11 ms·
Women Who Ran Genghis Khan’s Empire
- cato_the_elder 4y agoThis part sounds very similar to the traditional role of women, and it is quite dishonest to frame it as "Running Genghis Khan’s Empire": > Chinggis Khan’s senior wife, Börte, is responsible for a camp. She’s responsible for their home, the yurt or ger that they live in. She’s responsible for the kids. If merchants come through, she’s going to talk to them about economic activity. She is going to oversee or perform the typical daily herding activities. There’s food preparation. There’s clothing preparation. There are religious rituals. There’s entertainment. It’s often a woman’s job to be the hospitable partner, to bring in food and welcome guests.
- HeroOfAges 4y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted for pointing this out. She was responsible for "their" home. Not the tens of thousands of households across the empire. There was also a sentence where the scholar being interviewed estimates that women made up to 20% of Mongolian armies of that era. That just seems flatout unbelievable.
- mrcheesebreeze 4y agohe is being downvoted for the same reason this article exists, pc culture doesn't like being corrected. There is a war against historical accuracy for the sake of adding in women or random races that wouldn't be there. The annoying thing is that it makes no sense to do this because there are plenty of non-male or non-white leaders to pick from anyway. My favorite empire is the Ajuuran sultanate that was a very powerful african sultanate in modern day somalia. It traded as far as china and it had many victories over great powers like portugal. A great female leader that actually existed was queen boudica, one of the greatest celtic anti-roman rebels. She led her people and dealt a lot of damage to the roman invaders before she inevitably lost to the chads that are the roman legions. Rather than blackwash or add in random women we can just look to the parts of history that already contain that.
- kevinh 4y agoWhat portion of this article do you believe is inaccurate?
- mrcheesebreeze 4y agothe main claim that borte ran the mongol empire, she didn't. She was a great help and most great leaders had amazing wives who helped them. Despite this her actions were greatly inflated by the title and main claim.
- coupdejarnac 4y agoI'd take every claim in this article with a grain of salt. There simply isn't much documentation from that time in the Mongol empire.
- ummonk 4y agoI think they’re basing that claim on some buried women exhibiting archery and horseback riding strength in their skeletal structures. I doubt they routinely fought in the army, given the lack of contemporary accounts observing any women in the Mongol army. This contrasts with, say, the ancient Sarmatians, where we see female burials with actual weapons of war, and have contemporary accounts that women did fight extensively in battles. There, a figure of 20% would be roughly accurate.
- nixlim 4y agoThe thing to remember is that a "camp" comprised thousands of people, livestock and other moving parts. She was essentially project and logistics manager of a massive project, with no automation tools or modern mechanical equipment. The logistics of it would have been mind boggling. Not sure what you mean by "traditional role of women", as that would differ between cultures, but her job would be no mean feat, in my opinion.
- mrcheesebreeze 4y agowhich is a fair point, but its a far cry from the claim of running the empire. The wives of many leaders tend to be important politically and have a hand in the nation's affairs, but its a large leap to claim that means they ran it. She was important absolutely, but the article was just using too much hyperbole. also the army stat was complete bs, we know they were not in need of resorting to female soldiers due to their large enough population.
- thevardanian 4y agoHousehold economics were often controlled by women, as well as structuring/securing social alliances or solidify social status. So it isn't hyperbole, so much as this aspect is entirely lost with more "modern" ideas about gender roles, rather the lack thereof. In older societies it was common to view women as playing a central role in bringing great ruin or great fortune to men, and by extension "their" empires, for this very reason.
- AussieWog93 4y ago>In older societies it was common to view women as playing a central role in bringing great ruin or great fortune to men, and by extension "their" empires, for this very reason. Honestly, even if we don't talk about it, it still is this way. If you want to achieve success, the single most important decision you make is who you marry.
- Barrin92 4y ago>but its a large leap to claim that means they ran it I don't think it is, not just women in particular but also bureaucrats and diplomats in general is what actually ran and does still run empires and nations. Today you'd call it the administrative state. Both historically as well as today people vastly overstate the importance of visible leaders and vastly underestimate the role that administrators, managers, and so on play.
- yorwba 4y ago"The traditional role of women" and "running an empire" are not mutually exclusive. What did you expect the day-to-day business of keeping the Mongol empire running to look like?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Archelaos 4y agoAnd what about "Töregene, who became regent of the entire Mongol Empire after the death of Chinggis Khan’s son Ögedei"?
- devindotcom 4y agoSuddenly everyone is an expert on the logistics of running an empire! Is it so hard to believe that women were in positions of real power there, especially when men were overwhelmingly occupied with warfare? If you read the article you find she later ran the whole shop. It's not dishonest at all, quite the opposite, as the scholar in the article notes, it is dishonest to _downplay_ the role women had in running and expanding the empire. They just weren't riding to battle.
- cato_the_elder 4y ago> Suddenly everyone is an expert on the logistics of running an empire! That's a strawman. > If you read the article you find she later ran the whole shop. May I suggest that before looking down on others like this, it is wise to make sure you've been careful when reading the thing? The article contains no such claim. Most likely, you are mixing up Töregene and Börte.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- karaterobot 4y agoI think part of the issue is that the title of the article is using the word "ran" in "ran Genghis Khan's Empire" to imply that Börte made strategic, judicial, or political decisions, and then the text in the article talks about more operational or logistical work. It's hyperbolic. The reasons are obviously: precious, precious clicks. A title like "The Women Who Kept Genghis Khan's Empire Running" would have been better.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrtweetyhack 4y ago
- friedman23 4y ago[flagged]
- Victerius 4y agoThere's no point in grinding one's teeth and squeezing one's fist at an ancient construct that predates your birth by nearly a millenium. At some point you'll want to let the steam out of your ears, sit down, and hit the books. And the same will be true of the Third Reich in a couple centuries, when anyone even remotely associated to anyone else even remotely associated with the atrocities committed by Germany will be long since dead. And the 1933-1945 period in Germany will become more of a subject of historical curiosity than a source of outrage.
- ttyprintk 4y agoInteresting to me that the only authority mentioned in the article has written a book about the same subject, published by Cambridge Studies in Islamic Civilization. Mongolians destroyed Baghdad, ending the Islamic Golden Age. Maybe the role of women in the Khanate was noticed by Muslims as they rewrote the place of women in their societies.
- avgcorrection 4y agoPeople might roll their eyes at Godwin’s Law but this poster has a point. Here’s how these headlines work: “The men who ran Genghis Khan’s empire” This title either evokes the air of scholarly history or makes you think about the brutality of large Medieval empires. “Women who ran Genghis Khan’s empire” This title makes you think (or is supposed to make you think), oh, I guess the Mongolians were kind of progressive. Good on you, Mongolians.
- fasteddie31003 4y agoIMO we should not look at Genghis Kahn's Empire fondly. After listening to Hardcore History's Wrath of the Khans, I think they have been the most evil group humanity has produced so far. Time seems to heal all wounds but Genghis Khan sure seemed to have made a lot of wounds.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoWho looks at the Mongol empire fondly?
- evv555 4y agoWhoever wrote this article? Obviously, are you asking a rhetorical question?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoNot an rhetorical question at all. I didn't see any wholistic judgment of the Mongol empire in the article. The Mongols did tons of amazing, fascinating, and great things. They also did terrible and atrocious things. The later should not preclude curiosity and appreciation of the former.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoDo you really think whoever wrote this article fondly reminisces of the Mongol Empire? If I list some positives of Byzantium does that mean I am fond of whatever they did in aggregate?
- mrcheesebreeze 4y agosome mongol people to this day. People tend to ignore their ancestor's warcrimes. Even if they admit they were evil they can't bring themselves to hate them. This applies to most old empires, many people can't bring themselves to hate the entire empire despite their barbarity.
- s1artibartfast 4y ago
- fdgsdfogijq 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- akomtu 4y agoI see they are trying to push a narrative here, but they picked a weak example. Wu Zetian started in a harem of some Chinese emperor, but climbed to the top, captured the throne and ruled for 15 years officially (and who knows how many years before that unofficially). She wasn't shy of killing her own newborn for a timely political move, and obviously wasn't constrained by morals in her climbing after that. And Genghis Khan was just a powerful savage who wiped out entire chinese cities who dared to defend themselves. His take on chinese civilization was that it was occupying land that could be used to grow grass for his horses.
- markdown 4y agoHundreds of years later... the US, unconstrained by morals, was doing the same, overthrowing the Kingdom of Hawaii to control more land to grow grass (sugarcane).
- _8j50 4y agoAhh, the modern take on war and nations, the desire for moral superiority and the silly game of pretending there are rules in war. As hard as it maybe to wrap one's head around this, historically, war was a way to obtain resources, or rather resolve conflicts over resources. Genghis wanted a resource for his horses, he resolved it. If your city was wiped out by him, it was your fault for being weak. You should not expect peace between nations or compassion. Nations are built on stolen land, their borders drawn by blood. We live in a world where nuclear powers maintain balance and modern technology has resolved many of the world 's resource scarcity issues. Our countries are ruled by law, not people. People allowed themslves to be ruled by the most cruel and ruthless in the past because that meant obtaining the most resources for them, even if done on a wh im to satisfy their rulers. People sit back and judge empires from the romans to the british and criticize their morals. It is utterly absurd. I mean, even these days the US invades the middle east and Russia its neighbors for resources. And the terrible thing about democracy is that people think the whole world runs on some system of rules where people's wills and lives matter at a global scale. It sounds nice but that isn't reality. It can be that way in a country but between countries, when you have food shortage your government will not hesitate to wipe out cities and commit genocide on your behalf. My point is that such criticism should be based on reality not on how things should be in an ideal world. The primary directive of any government is not just to secure its borders but the nation itself, whatever that stands for. Be it the elected ruler's will or the monarch's whim.
- ummonk 4y agoIs Borte “largely forgotten”? After Subutai, she’s probably the most recognizable figure in Genghis Khan’s administration, save Genghis Khan himself.
- bergenty 4y ago
- imtemplain 4y ago