8 ms·
Lockheed Martin Prepar 3D
- tgorgolione 4y agoWhat's interesting about this is that they are using Microsoft's Flight Simulator X's codebase, and I think plugins that work in FSX will work in Prepar3D.
- akpa1 4y agoIt's veeeeery hit and miss as to if an FSX add-on will work with P3D. One reason is that FSX is 32-bit only whereas P3D is 64-bit as of v4 - they've changed a lot of stuff.
- mm007emko 4y agoUntil Prepar3D version 3 it was somewhat true. Since V4 it is 64-bit and it broke the compatibility with most older plug-ins.
- dlojudice 4y ago> Prepar3D furthers the development of Microsoft® ESP™ while maintaining compatibility with Microsoft Flight Simulator X, allowing many thousands of add-ons to be used within Prepar3D. [1] Interesting. Microsoft ESP? First time I hear about this Microsoft product. Furthermore the simulation is based on Microsoft Flight Simulator X, 2006 software. [1] https://www.prepar3d.com/product-overview/ https://www.prepar3d.com/product-overview/
- mynameisvlad 4y agoESP seems to be the commercial platform based off Flight Simulator X: https://news.microsoft.com/2007/11/14/microsoft-esp-debuts-as-a-platform-for-visual-simulation/ https://news.microsoft.com/2007/11/14/microsoft-esp-debuts-a...
- yodon 4y agoESP was an effort to turn Flight Simulator into a general purpose commercial and military sim. They assembled a great team to do that, then shut it all down in the aftermath of the 2008 crash. Balmer decided some part of Microsoft Game Studios needed to be shut down to save costs and the Flight Sim team had always been an outsider with the weakest political connections into the core of MGS, so even though the ESP business plan was much more sensible than most of the MGS products, it was the piece that ended up getting killed.
- com2kid 4y ago> Balmer decided some part of Microsoft Game Studios needed to be shut down to save costs and the Flight Sim team had always been an outsider with the weakest political connections into the core of MGS, so even though the ESP business plan was much more sensible than most of the MGS products, it was the piece that ended up getting killed. Worse than that. This was relayed to me by someone who worked on the flight sim team. So flight sim wasn't actually part of Microsoft game studio, they were in the middle of transitioning over when the shit hit the fan. The head of the organization that they were a part of (I forget what it was called), blocked the transfer so he could keep the flight sim team around as that org's sacrificial lamb to be laid off.
- rburhum 4y agoI worked on this product for a year back in the day. The cool thing about MS ESP was that we used the FSX Engine for the "1000 foot experience". Everything looked great from far above, but not close by. The solution to this was that MS Train Simulator 2 made tons of improvements for the "1 foot experience". The idea was to include a "world editor" with world-wide geospatial data, too. https://youtu.be/GXzE1Yb54xU?t=406 https://youtu.be/GXzE1Yb54xU?t=406 The physics models of the planes and the trains were great, but obviously to be a generic simulator you needed to include physics engines for other types of objects like Cars. So we grabbed the physics engine of Forza and included it there. These things combined were honestly beautiful - and add to that the backwards compatibility with all the 3rd party FSX plugins/adds ons. Bummer that this is exactly when the iPhone came out and the cloud-based strategies were taking over "classic" enterprise software. Re-org and bye bye FSX/TrainSim2/ESP. I had left before this happened, but was really a bummer not to see the full potential of ESP :-(
- M3L0NM4N 4y agoI play MSFS a lot with realistic add-on planes like the A32NX or the PMDG 737, even though the flight model isn't quite "as good" as XP or P3D, the visual dominance of MSFS adds so much to the immersion for me.
- mm007emko 4y agoWell, I honestly put flight modelling over graphics every single day. X-Plane 11 might not be as good as MSFS in terms of graphics but everything else (i.e. the really important things) is.
- M3L0NM4N 4y agoFor me, I am not a real pilot (yet) and can't really tell the difference in 99% of cases. Also, the fidelity of 3rd party addon planes in MSFS is just as good if not better than in XP.
- mm007emko 4y agoMaybe I should give it a try again, then.
- blt 4y agoI heard somewhere it can be counterproductive to learn stick and rudder skills in sim, that sim time is better spent learning how to use instruments, automation, fly complex procedures like DME arc, etc. So maybe the fidelity of aircraft system models (vs aerodynamics) is also really important?
- Macha 4y agoThere's some amount of the physical feedback you get in a real plane (from resistance in flight controls to actual physical sensation of the movement) is not something you can get without a lot more sophisticated sim setup than most people will have at home and then also as you mention the model of the flight characteristics not matching the real airplane
- tra3 4y agoI would love to learn about the software development side of the US military/industrial complex. I read the Pentagon Wars [0] last year and it was fascinating. Read Skunk Works a while back [1]. What I found really interesting about the Pentagon Wars, is how the incentives don't really parallel what I see in "normal businesses". I wonder if it's the same for software? Is there anything more recent with the focus on software? If not, I'd love to read more about the design/development/testing of hardware as well. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pentagon_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pentagon_Wars [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skunk_Works#cite_note-16 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skunk_Works#cite_note-16
- anewpersonality 4y ago> I would love to learn about the software development side of the US military/industrial complex. I read the Pentagon Wars [0] last year and it was fascinating. Read Skunk Works a while back [1]. Judging by Ghidra, America's Army and BRL-CAD, it's amateur hour over there.
- make3 4y agoare these bad? asking as someone who knows nothing of any of them
- ascagnel_ 4y agoAmerica's Army is one of a few video games the DoD has put out as recruitment tools. They're a little weird (both sides always see themselves as US troops, fighting an unspecified opposing force), but I'm not sure how successful they've been over the years. Another interesting one is what Bohemia Interactive does -- they develop and commercially release simulation-style shooters in the ArmA series, and they developed the original Operation Flashpoint back in the early 00s. But Bohemia also has a product they sell to armed services around the globe. It's gotten them in trouble before -- a few developers were detained in Greece while gathering reference material for the fictional island of Altis in Arma 3.
- codethief 4y agoFrom https://prepar3d.com/product-overview/ https://prepar3d.com/product-overview/ : > Prepar3D (pronounced “prepared”) is a visual simulation platform that allows users to create training scenarios across aviation, maritime and ground domains. Prepar3D engages users in immersive training through realistic environments.
- m0llusk 4y agoFor me the site slowed and then returned only database access errors. It seems they were not prepared.
- IceHegel 4y agoThis looks about as good as heavily modded battlefield 1942. That's not saying it's bad sim software, but its look is behind the times.
- t0mas88 4y agoIt's based on an old version of MS Flight Simulator from around 2009 or 2010 or so. The graphics aren't any worse than most multi-million dollar full flight simulators used for pilot training. Even better compared to some of the slightly older simulators.
- afterburner 4y agoThing about multi-million dollar full flight simulators used for pilot training is, I doubt they're as concerned about having the latest picture perfect beautiful graphics.
- kqr 4y agoThis is corroborated by research into training for expertise. Simulations don't need much visual fidelity to be useful. At no point do you need to be fooled into thinking you're doing the real thing. The important thing is that your mind and hands go through the right motions. (This is useful knowledge! I have trained system administrators with simulations that basically amount to pen-and-paper role-playing with some screenshots interspersed.)
- t0mas88 4y agoIndeed, in the older ones the graphics for any enroute flying are even completely missing. They'll by default get you into the clouds at 400 or 1000ft above ground level and come out at similar heights on landing. In between the front windows just turn white. That's fine for learning to fly a 737, by that time it doesn't matter much anymore. But for earlier training it's too easy, because in the real world partial visibility and light effects in clouds cause much more disorientation than zero visibility.
- choonway 4y ago
- akie 4y agoGoogle cache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:cKimjWe1lyoJ:https://www.prepar3d.com/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=de https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:cKimjW...
- gigatexal 4y agoNot to be used for fun? Aww dang it
- criticas 4y agoIf you've bought a license, who's going to know? "Developing Mission Scenarios" is indistinguishable from "Flying the Cessna under the Golden Gate Bridge". The question is more "Is it worth buying a Dev or Academic license"?
- gigatexal 4y agoI’ve not got an edu license :/ so a dev one is one I’d have to do
- fffobar 4y agoWith the successes of F-22/F-35, PAC/Patriot and HIMARS/M270 (each is an obvious top of the shelf product in its category) - is Lockheed now going after Boeing's professional flight simulator supremacy?
- gbraad 4y agoThey have flight simulator centers here in Beijing based on Prepar3d. Very impressive. My kids have flown a Cessna in those several times to teach them the basics.
- theYipster 4y agoWhen Microsoft shut down the old Flight Simulator development team and program (FS1 up to FS X, not including the new MSFS2020,) they licensed the commercial version of the platform to Lockheed Martin, who took over development and kept it going as Prepar3D. Lockheed's biggest contribution to the platform over their years of stewardship was to port the codebase to 64-bit and to modernize for DirectX 11. There is still a very rich library of add-on software for the old MSFS, including some very detailed simulations of airliners, that today are flown on Prepar3D. Since Lockheed Martin doesn't want to be seen as a video game company, the $60 license is an "academic license." However, this is what most people looking simply for a modernized FS X engine will buy for their home use.
- caycep 4y agoHow does it compare w/ the new MSFS, or the other big names w/ commercial "gaming" development efforts behind them, i.e. Xplane, DCS, etc?
- Macha 4y agoThe base game is very very sparse compared to newer offerings like XPlane or MSFS. Due to its long history of development it has some of the most well received third party aircraft add-ons, but be warned, these will cost more than the sim itself. If you want a video game, you should get the new MSFS. If you want something more realistic you should get P3D + third party aircraft for airliners or XPlane for GA aircraft (+ setup ortho scenery for XPlane), but much of the ecosystem is slowly releasing MSFS ports too. I am a little worried for what will happen to hobbyist flight sims after MSFS though. A large part of its appeal is the bing maps powered streaming of good terrain and other map features, and I suspect Microsoft won't maintain that forever. If they lose interest for a similar length as between FSX and Microsoft Flight or between Microsoft Flight and MSFS, that could be a bad time for the flight sim world if they've gotten too used to MSFS. --- If you do get into the P3D third party ecosystem, be warned that many of the developers are older hobbyists turned devs which have been in their own universe and so can have weird ideas from time to time. Like a support system that is a public forum where you must manually sign your real name at the end of each post or get banned (PMDG), or uploading the chrome username/password DB of suspected hackers based on a check for username (FlightSimLabs).
- stby 4y agoI think it should be noted that Prepar3D exists for 12 years now [1] and has been heavily used by flight sim enthusiasts after FSX development was stopped and before MSFS came to the market. It is somewhat unclear were exactly this is used for professional training. The US Air Force apparently uses it for their pilot training [2], and some sort of F-16 simulator seems to exist [3]. I assume their F-35 simulators are also based on Prepar3D. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Flight_Simulator#Lockheed_Martin_Prepar3D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Flight_Simulator#Loc... [2] https://youtu.be/NMLg7THwhAI?t=164 https://youtu.be/NMLg7THwhAI?t=164 [3] https://www.lockheedmartin.com/content/dam/lockheed-martin/rms/documents/training/LM-Product-Card-LM-Platform-Training-Provider.pdf https://www.lockheedmartin.com/content/dam/lockheed-martin/r...
- anarcticpuffin 4y agoI believe Perpar3D powers the Redbird simulators [1] some of which are accepted by the FAA as AATDs (Advanced Aviation Training Device), meaning they can be used for a portion of the training requirements for the Private Pilots Cerficate (often called a license), Instrument Rating, etc. I've trained using one and while they're not perfect, they do save you some money and time with certain procedures. They're also great for more accurately simulating subtle systems failures. [1] https://simulators.redbirdflight.com/ https://simulators.redbirdflight.com/
- TimTheTinker 4y agoI'm pretty sure RedBird is based on X-Plane. I flew one a few weeks ago and the functionality was very familiar.
- stby 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if they supported both, but the pictures on their website all show Prepar3D.
- altgans 4y ago"Accurate topography with regionally and culturally appropriate textures" What does that mean?
- maxerickson 4y agoSpeculating, things like crops and building decorations (if they have 3d buildings anyway).
- KineticLensman 4y ago> culturally appropriate textures 'Culture' in the sense of human artefacts (buildings, etc) laid down on an underlying terrain. Such culture will be specific to particular regions of the world.
- _fat_santa 4y agoI would think things like roofs. If you're flying over Florida, make it "culturally appropriate" by making the roofs look like they are made of that tile rather than regular shingles. Edit: There's a Florida joke in there somewhere but I'm not going there.
- mmmpop 4y agoThat's no fun, especially when I don't really know where you're trying to go with this one?
- buildsjets 4y agoThey won't auto-generate thousands of replica KFC restaurants in rural Mongolia, as they did in Flight Sim 2004. If Google Image Search worked anymore, I'd link a screenshot. https://www.flightsim.com/vbfs/showthread.php?48720-Giant-chickens-on-the-move https://www.flightsim.com/vbfs/showthread.php?48720-Giant-ch...
- adolph 4y agoWht a fascinating EULA stipulation: Prepar3D is not to be used, offered, sold or distributed through markets or channels for use as a personal/consumer entertainment product. https://www.prepar3d.com/product-overview/prepar3d-license-comparison/ https://www.prepar3d.com/product-overview/prepar3d-license-c...
- jaywalk 4y agoLockheed Martin just doesn't want to be in the "video game" business. They'll still gladly take your money, though.
- iggldiggl 4y agoIt might possibly also have been one of the contract stipulations when Microsoft licensed the FSX code to Lockheed.
- kube-system 4y agoIts almost an obvious stipulation if you’re intending on continuing the franchise.
- jaywalk 4y agoDidn't even think about that angle, but it makes a lot of sense.
- joezydeco 4y agoFunny thing is... they used to be. https://segaretro.org/Lockheed_Martin https://segaretro.org/Lockheed_Martin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real3D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real3D
- Macha 4y agoMicrosoft sold off the rights to FSX to two parties. Lockheed got the rights to the "professional" version and Dovetail the rights to the "consumer" version. Same starting codebase, Lockheed released Prepar3d and Dovetail the somewhat successful Flight Simulator X Steam Edition and later the unsuccessful Flight Sim World. I'm sure this is a CYA clause to show they're not stepping on dovetail's license and little else.
- caycep 4y agoIt's the new new economy when "Lockheed Martin" features a YouTuber to promote its commercial military software...
- armchairhacker 4y agoSlightly off-tangent, but i really wish there was a good, freely available, decent-quality dataset of the world surface (like Google Earth but anyone can use it). I obviously don’t expect everywhere to be fully mapped but even popular cities like Boston don’t have very good models. And it would be amazing to even have models of some of the more rural places. It would make a great scene for games and animated movies. The world is a beautiful place and seeing places you’ve been is nostalgic.
- dewey 4y agoIt always makes me a bit sad to see how much time, energy and money is wasted on mapping and 3D modelling the same place over and over again and everyone accumulating all this data in their own silos. Google Maps, OSM, Apple Maps, Bing Maps and all the work that Microsoft Flight Simulator is doing by building 3D models of every airport and city from scratch. MS at least have a good way of utilizing Bing maps in the game and probably have data flowing both ways in case they improve something but seems like a giant waste of resources.
- somat 4y ago"Google Maps, OSM, Apple Maps, Bing Maps" One of these things is not like the others.
- mmaunder 4y agoI wonder if the NGIA might release their radar mapping of the Earths surface at some point. Kind of like the mapping databases available from the census dept.
- fortysixdegrees 4y agoSearch for SRTM DEM for global elevation data, and Microsoft building footprints for buildings. That will get you pretty close
- joezydeco 4y agoHere's a YouTube livestream where someone hooked up Prepar3D to an ADS-B receiver and created a virtual planespotting system at LAX: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t0GrpAgdBFI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t0GrpAgdBFI
- r212 4y agoThats so cool
- illwrks 4y agoThat's brilliant! It took me a few minutes to understand what I was looking at... realtime data, hooked into a flight sim, live streamed.
- joezydeco 4y agoIt seems like there's of potential for synthetic displays like this in other areas or industries - the buzzword du jour being "digital twin" but that's more for simulation, maybe this is more augmented reality? But you need a really solid set of incoming data to make it happen. The openness of ADS-B is the huge advantage here.
- mmaunder 4y agoOn a related note, Foreflight integrates really well with MSFS and when you combine that with PilotEdge it's a great learning tool. Works with Prepar and X-Plane too.
- t0mas88 4y agoYes, perfect for IFR and procedure training. The lack of control loading / feedback in home simulators makes it not a great choice for primary training. I've had to teach some simulator enthusiasts in real aircraft for primary training, there is a lot to unlearn. Especially in terms of trimming, fine gained control and looking outside. But for IFR training if you already know how it fly it's amazing what home sims can do. Add in Navigraph to get up to date data / procedures and Jeppesen charts and you get a better real world representation than some of the certified simulators used in flight training.
- johnohara 4y agoThe Warthog Project on YT is worth mentioning here as an example of what happens when passion meets technology. Been watching since the second vid. Never disappointed. [0] He uses Digital Combat Simulator (DCS) from Eagle Dynamics SA. They also sell commercial versions of their simulator software. [1] Getting the terrain right is one thing. Getting the cockpits right is another matter entirely. [2] [0] https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJq3cq9N6xYF0fAvTgpwoBg/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJq3cq9N6xYF0fAvTgpwoBg/vid... [1] https://www.digitalcombatsimulator.com/en/ https://www.digitalcombatsimulator.com/en/ [2] https://www.rferl.org/a/u-s-deports-russian-convicted-of-smuggling-f-16-manuals/30009039.html https://www.rferl.org/a/u-s-deports-russian-convicted-of-smu...
- dharmab 4y agoOther cool related resources are OpenHornet and /r/HotasDIY
- billfruit 4y agoDoes it have crash/collision physics?
- Macha 4y agoNo, most modern flight sims refuse to implement them because they don't want to be branded a 9/11 simulator when someone would inevitably make a youtube video of them crashing into buildings. Also the ones that use real planes have licensing from manufacturers to deal with, who don't want their planes portrayed being destroyed (similar to limited damage modelling in modern driving games with licensed cars). You'll want a combat sim.
- choonway 4y agoit’s not implemented because it’s a lot of work and doesn’t add to training value. The time would be better spent on improving damage models
- Aspos 4y agoDoes anyone have experience with its API? I use Microsoft AirSim for drone simulations, but it lacks fixed-wing aircraft physics. Having skimmed through Prepar3D SDK docs it is not clear if I can get images from the engine, not sure if it is possible to control aircraft from external code. Does anyone know if it is possible?
- metadat 4y agoIs there a way to run a demo version or otherwise try this out to make sure I want it before buying a full-fledged license? On a related note- Recent HN submission covering Geo-FS: a free, web-based, global satellite imagery flight simulator https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30345760 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30345760
- gamedna 4y agoAm I missing something - what exactly makes this HN worthy? AFAIK Prepar3d has been around for a long time, and the headline is from 2021.