8 ms·
No antibiotics worked, so this woman turned to phage scientists
- ratdragon 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halicin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halicin - a recently (2019) discovered ATB with "an unusual mechanism of action" has been found to be effective against Acinetobacter Baumanii in mice. Found using deep-learning.
- treeman79 4y agoHow on earth did she get approval? It took me a year of doctor shopping to get an approved treatment for a common condition.
- yawnxyz 4y agoIn Australia, we're starting a new clinical trial (phageaustralia.org) for phage therapy, funded by the Australian Medical Research Future Fund: https://www.health.gov.au/initiatives-and-programs/medical-research-future-fund https://www.health.gov.au/initiatives-and-programs/medical-r... We're just gearing up with a team distributed across Aus that tackles the clinical, biology and data/engineering side (this is my job). This clinical trial is a bit different from trad drug discovery, since this clinical trial assesses the entire PROCESS of: (1) sourcing the phage (2) testing the phage's effectiveness against a patient's bacteria (3) manufacturing the phage to be safe for the patient/indication. We're not trialling a phage itself, like most active phage therapy clinical trials out there right now. We're emphasizing the "therapy" aspect, of collecting data on the phage, bacteria, and measuring immune reaction in the patient to figure out what works, what doesn't work, and most importantly safety. Phages are interesting because we can "train" them to work specifically for each patient's infection, and this is much more complex than just throwing antibiotics at a wall. In essence, effective and large scale phage therapy is a data problem — we need to figure out why a phage works (or doesn't work) for a specific bacteria and indication first. (How will a phage respond to pseudomonas in the lungs? How will it work in the gut? On the skin? etc.). We also need to know what phages will work in combination with antibiotics, because most doctors will want to keep using antibiotics. But ideally, we want to be able to predict what phages will work in a patient, so we can just prep and manufacture those ahead of time, and have some amount of certainty that given our data this will work. There are tons of phage therapy clinical trials going on, including from places like UCSD, Mayo Clinic in the US, in Portugal, Israel, Belgium. Most of these aren't trialling the process itself like Phage Australia though — they're trialling the phage itself, or a combination (a phage cocktail)... And there's more countries like Canada and the UK getting interested in it as well. Some other places doing cool phage stuff right now: - https://www.biomx.com/our-pipeline/ https://www.biomx.com/our-pipeline/ - https://www.armatapharma.com/ https://www.armatapharma.com/ - http://technophage.pt/2020/ http://technophage.pt/2020/ - Felix: https://www.cff.org/news/2022-03/cf-foundation-awards-1-million-felix-biotechnology-develop-novel-phage-therapy https://www.cff.org/news/2022-03/cf-foundation-awards-1-mill... - https://www.aphage.com/science/case-studies/ https://www.aphage.com/science/case-studies/ - http://www.yalephagecenter.com/ http://www.yalephagecenter.com/ - https://medschool.ucsd.edu/som/medicine/divisions/idgph/research/center-innovative-phage-applications-and-therapeutics/Pages/default.aspx https://medschool.ucsd.edu/som/medicine/divisions/idgph/rese... (Steffanie Strathdee's project) - Mayo Clinic: https://www.mayo.edu/research/clinical-trials/cls-20512857 https://www.mayo.edu/research/clinical-trials/cls-20512857 - TAILOR at the Baylor College of Medicine: https://www.bcm.edu/research/research-centers/tailor#:~:text=TAILOR%20provides%20personalized%20solutions%20for,attributes%20for%20your%20unique%20applications https://www.bcm.edu/research/research-centers/tailor#:~:text.... - Queen Astrid Military Hospital in Belgium: https://phage.directory/capsid/phage-futures-jean-paul-pirnay https://phage.directory/capsid/phage-futures-jean-paul-pirna... -
- Fomite 4y agoPhage comes up a lot here - it seems to be on of HN's favorite biology topics. I have a deep and abiding fondness for phage, but they're not quite as awesome as they seem at first glance. From the perspective of an infectious disease epidemiologist who has been super-interested in phage for my whole career (literally tried to get a job out of undergrad with a phage therapeutics startup): 1) There's no such thing as a "broad spectrum" phage. They're organism specific, and that means not only would you need to keep a phage library on hand, but you'd have to do a lot of diagnostic tests. That's going to be both expensive and tricky. There are treatment guidelines for things like sepsis right now that are basically un-doable with phage therapy because of the time it takes to tune a phage library. 2) Phages are living things. Not only is that a weird regulatory framework to be in for a drug, but it also means that you need to be able to keep phage alive. In contrast, antibiotics are inert. 3) Phage therapy is also relatively new in the West (after being abandoned for some very real, very serious safety concerns back in the day), which means there's just less of a R&D infrastructure behind it. There have been people working on commercializing phage therapy since I was in undergrad (I'm now a tenured professor). The problem is it's hard, and antibiotics are so much better as a treatment that there's kind of a ceiling on the excitement that they can generate, especially when trying to treat at scale.
- voldacar 4y agoThanks for your insights here — is there any innovation going currently wrt phages either in academia or the startup world that looks significant from a practical point of view? I've also seen people claim that phages were never researched as much in the West because they were popular with the Soviets and therefore had a kind of tainted PR image, is there any truth to this or was their lack of prevalence primarily due to more serious issues?
- Fomite 4y agoAnswering in reverse order: Phages were used in the west prior to the advent of antibiotics. They had a repetitional issue then, because our purification methods weren't always great, so phage preparations had both phage and potentially bits of the cell wall of the bacteria they had killed. Bacterial cell walls contain endotoxins, which are potentially quite dangerous. They were largely abandoned in the West because with the advent of antibiotics, a wildly more effective solution to bacterial infections was present. The Cold War meant the Soviet Union had less access, and so needed to continue working on phage research more intensively. There's a lot of work on phages going on in academia - I don't know about the startup world, TBH. I think some of the most promising leads are in combination therapy. It appears that treating with phage can push bacteria back into susceptibility (basically, two selective pressures at the same time), which is a cool idea. But the gap phage has to jump from "Interesting bespoke one-time treatments" to a generalizable treatment is a pretty big one. My expectation at least in the medium term is they'll be supplemental treatments for a few well known conditions where you can maintain phage libraries for them.
- donkeydoug 4y agoI listened to the audiobook for 'The Perfect Predator' (https://www.audible.com/pd/The-Perfect-Predator-Audiobook/1549114484 https://www.audible.com/pd/The-Perfect-Predator-Audiobook/15...) ... was a good story and amazing he survived with so few long term complications. They were certainly well connected, but he also was very resilient being able to recover from (if memory serves) multiple rounds of sepsis & organ failure.
- i_like_apis 4y agoIt’s amazing and very heartening that they were able to get the FDA on board in a matter of weeks. Fascinating article. Although the page spontaneously reloaded while I was in the middle of reading, twice! Very annoying to try to read something with so much ad code doing reflows, popups and reloads …
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y agoInteresting topic aside, thank you so much for linking to the lite version.
- triyambakam 4y agoI didn't even realize it was CNN
- mirekrusin 4y agoWhoever came up with lite version at CNN should get standing ovation.
- docdeek 4y agoVery interesting - thanks for sharing. I'm not a scientist and the only time I've come across discussion of phages before was in the Michael Crichton novel, Prey.
- DonaldFisk 4y agoBacteriophages are also in Arrowsmith by Sinclair Lewis, where they were used to treat plague.
- carapace 4y agoIn a nutshell, it works but antibiotics work better (until they don't, eh?), so phage therapy was largely eclipsed in the West. However: > Isolated from Western advances in antibiotic production in the 1940s, Russian scientists continued to develop already successful phage therapy to treat the wounds of soldiers in field hospitals. During World War II, the Soviet Union used bacteriophages to treat many soldiers infected with various bacterial diseases e.g. dysentery and gangrene.[28] Russian researchers continued to develop and to refine their treatments and to publish their research and results. However, due to the scientific barriers of the Cold War, this knowledge was not translated and did not proliferate across the world. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phage_therapy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phage_therapy See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marine_bacteriophage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marine_bacteriophage (for fun, or maybe horror? The oceans are grey goo.)
- robocat 4y ago> However, due to the scientific barriers of the Cold War, this knowledge was not translated and did not proliferate across the world. I would hazard a guess that the reasons are other than translation. Keen scientists learn enough of foreign languages to read papers in their area of interest - reading scientific language in a speciality area is much easier than learning a language generally (I personally know scientists that have self-taught themselves for Russian, German, French, etcetera). “Many researchers agree that the development of phage therapy has stalled because of ‘concerns over intellectual property protection’ and ‘lack of a predefined regulatory pathway’ (Kingwell, 2015)” https://academic.oup.com/phe/article/13/1/82/5741402?login=false https://academic.oup.com/phe/article/13/1/82/5741402?login=f... > across the world. Is that an American centric worldview? It makes little sense. Maybe the USA and allies, but there is a lot more to the world than that, and phages haven’t been used. The reasons for that are very unlikely to be due to what appears to be a simplistic world view.
- eranation 4y ago> First, Strathdee found an obscure treatment that offered a glimmer of hope -- fighting superbugs with phages, viruses created by nature to eat bacteria. > Then she convinced phage scientists around the country to hunt and peck through molecular haystacks of sewage, bogs, ponds, the bilge of boats and other prime breeding grounds for bacteria and their viral opponents. The impossible goal: quickly find the few, exquisitely unique phages capable of fighting a specific strain of antibiotic-resistant bacteria literally eating her husband alive. > Next, the US Food and Drug Administration had to greenlight this unproven cocktail of hope, and scientists had to purify the mixture so that it wouldn't be deadly. > Yet just three weeks later, Strathdee watched doctors intravenously inject the mixture into her husband's body -- and save his life
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chasil 4y agoIt appears that commercial sources are already available. https://mybacteriophage.net/ https://mybacteriophage.net/ Anyone with an aggressive bacteriological infection should be aware of and consider phage therapy when beginning treatment. It is also important to pre-treat the selected phage in a concentrated solution of the pathogen to allow time for adaptation prior to injection.
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoWhy do we keep reading annoyingly insular case reports of people with relatively common, but highly multi drug resistant bacteria who get saved by phages, while at the same time being afraid of the antibiotic apocalypse? What keeps us from having a register/bank of highly effective phages to treat people with those boring old multi drug resistant bacteria bacteria? Why do we keep saving and at the same time ruining peoples lifes with fluoroquinolones, gentamicin and other dangerous antibiotics instead of just giving them phages?
- jryb 4y agoIt's super complicated - clinical trials of phage therapy have been relatively unsuccessful for one thing, so there's that. But additionally: - Bacteria adapt to phage infections, just as they do to antibiotics - Many phages are very host-specific, so a given cocktail might not even be able to target the pathogenic bacteria in question. There are phages with broader host spectra, but then they might be able to target the rest of your microbiome, which can lead to other health problems - Since phages have protein shells, human antibodies will target them, and may prevent them from reaching the infected tissue. You might also only be able to use a particular phage once for this reason. I could go on, but suffice it to say, there are lots of unknowns and lots of complexity. Still, I do have hope for the technique in general, and our ability to understand phage-bacteria interactions is only getting better now that sequencing is super cheap. But I wouldn't bet my life on phage therapy working if I needed it today - which is why it's generally limited to compassionate use when antibiotics have failed.
- coryrc 4y ago> What keeps us from having a register/bank of highly effective phages The FDA. The only freedom you have in the USA is to die. Oh, sure, you are allowed to do it entirely yourself and with your own funds, but you can't share the burden with people. Yay freedom.
- stareatgoats 4y agoWhat an amazing story, one which should give hope to the many people that are battling superbugs as we speak. Her (Strathdee's) Wikipedia page gives some more background, out of which this stood out to me: "Although phage therapy had been used for one hundred years in Eastern Europe, it was not licensed for clinical use in the United States or most of Western Europe" [0] Which indicates (if not proves) that healthcare is one one of the casualties of our polarized world. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steffanie_A._Strathdee#Role_in_promoting_phage_therapy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steffanie_A._Strathdee#Role_in...
- Fomite 4y agoIt's not really that. Eastern Europe had to continue with phage therapies because they didn't have great access to antibiotics, which have many superior properties. Phage was used in the Western world, but early versions had serious purification issues, where people were getting killed by bacterial endotoxins present in the solutions. It's not really "lost" as much as a readily obvious alternative was present in one setting and not the other.
- inkyoto 4y ago> Eastern Europe had to continue with phage therapies because they didn't have great access to antibiotics […] This is a very bubble centric view of the history. Eastern bloc countries, notably East Germany, Hungary and Yugoslavia, had very active and thriving drug research and manufacturing sectors. The Soviet Union, whilst having the drug research and manufacturing of their own, was purchasing swaths of drugs from the three aforementioned countries. Azithromycin, one of the most widely prescribed macrolide antibiotics in the US today, was, in fact, discovered in Yugoslavia and licenced to Pfizer in 1980s. Phage therapy was considered a novel area of research in a few of the Eastern bloc countries, but it never became neither widespread nor a substitute for antibiotics. It was just as fringe in those countries as it was elsewhere.
- bsedlm 4y agoit's really terrible how the caring for one's health aspect of the medicine industry has taken a secondary role, the really important thing is corporate profit, patients are getting treated, but not healed this is not to say the treatments are not effective, but I think it's telling to consider that the reason treatments remain effective is to avoid defrauding customers (err. patients), not becuase the intention is healing people.
- kosyblysk666 4y ago
- Archelaos 4y agoResearch in the field of phage therapy has traditionally been strong in the Soviet Union since the 1920s and in other Eastern Bloc countries such as the GDR after WW2. In recent years, the area has gained renewed attention in Germany. There exists currently an extensive programme of basic research on phages funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG). The project Web-site is located at: https://spp2330.de/ https://spp2330.de/
- jamal-kumar 4y agoShout out to the country of Georgia for being the stronghold of this since the 1920s [1] [1] https://eptc.ge/ https://eptc.ge/
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoThey've registered an even better domain name I see: https://pha.ge/ https://pha.ge/
- bijant 4y agoBroad Spectrum Antibiotics were superior to Phage Therapy when they were first introduced, as they didn't necessitate time intensive cultivation of the pathogen prior to administration. The high selectivity of Bacteriophages was their main disadvantage. Today, with all the knowledge about the importance of a healty gut Biome, the potential risk to "good bacteria" has to be weighed before administration of antibiotics is considered. Fast diagnostic tests, like the use of PCR to detect Covid-19, turn Phage Therapies greatest Drawback, its selectivity, into its greatest advantage.
- PaulKeeble 4y agoThere are two really interesting parts of Russian medicine which the West hasn't really pursued which it should. Phages is one and they really are an incredible solution to antibiotic immune bacteria, the issue is always finding the right one, there are so many different phages and bank of all of them would be enormous, 10s probably 100s of thousands. The second is auto vaccines and Lysates which present dead bacteria to the body so it can create an appropriate immune response. They are used in Russia for things like Urinary tract Infections which in the West are often untreatable with antibiotics but they do seem to work. Get the immune system to recognise the baddy and work out how to kill it and then in the harder to reach places it can be effective. Works fairly well for Chronic infections but the issue is identifying the bacteria precisely to match and existing mix or collecting the bacteria and cultivating and killing it mechanically or with heat so it can be injected back into the patient safely in other places in the body. Both techniques were outrun by antibiotics in the beginning, antibiotics are a lot easier to administer as you don't have to identify the pathogen precisely and its easy to make in bulk. But both these more natural solutions are a lot harder for bacteria to become immune to and have undergone the evolutionary process alongside us and them. I think both are worth serious efforts and development.
- anewpersonality 4y agoWhy don't we use machine learning to find phages?
- gnicholas 4y ago> But the long illness took its toll: Patterson was diagnosed with diabetes and is now insulin dependent, with mild heart damage, no feeling in the bottoms of his feet and gut damage that affects his diet. So if he had received the phage treatment sooner, would that have lessened these effects? Or are they sure that these effects were not caused by the phages themselves? Obviously it's better to be alive, even with these effects, but if doctors were choosing between several options for a future patient, they'd presumably want to know the causal chain.
- elcritch 4y agoYes getting the treatment sooner would’ve prevented damage, though how much would be harder to say. According to the account, by the time of treatment the bacterium had caused widespread damage and the patient had multiple organ failure before the treatment. Phages are also highly adapted to attack bacteria and often specific bacteria. It’s highly unlikely to affect humans. That’s easy to show since dirt is loaded with bacterial phages. Additionally there was significant research in Soviet bloc on the safety and efficacy of phage treatment. I’m hoping phage treatment becomes more common and better. The rise of bacterial superbugs is one of the greatest threats to modern life, as in we don’t expect ourselves or loved ones to die routinely from bacterial infections. However that’s very recent thing in human history. I’d readily wager that bacterial diseases have killed far more people than viral infections. They’re the literal plague.
- pieter_mj 4y agoThere's also the success story of terror victim Karen Northshield. She has had about 70 operations after the march 2016 Brussels airport attack. In the beginning of her recovery, she survived life-threathening bacterial infections with phage therapy.
- pieter_mj 4y agoThe open access article about her phage therapy in Nature : https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-27656-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-27656-z
- t_mann 4y agoThanks for sharing. Multiresistant bacteria are high on my list of slow-mo crashes happening before our eyes that no one seems to be talking about (compared to eg climate change, which is also a slow-mo catastrophe, but at least one that people are talking about). And it's always puzzled me how little I hear about work being done on phages, which pose an interesting approach to tackle the problem (compared to eg quantum computing, where commercialization potential seems to be a lot further out).
- abirch 4y agoPharma has thought about it. They are working on drugs it hopes to never use. https://www.merck.com/stories/antimicrobial-resistance-an-emerging-public-health-crisis/ https://www.merck.com/stories/antimicrobial-resistance-an-em...
- salawat 4y agoIf nature made it, no patent. Where's the lockin with that? /s
- taf2 4y agoReally I feel like this has been a hot topic for at least 15 years.. for example 5 years ago this https://youtu.be/plVk4NVIUh8 https://youtu.be/plVk4NVIUh8 was on hacker news and got a lot of discussion as I recall… Ok maybe you are right my search yielded few posts that got any traction - so maybe it was just me sharing with people I know!
- Fomite 4y agoI say this in another comment, but this has been The Next Big Thing For Infectious Disease since I was an undergrad. I got tenure this year.
- Loic 4y agoAt least in France, a series of antibiotics are not allowed to be used/sold outside of hospitals. This is to ensure that hospitals have some last resort antibiotics in hard cases. But even with that, they have issues. In Germany, where I live at the moment, the risks and issues are well known and talked about. I have seen a large reduction of the prescription of antibiotics. The younger the MD, the less antibiotics are given. But 80% (maybe even more) of the antibiotics are used by animal farming...
- adventured 4y agoYou might notice something very peculiar about this story. Here are the pieces: > What she accomplished next could easily be called miraculous [bullshit] > Buoyed by her newfound knowledge, Strathdee began reaching out to scientists who worked with phages: "I wrote cold emails to total strangers, begging them for help," she said at Life Itself. > she convinced phage scientists around the country to hunt and peck through molecular haystacks > One stranger who quickly answered was Texas A&M University biochemist Ryland Young. He's been working with phages for nearly 45 years. Young, a professor of biochemistry and biophysics who runs the lab at the university's Center for Phage Technology. "We just dropped everything. No exaggeration, people were literally working 24/7" ... [that's what happens when I need help, university departments drop what they're doing to assist] > Next, the US Food and Drug Administration had to greenlight this unproven cocktail of hope [in a week] > But the woman who answered the phone at the FDA said, " 'No problem.' ... " [like magic] > And then she tells me she has friends in the Navy [who doesn't] > Yet just three weeks later, Strathdee watched doctors intravenously inject the mixture into her husband's body > Legal staff at Texas A&M expressed concern about future lawsuits ... But Stephanie literally had speed dial numbers for the chancellor and all the people involved in human experimentation at UC San Diego. After she calls them, they basically called their counterparts at A&M, and suddenly they all began to work together [suddenly it happened, a miracle] Ready for it? > Strathdee was the associate dean of global health sciences at the University of California, San Diego It wasn't a miracle. It was extreme privilege. She had elite access and got extraordinarily special treatment and response at every step. The phage aspect is very interesting, I've been reading about phages on HN for over a decade probably (and in that time there has seemingly been relatively little progress in their usage in the West). The rest of the story is rather disgusting in how it's portrayed in the article vs what's actually going on (connections, status, privileged treatment). Oh but it was like a miracle - no, no it wasn't.
- anewpersonality 4y agoI got this from the article too. This couple was incredibly connected. But.. they lived and worked in a field for 40 odd years, why the hell couldn't they take advantage of it? This isn't like Dad getting his frat bro son a job at Goldman.
- 4y ago
- uthinter 4y agoGeorgia, the country. It has some of the best research and treatment facilities when it comes to phage therapy.
- yibg 4y agoGreat story and glad about the positive outcome. But also highlights the benefits of being well connected. Doubtful a couple in a similar situation that were not a professor and associate dean at a well known university could've obtained the same outcome.
- derbOac 4y agoYes, I had the same reaction. Altogether it's inspiring and I'm happy to see novel treatments like it when antibacterial therapies are desperately needed. At the same time seeing these inequities in the system was disturbing to me. It's not only the special privileges the couple enjoyed -- how they received the treatment and another did not -- it's also how generating some sort of enthusiasm about a research area can require this kind of private string pulling. If one of those researchers had submitted a research grant on phage therapy would it have been approved? I liked the article and am not meaning this as a criticism of it, the couple, the people involved, or the therapy. It's just revealing of structural problems in academics, health care, and society.
- vegetablepotpie 4y ago> Legal staff at Texas A&M expressed concern about future lawsuits. "I remember the lawyer saying to me, 'Let me see if I get this straight. You want to send unapproved viruses from this lab to be injected into a person who will probably die.' And I said, "Yeah, that's about it,'" Young said. >"But Stephanie literally had speed dial numbers for the chancellor and all the people involved in human experimentation at UC San Diego. After she calls them, they basically called their counterparts at A&M, and suddenly they all began to work together," Young added. >"It was like the parting of the Red Sea -- all the paperwork and hesitation disappeared." If you know who to call, things happen fast.