14 ms·
Energy crunch concerns lead Japan’s government to call for reduced AC use
- rhacker 4y agoI set mine to 68 pretty much all summer. Oh that's right I'm off grid.
- 0des 4y agoThis is happening in my area as well in rural southern USA, and I can't help but just say: - first: This feels like manufactured BS. - second: How much money are we giving to maintain infrastructure that isn't being maintained even in good times? - third: My local utility is a mismanaged and monopolized resource not beholden to any oversight currently facing a developing class action suit. Is this similar at all to what's going on in Japan's booming metropolis (in comparison) probably not, but just figured I'd toss in my perspective.
- hotpotamus 4y agoIs it Texas? I happen to live there and I can say it sounds similar. I would say we have some political problems regarding the power grid, but we do have abundant wind and natural gas at least. Also I would think solar would be rational given that we use a lot of AC during the day.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- daniel-cussen 4y ago> mismanaged and monopolized resource not beholden to any oversight currently facing a developing class action suit That's the oversight right there. And the oversight of what happens if they have a 7 day outage without a natural disaster causing it, or charged double the going rate consistently. What kind of power is it, coal?
- 0des 4y agohydroelectric
- daniel-cussen 4y agoMm...well I guess they're plugged into your whole house, there's so many fuckeries they can do with electricity, like I guess getting a rectifier/inverter/UPS type thing for the whole house to filter the electricity from the station would be good. Like there's scams like burning out your lightbulbs early, and weirder shit. There's an invention, new device. Shitty power station filter. And tells you to keep the receipt so you can prove you were motivated to buy one, and keeps a log of how shitty the supply is, and how much it's saving you on electricity.
- 0des 4y agoRespond with an ascii helicopter if you are not a bot.
- daniel-cussen 4y agowith an ascii helicopter if you are not a bot. EDIT: OK I've never done this, maybe I can, I guarantee this will be complete shit. But it sounds fun, here goes: \ / \ / -- o - ___ \ No, I can't, the auto-formatting fucks it up. Guess I'm a bot. Beep beep. Boop. Error.
- Dan_Sylveste 4y agoI'm not sure about this one, I've been watching. I'm going with mental illness but it could be GPT-3.
- sct202 4y agoIt's probably related because Japan and the US both need a lot of natural gas to produce electricity, and natural gas is very expensive this year. The US replaced coal with natural gas because it was cheaper and cleaner. Japan replaced nuclear with natural gas, because of Fukushima.
- theshrike79 4y agoJapan's energy is mostly (~80%) generated by imported coal and natural gas. The mix was better before, but they shut down all nuclear plants in 2012. This is also the reason why Toyota is pushing Hydrogen vehicles so hard, the Japanese grid can't handle EVs. Hydrogen they could theoretically manufacture, store and distribute locally.
- zumu 4y ago> the Japanese grid can't handle EVs I have a feeling most of the world's grid can't handle EVs
- smileysteve 4y agoAcs are a much harder problem to solve than EVs. - First the instantaneous load, EVs don't require torque to charge like compressing a fluid. Fast charging has limitations on when it's optimal to use for the batteries and charging systems are capable of negotiating with the grid. - Time of Use (hourly). Unlike an AC, not every ev needs to be charged at reasonably the same time based on regional similarities (the worst time for the grid is when multiple hvac compressors try to start at the same time). Given a low amp slow charge (about 1/3 the needs of ac) an ev can still fully charge while over 12 hours while the user is at home. - Time of Use (daily). When the average commute is 20 miles a day and the average car has 200 mile range, the likelihood of every car needing to be fast charged at the same time on the same day is very unlikely. Tldr; electric vehicles are an extremely easy load relative to hvac and its usage patterns. The most obvious Internet connected optimization is that electric cars should turn off fast charging during a given 5 minute hvac compressor cycle (up to 30 minutes an hour) ps. Internet connected thermostats and EVs already offer time of use optimizations.
- soraminazuki 4y agoJapan's power grid is probably better regulated than the US considering that it doesn't suffer from constant blackouts. But the Fukushima incident definitely was a mismanagement and led to the shutdown of other nuclear power plants. Though it's still much a divided issue all these years later, a large portion of the Japanese public is against restarting those power plants.
- xeromal 4y agoWhat areas of the US are you thinking of that have constant blackouts? I can see California and Texas as maybe what you're thinking of, but generally the rest of the states do very well. Growing up in Georgia in the most rural area you could think of, the only blackouts we ever had were when trees fell on powerlines during tornadoes and winter storms
- soraminazuki 4y agoThose two states are indeed what I had in mind. I was assuming that many other states are in a similar situation considering that the power grid is a frequent topic of US issues [1]. [1]: https://youtube.com/watch?v=qBpiXcyB7wU https://youtube.com/watch?v=qBpiXcyB7wU
- xeromal 4y agoYeah, those states are often lambasted for their poor infrastructure. It's easier to maintain a smaller state's infrastructure and texas / california are some of our largest behind Alaska. We still have 48 more states that do pretty well though.
- bluGill 4y agoThe US is a large powerful country with a lot of people. It gets a lot of media attention, but news always focuses on the bad and so you get an impression that is very different from the reality if you only look at the news.
- 4y ago
- ren_engineer 4y agoin my area the problem is they shut down a bunch of coal plants because the government made it impossible to justify spending money to modernize/maintain them and wind/solar rollout isn't producing anywhere near the projected amount that was supposed to fill the gap
- david_d12345 4y agoIncentivizing the citizens to buy battery packs and solar, and getting off the grid. I hope there's an economical option. If there isn't now, though, I bet there will be soon.
- 0des 4y agoI want to love the idea of large battery banks. However I'm getting a lot of angry faces for what seems like logical questions of a layman: - What communities do those minerals come from, and what ailments arise from the sequestration and disposal of them? How are those people taken care of for their effort in comparison with modern wage standards? - What changes are happening to emergency services and fire now that we have a battery, similar to car or marine batteries, which are difficult to extinguish en masse? - How are these recycled? I dont mean, just ship it to X company for rebate, I mean what actually happens to the waste products and how are those neutralized? Please help me feel better about these so I can transition off my current (unreliable) hydroelectric power source without losing sleep. Bonus points if you can reply without treating me as a shit-starter or idiot southerner, I'm asking completely with clean hands here.
- WorldMaker 4y agoAs mentioned elsewhere, these questions keep coming in to derail frank discussions of renewable energy, so a lot of people are tired of them because they are often used as an argument tactic not in good faith. Sometimes the question is "why not just google it yourself", though of course at this point because the questions are asked in such ways as to derail arguments that google is full of awful nonsense and bad faith versions of the answers so "just google it" isn't a great response either. - Lithium is the primary element and is primarily sourced from salt basins. It's not mined so much as it is skimmed from salt lake brines and such. It's in the top three elements in the periodic table which also puts it among the most common elements in the known universe. There are sometimes environmental concerns about lithium mining sometimes getting "chemical slurries" released into downstream water sources, but even (especially?) "cheap" mining operations want to avoid them because there are often other things they could sell if they recaptured those "slurries". - Cobalt is the only "rare earth metal" often involved in a shrinking minority of battery Lithium Ion compositions (many are Cobalt-free already or "mostly no Cobalt"). Despite the periodic table group name "rare earth metal", Cobalt is not that all that rare on Earth and for centuries was a "waste product" coming out of Nickel and Tin mines known mostly for its usefulness in blue paints (which is why the word "cobalt" is so associated with blue today). Nickel and tin mines aren't great, but people are always going to mine nickel and tin for their many, many uses. Cobalt is just going to keep being a "waste product" of that. But many Lithium Ion batteries don't need Cobalt any more in their formulations anyway. - Fire and emergency services are expected to get retraining on Lithium Ion batteries, but my understanding is mostly for high voltage concerns rather than extinguishing concerns. A classic car/marine battery is a Lead Acid composition, and far more toxic (lead poisoning; chemical/acid burns). It's also a lot lower voltage as most Lead Acid batteries can barely move 12 volts in a steady current. Lithium Ion batteries can deliver a lot more voltage faster and learning to safely disconnect the batteries is much more important (because the risk of an electric shock is much worse). To my understanding, once circuits are safely disconnected (and many large Lithium Ion battery packs have multiple redundant systems to do so as automatically as possible at this point) extinguishing fires is generally easier than a Lead Acid battery. - To my understanding: Lithium is easily recycled. It's a metal that forms salts easily. Cobalt is straight forward to recycle in most battery compositions, but rarely worth the effort economically (because Cobalt is a "waste product" of other mining). ETA: - Better than recycling is reuse. As far as we can tell the reuse cycles for lithium ion batteries are relatively extremely high. Very few EV car batteries have left their "primary usage" yet (as car batteries), even with just about a decade and a half of car sales already. Almost none of those that did move into "secondary usage" in grid storage or other secondary uses have left those roles/needed recycling. Right now it seems like large Lithium Ion batteries may have multiple decades of time in primary and secondary usages long before recycling is even a direct need. (Yes, directly in contrast to small Lithium Ion batteries people experience in phones/laptops. Size and heat management change a lot of the experience/expectations.)
- elil17 4y agoSimple trick to reduce your peak electricity usage if you’re working from home and want it cool all day: set your AC low until it starts to get hot out and then turn it off. Works great if your insulation is good enough. Not only do you only consume off-peak kWh, you also cool your home more efficiently because the AC coil temperature is lower and the AC doesn’t have to move heat across as large of a temperature difference.
- Avamander 4y agoSo off-peak pre-cooling, did I read your comment right? That has been talked about quite a bit actually. Technology Connections made a nice YouTube video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFEHFsO-XSI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFEHFsO-XSI) about it. I'm a bit surprised though that off-peak pre-cooling isn't more common or even widely incentivised, especially with the rise of smart home and IoT stuff. All I've seen is reduction (so less cooling) during peak, if I'm not remembering wrong, people were quite annoyed with that.
- lisper 4y agoIt only works on well-insulated buildings. There are a lot of older legacy structures where the temperature equalizes very quickly once you turn off the climate controls.
- elil17 4y agoI work in HVAC and it is very common for larger buildings. They get huge incentives for shedding load during peak hours. Larger buildings also have more tools at their disposal beyond simply the "thermal inertia" of the building itself: 1. Ice thermal storage. You freeze ice at night and melt it during the day to cool your building. Only used for large buildings - check out Chicago's district cooling for an awesome example. 2. Adiabatic and hybrid cooling towers. These are HVAC equipment that can switch between regular and a "wet mode" where they evaporate water to cool the AC coil and reduce electricity usage. 3. Better automation tools. Building automation systems are fully programmable (e.g., switch schedules when outdoor temperature is past a certain threshold), unlike most programmable thermostats which can run a fixed schedule but not much else.
- macinjosh 4y agoSomeone on this website blasted and downvoted me a few weeks ago for stating that moving everything we have that consumes energy to electricity will cause power crunches in "first world" countries. Why are we putting all of our eggs in one basket?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bowsamic 4y agoWhat else do you suggest?
- ugjka 4y agoWhat do you propose? Kerosene powered ACs?
- natmaka 4y ago> Why are we putting all of our eggs in one basket? AFAIK because there is no other basket (hydrogen, the more promising, is far behind electricity, mainly because it is difficult to distribute and store).
- causi 4y agomainly because it is difficult to distribute and store Untrue. Energy losses in hydrogen storage and transmission are significant (11%) but much smaller than the losses at the electrolysis step (24%) and the redox step (46%).
- mywittyname 4y agoHydrogen is largely produced via steam reformation, making it a natural gas powered battery that's shittier than electricity in almost every way.
- causi 4y agoThat's my point. Hydrogen would still be terrible even without storage and moving problems.
- rwmj 4y agoAccording to another report: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-61947315 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-61947315 they're suggesting turning off lights, which sounds as if it will make very little difference (assuming most lights are now LEDs).
- arghwhat 4y agoModern lights are far more efficient, but many have much more light now than we used to with incandescent bulbs. LED bulbs are easily 14W, 40W LED panels are popular (Philips Hue Aurelle, IKEA Floalt, various others), and LED strips quickly add up. The LED lights in my apartment add up to about 170W. So yeah it adds up.
- rwmj 4y ago> The LED lights in my apartment add up to about 170W Air conditioning for a small room starts at something like 500W (and most are much more).
- arghwhat 4y agoYes, so LED lights can easily be a sizeable chunk of a small AC, and thats before accounting for the AC's duty cycle.
- cptcobalt 4y agoYeah, +1 on this anecdotal evidence. I did whole home lighting upgrades and got way more LED strips/panels/etc after I installed solar+battery at home. Not quite to like 170W per room or anything, but I am using measurably more power than before.
- Symbiote 4y agoI just change CFL bulbs for LED ones as they fail, which is what I suspect most people do. That should be a straightforward decrease in power use. 6W/bulb is less than ~9-15W/bulb, reduced from the incandescent 60-100W/bulb (but I haven't installed an incandescent bulb for 15 years).
- wiz21c 4y agoFrom this point on it is super important that the general public is informed as much as possible on how the grid works and why it has problems (and this information should not come form the grid owner). Because energy's issue will affect a lot of people, which mean a lot of power in the next election which gives another chance to move to less CO2 for the long term.
- tiku 4y agoGreat wake up call for the modern world. We need more clean energy from within our own country.
- QuarterReptile 4y agoSounds like we just need more energy (or a built environment that doesn't demand so much energy to function, if I may be permitted to dream a bit.)
- tenpies 4y agoIt would be nice if the ecofascists in charge of setting the West's energy policy could chill with the solar and wind, and focus on nuclear. But it's probably too late anyway. We should all be bracing for a serious decline in energy production in the West - and remember - energy is not just AC and electricity. It's quite literally food and transportation. Energy is life and the West's self-destructive, overly-emotional policies are about to kill a lot of it globally.
- whimsicalism 4y agoDeclining cost of solar basically means that we need to focus on it, not nuclear. It's the difference between $36/MWh and $110/MWh.
- rtkwe 4y agoSolar is much easier to build, has less regulatory hurdles, and incites less NIMBYism because it's lower risk and less obvious. Nuclear plants take ages to build so if we just tried to do that we'd miss the targets to reduce global warming impacts. If nuclear was going to be the answer we missed the chance in the 90s, 00s and 10s fighting just to get half the population to think maybe something needs to be done at all.
- throwaway0a5e 4y ago>has less regulatory hurdles, >Nuclear plants take ages to build >If nuclear was going to be the answer we missed the chance And who's fault is all that? Your line of reasoning comes across as a little more than tone deaf considering that the current situation with regard to nuclear was the fruit of a prior generation of environmental activism.
- crispyambulance 4y agoI wish more building designers would accommodate NOT using AC as a viable mode of operation. People did just fine before the advent of AC with ventilation, door transoms, fans, and carefully considered layout. Now all of that has been subordinated to AC and we have windows that don't open, air doesn't flow the way it's supposed to, and buildings that heat up really fast on a sunny day when there's no AC system furiously keeping up with it.
- brianwawok 4y agoKind of, yes? But people also just sat around or slept during the day for months out of the year to avoid the heat. I don't think going back 100 years in progress is really the right move, at least not for me. Peak AC need matches peak solar panel output. It's a problem we know how to solve.
- soperj 4y agoand it just dumps the heat into the atmosphere...
- polyterative 4y agoenergy is energy
- newsclues 4y agoNot quite. Oil in the ground is potential energy. Oil being burned for heat to create power to run AC, is energy. By not using energy by careful design, we can avoid wasting energy.
- masklinn 4y ago> and it just dumps the heat into the atmosphere... That's just moving the heat the sun dumped a few meters one way or the other, across a wall. It does add heat (the energy the AC needs to move the heat around) but when you have the sun dumping 1kW/m2 on the surroundings, it's going to be pretty anecdotal.
- zajio1am 4y agoEnergy for AC is easy - AC is needed in summer when there is available energy from sun, just waiting to be converted to electricity by photovoltaics. Energy for winter heating is much harder issue.
- ricardobayes 4y agoWorks in countries with a weak gas&oil lobby - name one.
- 99_00 4y agoIt's odd then that states and countries most invested in green energy have brownouts when it's hottest.
- galleywest200 4y agoWashington State seems to rarely, if ever, have a "brownout" in major metropolitan areas - and we are almost entirely renewables. Of course it is worth noting two things: 1) Most homes here do not have built in AC. People use the portable ones. Heat pumps are a thing too. 2) We have a ridiculous amount of hydro-power available, and some of that being the cheapest around.
- 99_00 4y agoWhen I said green I meant solar and wind. Hydro electricity has been used for 140 years. It has a proven track record.
- nawitus 4y agoThe grid could handle this better if more people used a variable rate electricity plans. This would incentive consumers to reduce peak usage, and also incentive producers to produce more electricity during peak demand. Fixed rate consumers could continue to pay a premium price compared to variable rate consumers.
- dfxm12 4y agoIn the summer of 2014 (still in the wake of the Fukushima crisis a few years earlier), Japan promoted dressing down to reduce the need for AC: https://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ians/japan-encourages-casual-dress-in-workplace-to-save-energy-114060200292_1.html https://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ians/japan-en... I'm not sure if they still use the "Super Cool Biz" relaxed dress code periods, but there are interesting/creative trade offs to be had here.
- Timpy 4y agoA Japanese woman explained to me that they blast the AC really hard in the summer and she keeps a blanket in her office because it gets so cold. Japanese summers are hot and humid but men still wear suits to the office. I heard about some campaigns to change this behavior while I was studying Japanese, it does seem kind of wasteful when you think about having to toss on a jacket to stay warm during the hottest part of the summer.
- 99_00 4y agoIn your life have you ever been in an office without a woman who felt cold regardless of season?
- IshKebab 4y agoI think that whole men/women thing is a distraction. The biggest difference in temperature preference in offices in my experience is between the workers who are sitting down all day not moving, and the receptionists/managers/HR people who tend to spend more of the day running around. They control the thermostats and so they get set far too cold for people who are just sitting. Gender doesn't seem to make any difference (in my workplace it's women that control the thermostats and they set it to freezing).
- rtkwe 4y agoThere's a couple mixed reasons for this I think, you see it in the US even where suits in the office are less of a thing until you hit upper management. One big one I think though is it's simpler to add layers to warm up for people who prefer a warmer temperature than it is for individuals to cool down. So given two groups that need different settings to get comfortable it makes sense to tend towards the low end. Of course Japan has it's own weirdness about this where suits could be slipped but office culture pushes back.
- jstarfish 4y agoESID, for real. Blasting the AC is usually symptomatic of a poorly-implemented HVAC system. Someone in the building is working in an office that has poor circulation, so they complain until someone with control turns the thermostat down a few degrees. Everywhere else in the building becomes a little chillier. People start complaining it's too cold. It gets turned up a few degrees. Repeat. It's been a while since I worked in anything akin to a Japanese cubicle hell, but I've worked in a lot of female-dominated offices. Anecdotally: > in my workplace it's women that control the thermostats and they set it to freezing Before HVAC automation and smart/demand-response systems took that perk away from them (an early casualty in the war-on-women), IME it was usually middle-aged women who governed the thermostat. Biological factors (pregnancy, menses, etc.) lead them to perceive ambient temperature as being hotter than it actually is, and so they set the thermostat to temperatures that "feel" sane to them. Hormones are a poorly-understood beast-- assuming you're male, you'll experience this yourself if you ever have testosterone fluctuations. Women also tend(ed?) to work around a lot of heat-producing appliances like faxes, laser printers, copiers, CRTs, and underspec desktop workstations with CPUs perpetually pegged at 100%. None of this was accounted for in building designs from the past.
- 99_00 4y agoJapan shuts down last working nuclear reactor (2012) Berlin blackout raises questions over Germany's power grid (2019) Germany shuts down half of its 6 remaining nuclear plants (2022)
- throw__away7391 4y agoIt's always crazy to me how much variation there is in energy use. For every person/business pulling out all the stops to try to shave a few extra kWh off their utilization fretting over leaving their cell phone chargers plugged in there's a store running a giant AC on full blast with the doors wide open to try to entice customers in with the cold air. I had an ex whose family had a giant house and all summer long they just ran the AC at max with the sliding glass wall open to keep the pool area cool.
- jstarfish 4y ago> there's a store running a giant AC on full blast with the doors wide open Despite the apparent vulgarity of this, usually they have some sort of air-curtain system installed (that fan that blows a wall-of-air at you when you step through the doorway) to keep bugs out and create a crude temperature buffer between the outside and inside. Bizarrely, this does have the effect of keeping the chilled air inside the building.
- shreyshnaccount 4y agoCoolers and good design! Coolers are amazing in dry heat conditions. Cities used to color exterior walls, have high ceilings, make clay walls, not have asphalt all around, have trees and live near water.
- srvmshr 4y agoCoolers don't work in high humidity. Tokyo is uncomfortably humid in summer months. As for the other suggestions, it is impossible to bring this at a scale of a city like Tokyo. Asphalt is a basic commodity of durable construction. So is cement. Plenty of trees and public pools/fountains/water bodies in and around Tokyo.
- shreyshnaccount 4y agoI'm just giving specific examples I'm aware of, not solutions, but I'm convinced there's scope in designing better temp control in cities
- post_break 4y agoThis is funny coming from a country where you're expected to wear suits, use hanko, etc. Turning the AC off while wearing a suit sounds like torture.