12 ms·
Assassin’s Creed Liberation delisted, unplayable even to owners starting Sept 1
- zac23or 4y agoThat's theft. The theft pure and simple, ancient, which has been around forever. Nothing new.
- shbooms 4y agoUnfortunately, per Steam's TOS, you do not own anything you "purchase" on their platform. Instead you "subscribe" to access of whatever games/other content you've paid for: ...the rights to access and/or use any Content and Services accessible through Steam are referred to in this Agreement as "Subscriptions." ... The Content and Services are licensed, not sold. Your license confers no title or ownership in the Content and Services. https://store.steampowered.com/subscriber_agreement https://store.steampowered.com/subscriber_agreement To me, that's their business if they want to operate that way and folks can choose to accept that and be a customer if they so desire. I think what's really wrong is that nowhere on their store pages do they use the word "Subscription" and instead they use the word "Purchase". This should not be allowed and is false advertising, plain and simple.
- zac23or 4y ago> I think what's really wrong is that nowhere on their store pages do they use the word "Subscription" and instead they use the word "Purchase". Perfect. > This should not be allowed and is false advertising The result of false advertising is theft.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- blibble 4y agothe terms of service don't override the law the consumer rights directive in the Uk/EU specifically states remedy (i.e.: refund) if vendors remove features from a purchased digital service
- shbooms 4y agoagreed, I didn't mean to imply that they did. merely that this is something that is inherent to Steam's platform meaning they as much a part of the problem as the publisher here
- shakna 4y agoBut also note that the limitation of liabilities section does not apply to UK, EU, Australian or New Zealand customers. For example, the statement on Australia: > FOR AUSTRALIAN SUBSCRIBERS, THIS SECTION 7 DOES NOT EXCLUDE, RESTRICT OR MODIFY THE APPLICATION OF ANY GUARANTEE, RIGHT OR REMEDY THAT CANNOT BE SO EXCLUDED, RESTRICTED OR MODIFIED, INCLUDING THOSE CONFERRED BY THE AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER LAW (ACL). UNDER THE ACL, GOODS COME WITH GUARANTEES INCLUDING A GUARANTEE THAT GOODS ARE OF ACCEPTABLE QUALITY. IF THERE IS A FAILURE OF THIS GUARANTEE, YOU ARE ENTITLED TO A REMEDY (WHICH MAY INCLUDE HAVING THE GOODS REPAIRED OR REPLACED OR A REFUND). IF A REPAIR OR REPLACEMENT CANNOT BE PROVIDED OR THERE IS A MAJOR FAILURE, YOU ARE ENTITLED TO A REFUND. Which means that removing access to the purchased item, does in fact entitle you to a refund.
- nightski 4y agoI understand one does not own the game as that entitles the user to additional rights. But I feel like the user should own the license and they should not be able to revoke your ability to download/play it barring they go out of business or something.
- chris_wot 4y agoWhat, an unending subscription? If they want to end the subscription, then they can refund the person.
- gruez 4y agoUnless your definition of "theft" is a very expansive one that covers everything from swiping something from a store to downloading movies, the act that ubisoft is doing really isn't comparable to anything that's "ancient, which has been around forever". Back in the "ancient" world there certainly wasn't pieces of software running on networked turing machines that required authentication servers to function. The closest analogy would be some sort of widget that required a proprietary input from the manufacturer to continue functioning (eg. a car that required OEM blinker fluid to work). The manufacturer refusing to provide such inputs to the end user would definitely be something that negatively affects the end user and might even be a tort and/or run afoul of anti-consumer laws, but it's certainly not comparable to someone breaking into your house and making off with your car. You still have the original physical disk and/or bits, after all.
- zac23or 4y agoIf you SOLD something and somehow REMOVE or the ability to use it, it's theft. Whether it's done using modern technology (software) or old technology (crowbar) is not important.
- gruez 4y ago>Whether it's done using modern technology (software) or old technology (crowbar) is not important Even if you equate taking down DRM servers with breaking into someone's house and using a crowbar to break their widget, that's still a different crime than theft.
- Thiez 4y agoSo if it turns out that your car dealer can remotely disable your car and they announce that starting September 1st, you will no longer be able to start it. You would not consider that theft? In this scenario it would also be very difficult and/or illegal to circumvent the disable-mechanism.
- gruez 4y ago
- yomkippur 4y agoso there's no way to get a refund???!!
- layer8 4y agoMaybe with more punctuation there will.
- jrh206 4y agoWhy?
- hatsuseno 4y agoPublisher is financially incentivized to kill the servers, maintenance, and bugfix time for this title since single purchase licenses and long term online infrastructure requirements are financially incompatible.
- tomc1985 4y agoThere is a whole single-player game in there that doesn't need online connectivity.
- toyg 4y agoAh, but if you're playing offline, obviously you're a filthy pirate.
- goosedragons 4y agoYeah. It's bizzare and insanely cheap of Ubisoft to not at least patch the game to work single player offline for people that already bought the game. I'm pretty sure my older Vita cartridge of Liberation will keep on trucking too...
- pseudalopex 4y agoUbisoft will disable online services and paid DLC for other games too.[1] [1] https://www.techspot.com/news/95177-ubisoft-disable-online-features-15-games-gamers-lose.html https://www.techspot.com/news/95177-ubisoft-disable-online-f...
- glotchimo 4y ago> To play the solo campaign, you will have to set your console into offline mode. I’d like to think this would be an easy patch to at least let people down easy, but I don’t know much if anything at all in this context. Why couldn’t they just release an “flick a switch off” update? And why would this be required in the first place?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoEh, I wanna say money. You gotta pay someone to get that patch working. And then tested. And testing, based on my limited experience, invariably creates unexpected issues and costs money companies are not willing to part with. I initially wanted to say it is a little cynical, but I am starting to think it is just fiscal prudence ( and customer can stuff itself really ).
- yomkippur 4y agothink their office in Quebec is losing talent too after they enacted that bill mandating French language. English speaking engineers are leaving Montreal.
- mikl 4y agoIs this even legal everywhere? Can they just pull the game people had paid for, without providing a refund in countries with consumer protection laws?
- oblak 4y agoEA has been routinely shutting down game servers for almost 20 years now. Legal or not, I cannot say. In any cause, the usual targets seem to be games with annual releases. Apparently, people love buying the same games over and over. While it sucks, this is clearly not on the same level as Blizzard shutting down StarCraft battle-net servers. Lots of people would be rightfully furious.
- pseudalopex 4y agoShutting down servers is 1 thing. Breaking the single player game is another.
- oblak 4y agoYour biases may be showing here. I think shutting down servers is just as bad as removing single player games from people's libraries. The end result is quite the same for the customers: they can no longer use the products they paid for. In my case, the last Ubi game I purches, and played, was released back in 2003. Hopefully that clears my stance on this particular company
- zamalek 4y agoAs someone who does not enjoy single player games, I don't think this is bias. There is no functional reason for a server for a single player game. There is no reason for Ubisoft to have to make these cost-cutting moves in the first place. It's bringing an inherent disadvantage of closed multi-player games to single player games.
- the_af 4y agoGame servers require a cost to operate (in money and people) and I don't expect them to stay up forever. What's the excuse for forcibly shutting down the single player experience though?
- bnj 4y agoIf platform licensing arrangements don’t protect customers from losing access to purchases, they should be forced to advertise them as rentals or leases and not something the consumer is buying.
- Shadonototra 4y agoFrance tried https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2019-09-19-french-court-rules-countrys-steam-users-can-resell-their-games https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2019-09-19-french-cou... Then steam said you don't own the games they are selling to you So you buy games that you don't really own with a 30% tax on the developer's paycheck on top of his local taxes, thanks Valve!
- convolvatron 4y agoits really puzzling how a technology so perfect for lowering cost of entry and promoting disintermediation has done the exact opposite.
- tuxie_ 4y agoThe tech did its part, the costs are lower, just that the margins of profit are much bigger now.
- bobthepanda 4y agoIf anything it promotes centralization. Steam is a one stop shop for buying games that you can access globally, for the most part. Before if you wanted to buy games you had to show up in person, so competition between corporations and mom and pops was limited to what a corporation was willing to spend on capex and staff for a new store. The internet destroyed that need and so now the costs of corporations to compete with more efficient services due to economies of scale is very low.
- j_4 4y agoI don't get it. Steam has a near-zero cost of entry and provides massive disintermediation. I'm a small indie dev and they gave me immense value. I'd never be able to make a living with this otherwise. I'd love if they lowered their cut but as things are, no one even seems to be trying to seriously compete with them. All consoles and all other PC distribution platforms seem hell bent on hand curation through human intermediaries, which often comes down to rubbing elbows with the right people / impressing arbiters rather than just letting customers judge. Even itch.io does this for the promotion / discoverability part. Mobile has a slew of its own problems but gets this basic thing right, too.
- choward 4y agoThey keep using this word "own" throughout the article. I do not think it means what they think it means.
- zbird 4y agoIndeed. They will learn the real meaning soon enough.
- rvz 4y agoYou will own nothing and you will be happy. All your digital games gone like I said before. [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31970488 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31970488
- sergiotapia 4y agoThis is why I purchase all of my games physical. Edit: To clarify I have stopped buying any big titles on PC. I may splurge $2-5 on a key site but that's about it. I own console games because I want to leave my grandkids something.
- josephcsible 4y agoThat doesn't help though. Consider the Orange Box (HL2, TF2, and Portal). You could buy this on DVDs from a brick-and-mortar store, but playing it required you to set up a Steam account and activate it there.
- nibbleshifter 4y agoI distinctly recall buying HL2 from a store named "Game" shortly after release, only to find it required some shit called Steam, and the Steam key had already been redeemed. Eventually got a working key after returning to the store and complaining vigorously, and then had to wait approximately a million hours for the game to update itself over our shit tier dialup connection and eventually become playable.
- brians 4y agoThat’s a good start! But it doesn’t always help; I have plenty of physical copies of games that won’t work without Ubisoft servers.
- scoot 4y agoIf only it were that simple. A physical DVD simply reduces the download time. It typically still copies onto the console HD (the DVD being used as an annoying proof of ownership.), and still depends on online services.
- trentnix 4y agoDoes it? I had an 80+ GB practically-day-one-download waiting when I bought Forza Horizon 5 for my XBox. The disc might as well have been a blank.
- Shadonototra 4y agolooks like there are some people at ubisoft willing to do everything to lower the stock price looks like they'll get purchased soon, microsoft behind the scene perhaps?
- tomc1985 4y agoI think this is unprecendented with Steam. I have heard of games being delisted but I can't recall Valve ever removing them from peoples' libraries. If I owned a copy of this game on Steam I'd be requesting a refund immediately; they have been known to make exceptions to the standard 2-hours rule under special circumstances. Also, Steam has a game files backup feature, it might be a good idea to use that and wait for someone to figure out how to disable Steam DRM
- Shank 4y agoIt's not Steam's DRM -- the game relies on a server system hosted by Ubisoft, which is being shut down on September 1st. You'll still technically be able to download and execute the game binary on Steam but it won't connect and won't let you in to actually play.
- LegitShady 4y agoits not steam, its ubisoft DRM servers
- smileybarry 4y agoThis is almost definitely because Ubisoft shipped this with some SecuROM-alike DRM and doesn’t want to keep paying pennies for activation servers. If we’re lucky, they probably even opted out of offline machine keys (because “piracy”) so that the game will stop running because reactivation will fail.
- tomc1985 4y agoHmm, I have AC: Black Flag and I thought it worked fine offline. I will have to check now, because that game isn't much newer than this.
- account42 4y agoThey don't even need to keep paying for those activation services if they don't want to. Not when other nice people have already created a version of the game that does not rely on those services which Ubisoft could simply distribute https://www.bit-tech.net/news/gaming/ubisoft-uses-reloaded-crack-as-patch/1/ https://www.bit-tech.net/news/gaming/ubisoft-uses-reloaded-c...
- ConstantVigil 4y agoWhat will likely end up happening is the more dedicated fans of the series will do what others have done with old MMO's and make their own servers and such to ensure the game stays playable. There may be some legal issues, but once Ubisoft does this on Sep. 1st, there are some technicalities surrounding vaporware and such that make it legal to 'own' the game without ever paying for it, etc and so forth. Running servers to make it playable again as well would also be fair-game as well as I understand it. But I am not a lawyer, so if anyone knows better please by all means say so; but keep in mind I speak from the Canadian side of the law. So there may be differences that matter.
- the_af 4y agoNote this move, crappy as it is, wouldn't turn the game into "vaporware". I think you actually mean "abandonware". But it wouldn't, either. I was part of the abandonware community for decades -- ah, good old Home of the Underdogs -- and the sad reality is that abandonware is not a legal term, and the legal owners of games long abandoned and forgotten are sometimes petty enough to actively prevent them from being made available or playable again. It must also be said that other authors and publishers kindly make them available for free, or at least don't interfere with preservation efforts. But abandonware, as such, is not a legal thing and nobody is entitled to playing abandoned games :(
- makeitdouble 4y agoYes. From the other side of the table, there's always an option to rerelease a game as an emulated version for instance. They don't even have to do it themselves, they can just license the IP to companies willing to take the risk. So the rights holder have no incentive to ever declare it "abandonware" nor give up on the IP, and rights last long enough that ignoring them for decades isn't enough to make them worthless.
- ConstantVigil 4y agoYes, I meant Abandonware, thanks. Sorry about that. Hmm... I could have sworn it was legal; but it looks like it's only legal once the copyright expires and nothing prior like failure to support... Even then, all they have to do is do what Nintendo did with the e-shop. That said, I think there is legal grounds to take these kinds of scenarios into court to attempt to get the laws changed. Maybe not in past decades, but the current situation with digital goods basically requires that abandonware be legal; lest we are just going to roll over and give in to these companies that only care about profits solely and only. Yes, profits are important; but so is repaying your fanbase for their loyalty. They might not be able to keep these games running forever, but that shouldn't stop people from being able to do it for themselves. That's my nickels worth on this matter.
- keyle 4y agoWhat annoys me about this the most is the message from Steam, that sort of plays along with this. "This game is no longer available for sale on Steam". No big deal, right. Ok, fine, but it doesn't imply the servers going down and the title becoming unplayable... Then 2nd message: "Please note this title won't be accessible from <date>..." Once again, accessible doesn't imply "the game won't start, thanks for the monies". It's a bloody shame that I can start any games from the 90s on an emulator and they run just as fine, even content heavy. While these titles are completely riddled with DRM and screw you over after X years. Publishers need to come clean, and after years of milking the cow, they must have a plan allowing paying customers to play the title they've been enjoying all these years. Otherwise, they should be forced to include the verbiage at release date "This title will stop working as of <date in the future>". This kind of nonsense only promotes cracked games.
- Victerius 4y agoGames were already cracked before companies like Valve started pulling them from players' libraries. If games are cracked anyway, why would studios and publishers care one way or another?
- the_af 4y agoI think in many cases, movies and video games piracy is a matter of convenience. If pirated media is more convenient -- not just as in "free", but because it's less encumbered and doesn't pull this crap on you -- then paying for legal media will become less appealing. There's a baseline of piracy, sure, but there's also making the lives of paying customers more difficult so that piracy becomes the preferred option.
- jquery 4y agoExactly. Steam is more convenient than manually maintaining a large gaming library and keeping it up to date, and collecting titles on sale. However if it develops a reputation of killing games once a publisher decides to (???), the value-add is greatly reduced. I have a probabilistic expectation that my Steam library will work ten years from now, and stuff like this GREATLY reduces my estimation of the probability.
- everdrive 4y agoDon't buy Ubisoft games, clearly. Games which require servers to work at all (vs. just the mulitplayer components working) are also a big no. This is likely a good thing: it will educate gamers about unnecessary DRM.
- zamalek 4y agoI stopped after the first Denuvo saga. I am so glad that I did. GoG remains my first stop for buying games, Steam a very cautious second.
- cubesnooper 4y agoUbisoft actually sells some DRM‐free games on GOG—the first Assassin’s Creed, Far Cry 1 and 2, Rayman Origins (but not Rayman Legends). If you have disk space to spare, I would recommend downloading GOG’s offline installers as a backup. The risk of the service disappearing or games you’ve bought being removed seems pretty low, but DRM‐free offline installers are just as good as the classic “physical copy,” provided you actually saved them!
- account42 4y ago> DRM‐free offline installers are just as good as the classic “physical copy,” provided you actually saved them! Better even as the classic physical copies often had DRM to prevent you from making backups. Not that there weren't workarounds but still, being able to just back them up like any other file is better in my book. Unfortunately the "if you have disk space" part is not always irrelevant. Would be nicer if we could share that backup space by chunking up the installers into blocks and then advertise via a distributed table of hashes who has which blocks available. Ideally we'd also have a protocol to let these blocks of bits flow from those that have them to those that need them.
- dreamcompiler 4y agoExactly this. I try to avoid any software that requires an internet connection to work or continue working, unless an internet connection is obviously necessary. Taking perfectly good software and ruining it by making an internet connection mandatory for DRM purposes does not constitute "obviously necessary." Looking at you Microsoft Office, Quickbooks, and every Adobe product.
- lousken 4y agoThat's why games like these should have dedicated servers as an option. Why is this acceptable in the cloud era where everyone can spin up their own server for a few bucks?
- cmckn 4y agoI think it's a nice idea, but it just won't happen. The game companies won't offer managed game servers, because it's a totally new, small-market line of business outside their core competency. They won't open-source the server and let users run it themselves, because myriad licensing/IP/legalese reasons. Even if they did open source it, the stack likely isn't designed to scale down to a few bucks a month on the public cloud -- most users interested in running their own server wouldn't be happy with the actual cost of doing so. The handful of folks willing to pay for it won't move the needle.
- josephcsible 4y agoYou make it sound like this is a hard problem that studios don't know how to solve, but it's been solved for decades. There's still a bunch of third-party Quake III Arena servers you can play on, for example.
- cmckn 4y agoSelling managed software is definitely a hard problem that game studios don’t have expertise in. It’s cool that the community reverse engineered Quake’s server, but that doesn’t mean it’s trivial for all studios to offer server software for their titles. Implementation aside, I think it’s primarily a money thing—the studios don’t care about this because the numbers say they shouldn’t.
- rasz 4y agoThere are third party Quake 3 servers because it _was_ trivial for the studio to offer server software for their title.
- 4y ago
- toyg 4y agoThere should be a law: if you sell an entertainment experience with significant online elements, and you shut down such elements, you should be forced to opensource the server. Just like that, dump the code wholesale on the internet somewhere.
- Victerius 4y agoSource code is often reused in other products. Corporate studios would balk.
- toyg 4y agoAnd? They'd figure it out. Millions of businesses have to deal with changes in law every day. In fact, there is a good chance this would result in standardising the most basic aspects of online activity (license checks etc) into free opensource libraries, saving such corporations a decent amount of money in the long run.
- josephcsible 4y agoWe'd need a way to handle all of the companies who'd say "oops we lost the source".
- pseudalopex 4y agoEscrow.
- Yoofie 4y agoTheir incompetence should not be an excuse to avoid or skirt the law. If they lose it, they should be fined or penalized. Once they start bleeding money, I guarantee that this problem will go away.
- the_biot 4y agoNo, there should not be a law that forces anyone to give away their property. That's just complete nonsense. You should draw your own conclusion as to what you spend your money on, and possibly you might conclude that "buying" online games that can be taken away from you at any time is a waste of money. But you can't go from there to "we must take away intellectual property from these capitalist swine!".
- dbetteridge 4y agohttps://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/full-federal-court-confirms-that-valve-misled-gamers https://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/full-federal-court-con... Sounds illegal if anyone is based in Australia and feels like giving the ACCC a nudge. “This case sets an important precedent that overseas-based companies that sell to Australians must abide by our law. All goods come with automatic consumer guarantees that they are of acceptable quality and fit for the purpose for which they were sold, even if the business is based overseas,”
- Apocryphon 4y agoHm, sounds as ironic as when Amazon was taking away ebook copies of 1984.
- toyg 4y agoRMS had predicted all this, as usual.
- sylware 4y agoWe know ubisoft has been a sidekick of microsoft (in my country they are the same ppl). But removing that big game from PC, very weird: maybe they don't want to maintain technically the game anymore, or go to epic.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chrysoprace 4y agoWouldn't be surprised if the ACCC (Australian Competition & Consumer Commission) went after them. This is almost certainly breaking the ACL, and all customers would be eligible for a refund.
- smileybarry 4y ago> Do note that this doesn’t appear to be affecting the Remastered rerelease, though keep in mind that would require an additional purchase as the original release does not grant you access to it. Ah, great. So poor little Ubisoft doesn’t want to pay for the activation servers of Liberation HD and Liberation HD++. How nice of them to drop just the older, original version and not even offer the working remastered version to existing owners.
- lelandfe 4y ago> not even offer the working remastered version to existing owners I can't believe they're not doing this. The remastered version is frequently on sale for just $20, and revoking access is clearly a PR nightmare. If Ubisoft so dearly needs to shut down these servers, why not just gift existing owners the upgrade?
- toyg 4y agoProbably because the cost of the PR nightmare is either not easily quantifiable, or simply an acceptable loss; wheras the potential "forced profits" by people having to buy the remaster are fairly easy to predict.
- Jiro 4y agoBecause if they do, the next time they sell a remastered anything, people will think "I don't need to buy this because I'll get it anyway when the servers for the original version run out," costing them sales.
- account42 4y agoYou clearly overestimate the average gamer's patience.
- usrusr 4y agoBut that PR fallout hits Valve much harder than Ubisoft, because unlike Ubisoft Valve still has a reputation to lose. That reputation is the main source of the stranglehold Valve is holding the entirety of PC publishers in (except Blizzard). They might in fact consider the PR nightmare a positive side-effect of shutting down, leveling the playing field.
- olodus 4y agoWhen something like this happens they should be required to hand over the server software. Even better would be to have to open source the code but atleast give out the server. Then the company would have a choice; either you pay for the server but can keep the game harder locked down for Intellectual property reason or whatever. Or you can cut the server cost but risk loosing a bit of your control over it.
- alexklarjr 4y agopffft, just download it from torrent, as you do for any abandonware and Nintendo games, it had been cracked for 10 years, what you are expecting, windows backward compatibility or respecting your rights by Steam, created by former Micro$oft employee?
- the_af 4y ago> "This is yet another reason why owning digital games is frowned upon by some consumer groups, as you technically never own the game themselves given this thing can happen." I think things like GOG or Humble Bundle are better, because they don't "phone home" when you try to play games you bought there (unless, of course, they are actually Steam keys). They could get delisted, but if you backed up the game you can still play it. That said: what a crappy situation. Are they at least giving the money back to customers?
- donatj 4y agoGiven how decent a company Valve is, and the rules they put on things for sale in their store, I'm honestly surprised that Valve even has store terms that allow this kind of shenanigans. If I was them I would lock that down, because this is a bad look.
- jimbob45 4y agoValve tends to be pretty decent. If I had to guess, it’s cheaper and easier for them to say “yes” and let public opinion turn that into a no than to say no being the scenes and have to dicker with Ubi lawyers.
- smoldesu 4y agoValve's rules are pretty permissive, all-in-all. And like many other people in this thread have already pointed out, many digital-only games can't ever truly be "owned". You're given a license, and that license is subject to terms that you agree to when you use it. It sucks, but this is the path we chose when we decided that software should be a proprietary production.
- MikusR 4y agoSteams refund policy is the result of a lawsuit.
- CursedUrn 4y agoUbisoft seems like an outlier on Steam. The way many of their games just launch UPlay, which then does its own downloading and ownership check is very strange and awkward.
- wincy 4y agoLuckily there’s a SKIDROW release. 2.85GB ISO that’ll work until the end of time and nobody can turn it off.
- zbird 4y agoIf only we could pay the original publisher/developer for a DRM-free version of the game, that would be revolutionary.
- zac23or 4y agoAnd that's how regulations are born.
- stubish 4y agoBetter article at https://www.techspot.com/news/95177-ubisoft-disable-online-features-15-games-gamers-lose.html https://www.techspot.com/news/95177-ubisoft-disable-online-f... , which tells us it is 15 games (not one) and Ubisoft's end (affecting all delivery mechanisms including physical, not just Steam/Valve) Personally, I stopped buying Ubisoft games years ago, because a month of their subscription service is cheaper than their games even at 75% off sales, and actually owning the game means nothing as this article demonstrates. I'm not sure how this business model is sustainable.
- 3np 4y agoThat article only mentions multiplayer and DLC to become inaccessible, while OP is about the single-player game being unplayable. Not clear if that's the only one of the 15 titles or not. > Space Junkies is a notable outlier, as it launched three years ago. It's a multiplayer-only VR game, and for some reason, Ubisoft is still selling it (for as much as $20) without even mentioning that it will become completely unplayable in two months. Wow.
- jmyeet 4y agoThis will only ever change if actions like these affect the sales of future titles. But like many things most people just don't care. It's kind of shocking this happening with a 10 year old game. This whole online required for a single player game (because piracy) is really ridiculous. So many dumb things are done with DRM and the like because of "piracy". Remember DVD regions? The unskippable FBI warning? DVD "encryption"? After 5-10 years games should just go DRM and server free. Not sure how we can enforce that without materially affecting sales however.
- SpaceManNabs 4y agostuff like this is why i sometimes still buy physical games. ofc nothing stops people from just disabling the reading of the disc from the software side if not connected to internet or wtv. buying discs is only going to be slightly more "own your stuff"
- giancarlostoro 4y agoWhy bother buying a single game from this game publisher / developer? That's my takeaway.
- robertwt7 4y agocan't they be sued for this? don't we all own our rights once we bought it? unless if it is listed somewhere in steam's terms and agreements when we purchase the game. If so, then this is totally messed up, knowing that I have 300+ games on steam that can be removed one day without my consent. Even after I purchase it with my own money. Insane
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoI think there's a lot of valid crossover between this situation and the one recently discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32010317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32010317 (Playstation Store removes Studiocanal movies, no refunds offered)
- crooked-v 4y agoWhile I doubt many people would take a day off work to do so, this seems like it would be an easy case to take to small claims court in most parts of the US to force a full refund.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoThere is also a small claims procedure in the EU for these kind of things: https://europa.eu/youreurope/business/dealing-with-customers/solving-disputes/european-small-claims-procedure/index_en.htm https://europa.eu/youreurope/business/dealing-with-customers...
- CHB0403085482 4y agoThat's why I always get discs. Oh wait... https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2022/07/god-of-war-ragnaroks-priciest-bundles-dont-include-physical-game-discs/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2022/07/god-of-war-ragnaroks-...
- jquery 4y agoI just requested a steam refund, to try and send a message. I have no playtime, I bought it on sale for $5, but this is gross. I will stop “buying” steam games entirely if this starts happening on a regular basis. Update: that was fast, my refund request was rejected because it has been “more than 2 weeks since my purchase”. I opened a new refund request with much more pointed language and told them it’ll be the most expensive $5 they ever stole. I’m fit to sue over this, it’s not even about the money. I have a large steam library and I do not want them to get away with this.
- 3np 4y agoDo keep us updated! I guess you're in the US? (Judging from the use of $ and suing being the next step of escalation) Would be interesting if individuals with Steam accounts in EU/UK/AU who "bought" the game and request a refund also report their experience, considering the differences in consumer protection.
- jquery 4y agoGot my refund rejected a second time. Customer support nonexistent, got the same rejection reason. Grr. Anyone else have a different experience?
- lakomen 4y agoNo. It's an automated response. You will have to go the legal way or divert public attention toward your case somehow. A friend of mine got a permanent ban on Steam for asking a gender question. It was the last of many bans, most unjustified and ridiculous. Steam is not your friendly platform. It's hostile to customers. If you're positive you're correct and can afford the trouble and cost go the legal route.
- account42 4y agoI don't think they even read what you write for the refund request if its outside of their policy. Either that or they are OK with losing over 1000 EUR in sales and counting over a 7 EUR refund and never bother to respond with anything that doesn't look like an automated message.
- zbird 4y agoAnd this is the reason why I buy DRM-free on GOG. I always check GOG for games before Steam.
- muzani 4y agoA lot of people blame Steam, but I'm willing to accept this risk. I didn't buy games before Humble Bundle and Steam, and if it all collapses, I'd probably pirate it somewhere or get it off sites similar to Home of the Underdogs. The licensing allows them to do things like this, but frankly, the odds of it happening is extremely low, like 1 in a thousand, and the lower prices make up for the risk.
- UberFly 4y agoAs sucky as this is, I still prefer the Steam model (and the chance of something like this happening) over a bunch of dusty disks and trying to find the latest patch on some sketchy website.
- dusted 4y agoAnd this is why we need finished products that does not require Internet access, on physical media.
- lemoncookiechip 4y agoFor the people blaming Steam here in the comments. This is an Ubisoft title, meaning, Steam is just a glorified launcher for Uplay which then launches the game itself. The only fault Steam has in this, is not being clearer in the store front (which is still Ubisoft editing). Ubisoft is the one not providing refunds. Ubisoft is the one shutting down online servers. Ubisoft is the one who asked for it to be delisted. There's a lot of things to be angry for against Steam, but this isn't it.
- trumpablehump 4y agoSteam should not allow such schemes to be sold in their store.
- int0x20 4y agoBut I'm buying from/through Steam and expect that refunds will be handled by them as well
- breadloaf 4y agoGame can't run without a server and server owner decided to shut them down? Then game is a defective product and customer is eligible for full refund of the game. Those servers will be running forever or should not be necessary at all.
- vntok 4y agoLol no that's not how it works. Imposing a company to maintain expensive equipment forever in echange for a ~$60 one-shot payment is crazy.
- timwaagh 4y agoSteam should simply disallow this. People invest thousands into a games collection. Having games become inaccessible is not acceptable. If they do not and this becomes the norm nobody will even bother with Steam anymore. People will just move to gamepass and other cheaper platforms that do not give the consumer any sense that they own games. I'll be trying to move to gog a bit more because of this, but my Steam collection is big.
- Lutzb 4y agoSomething similar happened with Rayman Jungle Run on Android Play Store. The license server is no longer running and as such the game cannot be started anymore. I took Ubisoft at least a year before they removed the software from Android Play Store. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.pastagames.ro1mobile https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.pastagames...
- okamiueru 4y agoThis seems like a what should be a non-issue, and good PR for very little effort. Push an update to steam where DRM has been disabled. Arguably DRM has only ever inconvenienced legitimate users. Explain the situation saying it has reached end of life, so DRM protections will be disabled. The developer/publisher gets this in return: - Good PR - No DRM server costs - Continued sale (/or make it PWYW and give proceeds to a cause).
- t0bia_s 4y agoOne of many reasons why I buy games excslusively on GoG. Btw, why is this game delisted?
- LocalH 4y agoIf this isn't just a huge miscommunication on the part of Steam and/or Ubisoft, then this is theft, plain and simple. When you pay for a specific product, the manufacturer should never have the legal right to unilaterally remove your access to that product. This isn't a subscription service, where the terms are different (and you're paying much less than you would have in this situation).
- idonotknowwhy 4y agoMight be available on a torrent site
- pdimitar 4y agoAs long as publishers pull crap like this, piracy will not only keep going. It will thrive and increase.
- roxaaaane 4y agoIt has been increasingly annoying to play video games nowadays, take the recent Call Of Duty releases, I don't like playing multi-player I just want to play the 3-4 hours campaign and yet to do that I need a Battle.net account and need to be online, also I can't just install the single player campaign I need Warzone. Ubisoft is also a hot pile of mess with their Ubisoft buggy client that constantly needs an internet connection.
- lakomen 4y agoWARNING: back button shenanigans
- lakomen 4y agoSteam has been evading responsibility for a very long time. Actively lobbying and smearing politicians and law people. The right to sell used games? They have paid a lot for this not to pass. 14 days of withdrawal not applying to games in the EU? Them. Not that Epic games is any better. I'm not buying games online anymore. I used to spend a lot when I had the income. It's a scam a scam that is covered up with dollar bills. Justicia is blind. In the EU you can buy everything if you have enough money. It goes without saying that the same is true in the US, but EU was supposed to be different, better. They're not. And Valve has bought laws and averted lawsuits with their monetary power.
- shyn3 4y agoWhen Rogers was down if you didn't have any games on disc your games wouldn't launch if you had them on gamepass for the series x. The industry is staring to make this normal.
- HelixEndeavor 4y agoYou don't own digital media unless it's 100% DRM-free and can be installed and used offline. I try always to buy my games from GOG if I can for this reason. Your GOG games will still work long after their service is dead. If they lose a license and have to pull a game from sale, so long as you have a backup, you can always install the game you bought from the original EXE. I back up my GOG games to CD, DVD, and BD discs for that retro flair and because they're a lot more difficult to accidentally delete.
- npteljes 4y agoIf they were cool, they'd release a patch that'd make the game DRM free, and then abandon it.
- MacroChip 4y agoWeb3 games will never be shut down (if properly decentralized). The "game server" is effectively pay-as-you-go. NFTs grafted on to web2 games is a start of player owned gaming, but true web3 games will be wholly player owned. These shutdowns (along with things like Diablo's Error 37 launch) are why gamers will gravitate to games they can't get rug pulled on.
- b3nji 4y agoRemember the days when you bought a PC game, it came in a beautiful box, with a nicely illustrated manual, and you owned it? Install the game, 20 minutes later you were off. Also, it was fun to find the bugs and found that sometimes they were useful in game. It's a shame people don't really own games nowadays, isn't it?
- vagab0nd 4y agoThis brings up an interesting question: What happens to games sold on Steam today, 10 years later? Will I still be able to play them on the latest OS then? If so, how would Steam implement it?