10 ms·
Lidl’s parent company launches cloud unit to offer ‘Made in Germany’ AWS rival
- mrits 4y ago2025 - Lidi acquired by AWS.
- rndgermandude 4y agoI know it's more of a joke, but some people might think this might actually happen. Here is why not: The Schwarz Group (Lidl's parent, as well as Kaufland's parent) is the largest privately held company in Germany and the largest retailer in the EU. While it's not owned by the Schwarz brothers anymore, as they have died, they transferred their ownership into a "non-profit" "charitable" foundation upon death. The foundation itself is in turn controlled by other foundations, which are then controlled by a mix of family members and hired trustees. Selling this is virtually impossible, as everybody would have to agree. While Schwarz is small compared to Amazon (~143 billion USD vs ~470 billion USD in 2021 revenue), they aren't exactly a lightweight either. Look what "tiny" twitter (barely over 1 billion USD in revenue) is gonna cost a Musk... Maybe at some point Schwarz might sell off just the cloud stuff. But if it's gonna be profitable they are unlikely to. And it's likely profitable or close to it from day one, as they already did most the hard work to support their internal IT needs. And they are a big name brand around here, known to do things "right" in their space (unlike e.g. Telekom/T-Systems) and a lot of German and European players have been looking at GDPR-compliant EU-based alternatives to AWS for quite a while.
- shp0ngle 4y agoAh, charity foundation, IKEA style. I didn’t know that about Lidl.
- kalaido 4y agoAs a German I would like to point out, that German companies are (as always) too late to the party. Nothing with worldwide relevance in the software, AI nor cloud space came out of Germany / the EU within in the last decades. It's embarrassing :(
- m00dy 4y agoExcept for the pharmaceuticals. We still rely on the inventions that happened in WW2.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoI wonder how much of this is due to the vast tech salary discrepancies (especially in areas like AI and cloud) between Europe and the US. I bet the Lidl cloud engineers are getting paid at most a third of their AWS counterparts. If you want AWS quality, you have to pay AWS salaries.
- geogra4 4y agoIt's sad, even sap runs a lot on aws
- shp0ngle 4y agoI thought they have their own “SAP cloud” but maybe it’s just some marketing BS
- shp0ngle 4y agoOn the other hand, you created Lidl and Aldi. So that’s not worth nothing.
- barry-cotter 4y agoIt’s not a German thing. It’s a European thing. Lots of Europeans have made huge contributions to technology working in US companies, mostly in the US because that’s where the money is.
- yayachiken 4y agoThey don't even have to work for US companies. As a recent example, the Dirty Pipe vulnerability was discovered by a German Engineer working for a very basic website hoster. He found it when he was investigating a customer complaint about corrupted log file downloads. There is still in-depth high-value engineering happening, even if you don't work for the flashy silicon valley VC unicorns. In fact, such a basic support request would probably have been closed as "could not reproduce" in a highly competitive environment.
- kosma 4y agoFunny how Germany is obsessed with privacy, yet the cookie consent prompt requires extra clicks to decline the consent.
- slickrick216 4y agoGermany weaponises data privacy and uses it to lock out foreign competitors.
- kensai 4y agoIt's the other way around, actually. Germany falls behind by using so much data privacy. Global competitors party around this nuisance.
- rmoriz 4y agoIMHO too late. Software to run a PaaS was the key 10 years ago, the future is custom silicon and universal runtimes (either via linux containers and k8s or WASM). In both areas the barrier to enter is huge and costly. Common commodity hardware (think x86) will not provide enough competitive advantage especially in terms of energy efficiency. That said, I'm happy that someone at least tries to attack. All the best wishes, I'll be happy once proven wrong.
- tluyben2 4y agoCustom silicon for what? AI training sure but what else? Most workloads outside that domain are fine with cheap ARM SoCs. Just call everything ‘compute units’ and deliver SDKs for common envs to package and deploy. No need to inform what you are running on.
- logronoide 4y agoSomebody should tell them “Made in Germany” may work for cars and capital goods, but not for tech. Too late.
- rndgermandude 4y agoNot to Germans it's not. Not to the EU countries in general, with GDPR compliance hovering over their heads, it's not. The reputation when it comes to "tech" as in "IT" is not stellar for sure, but it's not unrecoverable bad, and you're forgetting political dimensions.
- barry-cotter 4y agoWhen I try to think of European tech companies I think SAP and Spotify. There’s just nothing remotely comparable to Silicon Valley in Continental Europe, Switzerland included. London and Tel Aviv are each very far ahead of the closest European startup hub, Berlin and there’s just nothing there. I understand the urge to look for something to find pride in somewhere but aiding regulation isn’t something normal people are aware of, never mind proud of. > 4/ So the panel discussion turned to "What should the EU do?" > And the more or less unanimous conclusion (except for the entrepreneur) was "We are going to build on the success of GDPR and aim to be the REGULATORY LEADER of machine learning" > I literally laughed out loud https://twitter.com/punk6529/status/1509832361449504770?s=20&t=jQxNl6KMcql_ptPRHHx0vw https://twitter.com/punk6529/status/1509832361449504770?s=20...
- rndgermandude 4y agoI don't disagree with your remarks about startups and big "software" companies, or rather the lack thereof in the EU. However, that's not even what Schwarz is targeting here. They are targeting the IT departments of existing companies that aren't necessarily in the tech space at all. I know of a bunch of companies who'd love to move a lot of their stuff into a managed cloud, but wouldn't touch a US-owned cloud for compliance reasons. They stay aware from Telekom, because... well... Telekom. They stay away from Hetzner because Hetzner is not considered "serious" enough for now. So they often end up running their own infra or at most do unmanaged colo. The GDPR I do like, and are a bit prideful that the EU made it happen. But it isn't about pride here so much anyway, as it is about political and regulatory realities. Schwarz has to convince their potential customers that they are "serious" (and Schwarz is considered pretty serious in the business space), that they can execute on promises (and Schwarz again has a reputation for that too, though in the retail space) and that they can offer a cloud that is compliant with regulations, even if at first it's not much more than some managed vms/colos.
- aaronchall 4y agoIsn't "Made in Germany" Hetzner's thing?
- sschueller 4y agoAs long as I can't provision these service myself without having to "call for advice" I am not using it irregardless of the price. It's 2022 and any company still hiding behind "call for pricing" or "call for quote" that isn't servicing government agencies is going to be eaten alive by any other provider not making customer run thought hoops. They claim they are the German AWS when they miss the first thing that Bezos did at Amazon. He removed the barrier of entry to the max. He realized that people do impulse buying and the easier it is to do this the more business you get. Does anyone remember 1-click? I am sure a I have quit out of a purchase a hundred or more times at random vendors when I ended up having to create an account to just find out how much shipping is. I had to order some custom laser cut metal parts. There are hundreds of companies offering this in Switzerland but almost all require a call for quote. The one company that let me upload my Fusion 360 file and give me an instant quote is the one I went with even if it cost more because I don't have the time to write 10 companies and send each one of them a CAD file having to explain what I want for such a limited run.
- asvitkine 4y agoUnless EU governments pass protectionist laws requiring the use of local services.
- radicalbyte 4y agoIt's literally only a problem because the US laws allow the US government to force MS / Google / Amazon to hand over all data stored by German companies on data residing in German datacenters located inside Germany, if an American company is running them. That bullshit caused us a huge amount of headaches when we wanted to deploy our COVID systems to Azure...
- holografix 4y agoCMEK was introduced for this. NSA can have the data but won’t ever read it
- 4y ago
- some_random 4y agoI'll believe it when I see the CapEx.
- virtuallynathan 4y agoThese 2 data center facilities are super small - I hope they have rapid expansion ability if they want this to succeed.
- rmoriz 4y agoLidl is known to expand quickly, if they succeed they should do a co-op with hetzner or OVH both very well known for rapid expansion of data centers with a very high efficiency and low costs. (Yes, both made their mistakes, but they built and learned their lesson in-house hence aquired deep domain knowledge in contrast of typical players which just rent or outsource)
- machinekob 4y agoIt looks more like B2B cloud at least from past informations about it not sure about AWS rivality.
- oblio 4y agoAWS is huge. The entire Lidl group made €57bn last year. Just AWS made about $62bn, so pretty much the same thing. And AWS is growing about 30% per year. More than that, AWS is just one piece of the pie. Azure supposedly made about $38bn last year, also growing by about 30% per year. Alibaba and GCP both made about $10bn and they're both growing at about the same pace as Azure and AWS. And I didn't even include IBM or Oracle. How much is Lidl actually investing in this? A few billions, at most? I'd love to be proven wrong and I definitely think Europe needs at least a few top notch cloud providers, but it's going to be an uphill battle.
- rndgermandude 4y ago>The entire Lidl group made €57bn last year. Just AWS made about $62bn, so pretty much the same thing. While you have a point in general, I have no idea from where you got your numbers... Lidl had revenue of 100.8bn EUR (~108bn USD) in 2021, the entire Schwarz Group of 133.6bn EUR [0]. >How much is Lidl actually investing in this? Nitpicking, but Lidl isn't, Schwarz Group is. I suppose how much they will invest is a matter of how promising it will look. Remember that amazon started out selling books. ;) I genuinely think that Schwarz Group has a real chance to become a player in the long run, at least in Europe, if they really try. If it happens, it will not happen quickly. But they seem to have the "company culture" to make it happen, the deep pockets to make it happen, the political connections too. They are however a new player in this "IT thing". They might as well end up scraping the idea again, or be content on just being a datacenter provider for colo for other EU deep pockets instead of offering the full range of AWS services. [0] https://www.zeit.de/news/2022-05/19/schwarz-gruppe-steigert-umsatz-deutlich https://www.zeit.de/news/2022-05/19/schwarz-gruppe-steigert-...
- Sakos 4y agoI think what everybody is missing so far is that they're able to dogfood their own cloud offering through their Lidl and Kaufland subsidiaries the same way Amazon did. That's a huge boon because it means they need to build it to meet real world requirements. It will help them be more competitive, though how much remains to be seen.
- MontyCarloHall 4y ago>Built in 2018, the first [datacenter] offers up to 1,000 sqm (10,760 sq ft), with another 4,500 sqm (48,400 sq ft) to be offered in phase two; it reportedly has a PUE of 1.1 and utilizes river cooling. [The second datacenter] offers 300 sqm (3,200 sq ft) across two data halls. These seem implausibly small for the total footprint of an entire datacenter designed for providing resources on par with an AWS zone. Perhaps these figures are referring to the maximum collocation space available to a single client?
- oblio 4y agoNah, I'd be surprised if it's something else. This is a Lidl project that's being touted as "AWS competition" every few months, but it looks more like a small proof of concept that an actual competitor. Sort of like a kids bike is a competitor for a truck.
- lupire 4y agoIt only needs to serve customers in Germany and maybe EU, and can grow over time.
- mkl95 4y agoTheir products lead to a complex "Get advice now" form. Guess I'll stick with my 'Made in Cyprus' VPS provider that lets me create and destroy VPS instances with a couple of clicks for a similar price.
- schleck8 4y agoI don't know whether running a vps for sensitive data in production is a good choice with a small cypriot host...
- m00dy 4y agoI know some of my dudes running tor services on turkish-part of Cyprus and believe me they really care about their customers due to the competitive nature of the business.
- BonoboIO 4y agoCan u name the company?
- mkl95 4y agohttps://www.mvps.net/ https://www.mvps.net/
- radicalbyte 4y agoThe reason for this is that the GDPR limits EU countries from deploying in countries like the USA who do not respect privacy. Due to the various US laws (Cloud Act) using infrastructure from an US-owned company is also a huge issue. There is a huge gap in the market for an EU-owned and EU-focussed cloud provider with the main issue being that it is extremely capital intensive..
- geogra4 4y agoDoesn't hetzner do this?
- rndgermandude 4y agoKinda but not really. Hetzner targets small businesses, etc, or at least they have the reputation to do that. Large companies in the EU will mostly avoid them for anything serious, because they do not seem "reliable" and "stable" and "big" enough. Same thing with OVH. One of OVH's data centers burning down did additional reputational damage (which happened because they seem to have skipped on proper fire suppression systems in order to build it faster). I am sure Hetzners reputation took a hit as well, even though they had nothing to do with it, but are kind of considered to be on the same tier as OVH.
- imtringued 4y agoI do not understand the purpose of AWS style cloud platforms. What's wrong with Hetzner or Contabo? What is the advantage of paying 270€ per month for a 60GB RAM instance with 8 cores if you can get the same instance on Contabo for 27€? It really feels like these cloud platforms are following the Microtransaction model of mobile games.
- jstummbillig 4y agoScalability and in code provisioning
- seydor 4y agowhich for most people is, the aspiration that they might need scalability
- oblio 4y agoOr just the peace of mind of being able to fully recreate infrastructure easily, if need be. Code, you know, version control, diffs, CI/CD pipelines, inherent live "documentation" (up to a point, of course you won't know the "why", but you'll know most of the "how" and "what", git offering the "who").
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tluyben2 4y agoBut at what price… I have said it here many times, but I am a nobody so I can repeat it; one of my weekend side businesses is optimising overall performance for companies. They contact me with something like ‘I am paying 50k$/mo for aws and out app still goes down with traffic’. The case I did today one month ago was doing 10k/mo on aws and that jumps up mentally with traffic. This is a SaaS site and startup and they are bootstrapped. I moved all over to docker compose and then to a $10/mo vps; it didn’t crash and burn and now they make profit. This is not apples to apples; they made a complete shitshow on aws and in their code and their db (on rds). So I fixed some things and moved it over. On aws this improved setup would still be 10x or more expensive. It is very visible that most startup owners never saw a crisis now; this took me 12 hours… so that’s about 2k$ cost for me for a $9990 saving per month.
- t_mann 4y agoThe US administration brazenly forced TikTok to move its US business to the US, it's fair play if the EU uses some subtle regulatory nudging to incentivize European companies to store their data inside the EU.
- AnonMO 4y agoThe Chinese government has forced plenty of US companies to move data local from apple to tesla. Also a vast majority of tiktoks revenue comes from the US to this day, they can’t afford to lose it. unlike with india and probably every other region they operate in outside of china. It’s also not brazen as the two countries aren’t on best terms atm.
- marvinblum 4y agoWe have Hetzner for this.
- m3nu 4y agoHetzner is the AWS of Germany already. Good luck breaking into this space with the "Call for pricing" mentality mentioned in the comments.
- Tenoke 4y agoI love hetzner but they aren't really the AWS of Germany - they are a great place to get simple cheap instances but don't have many of the more complex offerings that would make them an 'AWS'.
- lupire 4y agoIt's not call for pricing. It's call for signup. https://www.stackit.de/en/prices https://www.stackit.de/en/prices
- Mortiffer 4y agoHetzner for the win
- Havoc 4y agoSpotted something intriguing. Full price list has no pricing for ingress/egress. None whatsoever. For anything. None of the basic pricing looks particularly competitive, but if that isn't an omission then that could be interesting
- bkircher 4y agoThere are a couple of smaller "cloud" providers who do not ([1]). I think this might be simply because they lack the tech for traffic shaping here. So they usually implement a "fair use policy" (whatever that means). But yes, ingress and egress traffic is essentially offered for free. [1]: Another one is gridscale.io, also from Germany
- gerhardhaering 4y agoThis is yet another attempt to put something together on top of Openstack and sell it as an alternative to the big three cloud providers. As a German, it always annoys me when crap like this is presented as "made in Germany". No sign-up process, no IaC first approach, documentation is a joke. No,thanks.
- kensai 4y agoIt is a big matter in Germany and the EU, generally, where the data resides. There is some general consensus to avoid "overseas" servers for mission critical stuff, thinking that there is no control over them regarding privacy. There is literally all kinds of mirrored services (from Dropbox to now apparently this, AWS) in Germany, in case one feels paranoid about respecting local privacy legislations (ie GDPR) and feeling that no foreign government/court order (possibly with a gag order for anyone to ever know) compromises the data.
- Termitiono 4y agoI'm so amused by this. Even the tsystems cloud was / is shit and now they think they can just do it?
- drumhead 4y agoDo they even understand how difficult it is to be AWS? They had to write off over €500m on a botched implementation of SAP. Are they trying to apply their no frills low cost philosophy to cloud services, do they think thats going to be enough? Whatever it is I wouldnt really want to trust my infrastructure and data to a food retailer on their first attempt at providing IT services. That sentance should be enough warning.
- baobabKoodaa 4y agoFood retailer selling IT services, can't think of anything more awful! Except maybe a book retailer selling IT services...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amai 4y agoI would love to see the CERN open up its Openstack cloud to the public: https://openstack.cern.ch/ https://openstack.cern.ch/ I would trust the CERN much more than GAIA-X and this Lidl cloud to become an european alternative to AWS, Azure and GCP.