12 ms·
Vets today are like doctors yesterday
- giantkittycat 4y ago
- atwood22 4y ago> Many of the conditions that vets see don’t have specific drugs associated with them (or even high quality studies), so vets often have to get creative. > If I want to market to doctors, I’m best served by having high-profile researchers in that specific indication and high profile studies. Ideally, I’d also get a change to the treatment protocols, too. If I want to market to vets, I’m best served by having well-known speakers (who don’t necessarily specialize in that indication) and well-run (not high-profile) studies. > There's something sad about what American physicians have become. Yes, we have an expectation today that medical procedures be backed by scientific evidence of efficacy. It's not like the "good ol' days" where doctors had carte blanche to do whatever they want. If you want to market a product without scientific evidence that it works, go ahead, just don't do it when people's lives are on the line.
- betaby 4y ago... and then we have dentists. With the treatment variability of x10 in price and procedures 'needed'.
- vanattab 4y agoMy understanding is the price variability in dentistry is much less then for various other medical procedures. I have been told it because much of dental work is non inssured but I am just relying what I have heard.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stubybubs 4y agoAs the meme goes: > Being an old-timey doctor would rule, just drunk as hell like “yeah u got ghosts in your blood, you should do cocaine about it”
- elif 4y agoThe problem with that perspective is that it essentially dooms every "life on the line" with a condition which can not be established with "scientific evidence" For a simple example, the multitude of young lives lost to cancer because "scientific evidence" does not support screening before age 50. That perspective seeks to minimize and mischaracterize early warning symptoms because of public health probabilities.
- i_cannot_hack 4y agoAre you implying that more active screening would cause more good than harm, and that the scientific evidence that shows otherwise is mistaken? What makes you think the evidence is wrong? Screening is a very complicated topic and being overly aggressive with screening can really hurt patients. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yNzQ_sLGIuA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yNzQ_sLGIuA Or do you simply not support using scientific evidence and/or harm reduction to guide medical policy? What do you propose should be used instead in that case?
- ptero 4y agoI think the point is that not all cases are cut and dry. There are many for which evidence is inconclusive; and for those having a blanket regulation is worse than letting the patient and the doctor select a choice that the patient prefers.
- i_cannot_hack 4y agoThen they chose a poor example to illustrate their point, since anyone is free to book a cancer screening even if they are younger than the recommended age, if they so prefer.
- kurthr 4y agoYou can try and book anything you like, but the doctor/technologist is under no obligation to actually run the screening test for you, and if they do there is not requirement that your insurance pay for it. So you can have a full body MRI reference done, but it will cost many k$ out of pocket, if you can get someone to do it for you.
- lettergram 4y agoWho are you or some nameless fed to tell me I can’t take drugs of choice? That’s insanely authoritarian.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoThe government routinely legislates public health issues.
- lettergram 4y agoYes, an the government in the west is very totalitarian by historic views. Recall the United States declared independence over 1/4 the taxes we have today and “no representation”. Now, I can’t buy antibiotics for myself (but I can for my fish or cow) over the counter. Wtf world is this.
- RugnirViking 4y agoyou are angry that antibiotics are restricted? You know why that is, right?
- atwood22 4y agoAntibiotic use in food-producing animals is regulated by the FDA.
- pessimizer 4y agoThat's not responsive. Nobody is asking what does happen, they're asking why it should happen on this specific issue. I can make you pray in school and call it public health.
- derefr 4y ago> Yes, we have an expectation today that medical procedures be backed by scientific evidence of efficacy. Statistical evidence of efficacy, you mean. Doctors today are much less "scientific", insofar as they're less willing to work with a patient to try to experimentally derive an intervention that will work uniquely well for that patient. Instead, modern doctors try to fit the patient into a coarse-grained statistical mold, and then apply the flowcharts of rote treatments that are "proven" to work for people who were labelled as fitting that mold according to some arm of a trial. They persist in this, even when it can be seen that the individual patient isn't responding. A doctor who's actually practicing medicine as science would, for example, run a patient up the current DSMV flowchart for treatment of depression, rather than down it — first determining, as the most important step, whether the most hard-line treatment will do anything at all for the patient; before then finding the weakest treatment that will still have a useful effect. Also, a doctor practicing medicine as science would be doing a lot less "try this because it has no side-effects, regardless of whether you're likely to be a responder to it", and a lot more measurement to "cleave the problem-space at the joints." (Yes, ER doctors can't afford time to measure. Most doctors are not ER doctors.)
- brnt 4y agoI'm glad somebody is making the distinction between scientific experimentalism and executing a protocol based on scientific research. I've worked in medicine as an experimental phycisist (radiology, imaging), and I found so-called evidence based medicine anything but. Evidence based is used to cement existing methods over new ones into protocols that are very, very slow to evolve.
- rscho 4y agoIf doctors did science on each patient (which would open up a huge can of legal liability worms), you'd pay ten times as much for healthcare.
- kcexn 4y agoThis is just the trolley problem from ethics. A doctor who follows those course grained recommendations derived from statistical evidence will provide the best outcomes to the most patients in aggregate. A doctor who tries to uniquely discover the best outcome for each individual as they come through, may provide the best outcome for any given individual. But overall the deviation from the statistically recommended procedure will lead to worse outcomes in aggregate. It has to, because if it lead to better outcomes, the doctors 'personalized' process should become the statistically validated process with time. When initially presented with the trolley problem, most people side with the saving the group over the individual. It's funny how quickly their minds change when they realise that in a healthcare context, they are never the group, they are always the individual. Measurement in medicine is also in many cases not particularly quantitative. E.g., fatigue, pain, cognitive dysfunction etc. So taking more measurements doesn't necessarily give you any useful information. In fact, near as I can tell. In the US, there is so much fear from doctors of misdiagnosing and starting patients on the wrong treatment plan, that they order too many measurements. Overall reducing the quality of care. The time needed to take measurements, as well as the risks of measurements are not negligible factors in healthcare outcomes.
- greatgib 4y agoHis analysis is based on the comparison between his grand father era and his mother area ; but this predicate is if not wrong, at least still unproved. He took a sample of 2 persons, with different characteristics and made deductions based on that. Nothing can't be deduced from his sample in fact. For example, we compare at the same time a 'psychiatrist' from period X, to a 'dermatologist' from period Y. Psychiatrists in general will not have the same mentality as dermatologists! Medecines in the psychiatrist area will meddle with the brain and will try to affect the mood of a patient. Effects are hard to measure and side effects often unclear. At the opposite, it is quite easy to see the effects and side effects of medecines in dermatology. You can tell someone: go have a walk in the forest and your depression might pass, but your scabies problem will not resolve itself alone like that...
- plaguepilled 4y agoThank you, there needs to be way more statistical skepticism for situations like this.
- classichasclass 4y agoAs an MD who is the son of a DVM: Dad had his interests (hip dysplasia and veterinary orthopaedics) but was comfortable with pretty much everything including dentistry, most surgery and internal medicine. Newer DVMs do specialize somewhat in the sense that they tend to adopt more limited scopes of practice. There are even some that don't do spays and neuters which would have horrified my late father; those and vaccinations were the business bread and butter. Veterinary HMOs and PPOs are still a small part of the market and Dad never took them or completed claim forms for clients, but they're growing. When I was in general practice I had a fair number of fee-for-service and cash pay patients (most were Medicaid/dual Medi-Medi and some HMO-PPO, but not the overwhelming majority), and I had the list of the (then) $4 drugs at the local supermarket pharmacies and we used that like a formulary to keep their out-of-pocket costs down. I'd say about a third of my patients were pediatric, the rest adults, and a smattering of prenatal. However, by modern standards even though we're trained to do it in family medicine I don't think many family practice physicians do full-scope because of the liability, particularly for prenatal care. I'm not in general care anymore, though I still see patients intermittently. Veterinarians may have been more like yesterday's primary care a decade ago, but I'd argue that's increasingly no longer true.
- mrtranscendence 4y agoAs far as I can tell, specialization is increasingly popular. Within the past few years I've dealt personally with vets who specialized entirely in ophthalmology, oncology, and obstetrics. At the same practice as my oncologist there are specialists in cardiology and internal medicine as well. I've also had to seek out specialists in rabbit care, which are surprisingly hard to find (though no vet I'm aware of treats solely rabbits -- usually they're exotic vets often with a "real" specialty in birds).
- jaqalopes 4y agoInteresting article. I agree with other commenters that change in medical science over time probably necessitates changes in the industry, but I don't think this precludes making the work of medical professionals less onerous and expensive. Prior authorizations in particular seem like a uniquely wasteful and American phenomenon, whereby time (and thus money) is burned just so doctors and insurance can try to get on the same page. That cost, we can be sure, is then passed along to patients, on both the service and insurance ends. But more interesting to me, the broad picture in this article is of a world in which insurers have steadily clawed away more and more diagnostic and prescriptive responsibilities away from doctors, because the economic logic of a world with private health insurance allows them to do so, to the detriment of doctors' lives (as the article describes) but more saliently (for an American non-doctor like me) to that of all Americans trying to receive healthcare via insurance. I think it's pretty hard to dispute this phenomenon is real and harmful. The question, which this article doesn't really address, is what to do about it?
- daguava 4y agoTook my dog who tore his ACL to the vet in Kiel, WI. They wanted to put him on life ending pain medication which would get him a few more months tops. Took him to another vet in a local smaller community with staff that actually cared, they were able to properly wire the tendon and give that dog 5 years relatively pain-free life. Many vets are absolute hacks and need to be roasted for it.
- Hellbanevil 4y ago
- vlovich123 4y agoMy experience with vets is extremely different. Either I’ll go to one that’ll charge significantly more for testing/operations or the one that charges less will make up the difference by aggressively pushing unnecessary testing and treatment (and charging insane materials rates for something as simple as saline). I wouldn’t look towards veterinary medicine as the model, at least not from what I’ve seen (granted a lot of this exists for human treatments too).
- lettergram 4y ago> My grandfather, trained in an era before strong FDA regulation of medications, was mostly distrustful of medications. Technically that Supreme Court ruling on the EPA is going to likely impact the FDA. At least, it’s a sign of where the Supreme Court is at on the issue. All the FDA has congressional authority over is labeling between states. That is to say; the FDA labels a drug as safe and you can advertise for said drug. That’s it. There is nothing stopping you from ordering and taking almost any drug. At least in a legal sense. Provided it’s not regulated by congress (such as opium and derivatives). It’s why doctors can prescribe “off label” and what not. It’s very common.
- runnerup 4y agoThere's no way this Supreme Court is going to alter the CSA. Edit: Thank you Peyton for the additional context. I didn't realize that. I was reacting to "There is nothing stopping you from ordering and taking almost any drug." and I'd be shocked if the Supreme Court altered the interpretation of the CSA in such a way to allow arbitrary people to order controlled substances without a doctors prescription. Even if their state law allowed it.
- junofan 4y agoThey did a couple days ago.
- mellavora 4y agoTo add to Peyton's comment: "On June 27, 2022, the United States Supreme Court ruled that doctors who act in subjective good faith in prescribing controlled substances to their patients cannot be convicted under the Controlled Substance Act (“CSA”). The Court’s decision will have broad implications for physicians and patients alike. Practitioners who sincerely and honestly believe – even if mistakenly – that their prescriptions are within the usual course of professional practice will be shielded from criminal liability. ... The Court’s decision will protect patient access to prescriptions written in good faith. However, for the government, the Court’s decision means prosecutors face an uphill battle in charging, much less convicting, physicians under the CSA. Indeed, the Court’s decision may have a chilling effect on the recent surge in DOJ prosecutions of medical practitioners and pain clinics. " https://www.natlawreview.com/article/update-opioid-liability-ruling-doctors-scotus-deals-blow-to-doj https://www.natlawreview.com/article/update-opioid-liability...
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoTangentially related: I think the price of veterinary care is likely the best (albeit still an imperfect) estimator of how much human healthcare actually costs. There are virtually no price distortions caused by insurance markets, single payer systems, or strict regulations. It’s the closest thing to a fully free market in healthcare there is.
- spaetzleesser 4y agoThat's probably true. They also like to sell expensive but useless treatments. What's missing is clear information about efficacy of treatments.
- lostcolony 4y agoUh...it still has the "you need this or you see a loved one suffer" thing going for it which leads to an ability to seek maximum profit. Large multinationals are monopolizing by buying out small vet practices, also allowing them to set prices. And those monopolies not only offer their own insurance, but there are also numerous others offering pet insurance. So it might be the "closest thing to a fully free market in healthcare there is (in the US)", in that it's slightly better than the human healthcare market...but that's it. It's still nowhere close. And there are plenty of other markets, all of them cheaper, and many with better outcomes...though I guess few countries with "freer" markets (since pretty much every other western country either has a single payer system, or has mandatory private insurance or similar, such as Switzerland), so I guess if your point is that having a "free market" approach to healthcare leads to worse outcomes in every instance?
- erosenbe0 4y agoVeterinary medicine technically deals with property, not really loved ones. Numbered dairy cow or muddy sow needing a c-section is an asset, not a loved family member. Pets are loved but they are property with negligible economic value, unlike a human life.
- PetitPrince 4y ago
- oceanplexian 4y agoIn the USA since 1960, healthcare has gone from 5% of GDP to nearly 20% of GDP, something I would consider a crisis. If you think of the enormous amount of money that’s being spent, and then ask if we’re really living better or longer lives, I would disagree. Some might argue that the average lifespan has gone up a 8-10 years, but take out infant mortality, account for improvements in vehicular safety, the fact that most people no longer smoke cigarettes, and improvements in workplace, food and drug safety, and what are you actually left with? I would say most dollars in healthcare are selfishly spent squeezing a year or two of extra time in the twilight of most peoples’ lives, while destroying our society in the process.
- colechristensen 4y agoIt is an American problem, we must do something. Which leads to antibiotics being over prescribed because parents don’t want to leave the doctors office without something to do afterwards. Life is worth living well, but it’s also worth accepting the end, something to which many people are openly hostile.
- cs137 4y agoWhich leads to antibiotics being over prescribed because parents don’t want to leave the doctors office without something to do afterwards. You're not wrong, but sometimes this is purely preemptive and might still be a sound decision. For example, influenza almost never directly kills anyone--the monster flu in 1918 is an exception--whereas secondary bacterial infections (leading to pneumonia) can and do. Antibiotics are often prescribed as an extra precaution; given the atrocious financial resources of most Americans, most doctors know that they only get one shot with most patients, because they can't afford the copays or get the time off work, and that if they under-prescribe and are read to have missed something, they'll face malpractice suits from the desperate. So, they err on the side of immediate caution, since antibiotic resistance is one of those diffuse long-term problems. Life is worth living well, but it’s also worth accepting the end, something to which many people are openly hostile. Part of the problem is that capitalism creates a collapse of trust from which there is no recovery. Is the hospital denying or rationing care based on sound medical reasoning (i.e., that the requested procedures won't work, and will divert resources away from people who need them) or because they don't think the patient will be able to pay? Is the doctor performing a surgery because it will improve the patient's quality of life, or because he needs to generate fees? I'm sure most doctors are ethical and try to make the best decisions for the patients--I imagine, at least 90 percent of them do--but, as soon as the profit motive gets involved, distrust becomes endemic and personally mandatory. Medicine is, to put it bluntly and factually, too important to trust to the profit motive and capitalism.
- mastax 4y agoPrivate Equity is acquiring and combining small practice veterinarians and pet insurance is becoming more common. Soon vet care may feel much more like human care. https://www.axios.com/2022/03/04/pet-care-lures-private-equity https://www.axios.com/2022/03/04/pet-care-lures-private-equi...
- MBCook 4y agoThat’s exactly what I was thinking and I thought it was where the post was going to go. The writer’s grandfather and mother would have seen how it happened in human medicine, I bet very direct comparisons could be drawn to the current state of veterinary medicine by the author.
- notimetorelax 4y agoSome of it seems to be unwinding: http://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2022/06/ftc-takes-second-action-against-jab-consumer-partners-protect-pet-owners-private-equity-firms-rollup-of-veterinary-services-clinics http://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2022/06/f...
- cs137 4y agoThe fact that private equity firms aren't being bombed for the shit they're pulling now--i.e., the way they're moving into the housing market--is an embarrassment to us as a people. When they were playing abstract numbers games, it was easy and well enough to ignore them; now that they're getting involved in things that affect human life, it's time to take action. That said, I don't think pet insurance itself is a bad thing... no one should have to give up on their pet because of bullshit money concerns... but I think insurance should be universal... and we should solve human health insurance first.
- mrtranscendence 4y agoAs much as I love my pets and am willing to spend beaucoup bucks on their health care, I'm not sure I ever see free universal veterinary care being a thing. Too many people human problems will always be there for people to be comfortable using taxes to fund Fido's chemo.
- lofatdairy 4y agoSpeaking from a US perspective: I'll just add onto the point about EHR/EMRs being generally pretty bad. It's like medical IT is about 20 years behind in terms of tech, so I'm not surprised to see that it's contributing to an overall inefficiency in the medical space. On one hand, you have Epic's EMR, which is easily the best in the industry, and reasonably feature-rich and appears appreciated by doctors in my experience. On the other hand, you have almost everyone else, down to utter dogshit like eClinicalWorks (apologies if any employees frequent this forum unless you work in UI/UX, in which case kindly consider a career change), which essentially exists to allow less well-funded operations to meet regulatory requirements (despite the fact that they're literally being sued for failing to meet this bare minimum [^1]). I'll just quickly add on that if you want to write software to connect your EMR/EHR you're in for a bit of a pain to say the least. There's essentially a whole middleman industry for various data solutions like APIs or on-prem SQL databases[^2] that somehow managed to get vendor status with one or several EMR companies or managed to find the obscure way of actually accessing the hospitals' own data. I'll note here too that 1. sometimes the data is stored on site, so you should be able to read it off your own server, but I imagine a decent number of places treat it as SaaS which makes the task more difficult and 2. that I think EHRs should follow the FHIR spec but whether you can openly communicate with the software along this is another problem. I haven't tried to work with Epic, so maybe they're kinder. I know this isn't really the point of the article, but the tech infrastructure around medicine really is shockingly poor. There's a lot of problems with inconvenience (handwriting really is often _that_ much faster than typing stuff into software especially when the software is so un-ergonomic), double-entry (since a lot of operations weren't designed with technology in mind), and lack of inter-operability. Combine this with outdated software infrastructures (I've seen Drs still use windows 7 on hospital laptops since that's the only thing their sw runs on, I've also seen a weird OS that looks like a 98 clone with less features and far slower on modern hardware), annoying problems like shitty WiFi in hospitals, really high stakes since it's patient data, and regulatory pressure - you end up with a system with little new competition, which means no innovations except in extorting hospitals. Apologies for a long rant, but there really is a need for talented developers to work on these sorts of problems, because the current situation is like being forced to either have mountains of paper charts (I visited a small clinic that does exactly 1 operation and they had an entire basement filled with shelves of charts) or use some terrible software and likely have your data locked into it. [^1]: https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/ehr/eclinicalworks-ehr-class-action-lawsuit-onc-certification-inaccurate-medical-records https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/ehr/eclinicalworks-ehr-clas... and https://www.healthcareitnews.com/news/eclinicalworks-sued-nearly-1-billion-inaccurate-medical-records https://www.healthcareitnews.com/news/eclinicalworks-sued-ne... [^2]: Admittedly it's not always clear _what_ they're selling. One rather dubiously named "datasheet" lists "designed to be flexible to support definition changes in an AGILE fashion rather than via a prolonged software development and release cycle" as a feature despite the product being just a MS SQL server with data cloned from the EHR
- zeckalpha 4y agoThere’s an opportunity here in the less regulated pet health space: flip the pipeline around and treat it like a staging environment for human healthcare, rather than a place to expand treatments later to extend ROI. One example: glucose monitors for pets lag a generation or two behind glucose monitors for humans. Releasing a human glucose monitor requires lots of testing and certification. Starting in the pet space and then expanding into humans would allow you to iterate faster than your human health care first competitors.
- gen220 4y agoThere are definitely companies and investors thinking/working in this space. They think if you can demonstrate an ability solve X in “staging” it has a chance to transfer to “prod”. It works better for some things (generally, simpler/smaller and deterministic things) than others. Practically speaking, the human health space is heavily regulated, and the costs associated with compliance are high. Intuitively, to me, there are not many health-specific innovations that one can discover in pet care that will lead to reduced costs in human care. Because most costs are not technologically-induced, rather they’re regulatory or bureaucratic. You can iterate towards a better mouse trap in pet-land, but the time and financial costs of getting that mouse trap FDA-approved do not magically go away, and unfortunately human care is not a very free market, so being a 10x better mousetrap is not enough to break through. The human healthcare market is also stupidly bigger than the pet care space, like 100x depending on what you include in each category. So if you’re after the big bucks, which most investors / investees are, it’s still generally worth it to target humans first. That being said, some are seeing pets as an angle because human stuff is proving so hard and slow-going, they’re willing to experiment with any potential shortcuts. Worked in human health and pet health.
- ben_w 4y agoOne thing I've been wondering about recently is SENS for pets. Lab rats can already be given extreme longevity, but I suspect there are plenty of dog owners who would pay a lot for double or treble life expectancy for their pets, especially as the lab rat with that treatment (reportedly) spent their years close to the peak of fitness.
- EricE 4y agoOverregulation has done more to shift the focus of healthcare from actually providing healthcare to instead feeding the bureaucracy. I switched to a health savings account and regularly negotiate paying for things with cash instead of going through insurance and the cost difference is mind blowing - routinely 1/3 to 1/5 the amount if you force your doctors to go through insurance.
- gumby 4y agoOne difference is that doctors don’t have the high suicide rate veterinarians do: https://blogs.cdc.gov/niosh-science-blog/2019/09/04/veterinary-suicide/ https://blogs.cdc.gov/niosh-science-blog/2019/09/04/veterina...
- xlii 4y agoI’m not surprised by that. Being in the veterinary care with my small pet (which I learned have very short all-good to all-dead journey) I noticed that vet clinic is a very depressing place. Sure, animals are cute, but a lot of them are dying or seriously ill and even being in the waiting room where loving owners rush-in scared or wait restlessly worried about their pets’ lives is a dark experience. Seeing how vets are handling animals I’d say it takes a very specific mindset and resolution to do the job. I can imagine that even the hardest of such resolutions can crack under the weight of owners breaking down over their pets misery. I believe that everyone should have access to periodic mental health evaluation, support and professional supervision. For people working in such hard to digest professions it is a necessity.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrtranscendence 4y ago> Being in the veterinary care with my small pet (which I learned have very short all-good to all-dead journey) I noticed that vet clinic is a very depressing place. I wouldn't call them small (necessarily), but this is my experience with rabbits. Over the decade we've taken care of them we've gone at least five or six times from "everything's okay" to "Georgie's lethargic and won't eat" -- which can mean death -- in the span of a few hours. So I'm driving over an hour each way in the middle of the night to take my rabbit to the nearest 24h emergency vet that treats them, not knowing if this is just gas or a blockage that will need surgery, mentally preparing myself for thousands of dollars in costs and the possible death of my pet. I imagine it's no fun for the vets who have to deal with me and others like me all night long, though I try my best to seem upbeat and empathetic externally.
- 4y ago
- Ericson2314 4y agoHeh but look where the trends with vets and dentists are. This won't last for long!
- quietthrow 4y agoWhere are they trending?Curious if you can expand
- Ericson2314 4y agoThere was a thing a few weeks back of PE buying up vets to consolidate them and jack up prices.
- wutbrodo 4y agoProbably a naive question, but why is EMR still so atrocious? I know there's a lot of garbage software out there, esp when it's single-purpose. But I usually assume that's a combination of low returns to better UI and little money to optimize (eg software improvements that make waiters marginally more efficient). By contrast, supply of doctor-minutes is a chronic bottleneck in a system that spends trillions. I know healthcare (esp in the US) is full of wonky incentives, but surely improving doctor productivity is connected to hospital outcomes in some straightforward way?
- namecheapTA 4y agoI've worked in car sales for over a decade. I've always hated the service departments for their totally militant focus on extracting as much money as possible from customers, with any concept of value or honest recommendations be damned. The last few times I've stepped into several vet offices, I get the exact same sense of money extraction and even see many of the same methods/training/tools/tactics.
- cs137 4y agoThis is a ridiculous take. Veterinary medicine is not some capitalist utopia. Most vets are miserable and, unlike doctors, most of them don't even make any money for their suffering. First of all, a substantial portion of the job is putting animals down, and I'm not talking about 20-year-old dogs with so many health issues that it's a mercy. A portion of the animals are in this case, of course; but a lot of the time, these are animals who'd be fine with proper treatment, and the issue is of owners who either don't care (yuppie shits who can afford the treatment, but who bought the pet for the kids, who are now in college, and see the pet as "just an animal") or who can't afford treatment at all. The idea that veterinary medicine is some capitalist utopia just because the prices are more reasonable (for now) is absurd... because the fact is that we live in what free-market capitalism has reduced (due to runaway wage collapse) to a third-world country, and so most people can't even afford basic services for beloved pets, even at the relatively low service prices of a few hundred dollars instead of a few thousand, because so many Americans don't even have that. Veterinarians have an astronomically high suicide rate. They are right in the firing line of this shitfucked economic system that should have been overthrown forty years ago when it stopped functioning for the people who do the actual work.
- verisimi 4y agoThe problem with both these 'sectors', in my view, is that it is almost impossible for the doctor/vet to actually act in the patient's interests. The doctors have to worry about lawsuits, giving the correct (pharmaceutical) treatment. The vets are better, but really I've been unimpressed with the care - lots of unnecessary cutting for the sake of insurance, sterilisation, etc. The background reason is that the incentives are 180° in the wrong direction. Practioners aren't paid for keeping you healthy, out of hospital, managing health by better diet selection, etc. Their 'best' scenario is the opposite to that - they want a long protracted illness with lots of treatment. Diabetes for example is a blessing, not a curse. Long illnesses pay the bills. Not only this, but doctors are fully boxed in with dysfunctional protocols/treatments (wrt the patient's best interests) as insurance companies' 'best practice', etc inculcate a set of behaviours that suit pharmaceutical corps that pay their bills. So the incentives and model are all wrong. But they are also hardened in law, insurance etc. So apparently we must proceed on this flawed model. But for the individual, for me at least, I do not plan to visit a doctor. Except in narrow circumstances (burns, force trauma) even if the practioners are considering my care (in the old-fashioned sense of the word), I don't think I can trust them to actually do the right thing, so fully deputised are they to big pharma. I have far more faith in my ability to resolve a problem myself or in alternative health practioners. The same applies to vets, to a lesser extent.
- gzer0 4y ago> The malpractice insurance of a family doctor is $13,000 a year, while an obstetrician’s insurance can cost $71,000 a year. This is flat out wrong. No one is paying $71,000 a year in medical malpractice. An average OB/GYN is at $5k / year in insurance costs [1]. A really good source for medical malpractice claims data is the National Practitioner Data Bank which posts data on all paid medical malpractice claims since 1991 [2]. A summary of the data for the U.S. as well as for each individual state is here [3]. All of this is to say, the number of paid malpractice claims has been dropping since 2001, and the total amount paid on these claims has also dropped by 23% since 2003. What is the real issue here? Defensive Medicine. Doctors are terrified of being sued so they order batteries of unnecessary tests on patients and make unnecessary referrals in order to avoid lawsuits. These unnecessary tests drive up healthcare costs, not the direct cost of medical malpractice. This is a problem with the healthcare system and how patients can initiate lawsuits. I don't think it is entirely fair to blame the physician in this instance for covering their bases. Any doctor who has been sued for medical malpractice will tell you that it was a humiliating and degrading experience even if they won their case. [1] https://truecostofhealthcare.org/malpractice/ https://truecostofhealthcare.org/malpractice/ [2] https://www.npdb.hrsa.gov/analysistool/ https://www.npdb.hrsa.gov/analysistool/ [3] https://truecostofhealthcare.org/malpractice_statistics/ https://truecostofhealthcare.org/malpractice_statistics/
- param 4y agoYour own link [1] says "Ob/Gyn about $30,000- $35,000". The OP said "an Ob's ins CAN COST 71k a year" [emphasis mine] so doesn't sound 'flat out wrong' to me. Next - could you explain why you are bringing in malpractice CLAIMS data in a conversation about PREMIUMS?
- dmurray 4y ago> Your own link [1] says "Ob/Gyn about $30,000- $35,000". The OP said "an Ob's ins CAN COST 71k a year" [emphasis mine] so doesn't sound 'flat out wrong' to me. And that's in California, while a chart lower down shows doctors in New York pay 7 times as much on average, and $35k on average across all specialities.
- 4y ago
- jstummbillig 4y agoa) People should be happy. b) I personally dislike blame-culture but I think that's already more debatable (you could reframe it as assigning responsibility, aggressively) c) I want the higher chance of successful therapy, as I am sure most of us do. So if you claim we are off path and "folklore and word-of-mouth" gets us back AND you can prove that, fine. Otherwise spare me the nostalgia and anecdotal data. I wanna live.
- andriesm 4y agoI don't just want to live, I want to understand why many things still seem to operate so irrationally in terms of cost. vs. value received. I actually appreciated the unique perspective, and the experience, and don't care that it is not statistically validated, since the point is to stimulate thinking. It suggests a few aspects to look into - an overly litigious society, crappy systems, an insulation of patients and doctors from the costs of treatments by insurance intermediatories etc...
- BrandoElFollito 4y agoIn addition to the regulations, there is also corporatism in sometimes unexpected places. During COVID in France, there was an idea for vets to provide shots of the virus, especially in places where we do not have a lot of doctors. This sounded reasonable to me, but apparently not to everyone as they were allowed to provide the shots only in vaccine centers. That were lacking exactly in the paces where they had their office.
- Zenst 4y agoLet us not forget that Barber's also doubled as surgeons. https://barbersurgeonsguild.com/magazine/history-barber-surgeon/ https://barbersurgeonsguild.com/magazine/history-barber-surg...
- OrvalWintermute 4y ago> [2] The biggest contributors to these are the twin demons of prior authorization and electronic medical records. Prior authorization is when health insurance companies require doctors to ask for permission to perform specific services for specific patients. This is incredibly time consuming (14.4 hours per week as of 2020) and also demoralizing for the physicians, as the ultimate decision on how to treat a patient is often not made by the highly-trained physician or the patient in need, but instead by a 25 year old making 40k/year reading off a script over the phone. This is a dramatic oversimplification. The person reading the script may issue a denial, and then there is a process of appeal, which may include other steps. Physicians interacting with insurance companies practice what is known as a "peer to peer", where a physician discusses the case with an insurance-employed physician, often trained in the same specialty as the physician. Sometimes the notes provided by a surgeon were inadequate, sometimes they need clarification, sometimes the incorrect codes were used, and payment is retroactively denied. There are a few things too many rejections can cause: 1 - Insurance switches 2 - Regulator problems 3 - Competing model with insurance 4 - Lawsuit, as some legal firms specifically target insurance companies for this activity
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- idontknowifican 4y agoincredibly apologetic for an industry that’s wholly unnecessary, that without we could just have the “peer to peer” communication and patient interest in mind. that would be terrible though, as some folks would have to pay more than they would’ve if they were able to live their whole life without needing medical care.
- OrvalWintermute 4y agoI am not apologetic, this is just a matter-of-fact response on how it works, and what happens. Keep in mind that healthcare fraud is a giant business [1] [2] I'm not trying to push any particular thing, though I do believe that the Kaiser Permanente type of business model (health maintenance organization) will eventually kill off much insurance. [1] https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdmi/health-care-fraud https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdmi/health-care-fraud [2] https://www.govinfosecurity.com/doj-healthcare-at-center-biggest-us-fraud-cases-in-2021-a-18433 https://www.govinfosecurity.com/doj-healthcare-at-center-big...
- dash2 4y agoThis was not the article I expected. My experience is that vets are like doctors yesterday for a different reason. I tore my ACL this year. Last year, my dog tore his. One thing I learned when talking to (UK) doctors about my ACL is that there has been a lot of recent evidence-based medicine about surgical interventions. As a result, surgeons are less gung-ho: it turns out, quite often, surgery just doesn't do much good compared to physio. By contrast, when I looked at the literature for animal cruciate ligament treatment, it's... oh gosh. I went into depth on this. In 2003 there was an article pointing out that there was almost no scientific evidence for most of the existing treatments. Ten years later, there was a review article which essentially said "oh, now the evidence is much better, we can rest easy". It categorized the research into four categories, the best one being credible randomized controlled trials. So I looked at the top category. The only RCT I found had about 40 animals, with substantial dropout (very likely non-random). There's a lot of natural improvement, and tiny effects from treatment, with significant results for some (out of many!) measured dependent variables. After reading the top category, I didn't bother with the rest. What a disaster! Cruciate ligament treatment for dogs is a $1bn industry. But there's just no decent science being done. It's all tests of 8 dogs without a control group, done by some guy pushing his new methodology. Honestly, it's shameful. By contrast, one of the strengths of the NHS is maybe that it can knock heads together , get large-scale RCTs going, and learn something.
- _the_inflator 4y agoSorry, that you tore your ACL. This is not cool. And you are right, modern medicine, especially if you can afford it, provides so much more today: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/05/200527181322.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/05/200527181322.h...
- dash2 4y agoThe linked article looks like a way to skirt the use of Human Growth Hormone by athletes. Is it doping if it's to cure an ACL injury? Such a grey area...!
- gxt 4y agomedecine is highly emotional, if you give people the choice of doing nothing vs doing something/anything people will, out of shame, do that thing. There has to be a strong cultural, evidence based, or other, justification to do nothing. Probably not the case most of the time, and it's going to stay that way, because as you mentioned, there's a boatload of money to be made out of it and careers depend on it.
- donatj 4y agoI have talked about it on here before, but I genuinely despise the modern experience of going to the doctor. They spend the entire time asking questions from a screen, most of which I answered last time, while staring at the computer. It feels more like an interrogation. I have also literally had my doctor google my symptoms right then and there, and the “I could have done that” feeling just doesn’t build confidence. Clearly it’s through the filter of his knowledge but still feels wrong. Going to the doctor in the 90s felt way more personal, way more like they actually cared about you and your health. Sit down and just talk about what was going on face to face. Like sure, maybe the modern way has better results overall? But it sure feels impersonal and I never leave with any feeling of confidence. I would have to imagine there’s a middle ground with similar if not better results.
- the_only_law 4y ago> They spend the entire time asking questions from a screen, most of which I answered last time, while staring at the computer. It feels more like an interrogation. It's like dealing with a shitty support script.
- donatj 4y agoYes! Honestly that’s a much better description of the feeling than my own!
- oneoff786 4y agoI’m not convinced a doctor’s knowledge is stronger than my ability to read papers and evaluate statistical evidence for niche cases though.
- Enginerrrd 4y agoIn my experience, for most general practitioners, it's not! There are specialists for a reason though. But I've found that YOU need to be able to do the work to get the referral and make the diagnoses. Interestingly though, I had a family practice MD early on in my medical process that had a hunch, long before I suspected I had what he thought I did. (i.e. before I was able to steer the conversation to heavily emphasize certain symptoms after I'd pretty much figured out what I had and needed some diagnostics to confirm.) He just knew... Alas, the test came back negative, and he got roped into other endeavors before retiring. He was brilliant though, he had a PhD in epidemiology as well as an MD. (He even saw one of the very last smallpox cases in the wild.) Much later on, and several doctors later, we finally got that diagnosis right. For one doctor, I had to walk him through the results of the test before he finally put it together.... pretty unbelieveable, and there's no hope for the average patient in that scenario.
- InvOfSmallC 4y agoI think it's country based. In DK Vets are way better than doctors. You could just see a different level of preparation and equipment.
- Finnucane 4y agoThere are now chains of for-profit full service pet hospitals, expanding into a business that not long ago was served by a few not-for-profit centers. For instance, locally, if I needed a service my local vet couldn't provide, I went to Angell Memorial in Boston. I adopted all of my cats there. Now there's a couple of Blue Pearl hospitals here too. This isn't entirely a bad thing. But one presumes that increasing use of pet insurance and the commericialization of the vet business will mean rising costs. And my local vet has had some staff turnover of late.
- kurupt213 4y agoI saw the same doctor between the ages of 11 and 27. He owned his own practice in California. The experience at the modern healthcare network is just not the same. I understand the need for hospitals to go the corporatized route, but I think corporatization of family practice has significantly degraded the experience for patient and doctor
- didntknowya 4y agoAs a a vet I think this author's limited experience is a bit out of date. In the veterinary industry, medical management is always influenced by costs. Just yesterday I had to deal with a blocked cat. Gold standard treatment costs thousands of dollars and the owner only had $200. You not only have to take into account the hospital costs, but how the owner can manage their pet at home for ongoing care too. Costs are one of the main stressors in the industry (there's plenty of Ted Talks on the high suicide rate), and commonly owners shift their responsibility by blaming vets as "money grabbers" or who are only "in it for the money". Thankfully insurance is quite common now (depending on the area) and with less financial restraint on costs we are able to do more advanced treatments. We have specialists referral daily and even recently had a brain surgery on a dog. This would have been very rare in the past and the limited opportunity to perform complex treatments like this hinders how much data we can collect and learn from this. You do have old-school vets or those in rural clinics who would be happy to do every treatment under the sun. But being a 'jack-of-all-trades' is unrealistic when each sub-field is rapidly expanding in knowledge, and most younger vets (especially in big cities) are more than happy to refer to specialists (and avoid risk of complaints), unless of course the owner cannot afford to do so.