6 ms·
Drone swarms that harassed navy ships demystified in new docs
- ncmncm 4y agoI expected at least an explanation why they didn't routinely shoot (some of) them down. Speculating they have a gentlemens' agreement where China doesn't waste American drones either.
- hugh-avherald 4y agoYou can't just shoot someone else's drone down because it's a bit iffy.
- hericium 4y agoIf it's doing flybys over your naval ship - why not?
- shadowgovt 4y agoMultiple reasons. Number one, you avoid an international incident if you can help it. Number two, and far more importantly, the whole point of these drones is surveillance and intelligence gathering, ostensibly. Why would the Navy respond to their presence by showing the human observers aboard the cargo vessel precisely how we shoot down a drone?
- Victerius 4y ago1. In the State of Nevada, around Area 51, there are signs reading: "Use of deadly force authorized". I'm not aware of anyone who has ever been killed by trespassing into Area 51, but the government has given itself that option and made it public. I don't see why a similar policy couldn't be enacted regarding unauthorized drone flybys of military ships. 2. If the theory that these drones are the work of an adversarial nation state is correct, then shooting down the drones would not provoke an ostensible reaction from said government. China (or whoever is behind them) telling the world that the US "illegally" destroyed their drones would blow the cover on these mysterious drone incidents and legitimize the destruction of every other drone observed displaying the same behavior in the future. 3. Other countries, and you know which countries I'm talking about (China, Russia, Iran, North Korea) have no qualms about provoking international incidents. Shooting down suspicious drones near US waters would be returning the favor. Iran destroyed a US Navy drone in the Persian Gulf a few years ago. "People sleep soundly at night because rough men stand ready to visit violence on those who would do us harm."
- julius_deane 4y agothese ships were not in nevada
- renewiltord 4y agoUS government will tax you in Nevada. Haven't yet seen them tax you on the high seas. Actually, why doesn't the US Government just put up "No Entry" signs in Xinjiang? Could probably prevent oppression.
- astrange 4y agoUS income tax applies to your income worldwide as long as you're a citizen. There's tax equalization treaties with some other countries, but not on the sea.
- renewiltord 4y agoThey should just pass a law to tax everyone on the sea. Imagine how much money they could make. Just like foreigners in Nevada have to pay tax.
- jltsiren 4y agoWhat happens in Nevada is a domestic matter. Other countries don't care about it, and the US government can plausibly claim it has a legal basis for its actions. There are no such things as "unauthorized" flybys in international waters. There are no laws or international customs against approaching foreign warships, as long as that does not endanger the ship. How the warship chooses to respond is a matter of foreign policy and best left to civilians. Escalation often leads to further escalation. There is a similar situation in the South China Sea, where China claims sovereignty over some areas. The US disagrees and frequently patrols the area. If the US shoots down a Chinese drone in international waters, China may consider that shooting at an American plane or a warship there would be a proportional response. That could turn very bad very quickly. Unless the US deliberately wants to escalate, it may be a better policy to ignore Chinese provocations with drones.
- hericium 4y agoI don't know naval law but I'm trying to apply your first point to a drone flying over a restricted airspace like an embassy. It's not you starting an incident when you shoot the drone down. You can choose not to respond to the provocation of course, but I'd imagine you'd want the drone down for security reasons. It can potentially carry a warhead or biological weapon. You don't need to use your best know-how to shoot the drone down. Good occasion to practice less-preferred methods.
- vanattab 4y agoI am pretty sure the Chinese embassy shooting down a usa drone in USA territory or elsewhere (or vis versa) would constitute an international incident.
- extr 4y agoShooting down a circling UAV with a missile, sure. But the equivalent here is sending a micro drone to go hover outside the windows. I think most people would agree that's pretty brazen provocation, a shotgun is a totally proportional response.
- rightbyte 4y agoCall the local police and let them catch it or use some peaceful fishing net? Can't have people fireing at the sky in cities ...
- shadowgovt 4y agoThere's precedent in some sections of the United States that down in a drone with a shotgun is legal. But it is not national president, and as far as I'm aware it hasn't been tried in a densely populated area. I completely agree that in general, discharging a firearm in an urban environment would probably constitute far more risk than the drone.
- 13of40 4y agoMaybe I'm reading this wrong, but it sounds like according to the FAA flying a drone over a Navy ship is only restricted if you're below 1000 feet: https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-establishes-restrictions-drone-operations-near-us-navy-vessels https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-establishes-restrictions-dr...
- markdown 4y agoA ship at sea, naval or otherwise, is traveling in the commons and we are all legally allowed to look at it and record what we see.
- ncmncm 4y agoHovering above is not the same as just looking.
- markdown 4y agoWhy can't I hover above a ship while staring at it and recording what I see?
- MonkeyClub 4y agoHover over two times, drop a bomb the third. Though in this case, it's not hovering over, it's politely observing from a distance (8,000 yards?)
- gorgoiler 4y agoWhat’s the difference between a drone and a guided missile? Is it because the drone can be shot down easily that we know it couldn’t possibly be threatening us? That’s fine until a drone drops 50g of suspicious powder across the deck.
- markdown 4y agoSeriously? A missile is a weapon. Should I, paddling by in my kayak, be torpedoed by the Navy because I could be concealing a weapon?
- gorgoiler 4y agoThe stakes are completely different for manned vehicles vs a DJI parrot loaded with anthrax. The cost to you — a hypothetical attacker — is now “your life” instead of “$5000”, and the cost to the defending vessel is now “we killed someone :(“ instead of “sorry about your drone no we aren’t replacing it now piss off”. I suspect if you looked like a Google image search for “fundamentalist suicide bomber”, you might find yourself being asked some anxious questions / shot at.
- dfhfhdfhshsdf 4y agoa flyby 8000 yards away
- softcactus 4y agoThe report says that the ships were not equipped with C-UAS systems.
- ncmncm 4y agoThey almost certainly have shotguns on board.
- ehnto 4y agoI think that's going to depend on distance and safety. Process and politics play a role too. I don't know if it's established if that would be considered an attack or not. Safe to say a bit of observation and caution was going on.
- cobertos 4y agoSome of the interactions were 3000+ yards away
- ncmncm 4y agoAnd some were immediately overhead. Shooting a few of those down would encourage staying further off.
- mc32 4y agoSo basically drone surveillance by foreign powers monitoring our exercises as those exercises expose our fighting mode of operation.
- Victerius 4y agoI'm almost certain that this is the work of China. If that is true, China is sending intelligence operatives aboard innocent looking cargo ships and fishing boats, across the Pacific Ocean all the way to the West Coast. They deploy drone swarms to observe Navy ships, evaluate crew responses, and collect electronic intelligence about the ships' sensors.
- shadowgovt 4y agoHonestly, it may not even be that elaborate. China intelligence could just be putting bounties out for information on American Navy worship operations and leaving it up to the cargo captains to buy their own drones and get creative about using them. And from China's point of view, this is almost certainly tit for tat. As far as they're concerned, the US has allowed one of its private corporations to deploy a space surveillance network. Using drones to observe individual Navy vessels is small potatoes relative to what China assumes the American intelligence edifice can gather from Starlink.
- boardwaalk 4y agoI wonder if we'll learn someday the NSO or some other TLA has actually bought some mass/volume/electric load/network access on each Starlink. It's such an obvious thing to do and it'd be so easy to hide. And then you have the v2 Starlink coming which are much more massive (nearly 4x) than v1.
- donthellbanme 4y ago
- dylan604 4y agoMaybe you're too young to know about how the Russians used fishing trawlers as spy platforms: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=russian+fishing+trawler+spying+on+navy&t=h_&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=russian+fishing+trawler+spying+on+...
- hackernewds 4y ago
- z9znz 4y agoThis will be an ever increasing scenario. I'm surprised that we are not putting priority into developing technologies to disrupt drone systems. And if there is some kind of non-aggression agreement, then some amount of subtlety and plausible deniability must be developed in addition to the direct disruption tools. It cannot be too hard to blind a device with RF or light or sound.
- maxerickson 4y agoHow is the DRAKE system mentioned several times in the article not a technology to disrupt drone systems? It's literally an RF jammer!
- dylan604 4y agoOne needs to read the article to know this though.
- rkagerer 4y agoSo useless against an autonomous drone?
- imtringued 4y agoYou mean military grade drones that cost tens of thousands of dollars?
- FastEatSlow 4y agoMany hobbyist drones are flying Linux computers [1], so it's not a stretch that an autonomous drone could be constructed. [1] https://youtu.be/5CzURm7OpAA https://youtu.be/5CzURm7OpAA
- ripper1138 4y agoThere is heavy investment into anti-drone weapons and defense systems. Directed energy weapons in particular are quite effective against small drones.
- aaron695 4y ago
- Animats 4y agoThe ones off the coast of California seem to be people just flying drones around. If they're showing a red light, a green light, and a white light, they're not hiding. The Navy doesn't seem to be too bothered by ones that obey the Rules of the Road. For one of the ones that didn't, they spotted an "unidentified pleasure craft" nearby with unregistered marine radio MMSI ID 003669184. They were warned off. The slides don't state if the unidentified pleasure craft was later identified, but it probably was.
- stevenhuang 4y agoReads like disclosure of UAP phenomena. > Domestically, drone swarms have been an issue for nuclear reactor facilities and critical industrial infrastructure. A lot of these reports were during the cold war. We didn't have drone tech at the time. This phenomena is known within UFO community as instances of alien's snooping around our nuclear capabilities.
- kfrzcode 4y agoOccasionally I'd laugh and move on but Occam's Razor would shave this down to... we had the tech and kept it quiet
- stevenhuang 4y agoI was a skeptic as well initially but when you really look into it, the details are suggestive of something bizarre. https://youtu.be/l4EXL7jgqns https://youtu.be/l4EXL7jgqns
- kfrzcode 4y agoOkay to be honest I was steelmanning because I totally buy it. There's too much folklore. I don't know what it's called in academic journals but there's a certain 'purse' and 'pinecone' [or hops] that seems to be omnipresent in all ancient civilizations that have left art for us.. the Annunaki Purse, maybe? Graham Hancock speaks of it. More realistically the incredible stories from Bob Lazar and Co. Is compelling to say the very least.
- dirtyid 4y ago> In congressional testimony, defense officials explained that "the triangular appearance is a result of light passing through the night vision goggles, and then being recorded by an SLR camera." Can someone explain physics behind this? Drones are apparently quad copter shape?