11 ms·
There is no reason to cross the U.S. by train but I did it anyway (2019)
- rascul 4y agoWeird. In Firefox, on Android, reader mode gets me a long article about some people in Alaska.
- bombcar 4y agoThe long-distance Amtraks are more like a rolling hotel or land cruise-ship in some ways. Highly recommended if you have the time - https://www.amtraktrains.com https://www.amtraktrains.com is worth the research, as Amtrak's ticketing system is literally a 70s airline ticketing system and if you learn how to play it you can get sleeper car reservations for relatively cheap. You can also find destinations that would otherwise be moderately difficult to reach - for example the Empire Builder stops at East Glacier in Montana from spring to fall - extremely small town with wonderful hiking, etc. Here's a song about a similar route in Canada: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YXcfRlEGJko https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YXcfRlEGJko https://www.viarail.ca/en/explore-our-destinations/trains/rockies-and-pacific/montreal-to-vancouver https://www.viarail.ca/en/explore-our-destinations/trains/ro... You can also have a quite interesting "explore America" trip in both countries with some planning (a travel agent can actually help here if they're knowledgeable) - as you can break the trip up into "daytime travel", stay in a city like Chicago for a few days, and then "overnight" to the next city.
- shagie 4y ago> for example the Empire Builder stops at East Glacier in Montana from spring to fall - extremely small town with wonderful hiking, etc. The southern border of Glacier NP is the railroad. https://www.nps.gov/glac/learn/education/railway.htm https://www.nps.gov/glac/learn/education/railway.htm So, in 1891, the continental divide finally was crossed and the rail barrons were trying to get people to use the railroad. They saw people taking steamships out from NYC to Europe to go see the Alps, and, well, they knew a thing or two about mountains, now too. So the Great Northern Railroad petitioned Congress to make a park in the area that the trains would service. In addition to the park proper, a number Swiss style chalets were built through the park that were approximately 1 day horse ride apart from each other. With this setup, you could take the train to East Glacier or West Glacier, go hose back riding through the mountains, and then get back on the train on the other side and go home. While many of these chalets have been lost to time, some still exist and are maintained - https://www.nplas.org/sperry.html https://www.nplas.org/sperry.html https://www.mtpr.org/montana-news/2018-06-06/funding-secured-to-rebuild-glaciers-sperry-chalet https://www.mtpr.org/montana-news/2018-06-06/funding-secured...
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, some of the most scenic landscape can be found crossing the Rockies.
- secabeen 4y ago> you could take the train to East Glacier or West Glacier Be careful with this idea; East Glacier train station is not actually in the park, and services at that station are limited (West Glacier even more so). It's possible to rent a car at East Glacier, but I expect it would be expensive. You can walk from the train station to a hotel, then be based out of there, but you will be dependent on the shuttle and bus services to explore the park. Some good details about the current situation in this thread; note that services have changed a lot around COVID, and any information from pre-2019 should be considered as out of date, and not reliable: https://www.amtraktrains.com/threads/need-advice-for-short-empire-builder-glacier-national-park-trip.81657/ https://www.amtraktrains.com/threads/need-advice-for-short-e...
- bombcar 4y agoIf you like hiking, you can technically hike from town into the park - I've done it even with snow still on the ground. But depending on what you want to do in the area, you will want to plan ahead.
- Fiahil 4y ago> While many of these chalets have been lost to time How can you loose something, less than 200 years old, to time ?!
- bobthepanda 4y agoWeather in the area isn’t a walk in the park, and I would assume the cabins are wood.
- Fiahil 4y agoSo does 'original' swiss chalets, yet, many of them are much older than that.
- kasey_junk 4y agoThe Empire Builder actually has a park ranger get on the train and do nature lessons/wildlife sightings from a viewing car. It’s pretty great.
- brightball 4y agoIs it true that Amtrak will ship your car for you? I thought about doing a cross country trip and the idea of having my car with me on the other side seemed like a solid plan.
- db48x 4y agoThere is a car train, but it runs along the eastern seaboard. Useful if you live in New York and want to visit/move to Florida for the winter.
- dwater 4y agoTo clarify, there is only one route in the US that has an auto train. It goes from Lorton, VA (about 30 minutes south of DC on I95) to Sanford, FL (a suburb of Orlando), and in the other direction. It has sleeper berths or regular coach class seats, leaves at 4pm and arrives at 9 am, and is generally full of "snowbird" retirees and families going to Disney.
- pimlottc 4y agoI used to work for a shipping company, they did a lot of business shipping cars back and forth to Florida for baseball players doing spring training.
- dvtrn 4y agoI've heard similar stories from a friend working at a major freight logistics broker here in Midwest, he also arranges the moving of parts for the pair of Boeing jets belongs to the New England Patriots NFL franchise. It's not something that sits at the front of your mind, but it makes total sense: logistics for professional sports teams must be a whole industry all on its own.
- Qworg 4y agoWhen I worked for the Chicago Bears, I had the pleasure of driving the smallest of the moving trucks to training camps. A max length box truck. Followed by 3 semis _just of equipment_ - clothing, gear, weights that the college didn't have. It is a circus production every year.
- THJr 4y agoI'm not too familiar with airline ticketing systems, if you don't mind could you clarify what you mean by your 70's ticketing system comment?
- bombcar 4y agoThe 70s ticketing system ran off of "buckets" where availability of fares at various prices wouldn't appear until previous buckets were emptied, or time ran out. I don't remember the details (my only sleeper car trip was paid with Amtrak miles) but if you studied it and worked it you could predict when new buckets would become available, or when a bucket was about to "expire" and the price might drop. If I remember right there was a sweet spot about six months before, and another very shortly before (and if you wanted to be risky, and knew the line, you could get a coach ticket and ask the conductor to pay to upgrade on the train - that is the cheapest of all if there is space available as it basically ends up being the cost of the meals). It's also a bit weird in that if you know some of the limitations, you can do things like get a sleeper for overnight only (from the stop around 5PM to the stop around 8 AM say) and then get a coach ticket from then on - which if scheduled right would end up being the sleeper for the whole trip as there's no point in resetting the room. You could also book "insane trips" that the system wouldn't let you do but were perfectly doable, because it wouldn't correctly recognize that you could make the layover, etc. People would also try to trick it into letting you book trips that wouldn't make sense unless you're trying to ride the train for as long as you can (sleeper car mile purchases were "zoned" in the past - so anything in "Zone 1" would be a fixed amount of miles). They've since changed that to the more standard "miles are just pennies against a normal fair" type of reward.
- secabeen 4y agoThis is much less doable now than it was some years ago. Amtrak's revenue management has gotten a lot better, and most long distance routes start at the highest bucket pricing, and only drop down into lower buckets if demand sags. Demand is also higher than it was pre-COVID, and I don't think you can predict when buckets will expire. > It's also a bit weird in that if you know some of the limitations, you can do things like get a sleeper for overnight only (from the stop around 5PM to the stop around 8 AM say) and then get a coach ticket from then on - which if scheduled right would end up being the sleeper for the whole trip as there's no point in resetting the room. This is also risky, as it depends on the largess of the conductor, who is totally within their rights to kick you out of the sleeper and down into coach at the appropriate time. You also would not get the included meals during your coach segment, and would have to pay for them in the cafe car. > if you wanted to be risky, and knew the line, you could get a coach ticket and ask the conductor to pay to upgrade on the train - that is the cheapest of all if there is space available as it basically ends up being the cost of the meals Amtrak has also introduced a pre-train bidding system for empty sleeper car upgrades, so its very rare for a popular train to have empty sleeper car berths that can be purchased from the conductor. > You could also book "insane trips" that the system wouldn't let you do but were perfectly doable, because it wouldn't correctly recognize that you could make the layover, etc. Making any Amtrak trip dependent on tight layovers is a mistake, in my opinion; multi-hour train delays are somewhat common, and unless you are booked on a single ticket, Amtrak will not hold a train for you, nor will they reschedule you on a future train if you miss your "connection" between two separately ticketed trains due to their delay. My advice has always been to put an hotel overnight between any connection involving two unrelated trains; it makes your whole trip a lot less stressful.
- Melatonic 4y agoRealistically how hard is it to just wing it? Like say I book one long trek to start - can I just wing it as I go along or is it a much better idea to plan the whole thing out train by train beforehand?
- bombcar 4y agoDepends on what you're willing to do - the worst case scenario may be getting stuck in a tiny town in the middle of nowhere for a day or two waiting for the next train. But they do have the rail pass: https://www.amtrak.com/tickets/departure-rail-pass.html https://www.amtrak.com/tickets/departure-rail-pass.html $500 for ten segments over a month, isn't bad.
- skinnymuch 4y agoI’ve only ridden when that$500 was discounted to $300. Amazing for the price.
- the_only_law 4y agoWhat is the general quaillotynofbthe cars and passengers. I’ve thought about taking it a few times, just to go somewhere random, but for some reason, my mind always wonders to bad experiences greyhound busses. I’m also in the south, so it’s rare I find an interesting looking route/destination that’s much cheaper than just flying.
- ghaff 4y agoUnless it's a short hop (and often even then), even modestly long Amtrak routes will often cost more than flying--and even more if you book a sleeping compartment. There are only a few long distance routes I'd consider--all out West. And I'd pretty much only take them on the western part of their routes.
- _delirium 4y agoI only really have experience in the eastern half of the U.S., but on some routes I've found Amtrak significantly cheaper (in coach) than flying, so I consider it if I'm not in a hurry and it's a day train under ~8 hours (not sure if that qualifies as "modestly long"!). The price difference is especially large in Amtrak's favor if you're doing a one-way trip, or to/from smaller cities that don't have much airline competition. For example, to pick Richmond, VA as a city I know about. Amtrak's Richmond to NYC service is about 6 hours 15 mins, and as low as $32 each way if you buy in advance. Flying is only around 1.5 hours but typically $150 one-way or $200 round-trip. Going the other way, Richmond to Charleston, SC is typically $68 one-way and 7 hours, 15 mins, versus about 3.5 hours and $200 to fly one-way.
- bombcar 4y agoI have had zero bad passenger interactions on any long-distance train I've ever been on; part of that may be the cost keeps out the riff-raff, but there's a certain group that travels by train and everyone gets along quite well in my experience.
- jobu 4y ago> you can break the trip up into "daytime travel", stay in a city like Chicago for a few days, and then "overnight" to the next city My limited experience with Amtrak in the West or Midwest is that it's impossible to reliably plan like this. Amtrak is renting access to rails owned by freight carriers and constantly gets delayed or blocked by freight trains with higher priority. Their "schedule" is an absolute best-case scenario that never actually happens. The trains usually arrive somewhere between 2-8 hours after the scheduled time, and occasionally it just doesn't show until the next day. They have an app that's supposed to give the "accurate" arrival time is often wildly off as well.
- secabeen 4y agoChicago is the exception here, though. It's the core hub of the entire system, and there are no trains that pass through Chicago. A Chicago train will nearly always leave on-time, unless there are equipment issues.
- parkingrift 4y agoSimilarly in the eastern corridor or at least all the major cities between Boston and Richmond, VA. Air travel has become such a nightmare that I'd rather take a 7 hour train ride than a 1-2 hour flight.
- cgriswald 4y agoI enjoy Amtrak even for short distances. In my younger days I traveled a fair amount across the midwest. Greyhound would get me there pretty cheaply and fairly comfortably; but it was boring and many of the bus stations were sketchy (although fellow passengers were always great). My preference was strongly for Amtrak, though. More room, the ability to walk around, order food and drinks, and also to see parts of the country that aren't immediately off the interstate. Compared to flying, the travel time is longer (but you gain some of that back by not having to hang out at an airport for so long), but it's a lot less hassle, there's more room, and it's just ... relaxing.
- dionidium 4y agoThis isn't really my kind of writing, so forgive me if my response is somehow impertinent, but there is a very good reason to cross the U.S. by train, which is that this is an enormous, beautiful continent and the train takes you to otherwise untouched parts of it that aren't visible any other way. I took the California Zephyr from Denver to San Francisco (technically Emeryville) a few years ago and it was one of the best experiences of my life. Truly unforgettable. I hope I get the opportunity to do the Empire Builder and Southwest Chief routes at some point!
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoYup, Amtrak from Chicago to Emeryville is probably one of the most impressive routes one can take, and I feel sad for folks who will never get to experience it.
- pengaru 4y agoAgreed re: Zephyr. I took it from SAC to CHI last month, even riding coach it was a pretty good two days I spent mostly fasted, drinking black coffee while programming in the observation car. It's the perfect duration for a short fast and that eliminates a bunch of the bathroom and food needs, just caffeinated coding with great views. And in the end I've gone from CA to IL for ~$150 with a mountain bike checked to boot. Something worth noting is the dining car still wasn't available to coach travelers on my trip, only sleeper cars could access it. Vestiges of the pandemic according to the announcements. It felt a bit like skimpflation to me, but they still had the little snack bar below the observation deck available to all.
- PopAlongKid 4y agohttps://archive.ph/hFVSY https://archive.ph/hFVSY
- PopAlongKid 4y agoLast year I drove my car round trip San Francisco to Chicago, this year I'm taking the Amtrak Zephyr instead (fortunately I don't need a car at my destination). When I hitched around Europe after college I took multiple overnight trips on trains (and boats) but this will be the first time I have dedicated sleeping accomodations on a moving transport. While I am looking forward to the trip I think there are some minor perils that should be noted (I haven't finished reading the linked article yet). Tracks are shared with freight trains, sometimes there are unplanned delays of hours. Bad weather, fires, or other incidents can also cause delays, a half day or more is not unheard of. Because of Covid, it seems that for now, coach passengers are not allowed in the dining car, only those with roomettes (not 100% sure about this). I've read blog posts that on some Amtrak trips, meals were only served in the roomettes, so the dining car not in use (easier to keep clean, I guess?) Wifi is not available on all trains. The following discussion forum for Passenger Trains has daily commentary on various Amtrak comings and goings, photos etc. The first page is free to view, to see more requires a 3-month or full year membership (disclaimer: not affiliated with this site). https://www.trainorders.com/discussion/list.php?4 https://www.trainorders.com/discussion/list.php?4
- CaliforniaKarl 4y ago> Because of Covid, it seems that for now, coach passengers are not allowed in the dining car, only those with roomettes (not 100% sure about this). I've read blog posts that on some Amtrak trips, meals were only served in the roomettes, so the dining car not in use (easier to keep clean, I guess?) Check out https://www.amtrak.com/onboard/meals-dining/dining-car.html https://www.amtrak.com/onboard/meals-dining/dining-car.html to see which services have traditional dining available. I've used Amtrak in California & Ohio, and I don't remember the dining car ever being available to passengers traveling in Coach class. The closest thing I can think of is this: On the Coast Starlight (Los Angeles to Seattle), the Dining Car was available to passengers traveling in Business Class.
- db48x 4y agoIt is available to Coach passengers, but they have to pay for the meal. Sleeper passengers just write their room number on the check, because the meal price is included in their ticket.
- nonameiguess 4y agoI hit rock bottom in 2002. My first wife, who I very stupidly married when I was 21, was committed to a psych ward. My landlord terminated my lease because of damage she did to the property that I had no means of paying for. I was an entertainer at Disneyland, of all things, and cuts to the entertainment budget meant layoffs in my department. Perfect confluence of shitty events, and I was living in my car for a few weeks. So I definitely did have a reason to cross the US by train. Several reason. At least then, it was cheaper than by plane if you didn't get a sleeper car, and you could bring more cargo, so it made for a decent relocate across the country method. I had a friend willing to let me live with her in New Jersey, so Los Angeles to Newark in roughly three days. As others have said, there isn't much you can see from 35,000 ft, but you can see quite a bit from a train, including places that are nowhere near roads and otherwise not very easy to see. Weirdest part of the trip for me was getting caught up in one of those post-9/11 dragnets and getting questioned by the FBI in Albuquerque. I guess they found someone buying a one-way cross-country ticket suspicious.
- daniel-cussen 4y agoThat's cool. Good you didn't end up that low again. Yeah the dragnet...well note beyond questioning you they didn't do you any harm. They are allowed false alarms too, mass transit attracts terrorism, because of the number of people and the speed at which they travel, together with collateral damage to the traintrack and congestion, everything. With high-speed rail it would be even worse. Trains are very sensitive to trainwrecks, always have been. On a mountain pass? It's no joke.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoI hit rock bottom in 2002. My first wife, who I very stupidly married when I was 21, was committed to a psych ward. My landlord terminated my lease because of damage she did to the property that I had no means of paying for. Sorry you had to go through this: My story had a similar path, though I didn't find my way out for some years later. Ex wound up in a psych ward numerous times, the first through a suicide attempt. It was out and in, and I sometimes wish I hadn't stayed so long. Then again, my life is pretty wonderful now and who knows if it would have turned out like this if I had left earlier.
- zagrebian 4y agoHow fast could you go from coast to coast in one of those high-speed trains that exist in other countries? 10 hours maybe?
- mastax 4y agoThe fastest train currently in long-distance service is the Fuxing Hao CR400AF/BF which is currently in service at 350 km/h (220 mph). San Diego to Jacksonville is 3350km (2100mi) straight line. That gives a lower bound of 9.5 hours. Of course the actual path couldn't be a straight line, and the train would need to accelerate and decelerate several times for intermediate stops.
- colechristensen 4y ago15 hours if the train didn't stop, considerably more if the practicalities of an actual rail system were in play. Japanese high speed rail has a top speed of 200 mph but not all lines, coast to coast is 3000 miles in the US depending on where you want to start and stop.
- robin_reala 4y agoIf you take exist to be “exists as a prototype” or “exists, but only serving a short route” then you could cover ~3000 miles in 11.5 hours without stopping using the Shanghai Transrapid,[1] or 10 hours using the latest Transrapid[2] or L0 Series shinkansen.[3] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_maglev_train https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_maglev_train [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transrapid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transrapid [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L0_Series https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L0_Series
- AlbertCory 4y agoHere's another chance to mention the greatest train song ever written: City of New Orleans, by the great Steve Goodman (RIP). Be sure to watch the related video where Arlo Guthrie talks about how Steve importuned him after a show at the Quiet Knight and played the song for him. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e4ztWNJYFrU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e4ztWNJYFrU
- stereoabuse 4y agoThe Audm app has a fantastic narration of this that I've returned to a couple times in the past years for a laugh. >Even on short plane trips, every passenger is offered the kindergartner’s communion of juice and cookies, as if a majority of adults are incapable of going 90 minutes without such provisions. On trains, passengers are treated as individuals even more powerful than adults: independent teenagers who just want to smoke. Amtrak knows you want to smoke. Amtrak knows you love to smoke. But while you’re living under Amtrak’s roof, you have to follow the rules, of which there is only one, and that is: Don’t smoke inside. The author Caity Weaver also wrote a fun autoethnography on #VanLife[0]. [0] https://archive.ph/1OKC6 https://archive.ph/1OKC6
- darkarmani 4y ago> Train people are content to stare out the window for hours, like indoor cats.
- pengaru 4y agoIf you've never ridden the Zephyr cross-country, I can't think of another time I've felt so deeply frustrated that USA hasn't developed a high-speed rail network connecting all its major cities. If you're on the fence about trains vs. planes and have never done it, give it a try and imagine what it'd be like to be traveling ~200MPH while in the observation car. Still enjoying the decadent landscape views, drinking your beverage of choice, emitting far less carbon than flying, while still traveling quickly, without most of the obnoxious TSA theatrics.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- ashtonbaker 4y agoWe did a round trip, Paris-Nice-Paris one summer. The trip to Nice was overnight on a sleeper car, and the way back we had first-class TGV tickets. I loved the sleeper car very much, but watching the French countryside fly by at 200mph was a vision of a civilized future that my American mind could scarcely comprehend.
- idontpost 4y ago> without most of the obnoxious TSA theatrics That's just naive. If train travel ever becomes common again, the TSA WILL get their grubby little fingers into it.
- ghaff 4y agoAnd the fact is that if you travel regularly and have TSA Pre, I do still get to the airport early but I pretty much breeze through security the vast bulk of the time. No shoes off, laptops out, etc. It's rarely a headache.
- xboxnolifes 4y agoI think TSA is mostly useless, but people really overblow how much of a pain it is to go through security for domestic flights. It's never taken me more than 45 minutes to go from dropoff to gate for a domestic flight, and most are closer to the 20 minute range (mostly just walking to the gate itself). All of that not even being TSA-Pre.
- karaterobot 4y agoBefore becoming a hagiography of Rick Steves (who deserves it, surely) the first part of this essay read like a parody of a New York Times writer who just discovered there exists a world between the coasts, and that people live different kinds of lives than they do.
- hahamrfunnyguy 4y agoI took the Southwest Chief from Chicago to Los Angeles a few years ago. I went coach and it was about the same price as an airline ticket, maybe $10-$20 less. The Southwest Chief was nice, but the train to Chicago was noisy and dirty. The sleeper car would have been about triple what we paid for the two coach tickets. It wasn't bad sleeping in the coach seats, though I am sure the sleeper car would have been fun. We bought our own food and ate on the train. We took a 2 day stop to visit Flagstaff and the Grand Canyon before continuing on to LA. It's worth doing. I enjoyed the ride and got paid for it too because I was able to work while aboard the train.
- em-bee 4y agoi made a similar trip from chicago to san francisco. also in coach. during the day i walked down to the lounge car with the extra large windows. that way my coach seat felt like a semi-comfortable place to sleep, and not a place where i would be stuck for three days. it was a wonderful trip. my only regret was that the train was moving at night and i missed seeing half of the scenery while i was sleeping.
- throwaway892238 4y agoI did the Zephyr from Denver to Sacramento during the pandemic. Wearing a mask for 40 hours is no easy feat, so of course the passengers respected the mask mandate less and less as time went by. Even so, I would do the Denver-SLC Westbound portion again in a heartbeat. The entire time you travel through mountains, canyons and plains where no automobiles can go. When I went, the observation car had excess seating capacity for the entire trip. If I was from a foreign country, experiencing this would be on my bucket list.
- xg15 4y ago> (The nonprofit National Safety Council reports that a person in the United States is several times more likely to die of “sharp objects” than a plane or train crash, though the events that preceded the recent emergency Boeing groundings make such statistics cold comfort) Somewhat OT, but I wonder: Do statistics like this actually take the priors into account or are they just comparing the absolute counts? Or in other words, could I add my own statistic and advertise the safety properties of unicycles for highway travel?
- jrnichols 4y ago> "a six-hour $129 nonstop flight" How you know this article is definitely a few years old. :) Now that the mask mandate has finally gone away, taking cross country trip on Amtrak is something that is on our 2022 plans. Surprisingly, most of the trains we've looked at have been at capacity or near it. Not sure if they're running shorter trains or if Amtrak has grown in popularity. Hopefully we'll be able to do it this year!
- stretchwithme 4y agoI did it in November, 1993. From Albany thru Chicago. Then to LA and up to San Jose. It was great. Fantastic scenery. Private room once I got to Chicago. Met a lot of great people, because you share tables in the dining car. Even had a friend visit met at the station in Albuquerque. I was moving and they let me bring 60 pounds of stuff.
- BrianHenryIE 4y agoI took Amtrack around the US: Sacramento -> Santa Barbara -> LA -> New Orleans -> New York -> Boston -> Syracuse -> Chicago -> Sacramento. I didn't buy the Rail Pass because I wasn't sure before I started that I'd enjoy it so much. What was great was WikiMapia – as the train was rolling through the countryside I was able to know what was around me. http://wikimapia.org/ http://wikimapia.org/ https://www.amtrak.com/tickets/departure-rail-pass.html https://www.amtrak.com/tickets/departure-rail-pass.html
- didizaja 4y agoHa, it's funny I'm seeing this now! I'm doing a cross-country trip from Charlotte, NC to San Francisco (technically Emeryville) by train later this month (June 18th-21st). It was something of a spontaneous decision. I have an on-site with my team in SF later during the week of my arrival, so I felt this was a good excuse to experience something different! I'll be in a sleeper car for a short leg of the trip (DC to Chicago, iirc), then coach the rest of the way. Hopefully I survive, lol.