35 ms·
Carbon dioxide now more than 50% higher than pre-industrial levels
- mrichman 4y agoSo what? Ice cores from Antarctica show that at the end of recent ice ages, the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere usually started to rise only after temperatures had begun to climb.
- MafellUser 4y ago
- withinboredom 4y ago
- __alexs 4y agoCurious. It's almost like the climate is a complex system that requires more than 2 variables to model.
- dotancohen 4y agoSo you've identified a feedback loop. Milankovich cycles warm the Earth, which cause a release of CO2, which further warms the Earth. Now imaging what an Earth warming would be like that is _caused_ by increased CO2 emission, rather than just being fed back by it.
- asaddhamani 4y agoDid that increase previously occur over 250 years or over thousands/tens of thousands?
- shrubble 4y ago'CO2 levels are now comparable to the Pliocene Climatic Optimum, between 4.1 and 4.5 million years ago, when they were close to, or above 400 ppm.'
- arethuza 4y ago"During that time, sea levels were between 5 and 25 meters higher than today, high enough to drown many of the world’s largest modern cities."
- Proven 4y ago
- lazyjones 4y agoIt's just scaremongering to mention this and imply that this could actually happen as a consequence of current CO₂ levels. Sea levels have been changing throughout all of human history and they've never drowned a large city instantly because people just resettle over the course of hundreds of years when needed.
- Group_B 4y agoNo point in reading any of this because there’s literally nothing you can do about it.
- xwdv 4y agoWe can get our affairs in order and prepare for human extinction.
- brohoolio 4y agoWe solved the ozone hole, we can solve this, it just takes leaders who aren’t bought by existing fossil fuel interests.
- throwaway6734 4y agoIn the US it's the voters not the leaders.
- throwaway290 4y agoTwo-party system makes it really tough to vote for the party that can do what you think is right, no? Either party is the enemy and basically the justification for the existence of the other, and as long as they throw back and forth petty issues those who want power and money get to keep it.
- masklinn 4y agoWhat are you talking about? An entire party is basically accelerationist, and the other one largely just waffles about.
- DFHippie 4y agoImagine you are made one of the politicians in the waffling party. Say you find the politician whose stated preferences most closely match your own. They step down. You take their place. What will you do now to ensure the wafflers stop waffling? The problem isn't that they choose to waffle, but that their power is on a knife edge when they have any power at all and they disagree about what to do.
- brohoolio 4y ago“CO2 levels are now comparable to the Pliocene Climatic Optimum, between 4.1 and 4.5 million years ago, when they were close to, or above 400 ppm. During that time, sea levels were between 5 and 25 meters higher than today offsite, high enough to drown many of the world’s largest modern cities. “ Oh boy, that’s not good. I mean it’s going to take a while for it to raise up, but so long Florida.
- oneoff786 4y agoWhere has this water gone exactly? Freezing wouldn’t explain it. Is it lagged thermal expansion of the ocean water as it catches up to the air in heat?
- kuu 4y agoFrozen in glaciers and poles, I would assume...
- arethuza 4y agoIt's a combination of melting of glaciers and ice-caps and thermal expansion of water as it warms: https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/sealevel.html https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/sealevel.html
- zamfi 4y ago> Freezing wouldn’t explain it. Pretty sure freezing is exactly it — Greenland and Antarctica contain lots of water stored well above sea level. These fluctuated a lot worth sea levels.
- oneoff786 4y agoSeveral people are saying this so I’ll reply to just this one. It wouldn’t make sense for water to freeze up over Antarctica over time as a way to reduce sea level. Water freezing on top of water doesn’t affect water height. And water freezing on top of submerged land would just raise the water levels because it’s more voluminous. There needs to be a mechanism for the ice to accumulate on top of itself far above sea level for sea level to go down beyond just water freezing. As another poster explained, it’s snowfall accumulating semi-permanently in the same spots that moves water to these areas. Excuse my pedantry.
- hkt 4y agoI remain stunned by the lack of action on fossil fuels and lifestyles generally. Even leaving aside the fact we are wrecking the planet, we rely on some deeply unsavoury countries for oil, gas and coal and we could have made a conscious choice to mitigate our dependence on them years ago and simply haven't done it. What's worse is politicians have no desire to lead, so it is life to people with "alternative" (eg sustainable) lifestyles to retrofit their homes, ride bicycles, and generate less waste. Presumably the fear is that we have invested so deeply in fossil fuels that we can't unwind that rapidly. I'm sure everyone here knows a sunk cost when they see one. I really do fear for my old age, and my kids lives. We've created too many incentives to wreck the world and people quite reasonably respond to them. Things have to change.
- Gigachad 4y agoDon’t have to look much further than this very website to see examples. Just look at the frothing rage in the comments every time the topic gets to reducing car and natural gas usage.
- starkd 4y agoThe formula is very clear. When mankind has access to cheap and affordable energy, they prosper. When they don't, they struggle. And it's not about getting rich. We've already spent trillions on "green energy" and we are no where near getting rid of fossile fuels. It's embedded in everything we do. There's also a lot of doom on this page thinking the end of the world is nigh. Scientists do not walk in lockstep on this question. There are climatologists who have pulled back on the alarm - like Lomborg and Shellenberger. I'm not saying they are right, just to be wary of anyone telling you they know what's going to happen.
- dredmorbius 4y agoDo you navigate in your car by staring only in the rear-view mirror? There's parlous little contention that fossil fuels transformed the world for exceptional capabilities and productivity over the past 250 years. That's simply not the argument. The problem is both what their continued use will do to the overall environment, and what their finite supply means in terms of continued prosperity. Quite simply, you're ignoring (and repeatedly) the elephant in the room: unintended consequences of the continued use of fossil fuels. You might care to recognise the beast. It's formidable.
- martini333 4y agoThis is great news for deserts and savanas all over the earth!
- masklinn 4y agoShort term certainly, long term it's harder to predict: warmer air also has a much higher moisture carrying capacity, thus the cascading changes in weather patterns could also lead to better water circulation over and to currently dry areas. For instance the sahara was extremely dry (even more than currently) during the last glacial maximum, the african humid period started with the Bølling–Allerød warming / Late Glacial Interstadial (and as its name indicates, greened up the sahara area). Then it dried up again with the cooling of the Younger Dryas, before humidifying again at its end. It also underwent a dry spell during the 8.2kYa "cold event", before the african humid period ending entirely during the 4.2kYa aridification event (which seems related to the Bond Event 3).
- am1on 4y agoCO2 is plant food
- oneoff786 4y agoSo are dead humans
- masklinn 4y agoThe primary limiting factor on plant growth is not generally CO2. You can know that by observing that CO2 is not really what fertilizers concern themselves with. Water, nitrogen, and micronutrients, tend to be the big issues. Existing plants deal fairly well with around 200~250ppm CO2 because that's been the concentration for the last 20 million years.
- AlgorithmicTime 4y ago
- betwixthewires 4y agoFor individual ecosystems or individual plants, yes, the limiting factor is nitrogen fixing in the soil. For the global biosphere however, the limiting factor to the creation of biomass (via photosynthesis) is carbon dioxide availability.
- philjohn 4y agoShame lots of plants have been cut down in the lungs of the earth, the rainforests of South America.
- Yizahi 4y agoI'm always at a loss about people arguing about CO2. Like there is a single graph to rule them all - a so called Keeling Curve, is is freely available to all, it is always monitoring and it is NOT POSSIBLE AT ALL to derive any conclusion from looking at it, other than we are heating the planet fast. Also it is painfully obvious that ALL so called "green" technologies are either fake or not impacting climate at all (especially those "carbon neutral" ones are def. scam, just shuffling emissions like a hot potato game, to other corporations or countries). The rate of CO2 in the atmosphere is increasing every year and the rate of increase (acceleration) is also only increasing every year. It takes one minute to confirm this :)
- bawolff 4y agoThe graph is not the sole reason we think the planet is heating. If it was just the graph, there would be other possible interpretations. (You know, causation vs correlation and all that). However we have more than just a graph to confirm climate change.
- suture 4y agoI agree with what you said but it seems this graph alone should be enough to convince people there is a problem. The heat trapping effects of CO2 are well known and beyond dispute, right? Forgetting all other evidence, isn’t the fact of the massive increase in CO2 alone enough to cause alarm? This was talked about in the late 1800s.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- akvadrako 4y agoNo, it certainly isn't beyond dispute that more CO₂ is significant and bad. Some example arguments: (1) The Earth has been cooler with CO₂ levels 10 times higher. We currently have some of the lowest levels in the history of the planet. (2) CO₂ increases and decreases also usually seem to trail temperature changes. (3) Warmer temperatures are not necessarily negative. We've been in an ice age for 2 million years, but life thrived at higher temps. (4) You have to balance negative effects with positive effects, like increased greening.
- lazyjones 4y agoI really don't like imprecise headlines like this one, where many people with superficial knowledge of the topic will be made to believe that CO₂ levels were never higher. But they were and the planet was much more hospitable, even the poles were probably green and bristling with life.
- suture 4y agoHospitable for which biological organisms? The issue is not that the planet is going to be destroyed. The issue is that the current political systems and human organization of the world is going to be destroyed (or greatly disrupted) in a short period of time. Talking about what the climate was like millions of years before humans evolved is not germane to the discussion at hand.
- zmgsabst 4y agoWhat makes it irrelevant? You have an unstated assumption that a change to the current political systems and organization is fundamentally catastrophic, but I’m not sure I agree. If the only impact is political, so what?
- suture 4y agoLife today evolved over time and adapted to the changes of the planet. Present day life is not adapted to living on the planet as it was millions of years ago. Rapidly increasing the heat of the planet and rapidly increasing the amount of CO2 will cause biological disruptions. It will also cause disruptions for societies as we too have adapted our current ways of life for a climate that increasingly doesn’t exist. The political impact is one of civilizational collapse. Some people are not nihilists and want to avert this.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> It will also cause disruptions for societies as we too have adapted our current ways of life for a climate that increasingly doesn’t exist. Okay — can you quantify “disruptions”, because that comes across as a “scare word” that just means “things will change”. > The political impact is one of civilizational collapse. Some people are not nihilists and want to avert this. Okay, how exactly? That last sentence, where you impeach the character of people who disagree with you, makes me think that this is political tribalism and an excuse for totalitarianism rather than a scientific point. Which has been my experience of people “fighting global warming”: they’re more interested in the excuse to reform society to their totalitarian vision than the science.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Tade0 4y agoThis is bad, but it appears that we've managed to avoid the worst: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-worst-climate-scenarios-may-no-longer-be-the-most-likely/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-worst-climate... Renewables have gotten so cheap that it's mostly fine that they're so unpredictable(for a certain definition of that word though, because we have weather reports to account for that) - at least for the time being, especially that so many long-distance HVDC are currently in place to distribute all that energy. Also all this CO2 in the air postponed the next glaciation by tens of thousands of years, so if our species gets through this crisis, it will have ample time to prepare for the inevitable decrease in temperatures.
- usednet 4y agoIt is not reassuring whatsoever that one article 2 years ago says that we have just managed to avoid near human extinction. Sure there will still be people alive after 3.9 degrees of warming, but I for one wouldn’t like that very much.
- Gravityloss 4y agoOne can "get started" with unpredictable renewables, and they are certainly extremely beneficial as they displace fossil fuels in the generation mix. 10% or 30% of yearly energy coming from renewables is great already. Some gas or hydro that has already been built can be used to flatten the worst peaks and valleys etc. But once renewables go to higher percentages, the issues get worse. The main problem is that energy storage is currently very expensive and still dependent on geography (hydro power). So the electricity price will crash when it's very sunny or windy. That hurts the profitability of solar or wind power. Like you mentioned, we would need to invest hugely in long distance ultra high voltage transmission lines, load buffering like green hydrogen for steel making, green concrete etc and maybe ultimately even batteries. These are large investments. Changing from fossil fuels takes a lot of money. The steel produced this way is more expensive than coal or natural gas based steel. So renewables have a compensating effect. On the other hand as technology develops, they get cheaper - but when their penetration increases, they also become more expensive since they require bigger infrastructure changes. Yet we still need to do this one way or another. Your new car or house will be smaller and more expensive because of it. Your electricity or heating bill will be more. The sooner we admit that yes, it will cause a lower material standard of living in the short term, but we still need to do it for the long term, the further we get.
- ken47 4y agoMeaningful action will happen by semi-random chance (breakthrough in low-emission energy) or by force of nature (climate changes so much that we have no choice but to act). In general, I don't think the average, or even somewhat above-average, person will be motivated by an abstract risk like the specter of CO2-induced climate change, unless incentives are created at a societal level to celebrate advancements in this field of technology and the associated low-emission lifestyle. And would it be safe to assume that low-emission energy has much lower ROI, in a traditional sense, than fossil fuels? If so, I double down on my above predictions about triggers for meaningful change. But that's life, isn't it? We're only capable of optimizing towards a finite distance in the future. If that weren't the case, we would be gods, not humans. And we certainly wouldn't be in this mess, or perhaps any mess, in the first place.
- ehnto 4y agoI agree, and I've been a proponent of remediation technology rather than preventative technology, since I have no faith we can actually pull off prevention. The incentives are not there for the majority of people. There has been no meaningful evidence to the contrary, as sad as that is. I think the severity of the issue is what makes it so easy to dismiss, and ignore. Just like people can ignore the impact a car accident would have on them, because such a thing is so severe that well, it's best not to think about it, so people don't.
- mattnewton 4y agoAll you need to look at in the US is the current conversation around subsidizing gasoline / lowering taxes in most states currently due to inflation. I don’t think the average voter is going to care if cities they don’t live in are under water as much as they care about their own gas prices.
- orwin 4y agoYes, andt sea-level CO2 have almost no impact on average temperature. Its only in the high troposphere that its impact is felt. And on average, CO2 takes twenty year to rise up to the level where it start to be impactful (and as it is an oxide, is ultra stable there). The the deregulation we have right now is caused by the emissions from 2002. What we emit today will start to have an impact on average temperatures (energy level, infrared re-emissions, whatever you want to call it) in 2042. That does not help us take decisions.
- verisimi 4y agoCarbon dioxide increases the growth of plants. I don't see how this is a bad thing. https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2016/carbon-dioxide-fertilization-greening-earth https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2016/carbon-dioxide-fer...
- bigDinosaur 4y agoPlants will likely adapt more readily than human civilisation.
- Fuhrer01 4y agoWhy do you say that?
- bigDinosaur 4y agoFor one, plants don't build cities, so if we have to deal with sea level rises than that's a problem for our buildings. The same with any increase in natural disasters: it's easier for a tree to grow again after a hurricane than it is to rebuild an electrical grid. We could deal with it, the issue is that civilisation entails cooperatively working to deal with it as opposed to going to war and killing everyone the second your crops fail.
- _fizz_buzz_ 4y agoIt's great if you are a plant. However, you are human, so higher temperatures, rising sea levels, extremer weather is a problem for you. Plants will be fine (at least some types of plants), humans have a problem.
- bsuvc 4y agoWhich countries are the biggest emitters of CO2? It seems like the challenge is getting all countries to take action to reduce CO2 emissions, especially the biggest emitters.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoAs you said, every country needs to reduce. Anybody asking your first question is usually involved in blame shifting rather than actually doing anything. "Why should we do anything if China and/or the US isn't?".
- bsuvc 4y agoIsn't it objectively true that the countries producing the most CO2 are more to blame? As are the ones doing the least to curb emissions.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoJust because it's true doesn't make it right. This is where the proverb "People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones" comes from. You don't have the moral standing to criticize the CO2 emissions of others if you aren't doing anything yourself, even if the others are worse than yourself. OTOH, only when you are leading by example do you have the moral standing.
- bavell 4y agoSo are you saying the "right" answer is to not focus on the biggest sources of CO2 production? And this is the best way to lower CO2 production? It seems like whenever anyone points out the obvious above, others will jump in saying we can't point fingers but they don't offer any real solutions either. Around and around we go.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe right answer is to focus on what is possible in your jurisdiction.
- readerbaza 4y agoThose are rookie numbers, if we try harder I'll finally have a beach house, come on people!
- paradite 4y agoMy thoughts on this hasn't changed: https://paradite.com/2018/11/06/extinction-is-natural-so-is-global-warming/ https://paradite.com/2018/11/06/extinction-is-natural-so-is-...
- Synaesthesia 4y agoWell unfortunately we may be headed for a situation where the world is unliveable forany people, and we don't have a way to colonise another planet. We're all stuck on earth.
- jarek83 4y agoThat's exactly what my thoughts are about all the drama. I believe also that we're too small in what we do to actually have any meaningful impact on what the planet is going to look like. The planet will just fart and we're gone, but she we'll do just fine.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThis just completely and naively sidesteps the issue though? "Save the earth" or whatever is obviously a simplification and a euphemism, a marketing approach not a moral necessity. What we're obligated to prevent is avoidable human death and suffering on a massive scale. It is the lives that matter not the origin of the threat. And it's not a simple dichotomy between total extinction and we're all fine. A plausible scenario is that hundreds of millions of people who are living right now will die preventably, and those with the most resources, including fossil fuel use, will be able to ride it out at their expense. We have obligations going beyond merely weakening the mechanisms of climate change; we must also address its consequences now and in the near future.
- paradite 4y agoYes, we are in agreement. Your points and my post are not mutually exclusive. Just looking at things from different perspectives.
- throwawaymanbot 4y ago
- boplicity 4y agoWe need to stop extracting fossil fuels from the ground. Period. Any other solution is just a gimmick. Unfortunately, the rate of extraction hasn't slowed. It's increased, or, at best, stayed relatively flat. The outcome, of course, will be quite predictable. All of this "green" technology we've produced hasn't made an iota of a difference, yet, in terms of the actual problem. Maybe it will soon? Let's hope.
- sieabahlpark 4y ago
- Retric 4y agoIncreased electricity efficiency kept US coal extraction steady from 1998 @24.1 exajoules to 2008 @23.9 exajoules. Green technology then help drop that to 14.3 exajoules in 2019. https://www.statista.com/statistics/265452/coal-production-in-the-united-states/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/265452/coal-production-i... Globally industrialization and increased economic activity hides these improvements, but without green technology things would be much worse.
- michaelbuckbee 4y agoA lot of this offset is natural gas displacing coal (still an improvement) but not great long term https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/natural-gas-use-is-rising-is-that-good-news-or-bad-news-for-the-climate/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/natural-ga...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoTotal fossil fuel use for electricity production is also down significantly in the US. 9,616 kWh per person in 2008 to 7,861 kWh in 2019.
- boplicity 4y ago
- hexo 4y agoSo, plants should be doing much better now, shouldn't they?
- snarf21 4y agoMy understanding is that land plants are probably doing better. However, the acidification of the oceans is the real problem. Despite what most people think, at least half of our oxygen comes from marine plants. The main concerns it that continued acidification will continue to decrease plankton growth and have drastic effects on the entire ocean ecosystems.
- mdp2021 4y ago«50-80% of the oxygen production... comes from the ocean ... (Prochlorococcus... produces up to 20% of the oxygen in our entire biosphere) ... although... roughly the same amount is consumed by marine life» (from https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/ocean-oxygen.html https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/ocean-oxygen.html ) At first appearance, «drastic effects on the entire ocean ecosystems», surely with massive consequences for humans, but a non clearly computed effect on the amount of oxygen in the atmosphere.
- snarf21 4y agoThanks for the information!
- chancePear 4y agoThis is where I get confused. I've seen online that about 3% of all CO2 emissions are attributed to humans. Is that wrong?
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe rate of absorption used to balance the rate of emissions.
- margalabargala 4y agoIt's true that total emission and reuptake is quite large compared to human-caused emissions: about 29GT from humans, 750GT total in the carbon cycle annually. However, the systems that reuptake the CO2 are fairly sensitive and don't have a lot of slack in them, so adding that additional 29GT turns out to have an impact. The Earth's atmosphere weighs about 5.5 quadrillion tons. Ignoring the differences in weights of different air molecules, adding 5.5 billion tons of CO2 would increase the CO2 concentration by ~1PPM. So if all 29 billion tons of human emissions were not reabsorbed into the biosphere, we would expect to see global CO2 concentrations increase by between 5 and 6 ppm. In reality we see an increase of just over 2ppm per year, meaning that while much of human emissions are indeed reabsorbed into the biosphere, ~40% is not.
- margalabargala 4y agoTo expand on this: the molar weight of dry air is ~28g/mol, while CO2 is ~44g/mol. So each increase in atmospheric CO2 by 1ppm corresponds to about 8.6GT of unabsorbed CO2. The Keeling Curve shows an increase of 1.86PPM from May 2021 to May 2022, meaning that the amount of CO2 emitted from all sources was greater than the amount absorbed by 15.7GT. So of the 29GT emitted by humans, 13.3 was reabsorbed. Obviously this is not the whole story. The Keeling Curve shows that worldwide CO2 levels were already rising in the 50s and early 60s, when total emissions were below the 13.3 our biosphere is absorbing annually. But this is sufficient to show that a (substantial) reduction in human emissions would reverse the currently increasing global CO2 levels, and the greenhouse warming that comes with it.
- Imnimo 4y ago
- hn2017 4y agoUnfortunately, most Republicans in Congress (and Trump) don't believe in human made climate change. But I guess that's not a surprise, since they don't believe in human evolution and other scientific models. There will never be any major solution here in the US unless this changes
- swader999 4y agoThere's an escalating proxy war between the two largest nuclear powers on the planet right now and we're heads in the sand arguing about a problem that could easily be adapted to over many decades.
- tim333 4y ago50% higher than the lows a couple of centuries ago but 10x lower than they were 500 million years ago.
- blindmute 4y agoDon't care; nothing I can meaningfully do about it. Just going to focus on earning enough money and living in the right location for my family and myself to continue eating steaks
- mikewarot 4y agoMy back of the envelope calculations show that 30 years of coal mining alone would dump that much CO2 into the atmosphere... so most of it is getting absorbed... which is good, or we'd be roasted by now. Perhaps, in addition to burning less fossil fuels, it would be a good idea to see where the carbon sinks are, and help those work more effectively? I know that sustainable farming captures a lot of carbon in the soil, for example.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoDirect result of crossing carrying capacity of the planet. At half the current population, the planet and species will thrive.