4 ms·
> home prices have been absolutely bonkers, with two massive bubbles (we are in one right now) Isn't the definition of a bubble that it has the capability to p
by mschuster91 4y ago
> home prices have been absolutely bonkers, with two massive bubbles (we are in one right now)
Isn't the definition of a bubble that it has the capability to pop and then eventually pops? At least for urban housing, I see no way of that even being remotely possible, neither for the US nor here in Europe. Rural areas simply are too far left behind to support decent human life - no high speed Internet, no public transport, no necessary infrastructure like doctors/pharmacies/grocery stores, no employment opportunities, schools closing down everywhere and that's just the short list of issues.
As a consequence, the rural flight can and will only accelerate - I see no way ever for politicians to approve the absurd amount of expenses for bringing rural areas back to speed, not with the aftermath of covid and the current Russian invasion having strained anyone's budgets to the limit.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoThe urban flight to the rural has just as many issues pushing it. Starlink also makes rural life more appealing for some even with all the other rural issues.
- ghaff 4y agoStarlink is a real gamechanger. My dad's house in Maine a little ways from a small city had 1Mbps "broadband." Houses further down the road had nothing wired and all the Plan Bs (conventional satellite/hotspot) were lousy options. While Starlink isn't 100% reliable I could actually work from there if I wanted to.
- tjr225 4y agoCould you? I have been remote for about 4 years and I have difficulty doing my job if my internet goes out for even an hour during my working time. I also have issues doing my job if I can’t stream audio/video due to speed issues- and this happens even with a hardwired connection on occasion.
- ghaff 4y ago>Could you? Yes? My internet from Comcast is pretty good but it's not flawless. Power is even better but can go out. And I have very marginal cell reception without WiFi assist. That's 40 miles outside of major Northeast city. I'm frequently on calls where someone or other has network issues and can't present or need to drop. Life goes on. If my Internet goes out for an hour or two I find something to do that doesn't require Internet.
- bombcar 4y agoStarling reliability is usually the "it goes down for a few minutes" type of failures, vs the "it's down for the day" you get (more rarely) with wired. I'm semi-rural and I still get 2-4 times a year where my cable drops out, which I suspect is due to moisture in the lines as it seems to usually happen during spring thaws. They're bringing in fiber at some point soon.
- ghaff 4y agoI've definitely seen Starlink go down for a few hours at my brother's place a couple times when I've been up there. At home, I've had longer outages with Comcast but usually it's more like going briefly in and out over the course of the day. It's better than it was and it's pretty much good enough as far as I'm concerned.
- 0xffff2 4y agoI have been using Starlink as my only internet since I got it about 6 months ago (working fully remote since COVID). It isn't flawless, but it's substantially more reliable than Comcast cable ever was in the various apartments I lived in when I was in the Bay Area. >I also have issues doing my job if I can’t stream audio/video due to speed issues- and this happens even with a hardwired connection on occasion. What on Earth are you streaming that causes issues on a hardwired connection? I never have had speed issues with meetings, on Starlink or broadband at previous residences. I do have occasional latency spikes, but those seem to be getting better.
- mschuster91 4y agoThat only fixes the Internet part, but not the rest of the infrastructure issues which need a lot of investment to break the vicious cycle of neglected infrastructure, people moving and the tax base to fund the maintenance of the infrastructure eroding as a consequence.
- Supermancho 4y ago> Isn't the definition of a bubble that it has the capability to pop and then eventually pops? It's a description of a linear trend over a period that rises and falls. Why the trend falls (or how sharply) is not related. A housing "hump" isn't the preferred metaphor, although it's more apt. People like to think that a trend bubble has to "pop" because they imagine a physical bubble instead of a hump in a line.
- dont__panic 4y agoInterestingly I wonder the exact opposite -- can urban housing really justify these insane valuations when US cities have next to no appeal to me? I recently moved out of a major city to a small, walkable town so I can get away from the crime, traffic, noise, dirtiness, and car-domination of US cities. It's pretty remarkable to see people and children walk around my neighborhood now -- didn't have that in my major US city before! Your list of infrastructure issues with rural areas also applies to many major US cities. Let's see: - no high speed Internet: I have faster internet in a small town than I ever had in any of the major US cities I've lived in. Some cities have fiber in nice neighborhoods, but it's by no means a strong rural/urban divide as you imply here. - no public transport: Public transit is complete crap in most US cities, with many stuck in a post-covid death spiral thanks to fewer commuters, cut service lines, and rising or perceived-rising crime. There were enough clearly mentally ill people on public transit in my last city that I stopped riding public transit entirely. Where I live now, I can get around entirely on foot or by bike, no need for public transit at all. - no necessary infrastructure like doctors/pharmacies/grocery stores: I can now walk to the grocery store. I could not in my last city. - no employment opportunities: Definitely an issue for some fields, but remote work gives more flexibility on this. If anything this is an argument that's weakened over the last 2-3 years. - schools closing down everywhere: You can only make kids ride so far on the bus in rural America. I know consolidations are an issue in many rural areas, but if you live in a small town, you'll likely be near the only school that remains open. If you live way out in the woods of course you won't have a super close-by school. On the other hand, rural areas are the only places where many of my non-tech peers ever have a hope of owning a home these days. I suspect their values will perform better over time than million dollar townhomes in rotting city centers with poor internet quality, no walkability, crappy public transit, and lots of quality-of-life issues.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thatfrenchguy 4y ago> next to no appeal to me That’s sort of the point. I’d kill myself before I’d live in a small town again instead of San Francisco. I can walk to 10 grocery stores, 20 restaurants, literally find all the food I want, and the public transit is pretty good. Who wants to raise kids in rural areas where there won’t be any opportunities for them?
- mupuff1234 4y agoHousing prices are affected by monetary and psychological aspects just like the stock market and inflation are. If people stop believing housing is a good investment then prices will fall.
- mschuster91 4y ago> If people stop believing housing is a good investment then prices will fall. People need something to live in though, and as long as the demand for places to live is higher than the supply, rents and purchase prices will keep going up.
- mupuff1234 4y agoThe population hasn't increased much (or maybe at all) in the last 2 years yet prices have sky rocketed - why is that?
- mschuster91 4y agoWould you choose to invite a recurring thousands-dollars-a-month expense in a time of economic uncertainity? Children are expensive AF - childbirth alone is a risk of dozens of thousands of dollars, you need more living space, clothing, diapers, food, more doctor visits, the person bearing the baby may not be able to work for a time which means less income, you need babysitters, ...
- jandrese 4y agoCapitalism. The government has completely failed its job of monetary policy, which in broad strokes is to provide back pressure on capitalism's natural tendency to have money move upward. Today there is way too much money at the top and it has nowhere to go. The economy is less and less resembling a healthy marketplace and more medieval feudalism, with lords stuck in their opulent castles while the peasants farm dirt. The more evenly money is spread across the entire spectrum of society the better the markets work. This is one of the side effects of highly progressive taxation and strong social programs--a healthy economy. Instead our politicians have been focused on reducing taxes for the ultra rich and this has only accelerated the consolidation of money at the top, which is why our economy is getting heavily distorted and why for people on the bottom they have only been getting poorer. Once you factor in rent/mortgage, health care, and inflation versus wage growth the average American is backsliding and has been doing so for many years now. This is a massive failure of fiscal policy, but nobody in Washington cares because the lobbyists and special interests are happy.
- hattmall 4y agoIs this actually happening in Europe? The US is the exact opposite. It's rather trivial to improve rural areas and housing costs are outpacing urban areas at least in percentage increases. Most rural areas still have access to all the basics that urban areas provide and are only a couple hours drive from major urban centers. There's no public transport but no one cares about that in the US. Even in the largest cities it is generally lacking. Highspeed internet is widely available with even more being deployed currently. Pretty much everyone is getting fiber in the next 3 years and 5g is already in most areas. Only the extreme rural areas lack connectivity and then there is starlink.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoIt's similar in Europe. You need extreme rural conditions to be more than 30 minutes away from anything. Public transport is a mess in most rural places, with busses arriving maybe once an hour (two hours if you're unlucky) at bus stops in 5-50 minute walking distance. That said, in The Netherlands, these places have also increased in prices. GP is underestimating correlation between rural and urban. If prices explode in the urban area, rural will generally see some increase too.
- bombcar 4y agoPeople define "rural" vastly differently - most "rural" areas in the USA are actually peppered with small towns (between 10 and 10k residents) which can be covered by high speed internet and even effective public transportation if desired - in a small enough town that can just be a guy with a van hired by the township. All you're really missing then is the connection to the nearest urban center - if it takes an hour to drive into town it's not much different than taking an hour to drive across town, after all.
- coding123 4y agoRural for me is 10 acre plots - can't see your neighbor too much. Rural for others is 40 acre plots. For some it's 400-1000.
- 4y ago
- ghaff 4y agoIs it your contention that the net migration out of many US urban centers that was going on through about the 1990s can never happen again? In spite of the fact that it's probably possible to do more things remotely than it was back then? There's also a lot between a city center and true rural wilds of Wyoming (especially the way the US Census defines it). There's a lot of pretty affordable housing and land within an hour or two of most major cities with decent infrastructure, hospitals, etc. No there's not much public transportation but that's true of anywhere that people are spread out.