5 ms·
That only works in the small scale — company X can’t find the staff, or person Y can’t find a home, but if they had more money they could. In the scale of nati
by ben_w 4y ago
That only works in the small scale — company X can’t find the staff, or person Y can’t find a home, but if they had more money they could.
In the scale of nations, adding more money without increasing supply is called “inflation”: if there was a shortage before, it’s still there even if everyone has an extra thousand currency units per month, per day, or per hour.
- hackernewds 4y agoI think you mean adding more money without increasing demand is called inflation
- ianai 4y agoWithout increasing supply*
- marcosdumay 4y agoBoth are defined as exactly the same value... Edit: And from the downvote to disagree reaction, looks like people not only get their terms from economics without looking their meaning, but seem to be also incredibly confident on it.
- sokoloff 4y agoI did not downvote, but the flaw in your reasoning is that while microeconomics defines supply and demand to intersect at equilibrium, it does not require those curves to stay unchanged. The argument of "if you add more money without increasing [demand|supply], the equilibrium price will change" has a different meaning depending on which of those words you choose, even though at both the old and new equilibrium, the curves will intersect.
- marcosdumay 4y agoWell, they don't intersect "at equilibrium", they are the same, with the only possible addition of some noise with average 0 due to accounting delays. In microeconomics you can cut your data and ignore parts of them, so they can become different, but the thread up there is taking about markets, not single entities. The argument does not change if you trade supply into demand. In fact, demand and supply are not good quantities to put on it at all, because both are defined for a set price, so if you add more money and keep them unchanged, the equilibrium price doesn't change. The entire inflation event happens because they change. Both sides of the disagreement up there are logical consequences of looking at half of that issue and trying to get a full picture from it.
- sokoloff 4y agoEquilibrium does not refer only to a static two-dimensional chart with quantity on one axis and price on the other. It also refers to the reactions of market participants to other factors (substitute goods, supply and prices of key inputs, money supply, taxes/tariffs, etc.)
- marcosdumay 4y agoI don't get where you are going. Supply and demand being the same does not depend on the reaction of people. They are the same because they measure the same thing.
- sokoloff 4y agoThe supply curve shifts when conditions change. (When you make inputs more expensive, suppliers will offer fewer units at a given nominal price.) The demand curve shifts when conditions change. (When you airdrop money to people, they will be willing to pay more in nominal dollars for normal goods at any given quantity.)
- marcosdumay 4y agoWell, I'm pretty sure the OP was talking about quantities. Anyway, those curves are mathematical things people create for analysis, that mean absolutely nothing by themselves, and only give you back the conclusions of whatever assumptions you put on them. The phrases you have between parenthesis mean something, the ones you have outside of the parenthesis do not say anything. If people kept their discussion at the real stuff from the beginning, they wouldn't ever miss their meaning and try to form mathematically invalid arguments by trying to change half one equation while assuming the other half constant.
- mantas 4y agoThen it creates more pressure for productivity improvements. E.g. automatization. Or product price increase reduces demand. E.g. pay restaurant workers more -> less people come to more expensive restaurants -> less workers needed.
- yetihehe 4y agoIf restaurant prices were 100% worker pay, that would be true. But when you increase pay by 50%, your prices do not necessarily increase by 50% which also does not mean you will have 50% less customers. Currently owners of businesses minimise ALL expenses, but for workers, that is already at minimum. For some workers it's below a minimum which they can accept, so they don't work.
- wongarsu 4y agoThat depends on how elastic the supply is. If everyone is willing to pay more for van Gogh paintings they simply get more expensive. But most things have a much more elastic supply, even if often only on the scale of years instead of months. If there's a sustained screw shortage that drives investment in new factories. If there's a sustained oil shortage and everyone is willing to pay double for oil that drives investment in extraction methods that previously weren't economically viable. Germany had a sustained labor shortage in the 50s and 60s due to a booming economy with a war-decimated population, which drove immigration of Turkish workers (including bilateral agreements to smooth the legal process).
- makomk 4y agoIn particular, there's a fundamental constraint we need to remember: in order for people to buy things with their wages, those things must be produced. That is to say, it's not possible for businesses across the economy to just decide to pay everyone better in real, inflation-adjusted terms of what they can actually afford to buy with their income and make everyone better off, because that doesn't magically make more stuff spring into existence to purchase. There's a kind of thinking I see a lot in these threads where there's no labour shortage, businesses just need to pay better and if they don't then they don't deserve to continue existing as a business, framing this as evil businesses jsut complaining about not being able to keep their non-viable business models going anymore. The thing is, this misses the other side: a lot of those businesses produce stuff that consumers want, and if they're no longer viable any more then that consumer demand cannot be filled at the price people were willing to pay, again decreasing the value of people's income in real what-they-can-buy terms.
- verve_rat 4y agoSure, but those business could take reduced profits. No extra money needed, just a redistribution, if you will.
- ghaff 4y agoIn many cases, especially small businesses, there may not be sufficient profits to spread around. At some point on the price scale, a lot of restaurants just aren't going to have customers. And how many people will be willing to take an Uber if it costs $10/minute?
- michaelt 4y agoYou're right that if you've got a sinking ship with 1000 passengers, and only 500 seats in lifeboats, no means of allocation will make 1000 less than 500. But in almost all markets, higher prices reduce demand. I don't own a Rolex because they cost too much, I settle for a Casio instead. Does that mean there's a Rolex shortage?
- nradov 4y agoLuxury goods like Rolex watches are kind of a bad example because manufacturers intentionally produce less than they could in order to create artificial scarcity.