5 ms·
>It pains me to say this—because the Long Tail was sold to us as an economic law that not only predicted a more inclusive era of prosperity, but would especiall
by ghaff 4y ago
>It pains me to say this—because the Long Tail was sold to us as an economic law that not only predicted a more inclusive era of prosperity, but would especially help creative people.
My recollection is that Chris Anderson's "Long Tail" never particularly promoted prosperity for those in the long tail but rather for the aggregators of the long tail. And that seems to have happened to a large degree.
Here's part of the blurb for Anderson's book:
Wired editor Anderson declares the death of "common culture"—and insists that it's for the best. Why don't we all watch the same TV shows, like we used to? Because not long ago, "we had fewer alternatives to compete for our screen attention," he writes. Smash hits have existed largely because of scarcity: with a finite number of bookstore shelves and theaters and Wal-Mart CD racks, "it's only sensible to fill them with the titles that will sell best." Today, Web sites and online retailers offer seemingly infinite inventory, and the result is the "shattering of the mainstream into a zillion different cultural shards." These "countless niches" are market opportunities for those who cast a wide net and de-emphasize the search for blockbusters.
That actually seems pretty accurate. Amazon and YouTube have done just fine by the long tail. And the variety of streaming services have pretty much fractured primetime network viewing and Top 40 radio. Power laws are still in effect and small-time artists are often doing even worse financially than they used to, and even some of the aggregators (e.g. Netflix) have their own struggles.
- incrudible 4y agoEven if Amazon was profitable selling goods (it is not), its approach is to let marketplace sellers figure out which products sell well, then it starts sells those items itself. Amazon is chasing the short tail. Streaming services are fractured, but individually almost all of their revenue comes from blockbusters. Attempts at original content are killed quickly when they fail to deliver bigly. Netflix is particularly guilty of this. The prediction in the book does not pan out. Today more than ever, the money goes to the top.
- ghaff 4y agoThere is a long tail and consumers get a lot of value from that long tail. But I don't wholly disagree that--in addition to the creators in the long tail not making much--the aggregators can make relatively little from it either compared to the blockbusters on the left hand side of the curve. So I think the observation that a long tail exists was absolutely correct but the claim of financial value from it is a mixed bag. (Anderson was also largely incorrect in his claims about the end of theory. https://www.wired.com/2008/06/pb-theory/ https://www.wired.com/2008/06/pb-theory/ )
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> even some of the aggregators (e.g. Netflix) have their own struggles. Netflix’s stock price is still pretty high considering their product. Disney market cap is $180B, Comcast is $180B, Netflix is $85B, Warner Bros Discovery is $35B. Fox/Viacom/Paramount are in the $15B to $20B range. Everyone else is much smaller. Disney and Comcast have other businesses than selling media, and Disney has particularly strong brands. Netflix’s content does not seem much more compelling than HBO’s (Warner Bros Discovery), but it does have global presence.
- Retric 4y agoNetflix might be overvalued, but those other companies aren’t in great places. Disney for example is in a tough place in terms of growth which really hurts their market cap. Take say their parks, they can’t significantly expand, open up new locations, or significantly raise prices and those parks have the risk of another shutdown etc. ESPN similarly dominates their niche but as a middle man they could lose major contracts. Again profitable but not a lot of room for growth. Disney+ is what their 3rd streaming service and eats into existing profits. Why buy an MCU blue-ray when 3 months of streaming costs the same. They executed their purchases of Pixar, Marvel, and Star Wars reasonably well but audiences are getting saturated and there isn’t a lot of franchises like that to keep buying. Worse they can’t seem to get new franchises off the ground. Frozen for example was a big hit but they ran it and other promising IP into the ground.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI agree, I do not know if any media sellers have sufficiently high and resilient cash flow to be worth $100B+, or even close to it. Well, except Apple and Amazon, but that is not because of the media.
- samatman 4y agoObjectively they've bungled Star Wars, it remains to be seen if they can get out of the woods with the amount of hostility they've created. Without the Mandalorian the situation would be dire. Pixar literally didn't miss for the entire independent era, the occasional lackluster movie isn't going to alienate their core demographic, which is parents. Marvel is of course printing money with no end in sight, but this is a two out of three thing imho.
- mattmanser 4y agoHe actually explicitly mentions Amazon and Netflix as counter examples of what you've said. Amazon - he says a lot of pundits claim their retail arm is not and will never be profitable, they have been saved by aws Netflix - has cut the number of movies on offer dramatically, cutting out the long tail, and adopted a strategy of chasing blockbuster TV shows It's worth reading the whole article, it is pretty good. As for a 'fracturing',everyone's talking about stranger things and obi-wan. Kate Bush is top of the charts because of stranger things. Remember everyone talking about Tiger King or GoT? Certainly doesn't feel fractured to me.
- ghaff 4y agoOf course things are much more fractured than they used to be. The audience for Stranger Things or GoT is minuscule compared to something like "Must See TV" on NBC Thursdays in the past. I think you might be surprised at the number of people who haven't heard of Stranger Things and certainly haven't watched. It's fair that Netflix doesn't really carry long tail content--never did carry the longest tail stuff and now that content owners want more money in general and there's a lot more competition for subscribers it doesn't make sense to pay for back catalog stuff that others own. YouTube and TikTok are better examples. It seems obvious that there is a long tail. But neither Anderson or most anyone else claimed that being in the long tail was a path to riches. And while I'm not sure it's valid to write off Amazon, eBay, Alibaba, etc., it's probably fair to say that the long tail has mostly not been a pile of gold for the aggregators either. But it does exist.
- jamiek88 4y agoThe long long tail of tv is now the likes of PlutoTV and Tubi etc. free streaming with channels dedicated to for example, the Beverley hillbillies !
- sitkack 4y ago> claim their retail arm is not and will never be profitable If this is true, then isn't the retail side effectively removing all the oxygen from the ecosystem? This sounds massively stagnating, the combination of not-profitable and extremely efficient.
- mr_tristan 4y ago> My recollection is that Chris Anderson's "Long Tail" never particularly promoted prosperity for those in the long tail but rather for the aggregators of the long tail. And that seems to have happened to a large degree. This was exactly my understanding as well, but, some personal anecdotes also bring up some interesting questions. The people on the long tail that I've seen be successful often just do things a bit differently, so I'm not entirely sure how you could easily measure success. Creators I know of use the aggregator platforms like a marketing tool, and sell "other things". So, for a couple of working musicians I know, no more CDs or any real money distributing music, you sell schwag, live concert revenue, etc. Woodworker's I've followed seem to embrace teaching and use a combination of schwag, recommended tools, educational tools, etc. in addition to the occasional custom piece of furniture. The successful ones do seem to follow the "true fans model", where they basically try to "live in their niche" out on the tail, and regularly connect with people. But I'm not sure the long tail examples that are succeeding, are the "future of business". Really, they're just people who've done the math and figured out how to keep a small business afloat. But this money is a drop in the pond now compared to the platforms itself. These aggregation platforms are basically becoming the gatekeepers and central banks of their marketplaces. And at least the way I've seen the long tail theory presented, they never really talk about the potential central gatekeeping aspect. It's always a happy "gee, we'll be really diverse and stuff", but never, "at the cost of fewer places to access a lot of these goods".