9 ms·
San Francisco could vote out progressive DA in heated recall
- dontbenebby 4y agoPlease don't.
- txsoftwaredev 4y agoConsidering how poorly run San Francisco and much of CA has been they should vote out everyone "progressive".
- m0llusk 4y agoHow do you think San Francisco should be run?
- lern_too_spel 4y agoApparently, they want more Prop 13 in more places.
- throwaway0a5e 4y ago> How do you think San Francisco should be run? By people who don't just ignore several thousand years of how various "not too dysfunctional" societies ran themselves for a few quick ideological virtue points. Much of the shitting on "progressivism" is misguided. There's just as much progressivism and liberal ideology on the other coast and they don't have the same dysfunctionality and failings to nearly the same extents. These kinds of clowns are everywhere but at the end of the day it's the California public who is responsible for electing them and tolerating their poor job performance.
- strikelaserclaw 4y agowe need to get rid of the two party system.
- adastra22 4y agoWe have, in San Francisco. There’s only one party here.
- hn_version_0023 4y agoOr, counterpoint: we need to get rid of the wealthy who pervert the system.
- DrewRWx 4y agoTo get the ball rolling, join or (or start) a push for ranked-choice voting in your city!
- smsm42 4y agoIn California, excepting some rare corners, there's only one party. California has a lot of Republicans, in numbers, but they don't have any power in any major city, let alone on the state level. So your idea has already been implemented.
- gcheong 4y agoBeing too “progressive” hasn’t been the problem. Politicians claiming to be be progressive then pandering to corporate interests has.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoApplying what we could call progressive ideas without thinking them through is a problem. IMHO we should vote for smarter politicians who don't have ideological baggage limiting their decision making. > Politicians claiming to be be progressive then pandering to corporate interests has. That doesn't have much to do with SF's problems as far as I can tell. Quite the opposite actually.
- gcheong 4y agoAll politics is ideological but to blame a single progressive DA for the entirety of the current crime problem in SF without realizing that much of what is happening today is more likely the result of past decisions than one guy actually doing what he said he would do to me is just ridiculous but if you feel that way then convince me in the next election with whatever platform you run on, not telling me I should recall someone so you can just put in your preferred puppet without having to say what you’ll actually do and how it would be better.
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago> All politics is ideological but to blame a single progressive DA for the entirety of the current crime problem Isn't that a straw man though? No one reasonable is saying that this DA is responsible for the entirety of the crime problem, and of course this uptick in crime is a nationwide problem! However, the DA isn't doing enough to make things better, and putting people in jail who are committing crimes repeatedly because they've realized there are no consequences for their actions is probably the smarter thing to do ATM. So let's instead elect a DA that will do that (like we did here in Seattle, it won't solve the problem...but it is a start).
- 4y ago
- bdcravens 4y agoI'm guessing you live in Texas (as do I), not San Francisco or California, and this is an expression of the "Everything in California is terrible" meme that's popular here.
- throwntoday 4y agoWell I live in SF and I can tell you for certain it is as bad as everyone says
- mint2 4y agoAs another resident, I can vouch there are serious issue but the DA is largely being successfully scapegoated by the troubled police department. Pretty much all the reasons the police cite for their chronic issues and ineffectiveness are utter BS but they seem to have successfully shifted all the blame onto the DA. With the serious police dept issues, pandemic, national trends, and lopsided analysis it’s hard to say how much role the da has had but it’s easy to tell it’s nowhere even close to what most attribute. I think the recall will succeed and the supporters will find nothing changes because he wasn’t the issue.
- acoard 4y agoCan you provide some more details about the types of issues the PD has shifted onto the DA? As an outsider, the only real issue I'm aware of is the refusal to prosecute theft under $1k (edit: $950), which seems like something that is completely out of the police's hands.
- adastra22 4y agoExample: the DA won’t prosecute theft under $950, as you say. So the police will literally stand across the street and watch a street vendor get robbed and do nothing. Just because the DA will refuse to press charges doesn’t mean they couldn’t have still arrested the guy for the night and returned the property, not to mention intervening in a potentially dangerous situation for the shop owner and customers.
- bergenty 4y ago
- deeg 4y agoAs an American who doesn't live in Texas or CA it doesn't look like Texas is being run any better.
- linksnapzz 4y ago
- nradov 4y ago
- spoils19 4y agoHave any examples? It may not be perfect, but that's the price for being the most free state in the world.
- deeg 4y agoUvalde is currently at the top of that list and the power problems from last winter. And while I know it's largely dependent on one's political leaning, the Texas laws against books, abortion, immorality (e.g. sex toys), and LBGT issues, among others, don't speak "most free" to me. I'm sure someone will counter with "but in California..." and the objections will all be true, which is why I stand by my original opinion: neither one is obviously better run than the other.
- txsoftwaredev 4y agoIt's clear that TX has been run better than CA. Many large corporations have left CA for TX. Crime in CA is significantly worse and you are not allowed to protect your life or property. You are free to steal and no one does a thing about it, plenty of examples in the news of this happening in the middle of the day. You have celebrities saying "no big deal" about getting your car broken into, just part of life in CA. Look at all the businesses shutting down, Wallgreens for example. TX isn't covered in homeless camps, drugs and feces. TX's economy is strong and will remain strong due to a business friendly environment. Housing is more affordable (though less than it used to be in metro areas) in part due to less regulations. And the items you point to as negatives are positives for me. I'm against abortion, sexualizing children (including books). Not sure what you mean by "sex toys". Plenty of those shops around if you are in need of some. And I've visited CA a few times and have seen it first hand. It's not a place I'd want to take my family for vacation, let alone live. I wish that wasn't true, weather is wonderful.
- sn0w_crash 4y ago
- guywithahat 4y ago
- qgin 4y agoIn SF, theft under $950 is a misdemeanor. In Texas, theft under $2500 is a misdemeanor.
- Petersipoi 4y agoI'm not sure the actual law is as important as how the law is enforced. Lack of enforcement seems to be the problem in CA.
- infamouscow 4y agoIn Texas, a class C misdemeanors for theft is $50 or less, with progressively increasing penalties based on the amount. $1500 is a felony. You can also shoot thieves in Texas.
- Ancapistani 4y ago> You can also shoot thieves in Texas. Don’t be absurd. You can only legally shoot them at night.
- smsm42 4y agoThe question is not how it is classified, but how it is prosecuted. From what I can see in CA, "misdemeanor" means "no prosecution, and likely not even a brief arrest" (not that thieves care much about brief arrests - they just go back to business after the fun ride is done).
- dontbenebby 4y agoMaybe the thieves are rational actors responding to incentives. Have you considering offering them something above minimum wage if you're annoyed enough to recall a DA because you lack the will or the funds to purchase private security?
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoI tend to think recalls in general are bug in a democratic system. For candidates who have done something actually terrible (like breaking laws) there's impeachment or other kinds of dismissal. Otherwise, you wait until the end of the term and vote the bum out?
- gruez 4y ago>Otherwise, you wait until the end of the term and vote the bum out? I don't see how that's a convincing argument for why it's a "bug". Quick remediation seems like a feature?
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoBut why have terms in the first place, if they're that up in the air? The nicest thing I could say for a recall effort is that voters who were too apathetic to vote for another candidate now feel motivated to engage in the process, but as it's an extra vote it incurs costs which the normal cadence of elections doesn't.
- ch1234 4y agoI would agree if it was trivial to bring these things about, but it takes a lot of public backing to even get to this point. It’s just like if we were to hold a state ratification convention. Things would have to be really wrong for us to successfully make changes to our constitution & get everyone on board.
- smsm42 4y agoThe terms are ordinary balances, for regular circumstances. Recall is for extraordinary bad performance. Like performance reviews and firing on the spot in companies. The former is regular, the latter is for somebody who really screwed up.
- theptip 4y agoThe problem is that in practice, recall elections have lower turnout, and so a sufficiently-aggrieved minority can pay to replace the choice of the majority. (Also you don’t get to vote for the replacement, the mayor chooses one in this case). I think there are clear cases where a recall is useful, but it’s probably fair to say it’s too easy to initiate a frivolous recall in CA right now.
- legitster 4y ago> His prosecutors are not permitted to seek cash bail, try juveniles as adults or seek longer sentences for perpetrators with gang affiliations. For the kinds of crimes that frustrate San Franciscans, I don't know if any of these things actually make a difference. Whether prosecutors seek a 3 years or 5 year sentence doesn't seem like it will move the needle. By the time crimes get to the DA's office, the horse has left the barn - agree or disagree with Boudin, SF crime is predominantly an enforcement (and/or cultural) issue.
- nickff 4y agoWhat do you mean when you say it's "an enforcement (and/or cultural) issue."? Isn't all crime a cultural issue to some extent? What is the purpose of law enforcement, and prosecution in your mind?
- legitster 4y agoStopping/preventing crime is handled by police and other organizations. Prosecuting criminals who are caught is handled by the DA's office. Simply put, it's not the DA's job to stop crime. So if the problem is "there is too much crime in SF", changing the DA themselves isn't going to do much in the short term (perhaps in the long term though, with more people locked up).
- nradov 4y agoThe SF police no longer bother even trying to stop certain crimes because the DA won't prosecute criminals, so it's a waste of police time. Changing the DA could give police an incentive to resume active enforcement.
- icedistilled 4y agoIt's strange how every year the police have a new excuse. Prior to Boudin they blamed the change to the $950 felony theft limit ( Texas has $2,500). Now they wore that out they've decided it's Boudin. After the recall what will it be next? Anyway, taking the the cops at their dubious word, assume the DA is terrible. Does it actually make sense to be like "because the DA is terrible, we will also be terrible but you can't criticize us". (Not even getting into the long history of SF policy chronic issues)
- photochemsyn 4y agoAs someone who was born in San Francisco (third gen) and has bounced around between the city and other areas of the state/country most of my life, I can assure you that swapping one set of politicians for another is going to have very little effect on the deep-seated problems facing the city and the Bay Area in general. Which issues are the most important are debatable, but these have to be considered: (1) Jobs. There used to be a ton of electronics and garment manufacturing jobs in the region. Most such jobs required no more than a high school education, possible some vocational training, but the R & D and white-collar sections also provided employement for the college-educated. That's mostly all gone to China, Mexico, Indonesia, etc. Right out of high school I actually did a couple years doing electronics assembly line manufacturing in various locations, including in an exciting laser-welding shop, making ridiculously good money relative to my peers (I could afford my own apartment at 18) - and there were people who'd been there decades. Gets boring fast, so I went to college, as I didn't want to be there forever. When you look at the huge homeless population today, I think it was less than 10% back then of what it is now, and my guess is that the availability of those jobs played a big role in that. (2) Housing. The reality is, either you are in or near the 1% by wealth or you can't buy a home, and rents are ridiculously high, and there are confounding factors like AirBNB taking homes off the market and foreign investors using real estate as a tax haven / money laundering scheme, etc. Developers don't want to build high-density affordable housing as profit margins are lower. Increased population puts strains on public transportation and traffic. The whole region could turn into something like Mexico City (wealthy center protected by police, surrounded by miles of slums and shantytowns). Importantly, people who serve key roles - teachers, service workers, etc. - generally have to commute into the city, was they can't afford local rents. This wealth/poverty class divide is not very stable or pleasant to be around. I think what a certain sector of wealthy SF wants (basically the people behind the recall effort) is for the police to mainly serve the role of kicking the homeless out of the pricey neighborhoods and concentrating them in areas where they never go, which will heavily impact these poorer neighborhoods, exacerbating the growing class conflict. Oh, and one job sector that is growing? Armed private security. I don't think the outcome of the recall will affect any of this significantly, however. The only real fixes I see would be a massive jobs program to bring back manufacturing to the region and a push towards Tokyo-style tiny apartment construction across the region.
- Apocryphon 4y agoI was in Burbank recently and amused to find that Los Angeles has its own progressive DA they're trying to recall, George Gascón.
- scruple 4y agoWho came to LA by way of San Francisco, so it's not as if voters didn't know exactly what they were getting...