9 ms·
The Ten Commandments for Detective Fiction (2017)
- Balarny 4y agoUmineko fans represent
- teddyfrozevelt 4y agoWhere are my Virtue's Last Reward fans at?
- jawns 4y agoOne reason why I prefer the classics (Agatha Christie, G.K. Chesterton, Arthur Conan Doyle, etc.) is that a lot of modern mystery authors think they need to be both mystery writers and comedians. The voice of the narrator, if not the characters themselves, is often snarky and sarcastic, and I find it incredibly off-putting. So if I could offer an additional commandment, it would be to acknowledge that you might be as clever as you think you are, but you're probably not as funny as you think you are.
- JackFr 4y agoBut to a large extent the appeal of Poirot and Miss Marple is the levity they add.
- baud147258 4y agoI found that Father Brown from G.K. Chesterton also added a lot of levity > the reader deserves a fighting chance to solve the mystery without the author’s use of cheap tricks. though I found he frequently didn't leave much (any?) chance for the reader to solve the mystery, though for me the mystery and its solution was never really the focus of the stories anyway.
- mikepurvis 4y agoNot the GP, but I think there's a difference between a leading character who is inherently humorous or says humorous things vs the narrator doing it. And in cases where the narrative is first person from the perspective of someone in the story (mostly famously The Murder of Roger Ackroyd), it should remain relatively flat and observational rather than being puffed up with a lot of that character's thoughts, opinions, or personality.
- fenomas 4y agoI've noticed this - but for me it's not the comedy per se, it's that modern authors (particularly in the noir style) want their detective to be a constant source of witty comebacks. You feel like the other characters are just there to deliver setup lines, so the detective can amaze us with his devastating zingers. Ironically, Raymond Chandler - whom I imagine many such modern authors are trying to imitate - commented somewhere in his letters that the detective should almost never get the punchline. He pointed out that it was more effective to have the bad guy deliver the zinger, and the detective just take it on the chin and shrug it off, leaving the heel unsure whether to try to top his own line or just awkwardly make his exit.
- hirundo 4y agoDective fiction is usually about the process of justice when someone breaks a commandment, frequently the sixth, often involving seven, eight and nine. I'm looking forward to the meta-detective novel in which a critic investigates violations of the Ten Commandments of Detective Fiction. The appropriate punishment might be more suitable to a fantasy novel: To sentence the writer live for a time as a character in a world built by an even more arbitrary, capricious and inscrutable author than Jehovah. I'd read that.
- ModernMech 4y agoAn additional commandment I can think of is that the crime has to be something significant, like a murder. I wouldn’t want to read a story about a detective solving a petty crime or finding a lost dog.
- nobody9999 4y ago> An additional commandment I can think of is that the crime has to be something significant, like a murder. I wouldn’t want to read a story about a detective solving a petty crime or finding a lost dog. Dirk Gently[0] would like a word... [0]] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirk_Gently_(pilot_episode) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirk_Gently_(pilot_episode)
- ModernMech 4y agoI think you've kind of proven my point, as Dirk Gently is more of a comedy than a mystery. The absurdity of a detective finding a lost cat is what makes it funny. And then all the rest about time travel... I mean, if you want to make a comedy mystery you would want to violate as many of these "commandments" as you could.
- nobody9999 4y ago>I think you've kind of proven my point, as Dirk Gently is more of a comedy than a mystery. The absurdity of a detective finding a lost cat is what makes it funny. And then all the rest about time travel... I mean, if you want to make a comedy mystery you would want to violate as many of these "commandments" as you could. A reasonable point. Although I'd say that humor (if done well) is a boon, rather than a detriment to mysteries (most fiction, actually). And cats always make things better[2]! As someone who enjoys mystery novels, I've noted that minor mysteries are often used as a device to bring the detective into situations where larger issues may be afoot[0][1]. It seems to me that if a mystery is engaging, the underlying "crime" isn't as relevant as the storytelling, clue planting and the thought process of the detective. At the same time, mysteries generally deal with serious crimes (especially murder), as it amps up the (fictional) stakes and provides a reason for the interest and participation of the detective. But that needn't be the case -- as long as the mystery is interesting, the prose is of good quality and the characters engaging. At least that's my take. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Red-Headed_League https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Red-Headed_League [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Adventure_of_the_Clapham_Cook_(short_story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Adventure_of_the_Clapham_C... [2] cf. Lillian Jackson Braun's "The Cat Who..." mysteries[3]. [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cat_Who_series https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cat_Who_series Edit: Fixed reference indices.
- mypastself 4y agoLove all of these (including the seemingly offensive “Chinaman” one), but I disagree with most of the updated list. Contemporary mystery authors too often feel the need to create the illusion of depth by having alcoholic protagonists with messy personal lives. It’s cliche, and it put me off the genre for good about a decade ago.
- hpkuarg 4y ago> the Celestial is over-equipped in the matter of brains, and under-equipped in the matter of morals. Indeed, what a line!
- john-radio 4y agoFull context matters here: > Why this should be so I do not know, unless we can find a reason for it in our western habit of assuming that the Celestial is over-equipped in the matter of brains, and under-equipped in the matter of morals. Knox is criticizing this assumption, not endorsing it. > I only offer it as a fact of observation that, if you are turning over the pages of a book and come across some mention of ‘the slit-like eyes of Chin Loo', you had best put it down at once; it is bad. I definitely agree with Knox's harsh judgment of the books that used to include such lines! I am reminded of the many ridiculous and racist caricatures of Chinese, African, Native American, and many other cultures in the (otherwise fairly wonderful) Tintin comics by Hergé. Of course, writing a rule against including any Chinese people in detective fiction is going much too far, and is also racist; but no doubt Knox's writing here is a product of his time. In fact, the first detective novel I ever read was "Walking Shadow" by Robert B. Parker, where his tough PI Spenser and his comrades Hawk and Susan Silverman go up against some Boston area tongs, and the Chinese people in that book are interesting, "round" characters; so I'm glad Parker had either never heard of this particular rule and chose to ignore it.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoHow about "Don't make the murderer a stereotype". (I suspect the Chinaman rule is in there because at the time, a bunch of less-well-done detective stories used it as an easy way to make a villainous villain. Well, until recently, you could do the same with the stereotyped-villain-du-jour. Depending on your audience, you still could today.)
- becquerel 4y agoPaul Auster's City of Glass is a good postmodernist read which violates a lot of these rules and other conventions of the genre.
- InitialLastName 4y agoThe other two books in his New York Trilogy (Ghosts and The Locked Room) do a similar job of deconstructing the genre in different, similarly mindbending ways. As an aside, I've never seen anyone do a better job of describing the very specific feeling of long walks in Manhattan. I recommend it to anyone who doesn't understand the joy I find there.
- keiferski 4y agoAlso worth reading in this genre is Raymond Chandler’s The Simple Art of Murder: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Simple_Art_of_Murder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Simple_Art_of_Murder https://www.fadedpage.com/books/20140930/html.php#Page_1 https://www.fadedpage.com/books/20140930/html.php#Page_1
- greggeter 4y agoFunny how many modern movies break most of these rules
- lqet 4y agoThis seems like a perfect set of rules to write dull detective fiction. Some of the best works I have read (or seen) from this genre violate a lot of these rules.
- thomascgalvin 4y agoYou have to know the rules to break them effectively. Like, if your story is about a new kind of poison, which your reader cannot know anything about, awesome. But understand that your story is now about that new poison, not about solving the murder, because solving the murder is impossible without special, in-universe knowledge.
- watwut 4y agoGood authors did not started by writing hundred formulaic stories first. Instead, they tended to seek own way even as they learned from predecessors. I don't like this saying, because in literature and art generally it leads to formulaic repetitive stories. If you dont break rules before learning them, you will never learn to break them. And when it is most common advice there is, we get the situation in which you can predict the rest of average book or movie after first 10 minutes. It is much better when authors treat rules as optional formulas - follow or not and be aware there is a lot more to choose from.
- thomascgalvin 4y ago> Good authors did not started by writing hundred formulaic stories first. Maybe not hundreds, but I bet many good authors started by writing a few dozen formulaic stories first. Humans learn through mimicry, and I don't think storytelling is any different. > If you dont break rules before learning them, you will never learn to break them. If you're good at your craft, you end up learning the rules regardless; the only question is how efficient are you at doing do? The best way to learn is through mistakes, but you can choose to learn from others' mistakes, so you don't need to make them yourself. That's what the "rules" are: things other people have done, that didn't work. They aren't absolutes, but they're good starting points, and until you have some sort of intuition about things, breaking the rules should at least make you stop and consider why you're doing so, and if you're doing so in a way that will work.
- ldjb 4y agoSee also: S.S. Van Dine's Twenty Rules for Writing Detective Stories https://www.openculture.com/2016/02/20-rules-for-writing-detective-stories.html https://www.openculture.com/2016/02/20-rules-for-writing-det...
- harpersealtako 4y agoI know this one from the Umineko visual novel series. Detectives in the Umineko universe are dimension-hopping reality auditors who wield the "rules of detective fiction" as rhetorical weapons (and sometimes literal weapons) when jumping into stories to fight against witches who are trying to create unsolvable mysteries to increase peoples' belief in magic. There's one detective who uses Knox's 10 rules, and another who uses Van Dine's 20 rules. It's a really fun, really meta story, one where the main characters are both participants in the story and genre-savvy readers debating who the murderer is using trope knowledge.
- ilamont 4y agoIs there a similar formula for science fiction or fantasy? It seems that the rules are looser, particularly for scifi, but maybe multiple formulas exist within the genre.
- purist33 4y agoThou shalt not cite Quantum theory for everything.
- baud147258 4y agoNor nanomachines (looking at you, Metal Gear Solid 4)
- dekhn 4y agoIt's interesting to think of Big Lebowski as a detective movie and compare it to the rules that are in this including the Chinaman. "Walter Sobchak: What the f** are you talking about? The chinaman is not the issue here, dude. I'm talking about drawing a line in the sand, dude. Across this line, you DO NOT... Also, dude, chinaman is not the preferred nomenclature. Asian-American, please."
- inasio 4y agoOne of my favorite detective stories is Dead yellow women, by Dashiell Hammett. Includes a crazy chase through hidden tunnels in San Francisco's (early 1900s, opium dens, etc) Chinatown.
- cafard 4y agoDid the original essay specifically mention Who Killed Roger Ackroyd? I read it a long time ago. Also, there is, for those not big on detective fiction, Edmund Wilson's essay "Who Cares Who Killed Roger Ackroyd?"
- karaterobot 4y agoIt doesn't mention that one, but it alludes to it. See also Who Killed Roger Ackroyd by Pierre Bayard, in which the author argues for a different outcome to the case.
- havblue 4y ago>I. The criminal must be someone mentioned in the early part of the story, but must not be anyone whose thoughts the reader has been allowed to follow. I've often been annoyed at modern police shows like law and order that I think fail to introduce the suspects sufficiently. The modern formula seems more like one suspect leads to another then another then another then the confession. There's seldom any way for the viewer to suspect who's actually guilty early on, unlike murder she wrote or columbo, so there's no payoff when you find out who it was.
- a1o 4y agoDoesn't Law and Order oftenly introduce the criminal early on? It's not about the investigative part, but being able to go through the full law enforcement process including the judgment part. Law and Order isn't a detective show in my opinion.
- nineplay 4y ago> The stupid friend of the detective, the Watson, Watson was not stupid and I wouldn't trust an author who read him that way. Matched with > Thou shalt strive to create a detective who has flaws. it suggests audiences who must be spoon-fed or they will be lost and confused. "The Detective Solves Crimes To Ease The Guilt Over His Tragic Loss And The Side Character Has No Backstory So Don't Waste Any Mental Space On Him!!"
- mysterydip 4y agoJust finished season 1 of "Only Murders in the Building", and it has some great examples of these principles IMHO.
- tpoacher 4y ago> The detective must not himself commit the crime Violation of this rule ruined an otherwise amazing PC game for me, which shall remain nameless to avoid spoilers. It was borderline silly to have the detective you played for 90% of the game narrating his thoughts on what clues meant, and on who the culprit might be, only to then turn out to be the murderer ...
- ThePadawan 4y ago(Trying to stay spoiler-free) I'm trying to discover which one you mean - I remember one which matches somewhat, but in which you control so many characters that you definitely don't spend 90% of the time controlling the one that ends up being the culprit. (But that game also just threw a handful of red herrings at the wall that ended up being completely meaningless, so it was a bit of a lame duck, rushed into release like all the releases by this "auteur" have been before and since) Apart from that, on the not strictly speaking detective side of things, there is also Planescape: Torment which pulled this whole idea off spectacularly (to the point that it has become tropey in the other direction again).
- mecha_ghidorah 4y agoIf it is the game I think you are thinking about then I disagree that you control "so many characters", but yeah you aren't controlling the culprit most of the time. Also god the plot of that game was dumb and made no sense at all
- tpoacher 4y agoNow I'm curious which one you are talking about :D I was talking about this one: https://bit.ly/3uvMGst https://bit.ly/3uvMGst Yes, Planescape Torment is amazing, but at the same time, the whole "it was you all along" is clear from the beginning of the game, the game doesn't try to mislead you in any way.
- ThePadawan 4y ago( I was talking about https://bit.ly/3AyXgCI https://bit.ly/3AyXgCI )
- watwut 4y ago> Watson, must not conceal any thoughts which pass through his mind; his intelligence must be slightly, but very slightly, below that of the average reader At some point, I realized that Watson is much less dumb, then submissive and constantly verbally bullied. Or rather, that we perceive him through the way Sherlock (or his equivalent) constantly puts him down, even when his reactions are not dumb at all. And since Watson equivalent never stand up for himself, he is dumb for reader who don't think about him. And once you notice it, it is quite frequent in literature. When character gets insulted by other characters without standing up for himself, people will take from it that character is stupid - even in cases where that character was completely normal or even for right all along. It actually works the same way in real life too. > science Interestingly, when you look at detective stories with scientific accuracy, the evidence detectives use is super shoddy. Most of it is at bike-marks accuracy at best - guaranteed to imprison innocents often. All this is because I read too many of detective stories.
- ksdale 4y agoI'm always complaining to my wife about movies with a detective/mystery component where the key to the whole thing is revealed after the mystery is solved and is is something that we, as viewers, could not possibly have known. It feels the same as using magic. It's always seemed to me that it should be possible for the viewer to solve the mystery at the same time as the protagonist, given only what the viewer knows so far. It's validating to see that this is considered a vital component of a detective story, at least by some.
- _def 4y agoEverytime I read articles like this I feel the urge to make writing a hobby, but I just can't get to it. Feels like I'm missing out but I'm not sure.