7 ms·
“Downthem” DDoS-for-hire boss gets 2 years in prison
- Rasbora 4y agoShould have taken the plea, speaking from experience lol.
- TimPC 4y agoHow much time did they want for Aaron Schwartz? This guy gets two years for making an entire business leading to thousands of CFAA violations. What a joke.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- frozenport 4y agoHow much was this dude making? With his skills and being based in the USA, he could be getting a six figure salary without the risk?
- rahn_doe 4y agoHonestly, if he's playing the long game, he wants to go inside- there is quite literally no better place on the planet for networking than prison.
- kingcharles 4y agoHaving spent eight years inside, I really don't think it's as good for networking as you imagine. For a start, everyone inside is a criminal that failed, that got caught. There are almost no tech guys locked up, it's 99% drugs, sex crimes, theft, murder, guns; so whatever crime you're planning, it'll have to be something regular. I managed to use the contacts I made to become a drug dealer for a few months when I got out to make some quick cash, but that quickly died out. And anyone from inside that you would really want to hang out with (and there will not be many) will probably be someone who is really trying to go straight and not go deeper down the rabbit hole. Just my 2 pennies. Reality isn't TV.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoAt least he’s guaranteed a Darknet Diaries episode when he is released.
- nyolfen 4y agoif your goal is networking with people who are mostly too stupid to read, you are correct
- duxup 4y agoAt lest from the news I’ve seen some of these guys don’t want those jobs / can’t get them for some reason or another (tech skills aren’t all it takes skill wise to get these jobs) and they seem to really identify with the idea of some sort of online hacker bad guy persona.
- dylan604 4y agowhy would you want to work for evilCorp when you just be evilIndy (bullwhip and hat not included).
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoI’d imagine it’s moderately passive income, a few hours here / there but not full time.
- dvt 4y agoThe guy successfully executed more than 200,000 DDoS attacks; at ~$15 an hour[1][2], he almost certainly made millions. [1] https://securelist.com/the-cost-of-launching-a-ddos-attack/77784/ https://securelist.com/the-cost-of-launching-a-ddos-attack/7... [2] https://www.missioncriticalmagazine.com/articles/93185-the-dark-web-ddos-attacks-sell-for-as-low-as-10-per-hour https://www.missioncriticalmagazine.com/articles/93185-the-d...
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoAnd TFA does not mention any fines. Does he get to keep the money? He used public defenders so legal costs were minimal.
- tptacek 4y agoCriminal convictions are typically accompanied by asset forfeitures. No, you don't generally get to keep the proceeds from crimes you're convicted of.
- carlisle_ 4y agoUnless you work in finance.
- autoexec 4y agoThat's pretty much any "respectable" industry really. The government will usually take their cut, but it'll be far less than the profit a company's illegal actions brought in, and the victims of the activity get shafted instead of being made whole.
- rot13xor 4y agoAnd if you didn't pay taxes on your illegal income the feds get you for tax evasion too, like how they got Al Capone.
- swatcoder 4y agoConsidering that most skilled tech work generally makes plenty to live on, lots of us don’t optimize for maximum salary (or want a “salary” at all). And “risk” isn’t something that gets shown to you in an excel spreadsheet and then rolled on a die when you start a project. It’s something that you assess for yourself, from very little data, and with your own particular risk tolerance. With all that in mind, choosing to work in an unauthorized industry is no different than working in any other industry: startups, fintech, enterprise, whatever. You do it because you like what it represents, or who you work with, or the way it feels, etc; or because you don’t feel like you have other choices for whatever reason.
- pawelmurias 4y agowhen choosing to go the crime route if the risk of getting caught is worth the gains seems like the biggest factor not if the work is cool.
- quickthrower2 4y agoBut then he'd have a boss.
- mvuksano 4y agoI feel like it should be illegal to run misconfigured DNS servers too given they can be used to commit crime. Analogous to drugs - it's crime to produce and sell drugs.
- jen20 4y agoUnder which jurisdiction would the server have to be running in a misconfigured state? What counts as misconfiguration? Would it extend to the advertising pages that consumer ISPs in the US regularly see fit to serve when they should be returning NXDOMAIN?
- walrus01 4y agothere are far worse things out there run by shady grey/black-market hosting companies than misconfigured DNS servers.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoNot really, analogous would be arresting pharmacists who don’t lock their medicine cabinet.
- autoexec 4y agoPublic DNS servers have their place. 8.8.8.8 and 4.2.2.1 are pretty popular. DDoS attacks don't depend on DNS servers either so you can't solve the underlying problem by making them go away either. I always thought it'd be great if the EFF ran a public DNS server. At least you could trust them not to use your requests to build a profile of your online activity or redirect you to ads.
- kbuck 4y ago8.8.8.8 and 4.2.2.1 have strict rate-limits configured that make them uninteresting/unsuitable for reflection attacks. The real issue is misconfigured resolvers exposed to the internet, not intentionally-provided recursive resolvers. If you'd like to have a private DNS server, it's fairly easy to set up your own recursor. (Just please don't expose it to the whole internet.)
- 4y ago
- a13n 4y agoPublish the list of customers - any person or organization purchasing this service is also complicit in a crime, right?
- the_doctah 4y agoHe turned over a bunch of evidence. I'm sure some customers will be going down as well.
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoWhat if a customer used the name of a person they dislike?
- a13n 4y agoThat’s a fair point - I guess they probably don’t have a good list of user/company names.
- ivantop 4y agoAlso, when I was the target of one of these "booters", a lot of them explicitly state they're only to be used for stress testing services you own, which is legal.
- walrus01 4y agoI'd be curious to know where this "ampnode" bulletproof hosting company physically had their servers and stuff colocated. ironically enough, ampnode.com right now appears to be behind cloudflare, I got the 5 second cloudflare javascript/browser fingerprinting loading screen when checking it out. "Dedicated Spoofing Servers Now Available. Unfiltered. Unmanaged. No scanning! No child porn! Buy yours today! Don't forget to inquire within about the bulk order discounts." well that certainly seems totally legit and not suspicious at all https://ampnode.com/servers.html https://ampnode.com/servers.html how is it that the marketing website for this is still up? https://www.justice.gov/usao-cdca/pr/illinois-man-convicted-federal-criminal-charges-operating-subscription-based-computer https://www.justice.gov/usao-cdca/pr/illinois-man-convicted-...
- 0xy 4y ago>how is it that the marketing website for this is still up? Honeypot run by the feds.
- walrus01 4y agoSeems like a less boring than normal job for some mid level FBI/DOJ linux sysadmin types. I wonder what department is responsible for keeping such honeypots running...
- sedatk 4y agoProbably IT :P
- arthurcolle 4y agoIT, Engineering... maybe "R&D" / Special Projects
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoHow did they work child porn into that? Are they saying they don’t host / store it, or don’t ddos child porn servers?
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago“ Despite admitting to FBI agents that he ran these so-called “booter” services (and turning over plenty of incriminating evidence in the process), Gatrel opted to take his case to trial, defended the entire time by public defenders.” What!!!?
- jmckib 4y agoMy first reaction was that he's probably not in his right mind. I mean he also openly ran a DDOS service, which also doesn't seem like a rational act.
- charcircuit 4y agoI don't think he openly ran it. He just got caught.
- chalst 4y agoThe proceedings of the nine-day trial will give lots of coverage of his unique skills. When he comes out of jail, he'll have quite the resume.
- mwint 4y agoReal question: Who would hire him? I'm not really familiar with the job market for felons.
- yardstick 4y agoThere is a job market for felons with skills. Probably not this guy, given what he ran, but others like Kevin Mitnick served 5 years and was successfully afterwards. I’ll fully admit Kevin is the exception to the rule! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kevin_Mitnick https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kevin_Mitnick
- Jistern 4y agoKevin Mitnick is very bright and is a very good salesman.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoI’m very curious about real world ddos. My guess is a large majority is reflective / udp or tcp zombies, with any cast edge sinkholing traffic from known heuristics or via user configured rules. My questions are - are there any organisations that provide good writeups - is there any well accepted guidelines on how to ethically self-test (unsure if service providers would be happy if you kill network hops in the process) - how much real world activity leverages non-bandwidth load, such as cpu/memory consumption?
- matsur 4y agoWe blog regularly about what attacks we see and how we mitigate them. https://blog.cloudflare.com/tag/ddos/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/tag/ddos/
- Rasbora 4y ago
- toast0 4y agoMy information is a little out of date, I left a company that attracted low-effort DDoSing about 3 years ago, but let me try. > My guess is a large majority is reflective / udp or tcp zombies, with any cast edge sinkholing traffic from known heuristics or via user configured rules. I mostly saw UDP reflection (usually chargen (!)), but sometimes WordPress reflection (thanks pingback), and occasionally old-school syn floods. We usually would get attacked on the www servers, and they had 10G (or 2x10G), which was usually enough to just ignore the incoming traffic. For the wordpress stuff, I did add a rule to block the traffic, because they were fetching large files and I don't care about pingbacks, and don't have good feelings for WordPress, so it was catharthic to deny all requests with WordPress in the U-A. Having to wait until after the TLS handshake was unfortunate though. :( Occasionally, something would cause real trouble with availability, but if the incoming traffic was significantly over line rate, our hosting provider would null route that IP, and our DNS would move users to other www servers; occasionally someone would come up with something that would cause issues without high volumes (ip fragments were painful without tuning[1], syn floods could be troublesome if enough volume, although going to syncookies only would mitigate that, and there were big kernel improvements at some point), I had sampled packet captures always running on the www servers, so that it would be easier to investigate than hoping to get in while the servers were having trouble. Letting the www servers fall over was acceptable as well. Somebody has a little fun at our expense, but our real service wasn't on www, so who cares? > - are there any organisations that provide good writeups Yeah, search for "DDoS trends" I see writeups from cloudflare, microsoft, f5, netscout, lumen (aka centurylink/Level3), sans. I'm pretty sure I read a report from Akamai once too. > - is there any well accepted guidelines on how to ethically self-test (unsure if service providers would be happy if you kill network hops in the process) I would get enough casual flooding (usually exactly 90 seconds worth), that I only rarely needed to self-test. But I did a couple self-tests for syn flooding, because the degree of improvement was hard to guess at without tests, and synfloods weren't super common. For that test, I tested from machines that were on the same (private) subnet, and was careful to make sure the attacked machine wouldn't transmit any responses. The point was to try not to impact equipment except the machine under test, and the generating machines. Alternatively, most of the DDoS our actual service faced, was when we messed up something and our real clients came with large numbers of requests. No need for DDoS testing if your real load is huge. :) > - how much real world activity leverages non-bandwidth load, such as cpu/memory consumption? IMHO, you're only going to see that if you're getting individually targeted. It might not be too hard to find something that will consume your cpu/memory, but it's unlikely to be in a DDoS as a service toolkit, or at least not at the casual level. Often, you can turn the tables on these and only do hard work if they've established a session of some sort, and then all of a sudden, they've got to keep sessions and it's a lot more expensive for them. [1] At that point in time, the FreeBSD kernel ip defragmentation was just a linear search through the array of fragments, with the array size limited based on the total ram available. I think there's some hashing now, but the array is probably still considerably larger than it needs to be. We did see a small amount of legitimate looking traffic with ip fragmentation, but it was tens of packets per minute; 16 fragments is more than enough storage for legitimate traffic, although with the hashing, you need a bit more. I'm not even sure the attack traffic was intentionally ip fragmented, but it was.
- yashap 4y ago2 years is less than I’d expect. I remember an 18 year old kid got 1.5 years for creating a variant of the Blaster worm (not even the original), and I don’t think he even profited from it? This guy is a fully grown adult, created an illegal business that performed 200,000 DDOS attacks, likely made millions and caused immense amounts of damage, and … just a 33% longer sentence? Although, maybe “hacking” type convictions are getting lighter over time?
- cafard 4y agoJimmy Breslin wrote that 1 year, or whatever, doesn't look like a lot in the newspaper, but it is quite long for the prisoner doing the time.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kbuck 4y agoSame here. Other people have probably collectively spent vastly more than 2 years' time mitigating and recovering from attacks launched by this guy's service. As a previous victim, I'm still glad to hear there are at least some consequences involved for booter operators.
- samplatt 4y agoIt's usually down to your lawyers and who the judge is on the case. It varies a frightening amount.
- Jistern 4y agoI agree. Justice is often unjust. I find this problem terrifying.
- effingwewt 4y agoI read or heard somewhere that we don't have a justice sysyem, we have a legal sysem, and those are very different things. Made me sad, as it rings very true.
- czbvyRZNsVcpTm2 4y agoA rookie researcher in this area here. We are currently working on how to solve DDoS in a better way (I can't share the details now, but it will eventually be published as a paper). Most previous research has used either a synthetic or an old dataset to verify their proposal. Two famous examples of these are the following datasets: 1. https://www.unb.ca/cic/datasets/ddos-2019.html https://www.unb.ca/cic/datasets/ddos-2019.html 2. https://www.caida.org/catalog/datasets/ddos-20070804_dataset/ https://www.caida.org/catalog/datasets/ddos-20070804_dataset... Aside from those, there are plenty of them available out there. However, I feel that if I am using the synthetic approach, it does not represent real-world traffic. On the old dataset side, it is ancient data. Also, it only contains the attack traffic, as the legitimate traffic has been removed. On the other side of the world, there exist these "DDoS-for-hire" people, who seem to have plenty of army behind them, which I think the cost to hire them is reasonable. This would justify the "newness" and the "real-world"-ness of the data to be used to verify our new proposal. Let's say I hire them to attack myself and capture the traffic on my side. As long as I have a powerful machine, I would be able to save all the attacks into a "real-world" dataset. However, this is problematic from an ethical perspective. Someone between me (as a victim) and the adversaries would also be DDoS-ed to some extent. And also, hiring the DDoS-as-a-service is considered risky for my job [0]. After thinking for some time, the big guys are the best entity owning this kind of data, i.e., Cloudflare, Fastly, etc. Does anyone know whether they share such data? [0] https://portswigger.net/daily-swig/dutch-police-warn-ddos-for-hire-customers-to-desist-or-face-prosecution https://portswigger.net/daily-swig/dutch-police-warn-ddos-fo...