3 ms·
The FF industry is leaping (has leapt, historically) on CCS as a getout clause and has sunk french metric tonnes of money into CCS. So far, its uneconomic excep
by ggm 4y ago
The FF industry is leaping (has leapt, historically) on CCS as a getout clause and has sunk french metric tonnes of money into CCS. So far, its uneconomic except for the specific use of pumping gas into wells to make them more productive, which leads to more fugitive gas. No significant CCS experiment worldwide has achieved its goals as sequestration. The one in Western Australia releases so much CO2 it has to pay a penalty cost, to maintain status. (its a gas field associated with other extractive industry I believe)
This money they've sunk: its not their money: they've been doing it off the public teat as "research" or, when it is their money, its booked to R&D and has massive royalty & tax offset benefits. Its a shellgame.
The inclusion of blue hydrogen+CCS in this piece is really regrettable: its being used to avoid having to wear the cost of going to green hydrogen, which is abandoning FF inputs. For holders of shares in coal and gas, this is not optimal so they oppose green and argue abatement by CCS is "the one"
It doesn't work. CCS is a giant con. The evidence is strong that at scale CCS is not working, and will waste years of time, billions of dollars of cost, and gigatonnes of CO2, to prove it.
Overall I like Gates trying to help. He's been badly advised when it comes to CCS.
- otikik 4y agoCarbon Capture and Storage works by capturing research funds and burying it deep, deep into fossil fuel companies accounts, where no tax officer can reach them. https://youtu.be/MSZgoFyuHC8 https://youtu.be/MSZgoFyuHC8
- sitkack 4y agoGates knows exactly what he is doing. Same Gates, different pasture.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoFF: fossil fuel. CCS: carbon capture and storage.
- Jabihjo 4y agoFFS..for fucks sake
- ugh123 4y agoTHANK YOU
- ggm 4y agoYea fair point. I should have expanded in my own piece. Thanks for that.
- joelthelion 4y agoYou can still do it :)
- anovikov 4y agoI fully agree with your perception of CCS but i think it's only a small historical detour of about the same scale/level of harm as cellulosic ethanol or concentrated solar thermal used to be. Tried, failed, moved on. No one bets the farm on it, Fit for 55 plan for example, makes no mention of CCS.
- ggm 4y agoNot here in Australia. Have a look at: https://www.kwm.com/au/en/insights/latest-thinking/ccs-in-australia-a-legal-guide.html https://www.kwm.com/au/en/insights/latest-thinking/ccs-in-au... (Burrup is the one I mentioned) Thats $250 million of committed funding to a range of high scale projects by the gas industry, coal-seam gas included.
- anovikov 4y agoThat's right, but by comparison, Australia has 25GW of solar installed, so this funding represents only $0.01 per watt of installed solar, probably less than 1% of subsidy that went to solar. It's an OK amount to try and fail once.
- Retric 4y agoMost of that is 25GW is recent and cheap PV at close to $0.02 per watt. It’s the tiny fraction from before 2015 that was really expensive. A 250m subsidy to grid solar right now would easily increase total installed solar to 100GW+. So, I wouldn’t be surprised if that project alone was a larger subsidy than every subsidy given to grid solar in Australia.
- anovikov 4y ago$0.02 per watt??? don't you confuse with the cost of kilowatt-hour of power? Cheapest installed solar is >$1 per watt, most of the time about $1.5-$2 per watt. Cheapest Chinese panels themselves are about $0.25 per watt and they make a tiny part of the overall setup costs.
- raylad 4y agoI think you are probably right, but some references would really be helpful. Could you share any that you have handy?
- ggm 4y ago(Strongly anti) https://michaelwest.com.au/carbon-capture-and-storage-epic-fail-at-gorgon-gas-plant/ https://michaelwest.com.au/carbon-capture-and-storage-epic-f... (Neutral to anti) https://www.abc.net.au/news/science/2021-11-06/carbon-capture-storage-coal-gas-fossil-fuels/100585034 https://www.abc.net.au/news/science/2021-11-06/carbon-captur... (Weakly pro) https://www.iea.org/commentaries/carbon-capture-in-2021-off-and-running-or-another-false-start https://www.iea.org/commentaries/carbon-capture-in-2021-off-... (Strongly pro) https://www.globalccsinstitute.com/resources/publications-reports-research/lessons-captured-from-50-years-of-ccs-projects/ https://www.globalccsinstitute.com/resources/publications-re...
- tinco 4y agoI think this might be the greatest comment I have ever seen on HN or elsewhere. Thanks, I wonder if BillG has read all four of them before he made up his mind, or that he's one-sidedly informed.
- Hypocritelefty 4y ago
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoCCS = Carbon Capture and Storage You should clarify what an acronym means before using it tens of times.
- breadloaf 4y agoI was honestly thinking that he is talking about CCS fleet gas pay cards.