7 ms·
40 years ago, Tron changed sci-fi movies
- W-Stool 4y agoWhen Tron was first released I was in a grad level computer graphics class at a university in the USA midwest. I convinced our rather stuffy professor to take the class across the street to the "Cinema Twin" and watch the movie. In those days computer graphics consisted of mostly pen plotters and Tektronix vector displays - pretty dry stuff, lots of theory in the class but not much interesting output was generated. To say the collective minds of the class were blown away by the movie would be an understatement. In its own way it showed the future of CGI and what the this domain could look like. If you haven't seen it lately, give it spin - it holds up well.
- retcon 4y agoPrecisely because of the minimal gfx world I can't imagine it ageing. Ironically I think it's possible only Disney of the major studios could have understood the necessity as well as potential of audience imagination to fill out the emotional picture.
- kwertyoowiyop 4y agoYes. Tron still looks good, while Polar Express already does not.
- WorldPeas 4y agoI take your polar express and raise you blade(1998)
- CoastalCoder 4y agoSo what was the professor's take on it?
- dekhn 4y ago"Call me when they can do shaded polygons" :) IIRC James Clarke (who developed the early graphics chips SGI was famous for) said something like "reality is just 80M polygons a second" (at least, in a gross approximation of how the real world is presented to our neuro-optical system).
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThey did better than that and had curves as well. See the multiple youtube links on this page.
- layer8 4y agoThere’s a short part of the solar sailer sequence with various landscapes that I always found particularly impressive for the time: https://youtu.be/8ruRruqKf5M?t=2m32s https://youtu.be/8ruRruqKf5M?t=2m32s (the music isn’t the original in that clip) For a long time I thought the sandy planes were a mandelbrot-like set, but it’s really a Mickey Mouse logo. :)
- dekhn 4y agoI think I'm jaded, but even when I saw Tron originally, I was only modestly impressed with the CGI. It felt very wire-framey (similar to the Star Trek II genesis sequence) to me, even if (as you say) it had curves and filled polygons. After some time working in computer graphics I realized that what I really needed/wanted was renderman and an entire team of animators/technical directors, circa 2010. So, basically subsurface scattering, monte carlo sampling, many light sources, rich models and textures. Obviously, none of that was really accessible at the time Tron or Star Trek II was made, but those movies opened the path for the necessary brain and money investment to make the Pixar rendering computer and the rest is history.
- sammalloy 4y ago> I think I'm jaded, but even when I saw Tron originally, I was only modestly impressed with the CGI. You’re being downvoted, but most of us who saw it when it was originally released were not impressed. My thinking on this is because we were searching for a different aesthetic, likely what we would see much later with Avatar. However, today, the Tron aesthetic has come back in a big way as a retro art style. This is not surprising. It may very well be the case that as contemporaries of the original Tron, it was not intended for our generation, but for the ones who would come later. Perusing art history, this seems to be very much the case. Most generations do not properly appreciate the art from their own time, either because they can’t or they are too focused on their own personal vision of what art should be. I can’t tell you what the real reasons for this are, but I think that the audience is a prisoner of their time, while the artist has more freedom with their vision to see farther than the species is able to do on the level of the group, which is confined by the herd and the status quo.
- oweiler 4y agoThe CGI holds up but the story doesn't. There is a reason the movie flopped on its release.
- layer8 4y agoThis was mind-blowing to watch as a kid: https://youtu.be/jyqS4IS7h8Y https://youtu.be/jyqS4IS7h8Y
- LaserDiscMan 4y agoI distinctly remember being mesmerized by this scene at the time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1kyiQzc4134 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1kyiQzc4134 Super Mario 64 was a similar experience of "wow, this is new!".
- layer8 4y agoTron led me to code a 2D version of the lightcycle game on the C64, but it was super slow because I didn’t know assembly :). I then added random obstacles to the playing field to make it more interesting. A good friend later wrote Armagetron.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoYup, especially when ones only exposure to computer graphics were things like Space Invaders and Asteroids. Definitely next level.
- gfxgirl 4y agoI love the movie, but just FYI, pretty much every scene with people in it is not CGI. It's hand draw backgrounds and tripled exposed live actors who were then physically hand compositied together Watch a makng of movie to see There's pleny actual CGI like the light cycles, the recognizer scenes, the MCP, the light sail.
- mikey_p 4y agoIt's been more than 40 years, but for some reason I thought Disney's weirdest failure would have been The Black Hole.
- tcbawo 4y agoAnother strange failure for Disney was the Black Cauldron. Although, I knew it wouldn’t have impacted science fiction.
- chiph 4y agoThey got so much right with that film. And so much wrong. It could stand a remake, or even a sequel where the Cygnus reappears after surviving it's apparent destruction.
- LaserDiscMan 4y agoAlthough different in many ways, I think Event Horizon shares some similarities with The Black Hole. The Gothic style of the ship, the setting, the plot etc...
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoTrue, it's exceedingly uneven, maddening even. The things it gets right, it gets so right that you can feel the potential the movie had, and then something clunky or poorly written shows up to ruin the moment. Similarly, the idea of remake both excites and frightens me because I have doubts that the high points would be matched by a modern version. Probably something mostly bland and generic, with some rapidly dated contemporary political themes thrown in the mix.
- remoquete 4y agoI was about to say that but… Turns out TBH grossed 35 million dollars, more than its cost.
- MBCook 4y agoYeah, but at a $20m budget that’s not a ton. Isn’t something like 2x considered minimum-success in Hollywood? Between that and the poor reviews it’s clear it’s not what they wanted.
- mrandish 4y agoTRON was technologically notable because it was the first wide-release film to extensively use high-res CGI. Getting high-res electronic images transferred cleanly to film was still being figured out. I remember reading in an effects magazine about how they cobbled together a workflow to get images from the 4096 line frame buffer onto film.
- Legion 4y ago> It also had the misfortune of trying to compete with two other huge sci-fi blockbusters in the summer of 1982: Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan and E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial. I miss when "summer blockbuster" meant something other than the 40th Marvel comic movie and the 20th DC comic movie.
- Gibbon1 4y agoBlade Runner totally got hammered by those three.
- aidenn0 4y agoWow, '82 was a year for sci-fi: E.T. Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan TRON Blade Runner The Road Warrior ...and Fantasy: Raiders of the lost Ark ('81 release, but stayed in the theater for 80 weeks) Conan The Barbarian The Secret of NIMH The Last Unicorn Beastmaster
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI saw Blade Runner and Road Warrior as a double feature. Blade Runner was pretty but Road Warrior was the one that kind of blew my mind. No way you kill the protagonist's dog and blow up his car half way into the film!
- jamiek88 4y agoRoad warrior being mad max for other parts of the world?!
- tedunangst 4y agoMad Max 2.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoThank you.
- walrus01 4y agoThe 2010 Tron movie has a good bit of outdoor Vancouver, BC in it, standing in for whatever generic American city it's supposed to be set in. Fairly typical example of Hollywood North re-dressing a city to match its needs. The building with the parachute base jump is actually the Shangri-La condo tower downtown.
- gnulinux 4y ago> generic American city Hmm, it's imho inaccurate to put it that way. I don't think there is a single "generic city" in the US. I think most American villages, towns and small cities look and feel the same (they all have the same CVS, Walgreens etc, you need a car) but when it comes to big cities, US cities are vastly, vastly different. Living in NYC feels nothing like living in Boston, which feels nothing like SF, which feels nothing like LA etc... When someone says "generic American city" I really can't think of any streotypes... E.g. you can say American cities are very car-centric which is 100% correct for e.g. LA. But e.g. NYC and Boston ([1]) are very much the opposite, where arguably it's more comfortable to live without a car (especially the case in Manhattan or Cambridge). Just a few data points, I realize this is not a very important discussion. [1] I was told Chicago is like this too, unfortunately never lived there myself.
- walrus01 4y agoI don't know that Tron (2010) actually specifies any city name, so it's left up to the viewer's imagination what US city it's supposed to be. Presumably ENCOM is a US company and their "headquarters" tower is supposed to be somewhere in the USA.
- schlauerfox 4y agoFlynn's arcade exterior is in Culver City, California. Right around the corner from the hotel the actors for the Munchkins of The Wizard of Oz (1939) stayed.
- pchristensen 4y agoNot the original commenter, but I presume they meant that if the location of the city isn't important to the story, then filmmakers can use buildings, streetscapes, etc to convey "city" without conveying "New York" or "Chicago". It didn't come off as disparaging American cities in general.
- olivermarks 4y agoI feel Tron was a masterpiece of style, art direction and graphic design. The color palettes are incredible.
- layer8 4y agoThe music as well, which famously uses 7/8 meter: https://youtu.be/gWEU5apbY0E?t=38s https://youtu.be/gWEU5apbY0E?t=38s There’s also an 8-bit homage to the soundtrack: https://youtu.be/NzRWXn5KNFI https://youtu.be/NzRWXn5KNFI
- olivermarks 4y agoMuch as I personally like the Wendy Carlos Tron work, I've got a feeling it didn't resonate with Disney audiences and that really hurt the film at the box office. The visuals were really slick but the music was very jarring and sometimes discordant for people used to saccharine soundtracks... https://www.wendycarlos.com/+tron.html https://www.wendycarlos.com/+tron.html
- ryandrake 4y agoAlso did the great soundtrack for A Clockwork Orange. An under-appreciated electronic music pioneer. https://www.wendycarlos.com/+wcco.html https://www.wendycarlos.com/+wcco.html
- olivermarks 4y agoAn all around amazing person!
- timc3 4y agoI wouldn’t say under appreciated, her albums sold millions and she has received several awards and is an important figure in the history of electronic music. Just not as well known as she should be in recent times.
- layer8 4y ago
- dang 4y agoRecent and related: Tron changed cinema, predicted the future of tech - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32033622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32033622 - July 2022 (107 comments)
- js2 4y ago> While The Last Starfighter would push the boundaries of computer-generated special effects two years later. Glad this got a mention. It may be cheeseball, but I can watch TLS even today and suddenly I’m 12 years-old again.
- aidenn0 4y ago"Greetings, Starfighter. You have been recruited by the Star League to defend the Frontier against Xur and the Ko-dan Armada."
- MBCook 4y agoFirst movie to use textured polygons instead of just colored! Another fun movie. I believe the movie didn’t do great with test audiences, but they loved the bits with the alien(?) pretending to be the main character in his place and significantly expanded that part of the movie, which worked out great.
- systemBuilder 4y agoI remember it well (I was 20). It was a very boring movie. I think it's famous just for being 1st, i guess they poured all the money into the CGI because it's a 2-star story.
- threads2 4y agoyeah, even if you're in awe of the technology it's a pretty crappy movie with a bad score.
- MBCook 4y agoIt’s more than just the CGI, it’s also the ideas of the movie. You’re right it’s not great on it’s own. You have to be the kind of person who would be interested in what it’s trying to do.
- js2 4y agoSemi-related: TANK - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YEdQ3mwyrQ4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YEdQ3mwyrQ4 And how it was made: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRkYP7wnD40 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRkYP7wnD40
- bitwize 4y agoTron may have been the first movie I ever saw in a cinema. My parents took us to a drive-in. I remember having the crap scared out of me by the face of the MCP up on that enormous screen. I wouldn't learn about its ancillary awesomeness -- the primitive CG, the use of the Super Foonly, the fact that the MCP is named after the OS for the lauded Burroughs architectures (now Unisys ClearPath)... Like it or not, as much of a dreamlike mishmash as Tron is, it is bound up tightly with the history of our profession and an important piece of our lore.