10 ms·
I wish we would just stop using phone numbers as the primary user identifier and SMS as the primary communication channel, period. The amount of cruft involved
by lxgr 4y ago
I wish we would just stop using phone numbers as the primary user identifier and SMS as the primary communication channel, period.
The amount of cruft involved in SMS delivery is unbelievable, and phone numbers are neither particularly stable, nor particularly well protected against takeovers.
- byteflip 4y agoAs someone who’s moving overseas shortly, changing/removing your number is a nightmare. It really is the primary UID. So many things use it for 2FA. In a lot of cases you HAVE to list a phone number. I ported my number to Google Voice as a decent alternative, but you kinda have to know what you’re doing ahead of time. My gf who moved first did not and deeply regrets it.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoWait until you move to your new country and discover that you need a local bank account to get a local phone number, but you need a local phone number to open a bank account.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoYes Ireland has this too. It's frustrating. They don't have a population registry so proof of address is a 'utility bill'. But to sign up for utilities you need a bank account which requires proof of address. Well you get it. Also relying on something from a commercial entity that's so easy to fake is weird.
- ghaff 4y agoIt's sometimes the case in the US as well. When I got my RealID driver's license I had to show some sort of utility bill as a proof of address--which, as you say, could be pretty easily faked.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoI recently did this and had two utility bills. But two isn't accepted so I was given an affidavit form where I wrote down that I was who I claimed to be.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoLol if you're going to take the user's word for it, why even bother asking for proof :)
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoIt was pretty ridiculous. I already had a passport, other state DL, SSN, and birth certificate. The points for proof of residence are the dumbest part of RealID.
- ghaff 4y agoSomeone I knew had some rigamarole to get their kid his first license because he didn't have any utility bills or whatever to prove his address. :-/ There's this weird thing that de facto you need state residency and a permanent address to live "normally," have government ID, etc. but there's not AFAIK any actual specific legal requirement to have same.
- fooqux 4y agoIt's also not a long-term solution. At some point, your ported number will be updated and flagged as a "voip number" since it's now associated to Google Voice. At that point, you'll start having issues as many services don't like it when people use a number they can acquire for free in a couple minutes as the UID.
- Scoundreller 4y agoDoesn’t work that way for Canadian numbers. Only original issuer is public info. Porting info is on a need-to-know basis (ie: telecoms need to terminate calls; but that’s it). This can work against you of course, so a good strategy is to get a burner phone and port that number to your VoIP provider.
- namecheapTA 4y agoBurner phone numbers in the US seem to be of a particular range of numbers and can also be flagged. I used to use pay as you go burners for random tasks in the past and noticed they gave me trouble when trying to use them to get verification codes sometimes.
- remram 4y agoI'm not sure what you mean when you say "burner phone". I know for a fact that you can get a regular prepaid plan from T-Mobile and pay for it cash, no IDs; that fits the "burner phone" requirements for me. Do you mean that every prepaid plan uses that range of numbers?
- Scoundreller 4y agoPrepaid plan vs post-paid, probably not, but some discount prepaid providers are probably considered “less trust-worthy”, or less profitable when evaluating VoIP numbers.
- giaour 4y agoShouldn't it be the same for the US and Canada? Both are administered by NANPA. Last time I looked into this (early 2020), you generally couldn't get porting info for US numbers, though original issuer was public and easily accessible.
- ghaff 4y agoThe dark side of the mobile number portability that we all wanted. I wonder what would have happened in the alternate universe where a lot of people would presumably have been changing mobile numbers with at least some frequency. I also have to wonder how Google Voice has survived Google's ax all these years.
- dasil003 4y agoProbably because execs use it.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoI’ve lost access to a phone number on Google Voice. After my parents died, I ported their landline to Google Voice. This number was in my family for more than 50 years. After porting a second number into Google Voice (and involving Google Fi) I lost access to the first. A 50+ year old phone number that everyone important to me already had memorized. If you call the number now, it’s answered by a Google voice subscriber message. So I know the number is still with Google. I just can’t access it anymore.
- JacobThreeThree 4y agoWhy don't you just contact Google customer service? I'll be here all week.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoReally? Have you ever tried that?
- hirundo 4y agoAfter ~15 years with it, starting back in the GrandCentral days, I recently moved from Google Voice to voip.ms, on my path to degoogling. The new service is paid, in a competitive domain, and so needs and has excellent customer service, and a much improved set of features. I'm happy to be the customer instead of the product.
- j_calvert 4y agoI ported my number from Google Voice to Google Fi and lost all the SMS messages sent/received while using the number with Voice. Mentioned this to a friend who works at Google on their messaging products. His take: "Yup. It's a mess"
- el_nahual 4y agoI did the same switch and can still access all my old SMS's and voicemails at voice.google.com
- Mikeb85 4y agoThis. A bunch of Canadian government interactions also use SMS as 2FA and I live abroad for months every year. At least most tech companies let you switch to an authenticator app...
- ihateolives 4y agoBut you still get SMS when roaming?
- lxgr 4y agoNot very reliably, usually.
- Mikeb85 4y agoCanadian roaming rates are so utterly shit the SIM card comes out the second I'm on the plane. It's like $15 per day to roam in the EU. Not per month, per day, let that sink in... I can get a plan in Europe for 30€ month that puts my Canadian plan ($90/month) to shame... I'm not paying $450/month to roam...
- gst 4y ago> Canadian roaming rates are so utterly shit the SIM card comes out the second I'm on the plane. It's like $15 per day to roam in the EU. Not per month, per day, let that sink in... I can get a plan in Europe for 30€ month that puts my Canadian plan ($90/month) to shame... That's cheap. My Austrian provider charges 1 Euro per 100 KB when roaming in Canada (no - that's not a typo). So for 10 GB that's a cheap 100k Euros.
- ihateolives 4y agoOk, I see. That's nuts. I've been to Canada with my EU SIM but apart from each SMS costing few cents instead of being free if didn't cost me much to keep using 2fa. I currently have plan for 22€ that gives me unlimited everything in my country (maybe there is cap to minutes but I don't call much) including unlimited data + 10gb data in EU. I remember that in Canada I was paying through the nose for some basic pathetic plan though.
- gorbypark 4y agoI ended up porting my (Canadian) number to a cheap pre-paid MNVO service that was $100/yr for unlimited talk/text and no data (within Canada), but seemingly allows me to roam forever and receive SMS for free. Cheapest option I could find in Canada, besides maybe some VOIP providers.
- judge2020 4y agoTo add, I've experienced a few too many services that seem to block Google Voice numbers for 2fa purposes (although, maybe they're blocking based on area code and there wouldn't be a problem if I ported my existing number to GV).
- lxgr 4y agoThis is pretty common, unfortunately (and a major factor in choosing a service provider for me when there are multiple options).
- ankaAr 4y agoI Will face the same soon. There is a guide or something to help you with that? I know that is just a simple task, but it is a really long chain of stuff to do and prevent yourself being at the other side of your services
- byteflip 4y agoIt’s probably trivial for the average HN reader, the key is to do it before you move. Otherwise it can be difficult since Google Voice is not available in most countries. (Will need a VPN). FYI iMessage is real wonky that I’ve removed my phone number. Should be obvious but you will lose your phone service, so you want to time it close to when you are leaving.
- herbst 4y agoI lost my SIM shortly after I moved and never got a replacement. I advocate against phone numbers since then :) My best advice is to find alternatives and don't depend on anything that depends on a phone number. Things can ALWAYS turn wrong.
- trinsic2 4y agoI removed all mobile based 2fa from all my sites that rely on it and strictly use TOTP and u2f. Now I only subscribe to services that provide this kind of authentication. There are a few sites that I still use that rely on SMS 2factor but its a short list now. Most of my sites that have TOTP and U2f support have the option of using SMS auth but does not require it.
- orblivion 4y agoI think this goes to the fact that we need a new sort of UID. Something thought through very carefully rather that something that comes to be. There's a sort of hidden infrastructure, hidden legacy, hidden stability that's been built around phone numbers and email. For instance, "valid Google email address" is a proxy for "a real person with X likelihood". Same goes for SSN + demonstrated knowledge of your last few residences, etc etc. It's a mess. Start from first principles, what do we really need to know about a person? What could we build? On the other hand, maybe if it's too good it'll be bad for privacy, and escaping into the shadows, should that become necessary for someone.
- aarreedd 4y agoThis a problem some people are trying to solve with blockchain technology. I'm not necessarily saying this is a good idea. It's just an interesting potential solution.
- orblivion 4y agoThe question I think I'm getting at is about who you are and why that matters in a given case. Blockchains are good for keeping identities intact once established, which is different though maybe it'll help overall.
- jdeibele 4y agohttps://support.google.com/voice/answer/1065667?hl=en#zippy=%2Ckeep-your-original-google-voice-number https://support.google.com/voice/answer/1065667?hl=en#zippy=... I've paid the $20 Google charges to make a number "permanent" once for myself and a couple of times for organizations. For myself, it's a highly secure phone number. I still only use a phone number when I absolutely have to, like with Twitter, preferring to use a hardware key or Authy. For organizations, it's like an answering machine. My kids' soccer club had a cell phone that was supposed to be answered by the VP when parents or coaches had messages. It was much easier to port the number into Google Voice, put it into Do Not Disturb mode permanently, and have the transcriptions forwarded to the VP on the extremely rare occasions that there were any.
- curun1r 4y agoI tried something similar when I went overseas. In my case, I tried to use Twilio and even got everything setup to forward correctly to the number I got in whatever country I was in at the time. But that doesn’t work for 2FA. I ended up locked out of my online banking accounts for my whole trip and it was a huge headache. My recommendation would be to port your number over to Google Fi and then just use that in whatever country you’re going to. It’s a bit more expensive that local cell service in many countries, but there’s nothing like having your phone just work wherever you go.
- CamelRocketFish 4y agoI kept my old number and switched it to a provider that offered a yearly prepaid plan with an eSIM. $20 a year and I can keep my old number and switch to it as an active sim to receive a 2FA whenever necessary. I agree to always using 2FA via TOTP however.
- lelandfe 4y agoNote that many services do not permit Google Voice numbers! Instagram and Facebook will quickly disable your account and demand a real phone number. I recently had a delivery app inform me at signup that it's not even a real phone number (it happily slurped up the submitted Voice number and later sent me ads about pizza anyway)
- ihateolives 4y agoWhat's exactly the problem? Is this something US specific? I've been living in different countries for years and always kept my original number in addition to getting local number as well. Never had any trouble with 2fa.
- lxgr 4y agoThere are many problems with this approach (I'm using it currently as well, out of necessity, not choice): - SMS delivery is not always very reliable when roaming. - Prepaid SIMs usually expire after a while of not topping them up. - Good luck losing one of these SIMs and getting a replacement abroad. (eSIMs make this both better and worse.)
- ihateolives 4y agoOk, fair enough with the third point. Never had missed SMS while roaming and I don't use prepaid as primary number. Have had same number for 20 years now.
- javajosh 4y agoThe hardware solution is either to have two phones, or one phone with two sim cards (which are common in Europe, for example).
- pkulak 4y agoAnd most things block Google Voice.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoWe don't really, here in Europe. WhatsApp is the main communication method.. I think SMS is still so popular in the US because it's a fallback for iMessage. But here the levels of iPhone users are much lower. So for me 2fa is pretty much the only thing I still use SMS for. Which makes a suspicious sms stand out a lot more. I wish we'd stop using it for 2fa though because it was never meant to be hardened for this.
- ghaff 4y agoHeavy SMS usage predates iMessage in the US. But iMessage was presumably a big contributor to making unlimited SMS messages the norm on most phone plans. In any case, there was just never a big incentive in the US to use anything other than iMessage when available and fall back to SMS otherwise. And without that incentive "no one" (who isn't texting people overseas) bothers to use different apps.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoOh this is true here too. SMS usage was huge pre-WhatsApp. What happened was that the networks were capitalising on that. SMS was historically quite expensive so it became a big cash cow. SMS bits must have been made of gold because they were hundreds of times more expensive than other bits. WhatsApp completely killed SMS usage here however. Leading to some carriers wanting to charge extra for WhatsApp usage to recuperate some of the 'lost' revenue. This sparked a big discussion about net neutrality which was then enshrined in EU law, so the discussion was finished. By this time, SMS became practically free but it was too late.
- ghaff 4y agoInteresting. It looks like WhatsApp predated iMessage in the US but it never really took off. Maybe US text bundles were more consumer-friendly in the US? Though I don't really remember it that way. (I didn't do a lot of texting though and mostly expensed the handful of work-related texting I did do; friends didn't really text at that time.)
- 4y ago
- sdflhasjd 4y agoLet's also not forget how unreliable SMS is too. I got locked out of an Apple account because I wasn't receiving codes.
- hinkley 4y agoThe problem here I think is that these sorts of failures are bursty, and account protection algorithms are typically not capable of tracking behaviors over time, because that would be expensive.
- reaperducer 4y agoI haven't been able to use Uber for the last four years because I never receive its verification texts. Uber's screw-up has given Lyft a few thousand dollars.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoE-mail seems to be the solution. It's out of bound; authentication/authorization are required; there's standards to flag an invalid origin; filters spam. It's not encrypted, but neither is SMS. Most of today's dumb phones can check e-mail, so it's almost ubiquitous. The only way it doesn't work is for rural users who have no data but do have GSM/SMS.
- lxgr 4y agoI agree, but unfortunately some regulatory bodies like the EBA have specifically labeled it "not a factor for 2FA purposes"... Ironically, my email inbox is much better protected than my SIM/phone number.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoWe should lobby them to change the rules, as a second e-mail account would literally be a second factor. Then it's up to the user to hook it up to their phone.
- devoutsalsa 4y agoEmail based authentication is lame. If a hacker gets access to your email, then they automatically have access to your 2FA. Lame.
- pkulak 4y agoSo if a hacker gets access to your second factor, they have access to your second factor?
- lxgr 4y agoAnd if they get access to my phone number they get access to my texts and phone calls. That's why neither should ever be the only authentication factor (nor a single-factor recovery method for that matter). That said, my phone number is significantly easier to take over than my email address and mailbox.
- ridgered4 4y ago
- ta988 4y agoMost companies use that because that's with credit card numbers excellent ways to track people opinions and whereabouts.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoSure, if you find something as interroperable, free, simple and mobile, go for it.
- kevincox 4y agoemail?
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoNot as mobile: you need internet and a smartphone. I still have a friend with a dumb phone. I'm sometimes in zones without internet but my mum call me and ask me to give her some confirmation code I receive. Not as simple: stuff arrive in the spam folder. Some providers just reject your valid mail (my main email tld is exotic, it causes lots of troubles). People receive so much junk they lose your message in 1000 of unread mails or are afraid of checking them. Not as interoperable: there are new kids that just don't have emails setup on their phone. They check them once a month at home on the computer. Email is for old people (although text is getting there too). Plus email is almost as easy to spoof and intercept, so the gain would be minimal.
- kevincox 4y agoSometimes I'm traveling and don't want to pay exorbitant roaming fees. Or sometimes I'm in a building or basement without phone service. I'm sure there are a few people without email on their phones but I don't think the number is dramatically different than those without SMS right now. If I have cell signal I have email, but I can have email without SMS access.
- BiteCode_dev 4y ago> If I have cell signal I have email, but I can have email without SMS access. In the US populated area, maybe. In the French country side, definitely not.
- 4y ago
- honkdaddy 4y agoCompanies use it as a cheap and easy way to combat spam without any engineering on their end. It's purely out of financial interest, nothing more. The mobile apps which require a phone number to use are doing this because if they only required email to sign up they'd have people sniffing their API and very quickly overwhelming it with fake accounts, and the cat and mouse game begins. By forcing the users to validate with a phone number, they're essentially pushing their spam problems upstream and out of their hands. More sophisticated actors know it's possible to automate SMS verification, but it does stop a lot of spam at the door.
- lxgr 4y agoThere's no reason that a service's "proof of personhood"/anti-bot mechanism has to be the same as that used for OTP delivery, though. Google does this very well: They require a phone number of spam account creation prevention – once. After that, I can delete the phone number from my account and use a FIDO key, TOTP or any other 2FA method.
- dheera 4y agoExactly. I deprecated SMS 12 years ago in favor of e-mail. E-mail supports encryption, >140 characters, attachments, alphanumeric IDs, and works across country borders and SIM cards. There is literally zero reason to use SMS.
- reaperducer 4y agoI wish we would just stop using phone numbers as the primary user identifier and SMS as the primary communication channel Come up with a good alternative and make yourself a billionaire. Difficulty: Good alternative.