12 ms·
I used to work for TomTom maybe 10 years ago. I was there when Google started offering turn by turn navigation for free. Other issue was live traffic informati
by scotty79 4y ago
I used to work for TomTom maybe 10 years ago.
I was there when Google started offering turn by turn navigation for free. Other issue was live traffic information. As you might imagine all this caused some concern among employees because that was, I think, the main source of revenue for the company.
They were already doing some other stuff like fitness wearables but they didn't seem to be leaning into it.
Main idea for staying in business, since you can't compete with free, was to go deeper into cooperation with car manufacturers to provide builtin navigation in cars. They were already doing it back then, I think, but they've seen their salvation in capturing bigger part of that market.
I was a software developer there, employed in projects pretty far from their core business, but I learned there a lot about how companies become corporations why they can and do run like a headless
chicken, spilling money left and right. It's basically about survival. Company becomes a corporation when it randomly discovers a gold vein in the economy. For TomTom this gold vein was maps on portable computers. This gold vein brings in absolutely insane amount of money. Then this money needs to be spent on doing a lot of unrelated inefficient discovery work wasting huge amount of money so they have a chance of finding next gold vein before shifting sands of economy and human development burry the original one.
From what I see shared in this thread, TomTom still haven't found their second gold vein.
Maybe I should get hired there again. A lot of my friends from other jobs work there now. I never seen from the inside how corporations die.
- tdfx 4y agoIf it makes you feel better, Google doesn't have a second gold vein yet, either.
- random314 4y agoIsn't the phrase gold mine?
- amelius 4y agoYou can't accidentally hit a gold mine like you can a gold vein.
- Integrape 4y agoYou build the mine after finding the vein.
- sp332 4y agoA vein of gold is an incredibly pure area of ore. Sometimes you can basically pick chucks of gold up off the ground. https://www.livescience.com/bonanza-gold-vein-nanoparticles.html https://www.livescience.com/bonanza-gold-vein-nanoparticles....
- metacritic12 4y agoBut they (chose / lucked into) a gold vein that's huge and growing. And played no small role in shaping the ecology (Android to keep abreast of mobile, Pixel to reduce hardware monopoly) to ensure that gold vein grew.
- wutbrodo 4y agoI'm always a little confused by this claim. Focusing on revenue-generating products and not the user products they use to sell them: Google Search was their first success, then AdSense (third-party display ads), then YouTube. The latter two each make almost $30B/yr (run rate). Ignoring ads, Google Cloud makes >$20B/yr, as do Google hardware sales, with an additional $30B/yr from "non-advertising Other". I don't really understand how one supports this claim without using decidedly non-standard definitions and grouping of revenue. If you insist on lumping together separate, wildly-successful revenue-generating products into overbroad groups by the manner in which the revenue is collected, and ignore a couple of objectively enormous revenue streams: Do you similarly feel that Apple "hasn't found a second gold vein" beyond "hardware sales"?
- alaricus 4y agoGoogle is fk'ed if wide-scale ad blocking really picks up. For example ISP-level adblocking.
- acchow 4y ago> For example ISP-level adblocking. Google could circumvent this if ISPs tried this. How would an ISP block ads coming in encrypted as normal content?
- alaricus 4y agoThe same way as PiHole does. It's not hard to block Google adds on 3rd party sites with a DNS or IP-level block.
- acchow 4y agoIf ISPs actually tried to do this en-masse, Google would move all ad serving to google.com
- alaricus 4y agoThis is basically what youtube is doing. PiHole does not work on Youtube, but uBlock origin does (so does NewPipe, FreeTube and a bunch of software). This would solve Google's immediate problem, but it's such a huge escalation that I expect lots of unintended effects not to Google's benefit. There is a reason they haven't done this, despite widespread adblocking use.
- ratww 4y agoYeah, the industry is definitely moving to that. Admiral, probably the most known ad-blocker-blocker already successfully circumvents PiHole and other DNS blocking by being served by the same domain. I also expect Google to double down on Chrome Manifest v3 limitations if ad-blocking keeps getting more popular. Or even using DNS-over-HTTPS as a default on Chrome if ISP blocking ever becomes a thing.
- agloeregrets 4y agoGoogle bought their other Gold. Youtube, Android, Google Search on iOS, ChromeOS. All of it is a moat to protect the first.
- sp332 4y agoYouTube doesn't make a lot of money. Android might if you include the Play store.
- sbrother 4y ago> YouTube doesn't make a lot of money. Citation needed... Is $7B/quarter not a lot of money?
- mrtranscendence 4y agoThat’s revenue, not profit. I don’t have profit numbers but I’ve heard that YouTube is extremely expensive to run.
- idiotsecant 4y agoGoogle doesn't release net income numbers by business unit but in 2021 revenue for search was around $148B and Youtube revenue was around $29B. Given that youtube revenue dollars are probably much more expensive than search revenue dollars I'd say that ratio will skew toward more of the profit being in the search category than the you tube category, not less. It does seem on balance to be a relatively small part of their business dollars-wise, although I'd make the case that the cultural relevancy that youtube gives google has a non-zero value.
- wutbrodo 4y agoA run-rate of $30B/yr is "not a lot of money"?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- perlgeek 4y agoWhat about cloud?
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoHasn’t Google said if they don’t “win” Cloud against AWS and/or Azure, they’re going to shut GCP down eventually?
- ceras 4y agoIIRC the rumor leak around that was more nuanced: the leaks reported someone allegedly saying that market economics may not ultimately be able to support more than 2 leaders, because the economics will make #1 and #2 able to profit at prices that numbers 3+ can't compete with due to lack of scale. So the statement was that GCP has keep up or its ability to profit will be at risk, not that they'd shut down just because their slice of the pie isn't big enough if they end up as #3. I don't believe it was clear who said this, how confident it was that someone said this, and whether it was an off-the-cuff comment in support of a push for more growth or an actual deep assessment of the economics of the space.
- kube-system 4y agoGCP loses money. They just reported their best quarter for cloud earnings. Negative 931 million dollars in Q1 2022.
- nix9000 4y agoThe numbers are trending in the right direction. From 2021Q1 to 2022Q1, revenue grew 43% (vs 34% at AWS and 46% at Azure), loss went down by 4%, and the loss to revenue ratio went from 24% to 16%.
- asdff 4y agoDon't they have like a dozen ore veins?
- Valakas_ 4y agoWhen you have unlimited money, there's no need to find it. Just buy it.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoInteresting that going deeper integrated into cars was their game plan. I've never used our in-car GPS (other than playing with it once). If it was any good it has a ton of advantages over using Google, including display on the "speedometer" screen. Sadly, it's pants. It comically announces caution stationary traffic on the M25, generally after we've been stationary for 5 minutes. The navigation directions aren't as good and Google is just so much better at door to door directions to a named destination. Others will get you close to your destination and you have to work it out. Google will, more often than not, take you to the correct carpark. With Android Auto displaying on the dash it's not even a competition.
- ratww 4y agoI remember TomTom being a lot better than the competition, though. Most other units were terribly slow and sometimes borderline unusable. Not to mention the updates... not software updates, but the map updates. I still remember my parents, with the help of my siblings, spending weeks trying update their cheap Chinese GPS using instructions from random internet forums, only to give up and get a more expensive TomTom unit. The Chinese unit was given away at a Facebook group to someone more adventurous. Of course, mobile apps have definitely caught up years ago, and I believe you that they're even better now.
- asdff 4y agoI have no experience with tom tom but I was a garmin user, and I got the sense that tom toms were pretty much identical. IMO an integrated tom tom into the car, if it performs as well as the external unit, would be amazingly better than your cell phone. The biggest advantage imo is satellite coverage is much better than quality data network coverage. I'm not even talking about in the boonies. Plenty of times in the middle of LA county I am sitting there waiting on a seemingly stalled LTE connection to render a map I supposedly had already cached locally according to google maps.
- cgriswald 4y agoI have an older in-car system and my experience is the opposite. First, the car doesn't download map data. I'm stuck with what was on the car when I bought it unless I want to pay an unreasonable amount to update it. Second, it does download traffic data, but it's so slow that it's useless. I took its advice once and it cost me over an hour, because the alternate route had already filled up and had the disadvantage of not being a freeway. Third, it can't navigate a path without connecting to the satellite (seemingly for traffic data, but possibly it isn't even calculating the path locally). So when I visit downtown SF, don't have up-to-date maps, and I'm inevitably behind some building blocking my southern view, it just abandons me.
- babypuncher 4y ago> go deeper into cooperation with car manufacturers to provide builtin navigation in cars. I feel like this is a dying market as well. Why would I pay $200/year to update the maps in my car's mediocre navigation system when I can just turn on Apple CarPlay/Android Auto and get the same excellent navigation system I enjoy on my smartphone?
- chrisseaton 4y agoMy car's built-in navigation can do things Apple CarPlay can't, like HUD, dashboard mapping, dead-reckoning navigation in tunnels, fuel management, etc.
- andiareso 4y ago...until feature parity. Soon Apple/Google will be able to integrate with those features too. Aside from "dead-zones", I'm sure they will eventually have more integrations with car interfaces. Even so, both Google and Apple seem to predict your location when signal drops. Somehow I still get decent navigation when I am in the middle of nowhere Iowa and have no cell service. Obviously the maps are cached, but somehow it knows I'm still moving. Must be accelerometer and gyroscope? IDK I'd really like dash HUD integration with CarPlay.
- sophacles 4y agoGPS has nothing to do with cell signal. GPS is it's own signal from satellites that your phone has no problem receiving in a place like Iowa. In fact Iowa has a lot of things going for it to enhance GPS receivership - it's flat so you can see most of the sky, it's open - there's just not a lot of vegetation to absorb the signal coming from overhead (e.g. trees), its in the middle of the US which means there's always going to be 4 or 5 satellites with a line of sight to your phone.
- tinus_hn 4y agoIt’s a $200 solution that has to compete with ‘good enough’. That’s really hard and they aren’t making it work.
- chrisseaton 4y ago> how companies become corporations Aren't all companies corporations?
- mrtranscendence 4y agoNo, a corporation is a specific type of business arrangement. For example, you can have a limited liability company (LLC) that is wholly owned by an individual.
- chrisseaton 4y agoI don't think TomTom changed what type of company it was.
- mrtranscendence 4y agoGotcha. You meant something more like "wasn't TomTom already a corporation?"
- scotty79 4y agoTomTom started as a small software company named "Palmtop Software" and was doing exactly that. Random software for palmtops. I'm not sure, but I think they might have changed their formal business structure along with the name once they discovered that they created killer app for palmtops that makes customers buy palmtops as fast as they were made so they can use just their app on them.
- throwawaycfg 4y agoJoin IBM
- cjblomqvist 4y agoThere is an alternative to "wasting" money to give a second gold vein. You can just do the cash cow thing and then die. That's a totally reasonable. If TomTom don't think they can use the money better than other investment alternatives (that their investors have), then they shouldn't. Of course, politics and personal interests. But sometimes it's just better to allocate resources to something where they're better utilized.
- enkid 4y agoHas a CEO ever been hired to do this? I just don't see a business ever saying don't invest in us because there are better alternatives.
- __alexs 4y agoThey are called liquidators.
- jackweirdy 4y agoSome see paying out dividends as saying “you can do more with this money than we can right now”
- MichaelBurge 4y agoREITs are required by tax law to pay out 90%+ of their income, and everyone invests in them specifically for the dividend. If the stock price gets too high, they always dilute it by issuing new shares to raise money for new projects. So you're never expecting lots of appreciation. There's hundreds of them, and also many private REITs that are unlisted with the same fundamental idea. Oil, utilities, REITs, small business lenders, etc. all have investors expecting management to just sit there, don't kill the golden goose, and pay regular dividends.
- speed_spread 4y agoThat Nokia guy when they "sold" to Microsoft. He was the captain put in place to run the ship aground.
- mason55 4y ago
- m463 4y agoI think there's a place for offline maps, both in terms of connection reliability and privacy.
- jollybean 4y agoI think this is a naive take, the glib view of a worker with no practical insight into company operations and decision making. It's doubtful that TomTom's foray into mobile was 'accidental' and it's also hard to understand how much money is being spent, and the risks involved in finding other revenue streams. When mega corps come in and suddenly make a major part of your business unworkable, yes, companies go into reactionary mode. That's normal.
- scotty79 4y ago> It's doubtful that TomTom's foray into mobile was 'accidental' They started as a small company writing random software for palmtops. Until one day they made mapping software. They didn't expect it will be that popular with people. It was popular to a degree that people were buying palmtops just to use their app and didn't care about all other software their new palmtop could have. It's as if today, small software shop released an app that bumps iPhone device sales by +20% just because people want to use that one app event though they don't care about all other things iPhone can do. Everybody can dream of that, but nobody can plan for that. It was purely accidental. > When mega corps come in and suddenly make a major part of your business unworkable, yes, companies go into reactionary mode. That's normal. What I describe as running like a headless chicken started many years before I came to TomTom. I've seen tonnes of internal wiki's that were once created for internal random, ultimately abandoned projects. I even seen two projects attempting the same thing, new one didn't have an idea that somebody, some time ago in that same corporation already tried to build that. It's standard mode of operation. In corporation you have core business that's kept tight and professional and huge amount of side activity that's just bleeding money trying to discover next big pivot.
- miohtama 4y agoI heard a similar story from a friend who works for ARM. It was a fun ride, but now extra fat and spent is being cut away for IPO.
- konschubert 4y ago> Then this money needs to be spent on doing a lot of unrelated inefficient discovery work wasting huge amount of money so they have a chance of finding next gold vein before shifting sands of economy and human development burry the original one. They could also return the money to shareholders and let the shareholders invest it into startups and companies that need investment to make money. These are usually much better bets than the old company re-inventing itself. A company is not an end in itself, it is a temporary assembly of humans to explore a gold vein. Trying to make it eternal serves the CEO, but not the shareholders. Instead of facebook trying to create the next facebook, it should return money to shareholders and let them buy into whatever is the next big thing.