11 ms·
Google will remove user location history for abortion clinic visits
- 988747 4y agoWhy only abortion clinics? They should simply stop collecting location history altogether.
- pc86 4y agoIt's not only abortion clinics, anything categorized as a sensitive place. I'd like to say more but it would violate at least two of the site guidelines. :)
- KennyBlanken 4y agoI don't see how the guidelines prevent you from mentioning places that google automatically does not include in location history.
- metadat 4y agoWhich guidelines, can you elaborate? Seems odd, especially considering the other low-effort comment you left in this thread (consisting only of the word "No").
- josephcsible 4y agoWhy isn't this considered destruction of evidence and thus a crime itself?
- gouggoug 4y agoIt's not illegal to visit an abortion clinic, domestic violence shelter or other similarly-sensitive place.
- gruez 4y agoSuppose you visited someone's house to murder them. Does it count as destruction of evidence to scrub evidence that places you at the crime scene (eg. google location history or your car's dashcam footage)? After all, visiting someone's house isn't a crime either.
- bmicraft 4y agoWhen google does it without knowing what you did there, no. You can't knowingly destroy evidence if there isn't a (known) crime.
- gruez 4y agoOkay, here's a new thought experiment: suppose some trump supporters did some illegal activities at a protest (think jan 6th). In typical trump supporter fashion, they also have truth social[1] installed and location tracking was enabled. Would you be fine with truth social scrubbing evidence relating to that protest? After all, showing up to the protest isn't illegal, so it should be perfectly fine to scrub all information relating to the protest. It'd only be illegal if they specifically searched for illegal activity and only scrubbed those. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_Social https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_Social
- somenewaccount1 4y agoYes. That's how privacy protection works. Both the good guys and the bad guys benefit equally.
- gruez 4y agoWell, that's the sane way of interpreting it. The alternative is finding some sort of post hoc justification to prevent your opponents for using it.
- mattzito 4y agoThere’s a nuance here, which is that in your scenario it sounds like truth social made a conscious decision to erase location data focused around this particular event - if that’s the case, and they picked this event specifically, that seems sketchy. Why that event, why just these people, etc. If, on the other hand, three months before January 6th truth social said “you know what, we are going to delete all location data that is near any government building going forward”, that seems to be to be morally neutral. The other way to look at it is that this change protects everyone who is at an abortion clinic, whether getting an abortion, protesting abortion, or just happened to be walking by.
- cma 4y agoBeing in the vicinity of a clinic isn't a crime.
- pc86 4y agoNo
- wesleywt 4y ago
- _-david-_ 4y agoNot accurate. There are millions of nonreligious prolifers.
- hda2 4y agoBillions if you count the rest of the world.
- smt88 4y agoThis is ridiculous. There aren't even 1 billion nonreligious people in the world[1]. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_atheism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_atheism
- _-david-_ 4y agoThere are under 2 billion nonreligious people in the world so billions is not accurate. I wouldn't be surprised with a hundred million or more, but I don't have worldwide numbers.
- hluska 4y ago
- danenania 4y agoApart from the other answers given, states have no jurisdiction to make actions taken in another state illegal.
- aaron695 4y ago
- tehjoker 4y agoHow would Google respond to a standing order to send abortion visits in real time? It's good to limit retention but that just speeds up the timetable for collection by reactionary states.
- car_analogy 4y agoI'd rather they just give us clear location spying settings, that are opt-in, instead of making it so deliberately confusing that their own engineers can't figure out how to disable location spying [1]. [1] https://yro.slashdot.org/story/20/08/26/1428200/unredacted-suit-shows-googles-own-engineers-confused-by-privacy-settings https://yro.slashdot.org/story/20/08/26/1428200/unredacted-s...
- kop316 4y agoIIRC, the location history in Google is pretty fine grained in both time (like minute to sub-minute) and location (GPS location if it has it). So if the location history is deleted when a user is within ....500 ft of a sensitive place? The lack of logs all of the sudden may be enough for an authority to ask for e.g. carrier location logs (or pick your favorite app that also logs location data too).
- userbinator 4y agoThe fact that there even is such a thing as "user location history" is the problem. Carving out (politically motivated, for sure) exceptions only shows the extent of Google's massive abuse of privacy.
- bArray 4y agoExactly. Collecting location data in itself should not be done, and the presumption that Google is somehow equipped to know when not to collect data is pretty disgusting. It's entirely possible that location data is abused in many ways they cannot think of. For example, a location that ties somebody to the illegal purchase of a pharmacy drug they desperately need, but cannot otherwise obtain. One could only imagine what the likes of Hitler, Stalin or Mao (to name a few) would have been capable of if only they had been able to compel the likes of Google to release location data. It's an exceptional tool and a weapon in the wrong hands.
- mc32 4y agoEven the better governments of the world are using this kind of information contrary to the spirit of the law and in many cases against the law itself --and very very few in gov't care, what's more most in government want to expand the capabilities. So, yes, imagine the bad guys and gals.
- kornhole 4y agoWatching everybody's movements is tyranny. When you compare how much power those classical tyrants had to what the state has now, you may not need to compare the relatively impotent states of the past.
- mc32 4y agoThis is a good opportunity for privacy proponents and activists to take advantage of this opening and push for a stop to the collection of any of this information. This is the time to take the mile, this is the time to make the slope slippery.
- 4y ago
- xwdv 4y agoThis only creates opportunities for other startups to track this history by other means, could be lucrative in some states.
- bdowling 4y agoSo, if you want to commit a crime, do it near an abortion clinic so that Google won't have your location data to give to the prosecution?
- somenewaccount1 4y agoYeah....that's what I would rely on, the data being scrubbed. /S Or, you could just leave your phone at home and commit the crime anywhere with the same location data anonymity. On a side note, isn't it weird how attached we are to our phones it's hard to imagine going anywhere without it? Even to commit a crime!
- bdowling 4y ago> Or, you could just leave your phone at home… Nobody does that. Not even criminals.
- ComradePhil 4y ago
- newshorts 4y agoThis misses the point remarkably completely. It’s not about folks feeling judged. It’s about folks being prosecuted for receiving an abortion. Google’s collection of personal data could make the prosecution pretty easy if it were compelled by the government to provide it.
- ComradePhil 4y ago
- 86383537531 4y ago
- hluska 4y agoAbortion is completely legal where I live. I don’t see any problem with corporations helping defeat sexist “laws”.
- mikece 4y ago
- pyronik19 4y ago
- myko 4y agoExtremely odd comment unworthy of the site.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hluska 4y agoYou’ll get used to pyronik and just learn to ignore.
- pessimizer 4y agoUnrelated to anything, but I see that "leftist" typo a lot and wonder if people just don't actually know the word, or if it's some weird cultural in-group thing like "blockchain."
- Noumenon72 4y agoDid they edit, or do you not consider 'leftist' a proper spelling?
- dang 4y agoWould you please stop breaking the site guidelines? You've been doing it repeatedly, unfortunately. Personal attacks are obviously not ok, regardless of how bad another account's comments are or you feel they are. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 4y agoWe've banned this account for using HN primarily for ideological battle. That's not allowed here, regardless of what you're battling for or against, because it destroys what the site is supposed to be for. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- bamboozled 4y agoThe mind absolutely boggles, what the hell is going on here? The world really is going insane, first the abortion being illegal, then the fact Google has to take steps like this.
- guelo 4y agoWhat is going on is that Christianists have seized extreme power and are using it ruthlessly.
- nathanaldensr 4y ago
- cromwellian 4y agoAh, the “states are laboratories of democracy argument”. You do realize GOP states are crafting laws to punish citizens who get an abortion in another state as well as the national GOP is already taking a our federal legislation for a national ban? So let’s dispense with the BS that this is a principled ruling in line with freedom and devolution of power.
- wutbrodo 4y agoCould you clarify how you think this falsifies the claim in any way? State legislatures planning bad law is somehow an indication that the SC ruling was too?
- lostgame 4y agoThis absolute piece of shit has been telling people to ‘move states if they don’t like it’, like a racist who tells Mexicans to ‘go back home’. I don’t think he gets that this is a human rights and, in particular, women’s rights; issue. Let us women speak and vote amongst ourselves.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- katmannthree 4y agoGiven how cell providers are likewise collecting location data and won't be following suit, it seems like this has a high probability of backfiring...
- fallinghawks 4y agoI'm curious if there will there be any defined radius of deleted location history. Will it leave some kind of gap that may be obvious?
- ronsor 4y agoThe lack of location history around "sensitive" places is in and of itself suspicious, or more simply put, lack of information is still information.
- lucasyvas 4y agoIt is - would it appear as a blackout during your trip? They should insert random/junk location data instead. It's marginally better in that the data doesn't appear amiss, but the algorithm would still be the problem if found out.
- nathanaldensr 4y agoIf Google writes software with knowledge that its use will explicitly be used to commit crimes, is Google an accomplice?
- crummy 4y agoMy location history is spotty enough; it doesn't appear to be constantly pinging GPS, so I don't think an hour sized hole would look amiss.
- Proven 4y ago
- patrick451 4y agoI'm missing something. If a state outlaws abortion, why would these clinics still be open? And if we're talking about underground, black market clinics, how would google know?
- mattzito 4y agoI think they’re optimizing more for people who travel across state lines to obtain an abortion in a state where it’s legal. Those people may face a risk of prosecution in their home state, so avoiding evidence they were at a (legal) abortion clinic is helpful.
- kyrra 4y agoWhat right would one state have to go after a resident that travels to another state to have an abortion? Isn't it clearly outside the first state's jurisdiction?
- boomboomsubban 4y agoI live in a state where failing a drug test is a crime, even if the drugs were consumed legally elsewhere. They can likely make a law similar to that for having an abortion, though I don't know the exact method you'd use.
- pessimizer 4y agoWhat state? Never heard of that and it's horrifying.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoNo comment. It's a misdemeanor in Utah and a felony in South Dakota though. It's called possession by consumption.
- londgine 4y agoI'm pretty sure that if the age of consent in another state is less than your state, it is forbidden to travel there to take advantage of that. I don't know how that law is legal, but I'm pretty sure the same logic can be applied to abortions.
- awinter-py 4y ago'when our system identifies you're at a clinic' implies they have a signal for this g is dreaming if they think they can make a signal for 'high likelihood illegal location' and not receive a pen register style warrant by every state that cares. roe provided federal a right to privacy for abortions. roe has been overturned. the google.blog post[2] linked by the wapo article talks about 'law enforcement demands' and says g has a 'track record of pushing back'. eff disagrees[1], says dragnets + keyword warrants are still happening in the US. maybe could do this with a broader commitment to wiping 'all medical facilities', and more clarity around deleting supporting data for trips. But you mostly can't get anonymous medical care in the US -- even if clinics take cash, states could ask insurance cos for info, or credit card cos, and assume the 'location history holes' in abortion states, not explained by insurance payment, were cash abortions. would be nice to have an actual right to medical privacy, aka anonymity + civil damages for violators. scotus leans the opposite way -- sorrell v ims[3] overturned a vt medical privacy law as violating the 1st amendment rights of data miners. 1. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/04/google-fights-dragnet-warrant-users-search-histories-overseas-while-continuing https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/04/google-fights-dragnet-... 2. https://blog.google/technology/safety-security/protecting-peoples-privacy-on-health-topics/ https://blog.google/technology/safety-security/protecting-pe... 3. https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/10pdf/10-779.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/10pdf/10-779.pdf
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoBy this logic, is there literally anything Google could do to push back? Say PrivacyCo launches their own maps app. In line with their brand, they don't retain any location history and they don't even keep activity logs. However, their server still needs to know where users are temporarily in order to send a map of the local area. So now Texas comes knocking on their door. "Hey, PrivacyCo, y'know that thing where you don't store location history? Well, you're about to start storing location history on X Y and Z, because we think they might be about to get an abortion and we want to catch them." At the end of the day, law enforcement is law enforcement and I'm not sure there's a lot private companies can do as long as they're providing these types of services. Perhaps this is the thing that will make us seriously rethink our relationship with technology. Maybe. Theoretically. Remind me one more time how I ever managed to get anywhere without Apple Maps?
- diebeforei485 4y agoWhy not all clinics?
- krapp 4y agoThe US Supreme Court recently repealed Roe v. Wade, a previous decision which established access to abortion as a Constitutional right on the basis of an implied right to privacy the current Court no longer recognizes. As a result numerous states have declared abortion illegal, which makes visiting abortion clinics, specifically (even out of state, in some cases) a crime. Other kinds of clinics are likely not included because visiting them doesn't pose the same legal risk.
- mlindner 4y agoThis is the third different rationale I've heard for roe v wade, and none of them agree. Last I heard it wasn't about privacy but about liberty. > specifically (even out of state, in some cases) a crime. That's not legal under federal law and the constitution. You can't arrest citizens for participating in some activity outside of the state.
- krapp 4y ago>This is the third different rationale I've heard for roe v wade, and none of them agree. Last I heard it wasn't about privacy but about liberty. I don't know what you've else you've heard but you can study the decision itself[0], or summary material[1,2], to find the actual legal argument used. "On January 22, 1973, the Supreme Court issued a 7–2 decision holding that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution provides a fundamental "right to privacy", which protects a pregnant woman's right to an abortion." [0]https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep410/usrep410113/usrep410113.pdf https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep... [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roe_v._Wade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roe_v._Wade [2]https://supreme.findlaw.com/supreme-court-insights/roe-v--wade-case-summary--what-you-need-to-know.html https://supreme.findlaw.com/supreme-court-insights/roe-v--wa... >That's not legal under federal law and the constitution. Feel free to tell that to the several state governments attempting to do so[3]. Relevant quote: “Just because you jump across a state line doesn’t mean your home state doesn’t have jurisdiction,” said Peter Breen, vice president and senior counsel for the Thomas More Society. “It’s not a free abortion card when you drive across the state line.” Of course the obvious challenge is through the Interstate Commerce Clause but given the nature of the current court and Conservative's disdain for it in general, I wouldn't expect the court to rule in the government's favor. [3]https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:7Goi6ixabHAJ:https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/06/29/abortion-state-lines/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-b-1-d https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:7Goi6i...
- mlindner 4y agoBefore people overreact to things, realize that it's completely illegal for a state to make a law that says "you can't go to another state for abortions". The supreme court has signaled as such that they wouldn't support any such ruling and would strike it down as illegal. That violates interstate commerce clause which is exclusively the domain of the federal government. States can't war with each other.
- sterlind 4y agoKavanaugh suggested that in his concurring opinion, but that's one justice, and it was a 6-3 decision, and he could change his mind. the Court could well find that bans on out-of-state abortions are necessary to properly enforce state abortion bans, or uphold a ban on facilitating travel since that occurs inside a state's borders, or that the commerce clause needs to be reigned in anyway, and gee, what an opportune moment to revisit that bit of precedent too. given how the Court just ruled in Oklahoma v. Castro-Huerta, doing nothing but (incorrectly) picking and choosing precedent that supported the outcome they wanted, I'd put approximately zero stock in this Court to be internally consistent whatsoever. except for Gorsuch.
- mlindner 4y agoIt wasn't a 6-3 decision. It was a 5-4 decision for overruling Roe v Wade. Roberts wanted a more narrow ruling and was against overruling Roe v Wade. Roberts wrote a Concurrence in judgement, not a full concurrence, and did not joint the majority opinion.
- vlovich123 4y agoAnd yet as far as I know Texas’ law hasn’t been overturned which accomplishes this in effect. For now I remain highly skeptical. These same justices claimed they would respect precedent during their confirmation hearings.
- mlindner 4y agoBecause the courts take time. The ruling is hardly a week old. It's going to take years for things to settle.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoI'm far too cynical, but I see this ending with police requesting location history to find someone who bombed an abortion clinic and Google using that as an excuse to never remove location history again.
- kube-system 4y agoAs if last week it was totally reasonable for Google to keep this data /s This just highlights why these gee-whiz features that are hastily implemented by big tech are short sighted. There’s plenty of other sensitive places that people go on a regular basis that are still being collected.
- spoonjim 4y agoGoogle will not be able to sustain this. In states where abortions become crimes Google cannot start deleting just the evidence pertaining to those crimes. They could stop collecting location data entirely, but this selective approach will not survive in court.
- cs2818 4y agoWould really like to know more about the implementation here. While I personally am not a user or fan of Google location history, I know people who have jobs that involve a lot of travel between medical facilities that find Google location history to be a good mechanism to verify their activities for billing appropriate accounts. Will there be a way to opt out?
- mariojv 4y agoThis is a nice start, but I am not sure if it helps at all with geofence warrants. See https://techcrunch.com/2021/08/19/google-geofence-warrants/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/08/19/google-geofence-warrants/ Location history is a feature that they use to help you track your personal movements, but I am guessing that they keep your location history briefly in a separate store that serves things like geofence warrants. Otherwise, their utility would be limited to the subset of users that has the feature (off by default) enabled. Even if they don't store the location history, imagine state authorities know an abortion clinic is operating illegally and just get a warrant to track who visits for a few weeks before shutting it down. They could get the data before it gets deleted, since Google appears to be storing it at least temporarily. These are really dark times for the future of dragnet surveillance if states do employ it in their criminalization of abortion. I hope that this sparks a conversation about digital privacy and that more people take steps to protect themselves online.