20 ms·
My New Sony NW-A55 Walkman
- csdvrx 4y agoAs the happy owner of a NW-Z507 (and matching Sony 1000XM4 earbuds and a more traditional WH-XB900N over-the-ear headset), the Sony Walkman lineup is worth every single dollar! It's helped me rediscover some of my classics! The 507 is Android, which was both a pro (more apps) and con (battery life) especially since the Sony default player is a bit special. I didn't need Android as I don't use streaming, but I wanted USB-C, and that excluded previous models like the A55. The battery life is less of a problem than I thought it would be, as my earbuds are drained first. However, I'm still not a fan of the Sony music player. If you want to try Sony newest Android lineup, I recommend installing the foobar music player. If you use wired headsets and the limited battery life is a problem for you, check the 1ZM2: https://musicphotolife.com/2022/05/sony-wm1zm2-review-digital-audio-player-walkman/ https://musicphotolife.com/2022/05/sony-wm1zm2-review-digita...
- MarkG509 4y agoI'd love to A-B these to my trusty old FiiO X5 with Sennheiser HD-650's (at home) or IE8i's (when exercising). Hearing the sound-stage and subtle do-dads buried by lesser set-ups is a pet-peeve of mine. A very important, perhaps dominant, factor in all of this is how the music was ripped/encoded. Except in my car, for which I did separate rips, I don't bother with MP3-320. For the X5, having 200 CDs ripped via WMA9 locks me in, until I can find a week or two to re-rip to a more modern lossless format. I grew up on vinyl via my (crazy/rich) older brother's Class A/B stereo. I'm spoiled, and feel sorry for the people today that think MP3-120 is "good enough".
- csdvrx 4y ago> Sennheiser HD-650's (at home) or IE8i's (when exercising). I prefer the 900N outside, and the 1000XM inside. To exercise with some music, I'm waiting for good neckband headphones with active audio cancellation: ideally something like the Anker Soundcore Life U2 - same form factor and USB-C plug, but with LDAC, AptX HD and a quality at least on par with the Shure AONIC. Yes I'm super picky :) > Hearing the sound-stage and subtle do-dads buried by lesser set-ups is a pet-peeve of mine. Oh so much this!! I'm hearing instruments that I hadn't noticed before! The first week, I thought it was in my head, because some of the tracks I've been listening to for years started sounding different!! But no, the Sony is that good. Again, it's worth every dollar. > I'm spoiled Now I'm spoiled too :) I just can't forget how much better it made my favorite tracks! TBH, the Sony has been my best purchase of these last few years: it has even rekindled my interest in music. Right now I'm exploring "pop urbaine", a very interesting genre that I didn't even know existed. My favorite tracks are inbetween EDM and Raeggeton, the best example being "On fleek" by Eva - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k_eEW2Ioe-o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k_eEW2Ioe-o (starts at 0:30) I would never have expected I'd take a liking to french music, but here I'm! Thank you Sony!! > A very important, perhaps dominant, factor in all of this is how the music was ripped/encoded. This too! I only use FLAC ripped from known-good sources like DDD audio CDs, but after reading a few things like https://sound.stackexchange.com/questions/51326/spotting-a-fake-flac-using-spectrogram https://sound.stackexchange.com/questions/51326/spotting-a-f... and https://musicfans.stackexchange.com/questions/12545/original-recording-of-traffics-the-low-spark-of-high-heeled-boys-good-sound-q https://musicfans.stackexchange.com/questions/12545/original... I've been thinking about developing a "scoring" app that would basically do a spectrogram and look for suspicious banding to rate my CDs on a 0-10 scale. > For the X5, having 200 CDs ripped via WMA9 locks me in, until I can find a week or two to re-rip to a more modern lossless format. I recently re-ripped using a slot-in Apple Superdrive with Windows Media Player Classic running on Windows 11 set to auto-rip into FLAC. I just worked as usual and every now and then swapped the CDs from 2 huge piles on the side of my desk. > I'm spoiled, and feel sorry for the people today that think MP3-120 is "good enough". Same lol
- mellavora 4y agoYou might be interested in building your own Class A amps. The sound is amazing. See https://diyaudiostore.com/ https://diyaudiostore.com/ https://www.diyaudio.com/community/ https://www.diyaudio.com/community/ for details. Hobby-ist driven, fantastic stuff.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoYou've no doubt double blind tested these claims?
- gbraad 4y agoOn an Android device use USB Audio Player Pro. Supports most DAC and allows for good EQ.
- csdvrx 4y agoAre you sure it will help on a Sony? It seems to be for USB OTG DAC.
- kixiQu 4y agoA. User CSS changing the font was maybe not a good idea here -- definitely misread that product number... B. I resent that this is so expensive. I'm not saying you shouldn't pay it, but it feels too expensive by half.
- mkoryak 4y agoOne thing no "new" mp3 player has done correctly is audio books. None of them do bookmarking as well as rockbox. Also, new mp3 players usually have terrible battery life. Because of these reasons, I bought myself about 7 sandisk sansa players on ebay and have gotten very good at fixing their shitty headphone jack problem. With a rockboxed sansa I get about 60 hours of battery life and bookmarking on stop with a list of recent bookmarks per file. Can this sony do any of that? Hardware music player have gone down hill.
- bpye 4y agoI'm surprised there hasn't been a successful open hardware project for a portable music player. Rockbox, a low power SoC, some decent DAC, a basic display - epaper would be kind of neat - and preferably a standard battery - something like the Nokia BL-5C.
- dangus 4y agoI don’t find it surprising. It’s a solved problem. Every phone has a music player built-in, you can even choose which one to use from hundreds of options. Offline, streaming, self-hosted cloud, the options are nearly infinite. Even if you don’t love the lack of headphone jack in the typical phone [1], the solution is an adapter that costs less than $10. What open hardware project can compete with that? [1] Non-audiophiles are perfectly happy with AAC/AptX codecs over Bluetooth, the bottleneck is still the quality of your headphones, IMO, and the convenience of never tangling a cable greatly outweighs missing out on the audiophile ghost whispering that they supposedly hear
- NikolaNovak 4y agoI mean, I don't disagree with your main point, but I hundred percent disagree with the notion audiophiles are the ones missing the 3.5mm jack. I miss it awfully and it's due to sheer convenience. Every one of my headphones used to work seemlessly with every one of my devices. I had cheap headphones (and later headsets) in each car, at the office, in the backpack, at home, and nice headphones at home, and they each and all worked with every phone and device immediatelly and without hassle or issues. They never ran out of battery, never disconnected, never had any lag, never garbled music, and were never obsoleted due to new codec or BT version or incompatibility or the eventual death of lithium ion. And they never wanted me to pull my little remaining hair if I dared to switch headphone or device. Labeling those who vehemently miss 3.5mm as audiophiles is a straw man or phenomenal proportions.
- moralestapia 4y agoI loved the iPod Nano and these players are fairly similar, might give one of them a try, thanks for sharing.
- pcmoney 4y agoSomebody help me understand this? If the audio quality isn’t better why is it so much better than the “bad” subscription services? I understand critiques of how little they pay artists but I mean from a customer perspective, why is spotify et al bad? I assume you have to buy download organize and sync the music for this system? Is it just nostalgia? Just a single purpose device that cant text you etc?
- ge96 4y agoNeil Young comes in with his Toblerone MP3 device
- 0xbadcafebee 4y ago> why is spotify et al bad Because Spotify et al doesn't give you a big directory full of MP3s. On top of that, the physical interface and features of a small dedicated player is a better user experience.
- dangus 4y agoWhat’s better about a small dedicated player compared to using an offline media jukebox app? Smartphones can play offline media. They can play media hosted on a private server. Nobody’s forcing any smartphone user to use Spotify in particular. There’s always alternatives like VLC and countless others that offer that same functionality. To me, a dedicated player is redundant hardware with less processing power and refinement than a typical smartphone. Even Apple, king of the locked down proprietary experience, has a Music app with the option to completely disable and hide their streaming service from even being visible. You can sync music via a USB cable or WiFi from local files just like it was an original iPod.
- erwincoumans 4y ago>> But the audio quality is a noticeable upgrade from my iPhone 8 Is this still true with latest iPhone? I would expect that iPhone hardware is not a limiting factor for audio quality (assuming a wired adaptor for HiFi headphones)
- capitalsigma 4y agoYeah, it's really hard to believe that... compute power is the limiting factor on audio? In 2022? On a $1k piece of hardware? Over Bluetooth, in both cases?
- KerrAvon 4y agoNo idea, but it doesn’t surprise me that a dedicated audio player could theoretically do a lot better. Just as one would generally expect a DSLR to beat the iPhone for picture quality.
- iasay 4y agoWell it depends on the material really. You can take a good photo on a phone and a crappy one on a DSLR. You can listen to crap music on a dedicated audio player too…
- don-code 4y agoWhile I can't speak to either the iPhone or the Walkman, the quality of the digital-to-analog converter is significantly more important than raw horsepower or other capabilities. Where they're analog devices, there's much less to be said about the "it's just zeroes and ones" argument. Some older devices I've owned had good-quality DACs - a Palm Treo being the best. My current ThinkPad has a downright awful DAC, to the point where music sounds _better_ over my Bluetooth headphones (Audio-Technica ATH-M50xBT) than when plugged straight in. The quality issues are even more egregious for the cheap dock I use for my work MacBook Pro, which puts out so much electrical noise over the headphone jack as to be annoying even in in Zoom calls.
- erwincoumans 4y ago
- 13of40 4y agoProbably over a decade ago my wife bought me a Sony Walkman MP3 player for Christmas, and even though I ended up going with something that was Audible.com friendly, I was so impressed with the earbuds' quality I've sourced them a couple of times so I have a lifetime supply at this point. (If interested, I think the model number was MDR-EX082)
- Arn_Thor 4y agoThose Sony earbuds are absolutely fantastic. Excellent audio quality for the price, solid build quality and cables that seem to last longer than most.
- phuff 4y agoI got a Fiio M7 for Christmas or my birthday a year ago. It's amazing how awesome it is to have a device that's dedicated to music and does a great job at it. There are side loadable apps like Musicolet that also do a great job of providing all the music management you could want.
- noisy_boy 4y ago+1 to musicolet[0] - hands down the most flexibility and features I've seen in a dedicated music app. [0]: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=in.krosbits.musicolet https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=in.krosbits.mu...
- alexalx666 4y agoiPod Video is Still better
- aquova 4y agoI too assumed that dedicated MP3 players were relegated to very low-budget devices, and I didn't realize that Sony was still producing the Walkman line. I decided to take a look at their line up to what was happening in the space - https://electronics.sony.com/audio/walkman-digital-recorders/c/walkman-mp3-players https://electronics.sony.com/audio/walkman-digital-recorders... Boy... what a massive range of prices. There's a touchscreen-less device for $75, one resembling the one described by the author at $350, an $850 model with different chassis and higher output but nothing else I can immediately see, and then models jumping up to $1100, $1400, $3200 (!), and even $3600 (!!!) which is apparently made out of a gold-plated copper. I was vaguely interested in such a product but even $350 seemed too much, let alone the other ranges of products with, for the general audience, not much in the way of obvious differing benefits.
- rtpg 4y agoThe unfortunate thing is at least for me I’ve found the … basically glorified locked down android interface on the expensive walkmans to be insulting. Give me a dedicated interface if you’re gonna charge me that much for a dedicated device! At least comparable to an iPod nano in “time to play mp3”
- makeitdouble 4y agoHistorically, Sony’s in-house developed software hasn’t been great, to say the least. Getting android could be a blessing in this specific case.
- tuxie_ 4y agoReally? I mean we are talking about the company that develops the Playstation. I have a very different opinion on Sony.
- makeitdouble 4y agoYes..."Sony" is probably better seen as a group, with a lot of different entities doing their thing almost independently (not even talking about their entertainment and financing branch, really just the main bloc) For instance Sony's audio branch is probably completely separate from the camera branch, which is separate from the TV branch, which doesn't talk to the EV car branch. I don't know if financially they are separate companies, but from what I got they are clearly cut divisions. I imagine them as an archipelago of products and services, all under a common flag, but only talking to each others by delegations. For instance Sony has a NFC venture that is really good with encryption and hardware data transfers, it's even integrated in their VAIO computer line. Yet their Network Walkman was an utter pile of poop when it came to move songs from the computer to the encrypted MD disc.
- gbraad 4y agoGot a Fiio. Never trust Sony anymore after the forced Atrac-nonsense in almost every device: it would only play MP3 after being converted to an Atrac-file. After they blocked my Sony PSN account it is Never again Sony.
- CamperBob2 4y agoKeep fighting the good fight, but... if the CD rootkit wasn't enough to convince people not to buy Sony, I can't imagine what will be. One of my most cherished personal mottoes: "If the answer involves giving money to Sony, you asked the wrong question."
- noisy_boy 4y agoToo much internet... I read it as newass walkman.
- WWLink 4y agoI'm still reading it as such.
- UkrainianJew 4y agoCuriosity question: has anyone done any work on reverse-engineering the Sony Mega Bass feature they used to have on old analog players (and ported to some early MP3 ones)? It sounded so much deeper than any phone/sound card would give. I'm wondering if it's some purely analog schenanigans (some tricky extra capacitors?) or if it can be replicated in pure software.
- csdvrx 4y ago> It sounded so much deeper than any phone/sound card would give If you have a full Sony setup (walkman + headphones) DSEE Extreme sounds just like that, and seems to be purely software. One of my "tests" is to run my favorite Pavarotti rendition of Verdi's La donna e mobile - with DSEE Extreme on, it's night and day. However, on my normal FLACs, it's far less important. Some people even dislike it: https://www.reddit.com/r/sony/comments/ipcqf9/dsee_extreme_on_sony_xm4s_worth_being_enabled/ https://www.reddit.com/r/sony/comments/ipcqf9/dsee_extreme_o...
- fortran77 4y agoThere’s a Wikipedia page on how these techniques work. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_fundamental https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_fundamental I’ve played pipe organs that do the same thing with “resultant” stops to fake 32’ or 64’ stops.
- Markoff 4y ago> The NW-A55 is part of Sony’s budget digital audio player lineup. ... It worked out about AU $300 including shipping, not bad considering how expensive iPods and cassette Walkmans used to be. We must have very different definitions of "budget" because 200 EUR for MP3 player is nowhere close to budget line in times when you can buy decent budget phones for that money or how much I spent for great cassette Panasonic walkman. He is also comparing prices of technology at peak with price of technology pretty much nobody buys anymore and they should be giving pretty much for free. Btw 16GB model having 12.26GB available capacity I'd expect from some Android phone and not dumb MP3 player.
- bjarneh 4y ago> You don’t need to use any special desktop software; you mount the Walkman as a USB storage device and transfer files. Wait… that’s it? Yes! That's always nice, although I struggle to see the need for an additional device to play mp3's at this point...
- dmix 4y agoIf sound quality + local music + non-android is the goal there are plenty of lossless audiophile dedicated devices with DACs and amps built in on Amazon, with some nice designs: https://www.amazon.com/FiiO-M11Plus-Resolution-Portable-Bluetooth5-0/dp/B09P885CC9/ https://www.amazon.com/FiiO-M11Plus-Resolution-Portable-Blue... https://www.amazon.com/Surfans-F35-Resolution-Music-Player/dp/B09TKL76V5/ https://www.amazon.com/Surfans-F35-Resolution-Music-Player/d... https://www.amazon.com/iRULU-F20-Bluetooth-Lossless-Resolution/dp/B07VWK4FP3/ https://www.amazon.com/iRULU-F20-Bluetooth-Lossless-Resoluti...
- IlPeach 4y agoCool... But will they last?
- herbst 4y agoI owned a FiiO many years ago, took it travelling, drowned it multiple times and it died underwater, still playing music on a boat after like 6 years of constant use and abuse. It's the best device I ever owned.
- at_a_remove 4y agoHonestly, I have trouble finding out if these devices even do playlists, and if so, what format? I have a sneaking suspicion that, while I have some "musts," I probably don't even know the right questions to ask, and I guess forums for this kind of thing stopped existing.
- csdvrx 4y agoDo you like the M11 plus? Music is very important to me. I'm considering the WM1ZM2, but I've seen a lot of great reviews about the FiiO and Surfans - but the F20 doesn't have Bluetooth (ok if LDAC and AptXhd are supported) and the F35 doesn't have USB-C. The M11 plus has both BT+ USB-C, along with hardware buttons. If it can give me better audio and battery life than the WM1ZM2, I'm interested!
- nicklaf 4y agoThis used to be available in the United States for purchase. I have one, and bought it in 2020 from Best Buy for $170. [0] Good to know it's still available in Japan, but it's a shame it doesn't seem to be in stock in the US anymore since it's a fantastic player. It's free from all the smartphone bloat and runs a slick interface on vanilla linux (and works just fine with linux as USB mass storage device, as well as an FM radio receiver, and a bluetooth client/host). That there is no wifi in my mind is a feature rather than a bug. I also like to think that model name is an homage to the hip hop group, N.W.A. :-P [0] https://www.bestbuy.com/site/sony-walkman-nw-a55-hi-res-16gb-mp3-player-black/6395918.p?skuId=6395918 https://www.bestbuy.com/site/sony-walkman-nw-a55-hi-res-16gb...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- drpixie 4y agoI can’t describe what a breath of fresh air this is compared to how bad modern smartphone music and streaming apps have become. It’s also nice having a dedicated player that isn’t inundated with notifications and other modern distractions. Until you see something done well, we get seduced by "features" and loose track of how nice a really well design thing can be. (Got to hand it to old Apple, they did know design.)
- urlwolf 4y agoI use a dedicated voice recorder to think while I walk. It has made a world of difference in my thinking. And no, a phone with an app is not the same. A button you can press anytime that just records is a godsent. No notifications, no chats, no Trillion dollar companies giving you dopamine shots. Your attention is too valuable. We are squandering it on devices that are designed so you can't think clearly.
- evanrelf 4y agoWhat device do you use?
- subhro 4y agoNot the OP but I use a Zoom H1N. Terrific device and runs on 2 NiMH AAA cells
- hitekker 4y agohear, hear!
- rocketbop 4y agoAs a public information aside, the phrase is actually "hear, hear".
- hitekker 4y agoToday I learned, thanks.
- hardlianotion 4y agoHm - either parent has edited, or you are objecting to an exclamation mark.
- subhro 4y agoThis is so true. I avoid using my phone other than to receive phone calls and sometimes text people. I find most of the dedicated devices like voice recorders, GPS, flashlight has a far more intuitive, faster and more functional interface than the apps that mimic them on a phone. Also, my GPS can (and has) jumped out of my backpack and dropped over 100ft and worked (and still works) just fine. Not sure I would like to bet my life hoping the same outcome with my phone while I am in the middle of nowhere.
- cm2187 4y agoIt's crazy that we have come there, but reading this I am actually entertaining buying one. It is shocking how bad the experience of listening to my own music has become on iphones. Dongles (different for ipads and iphone of course), itunes for windows is barely usable, there is a bug they never fixed where the music player on iOS randomly mismatch the album artwork, and there are so many conflicting gestures that I always end up messing what I am trying to do. And like a year ago an OS update auto-decreases the volume if it deems I am listening too loud. Android isn't an option for me because Google. But it's a pain to have to carry two devices, manage two batteries.
- ozzythecat 4y agoI religiously use Spotify for music on my iPhone. Are you against the subscription payment model, or are you considering this device because it’s better than Spotify on an iPhone? If it is better, how so? Genuinely curious if there are better music options than my current “setup”.
- cm2187 4y agoSubscription model doesn't work for the stuff I listen to. I want specific interpretations of specific operas, I want playlists by composer (no two album uses the same spelling for a classical music composer). I want playlists that skip the recitatives, etc. And I already own the music, legally purchased on itunes and amazon. Why would I rent it?
- thirdsun 4y agoWhile Spotify covers most popular stuff there's a huge amount of music that isn't available on any streaming service. Plus, your content might disappear any day. I use Spotify for previewing, exploring and making some buying decisions but my actual collection is mine. It's lossless, DRM-free and I plan to have it for ages to come.
- chanc3e 4y agoThis is it for me, I used Apple Music for a few years and eventually I noticed that some of my playlists would have tracks missing - sometimes a listing would be ghosted, sometimes it would straight up vanish. I called time, brought a A50 and haven't looked back: https://chanc.ee/posts/20200830-abandon-stream.html https://chanc.ee/posts/20200830-abandon-stream.html Granted my music tastes are esoteric but silently modifying my playlists felt grievous. Now I make sure that subscription money goes on supporting artists directly.
- waiseristy 4y agoHottest of takes : A shitty music app on my phone like Spotify is 1000x more convenient than a dedicated music device will ever be. As a society we already processed and answered this question in the late 00's. PMP's (heh, remember that term?) suck. All-in-one devices are better Hot-take over.
- gyulai 4y ago> As a society we already processed and answered It's difficult to disentangle this from the switch to streaming and regarding the latter it is very much unclear whether this was a consumer preference or just something that one-sidedly benefitted an oligopolistic music industry and consumers just had to live with it. Even if a preference for streaming apps reflects an uncoerced choice that a majority of consumers made back then or would make today, it's still a hallmark of a well-functioning market and a free society if the needs/preferences of the minority don't go entirely unserved by the market.
- waiseristy 4y agoYou know what was an oligopoly? The original music services we used in the early aughts. The *vast majority* of music being bought and downloaded in the wild west days of PMP's was from iTunes. And I think you would be surprised to see that Amazon and iTunes account for a significant amount of music sales still to this day It's plain to see that the needs and preferences of minority users are being served too. This NW-A55 device obviously has a following. Sony pumps out a PMP every so often. Music nerds are probably the #1 target for weird enthusiast gear outside of gaming/pop-culture knickknacks.
- gyulai 4y agoWe seem to be in perfect agreement then. It's a good thing that these devices are still getting made. Your initial comment made it sound like you took a different view, but maybe I misunderstood.
- waiseristy 4y ago
- rob74 4y ago> ...you can pocket the player and use its physical side controls for play/pause, stop, back, forward, and hold... Many Bluetooth headphones have physical controls for that. E.g. my Marshall headphones have a nifty little "joystick": up/down for volume, left/right for skip, press for pause/accept call, long press to turn on/off. Elegant, minimalistic, easy to remember. > It’s also nice having a dedicated player that isn’t inundated with notifications and other modern distractions. Separating out ebooks to a dedicated tablet worked the same wonders for my anxiety. YMMV - I for one would be ridden by the anxiety of missing an important call on my phone while listening to a dedicated music player...
- shmerl 4y agoLooks pretty cool. Is there some open source firmware for it? Rockbox was good for Sansa players.
- d--b 4y ago> But the audio quality is a noticeable upgrade from my iPhone 8 What? Can anyone second this?
- jwmoz 4y agoIt's nerdy. Pointless though imo when you have a phone and Spotify. The days of hoarding mp3s are gone, thankfully.
- loser777 4y agoPointless until you veer even the slightest bit from what Spotify is able (cares?) to license. City pop listeners in the states will back me up on this one (it's not even an esoteric genre!) but where's Yamashita, Kadomatsu, or Sato? The Spotify US catalog is black hole here. Ironically the best legal way for listeners to buy this music is to fly to Japan to buy vinyl.
- ifelsethenyeah 4y agoKeep your hands off my FLAC and MP3 hoards. :P Actually, Spotify's catalog isn't that impressive. I use Plexamp when Spotify's choices get old. Soundcloud also has infinite permutations of remixes.
- 8fingerlouie 4y agoYou don't even need to add Spotify to that equation. I have all my music stored locally. It's about 300 CDs that i ripped (out of a 1000 CD collection) and stored the originals in the attic. Since iTunes removed their DRM, i've purchased my music there. My iPhone is "plenty" good for playing music where i want it, and with an iTunes match subscription, i have my music available in the cloud. I don't subscribe to any music streaming service, and i doubt i ever will, especially since "modern music" seems to be about cranking out one hit wonders with very little quality and skill. It may be survival bias, but i am hard pressed to find any band/musician from the past 2 decades we will still listen to in 2 decades time.
- ifelsethenyeah 4y agoArgh, I mistook it for the classic yellow WM-F45. Tapes and pencils forever. ;P Edit: I remember one of the last-ish MP3 players was a Dell one with a micro HDD. First drop and it died. xD
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gbanfalvi 4y agoI recently started transitioning away from using my phone for everything to having dedicated devices and I quite like it. I have an Analogue Pocket I buy second-hand game boy cartridges for, I have an e-reader on which I read e-pubs, etc. The “integration experience” is _a lot_ tougher. I can’t buy games from an App Store and I need to plug in the reader to Calibre to get my next book… but the actual user experience is so much better. I don’t know if it’s the dedicated hardware or the uninterrupted experience or something else… it just lets the content shine through much more clearly. I’m an app developer and I strongly believed that we can have one device replace pretty much everything else almost perfectly… but now I kinda wanna try having a Walkman and getting rid of Spotify.
- thekingofrome 4y agoI took my music collection offline at the start of this year, so I would lose my final reason to "need" to carry a smartphone around. It took me about 16 hours over two days to plan, organize and acquire all the music I would otherwise have listened to on Spotify. In the end the experience was far inferior. My wireless earphones were harder to manage and connect, the UI and build quality were outright unpleasant ($40 price tag, wasn't willing to spend more), and podcasts wouldn't save the point I last stopped at. Not only that, but the MP3 player didn't recognize the track number from within the MP3 data, meaning that albums were played with the tracks in alphabetical order, until I found a program that could change the file names to contain said number at the start of the file name. The problem was clearly the really crappy MP3 player I got, but I couldn't find anything better that was reasonably priced in the market available to me in Europe. If I could find something then I'd love to give it another shot.
- jstummbillig 4y agoI am mostly confused by what the author thinks the selling point is. > I can’t describe what a breath of fresh air this is compared to how bad modern smartphone music and streaming apps have become. Well, I was hoping they would try to describe it, because personally, I would have to wear my most deeply shaded nostalgia glasses to think that MP3 player UX has ever been comparable to what Spotify offers nowadays. And we can not even directly compare a MP3 player to Spotify, which is paid to do an entirely different and way more complicated job, considering that you are able to browse and organize a completely different and incomparably larger (and automatically growing) set of media. In the end, this feels like a case of someone convincing themselves of a peculiar diet, where the believe in its effectiveness does all the heavy lifting. Which is great, when it works for that person – but probably not applicable in general and likely worse than the market solution.
- izacus 4y agoI don't remember any of the MP3 players desperately trying to shove podcast down my throat instead of showing my music. They also never lost all my downloaded music in the first 30 minutes of an 11 hour flight due to a crash bug. So just in those simple ways Spotify is worse.
- hnlmorg 4y agoI've encountered plenty of bugs with portable music players. I've had CD walkman scratch disks, cassette players eat tapes and I've had SD and compact flash storage fail on me too. No technology is beyond failure.
- varispeed 4y agoPlease someone make an mp3 player that has precise progress bar, ideally controlled by a physical slider or potentiometer. Also please add an option to slow down or speed up the material with reasonable anti-aliasing and an option to retain pitch. Please make it so that you can scroll through thousands of mp3s and preview without interruptions. Let me store cue points recallable by dedicated physical buttons. At this point you may see that I am actually describing professional DJ player, but these things are mad expensive and bulky.
- zasdffaa 4y agoRegarding the interface: no. I bought one of these and regretted it ever since. It may well be better than the competition currently, but it is still got a shitty interface that demands your attention for anything. Small example: to switch off you have to press and hold the off button (edit: a few seconds), then it pops up a modal but asks you whether you really want to turn it off. Err, yes please? The 'off' button at the top is actually well engineered you can't hit it by accident, it's hard to hold in and you have to do it for several seconds. I don't want to a confirmation dialog popping up that when I'm getting off a bus. It isn't needed. The damn thing demand your attention all the time. I used to have an Archos, I could navigated using its clunky front-the lever without looking. Not with this you can't. You have to concentrate. The buttons shown on the side are too small to feel unless you concentrate (the smaller ones are ~2mm wide, the volume 'bar' is thankfully usable after a bit of practice). There's other problems with it - turn it on? Pretty animation + almost a minute startup time before it's ready. Unplug it from charging, it remains on despite going blank, on standby, looking like it turned itself off - come to use it in a few days, it's gone flat - "but I just charged it, what happened?". It's beautifully well-made in hardware, sound is really great, the UI... I bloody hate navigating the music on it. It's an absolute pain in the arse. Bring back proper user interfaces, not touch screens. You know, with user testing. It's a lovely bit of kit that I just don't want to use. Rant over.
- theodric 4y agoBeautiful hardware let down by its software? Sounds like every Sony product I've ever bought.
- voxadam 4y agoIn defense of Sony's software/firmware team I'd argue that we've also been repeatedly burned by Sony's flawed hardware full of their endless NIH proprietary BS (e.g. Memory Stick, UMD, Minidisc, ATRAC, Betamax, to name just a few).
- layer8 4y agoMiniDisc wasn’t proprietary, it was available from many manufacturers: https://www.minidisc.org/equipment_browser.html https://www.minidisc.org/equipment_browser.html And the hardware itself was great, even when it was for a proprietary standard.
- varispeed 4y ago> I can’t describe what a breath of fresh air this is compared to how bad modern smartphone music and streaming apps have become. My biggest pet peeve is that very much all streaming applications have very tiny progress bars, it's almost impossible to navigate through longer piece of music or podcast precisely. It's like all the functions to navigate around the music have become an afterthought and they focus on showing artwork and other bells and whistles over utility. As if people making these apps don't actually use them.
- porcoda 4y agoI got one of the NW-A45 Walkmans a few years ago - it's pretty nice and similar to the A55. Good audio quality, but most of all, it lets me focus on music without temptation to do things I would do on a phone. My biggest gripes are the interface. - It takes forever to rebuild its database when I add new music to the SD card. No matter how much I searched, I couldn't figure out how to build this myself on the computer side when I added music. - Creating playlists isn't possible. You can add to existing playlists, but if you want new ones you need to add them from the computer side. I did find that if I add a skeleton playlist file to the SD card I can add to it on device, but that means I need to plan ahead for what playlists I'm going to want. - Navigating is a pain when you have a big collection. I collect live music, so sometimes I have hundreds of "albums" for a given artist. It's painful to find what I want. The inconvenience of using it has led me to usually leave it at home and fall back to the Music app on my iPhone and use iTunes Match to shove all of the music up into the cloud after I've transcoded it from lossless to a smaller lossy form. I know lots of people hate that app, but so far it's the only one that I can fly around in my 90k+ song collection with. I'm always on the lookout for better ones, or better dedicated devices, but so far no luck finding one that isn't a pain to use.
- zasdffaa 4y agoYep; see my other post. Let me add one to this, perhaps it affects you? I'm fussy about what I like, I buy a CD, rip, and listen. Usually I want to throw that track away after a few listens. You can't delete the track you are listening to (you can sort of, depending on how you found it via the UI, but usually you can't) so you must remember to delete it at home on your main computer. That's a major feature for me and it messes that up.
- porcoda 4y agoI do the same - buy CDs, rip, archive CD away in a box as my backup. I don't delete though. I approach my huge collection as stuff I know I have, and who knows - sometimes I'll listen to something I haven't felt like hearing in a decade, so I like knowing it's there if I hunt for it. I do agree with your post - the UI is bad. Even with the tiny buttons, a better UI would be nice. It seems to be designed for people with relatively small collections. I find this a lot - devices that market to audiophiles emphasize sound quality as all that matters, but often ignores that audiophiles may also have massive music collections. They usually suck on the "how does the audiophile organize and find the music they want to hear through that fancy expensive hardware" aspect.
- tlkwejrp234 4y agoI'd probably just buy a Xperia X / XZ compact. Added bonus: cheap wired NC earphones that works quite decently.
- binbag 4y agoI enjoy high quality audio, but I use my phone. If you get a Quboz or Tidal 24/96 subscription then as long as you take care of the DAC and speakers/headphones you've got a great chain. Rather then buying a Sony digital audio player, you could spend that money on a good set of Sony headphones - assuming you already own the requisite phone. And in the house, you can build a very high performance audio setup for about £200 via hifiberry, avoiding the bonkers price of hires hi-fis.
- tsak 4y agoI love my Sony NWZ-A15¹. My whole music collection fits on a 128 GB SD card. I always found streaming apps lacking. Spotify's UX is atrocious. I also don't think that their recommendation algorithms work well. There's also a huge gap in availability of non-mainstream recordings in most streaming services. ¹ https://www.sony.co.uk/electronics/support/digital-music-players-nw-nwz-a-series/nwz-a15 https://www.sony.co.uk/electronics/support/digital-music-pla...
- justinclift 4y agoWonder if there are any OSS dedicated portable music players out there? eg something like this Sony player, but OSS so hardware/software problems can be iterated on
- stevepdp 4y ago> I can’t describe what a breath of fresh air this is compared to how bad modern smartphone music and streaming apps have become. It’s also nice having a dedicated player that isn’t inundated with notifications and other modern distractions. Separating out ebooks to a dedicated tablet worked the same wonders for my anxiety. A place for everything, and everything in it's place.
- johnchristopher 4y ago> You don’t need to use any special desktop software; you mount the Walkman as a USB storage device and transfer files. Wait… that’s it? Yes! Ooof, yes ! I remember my minidisc fondly but I somehow erased from my memories the atrocious file management thing.
- plaff 4y agoBeing inundated with notifications is not a problem with the god damned smartphone. It's a problem with you not being able to set up apps to shut the hell up if they don't have any business throwing notifications your way. I see this argument all the time and it's completely foreign to me. I get notifications on messages, lost calls and some very specific emails regarding downtime or exceptions in production. That's it, and it works very, very well.
- herbst 4y agoThe worst about modern MP3 players is that they have little to zero buttons. I am on my second Sony E39X since my FiiO died a while ago. The Sony are way to expensive for the quality, but other button MP3 players are a different weight and price class. I hate wasting battery for a fancy screen and Android like OS, like most MP3 players these days. The reason I never stopped using a MP3 player is because I have 20/30+ hours of HQ music organized in folders, just as I like it.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> The reason I never stopped using a MP3 player is because I have 20/30+ hours of HQ music organized in folders, just as I like it. 20-30 hours. Hmm. Clementine tells me: 16345 tracks (64 days 16:52:45) And that's not even large by the comparison with some friends. And yes, it all fits on my Sansa Clip+ (except that I keep the christmas music off the Clip+).
- herbst 4y agoI ment the battery life. Compared to a phone that maybe makes 6-10 hours audio playback.
- m1sta_ 4y agoSony phone and spotify. What's not to like other than a lack of Sony 360 content?
- new132122 4y agoQuestion: is there any hardware related proof that this thing can play music better than any modern iPhone? Edit: With better I mean in terms of quality of the outgoing analog signal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anentropic 4y agoCan anyone recommend a good non-streaming, album-centric music player for Android?
- Stormwalker 4y agoPoweramp is what you're looking for. It is paid player, but it's worth every penny
- worble 4y agoI upvoted this but honestly feel like that isn't a strong enough recommendation for Poweramp. It blows every other player out of the water, there's no competition. I also just checked their website and as of v3 it doesn't even require google services to buy, so even if you have a degoogled phone you can still use it.
- Reason077 4y agoIt’s not a real “Walkman” unless it can play cassette tapes. I’m sure anyone who grew up in the 1980s/90s would agree. How else am I going to listen to my Spice Girls and Backstreet Boys collection?
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoSame way I listen to my collection of 80s dance/club 12" vinyl, which I sold 3 years ago: find them all on YT and download the audio.
- Reason077 4y agoBut it just doesn't sound the same as on classic, analog cassette!
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agothat depends on whether or not it was a Sony MDR or a TDR TDX
- layer8 4y agoVolume buttons not being granular enough is what I despise about iPhones/iPads (and also the one Samsung tablet I own). It’s something that would be so easy to make configurable. (Jailbreaks enabled that.)
- Stormwalker 4y agoThis is cool, but how do you obtain music as files legally? The only platform that allows that is Bandcamp, but if artist is not presented here, torrents is your only option I can think of.
- toastal 4y agoSoulseek is still going.
- ploika 4y agoYou can (almost) always buy CDs and rip them. I'd be mildly surprised if an artist was selling music without either a presence on Bandcamp or a store on their own website that you could download from. I'm certain I've bought a handful of albums from Amazon and Google over the years that I've put onto various phones and MP3 players. Is that not possible anymore?
- Jaruzel 4y agoAmazon still let you download DRM free MP3s for any music you've bought (well, as a Prime customer I still can, maybe it's different for non-Prime). I still buy CDs. That way the music is mine, and no-one can suddenly delete the CD from my bookshelf without my consent. I rip the CDs lossless, then de-jewel-case the CD and put the disc and inlay into an acid-neutral storage bag, and seal it. I can't do hi-bitrate music like this (unless I want to rip BluRay albums) but at my age, it's not like I still have a high-fidelity hearing ability anyway.
- aceazzameen 4y agoAmazon. I still buy mp3s off Amazon to play on Winamp.
- hilbert42 4y agoDoes anyone know if this device reads NTFS-formatted MicroSD cards? (I've had too many failures with ExFAT where I've lost everything - the last crash having wiped out about 200GB files - so I've switched to NTFS. ExFAT is just too fragile to be used regularly as an interchange medium.)
- otikik 4y ago> you mount the Walkman as a USB storage device and transfer files. Wait… that’s it? Yes! Ahh yes that is a Premium feature not even Apple or Android flagship phones are able to provide. For some reason.
- otikik 4y agoIn case it was not clear: connecting a mobile phone to a computer and using it as a usb storage devices is simply not possible, doubly so if you are looking for platform independence (windows/Mac/Linux). At the very least you will have to use external specialized apps, or jailbreak your device, or a combination of both, if it's at all possible. This was a basic feature that all phones used to have. It was quietly removed, I suspect in an effort to push users towards iTunes/Google Play Music, both of which are dead now.
- locofocos 4y agoThe death of Google Play Music sent me down a similar path. I fired up my old 3rd gen ipod touch and synced it up with my old iTunes collection. It was jarring missing out on a decade of UX development, but it's been a breath of fresh air being able to just.... manage your music collection and play the music you want to play. No ads, no playing something I didn't ask for. ITunes on windows is really nice today. Older CDs are super cheap, and my family is often happy to offload their old CDs to me. It's also helped me rediscover a lot of old music from my formative years. If I had to choose between my old favorites and all the new neat stuff I've found on Spotify, I would choose the old stuff! And I can still pull out my phone for those occasions I want something on Spotify, but if that happens enough, I buy the CD and it gets loaded into the collection. It even sent me down a rabbit hole of getting a home stereo again. It's so nice leaving music playing in our living room. For music on the go, iTunes makes it dead simple to copy/paste playlists onto my android phone's storage.
- wg4t3464y4 4y agoSandisk makes a line of budget players, that while inferior in many aspects, excel in at least one major area over most competitors: they all have physical buttons, not a touch screen. For a music player, this is a must, because it lets you pause/play, fastforward/rewind, skip track go back, raise/lower volume without having to actually look at the screen. I clip mine to the inside of my left pants pocket, and other than track selection, I can operate the entire thing without having to look at it.
- rchaud 4y agoAs an MP3 player fanatic in the pre-smartphone era, this post brought back a wave of nostalgia. Tactile buttons! A proper DAC! A device that does one thing, and does it well! I miss the ability to control playback using physical buttons, and not having to look at the device. Back when Android firmware flashing was common (OEMs rarely sell phones with unlockable bootloaders today), you could use the volume buttons to act as "forward/backward 1 track" buttons by holding them down. That hasn't worked on a single other phone I owned after 2014. I loved the default Android music app too, and then one day the UI started showing items from Google Music Cloud or whatever, right alongside my locally stored tracks, as if they were the same. I jumped ship right away, but had to find an alternative music player app that was "offline-only".
- ngcc_hk 4y agoWonder how it compares with sony audio recorder which do raw.
- kwatsonafter 4y agoMan Rube. I really hope you never, ever have to live around working class people. They'll literally tear you apart. Thank god for inequality keeping these little anime dorks safe. God bless America.
- csdvrx 4y ago> I really hope you never, ever have to live around working class people. They'll literally tear you apart. ? > Thank god for inequality keeping these little anime dorks safe. God bless America. ?? Can you explain the point you are trying to make? Is the problem the price of the unit? Or is it your opinion that "working class people" would tear apart the argument that the NW-A55 is a nice device? If so, why do you think they will dislike about the device? Or which alternative will they prefer and recommend?
- kwatsonafter 4y agoIt's a rhetorical point about the degradation of our social economy. I shouldn't have to explain poetry.
- csdvrx 4y ago> It's a rhetorical point about the degradation of our social economy. I'm sorry, I still don't get it - neither from a rhetorical angle, nor from a poetry standpoint. I like poetry though, and after checking your profile I like your take on things (ex: the new programming paradigms) even if I couldn't understand your reply here or to the person who suggested putting side by side Rousseau, Montessori and Steiner. Anyway, if you've got 5 minutes, please explain! You said you are an academic pedagogist in training, and I'm always eager to learn more about things that interest me. Music, sociology, and the sociology of music are SUPER interesting to me!