12 ms·
> We will rescind a number of accepted offers. This continues to happen over and over again in the industry, and is the reason why I always advise people who g
by paxys 4y ago
> We will rescind a number of accepted offers.
This continues to happen over and over again in the industry, and is the reason why I always advise people who get exploding offers from companies to just accept them and then back out later if they need to. Loyalty and respect cannot be a one way street. There's so much propaganda around "burning bridges" that keeps prospective employees in line (and it also extends to stuff like negotiating wages, discussing salaries at work, job hopping and more). Look out for yourself out there, no one else is going to do it. Certainly not the HR department.
- kbuchanan 4y agoWhat is their next best alternative? Rescinding offers is a way to show loyalty to those who already work for you.
- wdb 4y agoYeah, I had job offers rescinded on me. Funny enough these companies still have the audacity to have recruiters message me about new roles. Personally, I also stopped using these companies as a customer.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> Yeah, I had job offers rescinded on me. Funny enough these companies still have the audacity to have recruiters message me about new roles. Personally, I also stopped using these companies as a customer. Rescinded offers are an extremely rare occurrence. If I had not one, but two offers rescinded I'd start wondering if maybe employers were discovering something they didn't like during routine background checks: Unflattering social media posts, something on your record, and so on. Maybe it's purely coincidence, but if this becomes a pattern I'd start looking more closely for potential issues in your public profile or public records.
- runnerup 4y agoOr they're applying at small companies with unprofessional leadership. I've seen that fairly often while mentoring second-tier university students. Little fly-by-night cottage industry companies sometimes try to hire out of narcissism but don't have the cash.
- whymauri 4y ago2020 and now 2022 are bloodbaths for anyone who was a new grad from 2019 until now. Not only have I been rescinded, but several friends and my girlfriend have been rescinded (we went from employed to jobless in a snap). My anecdata is that nobody in my circle of friends would bat an eye accepting an offer and rescinding for something better. When I worked at a startup, we had people rescind on a regular basis. If Amazon gives me an exploding offer, I shed no tears for Bezos by rescinding. You might perceive this as rare depending on where in your career you are, but going through this has fundamentally changed my perspective on job hunting. There is a power imbalance. If I rescind, a normal company will survive. When I was rescinded on, I had to completely change my life plan, apply for unemployment (unsuccessfully), and re-interview while studying for finals. In a twist of irony, I ended up rejoining the company that rescinded my offer a year later (it's a good gig, what can I say) and it spread that some interns had their offers rescinded that year -- bloodboiling. Companies will literally not care, and I will not either.
- wdb 4y agoTrue, only has happened during the pandemic period
- choppaface 4y agoWhile I have seen several people accept two offers and then no-show to one in the first day, it’s not the safest thing to do. At the end of the day, the employee controls the capital and most of employment law. That lets any negative sentiment carry a lot of weight. Make sure there’s a clear and understood story; don’t ghost.
- paxys 4y agoEmployers have in fact lobbied hard for laws that make this possible in the first place. They want all the benefits of at will employment, so there's no reason why they shouldn't also be on the receiving end of it.
- 0des 4y agoIs California at-will?
- paxys 4y ago49/50 states in the US (all except Montana) are at-will.
- 0des 4y agoWow, nice. I thought it was mostly just the south.
- Root_Denied 4y ago"At Will" and "Right To Work" are different things, but often confused as being the same thing. Right To Work states are indeed mostly in the South.
- 0des 4y agoAh this is the tidbit I needed. Thank you.
- ensignavenger 4y agoIt does appear Coinbase is paying severance to folks who hadn't started yet- so that is a plus. I have no idea if it is really "generous" as they claim in their blog post, though.
- actually_a_dog 4y agoConsidering how the usual "severance" package in this type of scenario is a "fuck you" and a kick in the ass, I'd say any amount is pretty generous.
- xosset 4y agoThey also are a growth company with revenue "growing" -35% last quarter. It is a pretty nice touch really given the circumstances.
- abirch 4y agoHow likely are good programmers to accept offers from Coinbase in the future? It sounds like a death spiral with the lack of backfilling.
- turtledove 4y agoOne hopes not likely, but who could say. An unethical company that mistreats its workers and also expects them to shut up and get in line? ... Describes quite a few tech companies to be honest.
- abirch 4y agoYou're right about who is to say. It depends on how much Crypto grows and how important engineering is to a Crypto brokerage, e.g., Vanguard's UI sucks but their rates are great and that's why I have my money there.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- devoutsalsa 4y agoDon’t quit your old job until you start your new job!
- 0des 4y agoMonkey never lets go of one vine until theyve firmly grasped another
- diehunde 4y agoIt gets complicated if you want to leave your old job on good terms and give your 2-week notice.
- jchw 4y agoIn many cases, it's OK to negotiate your start date a couple of weeks out from the offer agreement. I've gotten almost a month in both of my last offers.
- CydeWeys 4y agoYes, and the point of this article is that Coinbase is rescinding employment for people who have accepted offers but haven't started yet. These people have already given notice at their current jobs and now won't have a new one to start. They are Screwed.
- tomjakubowski 4y agoIn California does a rescinded offer after quitting another job qualify someone for unemployment benefits? It's a small amount compared to tech salaries, but is helpful when between jobs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- devoutsalsa 4y agoI’m sure you could. You can collect unemployment even if you quit without a new job in many cases.
- jrochkind1 4y agoGeez, are you supposed to not give your current employer even two weeks notice, but not tell them you're leaving until your first day at a new job, to avoid getting screwed? What a mess!
- kirykl 4y agoSpend the 2 weeks in silence but prepare good handover documentation to soften the blow at old company
- lovich 4y agoUnironically, yes. On top of all this, you also lose unemployment benefits if you quit your job and the new one has rescinded their offer. As far as the states are concerned, you voluntarily quit your previous job, and never started a new one
- nickff 4y agoThat is a problem with how the governments treat layoffs vs quitting. In attempting to make companies and individuals responsible for more unemployment benefits, they made a number of large cracks for people to fall through.
- lovich 4y agoIt a problem with corporations too. They’re not bound by the laws of physics to leave you high and dry. Anyway, the point of the GP question was if it was necessary to give notice after you started your new job. Given that companies are almost always choosing to leave people high and dry, the rational response is to not let yourself get into that situation by not giving your employer advanced notice
- actionablefiber 4y agoEmployers have PIPs as a way to give themselves optionality in deciding to fire someone or not. Seems a bit unfair that employees don’t have much way today of saying, “hey, I might peace out any day now, and don’t take it personally if I do, but I expect that things should still be cool between us if I end up sticking around.”
- throwaway5752 4y agoDon't have your personal ethics be subject to someone else's ethics, because if you do that, then it means you don't really have ethics. You aren't accepting to an industry, you are accepting to a hiring manager. And it's just rude to act this way. Exploding offers aren't great, and if you have a problem with them, then simply don't accept them. You miss some opportunities this way but you feel better when you look in the mirror. Regardless, as others have noted, Coinbase has some specific issues that aren't indicative of a broader industry probem. They seem to be handling this as well as can be expected given those problems.
- whimsicalism 4y agoThere is basically no company that wouldn't rescind an offer if it made the difference between 1x profits and 1.5x profits. Why wouldn't I behave exactly the same way if another company offers me 1.5x the salary?
- throwaway5752 4y agoBecause you are better than they are? edit: Since I can't delete my comment now, I just want to apologize that I read your message too quickly and missed the 50% salary difference part. Come on, there's ethical and then there is crazy, of course you leave and take the other offer if it's 50%, that's common sense and any hiring manager should understand it. But that's not really commonplace and you can handle it in a professionally ethical way.
- w-j-w 4y agoWhy? I am not dealing with a person. The ethical reasons for being honest don't extend to groups of people acting like psychopaths. Don't let profit driven corporations brand themselves as "family", or any other concept which deserves moral consideration.
- whimsicalism 4y agoI don't see anything particularly wrong with either way, I guess. If they have to rescind offers to be a profitable business, so be it. Sometimes I will have to renege in exchange for working fewer years. I'm joining a business, not the Knights Templar.
- mberning 4y agoCompletely and totally unethical slimeballs.
- dheera 4y agoI mean, if the shareholders hadn't downvoted Coinbase stock to oblivion, this wouldn't have happened.
- itsoktocry 4y agoWhat does the share price have to do with this? Perhaps if the co-founders hadn't paid themselves over a billion in stock compensation, this wouldn't have happened.
- dheera 4y agoCompanies lay people when stock price goes down?
- itsoktocry 4y agoYou have your causation mixed up. Poorly performing companies lay people off.
- polote 4y agoIs expoding offers worse than being fired on the first day at your job? If not then why does it bring so much hate? At least more hate than just firing people. Honest question
- Zenbit_UX 4y agoWell, the problem as I see it is, I just gave my 2 weeks notice when I accepted your offer. I might have even given it earlier and pushed the start date a week forward so I could get a nice gap week to decompress between jobs. Now, at this new company I've been excited to work for, I receive an email telling me that I in fact do not have a job next week and I am actually unemployed. My options range from extremely bad (begging for old job back) to mildly embarrassing (attempting to re-accept a previously declined counter offer).
- saagarjha 4y agoSure, if you're fired you get unemployment.
- i_like_waiting 4y agoWith big companies and if you are not household name, I believe it should be easier than people think. Change your email and phone number in CV next time you are applying and nobody will remember your past with the company. I am hiring manager in mid-size company and if you used different email to login into workday, to work for somebody who is not sitting next to me, no chance your previous behaviour could disqualify you in any way.
- samcheng 4y agoExploding offers are, by far, the easiest thing to negotiate in a job offer. Please don't be duplicitous - there are many teams out there with strong core values and an honest and open communication culture. Don't let the crypto-bros poison our collective dignity!
- anonymousab 4y agoTeams, yes. But the greater companies? By default, you should assume that any modern corporation cannot be trusted to do anything but act in its own perceived short term best interest. Some may not, some may do better, but you should never assume that they will.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> you should assume that any modern corporation cannot be trusted to do anything but act in its own perceived short term best interest Trust, but verify. You shouldn't set yourself up to get massively screwed if a corporate pinky swear falls through. But if you act like an asshole in ever interaction, you're going to select for people who find that the norm.
- azemetre 4y agoTrust but verify only applies to people not pseudo legal entities that have at most a few hundred years of legal history that will likely change again in the next 1,000 years. People acting behalf on these entities don’t deserve your unearned trust.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> People acting behalf on these entities don’t deserve your unearned trust I never said that. I just don't want to be permanently surrounded by assholes. Presuming the other side is an asshole is a good way to end up in that situation.
- anonporridge 4y ago
- omoikane 4y agoNote that there are companies that forbid employees from being on the payroll for another company at the same time. So if a person accepted two offers simultaneously, and both companies found out, this person could end up with zero jobs. Also, I wonder if this mainly a problem when there is a long gap between accepting the offer and the job start date. I would think a better strategy is to try to start getting paid as soon an offer is extended, by starting sooner.
- snotrockets 4y agoYou don't get on the payroll before day 1.
- phkahler 4y ago> We will rescind a number of accepted offers. Came here to quote the same line, but follow it with "yeah, fuck these guys". Its not fair to paint the whole industry with bad sentiment, but anyone who recinds accepted offers either has no decency or no ability to forecast their most basic needs.
- s17n 4y ago+1 to this It's at will employment so a signed offer doesn't really mean anything anyway. Practically speaking, people renege on offers all the time and nobody holds it against them.
- benatkin 4y agoI wrote this out: The honesty is refreshing. Still, why does it always have to be when they're doing something they shouldn't do? ... Then I realized that they really have to do something, and I don't know exactly what the alternative is. If they gave them any compensation they would be admitting harming people and that could be a legal issue. Edit: Oh, they are doing that, but are vague about it: > We will apply our generous severance philosophy to offset the financial impact of this decision. That's a pretty nice minimal way of saying it, and they probably will have a minimal approach of doing it as well, both to reduce the cost and risks.
- ary 4y ago> I always advise people who get exploding offers from companies to just accept them and then back out later if they need to This is not a sustainable long-term strategy for most people. You know what is? Walking away from the offer immediately when it has an overly-aggressive expiration date and letting them know the reason.
- jeffbee 4y agoAbsolutely. I got two exploding offers in my career and I declined them on the spot. Both companies later returned with better offers and longer timelines. There's really no reason to let a company push you around. Just walk away.
- adrr 4y agoTo be fair. Not all HR departments are like that. I’ve been through big layoffs during the last recessions and we let people go the day they joined and gave them 3 month severance packages, cobra access and unemployment insurance. Coinbase HR are just being jackasses and deserve to be blacklisted. This behavior should not be tolerated to prevent employees from giving 0 day notice when they quit and screwing over the rest of us. I know they are going in my hiring notebook for do not hire.
- darkerside 4y agoThey say they are giving severance, so I wouldn't be so quick to judge.
- adrr 4y agoThey shouldn’t have rescinded offers and just let people people go the day they join. The damage is already done and there are comments on here about giving no notice.
- ignu 4y agojfc, a coinbase recruiter emailed me just six days ago.
- deepGem 4y agoThere was a major hue and cry by founders, esp in Bangalore about how ungrateful the prospective employees were, when they ghosted the founders after accepting offers. These founders never really tried to understand the simple market dynamics and that they would do something similar to employees, should the market go down. The playing God shit by founders has to end and this move by Coinbase gives a huge boost to employees to hedge their offers. I won't be surprised if employees accept 2 offers, join one and after a a couple of days say no to the other or ghost them.
- tnel77 4y agoI worked with a guy who stayed with a company through “thick and thin.” Then when it was a good move for the company, they laid him off. He asked HR if they could help him find a new position within the company and their response was “HR is not in the business of helping people find employment.” TLDR: HR definitely does not care about you. It’s all about making sure the company doesn’t get in trouble while they do their best to exploit you.
- greyhair 4y agoThe only time the HR department has been a great help for me was in a layoff situation. I was part of a general 20% cut a few years ago, and the layoffs were staggered over six tranches spread over four months. Why the spread? To avoid reporting requirements that would trigger with that many people leaving at once. I was slotted for the last release. At the end of the summer. Just before my kids would return to college / high school. The first release was in May. I could spend the whole summer thinking about what to do next, and beach days with my kids. So I told management, I am out of here in May. They said 'no, and if you leave, you lose your vacation pay and severance'. So I called HR, explained my thinking, and told them to get me out of there in May. Management was not happy, but HR took full responsibility for the moved date. And I got to spend a glorious late spring and early summer lazing about before reentering the work force.