11 ms·
How San Francisco became a failed city
- mensetmanusman 4y ago“ In February 2021, at a corner in the lovely Japantown neighborhood, just a few feet from a house that would soon sell for $4.8 million, a 37-year-old homeless man named Dustin Walker died by the side of the road. His body lay there for at least 11 hours. He wore blue shorts and even in death clutched his backpack. I can’t stop thinking about how long he lay there, dead, on that corner, and how normal this was in our putatively gentle city. San Franciscans are careful to use language that centers people’s humanity—you don’t say “a homeless person”; you say “someone experiencing homelessness”—and yet we live in a city where many of those people die on the sidewalk.” Makes you think…
- dontbenebby 4y ago
- Clubber 4y ago"Actions speak louder than words," as an adage I think applies here. "Words are cheap," is another one. >you don’t say “a homeless person”; you say “someone experiencing homelessness” This is San Francisco's version of "thoughts and prayers." I suppose it would be better for overall humanity if we still called them "bums," but actually did something to help them.
- danso 4y agoChanging nomenclature is not at all enough toward actual aid and a solution, but it's not contrary to those ends either — i.e. I don't foresee a situation in which city politicians call the homeless "bums" while actually allocating adequate resources to helping them.
- newsclues 4y agoIf we judge people (especially those in or running for government) by what they do rather than what they say. Given the results of SF, the actions say, “fuck poor people” while the words are the opposite.
- MAGZine 4y agoThe poor people were basically not punished for crimes and allowed to pitch tents wherever they pleased. Also free housing if they wanted, so long as they didn't use drugs. Rehab if they wanted it. What part of that seems inhumane?
- newsclues 4y agoThe part where society didn’t build enough affordable housing so there was an option other than jail or living on the streets.
- rhino369 4y agoThe issue is the actions don't achieve the intended results. It's really hard to convince people the policies they believe in just don't work.
- newsclues 4y agoIf people believe in thinks despite data that proves those things are wrong (Marxists), ignore them and move on. You can’t placate mentally ill people at the expense of society at large
- mkmk3 4y agoIs this getting downvoted because of the harsh tone of it or what? I think it's a nice comment on parents observation
- MAGZine 4y agoBecause it implies a cut and dried solution, which does not exist. It's implies sf wants to care, but is too busy virtue signaling to do anything about it. Like as if the city doesn't want to put it's money where it's mouth is. Instead, sf has one of the most well funded social networks in the country. And they tried to take an innovative approach on policing, one that would not disportionately target poor people or people of a certain race. The remaining solutions are essentially to forcibly remove people from the streets, and revert to the standard American policing playbook. At least, those are the tools traditionally used to clean up these problems in other parts of the country. So, it's a comment that sounds nice but isn't actually true. Sf was taking actions. And now, as of last night, the citizenry are also taking action (by recalling the DA)
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> solutions are essentially to forcibly remove people from the streets Solution is to build more housing. This, however, cuts against two powerful San Francisco voting blocs, and the source of its problems: homeowners and entrenched subsidized renters.
- MAGZine 4y agoThis is probably a correct take but not really immediately actionable. It's up the the residents of the city to decide they want to change their neighborhoods. And most new construction ends up market rate which takes a while to free up housing supply for the affected group (which is at the bottom of the market.) I'm a yimby fwiw, but as new york has shown you can have both density and an affordability issue—density isn't a a cure-all. And what's perhaps most annoying is that certain minority activist groups also actively block new development. The mission hasn't been developed much, but it's not for lack of trying.
- 4y ago
- zbrozek 4y agoIt's also just bad English. It's both more verbose and less precise than what it replaces. If I walk down the street in SF, I've experienced homelessness. But I'm not necessarily homeless. Unfortunately the same people who will chastise you about your insensitive language will also vote down every housing project.
- dontbenebby 4y ago
- ch4s3 4y ago> because I suspect most of the people I'm referencing are doing JUST FINE friend Unless they own their homes or lucked into a rent controlled unit that isn't a dump then they are probably very much NOT FINE.
- dontbenebby 4y agoThey're all millionaires, because they did an internship, were hired onto a full time role, and then rented an apartment that is rent controlled that was below their means and saved aggressively. Unfortunarely, absent the same level of income I cannot make those choices, even with perfect or near perfect information. Or they live with their family, who are loving and supportive, but also encourage them to go out a bit so their housemates have privacy, so they'd run into someone like me at Red Rock or whatever. I don't think folks understand that the bay has a lot of rental protections not present in other places. (Eg someone can't just suddenly decide not renew a lease, etc) HN folks focus in a bit too much on rent control, I found a blog detailing some of the other protections (though it's quite obviously an ad for a particular firm): https://www.tobenerlaw.com/san-francisco-just-cause-eviction/ https://www.tobenerlaw.com/san-francisco-just-cause-eviction...
- andrewstuart 4y ago[flagged]
- guiriduro 4y agoUltra rich Americans absolutely love socialism ... for the ultra rich. Getting bailed out in 2009, having the central bank buy their broken assets in the bad times (they enjoyed the profits privately in the good ofc) Since it has worked so well for the rich, you'd think socialism for all would get a better write up. But apparently poor americans getting universal healthcare is an unaffordable catastrophe and harbinger of the apocalypse.
- tharne 4y ago> Ultra rich Americans absolutely love socialism ... for the ultra rich. Getting bailed out in 2009, having the central bank buy their broken assets in the bad times (they enjoyed the profits privately in the good ofc) The much more obvious conclusion here is that socialism for the rich has insulated them from the consequences of their actions and has led to even worse behavior. Any reasonable person would conclude that socialism for the rich has been a catastrophic failure and should be done away with rather than expanded across society.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smcl 4y agoThe government coddling the wealthy while trampling the poor is not socialism. I know there are folks who use "socialism" to mean "the government doing bad things I don't like" but this is a hangover from the Cold War, and it doesn't really belong anywhere near a civilised discussion.
- CrackerNews 4y agoAgreed. Socialism is defined better as workers owning the means of production. In "socialism for the rich", it is still the rich owning the means of production, aka capitalism.
- hyperboreanChad 4y ago
- tharne 4y agoThis quote from the article could be the motto of progressive cities everywhere, it certainly applies to the ones near me: "...making the citizens of our city miserable in service of an ideology that made sense everywhere but in reality"
- felixgallo 4y agobrother, wait until you find out about the gleaming metropolises, noble equity, and high academic standards of the red states.
- tharne 4y ago> brother, wait until you find out about the gleaming metropolises, noble equity, and high academic standards of the red states. Brother, wait until you find out that Trumpism and Wokism are not the only ways to run a government.
- felixgallo 4y agoMan, I cannot wait for you to tell me about the major conservative metropolis that does so much better for all of its citizens, and does not suffer under the yoke of Trumpism or whatever 'Wokism' (?!) is. I'm scouring a map and I'm sure I'll find it soon, but maybe you could drop a hint?
- FredPret 4y agoLook outside the USA
- the_only_law 4y agoSaudi Arabia is petty wealthy rn.
- meroes 4y agoI found Dubai did I win?
- jeffbee 4y agoWhat is the new line of commentary going to be after they turfed out Boudin but nothing changes because the problem is the SFPD won’t do their jobs?
- tharne 4y agoYou don't think having a DA who didn't believe in the mission of his own organization had any influence on police morale? Why would officers risk their safety arresting people they know the DA's office had no intention of charging?
- jeffbee 4y agoThe rate at which the DA’s office has charged arrestees has been about the same for decades and is slightly up under Boudin compared to his immediate predecessor. The rate at which the SFPD solves crimes stands at an all-time low.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wusher 4y agoBoth your statement and the parent statement can be true
- alphabettsy 4y agoIt’s what they’re paid to do. They’re not volunteers. Why are we taking the police narrative at face value? It’s usually not correct.
- jakear 4y agoIf you were paid to write PR’s knowing full well that absolutely 0 of them would get merged, and you’d make the same money whether you wrote any or not, what would you do?
- basisword 4y agoQuestion for people who actually live in SF now and have lived there for a long period of time: Is it as bad as I see online? 10-15 years ago I would have loved to live in SF, work for a startup etc. and all I heard were good things about the city. There was a homelessness problem but I didn't hear much more than that. Now it sounds like a hell hole. Crime seems to be the main issue and I'm not sure I'd feel comfortable visiting as a tourist never mind living there. Is my perspective skewed by the sources I'm reading or have things really deteriorated to that extent?
- MAGZine 4y agoIt's not great but I visit semi frequently. I think the media has exaggerated it. I left sf but it wasn't because of the crime.
- bushbaba 4y agoLived in SF in 2014. It’s way worse now. Back in 2014 you had a mesh of artistic and tech. This lead to a great social scene. Now the artists were priced out and they moved to Oakland. The SF tech workers left in droves. What’s left is the homeless and crime. Much of the city still hasn’t recovered from covid. Soma and fidi are in shambles. Feels like only 1 out of every 4 places is still in business. However Silicon Valley (San Mateo & Santa Clara county), San Jose, and east bay are all thriving relative to their past
- jeffbee 4y ago> Now the artists were priced out and they moved to Oakland This is the main part of the problem to me. There's nothing even remotely interesting going on in that city's culture. The entire city is split between people who can afford a 2-million-dollar house, retirees, and people who sleep on the street. Crime is about the same. When I moved to SF in '98 the very first thing that happened to me was my bicycle got stolen, and my convertible car got its top slashed so many times that I started leaving the doors unlocked, at which point people started sleeping in my car, so I sold it. Violent crime is actually much lower but that's a long-term trend. IMHO the problems with that city all stem from the inequality caused by the housing crisis. It drives property crime and it's the reason the city is intensely boring.
- zozbot234 4y agoA "failed city" and "$#!+hole" with some of the most expensive housing in the country? That can't possibly be a seriously-intended claim. If SF is in such obvious trouble, why is it that everyone still wants to live and locate there?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrew_ 4y agoeveryone? that's a buffer overflow error
- Grimburger 4y agoProbably because they can earn good money for a few years and then move somewhere they actually desire? Personally seen this play out in Dubai, Hong Kong and Singapore for a long time. There's a huge contingent of knowledge workers who have no intent of putting down long term roots there. It's just somewhere to extract wealth from with high paying jobs and housing costs are simply another acceptable tax on that. Stay a decade, make bank, move somewhere where you can work at leisure. Isn't that the dream?
- My71staccount 4y agoBecause this BS about crime in SF is just a republican pushback against "defunding the police" which never actually happened. It's a propaganda effort to push the pendulum further fascist. Villainizing and smearing a well known progressive city to let others know that won't fly. And rich white tech bros complaining about crime and homelessness from their ivory tower is disgusting. You're so detached from how humans actually live that you're threatened by just SEEING them, not even experiencing it.
- more_corn 4y agoBullshit. Have you seriously walked around SF recently? Had your car broken into, watched someone shit on the street in broad daylight? Watched blatant brazen shoplifting? It’s impossible to avoid. It’s worse and worsening. Pretending it’s not is the worst sort of self-deception.
- cedricd 4y agoWhat I don't get, living in NYC, is why it's so much safer (seemingly) than SF. Yes, we have homelessness and crime, and it has sharply risen during COVID, but not to this point. NYC is a much bigger city, politically very liberal, and our politicians aren't exactly amazing, so what's different?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- maxfurman 4y agoTo wildly speculate, NYC is much more walkable and has better public transit than SF. This puts the people more in touch with each other and increases the feeling of community, and also makes it harder to smash a car window when no one is looking. Or maybe NYC is just bigger and the crime happens further away from where you personally live? The feeling of safety is so subjective.
- cedricd 4y agoCould be a contributing factor. As for me I live downtown in Manhattan in a 'nice' neighborhood (though in downtown they're nearly all nice). The equivalent in SF is the opposite. One thing could be that there are real neighborhoods where people live in the denser parts of the city. Our public schools (in Manhattan) are extremely good, so families do actually live there. AFAIK folks generally leave SF once they have kids.
- bushbaba 4y agoCold winters. many would not want to camp out on the sidewalk during nyc winter. Sf doesn’t have that much violent crime. It’s mostly theft or quality of life related. Then you have a police force who are forced to release criminals due to chesa (DA).
- MAGZine 4y agoNYC has a lot more aggressive policies regarding homelessness and drug use. Open drug use and pitching tents are not tolerated. If you see a homeless person "in need of assistance" (their phrasing), you just call 311 and a team of people will come and deal with the "issue."
- basisword 4y ago>> A couple of years ago, one of my friends saw a man staggering down the street, bleeding. She recognized him as someone who regularly slept outside in the neighborhood, and called 911. Paramedics and police arrived and began treating him, but members of a homeless advocacy group noticed and intervened. They told the man that he didn’t have to get into the ambulance, that he had the right to refuse treatment. So that’s what he did. The paramedics left; the activists left. The man sat on the sidewalk alone, still bleeding. A few months later, he died about a block away. This is appalling. What kind of morons are in this advocacy group? If you're going to talk him out of getting 'official' help the least you can do is help him yourself.
- mariusmg 4y ago>What kind of morons are in this advocacy group? Same type of morons which "advised" people to not get to the hospital to get treated for COVID because the doctors will kill them, harvest their organs and send them to the aliens. This world is filled with idiots.
- NDizzle 4y ago
- seaourfreed 4y agoThis and all of the posts below show SF as a failed city. I work in tech and I'd never move there. Failed = "good people" doing things to cause more problems, which you illustrate very well
- mistrial9 4y agothis is a pendulum-swing reversal of a previous era where you could be institutionalized without redress. Similar arguments (rightly) are going on about the seriously-mentally ill. Another part of it is that super powerful painkillers are readily available and highly addictive. Like the crack "epidemic" in the 1980s, these drugs are so strong and pervasive that it visibly changes whole cities.
- pkulak 4y ago
- kwatsonafter 4y ago
- manuelabeledo 4y agoSo do you think that most large metropolis are not "cool" anymore?
- hyperboreanChad 4y ago
- boringg 4y agoContinuing the easy click bait money of isht posting san francisco. Republicans love it; progressives hate it. Chesa Boudin recall happened. It's just another easy dollar story you can sell to the rest of the country Are the problems? Yes - are some getting worse? Yes. We also are two years into a pandemic that has had an insane disruption on cities. This story is as old as the city itself. Save yourself the bother and don't click.
- weberer 4y agoWait, you're accusing The Atlantic of appealing to Republicans?
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoIf we all close our eyes, the problems cease to exist?
- boringg 4y agoDo you live in San Francisco or do you just post when there's a story about it? Seems like everyone in the country has an axe to grind against the city - has been that way for sometime. I'm just pointing out the consistent anti sf narrative in US media. That said thanks for your insightful comment.
- more_corn 4y agoThe author clearly lives in San Francisco.
- likeabbas 4y agoHaving had lived there for 3 years, it’s worth having the discussion. SF could be a fantastic place to live but the state that the city is in is abhorrent. Despite the weather not being as great, NYC is an infinitely better place to live and I couldn’t be happier having made the move.
- 4y ago
- jaywalk 4y agoAt the end of the day, the DA was kicked out of office for doing exactly what he said he'd do. It's a good step, but you'll have to excuse me if I have a hard time believing that the people who have voted for Nancy Pelosi every two years since before I was born actually will learn their lesson.
- the_only_law 4y ago> It's a good step, but you'll have to excuse me if I have a hard time believing that the people who have voted for Nancy Pelosi every two years since before I was born actually will learn their lesson. This is what I don't get. There are these politicians, across the board that don't seem to be well liked within their own party, but they win their election everytime. Either their state must really love them, or voting must be some sort of ritual where people just mark what they always have and go home. And look, I get it. CA doesn't want a Republican and KY doesn't want a Democrat. Great, that doesn't mean you have to elect the same person every damn time.
- saalweachter 4y agoWhile Congress as a whole has a net approval rating of something like -50%, in general everyone likes their own representatives and hates everyone else's. It doesn't matter what 330 million Americans think about Nancy Pelosi or Mitch McConnel. It only matters what the 780,000 people in CA-12 or the 4.5 million people in KY think about them (well, the majority of voters within the populations in question).
- philjohn 4y agoIs the problem that prison in the US doesn't focus on rehabilitation, leading to a revolving door of recidivism? Decriminalising drugs has been seen by many to have been a positive policy change in Portugal, is it just being done differently? Are there other externalities at play, like the opiod issue being much larger in the US, and states not minding foisting their homelessness problem on CA?
- aidenn0 4y ago1. San Francisco is a city that approximately zero people can afford to buy hosing in. 2. The weather in coastal California is mild compared to the rest of the country 3. The drug laws in California are more liberal (both in theory and in practice) than most of the rest of the country 4. The drug laws in San Francisco are more liberal (both in theory and in practice) than most of the rest of California. 5. It's not just drug laws that were de-facto liberalized in San Francisco, it's most non-violent crimes, including petty theft and shop-lifting. So if you want to steal lots of low volume items to buy drugs to shoot up and live on the street, this is the city for you. The city hasn't crashed under the weight of this because (due to the approximately in #1) there are enough wealthy people living their and paying taxes to fund a lot of these programs. There are, of course, lots of other reasons why the bay area has issues (e.g. There are many small cities across nine counties, so any central planning is difficult). The closest I can think of for Portugal might be "What if Faro, while in the middle of a real-estate boom, significantly liberalized its drug laws and a large fraction of the drug addicts from points west of Austria relocated there"
- philjohn 4y agoYep - that's fair, great answers!
- fzeroracer 4y agoRealistically, people single out San Francisco because it's hip to do so. It's easy to point to SF and say it's failed. Because of progressive politics, because of gentrification or whatever else you want to say. But the actual problem is endemic. It's an issue in almost every city across the US, from Seattle to New York. From red states to blue states. Even here in Austin we have a large portion of homeless people and homeless camps that shuffle around as the laws shift and change. The problems started years ago, it's only recently that they became more visible because class stratification is getting worse. Not only that, but there's a strong tendency among cities to simply 'solve' this problem by buying homeless people bus tickets and shipping them off to cities in fairer climates. The actual solution to this problem is a federal one, understanding that our safety nets and healthcare systems are ineffectual for a large portion of our society but even then that would take decades to take effect.
- shkkmo 4y agoCities like San Francisco have looked at the homeless crisis and our decades of failed policies and are trying to actually solve the problem. Unfortunately, it ia a national problem and attempts at creating better tools to solve the problems in specific areas mean that those areas naturally experience immigration of those in need of those tools. So while the types of approaches to homelessness that San Francisco have adopted are better for actually helping the homeless, they come with negative effects for the residents. I am sickened by the people effectively saying ”haha sucker" while they offload their people in need on San Francisco. I do have sympathy for the residents of San Francisco who are stuck between a rock and a hard place. They want to help solve the problem but are being put in a untenable position. This article is low on solutions besides ”arrest drug addicts so they get sober in prison" and "forcibly place mentaly ill homeless in institutions". These solutions don't help the target long term, but what they do accomplish is making life more difficult and driving the targeted population towards friendlier cities. This is just the same BS policy of not helping and competing to make life as misey as possible so these people go away.
- eweise 4y ago
- My71staccount 4y ago
- redleggedfrog 4y agoThis does not just apply to SF. The same problems exist in many left leaning cities like PDX. The far left cannot solve these problems (nor can the far right) because they are inherently reactionary. We need more middle-ground moderates in charge.
- teg4n_ 4y agoAh yes because the centrists aren’t reactionary.
- D13Fd 4y agoCalling San Francisco a "failed city" is like calling Tesla a "failed company." It has been wildly, ridiculously successful over a short period of time (in the grand scheme of things), and has hit a recent rough spot. That doesn't make it a "failed city" by any stretch.
- basisword 4y agoI thought I was pretty liberal but the section of this article about the school board is astounding. >> One night in 2021, the meeting lasted seven hours, one of which was devoted to making sure a man named Seth Brenzel stayed off the parent committee. >> Brenzel is a music teacher, and at the time he and his husband had a child in public school. Eight seats on the committee were open, and Brenzel was unanimously recommended by the other committee members. But there was a problem: Brenzel is white. >> “My name’s Mari,” one attendee said. “I’m an openly queer parent of color that uses they/them pronouns.” They noted that the parent committee was already too white (out of 10 sitting members, three were white). This was “really, really problematic,” they said. “I bet there are parents that we can find that are of color and that also are queer … QTPOC voices need to be led first before white queer voices.” Diversity on the board is a great idea but denying perfectly qualified people the role because they don't meet a laundry list of criteria (criteria they can't change) is mad.
- MrMember 4y agoEven worse he was the only person volunteering for that position. They didn't choose someone more "diverse" instead of him, they chose nobody.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoThat basic sentiment animates some of the arguments against diversity-oriented hiring.
- notacoward 4y agoThat part struck me too, but especially the part about using "intersectionality" as a weapon. I put the word in quotes because I want to highlight that it's the use of the word rather than the concept that offends. AIUI the whole idea of intersectionality is to recognize that even someone who's privileged in one way might be deprivileged in another, and vice versa. It's supposed to be inclusive. Using it as a trump card (pun/insult very much intended) to exclude others or shut down conversation seems abusive.
- basisword 4y ago
- beej71 4y ago"Americans always do the right thing after exhausting all other options." I lived in the Bay Area from 1999 to 2014. I didn't leave because of crime or homelessness; I just got bored and wanted a change of scenery. Every few years I visit. And every time I visit, I can't believe what I see in terms of the increase of the homeless, tent cities, drug use. But the place I live now has also changed radically in the same ways in the same timeframe, just on a smaller scale. And this place is considerably less liberal than San Francisco. I don't think the whole "left/right" fight covers it, and prevents progress by distracting us from the underlying, difficult issues. There's almost certainly at least one more axis here that we're not considering.
- rob74 4y agoHere's an article with a less positive take on the DA recall: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jun/07/san-francisco-vote-chesa-boudin-recall https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jun/07/san-francisc...
- somewhereoutth 4y agoCorporate tech ruined SF - that, and the wider national slide into failed state status. A real shame, truly it is a place you fall for. The crisp clean air at 10am welcomes each new day and anything can happen.