9 ms·
Over 13k Vivo phones found to be using same IMEI number (2020)
- car_analogy 4y ago> While IMEI number may sound rather irrelevant for a common user, however, it becomes a grave security concern as it makes it impossible for cops to intercept criminals. In the same way that not wearing a tracking collar is a security concern, because it makes it harder for the police to spy on you? We really should invent a new word for "security" that is actually "security against the user".
- DeWilde 4y agoIt's called surveillance.
- car_analogy 4y agoFunny how rarely they call it that, isn't it?
- OJFord 4y agoThought-provoking thread! Maybe I'm being too generous, but I think it makes more sense when you think about it 'top-down': 'national security', in the US 'the Dept. of Homeland Security', etc.
- mindslight 4y ago"Security" is a multi-perspective endeavor. When large institutions use the term "security" they are referring to their own security, which is generally at the expense of your own security. And unfortunately most people naively think that "security" is a scalar where more is good, when in reality they themselves are being made less secure by institutions pushing way past the Schelling points. Surveillance state, digital restrictions management, treacherous computing appliances, "two factor authentication", airport searches, totalitarian schools, prohibitions on mobile phones or pocket knives, no outside food or drink, etc. These are all instances of making some central entity's position more secure, while running roughshod over the ability for individuals to make ourselves secure.
- teddyh 4y agoSometimes people use “respect” to mean “treating someone like a person” and sometimes they use “respect” to mean “treating someone like an authority” and sometimes people who are used to being treated like an authority say “if you won’t respect me I won’t respect you” and they mean “if you won’t treat me like an authority I won’t treat you like a person” and they think they’re being fair but they aren’t, and it’s not okay. — https://flyingpurplepizzaeater.tumblr.com/post/115216522824/sometimes-people-use-respect-to-mean-treating https://flyingpurplepizzaeater.tumblr.com/post/115216522824/...
- rollcat 4y agoIf this is a legitimate concern to you, you should consider not carrying a phone. I know it sounds crazy, but I remember the times before everyone and their dog had a mobile phone - we somehow survived. Even if there's nobody out there to get you, it's very refreshing and calming to disconnect.
- car_analogy 4y agoThat would help me individually, but will do nothing to address my concern about society becoming a panopticon, and the proliferation of laws that make it illegal to attempt to evade surveillance: For example, in the United Kingdom, under the Mobile Telephones (Re-programming) Act, changing the IMEI of a phone, or possessing equipment that can change it, is considered an offence under some circumstances. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Mobile_Equipment_Identity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Mobile_Equipment...
- rollcat 4y agoYou also can't just change or hide your car's registration plates - it's also illegal. I 100% agree with your concern, but there's always a line to draw. Sorry for the car analogy, I had to ;)
- dmitrygr 4y ago> possessing equipment that can change it, On most pixel phones, the "equipment" is any computer with a usb cable and a copy of android SDK (adb). Better arrest every owner of said equipment...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dendriti 4y agoYou know this works for literally EVERY concern about privacy for ANY technology?
- Fatnino 4y agoYou should carry your phone, GPS on, with you everywhere all the time. The only exception should be when you need to go out and do something that will be frowned on by the powers that be. In those instances you should leave the phone at home playing a long YouTube video. If you are ever questioned about your whereabouts during that time your phone will supply a good (increasingly bordering on perfect) alibi.
- refurb 4y agoThe claim they can track criminals seem bogus? I mean in the US IMEI aren’t linked to a person, at least not required. Neither are SIMs. So if one really wanted an anonymous cell phone it’s not hard to do.
- rys 4y agoThe IMEI is trackable and triangulatable geographically as it moves around the network. So it still helps determined actors to find the phone, and therefore maybe the user.
- Nextgrid 4y agoThe same can be done with just a SIM though. What IMEI gives you is the ability to track the same phone across SIMs.
- robertlagrant 4y agoDetermined actors? Like Tom Cruise? He seems pretty determined.
- jsmith45 4y agoYes, but so is the ISMI, from the sim card, which is actually the primary identifier used for most things within the protocol. ISMI determines which phone number gets connected to the phone, who gets billed for phone calls, etc. The main scenarios where IMEI should be interesting to law enforcement are: stolen phone situations, criminals that keep getting getting new burner sims while continuing to use the same phone, or people that keep prank calling emergency services without having a SIM installed. In nearly all other cases, the ISMI is far more useful identifier. And obviously the phones in question all have unique ISMIs or the network would be having, err.... great difficulty with all of those phones having the same phone number, and being able to route calls.
- rootsudo 4y agoUS IMEI's potentially are. They are recorded upon purchase - from carrier or reseller. Sims same, they are immediately tied to your account and if you are post paid, there you go. Anonymous cell phones also aren't entirely possible anymore because of network effect and the convenience factor. 1. Network effect, who you know, who you call, when they call you - pattern. 2. Internet usage, where do you go? 3. Geolocation - GPS, proximity with other cell phones, and then internal measuring devices. You can disable reporting completely, sure, but triangulation is user carrier side data, and with 5g roll outs and other potential signal repeaters and cell phones, it's still very accurate. 4. Sideline recording of this data is possible, same as a heat map in googlemaps - just looking for repeatable patterns of usage, where you go, etc. It's not only hard, cell phones nowadays are not designed for anonymous usage. And this is before we even get into adtech, app tracking and other layers of interaction.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThis sounds like a pure benefit to the user. Hopefully the "problem" will continue to grow.
- flotzam 4y agoHope so too. Maybe one day IMEI addresses can be randomized as casually as MAC addresses.
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y agoUnless one of these phones has been used by criminals. There are numerous stories of people having the same name as a wanted person and suffering endlessly because of that.
- tinus_hn 4y agoThat’s a problem if you’re one of 10 people that happens to. If it happens to 13000 people it’s the polices problem.
- dutchbrit 4y agoWhatsapp use to use IMEI reversed and md5 hashed as its password on Android (username was the users telephone number) - on iPhone they used a MAC address. I brought it up as a security concern back in 2012. It would not surprise me if some apps still use IMEI (or MAC address) for similar purposes…
- chrystianv 4y agoThird party Android apps cannot read the IMEI number. Source: https://developer.android.com/about/versions/10/privacy/changes https://developer.android.com/about/versions/10/privacy/chan...
- rootsudo 4y agoThird party android apps used to be able too 100%, it's a very callable action. TelephonyManager tm = (TelephonyManager) getSystemService(Context.TELEPHONY_SERVICE);
- tpmx 4y agoSince Android 10, released in 2019.
- jeroenhd 4y ago… which means that apps that are working on any kind of modern device can't rely on this behaviour, and thus can't generate passwords or other account critical secrets using this method. Apps written for modern Android phones can't use the IMEI for any legitimate purposes anymore, unless the device is rooted or the IMEI is exposed in some other unofficial way.
- tpmx 4y agohttps://www.androidpolice.com/googles-latest-android-version-distribution-numbers-show-11-in-dead-heat-with-10/ https://www.androidpolice.com/googles-latest-android-version... hints that ~49% of Android devices will give out the IMEI to third-party apps. [late 2021]
- Qem 4y agoThat's a feature for me, not a bug.
- chmod775 4y agoThat's a surveillance problem, not a security problem.
- jokoon 4y agoThose phones were probably made for criminals who wanted to not be tracked... I guess it might have worked for a while, but it was not a great idea... I wonder if operators will block those IMEI, because in some countries, they might just refuse to block them...
- vaylian 4y ago> Those phones were probably made for criminals who wanted to not be tracked... Not necessarily. It could also have been an employee who knew about the dangers of surveillance.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gadders 4y agoIt's all fun and games until one gets reported stoled and 13,000 phones all stop working. I think something like this happened in India before.
- baybal2 4y agoThe major benefit of making embedded devices with exactly same firmware from device to device is that you can pre-order memory chips already flashed. Network cards do run into extremely uncommon MAC collisions because they just generate a random MAC on first start, which is then read, and printed after manufacturing.
- 0xbadc0de5 4y agofwiw - Certain chipsets, such as Mediatek, make cloning IMEI, WiFi and BT MAC addresses quite easy. There's plenty of tutorials out there.
- paulcarroty 4y agoPerfect for privacy.
- jeroenhd 4y agoIMEI is used for surveillance, yes, but also to identify devices. If one of these devices is used to abuse a cell network in any way, the ISP might just simply blacklist the IMEI and all those phones lose connectivity immediately, or, even worse, have their subscriptions connected to malicious behaviour. Some network providers might also block the device after one of those phones gets reported as stolen. The slight extra hassle this will create for law enforcement isn't worth the massive risk of disadvantages that duplicate IMEIs have.
- darkhorn 4y agoIn Turkey SIMs must be linked to ID. If you change owner of a phone number it goes trough approval from the government which takes a day. IMEIs must be registered before sold. If you buy mobile phone from abroad you can use it for few months without registering the IMEI. Then the mobile networks do not respond to the mobile phone, even if you change the SIM. Registering a phone requires a passport, that proves you have visited abroad in that last 6 months. If longer, you cannot register. And the IMEI gets tied to the SIM. Plus, it is very expensive, like half minimal salary.
- Scoundreller 4y agoThe device or one-time cost of registering a SIM? Are there large chunks of the population that just use wifi-only phones?
- darkhorn 4y agoThe half minimum salary cost that I've said is to register IMEI, in other words to register the phone. There is no wifi only phone or wifi network, if you really mean wifi. There are "only data" plans but for that you also need to register the IMEI.
- justsomehnguy 4y agoCan you clarify, do you need a "half-min-salary" for any new phone, or for the ones imported from the abroad? Last time I visited Turkie, I didn't had any trouble using the phone (except eye-watering 3G tariffs and somewhat spotty reception out of the main areas), bu the moment I tried to use a WiFi network in the mall it requested a SMS confirmation.
- div72 4y agoThey probably filter foreign SIMs so you won't have an issue but people with local SIMs do need to pay a one time fee for phones you bring from abroad. (not for the ones you can buy here) I've heard some people clone IMEIs from the old phone when getting a new phone from abroad and that it does reduce the cost significantly.
- ChrisArchitect 4y ago(2020)!
- IYasha 4y agoA rare case of bug that works in favor of people.