4 ms·
Transport System Bögl: a new magnetic rail system
- vosper 4y agoI looked at the site, I can’t tell what’s new about it. Kinda looks like less-grimy BART to me, and that’s hardly modern. Does anyone know more about what’s innovative here?
- bluGill 4y agomarketing, like most gadgetbahns. There is a reason transit enthusiasts in general look down on this. Anyone who knows something about how to run trains knows this at best done nothing to solve the real problems facing transit, and most likely if they get even one sale it makes things worse for everyone.
- mecha_ghidorah 4y agoI'd be interested to read more about the actual problems and how maglev trains might make them worse. Not that I don't believe you, but it seems counterintuitive and I'm curious now
- bluGill 4y agoThe biggest problems is the high cost of building track. Remember that trains do not cover everything, so you have to pay for roads (though in the most transit friendly places the few trucks that are needed drive on the sidewalks next to pedestrians no problem). Automated rail is the cheapest to operate, but there are very high upfront costs that may never be paid for compared to running a bus. (when self driving cars arrive I look forward to self driving buses - they would solve something like 75% of what I'm looking to a train for) standardization is a very useful thing in the world. Standards mean you can buy from many different suppliers - if one train manufacture is busy find a different. Standards also mean you can share track with different lines spreading construction costs out. (this even includes freight trains) Standards mean manufactures can invest in jigs that are not worth building for custom things that nobody else needs - or worth building but the cost of the jig is spread out across more parts. One special case of a jig is a long assembly line - note that a modern car is very complex and yet new they start at only $16,000. While trains will never be in high enough demand to get that cheap, there is a lot of opportunity to lower costs if only there were more orders of the same thing (like cars you can choose what color paint you want and a few other options)
- mecha_ghidorah 4y agoRight, I suppose that does make sense. What are the odds of a standardised high speed rail track being adopted at some point so that multiple manufacturers could build cars for that?
- gbanfalvi 4y agoHow is this better than a regular train/subway/tram?
- uniqueuid 4y agoMagnetically levitated, meaning up to 500 km/h (~300 mph), silent, and it's driverless. Downsides are that you need to build completely new tracks with limited curvature (and new stations).
- Octoth0rpe 4y ago> meaning up to 500 km/h (~300 mph) from the website: Cruising speed of up to 150 km/h I'm guessing that the value proposition of this particular system is that it's cut certain performance corners to achieve a far lower cost while still providing more than adequate speed for the intracity use case.
- bluGill 4y agoSure, but wheels work just fine at those speeds. the advantages of maglev over steel wheels need much faster speeds before they are realized. At least for all current maglev systems, this is still vaporware, ask me after it has been in use for 20 years and we have real world data on how it works out. Don't be the person who pays for getting that real world data though.
- iggldiggl 4y agoCynically speaking – it's based on a track made from pre-cast concrete elements, which Max Bögl (a construction company and concrete manufacturer at heart) will happily build for you. It's also marketed as a fully turn-key system where everything starting from the design and finishing with the vehicles and operations control will be provided by Bögl, which conversely also means that it's a fully proprietary system and you're dependent on Bögl for continuing support or any future expansions, too.
- jeffbee 4y ago
- uniqueuid 4y agoThis seems to be a magnetic levitation solution. You know, floating on air cushions, (almost) no friction, but needs specific new tracks. A prototype was developed in Germany some 50 years ago [1] but never caught on. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transrapid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transrapid
- thematrixturtle 4y agoShanghai built a demonstration line out to the airport that's still operational and the world's fastest rail line to boot: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_maglev_train https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_maglev_train But it looks like Japan will be the first with a proper intercity line in 2027-ish: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ch%C5%AB%C5%8D_Shinkansen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ch%C5%AB%C5%8D_Shinkansen
- PinguTS 4y agoShanghai IS the Transrapid. Siemens first build it and than sold the whole technology to China, because the Transrapid is basically dead end. I think, they extended the original track later on. But no new one will be ever build.
- cgeier 4y agoWhile similar technology, a lot more of that technology went into the train instead of the track which makes this new solution much cheaper to produce.
- dzonga 4y agoseems it's another maglev train solution. maglev trains seemed cool watching videos close to 2 decades ago. seems they're coming to fruition finally something to get excited about
- bluGill 4y agoNot something to get excited about because maglev doesn't solve any of the real problems trains have in the real world.
- cgeier 4y agoThis is very similar to existing maglev trains (such as transrapid) but has the advantage that a lot of the technology is now in the trains, not in the track. That makes construction of such tracks a lot cheaper (but separate and new tracks are needed anyway). Also, this new system is designed for cruising speeds of up to 150 km/h (instead of 500 km/h). But in addition to passenger transport, they seem to be able to carry freight as well. Last year there was a demo track for container transport in Hamburg's harbour [1], not sure, if it's still there. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tee6BjDY0N8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tee6BjDY0N8
- rob74 4y agoThe question in my mind is just: if not for higher speeds, why should you build a maglev line instead of a conventional (high speed / regular) train line? IMHO the other purported advantages are not really convincing - it may be a little bit quieter, but the "flexible track routing" sounds very unconvincing: at ground level you would have to fence off the track, so in an urban setting it would probably end up on stilts most of the time. And if you consider that, phrases like "Visually appealing track route for urban use without overhead lines" sound a bit ridiculous - is a concrete guideway on concrete stilts really more visually appealing than tram (or train) rails with overhead line? (In case anyone is wondering: Germany has the luxury problem of having all other cables - power, telecom, etc. - 99% underground, so they can debate the aesthetic impact of overhead lines of trams. Not an issue in most other countries.)
- albertopv 4y agoI live near a railway where over 100 trains pass every day, most are freight ones. They are very, very noisy, even a small reduction could help when these lines are within cities.
- Transrapid 4y ago
- moepstar 4y agohttps://www.google.com/maps/place/Transport+System+B%C3%B6gl;+Teststrecke+Sengenthal/@49.2188392,11.4515338,2088m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m13!1m7!3m6!1s0x479f6ff1a330a0ab:0xc3fd8c0f971ccc66!2s92318+Neumarkt+in+der+Oberpfalz!3b1!8m2!3d49.2772606!4d11.4671995!3m4!1s0x479f719cb20e84fb:0xd2b24f87dcfc090d!8m2!3d49.213866!4d11.4559458 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Transport+System+B%C3%B6gl... This is their test track, on the right-hand side of the road (edit: click on the picture, there's also a 360° panorama of the track)
- abrudz 4y agoWhy do they have a re-painted Transrapid 07 on their grounds?[1] Trnasrapid seems like a much more mature and capable design than their own. E.g. While Transrapid uses a T-shaped track, Bögl uses a U-shaped track. That's not going to work well with snow or falling leaves, not to mention people on platforms discarding items into the tracks… [1] https://www.google.com/maps/place/Transport+System+B%C3%B6gl;+Teststrecke+Sengenthal/@49.213866,11.4559458,3a,75y,90t/data=!3m8!1e2!3m6!1sAF1QipMz2ZnvatshNrFscsTiwZAYEU-lUBoCGGpGyhb1!2e10!3e12!6shttps:%2F%2Flh5.googleusercontent.com%2Fp%2FAF1QipMz2ZnvatshNrFscsTiwZAYEU-lUBoCGGpGyhb1%3Dw114-h86-k-no!7i4032!8i3024!4m5!3m4!1s0x479f719cb20e84fb:0xd2b24f87dcfc090d!8m2!3d49.213866!4d11.4559458 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Transport+System+B%C3%B6gl...
- usr1106 4y agoThey bought it for 1 Euro from Deutsche Bahn. Deutsche Bahn have given up the idea that it's something you could advertise for a brighter future with so they must have been happy to get rid of it without getting bad press for destroying industrial heritage. Max Bögl participated in the construction of the Shanghai line. So I guess they thought it would be nice exhibit of being a global player.
- PinguTS 4y agoWe should not forget the backstory of this company. Max Bögel is the largest family-owned construction company in Germany. They build mainly infrastructure like roads, but where also involved in the Gigafactory in Grünheide in Germany. So, for them its a new business unit to build more infrastructure as a whole contractor. They can delivery everything, not like it is today in infrastructure projects where you have many different contractors providing different parts. So, they want to sell more concrete.
- iggldiggl 4y agoLooking at that page, it's also marketed as a fully turn-key solution with really everything (design, track construction, vehicles, signalling) provided by Bögl, so they presumably also hope to get some sort of lock-in effect where buyers of their system continue being dependent on them for any ongoing maintenance or future expansions, too. For how this can go wrong, look at the story of the Translohr (some sort of guided bus touted as a cheaper alternative to a conventional steel wheel tram), where the cities who bought that system subsequently had difficulties in persuading Alstom (who had bought up the tram part of the Translohr technology and eventually decided to sort of discontinue that system) to continue providing maintenance support or possibly even additional vehicles for the exisiting Translohr installations.
- usr1106 4y agoInteresting, lived in Germany for 30 years (although decades ago), but had never heard about them. Just wanted to say if the Transrapid consortium with the biggest German industry players and decades of public investment backing could not make it, I would not try again. This is not the SW business where any can start with some resources rented in the cloud. Of course sometimes it's just too early to be right, but wouldn't count on it. On the anecdotal side my first presentation in school around 1972 was about the German Maglev train project. It did not go as predicted, they sold one minor line to Shanghai decades later.
- mschuster91 4y agoEdmund Stoiber's infamous 10 minute speech killed the Transrapid in Munich. One of the OG German memes.
- wffurr 4y agoQuiet, fast elevated trains and commuter rail would be amazing, but at this point in the US I'd settle for existing at all or in the few cities that have rail systems, equipment that's not >50 years old and can actually stay on the tracks, be on time, and have reasonable levels of service. But even that extremely low bar isn't achievable. Meanwhile, local, state, and federal government can find $200 billion dollars a year to spend on roads so we can all be stuck in traffic on good quality pavement...
- ucosty 4y agoAnother day, another gadgetbahn. It's hard to tell from their website exactly what problems they're trying to solve. They seem to have taken all of the worst aspects of monorail style operations, the relative complexity of maglev, and the vendor lock-in of a gadgetbahn and have just run with it. Off the top of my head: From their rolling (gliding?) stock concepts it looks like they're targeting the automated metro system market, think London DLR or Vancouver Skytrain. With these system top speed isn't really the issue as you'll be constrained by acceleration and stop spacing. Better gains can be had in this space by building better signalling systems, allowing the trains to run at higher frequencies. All of their marketing materials show the trains going in perfect straight lines. A lot of other monorail systems are constrained by this, because building switches for monorails is hard. Throw maglev into the mix and I can't imagine the problem gets any easier. They focus a bit on ease of construction with the elevated rail segments being made of pre-cast concrete sections. I'm faily certain any modern elevated train guideway is also made of pre-made sections on a production line. They're trying to sell normal as some kind of innovation. All the usual gadgetbahn things seem to apply as well. TSB goes bust? Good luck getting new rolling stock. Want to integrate this service with existing stations and track? Nope, it's all bespoke. Want to get rolling stock from a different supplier that can meet your local needs better? Good luck with that one. Nobody else buys this system, so it remains expensive forever? Sucks to be you.
- bluGill 4y agoMaglev has some advantages for high speed operation: less rolling resistance at speed (but worse in slow sections - while not rolling resistance, at low speed they are not as efficient), and less track maintenance. Problem is until you get to high speed those advantages are not worth it, and when you do air resistance is very expensive and so you need a lot more riders or a high ticket price. In the end maglev isn't worth it. It is only marginally faster than regular rail, and a lot slower than flying. You can bring a few cities just outside of regular rail range into train range, but if you just let those people fly you overall have a cheaper system. Sticking to standard rail means that you can share track with other service. While this isn't easy (you need a lot of people in the office ensuring the schedule works) the options make it well worth it. Even if you only share rail overnight when you are running less service, 24 hour service is something all cities should have on all lines.
- rincewind 4y agoIt's really hard to figure out how the system differs from PeopleMover. Is this new tech, or just a new vendor for basically the same design they have at Disney? Wait, is this a MagLev peoplemover?
- Shadonototra 4y agoNice, but it looks ugly AF, it feels very "industrial" I can't imagine this in the middle of EU architecture Or in the middle of Asian temples, or in the middle of a beautiful landscape They really need better designers Also the front doesn't look like aerodynamic
- azalemeth 4y agoThe website doesn't actually say how it works. I can imagine it fitting with some (admittedly german) aesthetics.
- danw1979 4y agoI mean, it looks a lot like the DLR in London which is a bit of a raised concrete eyesore too. But it’s not what you’d choose to plonk down in Vienna or Bruges, I agree.
- tgv 4y agoDid you ever see the Brugge train station? Anything looks better.
- Someone 4y agoTrains are relatively long in proportion to their width. That makes the sides of the trains become relatively more important for aerodynamics than the fronts. Possibly, making the front more aerodynamic has so many disadvantages that it’s not worth it. For example, a train with a long nose means less space for passengers in a given length of train. It also may be a bad choice aerodynamically if you want to have the ability to combine multiple railroad cars into a single train.
- SideburnsOfDoom 4y agoIf it's ugly AF and it takes 10K cars off the roads, then it's not that ugly. Much like "if it's stupid but it works, then it's not stupid". "EU architecture" already juxtaposes ornate pre-1900 buildings with brutalist concrete blocks and glass spires, so no change there.
- 4y ago