8 ms·
Open source body quits GitHub, urges you to do the same
- pdenton 4y agoWhat's a good alternative? Preferably not in the US, preferably not biased towards (or against) any political agenda.
- cassianoleal 4y agoRadicle? https://radicle.xyz/ https://radicle.xyz/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notpushkin 4y agoThat's one bad way to use blockchain, huh
- Comevius 4y agohttps://codeberg.org/ https://codeberg.org/
- mananaysiempre 4y agoThis does not nearly rise to GitHub levels of badness, of course, but reading their ToS thread[1] leaves me with an icky feeling. [1] https://codeberg.org/Codeberg/org/pulls/18 https://codeberg.org/Codeberg/org/pulls/18
- cookiengineer 4y agoHosting your code where all the nazi/racist/sexist assholes from imageboards are doesn't make your project shine.
- dementiapatien 4y agoThis website appears to be based in Europe, is that where all the imageboard trolls live?
- eline44 4y agoSelf-hosted gitea[1], or find a friend (or friend group?) who already has one, and ask for an account. [1] https://gitea.io/ https://gitea.io/
- chriswarbo 4y agoMoving repos between hosts is trivial; e.g. I keep bare clones on my laptop, on an AWS server, and GitHub; with post-receive hooks that keep them all in sync. GitHub's appeal is all the add-on functionality that's not actually stored in the git repo itself; e.g. Issues, Pull Requests, etc. That can't be migrated away easily. Anyone who (a) has concerns about GitHub (monoculture, Microsoft, Copilot, whatever), and (b) relies on such add-on functionality, should look into moving that metadata into their repos. To give Microsoft some credit, GitHub Actions already does this (via YAML files in a .github/workflows folder) For my personal projects, I use a simple program called Artemis to manage issues, which just stores maildir files in a hidden folder: http://www.chriswarbo.net/blog/2017-06-14-artemis.html http://www.chriswarbo.net/blog/2017-06-14-artemis.html
- pizza234 4y agoGitLab imports issues and pull requests, with some caveats: https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/project/import/github.html#prerequisites https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/project/import/github.html#p....
- bornfreddy 4y agoGitLab UI is full of warts though. Since they are there for 5+ years I doubt they will be fixed soon. I am talking about little things - weird button-with-dropdown to start a comment/discussion on a MR, infuriating emojis (no I don't want to put a sign :man-kissing-a-man: just because I entered a smiley) and similar. It looks like either their devs are not using the product or any change is hampered by red tape. Still, we use it, but try to use just core functionality (git, CI, issues, wiki) and avoid anything else. Always wanted to try gitea, maybe now it's the time.
- ghostoftesla 4y agoHave a look at Gitea. You can run it as a podman rootless container off the box on your local machine. The functionality is there, the community refuses to switch. There people who still have the idea that gh is still whatvit was 10 years ago.
- blueflow 4y agoYou don't need hosting to use git.
- MonkeyClub 4y ago> You don't need hosting to use git. This, 100%. Git is useful for all your textual versioning needs - but your friends don't really need access to all your git repos. The whole idea of putting your whole life on GitHub is a dev's equivalent of putting all your life on Facebook - an excellent idea, as far as Microsoft and Facebook are concerned. If you can't sell ads to coders, then perhaps you can sell them recycled code. But yeah perhaps I'm hatin' :) Speaking of GH alternatives, though, the Tildeverse has https://tildegit.org/ https://tildegit.org/ https://tildegit.org/ https://tildegit.org/.
- junon 4y agoExcept for when GH wasn't owned by Microsoft for almost a decade...
- xtracto 4y agoThe problem with that is that at that time GH was surviving with VC money. That money entered with the promise that at some point GH would monetize their users. The "paid account" model wasn't enough for them, And now that Microsoft owns them it's also not enough. They've found another way to monetize all that code. It surprises me though that Microsoft hasn't added a Stack overflow like panel to github. More. People are jumping between GH for the code AZ md StackOverflow for the support.
- npteljes 4y agoVersioning the source code is just one of the many things people use GitHub for.
- doublerabbit 4y agoOnedev is what I use for my personal code. Selfhosted too: https://code.onedev.io/projects/160 https://code.onedev.io/projects/160
- lapser 4y agoAs someone else has said, the alternative isn't to move away from GH (at least not for this specific issue). The alternative is to change your license to not allow for this.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoIf you change your license to exclude this particular use, it's no longer Open Source (no restrictions on how it's used). If you change your license to forbid removing the license, then there's a good chance that it doesn't hold any legal power. Reason being that machine processing is allowed by copyright laws.
- dento 4y ago> If you change your license to forbid removing the license, then there's a good chance that it doesn't hold any legal power. But almost all licenses already do that, for example the MIT license says: > The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoTherefore, changing the license is not going to improve matters at all. It's already forbidden, yet we are where we are.
- pabs3 4y agoThe Conservancy post/site mention SourceHut (thats in the US though): https://sourcehut.org/ https://sourcehut.org/
- junon 4y agoSourcehut is entirely self-hostable and Drew Devault is staunchly pro-FOSS. Nationality means little in this case.
- eesmith 4y agoAt https://sfconservancy.org/GiveUpGitHub/ https://sfconservancy.org/GiveUpGitHub/ they also mention CodeBerg, which is hosted in the EU. https://codeberg.org/ https://codeberg.org/ It's git-only. FWIW, I chose SourceHut in part because they support git and Mercurial, and I'm a Mercurial user. [1] FWIW, the main SourceHut developer last year moved to the Netherlands. https://drewdevault.com/2022/03/24/Netherlands-update.html https://drewdevault.com/2022/03/24/Netherlands-update.html , and commented "I will be re-locating SourceHut, the incorporated entity, to the Netherlands, and gradually moving our infrastructure over the pond." [1] Also because SourceHut is whole-heartedly pro-free software, and also because I feel better being able to pay for a service than depend on the largess of a large company, and also because I don't like monocultures.
- jacooper 4y agohttps://codeberg.org https://codeberg.org Its based in Europe and focuses on free and open source software. However I doubt I can really say its not politically charged.
- rapnie 4y agoGiven the breadth of services Github provide, forge federation using ActivityPub (and ForgeFed extensions) open standards look very promising. A whole host of projects are working on it, and among them is Gitea. They will likely be the first to federate with other instances, so you can work on remote projects from your own environment. Here is an overview of the federation activities: https://forgefriends.org/blog/2022/06/30/2022-06-state-forge-federation/ https://forgefriends.org/blog/2022/06/30/2022-06-state-forge...
- hericium 4y agoBlog post the article is about: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2022/jun/30/give-up-github-launch/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2022/jun/30/give-up-github-la...
- unwind 4y agoWidely discussed yesterday, 450+ comments [1]. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31932250 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31932250
- superfxchip 4y agoClassic Microsoft Move, Bravo.
- MonkeyClub 4y agoThe classic Microsoft move is EEE, I think.
- cassianoleal 4y agoThis is the second E. Just wait for the third.
- goodpoint 4y agoThe Extinguish already started to happen. I know more than one person that stopped contributing to FLOSS because they feel it has been turned into unpaid labor for tech corps.
- speedgoose 4y agoPerhaps one should create an open-source alternative to GitHub copilot also trained on proprietary source code, such as some leaked Windows source-code, and everyone will be happy and appreciate that we can use fair-use to train such AIs.
- sigmoid10 4y agoHaving seen parts of some leaked Windows source code, I'm not confident such a system would make it very far.
- blackoil 4y agoThe model may not be illegal, but anyone using this model to generate any large enough code which is verbatim copy of Windows code will be doing a copyright violation. So you'll waste CPU to create model and not use it.
- onion2k 4y agoSimply moving away from Github is not enough to protect your code if you see this as a problem. Moving your code away from Github to some open alternative doesn't stop Github consuming it to use in Copilot unless you specifically forbid that in your license. If you code is freely available to use for any purpose, as many open source licenses permit, then that includes using it as training data for a for-profit product. You need to use a license that restricts its use, and restricts the use of derivatives otherwise someone uploading a fork to Github will just put you back where you started. I think GPL3 would give you such protections, but you should check with a lawyer if this is particularly important to you.
- blueflow 4y agoOr don't license your code at all. Gives you great power with selective enforcement of IP rights.
- amelius 4y agoHuh? What if someone else claims they wrote your code and slaps a license on it?
- yakak 4y agoCopyright is independent of license.
- blueflow 4y agoWhen its my IP i can enforce it, send them a DMCA or sue them for damages. They used my stuff without having a license to do so. If they slapped an own license on it, granting others permission to it, that would increase the damages.
- amelius 4y agoOk, but you'd have to prove it.
- loldk 4y agoI remember back around 2011 I went to an Ionic framework meetup where they served pizza and soda. After listening for hours about how they basically made a streamlined design system for any company to use freely, QA began. I raised my hand and when called upon I asked whether or not anyone in the room felt that the companies who would be using it actually deserved it. The lead dev got flustered the room went quiet for a second before they moved on. Feels like maybe people are beginning to wake up a bit, I hope.
- gerikson 4y agoSFconservancy.org is a copyleft/GPL-aligned organization, so calling it an "Open Source" body is really not correct.
- dustinmoris 4y agoIronically I believe GitHub should play a bigger part in OSS. They and a few other platforms have a unique position which could help to make open source software more sustainable: https://dusted.codes/fund-oss-through-package-managers https://dusted.codes/fund-oss-through-package-managers
- akpa1 4y agoThe option you propose in the article is an interesting one, though not what I'd choose. Following the idea of "make it as friction-free as possible", something I'd like to be able to do is somehow track my usages of various packages across the course of a month, then divide a set amount of money, say £15, across each of them proportionally. Each project could have whatever amount they "earned" (doesn't seem like the right word, but never mind) automatically donated to them at the end of each month.
- LtWorf 4y agoThis would make js module writers disproportionately rich vs the people doing the hard work that makes their 1 line module run.
- LtWorf 4y agoIt makes no sense. A library downloaded 3 times a year might just have users that know how to set up a local cache, while a library used by unskilled teams will be downloaded 15 times every time they run a build. All your model does is push people to learn how to make local caches, and it also doesn't work at all with FLOSS licenses, since there is a right to redistribute.
- rvz 4y agoThe failure of the free software movement of totally removing closed-source software has resulted in the creation of GitHub and the 'open-source' crowd with the tech bros happily running along with that despite not learning anything about what happened to Sourceforge. The only one that learned very quickly to take advantage of this was Microsoft that is buying the open-source ecosystem and offering the best tools for free. It's not only a clever pricing scam, but a form of EEE; that suffocates the likes of JetBrains which they have to increase prices themselves. It is not early days anymore and this time GitHub is part of Microsoft and it tells us that it will be around for a long time. The tech bros cheering on GitHub and Microsoft will soon realise that neither of them are their friends and Microsoft is still at its Embrace, Extend and Extinguish ways.
- noisy_boy 4y agoMaybe its time to have versions of various open source licenses that expressly prohibit such use. GPLv4?
- kelnos 4y agoGitHub appears to be relying on a fair-use defense for Copilot. So it doesn't matter what license you slap on the code; if they're correct that their use constitutes fair use, as long as they can see your code, they can use it.
- Hamuko 4y agoYou could slap some kind of a clause in your license that forbids the use of your code in conjunction with an AI-powered code tool, and then try to sue people who use Copilot. Microsoft's claim is after all that training Copilot is fair use. Although if you find your code in a project even without such a clause, you can probably still attempt to sue them for copyright violation, since most likely they are not abiding by your license anyways.
- IshKebab 4y agoNo, fair use means that you can copy the code without agreeing to any license. It doesn't matter what clause you add. That's the whole point of fair use.
- 4y ago
- Proven 4y ago
- cjohansson 4y agoI think that Copilot is independent of license since it auguments/manipulates the source but the idea of Copilot is independent of GitHub and that idea needs to be explored
- bilekas 4y ago> Why Copilot was trained on FOSS code but not copyrighted Windows code, and whether the company can specify all the software licenses and copyright holders attached to code used in the training data set. Seems a case of "license respect for me but not for thee". Microsoft are just a string of companies changing their original promises when taking over smaller companies with proper values. See : Meta with Oculus not needing a FB account.
- master_crab 4y agoI don’t know. It might be a good idea for all of us that they didn’t use Windows code for the modeling…
- bilekas 4y agoActually this is kinda funny. But ignores the main problem!
- tr1ll10nb1ll 4y agoMeta is said to change the policy requiring a Facebook account soon, by the way. I would hope when they release the new VR headsets, this would come into effect. https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2021/10/meta-removing-facebook-login-requirement-for-quest-headsets-by-next-year/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2021/10/meta-removing-faceboo...
- ComodoHacker 4y agoSo they basically object to inventing any new ways to create value out of OSS besides direct reusing. They should rename themselves to Technical Progress Level Conservancy or something like that.
- kryptiskt 4y agoThe thing that worries me here is that supporters of free software wants to strengthen copyright. I would have thought that most were against IP in general or at least in favor of making it weaker. Is protecting your code against Copilot really worth giving this weapon to Disney?
- alpaca128 4y agoGo create the movie counterpart of Copilot based on Disney material and you'll see how little Disney lawyers need additional "weapons" to sue you to hell and back.
- Timwi 4y agoCan't speak for others, but I don't want to strengthen copyright at all, I want to strengthen copyleft: anyone should be able to make something like Copilot, but nobody should be allowed to hoard it to themselves and charge money for it. It should just be free.
- goodpoint 4y ago> free software wants to strengthen copyright. I would have thought that most were against IP in general That's a misunderstanding. In a world without any concept of authorship and copyright, people would share, modify and redistribute books, drawing, musical scores... But most software can be compiled (and even obfuscated), making it unpractical to further modify and redistribute a copy. This means than in such word closed source would be still present. And freeload from FOSS without even giving attribution. FOSS is about building a cooperative development model. Copyleft is based on copyright laws simply because there's no other legal instrument to ensure that software remains open.
- dento 4y ago> But most software can be compiled (and even obfuscated), making it unpractical to further modify and redistribute a copy. Tell that to people who remove DRM restrictions, fix bugs and then distribute the result. The only reason there aren't companies and university courses dedicated for such modifications is that it's illegal.
- M0r13n 4y agoFor me Github offers the best UI/UX of all public code hosting and collaboration platforms. At work we use Gitlab, which has come a long way. But I „grew up“ with GitHub and find it hard to switch.
- remix2000 4y agoI don't get what's wrong with Copilot being trained on GPL code. If I, a human, had learnt to code by reading GPL code, would that have rendered all the code I ever write GPL too? After all, all human-created content is transformative due to how our brains work. And AI isn't all that different from us in the way it learns.
- BaculumMeumEst 4y agoThe issue is that if you, as a human, regurgitated swaths of GPL code verbatim, you would be in violation of copyright.
- bobsmooth 4y agoI can't fathom the amount of copyright infringement the Ctrl, C and V keys have caused.
- npteljes 4y agoYou might not be able, but larger enterprises pay serious money for solutions that make sure that the code is clean, so that a junior copypaster won't make the company liable. One of such is https://www.blackducksoftware.com/ https://www.blackducksoftware.com/
- blackoil 4y agoIf CodePilot is outputting unique enough GPL code verbatim, then a simple search can inform the user about it and he can make the decision to keep it or not. This could be a feature requirement.
- dewey 4y agoThere will still be a person committing the code that Copilot came up with in the end, wouldn't that person be in violation of copyright too then? Just like if they would've copied it from some code base they found online under a non-permissive license.
- dsr_ 4y ago
- pjmlp 4y agoCopilot is no different from any company taking advantage of non-copyleft licenses . If you have a problem with that, learn to pick your licenses properly.
- madmulita 4y agoHow does a company using GH for their closed source code know it's not being used in training, good faith?
- tpoacher 4y agowhatever happened to bitbucket btw?
- ksaj 4y agoI noticed upon logging into GitHub today that there is now an option to share or not share your code with co-pilot.
- rambojazz 4y agonotabug.org has worked fine for me so far