5 ms·
> Obesity is not a disease of over-eating, it is a disease of managing hunger. Indeed it is, and the solution to managing hunger (i.e. returning your whole ins
by sph 4y ago
> Obesity is not a disease of over-eating, it is a disease of managing hunger.
Indeed it is, and the solution to managing hunger (i.e. returning your whole insulin and leptin system to a more optimal baseline) is NOT going for a 90% carbohydrate diet.
That's exactly why we have a bloody obesity epidemic. It's a fun thought experiment, but reading the comments in here people actually think this is genius and sustainable.
- nostrebored 4y agoCGMs should disillusion people of this pretty quickly. I really wish more people would try them for a month just to see how they respond to certain foods.
- ericb 4y agoCGM ?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- csours 4y agoContinuous Glucose Monitor. Related topic: Glycogen storage in the liver and muscles and glycogen depletion
- jrvarela56 4y agoI did and would recommend. It shows you the impact of foods in your blood glucose and made it easier to convince myself and change my behavior. Some lessons I got from using it for 2 months (these are personal, some should apply to most people): - Plantains cause a BIG glucose spike (I thought they didnt; in my case even more than pasta or rice) - Walking ~10min after a meal removes the glucose spike of even pretty large meals - Intense exercise before (duh) removes the glucose spike of any meal, even with big desert/ice cream - Eating veggies (or taking fiber pills) before a meal removes the glucose spike of most meals Some of these things I had read about online, but seeing the impact live on my own blood glucose made the lessons stick.
- dubswithus 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong but I feel that your comment is trying to connect a "big glucose spike" with the cause of diabetes. They are not connected. Millions of people are eating apples, grapes, plantains, strawberries, raspberries, etc every year without issue. To tell people to avoid these healthy foods is not backed by the science. And so what if it raises your levels temporarily? Running raises my heart rate and blood pressure. Does that mean I'm about to die?
- pcorsaro 4y agoThat's not what this person is saying. "Big glucose spike(s)" actually are the cause of diabetes. The more regular spikes a person has, the more resistant to insulin they become, which is where type 2 diabetes starts. The point of the comments I believe was just to say that certain foods cause different responses in different people. If plantains cause a large spike in a person, I would say that person should probably not eat them every day all the time.
- dubswithus 4y ago> "Big glucose spike(s)" actually are the cause of diabetes. The more regular spikes a person has, the more resistant to insulin they become, which is where type 2 diabetes starts. People who don't have diabetes or pre-diabetes spike. But I hardly see a body of work that suggests that everyone is at risk of diabetes. > If plantains cause a large spike in a person, I would say that person should probably not eat them every day all the time. People from South America eat them every day and they aren't linked to diabetes as far as I know.
- jrvarela56 4y ago> People who don't have diabetes or pre-diabetes spike. But I hardly see a body of work that suggests that everyone is at risk of diabetes. The problem is consistently exceeding a certain level of blood sugar for extended periods of time. I think this is how you develop insulin resistance. > People from South America eat them every day and they aren't linked to diabetes as far as I know. I am from Panama, where we eat a lot of plantains. That's why I decided to test because it's a staple and I would have never put it in the same category as other carbs (bc I thought they had enough fiber to counter).
- dubswithus 4y agoSo I think this is an attempt to link a random result to a metabolic disease? This goes against the advice of pretty much every health doctor, nutritionist, and scientist.
- nostrebored 4y agoI would be shocked if there aren’t more studies using CGMs to track diet adherence and health in the next few years. If your doctor is telling you that prolonged periods of high blood sugar sustained over time are good for you, I would suggest that they review a bit of the literature.
- dubswithus 4y agoIf I asked my doctor about using a CGM as a runner that likes to eat fruits and vegetables he would look at me like I'm an idiot. I imagine he would say, "So you aren't having any health issues and bought this $100 device anyway?" People who get pre-diabetes or diabetes (type 2), well, it's usually because they are overweight or obese. There's just not a lot of people getting diabetes in a mysterious way. Also, saturated fat is linked to diabetes. And cutting that out improves heart health anyway.
- autoexec 4y agoI'd do it if they had one that didn't involve needles.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoBy this logic, the obesity epidemic should've happened in the 17th century when the potato was introduced to the rest of the world and became the staple crop of poor farmers everywhere.
- sph 4y agoThey did not eat a potato only diet, however poor they were. I actually have relatives in a third world country that however poor they were they'd have a diet of mostly starches but including decent protein, even if it's just fish, literal bugs, small rodents and other subpar meat. They'd laugh you out the village if you'd tell them they can live on yams and tapioca alone. Staple doesn't mean one food diet.
- TrisMcC 4y agoDo you really believe that the obesity epidemic was caused by people eating 90% carbohydrate diets? The "high carb meals" at McDonald's, Burger King, Pizza Hut... are all also (and more per calorie) high in fat. Add 2 tablespoons of olive oil to your mixed-green salad? That has turned into a high fat salad. Most people cannot avoid cheese or nuts on salad, either. Eating the potato diet with sour cream/butter/cheese: High fat.
- devoutsalsa 4y agoI'm overweight because I eat too much. Eat caloric surplus, gain weight. That part isn't complicated. Why I eat too much is another question...
- mrguyorama 4y agoIt's funny too, because I have perfectly logged data showing that the weeks I eat fewer than about 1800 calories reliably, (because I have an incredibly sedentary lifestyle) reliably and predictably lower my weight. I've literally got a science experiment in my own body that shows reducing calories in, without reducing the actual design of my meals, reduces my body mass. I'm willing to accept that there are some minor irregularities and difficulties that make "Calories in == Calories out" not 100% accurate, but I'm betting the effect size is closer to +-10%, and therefore easily discarded for approximations, even though they are scientifically significant and could create a more accurate model.
- bumby 4y agoI agree that the CICO is a model that works, but it is at least somewhat complicated by the fact that CO is a function of CI. I.e., what you eat takes different amounts of energy to metabolize so it also contributes to what you burn. If I eat 1800 kcal of protein I may have higher CO than if I ate 1800 kcal of simple carbohydrates. There's already a lot of uncertainty when most people measure their calories (very few people actually weigh their food) and this just adds another layer of uncertainty. I have a feeling those all combine to make it inaccurate enough in practice for some people to claim the CICO model doesn't work.
- mpalczewski 4y ago> Indeed it is, and the solution to managing hunger (i.e. returning your whole insulin and leptin system to a more optimal baseline) is NOT going for a 90% carbohydrate diet. Leptin system returns to a more optimal baseline with weight loss. Insulin returns to a more optimal baseline by increasing insulin sensitivity. Exercise does this most effectively, loosing weight also does this. Low carb diets don't do this directly, only through weight loss. Managing hunger is managing your dopamine response. Eating nothing but one food, will make you very bored of your food. You won't be looking for food as entertainment, stress relief, or a cure for boredom(dopamine). You will only eat for true hunger(lack of dopamine can feel similar).
- bumby 4y ago>Exercise does this most effectively Curious, does it depend on the type of exercise and, if so, do we know what mechanisms cause some types to have a disproportionate impact?
- leksak 4y agoI believe that the more glycolytic the type of exercise is the greater the impact. Thus, higher intensity exercise is preferable if the goal is to improve insulin sensitivity which I reckon is a transient improvement and that a lot of it is thanks to GLUT4-translocation within the muscles in response to the exercise. This translocation means that less insulin needs to be secreted to deal with carbohydrates after training. https://scholar.google.se/scholar_url?url=https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Yutaka-Nakaya/publication/13711184_Bradykinin_directly_GLUT4_translocation_via_an_insulin-independent_pathway/links/56a6f61808ae0fd8b3fc777f/Bradykinin-directly-GLUT4-translocation-via-an-insulin-independent-pathway.pdf&hl=en&sa=X&ei=CfKBYoG8GpuVy9YP69K4iAE&scisig=AAGBfm3SAFuGanI_PZvtcao8Ul7k5Y9H0w&oi=scholarr https://scholar.google.se/scholar_url?url=https://www.resear...
- imtringued 4y agoSorry but your comment is complete nonsense. Insulin reacts faster than weight loss. In fact it is so fast, every time you wake up, your insulin resistance recovers a little bit every morning after you sleep. It is entirely possible to be obese without insulin resistance and to be skinny with insulin resistance. It is completely orthogonal to weight but insulin resistance makes it much easier to gain even more weight.
- seadan83 4y agoMy unsupported personal belief is that the human body processes different carbohydrates in very different ways. Carbs that come from starch are not equivalent to carbs from cane sugar, and yet again not equivalent to honey, and again not equivalent to high fructose corn sryup, and again different from breads & pasta. Ratio of fiber to carbohydrate and how that carbohydrate is processed by the body is also important as well. Hence, french fries are not good, they have added sugar, the skin is removed, and they have a lot of added fats from the fried oils. That strikes me as a world of difference compared to a whole baked potato consumed with a sauteed broccolli with a side salad (plenty of fiber). Unrelated, and unsolicited 2 cents, IMO it's all about eating as many fibrous and leafy greens as possible. At that point, a moderate side of lean meat, potato, carb, practially whatever - does not matter so long as the fibrous and leafy greens are the majority source of calories.
- goodpoint 4y ago> personal belief is that the human body processes different carbohydrates in very different ways This is nutritional science 101. Slow-digesting carbohydrates like big-flake oats are really good. Fast-digesting things like sugars, processed foods, fast food and meat products are bad as they create spikes in the glycemic index.
- autoexec 4y ago> Slow-digesting carbohydrates like big-flake oats are really good. if only they tasted that way!
- rootusrootus 4y agoWith enough brown sugar and butter they sure do. But I suppose that defeats the point...
- seadan83 4y agoI agree. I do wonder and was speaking a bit to other factors that I do not know but suspect, notably: - Do a high glycemic index food have a higher propensity to be stored on the body vs actually used? - Is the caloric absorption rate of high fructose corn sryup higher than say honey? Speaking to this, the body makes different choices on whether a food passes through you, is absorbed and used, or whether it is stored. It makes different choices in where and how to store that energy, all in all which makes me think that not all carbohydrates (or calories, or foods) are equal when actually consumed. That is not even getting started with on gut fauna and the effects of different foods on the microbial environments in our guts.