23 ms·
The Math Myth (2016)
- kazinator 4y agoA lot of people wouldn't be able to muster 8th grade math skills and do something usefl with Excel. Maybe there is a non-strawman version of the Math Myth is that the economy would benefit if more people could do that.
- blip54321 4y agoSince finishing school, I've used very little of the math I learned in school. I've used a lot of math. Most of it built on high school algebra and geometry. Does that mean that's all I needed to learn? No. The key thing I do use is more ephemeral: Mathematical maturity. In my current job, I use math I never learned in graduate school. I'm able to learn it quickly because I learned a lot of math back then. My math classes were a way to develop mathematical maturity. Which specific math I learned in graduate school was almost incidental. What I picked up was the ability to learn new math.
- kazinator 4y agoIn programming, you're doing math whenever you convince yourself that a rewritten piece of code means the same thing as the original (by thinking about it, rather than just running it).
- culi 4y agoI mean, at a certain point, you're just abstracting logical thinking in general and calling it "math". You can say the same about baking, working out your schedule ahead of time so you can pick up your kids and have time to buy groceries, or trying to sort your playlist of non-album singles in a way so that you optimally position each song in a way that minimizes how jarring the switch from one track to the next is I feel like the whole point of "math" is to abstract these natural patterns so we can like... write them down and investigate them further. We have a limited mental capacity so we abstract it into a syntax/system of meaning so that we can let the paper or the computer do some of the memory work for us. If you're doing it in your head, sure that's a skill, but is it really math?
- burrows 4y agoDo you use “math” and “deductive reasoning” to refer to distinct activities?
- jfengel 4y agoDeduction is used in a lot more than just the classes labeled "mathematics". Which makes one question just to what degree the mathematics classes are even useful. Perhaps deductive reasoning could've been taught to do more useful things than factoring polynomials.
- nicoburns 4y agoPhilosophy (at least in the Analytic tradition) involves a lot of deductive reasoning about non-mathematical things (the main difference from maths being that in maths everyone mostly agrees on the foundations, where in philosophy a lot of the reasoning is conditional: IF you believe X, Y, Z, then Q is also true).
- burrows 4y agoWhat are “foundations”? Inference rules, axioms, language?
- nicoburns 4y agoI was referring to axioms when I used the term "foundations" above. Inference rules are largely agreed upon across both maths and philosophy (and they're the same ones in both disciplines).
- burrows 4y agoA tangential but related thought. I’ve heard people say things like, “The world is math”, but it never seemed particularly coherent to me. Sometimes I’d assume they meant, “Inference systems with mathematical languages make useful predictions about my empirical experience.” But now I’m favoring the interpretation that experience is purely formal/syntactic with no semantic component. There is no additional meaning beyond (or behind) appearance.
- m463 4y agoI remember in school hearing "math is just symbol manipulation" and to an extent, this might be true. It's structured formal thinking. What's interesting is when the real, practical world runs into the theoretical, abstract math world. https://petapixel.com/2019/07/05/goodbye-aberration-physicist-solves-2000-year-old-optical-problem/ https://petapixel.com/2019/07/05/goodbye-aberration-physicis...
- panic 4y agoThe point of the article isn't that all symbolic thinking is pointless—just that the specific types of symbolic thinking we spend years teaching aren't actually used very often. Why not spend that time playing with code instead if you want to learn this skill?
- taeric 4y agoI would hesitate to call this math. When baking and you perform substitution of blackberries with raspberries, do you consider that a form of chemistry? It can certainly be justified with it; but I hesitate to say it is the same thing. Same for when a builder chooses to use a different type of fastener when constructing something. It could be borne of experience, but I would not necessarily call it material engineering at that point. Even if the exact same practice is how materials exploration happens, at a superficial level.
- dagw 4y agoThere is also a difference between learning math and understanding math. I was taught the basics of matrix multiplication, finding determinants, solving linear systems of equations and all the stuff in high school. I was half way to my Masters before I really understood what all those things actually where, how they related to different things and all the ways they could be used to actually solve real world problems.
- blip54321 4y agoThe term for this is transfer learning. https://learningcurrents.weebly.com/visible-learning-surface-deep-and-transfer.html https://learningcurrents.weebly.com/visible-learning-surface... It takes a minimum of about 3 semesters to be able to get linear algebra to the stage of transfer learning. There are slower ways to do it (which most people follow), but there aren't shortcuts -- there is no way high school Algebra 2 can get you there in the time allotted. That kind of high school surface learning is not a step you can skip, though: "Surface learning is critical because it provides a foundation on which to build as students are asked to think more deeply." There are a lot of shortcuts which can cut back on the number of hours, mostly by spreading out the number of years. Early surface exposure helps a lot, as does revisiting topics in different contexts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spacing_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spacing_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spiral_approach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spiral_approach
- yunyu 4y agoI have used very little algebra/calculus/pre-college content, but have used a lot of linear algebra/discrete mathematics. Would this be a common exception to the rule?
- samus 4y agoI think the author had purely calculus in mind. Discrete mathematics is indeed crucial to understand computer science. Statistics are very important too, especially in our post-fact world, to be able to call out obvious bull**** when you see it.
- devnulll 4y ago> Discrete mathematics is indeed crucial to understand computer science. FAANG engineer here, having worked in multiple companies you would recognize as a principle (or higher) engineer. I've also taken Discrete math when I was a CS undergrad. I've never used any of the advanced math learned in school, and I've had the pleasure of working on some of the largest and most complex systems ever made. Lots of basic Excel. The "math" I have needed for work (such as TLA+ modeling, percentile distributions, etc) was always learned "on demand".
- ecshafer 4y agoI don't believe that is true. As a trivial example, to say that you have never used Discrete Math in your work means that you have never for example write if(a && b) or have never done if(!a && !b) and judged it to be cleaner than if(!(a || b)). This also means that you never used a finite state machine, strings, combinatorics, trees, graphs or modulus. I would believe that you have not explicitly sat down and worked out Discrete Mathematics proofs. But the ideas of Discrete Math are pervasive and unlikely that you have never used them.
- taeric 4y agoI would think that would be more logic than discrete math? Math is a good abstraction, such that it can be brought to describe the work many other fields do. It doesn't stand that what the others are doing is automatically math, though.
- kenjackson 4y agoHe discusses how specificity is key in sports, but actually the consensus now is to avoid specialization for as long as possible. Playing other sports helps you in your primary sport, especially when it comes to injury reduction. The book Range by Epstein covers this well. The article also seems to be focused on a certain kind of math. Boolean algebra is a type of math that is used regularly in CS and EE. It is so fundamental that if you don’t get it you probably can’t code anything non trivial.
- natly 4y agoRange is kind of a niche book I'm not sure it represents the consensus yet.
- alistairSH 4y agoAt a bare minimum, excelling in most sports today requires conditioning in the gym. Weight lifting, plyometrics, coordination drills, etc. Cyclists don’t just ride their bikes. Footballers don’t just kick a ball around. Formula 1 drivers don’t just drive their cars. You can find Nino Schurter’s gym workouts on YouTube (elite mountain biker). Same for some top race car drivers.
- mym1990 4y agoThis needs more context, otherwise you're just throwing out a very broad opinion. A 12 year old that 'excels' at a sport is definitely not weight lifting, doing plyos, etc... A 15 year old might just be getting into some of those things. Everything you might be doing in the gym is in support of the task you're trying to accomplish, not the other way around, so I really doubt that the gym is 'the bare minimum' for most athletes.
- alistairSH 4y agoSorry, I was thinking about the author’s statement about specificity… if you want to improve your racquetball game, don’t practice squash. And my own experience studying economics and computer science. The math I was required to take (2 semesters calculus, 1 statistics, and 1 discrete math) was in support of the task I was trying to accomplish (basic competence in those subjects). None at a level I would have considered “advanced” beyond the scope of my degree. Friends that studied history or philosophy did even less math than that - many didn’t take any in college (after testing out based on AP exams or similar).
- xqcgrek2 4y agoI have a hard time believing the claims in the article. I use vector calculus and linear algebra everyday and so do my colleagues
- rrss 4y agoI’d like a job where I used more math - can you share your job & industry?
- majormajor 4y agoAmerican high school education does seem still unfortunately calculus mono-focused, with little of even what makes calculus interesting considered, just ram a bunch of rules for derivation and integration into your head. A broad base of at least some of stats, linear algebra, and others seems like it would be more useful to most even in STEM to me. I've met folks who were great at those who struggled with geometry and/or calculus, and vice versa. Yet plenty of need for people good at all sorts of those.
- aozgaa 4y agoCalculus is useful to make rigorous statements in stats. How do you relate the pdf/cdf of a continuous probability distribution without calculus? Agreed that “memorize rules” is not a great learning experience for students… but it is easy to present.
- dotopotoro 4y agoPoint0. Learning without any memorization… I’m not sure if that is possible. One must hold several concepts inside the head to learn new ones. Point1. Education system which would strive for bear minimum outcome would be something like “not everybody needs addition, cashiers can take care of that”. (You will cut calculus, somebody else will cut multiplication table) Point2. which iq range education system is optimised for? (Fair discission; though hard politically). Gifted people are random in population. If you teach and test only the bare minimum content, which 99.9% of population passes with flying colors, then gifted are undertrained and also harder to spot, thus under-utilised. Point3. Memorization is useful. Even if one understands the concept deeply, the “cheat sheet” inside the head (i.e. memorised info) makes things much much faster. Memorization is abit like muscle-memory and or caching.
- epgui 4y agoI think Point0 and Point3 are currently underappreciated. For all the failings of today’s public education, I believe things used to be “worse” as far as rote memorization went. The problems with rote learning are obvious, and I don’t mean to dismiss them. But I do think the pendulum has swung so far that today, there is excessive and harmful stigma attached to it. Rote learning is a bit of a leap of faith, and it requires trusting that it will be useful in the end (in other words it comes with an upfront cost)… and this is incredibly powerful for taking some academic shortcuts in a limited amount of time.
- discreteevent 4y agoI originally studied EE and we did a lot of math. Fourier series, Laplace transforms ... Never used any of it. The most I've used has been some simple statistics and a cubic spline for some curve fitting. Even ML seems to just use basic linear algebra. That said, trigonometry can be quite useful for DIY jobs.
- devnulll 4y agoI've used more Geometry & Trig working on my Model Train Set than I have as a professional software engineer. Figuring out table spacing, track radius, overhang from trains, is basic stuff. I needed to buy a bunch of precisely cut curved wood for a 2nd level (laser cut wood! So Awesome!), and had to actually re-learn the basics of trig in order to provide the details to have everything made.
- tasty_freeze 4y agoI too am an EE, though doing digital design. It is true I never have to do a Fourier transform in my professional life, but the time/frequency duality and all the ideas related to it have been useful throughout my career. In addition, that section of math was the most beautiful thing I've learned in my life.
- t_mann 4y agoI find it hard to believe that anyone working as a programmer / software engineer wouldn't be using any actual computer science (as in data structures, algorithm complexity,...). I could believe that most people working as engineers in civil/mechanical engineering would mainly use Excel, but not that they wouldn't be using exponential functions. But I guess his point is rather that most graduates of engineering schools don't even work as engineers at all, which might be true, I don't know (I even have difficulty believing that given the number of people I know who weren't even trained as engineers and are now working as software engineers).
- taeric 4y agoI don't know, this might not be as far from believing that painters aren't all chemists. Yes, many of them will be mixing paints. No, most of them will not know much more than "these colors mix." Similarly, is a quarterback running ballistics equations to determine if they can complete a pass? All while running an optimization on the timing of various other players on the field to know if they will have time to make the pass?
- rad88 4y agoIt might be true but it is a shallow truth if so. 100% of engineers need to learn elementary algebra even if only 25% of engineers "use" it, for a variety of strong reasons. Programming is a more interesting issue. If this blog had argued that computer science should be marginalized within software engineering then he might have found something to say (but which has already been said many times by others).
- misja111 4y agoThe vast majority of software developers spend their days mapping database tables to web UI's in some way or another. You don't need any CS or math for that and from experience I can say that most of them don't have this knowledge either. It's not that those jobs are without challenges but they are in other area's, such as requirements gathering and project management.
- contravariant 4y ago> This is a conjecture that desperately needs resolving with solid statistics and in-depth interviews. Ironic that a hypothesis that most people won't need mathematics should require solid statistics to resolve.
- jfengel 4y agoIn this case, the solid statistics have more to do with the humanities than with the actual mathematics. The math of that kind of stats is fairly easy, but designing a meaningful study of how people learn and apply what they learn requires a ton of work in sociology, psychology, and economics. You have to work around numerous ethical and pragmatic constraints, and deal with millions of confounding variables.
- AlbertCory 4y agoI was curious about Bryan Kaplan, since he seemed hard to categorize, so I did some research. Hate to say it, but he looks like a Malcolm Gladwell wannabe with some attention-grabbing book titles. Perfect for a TED talk.
- culi 4y agoNice you managed to categorize the work of this person who's been around 20 years longer than Gladwell. The important thing is that you found a way to place yourself above them without ever making a real criticism :)
- orzig 4y agoI disagree with many things he says, but don’t think he can be dismissed so easily. How many other public intellectuals have even attempted, let alone nailed, anything like this? https://www.econlib.org/my-complete-bet-wiki/ https://www.econlib.org/my-complete-bet-wiki/
- Hasu 4y agoBryan Caplan didn't even write the article, Caplan just posted it. The article is by David Edwards, who is a mathematics professor. This is literally the first line of the posted link. EDIT: I would add that Caplan is a working researcher who has made significant and original contributions to economics, where Gladwell is a journalist who interprets the work of scholars like Caplan. If anything, Gladwell is a Caplan wannabe (although I wouldn't characterize either of them in that fashion, I think they have different goals and methods)
- obviouslynotme 4y agoI am one of the exceptions that uses higher level mathematics on a regular basis at work. I agree with his theory that teaching everyone calculus, or preparing to take it, is not necessary for most. The problem I have is that he is looking at averages. In my experience, there are five tiers: counting, arithmetic, algebra, calculus, and higher math. The USA is simultaneously sending more people to the top two and bottom two, with the bottom two going from a small few to a real population segment. I don't even know if the worst public schools teach anything anymore or if they are just pseudo-prisons to capture taxes. I won't even go into the woeful state of logical and statistical knowledge. I don't know why those aren't core requirements for graduating high school.
- epgui 4y agoWow, this is exactly the sort of anti-intellectualist drivel that makes me lose faith in humanity. And oh, the irony of dismissing the case for mathematics as a thinking aid as “self-serving nonsense” for which the author has “a very low opinion”! Perhaps if the author had a better attitude towards education and was capable of appreciating the value of mathematics (or more generally, science) in everyday life (to say nothing about the importance of this in democracies), then he would not hold this infantile opinion. Sorry, not sorry. Edit: the point is not whether you “use it” when you’re out and about doing your groceries. If you’re judging the value of maths and science by this measure, you’re missing the point, and you’re at such a low level of insight that your perspective is useful to nobody. Rule of thumb: don’t listen to anti-intellectualists.
- barry-cotter 4y ago> Perhaps if the author had a better attitude towards education and was capable of appreciating the value of mathematics (or more generally, science) in everyday life (to say nothing about the importance of this in democracies), then he would not hold this infantile opinion. Caplan has a doctorate, teaches at a university, has written several books and home educated two of his sons to a level where they published academically before they entered university. He’s also more well read in philosophy and literature than average though that is a low bar to clear. If you don’t think a professor of Mathematics, David Edwards, understands the value of Mathematics why do you think you do?
- _hcuq 4y agoA professor of mathematics would have a vested interest, don’t you think? Your logic is faulty,
- barry-cotter 4y agoIndeed, when someone argues against their own interests we should take them more seriously, not less. That Edwards thinks the main arguments for teaching advanced Math is garbage when that’s his livelihood should make us look at it closely.
- vsareto 4y agoThere is a lot of statecraft behind governments promoting this myth, so I wouldn't be reading into it too much. The countries listed want as high as possible of a population of scientists, and they will forecast doom and gloom to try and convince anyone with a passing amount of patriotism to work in those fields. There never was a clear proof that we needed more.
- nicodjimenez 4y agoI started a math tools company (mathpix.com) and I could not agree more! US needs humanities far more than STEM. US is extremely strong at STEM and extremely weak at humanities. This includes understanding of the real world and human affairs. Young people now have zero understanding of religion, the military, geopolitics, or really how to think critically about ANYTHING related to social sciences. The truth about the reason for the death of social sciences in the US is a dark and complex one, I’m not even so sure that truth is even important. What matters is what’s next, and it had to start with a little bit of realist humanities education for young people.
- mym1990 4y agoA curriculum focused on STEM or a curriculum focused on humanities would do little to change how the younger generation thinks about the world. The reality is that current education patterns are stuck in rigid patterns that confine creativity into a small box for a majority of students. There are rules upon rules upon rules which disable student from thinking critically and creatively.
- tzs 4y agoJohn Adams, second president of the United States, in a letter written to his wife in May 1780: > I must study Politicks and War that my sons may have liberty to study Mathematicks and Philosophy. My sons ought to study Mathematicks and Philosophy, Geography, natural History, Naval Architecture, navigation, Commerce and Agriculture, in order to give their Children a right to study Painting, Poetry, Musick, Architecture, Statuary, Tapestry and Porcelaine. Somewhere along the line it seems we got stuck at what Adams wanted his sons to study, and never really moved on to what he hoped his grandchildren could study.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoI feel like integrating the two more could help. A big issue with the motivation to learn math is that it doesn't tell a compelling story for students for many years. But perhaps that could change.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoI've used calculus very little, algebra quite a lot. One of the side-benefits of learning calculus (apart from reading others' work) is how much solving those problems reinforces your algebra skills. Solving one scary calculus problem thrown at me as an undergrad - an integral - resulted in a solution which broke it into 16 separate integrals. Days of algebra were involved.
- eli_gottlieb 4y agoWhat in the actual fuck? Apparently I must be in "the 10%".
- Manuel_D 4y agoYou might not be writing out integrals and derivatives by hand, but I think most engineers use calculus a lot more frequently than they realize it. * If daily user growth is increasing linearly, total user count is exponential over time. * If I have a radially symmetric shape it's center of gravity is going to be centered on the axis of symmetry - if the density is uniform. But if the density isn't uniform, where will the center of balance shift? This is single dimension and multi-dimensional calculus, respectively. I bet most engineers use at least the former, at an intuitive level, on a regular basis.
- flopquads 4y ago"total user count is exponential over time" No, it's quadratic over time.
- xvedejas 4y agoIf daily user growth is increasing linearly, total user count is squaring over time. Exponential growth would be when daily growth is proportional to the current number of users, which is different.
- colinmhayes 4y ago> If daily user growth is increasing linearly, total user count is exponential over time. cracking me up here
- hnfong 4y agoIndeed. Maybe it's considered higher math where the GP lives, but I think I definitely learned basic concepts of quadratic functions by 8th grade...
- time_to_smile 4y agoMy experience learning math as a programmer was that there was a strange relationship between how much math I understood and how useful I felt math was. When I didn't understand calculus I thought that was pretty unessential for being a good programmer. Strange thing though, after learning calculus I find myself using to help understand or model problems a couple of times a week at least. When I didn't understand linear algebra I didn't see how useful it was for anything outside of the obvious niches like graphics programming. But once I learned it I was able to reduce a remarkable number of complex problems to literally 1-3 lines of code. Even when I knew statistics, I didn't see much use in all that fancy advanced theoretical stuff. Now I find one of the most useful, practical tools when modeling problems is the Laplace approximation, and knowing the Cramer-Rao bound let's me realize the limits of the results I get from this. Perhaps most famously, the great mathematician G.H. Hardy, in 1940, discussed how permanently impractical and "useless" number theory was (to be clear, he cited this as a virtue of number theory) in his Mathematicians Apology. Just a few years later Alan Turing (and several others) realized that number theory was the key to securing (and undermining) cryptographic systems. The lesson for me has been that programmers (and I'm sure many other professions) have a habit of finding good uses for the math they've learned.
- dgs_sgd 4y agoYour work sounds very interesting. Would you mind sharing more about the kind of programming you do?
- hamiltonians 4y agocryptography is just a tiny part of number theory
- aaron695 4y ago
- oh_sigh 4y agoAs a SWE at a FANG, I need to use college level math maybe...2-3 times a year? Almost never. But, when I do need to use it, it is for situations where I would probably never come up with an adequate solution if I hadn't studied those areas of math.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoYou don't use concepts from Discrete Math more than that?
- oh_sigh 4y agoWell...not that I explicitly recognize, but I'm sure it is possible that having been trained in it in the past, I may see certain problems a certain way. I guess I should phrase it like: I learned some math 15+ years ago but then after college I did not continue studying math or even continue refreshing the things I already learned, and I only find myself studying math-related concepts a couple times a year in my job.
- ultra_nick 4y agoEh, I don't think this has been tested. We've only taught a population to memorize random math functions. We haven't succeeded in widespread understanding of math ever. The welfare cliff and similar issues wouldn't happen if people could communicate using continuous functions.
- gumby 4y ago> I ... had two students in the class who had been engineers and one who had been an actuary. They claimed never to have used anything beyond Excel and eighth grade level mathematics; never a trig function or even a log or exponential function! That seems incredible to me. I guess that means I live in a bubble.
- maximus-decimus 4y agoThat means they never did napkin math to know what an investment might be worth in x years.
- gumby 4y agoAnd never used trig???
- hnfong 4y agoWhat on the napkin would be incomprehensible to an intelligent 8th grade student? Surely they would have learned concepts of compound interest by then?
- maximus-decimus 4y agoI don't know for you, but exponentials and compound interest was advanced 11th grade math at my school.
- alistairSH 4y agoDid I miss the thesis? He concludes with a statement that isn’t even true. Higher mathematics should be offered and taken by those who need it, or want it; but never required of all students. I studied economics and computer science at a top-20 university. I did a grand total of one course in the math department (1st semester calculus). Everything else was specific to my areas of study. I don’t recall anybody being forced to take high level mathematics outside of engineering programs. Even within the hard sciences, the requirement was usually something like “take 2 semesters of math, plus statistics.” Or something like that. Would the author also argue that since I don’t use history at my job I should never have taken government, architectural history, or a survey of western religions? Those all contribute to my understanding of the world around me. As does math. If his point is we need more generalists with a broad understanding of the world, including social sciences and history, that could be a valid point, but it’s not the one he made.
- colinmhayes 4y agoMy top 20 school had us take 4 semesters of calculus and 2 other math department classes for a cs degree. The econ major only required one semester of calculus. The upper level micro classes ended up being funny because they spent a considerable amount of time teaching multivariable calculus since taking derivatives is 90% of microeconomics. They even spent multiple classes proving lagrange multipliers without ever referring to them by name.
- alistairSH 4y agoThat micro comment sounds about right - my degree didn’t require many specific courses in the math department, but we did plenty of math as part of the program, it was just tailored to the specific thing we were trying to do.
- tomrod 4y agoEconomists describe this kind of filter (requiring higher math) in terms of separating equilibria for skills. The conceptual idea is that the separation is too costly for the low skilled group, and even a portion of the high skilled group cannot afford to pay the costly achievement. This is very much in line with Caplan's prior views. It holds true to a degree, but probably isn't universal.
- bee_rider 4y agoIn my engineering degree, the instructor would do the hard math on the board (or hand wave it away), and then often we'd hit the end result with a taylor series expansion or something like that. This gives a nice locally linear model that we could play around with using good old algebra. Sure -- most engineers shouldn't use advanced math, because that's easy to screw up. But either they are aware that their linear models came from some more complex equations that have been simplified, or they are living in a magic demon-haunted world where equations are just runes handed down by mystic sages. Hopefully it is the former! Teaching engineers the hard math serves dual purposes -- it helps them understand where their models come from, and somebody is going to have to invent the models. They are one population that has already shown at least some mathematical aptitude.
- fungiblecog 4y agoThis is dumb. Math is not just a set of tools you take out of a toolbox to solve specific problems. Math is a way of thinking. It's invaluable for solving all kinds of problems.
- siddMahen 4y agoHigher mathematics isn’t about performing fancy calculations — it’s rare to find a calculation that requires some higher mathematical tools that can’t be done more simply using elementary methods. So it’s no wonder people aren’t explicitly using higher mathematics everyday. Instead, higher mathematics allows you to add powerful new features to your mental models, and reason about these features accurately and effectively. A key example: the Fourier transform. Understanding a signal in terms of its frequency components is immensely valuable for understanding how periodic phenomena work, and since periodic systems are ubiquitous, this often leads to concrete insights into concrete problems. With this more sophisticated understanding of the problem, you can write down a solution that can be implemented with “8th grade algebra and a little programming”. Other similar examples: singular value decomposition, spectral decomposition, probabilistic reasoning (MLE, Bayesian inference). It’s important to equip people with the tools required to build powerful mental models of the world around them, so they can solve hard problems. Higher mathematics offers many such tools.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt is telling that this is a reprint of an essay by a mathematics professor. Of course they think their work has no real world application. It'll take two or three generations worth of dumbing it down before us mortals can turn it into a nice computer vision algorithm or something like that.
- leephillips 4y agoFew people use poetry, Greek philosophy, or history in their jobs either. We teach students mathematics in order to acquaint them with the civilization of which they are a part. Good teachers try to get them to appreciate the beauty and grandness of this bedrock of human culture as part of the process of transforming them into people. Who cares if they never “use” calculus in their dreary jobs. The don’t “use” Shakespeare either. And who are these “engineers” who don’t use math, but just plug numbers into Excel? I am afraid of China. I’ve met many of their engineers and scientists, and they sure as hell know math.
- barry-cotter 4y ago> And who are these “engineers” who don’t use math, but just plug numbers into Excel? I am afraid of China. I’ve met many of their engineers and scientists, and they sure as hell know math. Chinese engineering education is far inferior to Western according to every person I’ve ever met here who hired fresh graduates. I live in China.
- taeric 4y agoI mean, you aren't wrong on the lead in. But, the person you are talking to agrees. The number one position that most schools prepare students for, at face value, is to be a teacher at a school. The author makes a fairly compelling case against the way education is directed at kids today. And a lot of it is hinged on just how poorly adults show that they have learned in school. This includes in the area of critical thinking, where college students don't perform that much better than you would expect from non college level students.
- mrtnmcc 4y ago>> They [engineers] claimed never to have used anything beyond Excel and eighth grade level mathematics; never a trig function or even a log or exponential function! As a counterpoint, I use math on a daily basis as a principal engineer (architecting SpaceX's Starlink). In particular: lots of geometry/trig, optimization theory, linear algebra, Fourier analysis, quaternions, probability/statistics, control theory, dynamic programming, numerical methods. This is typically in the service of modeling physical systems, modulating or demodulation RF waveforms, and controlling or compensating for electrical circuits, orbital dynamics, etc.. The value of math is that it is an especially portable skill-- you can work in many fields and it still applies. I've worked so far in bio-sciences, chip design, and satellites / space. In each case the value of math was very high. US citizens are indeed underrepresented in mathematical degrees. In graduate school at MIT, the vast majority of my peers were not US citizens (EECS department). It's great the best and brightest from around the world study here, the US government should try hard to incentivize them to stick around (green cards, etc).
- jpasmore 4y agoIf 15% of 9th graders go on to become programmers, scientists, actuaries, etc (where maybe 40% (at best) of these use calc, probability, linear algebra, etc.), then at least 85% of 9th graders are talking math that they will never use. Side note, the same could be said for Chemistry and Biology -- while interesting in the abstract maybe, the actual utility is minimal. I have never had to balance a stoichiometric equation nor do I expect to to see one any time soon. I would agree, as a guess, that learning "higher" math helps you think more clearly or in a more focused way for a longer period of time.
- SyzygistSix 4y ago>If 15% of 9th graders go on to become programmers, scientists, actuaries, etc (where maybe 40% (at best) of these use calc, probability, linear algebra, etc.), then at least 85% of 9th graders are talking math that they will never use. Except to understand the context of the work those people do, which touches most of everyday life.
- topkai22 4y agoTo abuse an old adage about advertising "2/3s of my education was a waste. The problem is I don't know which 1/3 is useful." The usefulness of math, engineering, or computer science education in industry is typically in knowing how your tools work under the hood and being able to apply that knowledge to infrequently optimize them or extend them. It also helps to be able to transfer between similar tools/jobs/occupations with less lead time. From a society wide view, I'd argue we as a society benefit from pushing everyone toward STEM type education because even if 75% of people who go that route never utilize their training the 25% who do have an outsized impact on our collective well being. Overcommiting to STEM is necessary because we don't know who will be become our technical innovators a priori, so we try to make sure everyone with the potential to be a technical innovator is equipped with the tools to do so.
- ary 4y agoThe author seems to be completely blind to the underlying issue. Lack of numeracy, much less advanced numeracy, in the general population makes it difficult to communicate about complex topics. Communication with the general population is key. You don't "use" it because there isn't demand for its use. The advances we dream about in the sciences are retarded by a widespread lack of understanding regarding how those advances are made, how long they might take, what they cost, and what costs would be offset by their achievement. If anything needs to change it's the teaching of mathematics primarily as a language to describe everyday life more accurately. The question every grade school child asks, "why do I need this", requires an irrefutable answer that doesn't need several years worth of prerequisite knowledge. Then we need to get on with improving our civilization.
- rad88 4y ago> the teaching of mathematics primarily as a language to describe everyday life more accurately What does this refer to? And how would it affect physical sciences and biology?
- corrral 4y ago> If anything needs to change it's the teaching of mathematics primarily as a language to describe everyday life more accurately. The question every grade school child asks, "why do I need this", requires an irrefutable answer that doesn't need several years worth of prerequisite knowledge. Then we need to get on with improving our civilization. This. This right here. You can tell kids that math is super-important but they're just going to look at all the barely-numerate adults in their lives who seem to be doing just fine without it, and at all the nothing they encounter in their own lives that seems to call for much more than basic arithmetic, and decide you're a liar or some kind of weirdo, like the dude who's super into model trains and keeps telling them how fun it is (yeah, sure buddy, I bet it is) Reading doesn't need to be sold. It's useful everywhere, constantly, and you don't need to look for uses. It's even very useful for stuff that kids really want to do, like playing video games. You don't do 13 years of it and then find that almost the only part you ever use is the alphabet, and wonder why all those reading nuts wasted so much of your time with it and why some other lunatics are telling you that now you still have to do even more to get a college degree. For most kids, math needs to be sold to them. And that's not happening.
- tzs 4y agoPeople who found that article interesting (regardless of whether they agreed with it or not) might find the article "What is Mathematics For?" [1] by Underwood Dudley from the May 2010 Notices of the AMS interesting. [1] http://www.ams.org/notices/201005/rtx100500608p.pdf http://www.ams.org/notices/201005/rtx100500608p.pdf
- Blackstrat 4y agoIn the software development space, primarily in the financial sector, I’ve always been surprised by the number of developers who didn’t understand basic concepts from math, like Boolean algebra (DeMorgan can certainly be useful), logarithms, exponential functions (e.g. compounded or continuous growth), etc. I would have preferred that programmers had more understanding rather than less. Can’t one do all this in Excel? Sure, but actually knowing what one is doing seems to be beneficial. The article reminds me of Asimov’s Foundation: use the machine but hope they never break.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ouid 4y agoPreliminary complaint: Anything that can be "transferred to" from mathematics becomes mathematics, thereby removing it from contention. I think this take would have benefit from some mathematical experience. Mathematicians are mainly adept at discarding their beliefs. The rule of consistency, ie that my beliefs should not allow me to reach contradictions, is slippery to apply, and generally requires a lot of practice. Practice that is by far most easily obtained through a formal math curriculum, where it is least difficult to overcome the first hurdle of getting someone to agree that this rule exists in the first place, and the second hurdle of convincing someone that the contradiction does in fact follow from the assumptions. There is a lot of finesse involved, and that finesse comes with experience. In the real world, people assume things without proof, and this makes the ability to heuristically generate counterexamples on the fly much more important. All of my argument of course depends upon a world in which mathematics is actually the thing being taught, rather than whatever grotesque projection of it children are shown in school, but let's not pretend that that projection bears any resemblance to mathematics.
- smitty1e 4y ago> In sports there is the concept of the specificity of skills: if you want to improve your racquetball game, don’t practice squash! I believe the same holds true for intellectual skills. Do not concur. The former is concrete; the latter abstract. The ability to connect dots of information in unexpected ways is indirectly connected with physical prowess, at best.
- ksaj 4y agoI remember learning Boolean math in grade 10. I thought it was the stupidest thing in the world. Then later on I started learning Assembly and the lightbulb finally went on over my head. I finally understood it, and it totally made sense that what I'd learned in that class was super valuable. Math is context.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoWe would do well to figure out ways to make that lightbulb come on sooner for students. It's easy to tell kids that mathematics is the secret language that explains the universe and how it works. Demonstrating that in a compelling way would be great.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dataangel 4y agoWhat a rosy idea of what constitutes 8th grade math. My 8th grade math had no statistics and no programming. Hell I didn't get any of either until college.
- FullyFunctional 4y agoThis irks me greatly. I never ever use Excel and only rarely spreadsheet (and only for easy graphing). I use 1st year university-level math very frequently (stats, algebra, etc), but very very rarely anything more advanced. PhD in CS, not from a school on his list.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dang 4y agoDiscussed at the time: The Math Myth - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12418788 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12418788 - Sept 2016 (313 comments)
- jnash 4y agoAdvanced math is an absolute necessary for leading edge science and engineering. Nations without well educated scientists and engineers will not stay competitive for long. Having said that, it is only a small percentage of the population who will be able to learn and understand advanced math. So the question is how to select and educate that percentage without first trying to educate everybody. Splitting children into different groups based on IQ might be the optimum solution but it is never popular in general. So what to do?
- jnash 4y agoSo the author failed at math, feels crap about it, and now wants to convince himself and everybody else that math is useless anyway. OK got it.
- FranzFerdiNaN 4y agoThe author is literally a math professor, but sure, he failed at math.
- vkazanov 4y agoI got my Electrical Eng degree 15 years ago. This included reasonably advanced calculus, statistics, linear algebra and trigonometry. Been working as a programmer for 15 years now. I always felt needed MORE math: number theory, trigonometry, statistics, combinatorics, etc. The funny thing is that I started realising I'd need a lot of math even before working professionally. As a kid I wanted to understand game engines and ray tracers, so trigonometry and linear algebra were what was lacking. At some point I worked on a search engine of the bigger kind. Back in the day this meant I had to touch statistics and machine learning, distributed systems, computer science theory. I enjoy understanding my programming languages on the deepest level possible. And there's a lot of math-based and comp-sci stuff in compilers as well! In these days, original whitepapers are available for anybody to read. Not wikipedia, not story retold - the real stuff. Not being fluent in math means not being able to consume the most interesting part of the treasure. Surely, math is not directly applicable to web-dev or whatever the latest flavour of UI building is now. And that's a lion's share of work available today. The secret is that math is not like some kind of specialised tech. It's more like a language. Being able to read it gives access to more knowledge the same way reading is a way to get access to written knowledge.
- DantesKite 4y agoBryan makes a pretty good point in my opinion. And not even just about math, but education in general. For all of our technological advances, we seem woefully short of figuring out the best way to educate a human being, identifying their talents, and making the experience useful and enlightening. And it does feel like there's a lot of labor and energy going into teaching subjects that for the most part, people never use again. Some people argue that it teaches you the meta-skill of learning how to learn, but if that was true, you could literally just teach the meta-skill itself, instead of teaching it indirectly. And in some ways I sort of get that at the end of the day, what you're really trying to do is predict the future; what skills will be relevant to which people and so you go with a shotgun approach and go deeper and broader than most people will need, just in case. Maybe efficiency is overrated. Maybe it's better to waste time learning about things you may not necessarily use. But I do wonder what the opposite approach would look like.
- SyzygistSix 4y ago>Bryan makes a pretty good point in my opinion. And not even just about math, but education in general. For all of our technological advances, we seem woefully short of figuring out the best way to educate a human being, identifying their talents, and making the experience useful and enlightening. If that was his central point, I would agree. >Some people argue that it teaches you the meta-skill of learning how to learn, but if that was true, you could literally just teach the meta-skill itself, instead of teaching it indirectly. I think it is. And I sucked at math in school. I think it is a meta-skill every bit as much as reading is and nearly as important. But so are some of the other soft skills that we are not teaching kids.
- rimliu 4y agoI wonder, why do people got to gym. How often do they need to lift barbell or run in real life? Math is workout for the brains and also teaches how to analyse and solve problems. Maybe that's just a useless skill, what do I know, I was good at math.
- parentheses 4y agoI have often wondered what makes the supremacy of the United States sustain. Same thing makes this a myth.
- fiziks_hckr 4y agoMath not necessary being about numbers but concepts is something I'm really happy to see : ) in sibling comments on this article in HN.
- lordnacho 4y agoThe conclusion I've come to is this: The kind of person who is useful in engineering is that person who gets to the bottom of things. They not only find a way to understand the problem, they also find a robust solution. You come across this kind of thing on HN often, like that article about the guy who opens safes with a device hidden in a marker pen. For 99% of people, that level of effort is incomprehensibly deep. I mean you really have to know a heck of a lot about the subject, and you have to be willing to hurdle quite a lot of issues in the solution as well. Math is the ultimate get-to-the-bottom-of-things subject. That kid who asks you to explain Euler's identity, who wants to know why only 23 people are needed for half of such groups to share a common birthday, and wonders whether there's something deeper than complex numbers when looking at polynomials. The kid who diligently expands his binomials just to see that the formula is actually right. That kid is also the one who will figure out why your rocket is malfunctioning, how your car will drive itself, how to fix carbon dioxide, and every other problem that we call a technical problem. So yes, you don't need advanced math to do a lot of these things, and maybe doing advanced math doesn't even help you do these things. But math is a sort of flag that suggests you can get to the bottom of whatever problem you're faced with.
- epigramx 4y agoYou might be describing forms of OCD too. Sometimes the "engineering-smart" thing to do is to not look into it. There's only so much time.
- trashtester 4y agoYep. But "math" at various levels of depth is also helpful in guiding and inspiring thought. For instance, without stats, decisioning processes quickly become "gut feelings". But a little stat can be misleading, as seen in problems like p-hacking. To use statistical thinking generically, not by following some recipe, you need to understand calculus. Algerbra (linear- and abstract) similarly help structuring logical problems. Linear algebra builds an intuition for organizing problems into dimensions, and and can be useful for semmingly unrelated efforts, such as organizing work (by finding activities that are orthogonal or linearly dependent), and more related effort, such as vectorizing code. Abstract algebra is useful for thinking about symmetries and for transforming concepts into each other. It creates bridges between areas of mathmatic, like complex numbers and matrices. (Things like Euler's identity becomes easy to grasp if considering the unit circly on the omplex plane as a group, and this in turn remove the "magic" from complex numbers.) In computer science, algebra can provide intuitions for seemingly unrelated tasks, such as refactoring. Basically, tranform the "algebraic structure" of your code to a simpler one. Precisely how much of this kind of benefit people will get from knowing math probably depends on their talent for logical thinking. At the lower end, anything beyond basic arithmetic may not provide much value. But the close someone come to the gifted side of the spectrum, the more secondary benefits may be gained from knowing more math. A gifted person with the same education as an average person may be twice as productive, buth add some math, and that becomes 4x. Now, if the hypothesis above is true, math would turn a linear curve into a parabolic curve. Math/stats could both be used to test that, but even just coming up with the hypothesis requires some inclination to think mathmatically, beyond mere arithmetic. And, obviously, if the different between average and good math education is the same as the difference between the area under a parabolic vs linear curve, someone who learned calculus would instantly know how massive the economic benefit might be.
- yobbo 4y agoAnyone with some ability to understand the SIR model, and some statistics/probability, could gain some clarity and guidance what was happening in the pandemic. Complete lack of knowledge left people vulnerable to superstitions. Using everyday as a tool is not the benchmark for whether it is having impact.
- misslibby 4y agoPolitics is increasingly driven by "studies" and calls to authority of assumed experts. "Listen to the scientists" is the demand by modern authoritarians, while huge chunks of science have a reproducibility issue, among other issues plaguing the system. A good foundation in understanding scientific claims and evaluating proofs seems essential in such times. Maths is an essential part of that.
- trashtester 4y agoI agreee. If we want to keep democracy, the kids need to learn more math and science.
- Koshkin 4y agoThe math and science education was very good in the Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union. It is very good in China. Rather, as the US Constitution has bluntly put it, if we want to keep democracy, "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." The above examples seem to support this.
- trashtester 4y agoI agree with you that an armed populace is one factor that supports democracy In fact, I believe that the invention of firearms democratized military might by making the professional soldier (knight, man-at-arms or Swiss style mercernary) obsolete. In a time where military might was determined by how many men could be drafted into service, a government could only retain power through the support of those drafted men. A rule by "all drafted men", in other words, is the foundation of democracy. Like most societies, a democracy is rule by the predominant warrior caste. In the greek democracies, all male citizens were serving as hoplites. That was teh basis for their "democracy". The Roman republic had legions of citizens (until Marius), enabling another form of citizen rule. Then came the Marian reforms, with professional soldiers controlled by the elite. Almost directly after, Sulla, Caesar and Octavian introduced the Roman Empire. 500 years later, the Romans in Western Europe were overrun by Germanic chiefs. Their elite soldiers became the armored knights of the Medieval Europe, and they introduced Feudalism, where power was held by the nobility (and sometimes shared with a king, who was often quite weak). Then came the age of the pike armed Swiss mercenaries and similar non-noble military formations more similar to the legions of Imperial Rome. This gave many European monarchs full controls. The founding fathers saw this, and rightly predicted that armed citizens was an ingredient in ensuring governance by the people. In Europe it would take another 150 years or so for this to play out. Many on the left will not realize this. They think that democracy is self-sustaining regardless of potential for the elites to be corrupted and sieze the power. The founding fathers had studied their history. They knew about Marius and Sulla and how the Roman elites quickly had taken control once the citizens were no longer the backbone of the army. The founding fathers were not "common people", but rather highly educated members of the elites. Their existence had been made possible by a monarchical system, and they bore many similarities with the elites of the Roman empire (the senators). The guns may give the power to rule, but not the wisdom, and people like Thomas Jefferson understood this. And this is where the understanding of the populist right falls short. Thomas Jefferson in particular was a proponent of quality education for the citizenry, he thought that "no other sure foundation can be devised for the preservation of freedom and happiness". In other words, not only guns but also books were needed to keep the people free (and happy). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Jefferson_and_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Jefferson_and_education When citizens completely lose the ability to understand the world in which they live. He promoted the teaching of "Science and Virtue", but was concerned about intellectuals from "tyrannies" in Europe. Maybe he anticipated something like the Frankfurt School? The only way to prevent demagogues (like Ceasar) who promise to people that which is impossible to deliver, is to: 1) Make sure the people know enough Science to be able to know the possible from the impossible. 2) Make sure people know enough history to recognize what values are true Virtues that lead to healthy societies, and which are hollow lies, more suitable for use by would-be-dictators to gain control.
- zasdffaa 4y ago> The second argument is the one I always hear around the mathematics department: mathematics helps you to think clearly. I have a very low opinion of this self-serving nonsense[2] Disagree. It definitely changed the way I think, and I'm no mathematician. Also calling something 'nonsense' this way is an argument smell; no justification + ad-hom = "in my opinion". Problem is, you have to be at a very high level of maths[1] and be in the right place to use that before it becomes useful, but then it becomes vital at an industry or country level. Personal opinion: change the way maths is taught. It is so appallingly taught so often, starting with abstractions and no examples, not acknowledging that so many (like me) are competent but aren't brilliant minded, and we are not abstract thinkers, so root your abstractions in the concrete to get them over. Smart people just don't understand that we don't understand. [1] I'm going to regret this, but here's me making an idiot of myself over a maths paper yesterday, just getting the wrong end of the stick massively https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31643296 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31643296 [2] Added full quote after, sorry
- dash2 4y agoYes, I agree. I had a "humanities" style education - lots of essay writing, deep reading of classics in many languages. When I was 16, I burned my maths books under the apple tree. Then during my PhD I had to learn maths again. It taught me what a real argument was. Before then, I was blindly wandering in a sea of text. After it, I still appreciate the classics, but I understand the structure of argumentation far better.
- yobbo 4y ago> There is in fact a deskilling going on in our economy ... Yes, but in "software engineering" this has been a deliberate goal for decades. Every new language and platform is intended to make things easier and safer. One can debate what educational backgrounds are actually legitimate requirements for doing web frontends and such, but that's a debate for the recruiters to have. It shouldn't impact the curriculums.
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y agoI partially agree with this. Many engineers use little advanced math in their daily work. After years, they also forget certain things. However, from the point of view of a software developer, there are a few branches of math that tend to be very useful even if you're stuck doing some boring front-end work. I especially mean discrete math: it really pays off to study the ideas and solve some problems. In your mind, you will immediately try to translate them into code. There are some intangible benefits of this that will materialize sooner or later.
- coldtea 4y ago>Math Myth Conjecture: If one restricts one’s attention to the hardest cases, namely, graduates of top engineering schools such as MIT, RPI, Cal. Tech., Georgia Tech., etc., then the percent of such individuals holding engineering as opposed to management, financial or other positions, and using more than Excel and eighth grade level mathematics (arithmetic, a little bit of algebra, a little bit of statistics, and a little bit of programming) is less than 25% and possibly less than 10%. So? How does this follow: "Acceptance of the conjecture should have revolutionary educational implications . In particular, it undermines the legitimacy of requiring higher mathematics of all students. Such mathematics is actually needed by only a minute fraction of the workforce." The conjecture (if it holds) just states that only few use higher mathematics. Not that things wouldn't improve if more used them, and also if more "commoners" had a better understanding of basic mathematics (because even "basic algebra" and "excel" are way above tons of people)... Starting with: "The math myth is the myth that the future of the American economy is dependent upon the masses having higher mathematics skills". And concluding that it is false, because "even the vast majority of scientists just use little and lower level math" is a non sequitur.
- bluenose69 4y agoIt's not just Mathematics. I've heard of Science professors who use English scores to sift through PhD applicants. They reason this to be an effective way to find the strongest amongst otherwise equal candidates. (There is also a benefit in terms of writing papers, but writing strengths cannot make up for scientific weakness. Thus, writing is not the central point, as mathematical ability is not the central point in this econlib.org essay.) I've not seen "gold standard" (large, randomized, double-blinded, ...) studies of the effectiveness of this selection strategy. And I don't know how such studies could even be done: in research departments, it costs a lot to take on PhD students, and a lot rests on their success.
- metajunkies 4y agoThe author perfunctorily wrote the essay. By the gist of it, they sound like an elitist snob.
- bo1024 4y agoA few points I haven’t seen raised yet. 1) I bet a far fewer percentage of people use Shakespeare, Steinbeck, or any other literature in their jobs. Is this an argument for eliminating literature from the curriculum? Why or why not? 2) The percentage that do use higher level math are extremely useful to society, but the infrastructure that educates that smaller percentage needs to be large and widespread and accessible to all. A system that selectively educates a small amount of kids in valuable skills probably turns into a privilege filter and decreases the amount of talent educates massively.
- zmgsabst 4y agoRegarding (2): The participation in calculus class seems to have been the best predictor for who would “get out the hood” now that it’s been 15 years since we graduated. Shutting that pipeline down because the managerial class doesn’t see the point reeks of privileged nonsense — like removing AP classes because they offend the racial sensibilities of that same managerial class. How about you stop destroying lives to express your privilege? - - - - - I also just don’t buy the premise: a lot of people use concepts from advanced math routinely, even if they don’t set up equations.
- popcube 4y agostatistic is important for democracy working. how can politicians display their strategy work, show some statistical analysis results.
- WillPostForFood 4y agoa lot of people use concepts from advanced math routinely For example?
- zmgsabst 4y agoMy experience is biased since I work in technology, but: - the actuaries and economists I worked with used calculus, statistics, and linear algebra (even if software did the calculations) - the mechanical and electronics engineers I worked with used calculus, control theory, and signal theory (even if software did the calculations) - SDEs use type theory and category theory (and the equivalence of them), as well as implementing the math above (even if libraries did the calculations) and things such as discrete math and graph theory to reason about data structures For people I haven’t worked with, but know: - biotech workers use calculus concepts and statistics - Boeing engineers use calculus, statistics, and complicated simulations - physicists have a whole bucket of mathematics they use
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoSince it's in econlib, maybe there's that smug kind of economics answer to this issue. Are scientists all using 8th Grade math? Maybe that subset of math became 8th grade math, because it was the subset that was most used. Maybe the big top level planning already happened via lots of micro-transactions and came to the right answer. edit: commented before I got to the end, I think this is what they're arguing, though they're not being smug about it. I think I'd agree with them more if they weren't dissing Excel. Don't use it myself, but it (and it's predecessors/analogues) are powerful tools. Widely used and abused, for good and bad.
- henrik_w 4y agoSomewhat related: The Importance of Mathematics Courses in Computer Science Education http://devlinsangle.blogspot.com/2015/04/the-importance-of-mathematics-courses.html http://devlinsangle.blogspot.com/2015/04/the-importance-of-m...
- usrn 4y agoIMO a lot of this is just heavy competition because of elite over production because life is becoming unlivable for the working class. No amount of rearranging curricula will fix this.
- TrackerFF 4y agoWhen I studied engineering, and later math and physics - the overwhelming consensus was that the TWO philosophy classes we had, were useless BS classes. Total waste of time. No "real-life" application. To me, that was very disheartening. Philosophy is the foundation of all academia, and will work as a basis for all things both in your academic life, and life in general. But that was very much a product of the "If it's not math/engineering/hard science, then it must be a wishy-washy nonsense without real-life applications" Which is also what a lot of technocrats seem to believe. Whether or not something is "useful", depends on how you look at it, and apply it. I'm sure a lot of STEM students would greatly benefit having some liberal arts classes (or similar). If nothing for making you a more well-rounded person.
- gumby 4y ago> the overwhelming consensus was that the TWO philosophy classes we had, were useless BS classes. Total waste of time. No "real-life" application. Dickens used Professor Gradgrind to mock this attitude back in the 1850s in Hard Times. It’s just a grownup’s version of “will this be on the test?”. Some things never change.
- bee_rider 4y agoA lack of understanding of the philosophy of science is how we get engineers who confuse their models with reality and try to invent perpetual motion machines.
- rossdavidh 4y agoI have worked as a manufacturing/process engineer in the semiconductor industry (~10 years) and a programmer (~20 years). I have had frequent cause to use software which did math (beyond arithmetic and basic algebra), but seldom if ever needed to do it myself. I suppose the argument for learning how to do it yourself is that you have a better intuition about what the computer is doing for you, and thus can spot when something is wrong. The problem is that "it helps you think better" applies to lots of things, like being fluent in a second language, understanding ancient history in depth, studying great literature, etc. We don't require them, beyond an introductory class or two. We also have the ratio between calculus and statistics entirely wrong, with much more of the latter required in most engineering degree programs, whereas the latter is much more often going to come up in work (and the rest of life).
- dizzant 4y agoI use high math (very high math — control theory, numerical analysis, theory of optimization) in my day job as I finish grad school. I believe the article is correct in that I am one of very few in my office who actually employ this level of skill. I suspect that many enterprises are the same, in that a small number of technical experts are supported by a large cast of surrounding actors. But it is essential that the others share in the technical knowledge! How could managers evaluate my performance, make decisions about where to apply my skills, or understand my value if they knew nothing more than high school math? How would I remain sane with no one around to rubber duck proofs or concepts to, to commiserate or bounce ideas with? Sufficiently advanced technology is equivalent to magic; deskilling of the workforce makes the black boxes even blacker. Every colleague may not know the precise details of my work, but that this remains a strategic decision and not a limitation due to their lack of skill is essential.
- trashtester 4y agoManagers who don't understand math is a huge limiting factor that has a tendency to infiltrate companies over time. When you look at the most successful startups of the last 50 years or so, it seems to me that most of them were founded by people with a strong STEM background (and math talent), even if several dropped out before finishing college. On average, I think these founders had at least a quite strong pre-graduate level understanding of math, if not more. I believe that level is roughly the minimum required to lead a team of highly educated tech workers.
- Koshkin 4y agoI don't know why mathematics is being singled out as something difficult or mysterious. I do not find it more so than, say, chemistry or molecular biology or medicine or law, to give just a few examples.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rawgabbit 4y agoThe author is spot-on. Most of modern education is built on sheer myth and guesswork with little evidence on outcomes or importance. Why do American doctors need a year of calculus? It makes little sense. Advance Math is pure logic. While it is beautiful, it has limited application in real life. Most of the pain behind decision making is discovering what the facts are. People hide the facts, twist the facts, or falsify facts. Without facts, advanced math is of little use. This is why we need experts who have seen a problem in their domain a thousand times. They can quickly spot "outliers" or fabrications.
- trashtester 4y agoWhen I was 21, my gf at the time was teaching applied stats and research methodology etc to a batch of 30-something MD's who were planning to get PhD's. She was struggling a bit with the maths, so I had to read her book and train her in the curriculum. The maths was quite a bit easier than what I was used to from pre-graduate physics, so I found it mostly a fun diversion. (I also learned some concepts that have been useful later, since I only did mathematical stats, not applied stats myself). But even with this course, I would be worried about the ability of many of these doctors, even after a PhD to do a proper critical reading of a research paper. Indirectly this methodology would encourage p-hacking, and from memory, there was not much training in using judgment to see through such activity. And I don't remember if there were any domain-specific training in analysis beyond "statistically significant, P(H0)<0.05", such as calculating confidence intervals from effect sizes, in terms of medical prognosis, reductions in expected lifetime, etc. And THESE would be expected to be the experts. And for doctors WITHOUT this training, I think they have severe trouble digesting an original research paper themselves, which would leave them even more at the mercy of the advertising branches of Big Pharma.
- rawgabbit 4y agoYes to statistics for doctors. No to calculus for doctors.
- trashtester 4y ago
- hwayne 4y agoPart of the problem is that there's a difference between having the skill of math and having the skill of applying math to real-world problems, and the latter 1) isn't taught, and 2) is really hard to teach.
- GuB-42 4y agoI have always thought of advanced math as a mindset, a form of culture more than a practical skill, at least for 99% of all people. It is one of the many "useless" things that we learn at school. It is like history, literature, etc... none of these make me better at my job, at least not directly. In fact they are taught at school because they are "useless", no employer will pay you to learn which wars your country fought no matter how important it is for cultural identity. Math is one of the basis of science and engineering, so it is important for someone to teach you that. I think we should make a bit of space for programming now, not because we will all be coders, but because it is the basis of how computers work, and computers are everywhere, and like math, programming is a good way to teach rigorous and precise thinking. Computers are stupid, they do what they are told, not what you think you told them, that make them good training material.