16 ms·
New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of police
- bediger4000 4y agoHow is this anything other than an attempt to keep people from collecting evidence of bad police behavior? Now that a large majority of people have a high quality video camera in their pockets, we've learned 2 things: (1) alien abduction was not real (2) police very deliberately kill members of racial minorities. I think this law is a reaction to (2).
- UIUC_06 4y ago
- elmerfud 4y agoYou need to read the law to understand it better and also understand the current rulings that courts have provided on filming police. This law is none of those things that you state it's simply codifying a distance for what the courts have already upheld that police can do. If you are party to the police interaction you can film closer than 8 ft. If you are in a car as a passenger you can film the interaction and the police cannot ask you to stop. If you are a non-party person simply watching the interaction the police can now ask you to maintain a distance of 8 ft. Courts have already upheld routinely that police can ask people who are not party to the interaction to step away and they can create a reasonable area around them and the scene and keep people out of it. The definition of reasonable area varies based upon the situation. This that a reasonable area is a minimum of 8 ft. There are situations where that distance may be greater. Regardless of what you think of the police they do need to be empowered to keep bystanders out of the middle of an interaction with their cameras in order to conduct their duties. 8 ft for a bystander is a very reasonable distance. At 8 ft your camera can see anything that a human-sized person is doing it to another human-sized person and it can record the audio of that interaction as well at 8 ft. And as always the person who is party to the interaction can record the interaction and this is codified in this law as well. Laws like this do more to uphold a citizens ability to record the police then it does to take it away. Any reasonable person would understand that because without a law like this the police could argue that 50 ft is a reasonable distance. Now we have a law that says 8 ft is a reasonable distance in Arizona.
- watwut 4y agoPolice can tell you to step away whether you are holding the camera or not. The thing this does is that people who are close to what is actually happening will be scared to take camera and start filming. And if they do, the cops will be able to harass them.
- account-5 4y agoThanks for the calm and reasonable response. Some of the comments here make me wonder how close people want to be to an ongoing incident? Inches? A foot? At a certain distance you're just in the way, 8 feet seems completely acceptable. Police are able to do their job without obstruction from onlookers, onlockers are close enough to see/record the police doing their job.
- staticassertion 4y agoAs close as I want to be, if it's a public space.
- account-5 4y agoMaybe you could get a piggyback from the cops while they're dealing with something?
- staticassertion 4y agoThat would be assault.
- plandis 4y agoThis law only serves to tell police how close they need to move towards people filming in order to get them to stop so their abuses can be done without being recorded.
- ksaj 4y agoI think an officer approaching you makes you party to the interaction. I wouldn't shut mine off in this case, and I'd happily face court if an officer approached me while simultaneously claiming I'm not party to the interaction. The officer's approach to my person is the only the interaction I'm videoing at that moment. Anything else is incidental.
- fortran77 4y agoPolice kill way too many people. Whether there's a racial motivation or basis behind that cannot usually be determined by selectively watching videos. And scholarly sources have published studies that show the answer is complicated: see https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01846-z https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01846-z and https://www.manhattan-institute.org/verbruggen-fatal-police-shootings https://www.manhattan-institute.org/verbruggen-fatal-police-... for two different takes on ths.
- recyclelater 4y agoThere are roughly 350 million people in this country. It’s surprising the number of people killed by police isn’t higher. Everyone contextualizes police shootings as if they all happen in their local city, so the numbers seem large. I want this number as small as possible while not over correcting so much that we have other negative consequences (violent crime increases).
- ivalm 4y agoPer capita we are (edit: #33) in the world and are an absolute leader among developed countries [0] [0] https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/police-killings-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/police-ki...
- delecti 4y agoWe're #7 by count, not per-capita. Per-capita we're #33 (scroll down to the chart sorted by "per 10m"). Though our per capita rate is still absurd compared to other developed countries. The next comparable country is Canada at 9.7, 1/3 as high.
- ivalm 4y agoYou’re right!
- recyclelater 4y ago
- ddingus 4y agoI DO NOT agree with the other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32046231 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32046231 deleted! And boy did I have this wrong!! (This comment has been edited to show the text, and where I was in error!) Here's the text: ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Fifty-fifth Legislature Second Regular Session House: APPROP DPA 7-5-0-1 HB 2319: law enforcement activity; recording prohibition Sponsor: Representative Kavanagh, LD 23 House Engrossed Overview Outlines regulations for a person making a video recording (recording) of a law enforcement activity (activity). History Provisions 1. States that it is unlawful for a person to knowingly make a recording within eight feet of an activity and without the permission of a law enforcement officer (LEO). (Sec. 1) 2. Directs that for an activity occurring inside a closed structure on private property, a person authorized to be on the private property may make a video recording of the activity from an adjacent room that is less than eight feet away from the activity. (Sec. 1) 3. States a person may not make a video recording of an activity from within eight feet of an activity inside a closed structure on private property if the LEO determines the person is interfering with the activity or that is it not safe to be in the area. (Sec. 1) 4. Provides that a person who is the subject of the police contact may make a recording if doing so does not interfere with lawful police actions. (Sec. 1) 5. Asserts these provisions do not establish a right or authorize any person to make a video recording of an activity. (Sec. 1) 6. Classifies unlawfully recording an activity as a petty offense. (Sec. 1) 7. Classifies failing to comply with LEO verbal warnings regarding recording an activity or if the person has been previously convicted of unlawfully recording an activity as a class 3 misdemeanor (Sec. 1) Statute prohibits a person from obstructing governmental operations. A person commits obstructing governmental operations when the person uses threats or violence to hinder a peace officer from enforcing the law or acting under official authority. This offense is classified as a class 1 misdemeanor (A.R.S. 13-2402). 8. Defines law enforcement activity. (Sec. 1) Prop 105 (45 votes) Prop 108 (40 votes) Emergency (40 votes) Initials FK Page 1 Fiscal Note HB 2319 House Engrossed >and without the permission of a law enforcement officer (LEO). (Sec. 1) That language is not in the stories talking about the bill, and said language is not in line with the First Amendment.
- mlyle 4y agoI'm not sure why you think this law explicitly allows people to be 8' away and film. Instead, it criminalizes being closer than 8' and filming, while not superseding other laws that could be used to harass or prevent recording. An explicit codification of the right to record and circumstances when it applies could be part of a decent compromise here, but this legislation isn't it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- markovbot 4y agoThis is pretty transparently a law to keep people from collecting evidence of bad police behavior. There's been entirely too much of that and people are starting to question the unaccountable armed gangs that roam our cities. To fix people noticing that this might be bad, Arizona is enacting laws to ensure the police can continue to brutalize without repercussions. It's unfortunate that this thread is full of bootlickers doing mental gymnastics to justify what is clearly an unjust law, but this is HN after all
- UIUC_06 4y ago> police very deliberately kill members of racial minorities This is an inflammatory statement which demands some evidence. "Very deliberately" implies a knowledge of police state of mind. Do you have such knowledge? AFAIK, studies of police shootings are pretty inconclusive in that respect. Do you have support for your statement?
- m348e912 4y agoThis is tricky since it delves into first amendment territory. I wonder if it may be overturned by a higher court.
- spacemanmatt 4y agoI used to have some faith in the consistency of the appeals circuits but it has become a farce in my lifetime
- elmerfud 4y agoThe original law it was proposed to be at 15 ft and they changed it to be 8 ft because of questions like this. Since courts have already upheld that police can keep non-party bystanders away from a scene at a reasonable distance codifying an 8 ft limit as a minimum reasonable distance is unlikely to be overturned by a court. Considering that police training routinely would keep people 20 to 25 ft away codifying this minimum distance at 8 ft is actually a big win and is probably closer than what courts would allow should it be challenged. It's also important to keep in mind that this distance does not apply to people who are party to the police interaction nor does it apply to passengers in a vehicle that are. It also does not apply to people in a house or a confined private space who are not a party to the police interaction. There are a great many exceptions to this if you actually read the law. Basically the 8-ft distance only applies to people who are not a party to the police interaction.
- mlyle 4y ago> Considering that police training routinely would keep people 20 to 25 ft away codifying this minimum distance at 8 ft is actually a big win " C. THIS SECTION DOES NOT ESTABLISH A RIGHT OR AUTHORIZE ANY PERSON TO MAKE A VIDEO RECORDING OF LAW ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY." So, police can still attempt to keep people 25' away, and use other laws, they just can't charge them with this new misdemeanor.
- woodruffw 4y ago> Considering that police training routinely would keep people 20 to 25 ft away codifying this minimum distance at 8 ft is actually a big win and is probably closer than what courts would allow should it be challenged. This says nothing of either the constitutionality or propriety of keeping people 25 feet away, instead using it to bootstrap other limitations. The police are trained to do all sorts of absurd and patently unconstitutional things; the fact of that matter isn’t strong support for a law that further enables them to do so.
- threatofrain 4y agoRecent conversation from 1-2 days ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32030229 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32030229 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32025858 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32025858
- lb1lf 4y agoThis sounds good; a citizen can now refer to The Law(tm) and keep filming any police encounter with the general population from a distance of 8ft. I enjoy yelling about abuse of power as much as the next guy, but from the looks of it, this law empowers the citizenry.
- Raed667 4y agountil the police starts charging at you and now you're under 8ft.
- elmerfud 4y agoIf the police begin to charge at you because you are recording you now become party to the police interaction and you can record under the 8-ft distance. I know on emotional issues like police interactions logic is hard to follow but logic is still a thing.
- etchalon 4y agoThe idea that the police will follow the letter of the law during an interaction seems naive given what we've seen of police behavior.
- macksd 4y agoLogic didn't seem to have been a thing in the Daniel Shaver shooting, which happened in this state. I thought the bodycam footage was a pretty clear illustration of a terrified and confused unarmed victim doing his best to follow unclear instructions being shot by a cop who, in the end, clearly had some facts wrong. And the cop was then acquitted, got re-hired and given a pension because he had a disabling case of PTSD from the incident. Imagine what a state like that could get away with if video wasn't even public, or how easily a cop could get away with intimidating people who are even 8+ feet away. I wouldn't be quick to trust this law if I lived in Arizona and tended to be harassed by police.
- BoorishBears 4y agoI would consider it barely logical to think the cop approaching you specifically so they can claim you're in the way of their operations and gain an excuse to stop your filming (https://youtu.be/VWHOz5sLk-c https://youtu.be/VWHOz5sLk-c https://youtu.be/L7lHeRBgs9U https://youtu.be/L7lHeRBgs9U https://youtu.be/HEL8CdV9HUQ https://youtu.be/HEL8CdV9HUQ) would suddenly stop because: "Whelp now they're a part of this police interaction [as I intended] so I should respect their rights [which me approaching them was an attempt to interfere with]" The current MO is: - Cop approaches someone recording - Proceed to apply psuedo-legal pressure because you're now "too close" to a cop (who approached you to begin). And you actually think that a law that replaces a murky step two with "You can't film within 8ft of us" is an upgrade? You actually think the cop informing you you can't film them will take the law they approached you to enforce as a reason to leave you alone? - There's something beautiful yet dangerously naive about the kind of people who have this much good faith in how police leverage the law. Sorry but even the "good cops" are not about to use the law to expand your rights.
- ck2 4y agoIs it so when you start recording them barking at your car window they can arrest you for recording less than 8 feet away? Because that would be insidious.
- spullara 4y agoIn the article it explains the law excludes things where you are involved in the police action, including vehicle stops. This is for uninvolved folks that are recording.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kepler1 4y agoI don't see this as the same knee-jerk "the police are being shielded from having their misdeeds recorded" as other people are jumping to do. If you look at some of the video of police trying to do their jobs and having screeching bystanders yelling at them, I am absolutely fine with this law being invoked to maintain police sanity and prevent things from escalating.
- alistairSH 4y agoIn the vast majority of cases recorded in the last two years, the escalation came from the side of the police, not the bystanders. If a police officer doesn’t like being yelled and recording while beating protestors or murdering minor criminals, perhaps they need to find other employment.
- OrvalWintermute 4y ago> In the vast majority of cases recorded in the last two years, the escalation came from the side of the police, not the bystanders please provide some data to back up this claim.
- kepler1 4y agoAs I said in another comment, you sound like you feed on turning 0.001% exceptions into the rule. Almost all police in this country are not beating protestors or murdering people. I don't want to have a system where someone's extreme (though yes, bad case) sets the way we handle everything. Is your approach to solve for the 0.001% problem and care nothing about the rest of the 99.999% situations where the rule you put in place will have to be lived with by everyone else?
- fzeroracer 4y agoHere's a thought experiment for you: I want you to watch the video of the Daniel Shaver shooting in Arizona. Then I want you to consider the outcome of the extreme police violence cases vs the extreme cases of bystander escalation. The only thing that stops the police from getting away with violence is the fact that people are recording them. And even then, the police can execute an innocent and unarmed individual and get acquitted by court.
- social_quotient 4y agoSo if LEO walks to your window for a traffic stop you can’t film it with your cell phone from the dash?
- lettergram 4y agoMy understanding is you can film as party involved in the interaction. This is about onlookers (who often insert themselves into the situation making it more dangerous for everyone).
- lr4444lr 4y agoNo, that's excepted, since you are the subject of his stop, unless he has legitimate reason that your recording is interfering with his work, and he tells you to stop. I think the new concept here is that he doesn't NEED a reason for within 8 feet for bystanders. Just the proximity is justifiable grounds for him to tell bystanders they have to stop or back up beyond 8 ft. https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm
- pdpi 4y agoThis makes me want to head to Arizona with my biggest telephoto lens, and very conspicuously film everything from a distance. Shame I'm on the other side of the Atlantic.
- kenniskrag 4y agoI could imagine if you arrest one person and some people walk towards you they don't know if the just film or want to attack. I as police would need one who watch if someone come close and another one who arrest the person.
- 8organicbits 4y agoDo people generally walk up to police while they are arresting someone inorder to attack the officer? That seems like too vague a threat, let people record.
- puffoflogic 4y agoI've seen plenty of released bodycam footage where they basically do; usually some form of white-knighting for the arrestee. But this is likely heavily influenced by a form of observation bias, where footage which shows police "under attack"[0] is more likely to be released than footage of cops behaving badly. [0] usually it isn't terribly violent and the danger comes mostly from distraction; despite ACAB I do have some sympathy for the police in these situations
- bonestamp2 4y agoI'm in favor of officer safety, but if this law was actually about officer safety, there's no need to mention recording. Just write the law to keep all bystanders 8ft away. Because it specifically mentions recording, this law is not about officer safety, it's about limiting recording.
- puffoflogic 4y ago
- blinded 4y agoReally odd to see this from a blue state? am I missing something?
- polishTar 4y agoYes, the state legislature and governor of AZ are GOP, and they were the ones that pushed for this.
- delecti 4y agoYou're missing that Arizona isn't blue. They've only voted for the democratic presidential nominee twice since 1952, in 1996 and 2020. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arizona#Political_culture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arizona#Political_culture
- sparker72678 4y agoAZ is nowhere close to being a Blue State. Barely went to Biden in 2020, yes, but Gov and Legislature are GOP dominated, and have been for some time. (And they have been very successful in drawing district lines to keep themselves in power). Probably the best way to think of AZ's population is purple, but more red than blue in tint.
- wronglyprepaid 4y ago> Barely went to Biden in 2020, yes, but Gov and Legislature are GOP dominated, and have been for some time. But this is only because of Trump's lies and Fox news collusion with Trump. If they gave Biden and honest wrap and told their viewers how historic a Biden presidency would be and how Biden would fight like hell to bring the prices of kitchen table issues down then he would have won Arizona in a landslide.
- ISL 4y ago"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances." The first amendment doesn't necessarily directly apply (our understanding of the word "press" has broadened with time), but it is rather certain that this law will push us to improve our understanding of precisely where the rights of citizens and media will begin and end in practice.
- staticassertion 4y agoRemember when the police rioted in 2020, shooting or beating lawyers and press in the streets? First amendment doesn't mean shit to cops.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- IIAOPSW 4y agoEven the Constitutional Originalists are not so Literalist as to interpret press as meaning literal printing presses, nor arms as black powder muskets, nor the things subject to search and seizure as being strictly the tangibles locked in ones home. IIRC there's already stacks of precedent establishing all the forms of digital media as protected free speech.
- BrainVirus 4y ago"Nobody walks up to a cop when he is questioning a suspicious person or arresting somebody and stands one or two feet away. Common sense says you’re asking for trouble," Kavanagh said on Arizona PBS. Common sense tells me Kavanagh is a manipulative bullshitter. I am so tired of this governmental and corporate double-speak. This should not require any new laws. If you are interfering with official police business, it's already illegal. If you are not interfering, then recording them should not be a problem. The response itself is a classic manipulation technique. You add more words to a statement without changing its meaning, but confusing people about its purpose.
- samatman 4y agoNoting that this is the sponsor, Rep. John Kavanagh of Arizona, not Supreme Court Justice Kavanaugh, whose name is frequently misspelled in that fashion.
- p1mrx 4y ago
- decremental 4y agoSounds like a reasonable enough statement to me. If nobody is getting up close to cops while they're involved with a suspect then it won't be an issue. But we all know there a bunch of people out there who lack the sense to not keep a reasonable distance and this law will cover those instances.
- notch656a 4y agoI don't see a law enforcement carve-out. By my reading a fellow cop with a body camera getting next to another cop enforcing the law would result in their violation of this law. Wonder if you can citizen's arrest a police officer for violating this law.
- decremental 4y ago
- joshgroban 4y agoEveryone's so anti-police until we need them to defend against white supremacists. And most of these libertarian "1st amendment audit" and "copblock" types are covert white supremacists. I 100% support this law. Police should not live in fear of being recorded out of context when they're doing their duty to protect the citizenry.
- staticassertion 4y agoThe police are the white supremacists. The 2006 FBI report has some interesting documentation on the white supremacist police infiltration efforts. https://oversight.house.gov/sites/democrats.oversight.house.gov/files/White_Supremacist_Infiltration_of_Law_Enforcement.pdf https://oversight.house.gov/sites/democrats.oversight.house....
- pmoriarty 4y agoWhat about police who abuse their power? What about police who lie, victimize, murder, and torture? Shouldn't citizens be allowed and even encouraged to shine a bright light on their abuses?
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> police should not live in fear of being recorded out of context Then why should I? If being recorded is such a terrible fate, let's make it illegal to record anyone, right? No? thought so.
- joshgroban 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gaze 4y agoWhat's going to stop the police from lying and saying any camera was within 8 feet?
- OJFord 4y agoWell the footage seems like it would be pretty good evidence (whichever way), given some analysis and a site visit?
- staticassertion 4y agoI'm sure every cop will pull out their ruler and measure it out accurately lol
- OJFord 4y agoWhy would it be a cop? I'm saying if you were charged with it there would be no excuse for not having photographic evidence of it.
- woodruffw 4y agoGetting body cam footage from the police is like pulling teeth, except the teeth have guns and politicians. The public is barely able to get footage after outrageous murders by the police. Under this new law, the police are given additional and unreasonable cover for destroying evidence. After all, you’re interfering by recording them, and they can’t be blamed if they happen to curb stomp your phone while arresting you for interference.
- tintor 4y agolive-streaming
- speed_spread 4y agoNext thing you know, every police car is equipped with a short range cellular base station to intercept or block any outgoing streams in the vincinity.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- OJFord 4y ago~Note that it's been illegal in the UK (or is it just in London?) for some time (since shortly after the 7/7 bombings iirc) - deemed surveillance for potentially untoward acts under anti-terrorism laws.~ [See correction in reply.] Not taking a view on it really, just saying it's not unprecedented or perhaps as necessarily crazy as it might first seem. But then, the USA is different, the policing is at least in the eyes of many more/too militarised and unlawful itself, and there's a community around 'auditing' police work to review its lawfulness etc. (Which, afaik, doesn't really happen here.) So, when you have that, it is hard not to see this as taking away that liberty. Versus here, yeah, ok, worst case a bobby asks me to delete a great photo that he happened to walk into; if it might help combat terrorism that's probably fine. Not to say it wasn't objected to - historically there's been a principle of police (and other emergency services) not having any more rights or different treatment than any other citizen, no harsher sentence for assaulting/murdering a police officer for example. But that ships sailed a few times to varying degrees anyway.
- lozenge 4y agoThere's no law against filming police in the UK. https://www.met.police.uk/advice/advice-and-information/ph/photography-advice https://www.met.police.uk/advice/advice-and-information/ph/p...
- OJFord 4y agoI stand corrected, thank you. Am I misremembering (or misunderstood at the time) entirely, or has this changed/scope & guidance evolved, do you know?
- lozenge 4y agoNo, I can't think of any relevant change. I also did a quick search for news stories of people's cameras being searched or siezed under S43 for photographing buildings, but didn't find any major stories. https://www.statewatch.org/media/documents/analyses/no-105-uk-section-44.pdf https://www.statewatch.org/media/documents/analyses/no-105-u... ?
- 4y ago
- smugma 4y agoSee yesterday’s thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32030229 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32030229
- greesil 4y agoThe law applies to a person. How about a drone?
- netr0ute 4y agoThe drone might be considered an extension of a person, since it's only a tool and not a person itself.
- noduerme 4y ago
- jm20 4y agoIs it just me or does 8-10 feet seem like an optimal distance to film from anyway? Who’s shooting productive videos from two feet away? Even the George Floyd videos were at least ten feet away and they seemed more than adequate.
- lolpython 4y agoA fish eye lens works fine. That is what body cameras use.
- DangitBobby 4y agoAnyone who is filming from 8-10 feet away who is approached by an officer who wishes for the filming to cease.
- lionkor 4y agoIt doesnt apply then, it only applies to officers who are questioning, arresting, etc.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoJudges and lawyers will have to figure that out.
- khiner 4y agoJudges overwhelmingly side with police officers over defendants as a default stance. Adding laws restricting civilian rights and protecting police officers can only skew that stance further away from neutrality and towards the favor of police officers.
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago> Judges overwhelmingly side with police officers over defendants as a default stance. Definitely not true here in King County Washington, but Arizona is probably very different.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoWhy do right wing politians dislike Russia when they are trying to copy it's methods and tactics? laws like this one will encourage corruption and abuse of power, results in same problems Russia has - police can extorn local businesses and citizen without consequences" tale down political opponents, etc.
- black_13 4y ago
- advisedwang 4y agoText of the Bill (https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm): > 13-3732. Unlawful video recording of law enforcement activity; classification; definition > > A. It is unlawful for a person to knowingly make a video recording of law enforcement activity if the person making the video recording is within eight feet of where the person knows or reasonably should know that law enforcement activity is occurring, either receives or has previously received a verbal warning from a law enforcement officer that the person is prohibited from making a video recording OF A LAW ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY within eight feet of THE activity and CONTINUES TO MAKE A video recordING OF the law enforcement activity WITHIN EIGHT FEET OF THE ACTIVITY. If the law enforcement activity is occurring in an enclosed structure that is on private property, a person who is authorized to be on the private property may make a video recording of the activity from an adjacent room or area that is less than eight feet away from where the activity is occurring, unless a law enforcement officer determines that the person is INTERFERING in the law enforcement activity or that it is not safe to be in the area and orders the person to leave the area. > > B. notwithstanding subsection A of this section, a person who is the subject of police contact may record the encounter if the person is not interfering with lawful police actions, including searching, handcuffing or administering a field sobriety test. The occupants of a vehicle that is the subject of a police stop may record the encounter if the occupants are not interfering with lawful police actions. > > C. this section does not establish a right or authorize any person to make a video recording of law enforcement activity. > > D. A violation of this section is a class 3 misdemeanor. > > E. For the purposes of this section, "law enforcement activity" means any of the following: > > > 1. Questioning a suspicious person. > > > 2. Conducting an arrest, issuing a summons or enforcing the law. > > > 3. Handling an emotionally disturbed or disorderly person who is exhibiting abnormal behavior.
- jdblair 4y agoI believe this is most of all about stopping filming by drivers during traffic stops. It is impossible to be 8 feet away while sitting in the driver seat during a traffic stop.
- jlgaddis 4y agoI believe you are mistaken, as HB2319 [0] itself directly states: > The occupants of a vehicle that is the subject of a police stop may record the encounter if the occupants are not interfering with lawful police actions. -- On a side note, I encourage everyone to carefully read the actual bill. There's a lot of intelligent people here on HN but it seems that many of those commenting can't quite comprehend plain English (not as well as I would have expected, at least). -- [0]: https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm
- that_guy_iain 4y agoThe issue generally isn't with the bill but how the police enforce it. There are videos all over the internet of police officers telling people standing near to stop filming them and threatening to arrest them for interferring with police business. Hell, there is one video of a police office crossing the road to do so.
- jdblair 4y agoI stand corrected! Thank you.
- gardnr 4y ago> MAY RECORD THE ENCOUNTER IF THE PERSON IS NOT INTERFERING WITH LAWFUL POLICE ACTIONS This broad inclusive language was seemingly added to protect the act of recording while being the subject of an investigation. It also makes it very clear when the officer can turn off the citizens camera. This law has potential to be abused to shroud dirty shit. Existing laws previously existed to enforce this same behaviour. This is an unnecessary expansion of power.
- sk8terboi 4y ago
- ccleve 4y agoParadoxically, this law could lead to more filming, because it codifies the fact that filming beyond eight feet is perfectly okay. That may have been legally true before, but now the police have a clear, bright rule. This might be good for both police and bystanders.
- Vvector 4y agoC. this section does not establish a right or authorize any person to make a video recording of law enforcement activity.
- advisedwang 4y agoThis law is going to be abused. We've seen officers trying to use intellectual property to avoid being recorded [1], turn off bodycams [2], or just straight up pepper spraying folks that pull out a cell phone [3]. Recordings cause problems for officers, so if the state gives them an way to prevent it they will use that. This particular law [4] could be abused in several ways. 1. 8ft is from where "law enforcement activity is occurring". Officers will act assuming that this covers large areas, not just 8ft from the officer themself. Only later will courts get a chance to push back against this. 2. Nothing prevents a police officer walking closer to the person who is recording, pushing away the recording (or forcing them to stop as its now within 8ft. 3. The law says recording is illegal if interfering with the police or unsafe. Again, police will apply this to very wide circumstances. [1] https://www.techdirt.com/2022/04/18/cops-are-still-playing-copyrighted-music-to-thwart-citizens-recording-their-actions/ https://www.techdirt.com/2022/04/18/cops-are-still-playing-c... [2] https://kstp.com/kstp-news/top-news/officers-across-minnesota-allowed-to-turn-off-body-cameras-in-middle-of-investigations/ https://kstp.com/kstp-news/top-news/officers-across-minnesot... [3] https://www.star-telegram.com/news/local/crime/article251249349.html https://www.star-telegram.com/news/local/crime/article251249... [4] https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm
- tsomctl 4y agoYour examples aren't of this law being abused. This is the whole point of it. The writers know exactly what's going to happen.
- nimbius 4y agothe whole bill is wishful thinking. personal drones routinely show up at protests nowadays. it honestly also seems like these writers have never picked up a nice smartphone; most have enough 4k zoom to film a nature documentary. even the zoom on a knockoff go pro is shockingly good. its a feather in the ragged cap of tough on crime legislation at best.
- feet 4y ago
- swayvil 4y agoIn defense of the cops. If you are doing cop business and somebody approaches to within 8 feet of your business then they are involving themselves in your business. Some will use the defense "but I was filming, surely you don't hate freedom of whatever". Which is where this particular law comes in.
- woodruffw 4y agoFrom reading the actual bill[1]: no radius of "law enforcement activity" is actually established. In other words: the police may claim under this law that "8 feet" means "8 feet from the radius," not "8 feet from their persons." This, in effect, may allow the police to arrest anybody within the radius of ordinary "law enforcement activity," such as peaceful protestors recording themselves during a protest that the police are being paid to monitor. This is terrible law, designed to invite broad and abusive interpretation by the police. [1]: https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm
- jjtheblunt 4y agoSo film at 10 feet, if you want to film? Wider field of view with no loss of fidelity on modern cameras? Perhaps '8 feet' is meant to keep a filmer out of potential harm, and from interfering with a police officer and suspect potentially struggling.
- ubermonkey 4y agoNo. This law has been written so as to be deliberately vague, and thus allow abuse. There are precious few examples of people filming cops actually interfering. There are, however, a LOT of examples where video documentation of police misconduct led to departmental embarrassment, lawsuits, and even (though rarely) criminal charges. The law exists to try to prevent THAT.
- jjtheblunt 4y agostrange times
- vharuck 4y ago>Perhaps '8 feet' is meant to keep a filmer out of potential harm, and from interfering with a police officer and suspect potentially struggling. If that were the intent, there'd be no reason to focus on the act of filming. It would just say "8 feet for anyone besides police officers and those the police officers are dealing with."
- gaze 4y agoI grew up very comfortably, and in general the police have never given me grief. They've always been helpful. However, throughout my life, I've spoken to those who have had less favorable interactions with the police, who, as far as I can tell, were not doing anything to be worthy of the treatment they received. These stories have been so plentiful and consistently bad that I can not possibly believe that the police are an overall force for good. At this point, you can turn on the news and the evidence is right there. Maybe I was primed to draw these conclusions from the news from my prior conversations, I don't know. Either way, there are so many people in this thread who are convinced that this is a good thing and that it won't be cynically abused, and that these abuses will not be supported by the criminal justice system. There are a handful of threads that terminate in "well if that's the case, then we've got a bigger problem." What do you mean "if?" is my feeling. I just don't understand it. If you see the abuses and think "well, they deserved it" or "ah it's a few bad apples" I'm not trying to speak to you. I don't think we'd really ever find common ground. I'm really trying to ask such questions to those of you out there who still seem surprised when the police do something bad, or those who just claim to be unaware. Do you or do you not talk to people who claim police are abusive? If you do talk to them, do you just not believe them? How many of such people have you talked to, and after talking to this many people, how many more people would have to confirm such abuses before you believed them? When you hear such stories, how do you discount them, or otherwise minimize them to the degree that your beliefs are not swayed?
- dolni 4y agoWhen I hear such stories, I always remember that there are two sides to a story and people often lie or embellish to make themselves look good. Police don't do everything right. But if you think that _everybody_ who had a bad interaction did nothing wrong, well, that's just foolish.
- jfengel 4y agoWhen police "don't do everything right", people die. They are given extraordinary leverage to use deadly force, and are assumed to be telling the truth in a court of law. And we have seen that almost universally, police will protect other police who abuse their power. These are not equivalent. Police who do bad things not only cause extreme harm, but terrorize people whose protection is the whole reason we gave police the monopoly on violence in the first place. This is not a "two sides to a story" situation. This is a situation where one side has all of the power and far, far too much documented abuse of it.
- chmod600 4y agoI know there's a slippery slope or potentential for abuse here. But in its present form, it seems downright reasonable. Doesn't activate my outrage.
- batch12 4y agoMaybe I am wrong, but I understand this as if you're the person being questioned, arrested, etc then you can't legally record what's happening. If you record something illegally, is it admissible?
- mfer 4y agoThe text of the bill identifies the case for both those who are the subject of the "activity" and those that aren't. This is targeted at those who are not the subject and those who are (or are in a vehicle with the subject) have different rules that are called out. You can see the details at https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.htm
- Waterluvian 4y agoThis seems manifestly unconstitutional. How long will this survive a 1A challenge?
- aksss 4y agoI think the idea of a line being drawn at interference is pretty well established and could see the 8-foot rule as trying to establish a useable standard. How does it apply in a traffic stop though? Not sure if there are conditions for the 8-foot rule described in the law. I could see it being allowable (or at least NOT presumptively unconstitutional) in the public setting of a sidewalk as pertaining to parties not directly involved in a matter. I am far more skeptical that it could apply to a person who is the direct subject of an interaction or a companion thereof.
- raziel2701 4y agoGiven that the Supreme Court we have today is now an extension of the Christian Taliban I'm not very hopeful we're in a time of fairness and justice.
- scoofy 4y agoThe new court has a general thesis on things that different from the previous court. They see to be extremely pro broad, written-in-text rights. I think it would be a huge surprise if they allowed something like this.
- scoofy 4y agoIt seems like it would be trivially unconstitutional, yes.
- lizardactivist 4y agoHow much 8 feet is depends entirely on the mood of that officer, and possibly whether the person with the camera is black or white.
- cebert 4y agoHow would this law impact modern cars? My Tesla Model Y has cameras pointed in all directions. The car is continually using these cameras to perform functions and will inevitably record police. Teslas even have a dashcam feature that allows you to save footage to a thumb drive. I don’t see how cars like Teslas wouldn’t be illegal in AZ.
- balderdash 4y agoUsing a little deductive reasoning, If the law was really about officer safety, you could remove all reference to video recording, and just make it about people staying away from “police activity’ / not interfering with investigations, but then that would mean no one could approach a police officer. And since if I’m not filming I can still spproach, one has to ask, is it more likely that people film AND assault/interfere with the police, or just interfere/assault (I’d posit the later)? So it’s clear that this about stoping filming period, the pretense that it’s about anything else seems pretty hard to justify
- imposter 4y agowhy is a http library publishing news