5 ms·
Most of what you have mentioned are inherent shortcomings of tanks in a modern battlefield. They are fuel intensive. They need massive logistical support. They
by paxys 4y ago
Most of what you have mentioned are inherent shortcomings of tanks in a modern battlefield. They are fuel intensive. They need massive logistical support. They are vulnerable to targeted attacks, like from drones. None of this is unique to the Ukraine situation.
It is very hard for tanks to be effective in the age of cheap UAVs.
- nradov 4y agoRight. There were similar discussions about whether the tank has a future after many of them were destroyed in the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. The main issues were crappy Russian equipment and poor tactics. https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2020/09/30/armor-attrition-in-nagorno-karabakh-battle-not-a-sign-us-should-give-up-on-tanks-experts-say/ https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2020/09/30/...
- ksidudwbw 4y agoThere isnt a silver bullet for every situation and condition, but a moveable metal box that can target heat-emitting targets in its line of sight is useful. As long as its potential is fully utilised like machine assisted target aquisiton and liquidation (ai assisted optics + firing)
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoInfantry are vulnerable to literally everything, and yet no one besides some dingbats that watched terminator too many times are suggesting the age of infantry is over. Aircraft are vulnerable to missiles. Is anyone suggesting the age of aircraft are over? Drones, particularly consumer quadcopter adopted out of convenience are vulnerable to missiles, autocannons, and electronic warfare. Does not the very same logic being offered as proof of the end of tanks apply to drones as well? This whole argument is stupid and predicated on a vast misunderstanding of how combined arms operations work. Systems are not discard because they're vulnerable, if they can be employed in a way that min/maxes their impact vs vulnerability. There is nothing new about this conflict as far as tanks and ATGMs. Everything happening here happened in the Yom Kippor war, in Grozny, in Syria, and in Yemen. You just have a bunch of lazy bloggers and journalists making a sensationalized claim to sound like something exciting and dramatic is happening, at the cost of grossly distorting the actual reality. What will change is future tanks will likely prioritize active protection systems and sensors over bulk armor. But the basic concept of combing firepower, mobility, and protection is not going away any time soon. Example, Rheinmetall just announced their new tank prototype this week: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTBA5tQsDbE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTBA5tQsDbE A couple key features: * an active protection system specifically for top attack munitions like Javelin * a remote weapons station with a machine gun specifically for engaging small low altitude drones like quad copters * flexible manning, including looking at autonomy and remote control * ability to host drones for its own situational awareness * a loitering munition that's being co-designed, launched by the big gun Maybe the era of the T-72 is over. But the people confidently predicting the era of tanks and armored fighting vehicles in general are over, cuz missiles, cuz drones, frankly, have no clue what they're talking about.
- hinkley 4y ago> and yet no one besides some dingbats that watched terminator too many times and missed the moral of the story... > This whole argument is stupid and predicated on a vast misunderstanding of how combined arms operations work. Systems are not discard because they're vulnerable, if they can be employed in a way that min/maxes their impact vs vulnerability. The mythology of the board game Go is that it was invented by a Chinese general in an attempt to teach his son strategy and tactics. In that domain there is a concept called Aji, in which you should not write off pieces on the board that are doomed. The fact that they are still on the board makes them useful, even if they can't possibly be saved, saved only by gross error by the opponent, or saving them is possible but devastating to your overall prospects.
- chrisseaton 4y agoInfantry disperse and hide. Tanks really struggle to do either.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoWhich is why you screen tanks with infantry.
- chrisseaton 4y agoNot sure what you think a screen is... but it doesn't hide anything. A screen is about finding, not hiding.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoYes, exactly. The infantry screen the tanks from enemy infantry ATGM groups. Everything that makes enemy infantry with ATGMs more effective tank hunters makes infantry screening the tanks more effective at countering them.
- chrisseaton 4y ago
- hinkley 4y agoThe Abrams A1 got like half a mile to the gallon didn't it? How many miles can they move before you have to park them next to a giant, unarmored gas can?
- aaronblohowiak 4y agothe abrams had a 500 gallon tank, so... pretty far?
- formerkrogemp 4y agoSounds like a pretty big explosive to carry on hand.
- hinkley 4y agoTIL that the energy content of 33k gallons of gas is equivalent to a 1 kiloton bomb. I am probably on a list now for trying to figure out the explosive power of a Javelin missile, which I did not find.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoNot really. The tanks are outside the armor and just blow up if they get a direct hit. Shockingly enough the people who design gas tanks for tanks thought of the possibility the tank might get shot by something.
- VincentEvans 4y agoIt’s ok. They can put it next to the actual explosives.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoUS armor formations are based around a 12 hour resupply cycle. This is why an armored brigade is not just the tanks and such, it's also all the logistics equipment they need to sustain operations. That said, logistics is a strength of the US military, and something that is a severe challenge in Ukraine atm.
- 4y ago