11 ms·
Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. warehouse
- AlexTWithBeard 4y agoI do not fully understand what's going on. > Bryson had made 22 errors, the 2018 write-up said... If Bryson erred like this six times within a year, the notice stated, he would be fired Six is surely more than twenty two?
- bhelkey 4y agoI read this as being put on notice. More than six additional errors in a year would result in termination.
- kevincox 4y ago> The facility had about 5,300 employees around that time. So over 2 notices per employee. It would be interesting to see the distribution.
- BobOfW 4y agoIf there's a forest, I can't see it with all these trees in the way.
- jka 4y agoPer-employee distribution might tell one story; per-manager distribution might tell another.
- FreqSep 4y agoWell, the notices were over a year. Amazon has massive weekly turnover numbers so the real number of employees over that full year is likely well in excess of 5,000, putting it at least at 1.something per. Then consider it’s almost certain a small number of employees rack up most of the notices, and I can see this happening.
- Someone 4y agoReading https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/feb/04/amazon-chews-through-the-average-worker-in-eight-months-they-need-a-union https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/feb/04/amazon..., 5,300 employees means they had about 8,000 employees throughout the year, so the good news is that it’s fewer than 2 per employee. 8 months is extremely brutal, though.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- derbOac 4y ago"Supportive Feedback Document." It's like some cross between Kafka and newspeak.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoI don't know how anyone could not see this as a pretty clear sign of a toxic workplace. There must be a reason they named it that way and you can deduce a lot from that. Nothing that speaks well for the company.
- AlexTWithBeard 4y agoHow a non-toxic company should've called it? "A terrible fuckup notice"?
- raxxorraxor 4y agoThat would still be far better than passive-aggressively suggesting that complaints are to be uttered in a supportive way. I you are that dishonest in making a sign, you probably don't have a good and open culture to talk about errors or improvements and "supportive feedback" just screams that fact in you face. Could as put up a warning sign: "Please mind the vanity and ego of your superiors when handing in any complains".
- yardie 4y ago> Amazon told the judge in Bryson’s case that it could not meet NLRB demands in a subpoena to provide the thousands of disciplinary notices it delivered to employees that year, calling the requirement “unduly burdensome.” For a company notorious for making sure that employees dot Is and cross the Ts I find it ironic they can't produce the same disciplinary records for the NLRB as they can for their former employees.
- sithadmin 4y agoUnsurprising. I've been told by a relative that worked in an Amazon warehouse that the camera systems overhead (not dissimilar to the type you see in Amazon Go / Amazon Fresh retail stores) are used to issue disciplinary warnings, and it's pretty easy to get issued a warning for completely normal exception-handling behavior. For instance, the shelved/dry goods sections of Fresh warehouses are notorious for being a trainwreck, with items sort of strewn in the general area of where the inventory/pick list says they should be, rather than being neatly arranged. If an employee on picker duty stands around browsing a shelf too long to find the item they're supposed to grab (but can't find it, because it's been shuffled several feet down the shelf)...the cameras monitoring generates an automated warning that goes to your management. Mark the item as out of stock / missing from inventory instead? Get a warning when someone else finds it and scans it later that day, or when inventory is next reconciled. It's a no-win situation.
- iLoveOncall 4y ago> For instance, the shelved/dry goods sections of Fresh warehouses are notorious for being a trainwreck, with items sort of strewn in the general area of where the inventory/pick list says they should be, rather than being neatly arranged. If an employee on picker duty stands around browsing a shelf too long to find the item they're supposed to grab (but can't find it, because it's been shuffled several feet down the shelf)...the cameras monitoring generates an automated warning that goes to your management. Mark the item as out of stock / missing from inventory instead? Get a warning when someone else finds it and scans it later that day, or when inventory is next reconciled. It's a no-win situation. I would like to see any evidence you have to support any of those issues, because having visited an Amazon fulfilment center myself, I can guarantee you that the problems with picking items you mention literally cannot happen.
- pseudalopex 4y ago> the problems with picking items you mention literally cannot happen. How?
- gnatman 4y agoIt's pretty easy to imagine both of these things being true, and the one fulfillment center you visited having substantially less than 13k disciplinary notices. I worked 7 years in industrial staffing for a variety of large distribution centers (not Amazon), and the automated discipline systems in place around voice-pick efficiency were borderline draconian.
- bearjaws 4y agoAnecdotal but I have a friend who works at a urgent care and he says Amazon workers are the most common pattern he sees. They have to do 1 month of physical therapy at "AmCare" (their own internal urgent care...) and if they don't get better they have to get a doctors note to get put on light work duty... 5-8 people a week coming in, from ONE distribution center.
- frankbreetz 4y agoThis seems like a good thing, right? At least better then Amazon requiring these people to keep working. This sounds more like minor inquiries that are being tended to appropriately.
- wollsmoth 4y agoIt kinda sounds like they are pushing the limits of what their employees can handle physically. Just seems like it'd be simpler to deal with less turnover and push them a little less. But then again I don't have an MBA.
- hn_version_0023 4y ago> But then again I don't have an MBA. Are you implying that the process of getting an MBA strips people of their humanity? IME, this seems to be true.
- beastcoast 4y agoAmazon is notorious for hiring MBAs in its senior most ranks.
- klyrs 4y agoI'm not sure you've got the causative arrow going the right way...
- bannedbybros 4y ago
- jmyeet 4y agoAnd yet roughly half of Amazon warehouse workers have been successfully propagandized into not supporting unionization. I can sympathize to a degree with those who aren't subjected to such conditions not understanding how this works in practice (to be fair, a lot of Americans simply don't care if others are suffering straight up) but for those subjected to this? Many of them are still temporarily embarrassed millionaires. The American Dream. Labor organization is the only effective tool against dehumanizing and exploitative labor practices.
- doyouevensunbro 4y agoOr they are afraid of retaliation and losing their jobs? Amazon hits them with anti-union propaganda from day one. We’ve seen Walmart close locations that plan to unionize. https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/news/union-walmart-shut-5-stores-over-labor-activism/ https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/news/union-walmart-shut-5-stores...
- trasz 4y agoThis could be easily fixed by introducing a law forcing companies to give out half of company’s shares to the union. The only reason this doesn’t happen is political - peoples votes don’t matter, what matters is company lobbying.
- mmcdermott 4y agoConfiscating ownership of 50% of a company seems like a pretty big line to cross. I don't think it's purely about political imaging. That would have all kinds of ripple effects, both in terms of the direct results of doing it and of the indirect results of setting the precedent.
- trasz 4y agoQuestioning pope’s infallibility used to be a pretty big line too, and now we know it was all just bluff; there was never a proper reason not to cross it. To put it differently: the law must keep up with times. The law we have wasn’t designed for the business models we have today, from Facebook to Uber.
- chris_wot 4y agoAh, Amazon. I appreciate your efforts at single handedly reviving the union movement!
- xdrosenheim 4y agoAmazon is not only complaining about its own workers, but also about their partners in other countries. They do not (officially) have a Danish site, but sure will deliver anything you buy from their German/UK site. I work for PostNord, the Danish postal service (possibly the largest parcel service, not sure how well GLS is doing these days), and Amazon has been complaining about our "parcel quality", because some parcels are not delivered within 24 hours. (Even though it might take 3-5 days to even get to us)
- AlbertCory 4y agoDo you want to get a union in your warehouse? Because this is how you get a union in your warehouse. Companies that avoid unionization (most of them, these days) make at least some attempt to treat the workers as partners and human beings: pay them well and treat them well. Obviously there are other factors in play and sometimes that's just corporate BS, but it helps. Amazon, from what I can tell from the outside, does not believe in that.
- amcns8 4y agoAmericans are tacitly aware of what awaits even a sit down protest: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/UC_Davis_pepper_spray_incident https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/UC_Davis_pepper_spray_incide... I encounter people in the Midwest who literally believe all of Portland was on fire in 2020, nevermind it was two city blocks being “terrorized” by progressives, while conservatives and cops cruised quiet neighborhoods harassing and gassing people. The propaganda worked; two block peaceful protest was turned into “progressives creating a war”, and the part about the cops and good old boys is forgotten. This culture is a joke of cowards who would abuse the lower castes. And it has the nerve to talk down about China or India. Moral relativism towards you all is on the way; let the planet burn and your effort being wiped away. Who cares.
- jimnotgym 4y agoWhen the workers finally unionise at every warehouse, Amazon can rest comfortably in the knowledge that they caused it.
- AlexTWithBeard 4y agoSo when the workers unionize, what's gonna change? Workers will not be notified of their mistakes? They will not be fired if they make too many of those? Miscalculating the items won't longer be a mistake? They will pay the double of minimum salary?
- AlbertCory 4y agoI've never worked in a unionized place, but from what I've heard over the years: Firing an employee becomes much harder. You have to convince the union first. Employees can file grievances. If a disciplinary or surveillance system is considered onerous (by them), then they file a grievance, and much bureaucracy ensues. Pay scales tend to depend on seniority and job classification, not on a supervisor's idea of your merit. This is negotiated in the union contract every few years, as a rule. Major changes in how the warehouse operates have to be cleared with the union. Union dues are deducted from paychecks. The union can go on strike, and other unions generally respect their picket lines. I'm deliberately not making this seem like Heaven on Earth. That's probably why union elections are contentious.
- AlbertCory 4y agoIn case that seemed too even-handed for the employers: With a really shitty employer like Amazon (at least at some of their warehouses), a union really might provide some protection to the workers. All those stories about workers having to pee in a bottle because they get docked for too many bathroom breaks: gone. The union would take care of it. Getting fired for too many demerits from the overhead surveillance cameras? Gone. Of course, when you vote Yes or No for a union, you don't really know if they'll be able to negotiate all that. Prior to the 1930s, unions provided some on-the-job safety, and some protections against arbitrary management or pay cuts. Over time, those got written into laws or companies just refrained from really shitty practices. Most companies, anyway. Not all.
- bilekas 4y ago> it could not meet NLRB demands in a subpoena to provide the thousands of disciplinary notices it delivered to employees that year, calling the requirement “unduly burdensome.” That must be parody on the part of the legal team... The irony.
- therealbilly 4y agoWhen reading the article, I was reminded of how things must have been working as a slave laborer in the underground Nordhausen rocket factory in 1944.
- stuaxo 4y agoSounds like constructive dismissal.
- tiahura 4y ago
- refurb 4y agoI worked at a warehouse picking order, very similar to how Amazon works. I would get "disciplinary notices" on a regular basis when errors were found. It wasn't a big deal, just something they tracked. If you screwed up continuously, you could eventually be fired since fixing the mistake was quite costly in terms of customer service time, picking a new order, delivery costs and return costs.
- evilDagmar 4y agoWhatcha wanna bet that the deal they have with the local gov't promised they'd bring X number of jobs to the area, which is a target they can only meet by hiring some people, firing a bunch of them, and then hiring more, since every new hire counts as a job placement.
- peanut_worm 4y agoIt seems like the working conditions for unskilled laborers across the country are plummeting