3 ms·
> If you have the benefit of this inequality, you should use it to ensure the availability of life’s necessities so that any else with a similar inequality can
by marginalia_nu 4y ago
> If you have the benefit of this inequality, you should use it to ensure the availability of life’s necessities so that any else with a similar inequality can provide the maximum benefit regardless of the circumstances they’re born into.
Well let me be the devil's advocate here and ask why.
- imgabe 4y ago
- shuger 4y agoEntropy cannot be opposed. That's fundamental law of physics.
- fny 4y agoSure it can, I decrease entropy locally and reallocate it somewhere else. Space is huge and it will take a long time to approach the limit.
- jacquesm 4y agoIn the long term. But in the short term there are plenty of loopholes, according to those laws of physics.
- Ensorceled 4y agoYou literally opposed entropy by writing this comment.
- dsr_ 4y agoEntropy wins universally. Locally, lots of processes are anti-entropic. Look at a leaf.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- marginalia_nu 4y ago> To continue the proliferation of humanity and life in general throughout the universe. To oppose entropy. Right, but I'm a human being, I am not humanity itself. Humanity is just an idea, it has no agency or conscience. It cannot suffer, it does not want. As a human being, my primary responsibility is toward myself, to make myself happy, and to arrange the world according to the principles that resonate with my soul. Toiling to make other people happy at my own expense doesn't make me happy. Even if that was the way it worked, surely the best action would be to line up to work at an Amazon warehouse and bask in opportunity to contribute to the incandescence of Jeff Bezos' prosperity. > If that is not appealing to you, you should probably off yourself right now. I don't really see how that follows. I'll die regardless whether it's by my own hands right now or at the hands of external circumstance some years later.
- imgabe 4y ago> to arrange the world according to the principles that resonate with my soul. What are the principles that resonate with your soul?
- marginalia_nu 4y agoI can't list them, but I can try to explain through examples. There are certain vile things that when you see them or even think about them you shudder to the very foundation. It may be murder, rape, kidnapping, grievous torture, helplessness, and so forth. Nobody needs to be told this is not the way things should be. On the other hand, there are other things, when you see them, they bring you a sense that the world is as it should be. It may be things that are awesome, beautiful, or sublime. It may be good craftsmanship, self-sufficiency, human flourishing. It may be small things or large things. The former are such things I do not want to exist in the world, and the latter are such things I want to exist in the world.
- imgabe 4y ago> On the other hand, there are other things, when you see them, they bring you a sense that the world is as it should be. It may be things that are awesome, beautiful, or sublime. It may be good craftsmanship, self-sufficiency, human flourishing. It may be small things or large things. Sounds good to me. Why not exercise whatever talents you have to encourage and promote such things?
- harry8 4y agoThis is a terrible comment, unworthy of being said here. Maybe consider hitting the edit button and express the thought in a less vile way? If you disagree with me you should definitely continue to decide to live.
- imgabe 4y agoIf you are opposed to life, why continue to live?
- marginalia_nu 4y agoIf you truly are opposed to life, surely the best action is to stay alive so you can oppose it better than you can if you are dead. If you are dead, you can do nothing to oppose it.
- imgabe 4y agoSo you’re commenting here to advocate on behalf of mass murderers?
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoWhy not? Is there any compelling reason not to make the life of other people better? Is there any reason we should leave people work countless hours, suffer, and likely dying due to diseases that manifest out of stress (e.g. cancer)? Imagine for a moment a society such that there's no need for the proles to steal or hurt people. Criminality drops to near zero, world is safer, we all get to thrive. Edit: Kind reminder to argue for the position instead of downvoting out of disagreement.
- pc86 4y agoIgnoring the obviously ridiculous implication that stress causes cancer[0], there can certainly be enough instances where making someone else's life better makes yours worse, at least enough that it's completely reasonable to just pause for a moment and ask "why," expected a better answer than "why not" [0] https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/coping/feelings/stress-fact-sheet#can-psychological-stress-cause-cancer https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/coping/feelings/stress-f...
- grey-area 4y agoLife is not a zero sum game. if you insist on treating it like one, you will lose.
- pc86 4y agoPlatitudes aside, I'm not suggesting it is, and I'm not treating it like it is. I'm simply saying "why" is a reasonable question and "yeah well why not" isn't.
- grey-area 4y ago> making someone else's life better makes yours worse Definition of a zero sum game: A situation in which one person or group can win something only by causing another person or group to lose it
- PartiallyTyped 4y ago
- drekipus 4y ago> Well let me be the devil's advocate here and ask why. because there's civil unrest otherwise.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoOk, let's permit ourselves to think the unthinkable through to the conclusion rather than immediately withdraw: Why can't there just be civil unrest?
- malnourish 4y agoI would personally rather live in a safe society with happy and comfortable people, to the fullest extent possible.
- blitz_skull 4y agoI would personally like to live in a society that glorifies violence, and promotes survival of the fittest. A society filled with suffering and strength. I'm playing devil's advocate, but indeed there are those who agree with that statement. Who gets to decide which is right?
- imtringued 4y agoWe routinely abandon that strategy because it is highly inefficient.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoThis is a really good example of how devil's advocate strategies don't actually add to furthering or strengthening a discussion. Categorically they add friction to the conversation without providing a benefit. Arguments from DA-proponents only provides more evidence of this position.
- HWR_14 4y agoDevils advocate strategies have nothing to do with the post you are responding to. That was just contrary assertions- which is just bad argumentation.
- soraki_soladead 4y agoOne concrete disadvantage of _extreme_ inequality, specifically in a democracy like the US, is the erosion of your rights when they are inconvenient for those with more wealth/soft-power than you. When wealth inequality is significant, governments decide it's better to address the needs of a much smaller set of constituents and your rights become curtailed, implicitly or not, as a result. Unless you, personally, are an oligarch, you will be negatively impacted. This may manifest as minimally as living in a society that is worse than it could be. Separately, speaking as someone that spends a lot of time with optimizers, it seems silly to not have _some_ form of regularization. That doesn't mean zero inequality (that doesn't seem good either) but we should be wary of unchecked inequality.