 ft vs 12,000 feet means the blast might have a range roughly square root of 24 or 5x as far. But a more variable topology might work like the walls of an anechoic chamber and disparate the blast much faster. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anechoic_chamber#/media/File:Consumer_Reports_-_product_testing_-_headphones_in_anechoic_chamber.tif https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anechoic_chamber#/media/File:C...