9 ms·
The article is better than the headline. Remember that the reason we use so much land is because that's the cheapest way to grow food. We could grow more foo
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
The article is better than the headline.
Remember that the reason we use so much land is because that's the cheapest way to grow food. We could grow more food on less land by farming more intensively. We don't because that would make the food more expensive. At an extreme, a greenhouse can increase yields 100x but at an increase in costs of 10x.
- twox2 4y agoYields increased by 10x for costs increased by 10x sounds cheaper to me.
- dtech 4y agoI assume the 10x cost increase was per-yield, 100x the yield for 1000x the price.
- forrestthewoods 4y agoAhh that makes sense. The original language was pretty confusing. Increase yields 100x per sqft Increase costs 10x per lb
- jonny_eh 4y agoPeople can only eat so much food, and it can only be sold for so little.
- georgeecollins 4y agoYield per acre 100x, yield per $, 1/10x
- shagie 4y agohttps://agfundernews.com/the-economics-of-local-vertical-and-greenhouse-farming-are-getting-competitive https://agfundernews.com/the-economics-of-local-vertical-and... For greens, an conventional farm is $0.65/lb and a greenhouse is $2.33/lb. > Assuming a 40-45% gross margin for a typical supermarket produce department, retail prices for greens would need to be approximately $1 a pound for conventional, $4 a pound for greenhouse, $5 a pound for vertical, and $12 a pound for container-grown. A typical head of bibb or butter lettuce weighs less than half a pound. Therefore, the lettuce can be grown in a greenhouse or vertical farm and sold at retail for $2 to $3 per head. > Although greenhouse or vertical farming is three to five times more expensive than growing on a conventional outdoor farm, it still allows for competitive pricing to the consumer with other vegetables and sides. The yield can go up, but the cost per unit goes up too.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoWhat are the biggest factors that contribute to the cost? Is it mostly increased labor?
- cogman10 4y agoLabor and machinery. You can't run a harvesting tractor through a greenhouse. So, a lot of produce from greenhouses or vertical farms (etc) ends up with a manual harvesting step. This is why you pretty much see greenhouses exclusively used for foods which would require that manual step anyways.
- cupofpython 4y agowe have AI based dancing robots now, maybe they can figure something out for this
- cogman10 4y agoI think it's possible the whole system could be automated. The problem really ends up being one of cost. It's similar to the "burger flipper robot" problem. Possibility solvable, but also gonna be costly and buggy for v1 of the robot.
- shagie 4y agoIts an area of active development and research - https://youtu.be/5chk9Sory88 https://youtu.be/5chk9Sory88 Note that this is an area that is rather specialized - a pepper picking robot isn't good for tomato picking or lettuce picking ( https://youtu.be/EFC3OvkVKaQ https://youtu.be/EFC3OvkVKaQ ). Compare that to the incredibly versatile human ( https://youtu.be/oxbJVqfIK1U https://youtu.be/oxbJVqfIK1U ).
- DarylZero 4y ago>You can't run a harvesting tractor through a greenhouse. Sure you can. Just needs to be big enough.
- la6472 4y agoFTA “ improvements in crop yields, agricultural productivity, and dietary choices are so important.” and the biggest one imo is dietary choices. Our meat consumption has lead to pasteurization of forest land to raise and feed the huge amount of livestocks needed to satisfy our meat craving.
- jahewson 4y agoOnce upon a time everything was forest land. The line seems a bit arbitrary.
- criley2 4y agoWhile the many types of forests (deciduous, coniferous, rain, etc) dominate a lot of land on earth, there is still many types of plains, chaparral/savannah, deserts, mountain, tundras, etc.
- lupire 4y ago0 forest certainly seems bad.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThere is more forest in North Dakota today than there was when Columbus landed.
- smallerfish 4y ago> pasteurization You mean pasturization. Pasteurization would also be unfortunate though.
- wiz21c 4y agoYeah, but done at that scale, it'd be quite a thing to watch :-)
- Zababa 4y ago> Our meat consumption has lead to pasteurization of forest land to raise and feed the huge amount of livestocks needed to satisfy our meat craving Where? France has increased its forest surface since 1840, while increasing population and meat consumption.
- yumraj 4y agoWhat about nutritional value? From various reports lately, I don't have links handy but I've seen them shared here on HN, it is generally accepted that the nutritional value of the food is declining. This has been primarily attributed, from what I remember, to the condition of the soil. So, if we start producing everything in a greenhouse, won't that impact nutritional value as well.
- cjsawyer 4y agoIn the extreme case, this is something we’ll need to figure out for space exploration too. Hopefully people are working on it!
- jay_kyburz 4y agoIt's not just space, global warming could lead to a complete ecosystem collapse (think Mars). We may need to move everything into climate controlled environments.
- zemvpferreira 4y agoAs far as I remember from the last discussion on the matter the effect is overblown. Nutrient decline for modern techniques and soils is around 7% from baseline.
- beambot 4y agoIs that 7% one-time or 7% compounding? The latter has a pretty deleterious effect over time...
- zemvpferreira 4y agoOne-time, or rather total decrease over time. I'll see if I can dig up a source. EDIT - old but seems like a decent review: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/soil-depletion-and-nutrition-loss/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/soil-depletion-an... To recap, there are declines up to 30% in certain nutrients for certain vegetables. This seems to be mostly down to farmers choosing varietals that grow faster and handle transport better over time. Personally it's still my opinion that this is no big deal. Even if, say, oranges are lower-quality than a century ago, they are now cheap, easy to obtain and available year-round. You might have to eat four oranges instead of one for whatever nutrient allotment you desire but...that's a heck of a lot easier than it was for our grandparents. As long as people aren't eating mainly combinations of flour and oil, they'll be fine.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- masklinn 4y ago> the cheapest way to grow food. Not just the cheapest, but the easiest: in many countries, and especially (though not exclusively) the US, the primary purpose of farming is landowning, so the primary incentive is limiting inconvenience.
- siruncledrew 4y agoI can see agricultural land going down even further in the future as techniques, incentives, and people dynamics change. How much of what we farm is really just 'superficial agriculture' and not 'survival-driven agriculture'? For example: gigantic monoculture fields of corn in the midwest US, groves of almonds and grazing crops in California, huge amounts of grasslands for beef. (I'm sure there's more examples too) It just seems like many of the ways agriculture operates doesn't make sense from a needs-based perspective and certainly not from a nature-enhancement perspective either. Farmers just do their job of growing, and then money does its job of convincing.
- peteey 4y agoCorn makes up more than 10% of global food production. A significant fraction of the world would not 'survive' if those fields of corn suddenly disappeared. A better example would be specifically corn used for ethanol because driving a car is not essential for survival. The other two examples seem valid. Replacing part of your meat consumption with corn would reduce the required agricultural land.
- AlanSE 4y agohttps://thehill.com/policy/equilibrium-sustainability/3504613-five-things-to-watch-for-in-next-years-climate-farm-bill/ https://thehill.com/policy/equilibrium-sustainability/350461... An interesting quote which echos what you're saying here: > That means that table corn, carrots, cabbage, apples and broccoli are all examples of what is called, paradoxically, “specialty crops” — and they largely don’t get the same support as the heavily subsidized industrial crops. The absurdity here is that "specialty" crops are what you might call "food". Most corn is "what my food eats". If survival was important, people could switch trivially. I would take a 99% vegetarian diet in exchange for not dying. Problem is that the costs may be collectivized, and weighted towards future generations.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoLots of ways. We can live with much less sugar in our food. One example: sugarcane. According to the (UN) FAO, "The present area of sugarcane (Saccarum officinarum) is about 13 million ha with a total commercial world production of about 1254.8 million ton/year cane or 55 million ton/year sucrose. (FAOSTAT, 2001)." [https://www.fao.org/land-water/databases-and-software/crop-information/sugarcane/en/ https://www.fao.org/land-water/databases-and-software/crop-i...] That climbed to 1.9B tons by 2020. [WP ... 40% in Brazil] And 13Mha = 130,000 km^2 > 50,000 sq.mi. About the size of Iowa. And then, there's almonds.
- eloff 4y agoGreenhouses are amazing. One of the top agricultural exporters in the world is the Netherlands. That shocked me when I discovered it. Part of the reason is fertile soil and dependable rain. But a huge component of how they can do so much with so little land is greenhouses. It seems like something we could stand to invest a lot more in as a global civilization. An understated benefit is making the food supply more robust to volcanoes, asteroids, and nuclear winters.
- wait_a_minute 4y agoAnd vertical farms are set to increase the capabilities even more! https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkoetsier/2020/11/20/this-2-acre-vertical-farm-out-produces-750-acre-flat-farms https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkoetsier/2020/11/20/this-2-...
- betwixthewires 4y agoA 100x increase in yield at 10x increase in cost equates to a drop in cost of farming food of 90%.
- ball_of_lint 4y agoCost-per-unit
- betwixthewires 4y agoSo a 1000x increase in total cost? That doesn't add up, it doesn't cost that much to use your own greenhouse, I can't imagine something like that wouldn't benefit from economies of scale.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoThe extreme isn't too important and highly dependent on the plant but it still can reach 10x the efficiency on average. There are some plants that don't do well in a greenhouse since they need a period of dormancy. Power consumption is also a factor. Without fans the humid environment is prone to fungal infections and certain pests can spread pretty quickly too. Overall it is a benefit since it simply allows for climate control. But you also have to heat it in winter since the plants will be very susceptible to the cold in their pots. Still, greenhouses are barely an option in the hotter climates since the power consumption would be insane. And nobody would grow potatoes in a greenhouse because that would be extremely labor intensive.
- prawn 4y agoI've visited a very advanced tomato greenhouse. They have a heliostatic solar field and tower that provides heating for the greenhouses plus fans for cooling, and desalinates water to irrigate. The tomatoes grow in their substrate on top of big cooling/heating pipes that can be easily regulated. There's automated ventilation at the top of the greenhouses. They release wasps inside the greenhouse to control pests. Through summer, they spray the greenhouses with a chalky material to block some of the light. Picking carts can self-drive themselves via guiding tracks embedded in the concrete flooring. It's all very clever, the plants are insanely productive and the produce tasted good to me. Meanwhile my homegrown tomatoes are a constant battle on every front (heat, water, pests, etc).
- zxspectrum1982 4y agoThat's not true. I come from a family of farmers since centuries, in Southern Europe. I am the owner of several large plots of land and I helped my family when I was a kid. Growing food in greenhouses makes food cheaper than growing food outside greenhouses. Problem is quality. E. g. a tomato grown in a greenhouse does not taste as good as a tomato grown outside. In fact, the greenhouse tomato hardly has any taste. Another problem is organic, eco-friendliness and all of those "luxuries of the first world": when growing in greenhouse, you'll have to use pesticides and all of those things that improve yield and keep plagues at bay. But then you are no longer ecological so some markets (e. g. Germany) close for you. Also, this whole thing about "peak agricultural land". Bullshit. Really. There's plenty of unused agricultural land. The main problem with agriculture as of today is prices of sold goods vs cost of production, and that's only because of globalization, cheap transport and cheap labor in third-world countries (Africa, South America). E. g. where I grew up, there were big extensions of almond trees. Yet already 30 years ago, it was cheaper to bring almonds from California than grow our own almonds here! That crop is almost gone now, except for people (like me) who still have some almond trees for our own consumption (not to sell). And the actual problem will happen in a few years, one or two decades at most: most of the sons and daughters of farmers went to university or vocational school, and now they have other jobs. Not farming. What will happen if globalization reverses (like it seems to be doing since COVID-19 started)? or if transport costs so much that growing locally starts to make economical sense again? We will have lost that knowledge and skills about agriculture. My only hope is I am seeing a few of my school and university mates, who studied Economic Science, Psychology, Electric Engineering, Civil Engineering, etc and became so fed up with those jobs, that they went back to agriculture (and they are making money because they have an analytical mind and they know what to grow, when and who to sell to, and first thing they do is they have a "business plan" for their lands and crops). Something like what happened in electronics.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoWhat would be the cost of something like wheat grown in a greenhouse? The costs would be a lot more than a 10X increase.
- 4y ago