8 ms·
Ask HN: Is brogrammer a sexist term?
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3167412
First term I've heard this term is in a YC funded company recruitment post. I know I'm directly referring to a YC company's recruit post here, but someone did not switch their brain on when they posted that one.
Stating that you should be a fan of 'brogramming' to get a job comes across as blatant sexism to me. Especially given the pages that promote it at the moment.
Seriously, you're a company now, not a frat club. I'm not trying to spoil your fun, I'm sure that's your culture, but you just can't advertise for men only roles in this day and age.
I don't know the law in the US but over here in the UK these guys would be opening themselves up for a nasty lawsuit.
- ia 15y agomaybe they are going for cultural fit, first and foremost. if you were offended by this job advert, it's likely you wouldn't be a good fit. why hide company culture by writing a stiff and sterile ad? i'm not saying what they did was good or bad, unless they are actually breaking laws in the post--then it's bad. other than that, if you don't like the way they phrased things, don't apply.
- mattmanser 15y agoThe reason there's a law against it is because bigots that still exist keep women from attaining equality and that's bad, not the other way around. It is in itself bad. You have a strange moral compass to me. I know it's fun to be laddish when you're at college and uni, but cultural fit can often be a polite way of saying 'Hey, I'm a bigot, women are stupid and I'm not employing them above the level of secretary!'. I'm sure cultural fit was used because some racist thought someone with a different coloured skin wouldn't fit in the office. I don't like the way they phrased it because it was very easy to read that advert as advertising specifically for male programmers only. In other words, they're in danger of coming across as bigots. And by association, so are we. So I said something as it made me uncomfortable.
- ia 15y agoCan you explain your first sentence? I'm not sure what you're trying to say. I'm not defending bigotry/sexism/etc. Hopefully, you didn't take my comment that way.
- mikeryan 15y agoI'm not defending bigotry/sexism/etc You're defending the ad. By extension defending any sexism contained within it (actual sexism TBD).
- chernevik 15y agoI'm pretty sure that when I defend the right of, say, OWS to protest, I'm not defending whatever it is they're protesting. They went for a breezy tone and forgot to pass it through Legal. I doubt they're sexists. I'm sure sexism would, in this day and age, hurt them more than anyone else.
- chc 15y agoThat's not really the case in the software industry. There really are very few women in the field. That's why we need to call out stuff like this — so that female programmers' lack of visibility doesn't become an excuse to marginalize them. I don't think it was intentional on the job poster's part, but the fact that he didn't catch how it sounded of proofreading definitely indicates a blind spot to sexism.
- thomaslangston 15y agoYour conclusion does not follow from the premise. You can defend something based on one merit, while not supporting a related detriment.
- jessedhillon 15y agoYour original comment was to the effect of 'things are bad if they are illegal, but otherwise they're not.' He's calling you out on your sense of morality because whether a thing is right or wrong does not, to most people, derive from it's legal status. Stealing would still be wrong if it were legally acceptable, which some forms arguably are.
- davidhansen 15y agoThis is not a political site so I'm not going to debate the merits/drawbacks of outlawing bigotry in hiring practices. But one thing that ought to be pointed out is that free markets tend to punish companies, over the long term, that intentionally deny themselves access to talent due to bigotry. Conversely, companies who acquire talent with rational screening procedures will have a competitive advantage over those who use irrational screening procedures. It's a sort of corporate karma. In aggregate, bigotry in hiring procedures will eventually harm you, legal or not.
- hack_edu 15y agoThe notion that the long term will harm them is a bit out of scope. Being a startup, a YC one at that, you can assume they see no significant long term for the company anyway, and hope for an acquisition before their idealized startup culture dream is popped.
- jessedhillon 15y agoEvidence? I know free market theory sounds like the most plainly obvious, common sense set of statements but you still have to justify your conclusions. You are asserting without proof that the market is full of completely rational agents.
- davidhansen 15y agoI am not asserting that the market is full of completely rational agents. I am asserting that voluntarily excluding yourself from a resource pool or limiting your access to a resource pool will decrease your likelihood of success. To give an analogy, if you have access to all the food you want, but you voluntarily limit yourself to kumquats and bananas for arbitrary, irrational reasons, in the long run you will develop health problems. Likewise, a business that irrationally limits itself to a subset of all available talent will, in aggregate, lose out to those who are not thus limited. I admit to not having citations of statistical evidence at hand, although I have seen many publications in the past that indicate diversity of employee populations is correlated with innovation and success. I did not provide evidence because I believe as a Gedankenexperiment, the conclusion is self-evident.
- throwawayday 15y agothe reason there's a law against it is because men (yes, men!) were stupid enough to allow women to vote in the first place. and now we have a feminine culture takeover: used to be only sticks and stones would hurt me, now it's words that slay me. Get over the obsession already, this is tiresome! Everyone starts out equal, no one person is inherently better than another - but some people perform more valuable services than others. Men and women are different, hence the chromosomal difference. If these guys want an exclusionary company, let them have it! But you don't have to buy their goods/services. Birds of a feather flock together - people are almost always going to associate with people they feel more comfortable will - and each individual will decide which character trait they most like to identify with, and will seek out people with like traits. </rant>
- CodeMage 15y agoHey, that's great logic. Remind me to start a company where we have a dedicated "porn-watching hour", too. I'm sure it will make for a spectacular ad and attract a lot of serious talent.
- ia 15y agoIf that's the type of person you're looking to hire (say, for a porn site...), not sure why you wouldn't do this. Assuming, again, that you aren't breaking any laws. Not sure what point you were trying to make. Sarcasm doesn't translate well in writing...
- CodeMage 15y agoI daresay it translated well enough for a couple of people already. The point I was trying to make is that the goal of a job ad is to attract talent. The job ad in question fails at that goal, because the cultural implications will drive away talent. To be fair, it's not a job ad that fails here, it's the culture that came up with that job ad. All in all, you might be right in that they might have put "cultural fit" as their #1 priority, but that doesn't make it a good decision. Saying that the alternative is "a stiff and sterile ad" is a fallacy of false dichotomy.
- ia 15y agoSaying that the alternative is "a stiff and sterile ad" is a fallacy of false dichotomy. fair enough. to clarify--"a stiff and sterile ad" is the only type of add that won't alienate any possible subgroup. the goal of a job ad is not simply to "attract talent". it's to attract the right kind of talent. to that end, a job ad that emphasizes culture is one way to look for it. these guys made a choice, and it looks like their (imo) poorly-worded job ad isn't being well received by the majority of people on hn. but unless we know that no suitable candidates resulted from it, i don't think we can claim it a failure. To be fair, it's not a job ad that fails here, it's the culture that came up with that job ad. agree, in the sense that if people react adversely to this job ad, they would have a similar reaction to the company culture.
- rprime 15y agoExactly my thoughts, I really like that they actually exposed their cultural thoughts on this one, I hope to see this kind of trend in job postins more and it really makes me want to join that respective company. On the other hand I don't understand, why, most of you, as males are really getting mad about this? Why do you feel offended? If you have a female programmer friend, ask her about this and make her post their opinions, not you. I'll bet my life savings that all females that are into tech (that I know) will not have the slightest problem with this. Stop whining about this kind of stuff HN, you're better than this.
- mzbridget 15y agoWe do have a problem with this. We aren't whining. I asked some male friends about this just now and they think its shameful. It basically reads: "We are looking for male programmers, females need not reply." Yeah, just stick us back into the secretarial pool.
- rprime 15y agoWell, see, here's the difference, it counts how you see the glass, full or empty. From my point of view, and I assume theirs, that's simply a joke that most of you got serious. I was just asking for a female programmer to tell that she's having a problem with this, not a dude. Probably I haven't exposed my ideas in a correct and coherent way, but I am tired and english is not my main. But trust me, I know a lot of women that are programmers, at some I look up to, and those who aren't I try to help them integrate, we need really need female programmers, because we, as males, can never achieve their way of thinking.
- liedra 15y agoI'm a female programmer and I have a problem with this.
- sethbannon 15y agoTo say that males shouldn't call out things they see as sexism against women because they aren't women is dangerous thinking. We're all members of this community, and behavior that disrespects any of us is a problem for all of us.
- strlen 15y ago> if you were offended by this job advert, it's likely you wouldn't be a good fit So a company decides that most female engineers wouldn't be a good fit? It's fairly obvious that using it in a job ad (as opposed to using it in a self-deprecating way to joke about yourself: how the term started) has the effect of alienating female developers.
- yaix 15y agoNot if they'd also look for a Sisadmin.
- jgrahamc 15y agoPerhaps, but more than that it's bloody stupid.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- nasmorn 15y agoIndeed it would certainly make me not want to apply to the position. In my experience it is hard enough to maintain adequate professionalism in the 20 something caffeine crazed all nighter atmosphere of a startup. If it can't show a modicum of it in its official communication, I can already see the scenes in the office. Also: I would try to hire flowgrammers because you know they are always in the zone. EDIT: Make that flogrammers
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pyre 15y agoDoes that mean that adverts for non-developers will be pitching for 'nogrammers'?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- loire280 15y agoLooks like a heavy-handed attempt to maintain their culture - as uncouth as it may be.
- jorsh 15y agoI was going to post this myself. Thanks for beating me to it.
- phatbyte 15y agoI really think this is a douche term to be honest. What's next, "coder's shore ?"
- Permit 15y agoHahaha you will appreciate this. http://www.businessinsider.com/craigslist-has-a-casting-call-for-a-show-that-sounds-like-jersey-shore-silicon-valley-2011-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/craigslist-has-a-casting-call...
- michh 15y agoYes it is. Sounds like it's not the kind of company I'd like to work for, so I guess in a way it's useful that they use that term.
- wisty 15y agoIt also seems ageist. It sounds like it would exclude anyone more mature than Justin Bieber.
- jgrahamc 15y agoIt's actually "anything but just like us-ist", and with the rest of the ad saying they won't accept someone who uses Windows, and starting with "PG loves us" and continuing "We like to party. We are laser focused on work, but expect to get crunk at least once a month" I'd steer clear. They did one thing right though: they decided to be in stealth mode so we don't know who those fools are.
- felideon 15y agoI would, too [edit: stay clear]. We may be overreacting to what may have been a bad joke but the part regarding partying and "getting crunk" really pushed me into taking the post at face value.
- bvi 15y agoI've noticed a trend in posts like this. Some startups go out of their way to appear "cool". If you need silly phrases like "getting crunk" when you're looking to recruit someone...that's a red flag to me.
- achiral 15y agoYes. Always steer clear of any environment where one is expected to form close social bonds with others in a party situation. The best coworker is the one you communicate with via text, right?
- davidw 15y agoThe thing is, it's a professional relationship, not a friendship. If they need to fire you, they will. Sure, a friendship can form, but... I would say that true friendships are ones that have already weathered various changes of employer.
- 15y ago
- klapinat0r 15y agoTo answer your question, no, brogrammer isn't even a term.
- ordinary 15y agoIs it sexist to refer to a male programmer as "brogrammer"? No. Is it sexist to state you're only interested in hiring male programmers? Yes.
- Dylan16807 15y agoDoes "brogrammer" mean male programmer? No.
- davedx 15y agoHow can you be a 'bro' and not be male??
- jeffool 15y ago"Bro" has become a word used like "hey guys" in mixed company, or "dude", applied equally to men and women. It's cultural, and like many cultural things, is popularized from chan sites. Starting as mocking the fratguy and Jersey stereotypes, it's now a cultural mockery of itself, like hipsters who hate hipsters. My brother and cousins are increasingly "brotastic", with tough talk, and repeated high fives (followed by finger pistols). And they didn't even get it from the aforementioned chans; it grows naturally. As scary as that may be to the rest of us. So, if the term sexist? That's two questions: 1. Is it intended to offend or drive away women? Probably not. 2. Is it offensive to women despite intent? Not for me to answer, as a man. But this is the more important question. (Sorry, lots of editing. I realized I had a lot more to say. But if they wanted to go for this style, they could've just as easily made the first line say something like "looking for awesome dudes and lady-dudes with awesome skills and awesome personalities to join our awesome startup!" Or something as cheesy to ensure inclusion.)
- roguecoder 15y agoCalling everyone "you guys" is offensive; it suggests that being a dude is normal and everything else is deviations we can just ignore. I will believe that "dude" is gender-neutral when I can call the guys I work with "ladies" and have it be considered gender-neutral. 1) Yes, even if implicitly. It says "I expect people to conform to masculine norms; everyone else need not apply." Whether or not they specifically set out to exclude women, they did set out to exclude everyone who wasn't willing to tolerate their sexist and exclusionary behavior, who will statistically be more female than male (though plenty of men are excluded too.) 2) Yes it is. Plus, as men stated up stream, it is directly offensive to some men too, and it should be offensive to anyone who doesn't want to work in a field populated by sexist assholes.
- cfontes 15y agoWhat does brogramming mean ? I'm from brazil and this word doesn't make sense to me...
- Maro 15y agoBro is slang for brother, which in this context is supposed to mean (male) buddies. I guess "brogramming" is supposed to mean "programming with buddies". These super-duper-cool-stealth-YC-startup job listings are becoming more idiotic every month.
- dewhiskeys 15y agoAt first i thought it was a spelling error... I think it's something like bro-grammer: brother (so male) programmer. Anyway, is it sexist? At least in Italy you can't do that. But.. are there people who really like male only working environments?
- cfontes 15y agoDon't think anybody does so it would be really stupid to ask for an environment like that and boring also...
- hdctambien 15y agohttp://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=brogrammer http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=brogrammer I guess it means: "You write code, but you're not one of those nerds" Also see: http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=bro http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=bro (definition #1) for what the "bro" part stands for. It's not technically "brother". When I was in college the term was a little more harsh: "douche" http://peoplewtf.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/DOUCHE-4.jpg http://peoplewtf.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/DOUCHE-4.jpg It seems they have better PR now.
- genieyclo 15y agoOther commenters are close, but I think it's referring more to the bro from lax culture. Lots of chilling, popping natties with fellow brahs/bros and other stuff you can read up on http://mylifeisbro.com http://mylifeisbro.com edit: hdctambien's comment is on-point with the urbandic link. I believe a similar synonym with less euphemistic connotations is douchebag in certain circles, but not amongst brahs. also see http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi_AAqi0RZM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi_AAqi0RZM and this: http://www.quora.com/Brogramming/How-does-a-programmer-become-a-brogrammer http://www.quora.com/Brogramming/How-does-a-programmer-becom...
- mrspeaker 15y agoI think you could argue that "brogrammer" is gender neutral. I also think that anyone advertising for a "brogrammer", ironically or not, are probably not going to have or attract software engineers who you could learn from.
- bbrizzi 15y agoI agree that the post's title is not very tactful or professional but I don't think it's sexist. The term "bro" refers to values like fraternity and solidarity. Even the word fraternity comes from the latin frater which means brother but "fraternity" is not a male-only concept. I myself consider some girls to be my "bros" even though I wouldn't use that term, but I agree in the values it conveys. Additionally, if a girl applied for that job in particular I don't think she would be turned down because of her sex (at least I hope so).
- felideon 15y agoPlease google the term "brogrammer". You are defending the post (or playing devil's advocate) by implying a meaning that is not really the currently held inferred meaning. (As far as I'm aware.)
- Dylan16807 15y agoExplain. I can't find any definition of "brogrammer" that isn't a portmanteau of "bro" and "programmer". And "bro" is not a gender-specific term any more than "milkman".
- mikeryan 15y agoSeriously? The third google result for "brogrammer" is this: http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=brogrammer http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=brogrammer
- Dylan16807 15y ago1. Programmer who...frat boy...calling everybody "bro" 2. A programmer who looks like, acts like, or is a bro. 3. A popular, cool, or otherwise normal person who has become intrigued by the fun of programming. 4. a bro who somehow learned to program All of these seem to agree with what I said about it being bro + programmer and not itself about gender.
- cawhitworth 15y agoThat's not a real job ad, is it? Sheesh.
- arctangent 15y agoI think you might be missing the reference to a recent (funny) video about "brogramming": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi_AAqi0RZM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi_AAqi0RZM
- jgrahamc 15y agoPerhaps, but when I Googled "brogrammer" I quickly came across an @brogrammer Twitter feed where the latest tweet reads: "Just tried to jerk it to #siri. She couldn't get me off. #turing_test_fail or dyke?" https://twitter.com/#!/brogramming/status/129638489905053697 https://twitter.com/#!/brogramming/status/129638489905053697
- Game_Ender 15y agoI think that fits the stereotype being portrayed pretty well. "Bros" aren't PC, but then neither is a lot of good humor. The twitter feed and the job add are just jokes.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoI feel dirty just having had to upmod this. I've just learned an important author safety tip: Google the neologisms!
- yaix 15y ago#turing_test_fail was actually kinda funny. I think people take themselves way too serious sometimes. Relax, there is really more important things in the world than getting upset about "brogrammers" or guys making silly jokes about Siri.
- cafard 15y agoJuvenile, yes. Sexist, not very seriously.
- ryanmarsh 15y agoMaybe, who gives a fuck?
- mattmanser 15y agoThis is my way of flagging an unflaggable post. Hell, I love memes, Reddit, drinking, partying, etc. But is that a professional or appropriate job advert for HN? Do we want to be a community which actively cultivates a 'no girls allowed' policy?
- natrius 15y ago"Do we want to be a community which actively cultivates a 'no girls allowed' policy?" That's not fair. An unwise attempt at humor isn't actively cultivating such a policy. It may be inadvertently fostering such an environment, but so many comments are busy casting aspersions on the job poster without addressing that issue.
- mzbridget 15y agoThe subtle comments DO cultivate such a policy. Sexism in its worst form isn't overt - it is the small comments that are harmful.
- banane 15y agoHumor sometimes conveys the real meaning- and in this job post, it is undeniably, No Girls Allowed. Those that think "brogrammer" means anything more deep or nuanced is giving the poster a whole lot of leeway. If they wanted a more diverse (age, sex, even race) they'd convey a different culture. This is one of those things in the Valley that I really hate (I'm a ho-grammer). The immature attitude - up there with "rockstar" postings. Is there anything in the ad about the tech? Oh right, because it's "stealth" (another annoying Valley thing). I am also wary of a company that feels the need to state that programmers get some sleep. Really? The reality is that they're going to get tons of applicants because it's a recession. The applicants are going to be eager and inexperienced, probably not from here. The poster didn't evenhave to use brogrammer to get 95% men applying- that's roughly the % of men in the CA-Bay Area industry. The new hires are going to work for a bit, the start-up will fizzle to nothing, but in the meantime the brogrammer will learn how to party in SF, go to strip clubs, get crunk, work hungover, and write passable code. He'd doubtless leave with a few great connections, and then starting or join another startup, where he'll fondly remember the ad that got him here and post a similar one. A kid just out of a midwestern school will see it and buy a cheap one-way ticket to SF. Like begets like (another thing that annoys me about SV). The monoculture continues.
- cjoh 15y agoYes.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- shareme 15y agoif you have to ask, its obviously yes...WTF YCombinator quality falling very fast after free money given out
- mikeryan 15y agoI'm not sure you can make that assumption. Relative immaturity in YC company job postings (particularly on HN) has been a pretty consistent problem (I'm not saying all just enough bad apples slip through that its noticeable). I'm actually a bit surprised at this point that part of the YC program doesn't address this.
- natrius 15y ago"if you have to ask, its obviously yes..." That is poor logic.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- apricot13 15y agoI had the exact same thought when I saw this post! Although I don't personally find it offensive, you need to be fairly thick skinned in the IT industry if your a woman! That ad certainly tells me that's not the sort of company any woman should be working for. I agree with mattmanser, if that was a UK job add they would be in serious trouble!
- mdasen 15y agoRather than focusing on whether it's sexist or not, I would start by saying that it is unwise. I think that we (as a society) want young people to see all avenues as open to them regardless of gender. I highly doubt that the company doesn't want to hire women or has any sexist intention. However, it is unwise for us (as individuals and an industry) to use terms like "brogrammer" because it subtly suggests gender. One might not mean it as gendered, but certainly some young people will and will internalize it as meaning that "programming is really a guy's thing". This is compounded by the fact that programming is a field where women aren't well represented. I'm not suggesting quotas or anything like that. I'm simply suggesting that when people are thinking about their future, perceptions about industries affect their decisions and terms like "brogrammer" can create perceptions. The same could be said if a library position were to use female-gendered terminology. Library science is a field that is predominantly women and using female-gendered language can only help to reenforce that perception. We don't want to force males into library science, but we also don't want young males to feel like they shouldn't go into it "because it's women's work". When someone says that something is "sexist", I think a lot of people become defensive because they aren't sexists. I doubt that the person who wrote the post is sexist. However, a person who believes in equality can say something that negatively impacts that goal in our society. I don't know if it should be called sexist, but I do think that it negatively affects what we generally want in our world and our companies. Maybe not a lot, but it's something to think about when writing things in the future.
- davedx 15y agoIt's the second wave of the Ruby on Rails "rockstar development" thing that more or less died a death a few years back. Very sad.
- sitkack 15y agoBut if the company is full of Raging Brogrammers, it is good to call it out from the beginning. Same problem as over hiring programmers (getting compiler hackers when you are working on a CRUD app).
- ia 15y ago
- jwingy 15y agoIF brogrammer wasn't sexist (which is highly debatable), I wouldn't go so far as to call these guys juvenile and idiotic. Sometimes you just need to have a little fun with it and lighten up a bit. You only get one life to live so might as well not be so serious all the time. That being said, brogrammer probably is a bit sexist.
- adestefan 15y agoI agree that everyone needs time to unwind and I'll be the first in line for a drink or to hear an off-color joke, but a job ad isn't the place.
- jonhendry 15y agoI note they aren't looking for a broffice manager.
- danellis 15y agoThat's because it's already an Office MANager.
- a-priori 15y ago'Manage' comes from the Latin manus for 'hand' Edit to add: 'Man' either started in Old English as man or mon, or came from Old High German man. In either case it meant 'human being'. It seems to have become male-only more recently. Source: Marriam-Webster.
- RobSpectre 15y agoBrogramming is just a joke. And like all Internet jokes, they end up misused in job postings as a result of the author's effort to appear relevant. I think this YC-funded startup is likely more guilty of tone-deafness rather than misogyny.
- drivingmenuts 15y agoI almost stopped reading the ad at "we like to party". I did stop reading at "get crunk". Serious, that's how they're blowing their startup money?
- Sapient 15y agoYep, crunk was where I stopped as well. Nothing else in the ad really offended my delicate sensibilities until that.
- caseysoftware 15y agoAgreed. I always took the term as mocking the mindset/appearance than anything else. And these YC guys... they're just knuckleheads using the latest buzzwords. The "web scale" meme may fit them too.
- jsavimbi 15y agoBy all means, flaunt your inexperience by using idiot language in your recruitment posts.
- cdanzig 15y agothis is why I always use "looking for brogrammer or hogrammer" in my job ads
- goo 15y agoI'm now making that facebook group - 'Hogramming'
- corywilkerson 15y agoI can't believe we're having this conversation.
- twerth 15y agoSexist? maybe, insensitive? probably, immature and cliche? absolutely.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bzajac 15y agoCross Reference to a post yesterday: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3162917 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3162917 The title: "Female FOSS dev quits tech industry due to harassment" and the comments delved into the same issue here.
- DanBC 15y agoThe job ad is awful. Maybe they do not mean to be discriminatory; but that doesn't matter. Any woman applying for, but not getting, the job can then point to the ad and ask if she was discriminated against because of her sex. The hassle of dealing with that will sap time and resources from actual work. > You are a native english speaker (our tech relies on speech recognition) This sentence is also unwise in the UK.
- dgabriel 15y agoWoman programmer here: I automatically assumed they were looking for college aged men. "Brogrammer," is not a unisex term, no matter how they try to spin it.
- rezrovs 15y agoAnother woman programmer here: I'm glad I'm not the only one who assumed this.
- ajross 15y ago(Not a woman programmer here) The sad thing is that despite the clear evidence ("real women programmers read it as a gendered term") we'll no doubt see a ton of posts on this thread arguing that it's clearly not a problem. That said, I'm reasonably sure that it's not intentionally exclusionary. The poster had an image in their head of a work environment and came up with "brogrammer" as a catchy way to describe it. That this picture didn't include women is a huge problem, obviously, but I suspect it's probably not willful sexism.
- JackDanger 15y agoI agree that the poster may not have intended to exclude women, but when they imagined that work environment in their head I'll bet they weren't imagining it full of women writing code.
- chc 15y agoIn fairness, if you're starting a software company and you imagine a room full of women, you're either wholly ignorant of the demographics of the industry or you're planning to discriminate like crazy against men.
- pingswept 15y agoInterestingly, as an old male programmer, I also assumed that "brogrammer" does not include me. (Maybe it does, if I wear baggy pants or something.)
- hack_edu 15y agoIf you asked me to define 'brogrammer' prior to reading this thread and learning of the meme, I'd probably have described your typical technical cofounder of a generic 2011 startup. It doesn't help that the linked post _is_ a YC startup too... and they're one of those "startups for startups!"
- jdminhbg 15y agoThere is kind of a weird irony gap going on here -- to me it seems unremarkably obvious that all of the over-the-top language in the posting is tongue-in-cheek. Do people think they actually plan to "get crunk"? Programmers are stereotypically un-hip; the whole "brogrammer" meme is a deliberate poke at the incongruity of someone hunched over their keyboard 14 hours a day, yet drinking Natty Lights while wearing popped collars. It is kind of hard for me to believe that so many posters here believe that their office culture literally resembles the Jersey Shore house. That said, the instant gender reaction the word "brogrammer" provokes means it's kind of a terrible choice for a job ad. Whether they meant it to exclude women or not (I would put millions of dollars on a bet on the latter), I wouldn't want to be defending it to the finely-tuned ironists on the EEOC.
- atomical 15y agoGetting crunk "at least once a month" isn't all that hip or crunk.
- MostAwesomeDude 15y ago"Crunk" literally means being intoxicated from both marijuana and alcohol simultaneously. There's no way this posting was serious about the amount of partying. If one reads carefully, the ad does claim that non-bros are welcome to apply, but I doubt that anybody else has read that far.
- wallawe 15y ago...and a little bit of that "sean parker" if you know what i mean
- jontas 15y agoI don't know where you got your "literal" definition but that is certainly not the colloquial definition where I come from. It just means general inebriation without implying any particular substances (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=get+crunk http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=get+crunk). Also, if you read the post it says "at least once a month". Personally I don't really consider that an excessive amount of partying but I guess everyone has their own thresholds.
- aphyr 15y agoI feel it's worth mentioning that words aren't sexist; communication is. Even really awful words (n.+, for example) can be used both in hurtful and supportive ways. One can't always evaluate the meaning of a word in isolation; the contextual relationship between the writer and reader colors the emotional impact of that use.
- overshard 15y agoI really don't care, and I know female programmers who don't care, and I'm actually annoyed that this question is being asked.
- drivingmenuts 15y agoHow wonderful to be you and them. Some people very obviously do care, bro.
- runjake 15y agoPerhaps it's not so much a sexist term as it is a useful warning sign.
- molecule 15y agosexist? yes. valid EEOC complaint? yes. http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/qanda.html http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/qanda.html
- tmh88j 15y agoWhile I do agree that it was not professional nor would I have posted it, I feel like many of you guys are taking it personally. I was involved in greek life during my undergrad and we used to joke around about the "bro" lifestyle because we were all far from it, yet outsiders associated us with it simply because we were in a fraternity. That's what made it so funny to us; while other "frat bro's" would be out partying at 1am on a Friday, all of the engineers and CS guys in my fraternity would be in a computer lab.
- watchthevideo 15y agomy respect has gone down for all of you who take any of this seriously.
- ckolderup 15y agoIt's not about whether or not it was serious, it's about the repetition and legitimization of things that are being taken seriously by plenty of people and are a legitimate problem for the people who are disadvantaged as a result.
- dspeyer 15y agoAfter some research, I can't tell if brogramming is a parody or not. It could be that the startup figures it is, and wants people who can laugh at things like that. If so, still poor communication.
- grot 15y agoTo properly answer the question "is brogrammer a sexist term", I think it's important to distinguish -- for a moment -- what a sexist term might be. 1. Is a term sexist when the speaker intends to be sexist? 2. Or is the term sexist when others interpret to be? 3. Or is a term sexist in some other more subtle way? Some answers: 1. No idea 2. This varies. I know people here are saying brogrammer is an internet meme, but I've met plenty of start-up people that seem to enjoy various components of the meme -- polo shirts, bad sunglasses, incoherent misogyny. 3. This one is hard, and there are several conflicting possibilities. a) Usage of the word "brogrammer" (whether in jest, or not) could be good (for gender relations), if it is successfully used ironically, or if it somehow signifies the irrelevance of gender. I don't think either of these are true. Popping your collar is not irony. It might be a good halloween gimmick, but it's not irony. And as for brogramming signifying a post-gender binary world, uh, no, come on? b) The alternative is what I believe to be true, posts like this, regardless of intent reveal a serious cultural insensitivity. Whoever wrote it doesn't care if they offend you. They don't care if it sounds sexist, and they probably don't care if they _are_ sexist. This is very antisocial behavior, and it deserves disapprobation just for that.
- pyre 15y agoEven if this was inadvertent, the idea that the ad reads like: BROGRAMMERS COME WORK HERE (fine print: non-bros can apply too) This comes across like: 1. The writer of the ad had in mind a college-aged male as the target audience. 2. The 'non-bros can apply' part seems like an after thought. It makes it seem like someone that's a 'brogrammer' will get to the top of the list, and others will be looked at after the list of 'brogrammers' is exhausted. 3. It indicates a sort of Reddit/Frathouse-ish company culture, which women might not want to apply to any ways. (So some of the commentary could also be on whether or not we want to encourage such cultures in our industry, but that's stretching a bit from the original ad).
- grandalf 15y agoAnd the first honeypot article hits HN...
- sp332 15y ago"bro" puns are pretty non-sexed. Women make "bro" jokes too, because they're funny and no one should take them seriously.
- brndnhy 15y agoPerfect way to close out shark jumping week.
- bbwharris 15y agoYou can brogram with different sexes, do it all the time. Being PC all the time is exhausting. The females that I pair with would laugh at this term and not take offense to it. In fact by saying, "Let's brogram" would indicate the equality that I feel of that female with fellow male programmers. Lighten up and have a sense of humor once in a while. Life is supposed to be fun, not a myriad of social rules and regulations.
- yaix 15y agoFully agree. But in our lawyer run and lawyer trained society, most people don't see things this way anymore.
- melipie 15y agoIf they thought "brogrammer" was all encompassing they would have not felt the need to clarify that women could apply too near the bottom of the post. The problem is not that they were trying to be overtly sexist, it's that they didn't see it as being sexist(which is so often the case when one is in the position of privilege) Obviously new to the job posting scene, they are unaware of how this particular post would be interpreted by the EEOC, I would hate to see a brand new company have to face off with a govt. lawsuit before they even get off the ground.
- noodly 15y agoI really like the "brogrammer" term :) I think in this femi-age it's important to cultivate more masculi-terms. > you just can't advertise for men only roles in this day and age Why not ? And what has this day and age to do with it ? > I don't know the law in the US but over here in the UK these guys would be opening themselves up for a nasty lawsuit. That explains everything. UK is closer to orwellian state than any other european country, so I wouldn't be surprised if it was true.
- seanmcq 15y agoHow could it not be?
- bradfordw 15y agoBrogrammer? No. If someone referred to a female co-worker as a Hogrammer, then yes.
- Confusion 15y agoIt depends. Whether a term is sexist depends on intention, as the term itself is ambiguous in meaning. One of the meanings is sexist, another meaning is an oxymoronic contraction of words; the kind of language joke hackers are supposed to enjoy. If we attempt to spin things in a positive light, it may be assumed that the intention was to describe the culture in their startup, which involves jokes around such terms as 'brogrammers'. If we attempt to spin things in a negative light, they are obliviously sexist. The truth may be anywhere in between, but the truth doesn't matter: only reception does. And it isn't being received well.
- ewanmcteagle 15y agoIt's useful for weeding out this place as an employer. As a male programmer who intends to remain a programmer, I'm disheartened by this future where I may have to work for juveniles and have these types of discussions.
- anamax 15y agoThey're just doucheoisie. As to "We love all kinds of music, tv, movies, and books", they likely don't.
- brandoncordell 15y agoWhy so serious? Companies put little jokes and pokes in their job searches all the time. Do you think the company is really going to turn down applicants because they're not "brogrammers". It's certainly silly to assume so. Did you even read the full post? Here is what it says verbatim: * You are a fan (or future fan) of Brogramming on Facebook. (Non-Bros are still welcome to apply) That in no certain terms has anything to do with gender. I'm a male and would not be considered a "brogrammer". What if they said they were looking for the King of all Rubyists? Does that mean they would hire a female because by technicality she couldn't be a king? Sorry I just think this thread is ridiculous.
- ohyes 15y agoDevil's advocate here. I agree it is sexist and unprofessional and not how I would word a recruitment post. That said, it seems to be a reference to an internet meme. http://www.facebook.com/getwiththebrogram http://www.facebook.com/getwiththebrogram They also say pretty clearly that non-bros are welcome to apply (I'm male and I consider myself a non-bro). It also does not say that being a Brogrammer actually entails that you be male. (Admittedly, it could be interpreted that way). They are trying to show a work-hard/play-hard mentality, and maybe a little playful immaturity. All of this said, I think if they are willing to accept responsibility for the repercussions of the job posting, there is no reason to abridge their free speech. Whether this particular posting is a good idea for them as a company (w/r/t investors, image, actually recruiting the best people rather than people who are 'fun') is another matter.
- noodle 15y ago> it seems to be a reference to an internet meme. it is. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi_AAqi0RZM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi_AAqi0RZM
- tnicola 15y agoAre you sure that it wasn't just a bad joke and a case of someone trying to be 1337, but ended up at 1335.
- roguecoder 15y agoI would definitely never apply to a job that advertise a "brogrammer" culture, and I do consider it inherently sexist. In fact, I would go so far as to say that any guy who thinks of himself as a "brogrammer" needs to do some serious soul-searching and start reading bell hooks. Enforced standards of masculinity is patriarchal oppression, just like the objectification of women by those men. Stop defining yourself by your genitalia, get over your homophobia and accept that society is larger than your weird little cultural perspective.
- pekk 15y agoDon't call yourself a brogrammer, it's bad for your career. Maybe software brogineer or something
- unabridged 15y agobro =/= male being male doesnt make you a bro, females can be bros if you don't understand what bro means then you cannot possibly understand the word brogrammer. if you do not understand the word brogrammer, then you are not in the right culture to be hired by this company.
- nikography 15y agothis post is definitely real. i emailed the address on the ad, and they sent back a surprisingly dismissive reply. they open rudely, begin to say they made an error in judgement and then backhandedly defended themselves. pretty uncool, i'd really like to know who the company is. here was my initial email: http://lilpuff.us/non-bro http://lilpuff.us/non-bro and the reply from secretstartup@gmail.com: http://lilpuff.us/rY6D8r http://lilpuff.us/rY6D8r and the original listing, cached: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:WEsG46NDDRYJ:https://news.ycombinator.com/item%3Fid%3D3167412+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:WEsG46N... also, just to note: the fact that they put "non-bros still welcome to apply" suggests that they were aware that brogramming might come off as a men-only requirement, but did not see this as a problem. also consider the use of "still welcome to apply" vs. more positive or friendly language, e.g. "we love non-bros too!" which still utilizes the term in question, but is welcoming and follows the tone of the posting. and i spoke with multiple men and women (who do and do not work in IT) who found this pretty offensive.