5 ms·
I’ve long suspected that there is nothing terribly special about Tesla. They were simply the only EV brand. People didn’t have much choice if they wanted an EV.
by MBCook 4y ago
I’ve long suspected that there is nothing terribly special about Tesla. They were simply the only EV brand. People didn’t have much choice if they wanted an EV. They succeeded so much because they sold EVs.
Yes the Leaf and Bolt exist but they’re not exactly close to Model 3 performance. And not well known at all compared to Tesla.
Without the edge of being the “only” company with EVs is there any reason to think they’ll be big much longer? I’m not saying they’ll go out of business. But they may end up more Genesis than Ford.
They have some advantages like they seems to have the most efficient tech, they’re best at OTA updates, and have a relatively strong battery supply ready.
But is that enough given they’ll be competing against EVs from the entire industry?
We’re about to find out.
- spaetzleesser 4y agoMy guess is that Tesla will get bogged down by maintenance of cars that get older. It seems they have saved a lot of money by not setting up a service network but at some point they probably have to provide service and parts.
- echelon 4y agoExtremely limited anecdotal evidence: I recently talked to half a dozen contractors and they were much more excited about Rivian than Ford F-150 Lightning, citing a bad track record from Ford's new automotive hardware. They'd be open to F-150 after a few design iterations work out the kinks. What they wouldn't consider was CyberTruck. Electric pickup trucks will be a huge market, and Tesla doesn't seem to have a product for contractors and builders.
- MBCook 4y agoThat seems a little odd to me that you would trust a completely brand new company that has no track record over a not-perfect track record from a major manufacturer. Que sera. The CyberTruck thing makes sense. All though at this point I wonder if we ever see it at all (in something similar to its current form/promised specs). But that is a HUGE chunk of the American market. Ford is there, I saw one on the road earlier this week. Others like Chevy are coming.
- itsoktocry 4y ago>I recently talked to half a dozen contractors and they were much more excited about Rivian Ah yes, the Rivian truck that may never see the light of day versus the EV built on the best selling vehicle platform in North America that's for sale today (albeit at inflated prices), built by a 100+ year old company. How many of these contractors have been around beyond the housing-bubble-du-jour?
- helpfulclippy 4y agoI don't understand the "may never see the light of day" comment. I saw a Rivian in the parking lot just this week.
- metadat 4y agoThey will come, but it's going to take time for Rivian to scale up.
- MBCook 4y agoI’ve seen a few on the road. They exist in the wild. Will Rivian be with us long? I don’t know. Law of averages makes it seem unlikely. But it’s not pure vaporware like the CyberTruck or some of the other EV companies like Nikola.
- mbushey 4y ago> They'd be open to F-150 after a few design iterations work out the kinks. Ford already fired those engineers. I don't think there will be much more coming out from Ford other than Bankruptcy. Not sure how long they can last loosing a billion dollars a month.
- MrMan 4y agoI am not buying this anecdote I will go with ford
- recursive 4y agoAnecdotal, but I've been trying to buy an EV for the last couple of days. I've been to 4 dealerships. As a first-order approximation, everyone's out of everything. Around here, seems like someone could win just by having inventory. As if that were possible.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThat's all cars currently, unless you want something very odd, with a lot of features that are tacked on to increase price.
- jraines 4y agoYet I see new model stuff all over the roads where I am, despite cursory searching feeling similarly futile. Did these people have great foresight, pay out the nose, both, or …?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoBoth - car dealerships are accepting pre-orders, but some of them basically run an auction. With some luck, you can find something you want without paying too much.
- dagw 4y agoI know couple of people who very recently took delivery new cars, but they'd ordered them in September and April of last year.
- acdha 4y agoThe big problem is that they’re run by an egotist who thinks he’s the hero in a 90s sci-fi novel. His antics directly turn off some buyers but most of the people I hear passing on them are pointing to basic quality control and things like the UI (touchscreens are terrible, moving controls is even worse). I think they’d have been a lot better positioned now if he’d handed operations over to someone with better attention to detail. Say what you will about their other problems, the big car makers learned that you can’t skimp on quality without facing devastation like Detroit in the 80s and 90s.
- bostonsre 4y agoHe open sourced tesla designs so that competitors could learn from and surpass tesla if tesla stood still. The goal wasn't to be the sole ev car company, the goal was to help the world get off of fossil fuel burning cars. Go ahead and call him an egoist if you want, but that sounds pretty altruistic and the world is a better place because of his actions.
- api 4y agoIt seems like he's betting Tesla or at least its high stock price on full self drive. Unfortunately I think FSD is probably harder than flying Starship, fully reusing it, and building a base on the Moon. FSD might even be harder than landing humans on Mars. It's a totally different kind of problem though. It's the kind where getting 90% of the way there is 10% of the work and getting the other 10% of the way there is 90% of the work. Problem is that 90% there results in the tons of embarrassing FSD beta YouTube videos you see.
- bostonsre 4y agoHe could also be thinking that the future of tesla doesn't matter as much as the future of humanity and he took the action because it was in the best interest of humanity.
- acdha 4y agoLook, I’m not saying he’s satan — just that a lot of basic stuff seems to be getting ignored while he’s chasing public attention, and the competition is not sitting still.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI am saying that they will go out of business. They have invested in a lot of property assuming that their market share of EVs will continue to stay high, and EVs will have strong growth. So far, this has been true, but it won't be for long.
- rad_gruchalski 4y agoI’ve been saying this for a long time and always being laughed at. Tesla may still have an advantage in the battery tech but the Tesla machine is no match to established „legacy” (heh) manufacturers who have much better dealership and service network.
- MBCook 4y agoThey also have the plants. If they can get batteries they can scale faster. What’s going to happen faster? Tesla building an entire new factory? Or VW converting a factory from ICE to EV? I know Tesla has a few factories in progress now. But even if demand sticks grows they may not be able to meet it as fast.
- rad_gruchalski 4y agoThere’s that. And then there’s how fast „legacy” manufacturers can get their shit together. Look at Porsche. They rolled out a complete Taycan factory at €700m within a year or so [1]. No slips, no mess like what happened with Tesla in Brandenburg. [1]: okay, under 48 months: https://www.volkswagenag.com/en/news/2019/09/Porsche_opens_factory.html https://www.volkswagenag.com/en/news/2019/09/Porsche_opens_f..., https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=X1j6rHBoePw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=X1j6rHBoePw.
- novok 4y agoIMO the dealership network isn't really the issue, it's the lack of available parts, lack of repairability in their designs, like the battery pack, a lack of repair manuals for third party shops to adopt, choosing designs that break really easily (like the model X falcon doors) and not having physical buttons for safety reasons. But these are all fixable problems. Good parts availability and a good repair manual set will create a service network very fast, and dealerships are frankly annoying as fuck.
- elorant 4y agoThe problem I always had with Tesla is that their cars don’t feel like they deserve the money they cost. You pay a 100K for a Model S and it doesn’t feel like a 100k car. Even if you compare it with a Mercedes at half its price, assuming that half the price goes to batteries and R&D, it still feels subpar. So my guess is that now that traditional manufacturers get into the game Tesla’s value is going to drop significantly.
- scarface74 4y agoThe problem I have with Tesla is that their onboard infotainment system sucks compared to a $20K car with CarPlay integration…
- MBCook 4y agoI sort of understand what they’re doing. Companies like to control their product and not hand it off to someone else. In many ways that’s what putting a big CarPlay rectangle on the screen is. But… I won’t buy a car without CarPlay. I’ve used it, I love it, I want it. Ive heard owners say Bluetooth is fine or native Spotify is better or they like the Tesla controls. Ok. Not my style. Apple said at WWDC something like 79% of new car buyers won’t buy a car without CarPlay. That’s a big liability when basically all the competing EVs are offering it. Tesla can add it of course. But it’s a big omission.
- chinabot 4y ago"Apple said at WWDC something like 79% of new car buyers won’t buy a car without CarPlay." - Assumes 79% of new car buyers own iphones! is it really that much or are they including people who also use android auto ?
- MBCook 4y agoThey were asked. They did not mean that those people wanted CarPlay or Android Auto. They really meant CarPlay. Now I know that like 97% of cars that support one support both. It kind of makes sense. We know that the more money someone has the more likely they are to have an iPhone. We also know that the average new car in the US is more expensive than it’s ever been. Looks like it’s at $47,000. If you can afford that, it stands to reason you might have an iPhone too based on demographic. I suppose that would mean Android owners are more likely to buy used cars. As an Apple fan… I was floored at that number. It seemed too high to me too. But I haven’t seen any articles refute it. Either way. Even if it was a total mistake and actually meant “or Android Auto“ that’s a problem for Tesla.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoBMW i3 was more efficient, but is no longer made.
- MrMan 4y agoPerformance is for the track, I don't need performance. I need trouble free operation.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y ago> Without the edge of being the “only” company with EVs is there any reason to think they’ll be big much longer? Many years of head-start in terms of experience/designs/scale-up etc with EVs, brand recognition, and in the US a charging station network. Also, they're fully committed to EVs whereas most of the legacy manufacturers seem to be completely stuck at half-assing the transition at best. It feels like (with the exception of Volkswagen Group - includes Audi and Porsche) a few of the legacy competitors are starting now and many are not even seriously trying yet. The other competitors are newly founded companies. Everyone is playing catch-up while Tesla has delivered millions of EVs. Tesla has also bet on massive scale from the beginning (i.e. high up front costs for lower costs per unit later) whereas other companies seem much more cautious. They are also not burdened with decades of organizational cruft and ICE-focused structures that have built up in the traditional companies.
- wbsss4412 4y agoDon’t forget about Hyundai/kia. The Chinese automakers are going to be a significant factor in the industry in the late 20s/30s as well.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoI don't know why, but Hyundai/Kia don't seem to have much presence/mindshare in Europe. I wasn't even aware that they're seriously investing in EVs before I stumbled across them while searching for sources for my post. Agree that the Chinese ones will likely be huge too - they're new but they have a massive market and supply chains to back them, and eventually they'll make it across to the West.
- Someone 4y ago> Tesla has also bet on massive scale from the beginning According to the article being discussed, GM and Ford will have more scale in 2025. I think Volkswagen and at least on Chinese company likely will have, too. The article also claims that Tesla stopped betting on scale (“Tesla didn't take greater advantage of the free money it could have gotten, raise much more, open capacity faster, grow much faster and shut the door. He didn't. He didn't move fast enough. He didn't recognize what was going on in the market. He had tremendous hubris that they would never catch him, they would never be able to do what he's doing, and they're doing it.”)