15 ms·
Where are all the crypto use cases?
- AlexandrB 4y agoThis article seems like it's reaching. I don't think "money" accurately describes what cryptocurrency is because most people who use USD don't trade on the FOREX markets, but most cryptocurrency users are primarily focused on the exchange rate of BTC to USD, not it's functionality as a currency. It's better described as a security, and while it can be used as a medium of exchange its volatility can make that expensive or inconvenient. As for this: > Right now, you can take out a loan without involving a bank from one of the many crypto lending protocols. You put up some collateral and can take out a loan for extremely cheap, because there isn't a bank in the middle to take a cut. The reason loans on the blockchain are cheap is not because there's no middle-man but because they're over-collateralized so there's no risk. One of the reasons the bank charges you interest is that they're taking a risk that you will not pay back the loan. AFAIK this is not possible in DeFi.
- latchkey 4y ago> One of the reasons the bank charges you interest is that they're taking a risk that you will not pay back the loan. AFAIK this is not possible in DeFi. That's why there are options markets like, Nexus Mutual [1], that allow third parties to take on that risk. [1] https://nexusmutual.io/ https://nexusmutual.io/
- nappy 4y agoUnless I'm missing something here, this is insurance, not lending.
- christopherwxyz 4y agoBoth products are lotteries with premiums.
- nappy 4y agoThey are categorically different. The issuer of an insurance policy does not bear risk upfront. Insurance policies are not collateralized.
- junofan 4y ago> The reason loans on the blockchain are cheap is not because there's no middle-man but because they're over-collateralized so there's no risk. You’re talking apples and oranges. I think, given recent blowups, it could be related to limits on rehypothecation. But hard to know for sure.
- a2800276 4y agoThe Defi loan argument also discredits the argument that "crypto" is money. Why would I swap it for stablecoin, which presumably I swap for dollars which presumably I use to buy things if I could just buy things with "crypto"? Either I can't actually buy things with "crypto" in the world where grown ups reside or I don't want to part with it because I see it as a speculative investment/gambling.
- ogogmad 4y ago> Right now, you can take out a loan without involving a bank from one of the many crypto lending protocols. You put up some collateral and can take out a loan for extremely cheap, because there isn't a bank in the middle to take a cut. "Loan" is a very misleading description of what this is. This is margin trading. A loan is when you post a non-liquid asset in the real world -- like a house -- as collateral. Margin trading is when you post a fairly liquid asset (like other cryptocurrencies) as collateral so that you can buy more cryptocurrencies. You can't use these "DeFi loans" to buy a house in the real world. One reason I think DeFi is bullshit is because its critics describe what it does better than its advocates, who spout incoherent word salad.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoLoans do not need collateral, for example educational loans.
- jpgvm 4y ago> who spout incoherent word salad I affectionally call it crypto-babble. > critics describe what it does better than its advocates Seems to be true of pretty much all crypto. Most of the advocates have a very poor understanding of how it works, what the benefits/tradeoffs are and worst of all a complete ignorance of the systems they are seeking to "replace". As a result we see all the crypto stuff simply repeat mistakes/failures/weaknesses that have been known in financial systems for around a century or more in most cases.
- dubswithus 4y agoMost of the discussion about HN is not about technicalities of smart contracts or block times or ledgers. The skeptics are interested in repeating the same lines but have a very poor understanding of how it works.
- jpgvm 4y agoThat is much less of a problem than the reverse scenario. Being sceptical of something doesn't necessitate a strong understanding, being an advocate does, or at least should. Remember the existing systems work and thus far crypto isn't offering anything new, just alternatives with different trade-offs. That places an awfully high burden of proof on any crypto advocate and such a bar is far from being reached.
- alephnan 4y ago> Crypto is successful at being money. If you don't believe me, then I'm happy to sell you the laptop I'm writing this on for 1,000 ETH instead of 1,000 USD. Let us know when the laptop sells.
- Nursie 4y agoThis is packed full of odd arguments - > Crypto is successful at being money. If you don't believe me, then I'm happy to sell you the laptop I'm writing this on for 1,000 ETH instead of 1,000 USD. How about 1000 kilos of gold? Or 1000 1 Carat Diamonds? Does that make diamonds good money? > Right now, you can take out a loan without involving a bank from one of the many crypto lending protocols. Yes, but you over-collateralise that loan, swapping tokens around to do so. It doesn't look a lot like lending, it looks more like obfuscation of naive/fraudulent claims of productivity mixed with a game of musical chairs. And right now loan platforms in the crypto space are in all sorts of trouble. Look at "Solend" which appears to have suffered from a large token-holder taking out loans as a way to exit a cryptocurrency that was traded too thinly to cash out directly. Multiple DeFi lending platforms are mid-collapse, right now. I really agree with this - > In other words, crypto's use case is the one that it claims: decentralization. It's just that that use-case is far less universal, useful or desirable than we have been lead to believe by the cryptocurrency hype factory. For the most part nobody cares, the people putting money into cryptocurrency just want somewhere to gamble, the people not into that aspect are not lining up to use the products of this space, because of that promise. And in many cases (irreversible payments with no oversight!) it's actively bad. > "after 13 years, there are still no use cases for crypto" is not a rational fact How about "after 13 years there are still no use cases for crypto that aren't done better without the crypto aspect, or aren't just fucking stupid to begin with?" Because sure, there are some things you can do with blockchains and smart contracts, but honestly, why the hell would you?
- ab-dm 4y ago> Crypto is successful at being money. If you don't believe me, then I'm happy to sell you the laptop I'm writing this on for 1,000 ETH instead of 1,000 USD. > How about 1000 kilos of gold? Or 1000 1 Carat Diamonds? Does that make diamonds good money? This is a good argument, but I think a better one would be that there is no way the seller is willing to sell any laptop for 1,000 ETH, given that the value of 1000 ETH as of writing is over 1.5m AUD. If they gave me a quote for the actual value of the laptop in AUD (perhaps 1-2 ETH?) I would still say no, because the inherent volatility in even the most "stable" coins is too high. 2 ETH might be worth 3k AUD today, who knows what it will be when it arrives, let alone when I want to spend it.
- latchkey 4y agoExcellent article for once. Another one is decentralized compute. AWS pioneered taking unused compute and commoditizing it. Well, there is a lot of unused compute in the world and building ways to take advantage of it is part of what I see 'web3' as being about. PoW mining, however "wasteful", is still a great example of allowing anyone to effectively participate in the validation of transactions and getting rewarded for doing so. If you think of miners as a business, the 'customers' for miners are people submitting transactions, yet these business don't actually 'know' their customer at all. That's web3 decentralization (not silly NFTs). Protocols like Akash allow anyone to effectively run K8S on their own infrastructure and get paid to do so... all the while, decentralizing the compute away from central locations like AWS / GCP. I personally find that concept fascinating and super cool.
- RexM 4y agoI had not heard of Akash before. So I pay real dollars to setup and run a K8S cluster and people pay me in funny money to host their app on it? Looking at the calculator[0] the price fluctuates quite a bit. The 30 day average is 1 AKT/$0.35 while the current price is $0.215. [0]: https://akash.praetorapp.com/calculator https://akash.praetorapp.com/calculator
- latchkey 4y agoCorrect on both counts. The profit model just isn't sadly there yet. But it also wasn't there for Bitcoin in 2009 or ETH later on and people still bought hardware to mine.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoThat's because it's not a compelling service. It's been possible since the internet started and never took off. One of the most compelling services in the history of computing is the opposite - a centrally controlled service offering computing resources in return for standard, government issued currency. Throughout all computing, centrally controlled shared resources has been a compelling value prop.
- tptacek 4y agoIf these are powerful use cases, you probably won't need to inform us about them; we'll all be using Filecoin instead of S3, or Radicle instead of Gitlab. Instead of "here are some popular use cases", you'll say "you rely on crypto every day, in order to access this structured knowledge graph thing everyone uses". If replacing S3 and Github are the strongest cases you can make, I'm dubious: I don't doubt there are people who really want to replace S3, but I very much do doubt that there's a critical mass of them. The question being put to crypto isn't "can you come up with something that it can do"; it's "can you come up with something that will see mainstream use that eclipses the toxic speculation that's perceived to characterize every crypto application". I don't claim to have a dispositive argument here, but I also don't think crypto advocates do either.
- flaque 4y ago> “can you come up with something that will see mainstream use that eclipses the toxic speculation that's perceived to characterize every crypto application“ This is a far better question to put to crypto. The article isn’t attempting to address that question though. My bet is “yes”, at maybe 80% confidence. I would say it’s fairly difficult to see though, because speculative projects grow very quickly and dwarf “normal” projects, setting unrealistic comparisons. Both crypto skeptics and crypto promoters tend to be blinded by candlestick graphs. The total number of active wallets is still fairly small (a few million), and so a “non-speculative” project doesn’t “seem” like a major project when folks attempt to compare its market cap against speculative projects. For example, Dark Forest is fairly popular, but isn’t explicitly a speculative project. And so few folks outside of crypto have heard of it. Crypto suffers from the problem that the speculative parts are mainstream (or at least, are very well known about), but non-speculative use cases are not. I think this problem is mostly solved by the bubble popping. Crypto-skeptics can pat themselves on the back for predicting the obvious, but may end up being wrong long term because they missed the relatively “small” non-speculative projects.
- syntheweave 4y agoAnother way to put it is that crypto, being specified as a protocol, is likely not to be the product(which is how it's promoted speculatively) but a feature of a product. Like, HTTP isn't a product; but a web browser uses HTTP as a feature, and so do web servers. But they aren't the whole product either. And the categorical error is that traditional finance sees its protocols as products, but they're actually on the road to commodified features. It's easy to "print new money" now, so that's not the part of the value chain that matters.
- WheelsAtLarge 4y agoHelium as an incentive for the LoRaWAN network is the killer app for crypto. People are building a world wide LoT network. It's all decentralized. It's all being created by people who earn helium as a reward. I think the same model can be duplicated for other needs. If we give it time we'll see more solutions being created using the same model.
- wmf 4y agoDoes Helium have any usage yet? I heard they're charging higher prices than cellular carriers.
- latchkey 4y agoDoes it have to be a lower price if it works better? Uber / Lyft is often more expensive than taxis, once the VC funding dried up. That said, I still generally prefer shared rides cause it is an easy app to pull up on my phone.
- dubswithus 4y agoI use Uber so I don't get kidnapped -- which is a serious concern where I live.
- WheelsAtLarge 4y agoWell you need Helium to use the network so at the very least there is that. Maybe you can get Helium by setting up your own node(?), if you need to use the network. It make sense for you as a user to add to the network so you can get some Helium. I don't know the accounting but I think there is a possibility for it to be less expensive. I really don't know a lot but I do know that it's a self improving network so in time the economic parts will work themselves out. I also believe that the current model of setting up networks can't keep up with a self improving network. Imagine a network that's always a top of the line network. That grows or shrinks as needed. Who will have the resources to compete with it?
- aforwardslash 4y ago
- chowells 4y agoThis is the strawman-iest strawman I've seen in a long time. By this logic, there's a use case for getting stabbed in a back alley. Some people need surgery, after all. The proper question is what does cryptocurrency do better than alternatives? On the whole... I think bypassing financial controls to enable ransomware is not an improvement on the previous system.
- mike741 4y ago> The proper question is what does cryptocurrency do better than alternatives? Bitcoin, as one example, does a better job limiting supply and preventing inflation than its fiat alternatives. Of course, this doesn't make the article any less of a strawman.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoIf you define inflation as the devaluing of the currency, it doesn't really.... The mechanism by which a currency loses value matters little.
- mike741 4y agoI agree with that definition of inflation, so how hasn't it prevented inflation? Has the supply of bitcoins ever deviated from the intended rate? If it hasn't deviated from that rate then the supply, and thus the involuntary component of inflation, has been successfully kept under control.
- guerrilla 4y ago> Bitcoin, as one example, does a better job limiting supply and preventing inflation than its fiat alternatives. You assume that's a plus, but most of the world acts on the opposite assumption, i.e. NAIRU-like policies. I'm not picking a side, just pointing out that you disagree with almost every expert on the planet.
- mike741 4y ago
- bruce511 4y agoHe misses the two main use cases, and the two things that crypto are used for that dwarfs everything else. A) it's a great speculative asset. Huge volatility in value means fortunes can be made (and lost) in days not lifetimes. All those crypto ads on the radio talk about "investing" in Bitcoin - marketing it as an asset, not about using it as currency. It appears to be a zero sum game. I'll make no judgement about its actual value as an asset. B) it makes illegal transactions safer by removing the need to be physically present to receive cash. This simplifies things like drug deals, and of course with digital goods makes things like ransomware possible. Crypto already has two killer apps, it's just not the killer apps they wanted it to be.
- seibelj 4y agoI paid a contractor in Vietnam to do a side project for me once in a stablecoin. Because it avoided the central bank, they could avoid the stealing of their hard currency via the standard international payment system. One beneficial use case from the US perspective is further global dominance of USD (if you are into that sort of thing). This limits the ability of corrupt governments from inflating their fiat, which is generally a worse currency than USD fiat.
- hiq 4y ago> Because it avoided the central bank, they could avoid the stealing of their hard currency via the standard international payment system. How much was paid in fees in total, from your currency to theirs (I assume VND)? If it's a USD stablecoin, I assume they still had to convert it to VND, or at least they'd have to if they were paid mostly like this (to pay their taxes). Wise and others are quite cheap for the currencies they support.
- seibelj 4y agoI’m extremely deep in this space, so I will provide some more anecdotes. A lot of the Chinese crypto engineers (of which there are many) are paid in USDT. This avoids all of the capital controls and knowledge the state has. There is an entire subculture of Chinese who operate their businesses in USDT, mostly digital ones but it has bled into the physical world as well. In Hong Kong duffel bags full of paper currency would be swapped for USDT by various money changers. A lot of people look at crypto and see what’s on the surface. The easy, instant movement of essentially unlimited money without government oversight and intervention is scaring many authoritarian governments. See the total ban on crypto by the Chinese dictatorship.
- behnamoh 4y agoMost comments argue to the contrary of what the article lists as potential use-cases. I must say that the problem with crypto is not so much about its foundation (decentralized, blockchain) but rather the very fact that it promotes a broken business model that neither solves old problems nor offers new problems with novel solutions. I think any computation system that gets coupled with monetary incentives is potentially going to self-defeat its purpose one way or another. Crypto just makes it a lot easier for agents to game the system and lead it to corruption. Yes, the traditional financial institutions are not perfect either, but crypto takes their very worst (i.e., market manipulators) and provides them with a platform with far less regulation and much more reach.
- whatisweb3 4y ago> it promotes a broken business model that neither solves old problems nor offers new problems with novel solutions Have you looked at recent crypto currency research? ZK snarks and starks, multiparty computation, new polynomial commitment schemes and ZKP-friendly hash functions, new BFT consensus mechanisms. These are all novel solutions to age old problems. The use cases are niche, partly because the technology still has a long way to go before it becomes user friendly. We are only on the cusp of seeing stablecoin regulation - a few years from now, with robust stablecoins, PoS, and scalable L2s, the applications and use cases might look entirely different.
- jspaetzel 4y agoCrypto is more akin to a fundraising strategy then a specific technology. It's like calling a company "tech" and hoping that gets you more dollar signs. A use case like Helium sounds useful, but using a Blockchain doesn't necessarily add obvious value. The fundamentals don't make sense, you pay for power in dollars but you're paid back in monopoly money. It makes it harder for users to understand the underlying costs... But then again, maybe ambiguity is the value proposition.
- guerrilla 4y ago> It's like calling a company "tech" and hoping that gets you more dollar signs. Yeah but... that does actually work... so... hmm.
- uncomputation 4y agoI really wanted to agree but none of these claims really stand up to scrutiny in my opinion. > Few technologies have a clear start point. Did the internet start in Tim Berners-Lee in 1990? Or in 1982 with TCP/IP? Or in the 1970's with CYCLADES? Or in 1969 with ARPANET? Or in 1965 with the invention of packet switching? Or in 1950's with time-sharing? No, the web started in 1989 with Berners-Lee’s original proposal. The internet started in 1983 with TCP/IP (the Internet Protocol) being used for ARPANET. These are common, widely cited timeframes. > Can you distinguish the internet from computers or information theory? Yes, the internet is a network of networks made up of computers. A computer is not the internet. Information theory is the theoretical study of information and entropy started by Claude Shannon. > If you don't believe me, then I'm happy to sell you the laptop I'm writing this on for 1,000 ETH instead of 1,000 USD. Great, I’ll help you move house for a pizza, but that doesn’t make pizza money. The fact of the matter is, I can’t buy hardly anything with cryptocurrency except other cryptocurrencies. This is made more difficult even for companies that want to offer goods for crypto by the fact there is no stable exchange rate to USD. > Right now, you can take out a loan without involving a bank from one of the many crypto lending protocols. Lol, was this written before or after the collapse of Luna, Three Arrow Capital, and Celsius? Not to mention the numerous bridge hacks. I guess technically, sure, this is a valid (ie possible) use case of crypto, but not a strong one. > You may point to hacks I would argue a malfunctioning lending protocol is as good as no lending protocol, but again, this is a matter of opinion. > Filecoin Interesting use case for sure, but unfortunately it seems difficult to participate (and I initially had interest in doing so). IPFS is much further along development-wise. You may say “oh well this is still a use case of crypto” but… not really. I mean sure I can get paid in $FIL but if $FIL is useless in the real world (basically my earlier critique that it is not money) then why would I want to get paid in it? Overall, I want to agree and perhaps it’s just a couple years too early, but as of now, this is too strong of a claim to make, or at least too weak of an argument to support it.
- pcthrowaway 4y ago> > Right now, you can take out a loan without involving a bank from one of the many crypto lending protocols. > Lol, was this written before or after the collapse of Luna, Three Arrow Capital, and Celsius These have about as much to do with decentralized lending as Citadel and JP Morgan have to do with point of sale payment processing
- strangeattractr 4y ago> Crypto is successful at being money. If you don't believe me, then I'm happy to sell you the laptop I'm writing this on for 1,000 ETH instead of 1,000 USD. Utterly absurd and yet even still seems to make the exact opposite point. 1000 ETH can be sold for over USD1m, if ETH were successful money surely you would be indifferent to receiving $1000 and $1000 worth of ETH. Not to mention this seems to imply everything is ‘money’, I’d swap my phone for an RTX3090 so I guess it’s money too. In some sense maybe but this is so broad that the word ‘money’ ceases to have much use discussing. This piece is ridiculous. It accuses people who believe there are no use cases of making a bad faith statement while interpreting it in the most literal way possible. They aren’t saying you can’t do anything at all with crypto. Many crypto projects are interesting from a purely technical perspective, but mass market adoption isn’t driven by admiration of a technical implementation. It presents several technologies most of which have been developed as a crypto version of an existing technology for which a use case exists. In this circumstance the ‘use-case’ sceptics refer to is a feature that dominates the existing products for a price users are willing to pay. For the novel ones it's still unknown, but scepticism here is obviously warranted. I’m not even wedded to my scepticism of crypto. I have an interest in distributed systems and seeing ways people try to design byzantine fault tolerant systems. But I’m yet to see a project that I would use at all and I semi-regularly look. Even the final claim to cut out middlemen is false. To the end user transaction fees paid to miners don't feel any different to a fee charged by a bank on a transfer except maybe in magnitude. edited: said USD instead of ETH
- whatisweb3 4y ago> Many crypto projects are interesting from a purely technical perspective, but mass market adoption isn’t driven by admiration of a technical implementation. BitTorrent and Tor are interesting and useful but lack mainstream mass market adoption, but these do not make daily rounds on HN front page with dozens of “this technology is good for nothing” comments. I disagree with the author - ETH might be money-like but it’s use cases are broader than that, and the assets including stablecoins are more like shares or digital gold than state money. To those who use crypto a lot, all of these are just different assets with different uses and degrees of custody, be it fiat or crypto or stocks or physical gold. > To the end user transaction fees paid to miners don't feel any different to a fee charged by a bank on a transfer except maybe in magnitude. Part of this is lack of education. In ETH part of each fee is burned, providing value to all ETH holders by reducing supply. In PoS chains, the fees are redistributed to all staking validators - with delegation it means all users can also be, over long time periods, beneficiaries of these protocol fees.
- trash_goblin 4y ago
- ncmncm 4y agoDunno, but I notice if you pronounce it "grifto", people know exactly what you mean without explanation.
- hattmall 4y agoThe best use case I know of is Handshake. A domain name system that would be resistant to seizures and censorship. Domains are purchased and a fee is paid which gives a sustainable reason for the coin to have value. Though I think the same thing could be accomplished on Ethereum with web3. Of course running your own or shared DNS can have the same value, but I think Blockchain is a legitimate case for decentralizing domain names and having a record that can only be modified by the true owner.
- Nursie 4y agoIs there oversight? Does this do an end run around (for instance) trademark law? I'm not casting judgement when saying this, but if there isn't a governing body then that's attractive to some people but a huge red flag for others.
- aforwardslash 4y ago"that would be resistant to seizures and censorship" - from a cursory look, blocking the protocol and/or identifying peer nodes for a participant is almost trivial, for a state-sponsored actor.I dind't see anywhere in their site a proper threat model, attack simulations or any kind of actual fact that supports the claim of resistance to seizure or censorship. Have you seen those? Also, they clearly forget that most modern CAs actually store SSL certificate details on a blockchain. Its called certificate transparency.
- TameAntelope 4y ago> It's wrong though. Or at least, it doesn't stand up to scrutiny because it isn't falsifiable. If you firmly believe this claim, there's no new information you could learn that would cause you to update your belief towards the negative. Point of order, but "There are no use cases for crypto." is absolutely a falsifiable statement, and in fact this article goes on to falsify it. Even "There are no powerful use cases for crypto." is falsifiable along the same lines (it's arguable if the article successfully falsifies this statement, however).
- npc12345 4y agoThe crypto use case is bitcoin. Everything you can do elsewhere you can do it in Bitcoin, and safer.
- woopwoop 4y ago> Crypto is successful at being money. If you don't believe me, then I'm happy to sell you the laptop I'm writing this on for 1,000 ETH instead of 1,000 USD. Ford F-150s are successful at being money. If you don't believe me, then I'm happy to sell you the laptop I'm writing this on for 1,000 Ford F-150s instead of 1,000 USD.
- WatchDog 4y agoThe counter argument might be that Ford F-150s aren't particularly fungible. A slightly stronger example might be gold, but people don't use gold as money anymore either.
- woopwoop 4y agoFungible + trades at greater than one usd also includes, for example, aapl shares. Still well short of the mark.
- quickthrower2 4y agoWell AAPL shares kind of are a form of money used to pay compensation to its workers.
- redox99 4y agoI'm sure if trading or spending SPY was as easy as fiat, many people would sometimes prefer to pay or get paid with SPY instead of USD.
- nly 4y agoAnything perceived to have a stable value, is fungible, and is easy to move can be used as money. Just look at prisons. Gold stopped be used as money because people weren't really using it, they were using tokens pegged to it under a promise. That promise went away. Gold isn't exactly fungible (purity, fake gold etc), and it isn't easy to move in significant quantities. Gold makes for absolutely shit money in the 21st century
- 4y ago
- scott_w 4y agoThe entire thesis of this article is nonsense. He sets up a strawman to knock down. When people say “there are no use cases for crypto,” they’re actually saying “there are no use cases that aren’t solved better elsewhere.” This is the question he needs to answer and he doesn’t do so. Looking at the money example, he says he’ll sell his laptop for Etherium. That’s fine but if nobody is willing to buy it with Etherium, he can’t sell his laptop and Etherium is de facto not being used for money. Because he always skips this crucial last part, he never proves his argument.
- whatisweb3 4y agoThe statement always takes the form: there are no use cases that aren’t better solved by (some centralized company). The goal of crypto is to avoid that last part, and solve some of these problems without the need to place trust and lock value into a single entity. Uniswap as the author mentioned is a good example, in that it provides an exchange that allows users to trade tokens without reliance on a central company like Coinbase. This allows users to hold and exchange USD pegged assets like USDC and DAI in a non custodial fashion, and also take part in defining, improving, and even forking the Uniswap protocol if they want to, as it is not privately owned.
- scott_w 4y ago> The statement always takes the form: there are no use cases that aren’t better solved by (some centralized company). 2 things: 1. No it doesn’t. 2. Nobody cares. “Centralised” isn’t a problem. If it causes problems you need to demonstrate that and then show how blockchain solves that problem and how existing solutions can’t. I’ve seen no examples of that (Uniswap isn’t an example).
- whatisweb3 4y ago> No it doesn’t. This statement verbatim is regularly repeated on HN - users pointing to Stripe, PayPal, Venmo, Apple, whatever as being better solutions than the proposed crypto/web3 ideas. > “Centralised” isn’t a problem. Not for you, maybe. Some users will be happy to manage the additional complexity and risks of handling non-custodial assets on Ethereum L2s in order to achieve lower fees and take-rates, privacy preservation, censorship resistance, and programmable composability. A very simple example is a domain name. Outside of blockchain networks, we have no mechanism for non-custodial ownership and peer-to-peer transfer of a domain name asset - like you would exchange cash where two parties simply swap the bills directly without the need for a third-party to oversee the exchange and potentially extract rent.
- mrweasel 4y agoFirstly: I’m annoyed that crypto now seems to be synonymous with “blockchain”, rather than cryptography. Secondly: Most of the blockchain use-case feel a little like the argument for Bittorrent. It’s not that you can’t use it for sensibel purposes, but when you do you’re solving problem most people don’t have.
- ytch 4y agoMe too, I thought: " We use RSA, AES, ECDSA everyday, why is it a question" at first glance.
- cowtools 4y agoI think bittorrent solves actually does solve a problem most people have. If we lived in a bittorrent using utopia, you would never have to set up a web server because you could just seed static websites from a couple home computers. Popular sites would never go down due to DDoS because their users could support them with their own bandwidth. I think that's the idea behind the newer protocols like IPFS. I think cryptocurrency could be used to solve a micropayments problem, but I doubt it will ever catch on if it depends on internet companies' forward thinking and benevolence.
- maccard 4y agoBit torrent is _great_. It allows for a massive amount of global information sharing at little to no cost to the creator. I have used bittorent professionally - we were distributing 50+GB to 150 computers in a limited time frame with a limited external internet connection but fast intercommunication. We downloaded the entire package to one computer and used BitTorrent to distribute to the other 150 computers. Niche, yes. Incredibly useful? Yes!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- asasidh 4y ago
- WatchDog 4y agoHow are cryptocurrency loans supposed to work? If I need own enough crypto assets as collateral to cover the loan value, whats the point in getting a loan?
- ahtihn 4y agoSame point as getting a margin loan against your stocks. Leverage.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoAlso avoiding taxable events, and keeping a desirable position
- Aunche 4y ago> Filecoin - A commodity market for storage that's currently 0.0011% the cost of S3. This actually proves that there isn't a real use case of Filecoin aside from speculation. Amazon isn't making 99.9989% profit margins on S3, nor is it possible for Filecoin to be a hundred thousand times more efficient than S3. This means that Filecoin's storage product is so uncompetitive that you need to subsidize it a hundred thousand times just to get people to use it. > Toucan - Tradable Carbon Credits All the other use cases listed look like parodies of crypto products with plenty of buzzwords, and no real substance. However, this one is especially nonsensical. From their website: > Working with top DeFi protocols and the community we enable carbon credits to be used as collateral, yields and money, as well as a huge range of novel applications. That's literally missing the point of buying carbon credits. The only use case for buying carbon credits to blackhole them immediately, so that you can feel like you're offsetting your emissions. There is no reason to resell them. Even if you did want to resell them because you overestimated your carbon footprint and have some left "unused", no buyer has any reason to believe you. If there is anything carbon credits need, it's more centralization and trust, not less. Excellent relevant Wendover video about carbon credits: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AW3gaelBypY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AW3gaelBypY
- Dylan16807 4y ago> This actually proves that there isn't a real use case of Filecoin aside from speculation. Amazon isn't making 99.9989% profit margins on S3, nor is it possible for Filecoin to be a hundred thousand times more efficient than S3. This means that Filecoin's storage product is so uncompetitive that you need to subsidize it a hundred thousand times just to get people to use it. A few months ago I tried for a couple hours to figure out how to get files onto the filecoin network and I could not make heads or tails of it. There were some services that used it as a backend, but that wasn't my goal and they had weird pricing too. Wikipedia says "As of February 2022 the total storage capacity was 15.6EiB, and total data stored was 40 PiB." Clearly something's wonky here if it's so cheap and so empty. Does anyone understand what's going on there? For comparison I could mention something like Sia, which seems to be put together fine and comprehensibly, but the total size is single digit petabytes so it's completely irrelevant on a global scale.
- 4y ago
- lkrubner 4y ago"Few technologies have a clear start point. Did the internet start in Tim Berners-Lee in 1990? Or in 1982 with TCP/IP? Or in the 1970's with CYCLADES? Or in 1969 with ARPANET? Or in 1965 with the invention of packet switching? Or in 1950's with time-sharing? Can you distinguish the internet from computers or information theory? Maybe it starts at radio or the telegraph." Did you say 'over'? Nothing is over until we decide it is! Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor? Hell no! It ain't over now, 'cause when the goin' gets tough, the tough get goin'. Who's with me? Let's go! Come on!... (returning): What the f--k happened to the crypto I used to know? Where's the spirit? Where's the guts, huh? This could be the greatest night of our lives, but you're gonna let it be the worst. 'Ooh, we're afraid to go with you, crypto, we might get in trouble.' (shouting) Well, just kiss my ass from now on! Not me! I'm not gonna take this. Coinbase, he's a dead man! Celsius, dead! Ethereum...
- chexum 4y agoI'm quite confused, the article is supposed to be an advocacy piece, but it is just being all defensive about where the use cases are. With TCP/IP, or packet switching, they did have an idea that it will be useful, but noone could imagine how popular it's going to be. With crypto, it seems the opposite, I'm afraid. Noone needs a use case for a Raspberry Pi, or a Raspberry Pi Pico (the latter, many would say, borders on being useless with other, cheaper and/or more complete platforms being available). But I can just buy one, and tinker with it and voila. I don't need a use case to run a Z80 retro emulator on a Pico, I can just do it on my own, without any "industry" deciding which type of emulators should the investors have. Why "crypto" needs a use case is exactly because people insist it's money, and had to be acquired with money. While it was all P2P, and you could get whole bitcoins for fun, it were different times. Nowadays, you can't mine any meaningful amount of it unless you invest in thousands, or you buy them with money or credit card. And it's starting to be either illegal in some countries or in a custodial wallet, going poof when the company goes bankrupt.
- petesergeant 4y ago> cheap loans a loan that might double in the amount of fiat you have to pay back isn’t cheap, it’s nuts. Also there’s significant cost converting to and from fiat to take it out > filecoin https://randomoracle.wordpress.com/2019/12/07/filecoin-storj-and-the-problem-with-decentralized-storage/ https://randomoracle.wordpress.com/2019/12/07/filecoin-storj... > LabDAO Toucan Golden.xyz Why not just a centralised database though? > Radicle.xyz OK sure, if you have code that GitHub won’t accept, then this looks ok, but presumably it either has a mechanism to stop CSAM on it, at which point it can also be censored, or the Feds are coming for you if you run a node… > Helium - Incentivization layer for the LoRaWAN network Some kind of payment mechanism for sharing Wi-Fi? I didn’t have time to dig deep enough, but almost certainly a centralised authority would work better because it almost always does > NFTs Better handled by a central authority, and looks like OpenSea is already acting as one re stolen apes etc > A blockchain is not a database … A blockchain is an escrow without a third party And the lack of use-cases for that is the reason there are so few use-cases for blockchain
- redox99 4y ago> Also there’s significant cost converting to and from fiat to take it out No there's not. Trades on exchanges are under 0.1% [1]. ERC20 tokens have some fees because of gas but it's a flat amount [2], which is negligible for any operation over a thousand dollars. Fiat withdrawals are generally free [3]. The most expensive part usually is the gas to interact with the DeFi smart contract, but it's also a flat fee. [1] https://help.ftx.com/hc/en-us/articles/360024479432-Fees https://help.ftx.com/hc/en-us/articles/360024479432-Fees [2] https://etherscan.io/gastracker https://etherscan.io/gastracker 0.75USD as of now, but it can reach like 10USD when the network is congested. [3] https://help.ftx.com/hc/en-us/articles/360043023772-Depositing-Withdrawing-Fiat- https://help.ftx.com/hc/en-us/articles/360043023772-Depositi...
- petesergeant 4y ago> Trades on exchanges are under 0.1% Let's say I am the type of person who needs a cheap loan, and I decide to use Coinbase. My understanding is that money into Coinbase and money out of Coinbase is going to cost me 1.49% (at least) in each direction, and that's before the additional $1-$10 gas fees in each direction. So 3% + currency risks + whatever other fees + the risk of fat-fingering my crypto and losing it to the ether forever, and also trying to figure out if I have some kind of tax liability, BEFORE the actual interest rate itself. Or I choose a well-regulated provider to do a money-transfer[0] to and pay a one-off fee of 3-4% for several thousand pounds for a year or longer loan, even if my credit isn't perfect, and I do that with the full protection of the legal system, including bankruptcy protection, easy resolution if I type the wrong account number in, etc. Those are the rates for if I need cash too, if the thing I need to pay for can be paid for by credit-card, the rate falls to closer to 2%... [0] https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/credit-cards/money-transfers/ https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/credit-cards/money-transfe...
- davidperrenoud 4y agoCertificate Transparency. Both Chrome and Safari implement it and you will receive an e-mail from Cloudflare if someone creates a certificate for your domain: It is kind of a blockchain with proof of authority. More precisely it is a Merkle tree with certificate authorities seen as trusted nodes by the web browsers. This idea was extended in something called General Transparency and implemented in the Google Trillian project: https://sites.google.com/site/certificatetransparency/general-transparency https://sites.google.com/site/certificatetransparency/genera...
- kaoD 4y agoWhen people refer to "crypto" they mean cryptocurrency. In a more general non-currency sense they still refer to trustless blockchains that solve the Byzantine Generals Problem.
- MrPatan 4y agoDigital art and collectibles with easy ownership and provenance guarantees. You can't do that any other way. No, a centralized database doesn't cut it. Remember how you hate "buying" movies from Google or Amazon only for them to shut down the service down the line? Why would you not hate the same thing for art? Also, now it's cheap. Just buy some and relax, guys. Let it go.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- user_named 4y agoThe problem is that crypto is marketed (often) to consumers but crypto is really infrastructure so the target user is the enterprise, not the consumer. Any consumer use case is built on top of the infrastructure, and the consumers don't care if it's crypto or not. In short, crypto is b2b and not B2C.
- jiggawatts 4y agoThe problem with crypto is that the main unique features are only "distributed trust" or the "public immutable ledger" aspects. Everything else can be implemented or emulated much more easily emulated with simpler, traditional technologies. The thing is, nobody actually cares if the thing they trust is distributed or not. They just want to not have to trust some specific third parties. They very rarely want their information to be public and immutable. For example, banks would really like to be able to detect credit card fraud where customers use a cc from bank A to pay off the cc debt in bank B. But they don't want to trust each other, so how do they exchange this data? Crypto people would instantly jump and say: "Blockchain!" But what's required here is not distributed ledgers, and certainly not public ledgers. The whole problem is thank bank A doesn't want to give B their customer records. Making it public is worse. Instead what they do is hire a third-party that's not a bank, like Equifax, Experian, and the like. These companies hold the ledger centrally, secretly, and don't tell anyone[1] the contents, including bank A or B! Instead, they sell back to the banks the "cc fraud analysis" only, after having done the cross-bank transaction analysis. There are hundreds, if not thousands of companies like this around the world. I know of several that collect sales information from competing companies and then sell back the anonymized statistics to them. There's basically one for every industry, in every large country. About 90% of what crypto does can be implemented much more sanely, cheaply, and privately using something like a cloud service. For example, Azure SQL now has a "Ledger" feature where it keeps cryptographic hashes of transactions in a chain (sound familiar?), and keeps these in immutable blob storage. This blob storage can be restricted to specific private networks. Even if it is public, there is access control based on API keys and the like. Corporations that need an immutable ledger that "none of them control but all of them can access and verify" can just hire a third-party to spin one of these up and host it in the cloud. Faster, cheaper, simpler, compatible with ordinary SQL applications, and private. That last one can't be underestimated. That's a killer feature that no blockchain can provide without crypto wizardry that only 2 or 3 people on the planet understand. Ref: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/sql/relational-databases/security/ledger/ledger-overview?view=sql-server-ver16 https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/sql/relational-databases/se... [1] Have you ever wondered why the Equifax data breach affected the records of so many people from so many banks? This is why! Their core business model is cross-bank data collection and analysis.
- bowsamic 4y agoFor me it's just a waiting game. I'm not going to start the next big crypto project, and I really don't want to get too caught up in FOMO, so if blockchain actually becomes huge and useful, I'll wait and see. I don't mind if it does, or if it doesn't. There are certainly aspects of it that sound very exciting, but also it seems that the unwieldiness of it counteracts that. In many ways it's like quantum computing vs. classical computing, everyone is very hyped about it, but no one knows exactly what we are going to do with it, and it isn't clear that the cost and difficulty of using it justify the somewhat ephemeral benefits.
- mbar84 4y agoThe only use case for blockchain is money. Everything else is a scam. We only need one money, the one with the most dominant network effects. Right now, if it every happens, that money looks like it will be Bitcoin. This will take a while. How long it takes depends not so much on Bitcoin itself, but on how bad the competition undermines their use case as money. In the meantime, people may find it surprising that there is indeed no other use case for the most inefficient database man has ever conceived, other than the on e it was explicitly designed for.
- once_inc 4y agoMost altcoins and defi products would have a very different incentive structure if built as a second or third layer on Bitcoin, because the incentive and ability for rugpulls is vastly degraded.
- RichardHeart 4y agoNumber go up.
- once_inc 4y agoAs much as I agree with thise meme on longer timeframes, stating it now is a bit unfortunate.
- teekert 4y agoHere's another one: [0]. I love sending boosts and streaming satoshis (sats) back to indie creators (40 sats/min is the default in Castamatic which I use) who sometimes share them completely transparently with other parties (like opensats [1]) or guests on shows. [0]: https://podcastindex.org/ https://podcastindex.org/ [1]: https://opensats.org/ https://opensats.org/
- t_mann 4y agoThis is written with the idea in mind that a lot of HN users are both informed about and highly skeptical of crypto/web3 (my impression). I actually understand much of the critique, but I think it's not giving credit for a few things that are cool about smart contracts: a) You can enter arbitrary (computable) binding commitments with strangers. This is powerful, it makes all the difference between non-cooperative and cooperative game theory. b) You can separate the creation of web services from their upkeep. You can deploy a smart contract as a weekend project and it'll stay available for the community to use without you having to spend further resources. A plain smart contract without a web front-end is admittedly not user-friendly to access, but there are already several projects trying to provide a front end in a similar fashion (eg blockchains meant for hosting web apps, or uploading apps to IPFS). Is any of that strictly needed, in a developed country with trustworthy institutions? Well, we could argue. But I think hackers agree that those are at least cool things to tinker with. (And to those worried about environmental impact: the above doesn't apply to Bitcoin, and once Ethereum has switched to PoS, none of the relevant smart-contract-enabled chains will have that problem anymore)
- execveat 4y agoThese "arbitrary commitments with strangers" are only good as long as they do what you intended. Roughly every week there is a major incident with millions of funds lost due to a bug and people who lost money usually are very quick to put up case that the money has to be reverted as the contracts weren't meant to be so arbitrary after all.
- t_mann 4y agoYes, but from a technical perspective immutability leads to some interesting problems again (formal verification, standards, audits,...).
- hansword 4y ago> Crypto is successful at being money. If you don't believe me, then I'm happy to sell you the laptop I'm writing this on for 1,000 ETH instead of 1,000 USD. You might be happy to sell it, but I am not happy to buy it using ETH. I think it's a bit silly that the author accuses critics of not understanding crypto, but they clearly don't understand money. I might miss something here, but I am afraid in their logic the Kuwaiti Dinar is somehow better than the Dollar because you need to pay 3 dollar to get a Dinar. Edit: typo
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y agoI know the ship has long sailed but my first reaction was, "What? They're everywhere!" - understanding crypto as cryptography. I guess I'm officially an old man now.
- cryptica 4y agoUnfortunately, all the promising use cases are suppressed and kept from the public. It feels as though people are not allowed to invest in them. On the other hand, obvious scams and Ponzis get a lot of attention and funding. IMO, established interest groups are working hard and investing a lot of money to discredit the space. That's why they only allow shitcoins and scams to gain traction. This might sound strange or far-fetched, but many people who have been in this industry for a few years share a similar perspective. If you think the economy is behaving increasingly insane, it's because it is. That's what you get when some entities have access to unlimited fiat. They spend most of it on anti-competitive activities.
- Kbelicius 4y ago> Unfortunately, all the promising use cases are suppressed and kept from the public. It seems that you know what those use cases are but for some reason you are unwilling to share them here. Did the establishment get to you too or are you just talking out of your ass?
- cryptica 4y agoMy community launched a cryptocurrency backed by real estate income and we did token buybacks and burn using the income; we did this using our own DEX so our token serves as an alternative to a share (since obviously we cannot list shares of our business on a stock exchange; this had obvious business utility). It works (we managed to acquire 1 property and token price was stable for a long time) but unfortunately we've been struggling to raise significant funding since the beginning and there has been a lot of weird stuff happening with our community members like people pulling out for no reason and then soon after receiving awards from other mainstream (scam) projects whose founders don't like us. In some cases, we've had people spend months working for free building some apps (hoping to get some tokens), finishing it and then pull out mysteriously with weird excuses and refusing any tokens. You'll find that these buyback-and-burn 'token as a share' projects which are backed by real economic value are suppressed even though they provide businesses with exposure to investors which represents real value for those businesses (and potentially to their investors). None of them ever end up growing to the point that they can become fully decentralized (though most of them look promising initially). Obviously many founders take 'bribes' (in the form of price pumps) to sabotage their own projects. I've worked for such project before and watched it self-sabotage. It was very obvious but they started to hire a lot of people and adding more bureaucracy to make the business look more legitimate... But they achieved absolutely nothing in 5 years.
- drdrek 4y ago"Crypto is successful at being money. If you don't believe me, then I'm happy to sell you the laptop I'm writing this on for 1,000 ETH instead of 1,000 USD." Lol, Great reasoning! ll happily give you 1000ETH for 1000 1K gold bars! I'll throw in a laptop for free! Pretty indicative of the level of thought invested in writing this.
- jjuliano 4y agoOne of the use-case is to unfriend friends. Basically, you over-hype a crypto to your friends, then they invest huge sums of their savings, then immediately a crash occurs, wiping 90% of the saving. Next use-case is to recommend stables.
- obarthelemy 4y agoIs he actually closing the discussion on crypto as money because eth>usd ? Does this mean we should be using Berkshire shares as money ? Or platinum ? Or are there criteria besides "value" that make something good as "money" ? Shouldn't he be looking into those instead of whining for half his blurb that people are being simplistic, while being incredibly simplistic himself ? Is price the only criteria for file storage ?N What about performance, resilience, availability... Are in-game NFT any more tradable than regular in-game items ? His blurb actually took me a step further towards thinking that crypto is just a bunch of baselss claims. He sure does string them enthusiastically, with zero critical thinking.
- senectus1 4y agoI've bought a game and a mega subscription using btc. thats about it. after a year of having some.
- kobasa 4y agohttps://blog.chain.link/smart-contract-use-cases/ https://blog.chain.link/smart-contract-use-cases/
- JoeMascuve 4y ago